Dice Throne: Santa v. Krampus Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Dice Throne: Santa v. Krampus
Reviewers treat Dice Throne: Santa v. Krampus as a holiday-themed entry in a dueling dice system they already know. Brian McDonald of Brains On Games described it as a timely release for Kickstarter backers that is compatible with every other Dice Throne set, and said the characters are fun enough that their kids like to pull the game out. The host of Before You Play called it a holiday battle built on a Yahtzee-style dice rolling game, with each player starting at 50 health. That channel had met the system through sponsored Marvel boxes and said it had wanted this particular set for years.
Danielle of DaniCha said Christmas-related products are not usually their thing, but that they love Dice Throne enough to make an exception. Their unboxing focused on the set's components, including the rules booklet at version 2.4, the trifold player board, and the containers for each hero. Foster the Meeple chose the set as one of 24 festive games for a board game Advent calendar, and in a separate holiday game day guide the same channel recommended it as a two-player pick for a Christmas game night.
Core Mechanics That Define Dice Throne: Santa v. Krampus
Rolling for abilities and upgrades
On each offensive roll, the host of Before You Play explained that a player may roll up to three times, setting aside whichever dice they want between rolls. Each hero has its own dice faces and ability combinations. Santa's Trim Your Tree needs several of the most common axe faces, while Naughty or Nice needs two axes and a star. Krampus can trigger straight-based abilities with four dice for a small straight or five for a large straight. Upgrades are paid for in combat points, and the host noted that a player who upgrades an ability to a higher level pays only the difference. Brian McDonald pointed out that the six face appears only once on each die, which makes the ultimate abilities hard to trigger, and they said the rolling teaches players a little about probability.
Cheer, eggnog, coal, and rejects
Santa collects cheer and eggnog. One cheer buys a reroll, and three cheer can change a die to a six, while three eggnog can be spent to roll a single die for a random benefit, such as healing for two. Krampus works differently. Coal tokens are dealt to opponents, and a player holding four coal must remove them before gaining combat points, which lowers that gain by one. Krampus also gathers gifts that turn into Reject cards, which can be kept in play in a limit of three and activated for one-off effects. Brian McDonald said the Reject and companion cards use the same synthetic material as Radlands cards, which is meant to make them sturdy and reportedly washable. Before You Play added that spent rejects are reshuffled when the deck runs out, and that Rejects cannot be sold for combat points.
The Dice Throne: Santa v. Krampus Experience
Holiday flavor on every card
The theme runs through the names and text of the cards. The host of Before You Play pointed to card names such as Crusty Krampus, Squishy, Bitey, and Reindeer Games, and said the holiday cards are fun even when they are one-off effects. The channel praised the artwork, saying it gives the set personality and that the Rejects look both endearing and semi-menacing. Danielle of DaniCha said the trifold board looks very Christmassy and noticed a Mythic card in the box. Brian McDonald said the player board carries plenty of Christmas puns.
Asymmetric duels with swingy turns
Both heroes operate on the same core structure, but their resources and abilities pull the match in different directions. Before You Play showed a close game where an undefendable ultimate ability reversed the momentum, and the Krampus player said they felt Santa was very strong against them while they were trying to unlock their own options. Undefendable damage skips the defensive roll entirely, so one good turn can change the whole duel. Brian McDonald said the characters have different complexity ratings, with Santa rated two out of six and Krampus rated four out of six, so the two heroes play at noticeably different levels of difficulty.
What Makes Dice Throne: Santa v. Krampus Stand Out
An accessible entry point into a deeper system
Brian McDonald praised the Dice Throne line as having a low bar for entry, with each character deck feeling distinct and easy to set up. They noted that the set's two boxes keep everything organized and that Santa is a traditional, easy-to-learn Dice Throne hero. Krampus, by contrast, introduces companion cards and a more involved combat style. Before You Play said the system is popular for a reason, comparing it to other Yahtzee-style games. Foster the Meeple recommended this specific set as a top pick for a two-player holiday game night.
Components built to last
DaniCha noted that the rules are at version 2.4, that the set includes standees alongside the tokens, and that the containers are color-coded, with green for Krampus and red for Santa. Brian McDonald highlighted the synthetic card stock, which feels like regular cardboard but is sturdier and can be washed if something spills on it. They also liked the bright artwork from Roxley Games, which they described as a strong match for the rest of the Dice Throne line.
Potential Drawbacks
Luck and a dense set of effects
The host of Before You Play noted that much of the outcome depends on which cards a player draws, and admitted that their own winning streak on the dice owed a lot to luck. They also described a dense damage model, with undefendable damage, collateral damage, and standard damage all in play. Brian McDonald said the six face is so rare that Krampus's ultimate is hard to roll, although they framed that as a learning moment about probability rather than a flaw.
Box size and a steeper Krampus
DaniCha described the Dice Throne boxes as large and thick, and said they would rather not haul the whole collection around, choosing instead the characters they plan to play. Brian McDonald rated Krampus at four out of six in complexity, noting that the coal, gift, and companion systems make that hero more demanding than Santa. Krampus's companion cards and reject mechanics also add a layer of tracking that new players may need to learn during their first game.
If You Enjoy Dice Throne: Santa v. Krampus
- Dice Throne Adventures: Before You Play described Adventures as a different type of game from the same system, one the channel had not yet played, so it is a natural next step for players who want a different way into the dice-rolling format.
- Marvel Dice Throne: Brian McDonald said the Marvel sets are the ones they know best, and suggested pairings like Santa versus Loki or Loki versus Krampus. Before You Play also played the Thor and Loki box on an earlier sponsored video.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"each character deck feels unique and it's so easy to pull out and pick up a game of this and play it"
— Brains On Games
"I love anything holiday themed even if they're just oneoff cards, just the theming of it"
— Before You Play
"I love Dice Throne so much so this was an exception for me to actually dive into this."
— DaniCha