Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kickstarter has a major problem . . .

Transcript 19:09

I've spent 6 years now in the board game hobby space filming and producing videos backing close to 300 games I believe I'm at 298 games on Kickstarter not including other projects on other platforms like gamefound and Backer kit which have grown up over the last couple of years I have bought purchased supported and abandoned the kickstarter space more times than I'd like to acknowledge here's the reality Kickstarter like many many many people have said on video after video that I have produced and across platform after platform Kickstarter today is not what Kickstarter yester year was when Kingdom Death my favorite game of all time was first created it was a an ambitious Mammoth Masterpiece with board game pieces on what looked like a chess board it had no idea what it was and we backed it and loved it and absorbed it and gave the community the support they needed gave the publisher the support they needed to create something marvelous when Gloom Haven which is what we're exploring right now first came into existence it came into existence as an idea a a series of Diaries and journal entries and design notes that have been collected over the last two years of work where Isaac was just painstakingly creating something and finally it was

able to be brought to life it was able to be funded to be created because of platforms like Kickstarter but today the place we are now is a place that's rampant with well marketing tactics that trick you into backing fomo that makes you spend and put more money on a credit card than you could ever readily justify especially if you looked at the numbers piles of games that you have backed up behind you don't lie to yourself that you'll never actually get to the table probably never even shrink wrap or unwrap the shrink wrap because you should sell them tomorrow on Facebook or Ebay Kickstarter has bought paid tricked lied swindled and convinced you that you need every single thing under the sun and now we've seen company after company with quite a few that should have pulled the plug already but haven't cuz for some reason they think that they can make up the debt that they've imbued we've seen company after company fail drop the ball not deliver we've seen uh the marketing tactics and the greed that has enveloped our hobby the Ripoff copies of games that have already been created the 17th version of zombicide and we love zombicide I do love that game we've seen our industry really shift take a step back have a foul taste in its mouth and it's

not that there aren't great things out there but the stuff that's getting the most attention the stuff that's getting the most noise the stuff that is tricking people into backing buying and supporting beyond their reasonable means a lot of that stuff is stuff that doesn't belong on the platform it's stuff that could exist in another way it's stuff that like Stone Meer games did way back originally in the day should have its own SE pre-order system or should build a community that is rewarded and supported this video is one or two things ultimately this video is an analysis of what's gone wrong on Kickstarter and an advocacy for holding Publishers accountable and rewarding Publishers who are doing things right I've heard people for a long time talk about how they're tired of the marketing tactics they're tired of The Limited stretch goals the exclusive offers the sarges and the pledge manager where I backed for $100 and suddenly you're charging me 732 on the back end I've heard a lot of people complain extra contributions few people actually put their dollar M where their mouth is I mean anywhere you get that rampant consumerism you know you find something that's good and honest and pure and then it becomes successful and then it's

inevitable that consumerism is going to take over and you know it's it's a you know capitalistic market and for all the benefits of a capitalistic Market there's also a tradeoff there it becomes a little too good at convincing you that the money is better spent on Kickstarter or gamefound or whatever the crowdfunding platform is than it is doing something else in your life your account for example a multi ion dollar company I mean they've raised over the course of their they were founded in 2009 they've raised billions right like and some really good works come out of it and board games are the single biggest category on that insane platform and so like you said we've seen a shift in the tide mhm what is the point of this what are we leading to there's a little game that's launched game we've talked about a game we're highlighting a game we're celebrating game is called Rove it's made by atct games and it's designed by someone who I think is very important to our Hobby and important to this point M eisenbach he's the creator of a little project called Crimson scales this this these type of people are the people who crowdfunding platforms are designed for we're currently going through a gameplay series on Crimson scales and by the way we're not sponsored we're not financially or uh relationally involved at all with adex

games one of my friends West Todd who used to be on this channel is working with ro on this project and I met mty through his work on the single biggest free fanmade expansion ever created and we've become close friends since then but this is the type of game that people look for this is the type of person that people look for give them a breakdown of of what Crimson scales is and and why this type of Creator is the is the people that we want to see you know M miti mat miti miti I don't know mati um personally all not personally at all I just know of him through Jesse really in just these last couple days I had already backed Rove myself and and I've slowed down enormously on my you know backing like compared to what I've done in the years past and that's a whole other conversation but I did back Rove because I look at a game like Crimson scales as such an impressive passion project that I saw somebody who came to the market and just to hear the story of like this guy did it nonprofit he did this out of love for the board game space for you know what I assume is his favorite game of all time which would be Gloom haven over the pandemic his wife and him played through all of Gloom Haven M and he fell in love with it and so he joined it wasn't just him he was the lead head of it but some of the other people involved with ro were some of the creators of crimson scales to begin with he joined the community on BGG on Reddit

on Discord that were doing fan-made expansions they were creating their own custom characters and scenarios and just continuing to explore a game that they felt headed over heels with and eventually when they got to the point that they were ready to put an order in a print run in he started figuring out how to actually manufacture it how to create it he reached out to Isaac he got permission to do a print to actually get a order they ended up creating two production runs 8,000 copies delivered to fans with an expansion with Miniatures with a box this scale and size and on top of that he did every single bit of it not only with the full communication permission with full engagement of seair games he didn't want to ever step over any bounds that they set cuz they had opened up a Creative Commons license so that people could do this but getting to a commercial pre-order system is a whole Step Beyond creating fun assets on BGG but he also did it without any of him or his team covering their costs paying for their time it's incredible week and a half ago had a game that I backed on Kickstarter in July of 2020 I backed this game and it just delivered way after after multiple delays and I'm happy to have it I'm glad it's finally in my collection but you know it took forever and then there's another game that asked for additional contributions just to get your game yeah

you know and I and I did get that game so you know I was one of those people that ponied up the extra money yeah then you got something like this and Crimson scales on the level of quality the level of of love that went into this game for a game that I already love Gloom Haven I already loved it when I learned about this and I said this guy's coming out with another game and this is going to be his first you know for-profit game I went I I have to buy that just on principle alone yeah just to thank him for Crimson scales I'm not advocating that you go buy Crimson scales that's the enthesis of what this message of this video is the point of this video is to highlight and talk for a little bit just openly and honestly about the sins of the kickstarter and crowdfunding Industry the way they trick lie distort and manipulate you but the contrast of that and the thing we have to recognize is that creators like this need to succeed on the platform MH it's it's where Gloom Haven came from it's where Kingdom Death came from it's where still amazing projects get made and so you can't just get rid of everything if you appreciate a fan like you going out of their way to create produce and make the single most successful and single best produced board game expansion fan-made expansion free expansion uh ever in our industry um you should back row for a dollar you should put your money where your mouth is you should leave a comment saying hey I'm not g to back this this game isn't

for me I don't like Gloom Haven I'm not looking for a campaign game you don't this game might not be right for you if you like Gloom Haven if you are looking for a campaign game if you like the beautiful ethereal artwork of the original artist of Gloom Haven then yeah Ro's fantastic I don't mean to like make you not excited but the point is is that if you are frustrated with how the kickstarter indust is MHM you should do something about it creators like this Indie creators small creators firsttime Publishers creators from diverse backgrounds from various regions of the world who are collaborating working and bringing a dream to life are often times the most abused and overlooked on our platform and in our industry we had a policy from the very get-go here at quackalope about four years ago that we didn't or we went out of our way to avoid charging firsttime Publishers or Indie Publishers for Content that we made here on the channel the whole reason that policy was formed is because within the first year of working behind the scenes trying to figure out how to make this a career I discovered that the model of most of the other media companies in our space was built off of charging firsttime and small creators sometimes astronomical amounts geek and sunry come to mind and sometimes fairly reasonable amounts actually not that that bad but charging them with the knowledge that they would likely not make a profit not only on this print run but on any future print

run in the foreseeable window of time our industry disregards takes advantage distorts lies manipulates betrays you the fans betrays the Publishers who are trying to make a dream come true takes money right from us from them it takes dreams and dashes them tricks them into backing spending investing putting money on marketing ads that'll never get eyes enough to actually sell the game at a price they need to be able to sell it at all because we've built a really successful really successful big Financial system Yep this guy and the people that are on his team uh and other creators that are just like him I I could list a dozen and over the course of the next years or year here on quackalope I hope we'll get the chance to highlight shout about and continue to celebrate Publishers that are doing something worthwhile that are contributing to our hobby that are fans just like you and me who only want to see something cool that they created on a table in front of them and in the process of doing that don't really want to have to mortgage their house to make it happen I know a lot of people that have I know a lot of people that have Lo lost a lot of things on the road uh from fans and backers to big old publishers you know bonus tip speaking to what you're talking about you know the you know rampant consumerism and feeling as if you've got to get everything go all in get the next best game and you're

constantly back at the I was in that and for me I've done the back I I've done the what I call the kickstarter addictive model right you back everything for three or four months then you run out of money or you get a little bit of common sense you wait for about 6 months all the games start coming in and then you convince yourself maybe there's something cool you should pay attention to and theion come out and you're so here here's how I broke that cycle little bit over a year ago last February 2023 it would have been I started a new budget app and you know I don't I'm not I'm going to plug it just cuz I love it it's yab YNAB you need a budget it's an app and it's a budget app and it helps you to purposefully assign your money to different categories and I have a board game specific budget that I say this is what I allot myself for board game in general all right if it doesn't fit in that then I have to wait till that accumulates large enough to where I then make the purchase or if I really feel like it's that important I'll go to a different category and say maybe I don't need that you know extra fund money I'm going to move that over to my board game thing but you're purposely making decisions about how you spend your money and you're doing it in a more intentional way and that has absolutely changed the way not only I look at the board organ space but how I look at my finances in general and it's made me a much more responsible spender okay you know you already had your mechanisms for savings but what do you how are you spending your money and how are you

doing it intentionally whatever budgeting system you use use one that's how if you really want to be motivated to get out of this Kickstarter cycle of backing everything buying everything getting into everything find a budget app that works for you for me it was wab and I'll I'll speak the Praises of that forever because of how much of an impact it's had for me I just gave my wife my credit cards and I asked her permission to do basically everything and she said you need a budget she said I am your budget yep here's your allowance the final message the the let me just sum up there's a lot to talk about here and I am sure over the course of the next year on quackalope I will be revealing talking diving into I don't know I I've I've got a lot of thoughts as you can tell mhm here here's my two main points Publishers who care about their Community who support their fans who give updates who let you know what's happening Who deliver products Publishers who are putting stuff out for the sake of saving themselves like many companies you could probably name yeah uh that's a whole another can of worms we should support and reward the public Publishers who do it right people like when Oaths had to go ask their fans for funding they had been so good so honest so engaged with their Community you all donated thousands of dollars to help

these people bring their game to life the response of that compared to other Publishers who've been quiet silent and failed to deliver multiple campaigns and kind of had had have had rolling numbers we should reward the people that do it well that do it right we should keep them in business and we should rip apart and you know complain about the people who don't and then the second point I make Ro is my example Ro's my example I can't think of another person in our industry who has went out of their way for a board game they loved to the degree that MTI and his team have that's my reality M I think if you care if you're one of these people that watched this video to this point the part that you can play is supporting people like them if you're complaining on my videos if you're talking about how manipulative the kickstarter space is to me in person or over the phone or you leave a comment my first response from this point forward is going to be hey who'd you back for a dollar who' you support tell me the indie game that you're a big fan of that you advocated for you don't have to buy it you don't have to back it you have to put all your money in it you can back out of your dollar pledge the day before the campaign closes it's enough to support to show up to leave a comment to give them some encouragement and you should it's the only way that we and to be clear the WEA the storm yeah that's currently happening in our space to be clear the point of that is not the dollar that

you're putting into that campaign it's the comment that you leave on that Kickstarter and the effect it has on the algorithm the dollar just allows you to make the comment yep that's it and and that's where these small Indie Publishers that are trying to battle the big you know Mega companies that are you know a ble to uh generate thousands and thousands and thousands of comments in a day on their first day of C of launching the people who need the attention are those small guys they need that algorithm boost so if you're frustrated with Kickstarter you have every right to be I am and I have been for years uh with that being said who' you back who' you support who have you invested in who do you think is doing it right and is worth the platform that they have welcome to a new stage of calou I hope you're enjoying it

Progress saved