Paladins of the West Kingdom: City of Crowns Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Paladins of the West Kingdom: City of Crowns
City of Crowns is an expansion for Paladins of the West Kingdom, the worker placement game published by Garphill Games. It adds noble allies and diplomatic actions to the base game, and the reviewers at Board Games UnLocked and in their top five expansions of 2021 discussion came away positive. The overall view is that it is a worthwhile addition for players who already own and enjoy the base game, with a few reservations that are specific rather than general. One reviewer gave the expansion a nine out of ten and said it "just changes the game a little bit," adding that it is not a bad change. The reservations center on the set collection element, the clarity of its scoring rules, and whether the expansion suits players who value the base game's tight feel.
Core Mechanics That Define Paladins of the West Kingdom: City of Crowns
Negotiate and Muster on the White Track
City of Crowns adds two new actions, Muster and Negotiate. Negotiate is the one reviewers discussed most. It draws on a new White track, which represents your negotiating power with the nobles who come to the kingdom's aid. Depending on how high that track sits, a Negotiate action can deliver a one-time benefit such as a free garrison or a free commission, and it also raises another track by five. Some cards carry a condition, so one reviewer noted that the White track has to reach five before a particular card can be taken, which means players need to plan their track around the cards they want. Muster is the companion action. It lets a player move a noble worker on a separate board, works as an extra worker replacement action, and advances the White track. One reviewer described the pairing as "mustering and negotiating back and forth," and said the two actions feed each other across a turn.
Noble Allies Through Set Collection
The second headline addition is set collection built around the noble allies. Collecting three of one ally type brings that noble into your service, and each ally then pays out a worker in a particular color each time you pass, along with a benefit such as tax money or flipping a debt. Scoring is cumulative. While working through the rulebook, the hosts at Board Games UnLocked read the unique symbol sets as worth zero, two, five, and nine points, capped at nine for a complete set of four symbols. One reviewer credited designer Shem Phillips with striking a strong chord with this expansion, and the set collection path is best understood as an additional route to points that sits alongside the existing tracks rather than a replacement for them.
The Paladins of the West Kingdom: City of Crowns Experience
A Tight Strategy That Opens Up
Reviewers describe base game Paladins as a tight game in which you cannot do everything, so you commit early to a strategy and build your engine around it. City of Crowns keeps that tension but loosens it. One reviewer said the expansion lets a player do a wider range of things without making every mistake fatal, so falling slightly behind does not feel like being locked out of the game. The same reviewer was candid that players who enjoy the tightness should expect the expansion to "take that away a little bit." Another reviewer compared the base game to Agricola, which they described as tight with no choices, and said that Paladins felt tight while still offering lots of choices. City of Crowns, in their view, pushes that balance further toward choice.
A Comeback Path Through Negotiation
The other recurring feeling is that the expansion keeps a player competitive when worker counts or turn order run against them. Reviewers observed that the player with more workers tends to take more actions, which is a familiar dynamic in Paladins. The expansion counters this with compensation from Negotiate, which can deliver free benefits as the game progresses. One reviewer said that because they were negotiating more, they got a free convert, a free gift, and something else for free, and that this balanced out the worker advantage. Another reviewer described a game in which they maxed out tracks higher than they had ever managed in a Paladins game, and credited the expansion's new tracks with opening up that scoring.
What Makes Paladins of the West Kingdom: City of Crowns Stand Out
Enhances the Base Game Without Lengthening It
Reviewers repeatedly said that City of Crowns avoids the bloat that makes many expansions tiring. One host said the expansion did not lengthen the game in their opinion, with no extra turns or anything dramatic added. The same host argued that the expansion does not overcomplicate the rules, and that its purpose is to make what already works in the base game work better. Another reviewer summed up the balance by saying the expansion "adds more to the game without distracting from the game."
A Reworked Card Draw and New Paladins
The expansion also changes how the deck is drawn. A reviewer described the new rule in which you draw four cards, put one on top, put one on the bottom, and remove one from the game. Because the removed card never returns, players have to be deliberate about which cards they keep in rotation, and one reviewer noted that they wanted a particular card to come back and then realized they had removed it. The expansion also adds new Paladins with abilities that reviewers described as wacky, along with new workers and new cards to purchase. Together these changes give the base game's engine more variety without requiring a new set of core rules.
Potential Drawbacks
Set Collection Feels Less Rewarding Than Enlistment
The most consistent criticism concerns the set collection element. One reviewer said their only real concern was the enlistment track, which can ramp up so quickly that a player's attribute tracks climb in very little time. The other host agreed that the set collection path "still doesn't quite feel worth it" next to the immediate payoff of enlistment. The hosts also said that the rulebook wording for scoring is unclear. They initially scored the set collection incorrectly, adding two points to their totals because they had skipped the italic example in the rulebook. One host said the wording "isn't great."
A Looser Game That Depends on the Base Game
City of Crowns is an expansion, so it requires Paladins of the West Kingdom to play, and reviewers did not treat it as something to add automatically. One reviewer said it is "one of those expansions that you don't just auto include," because the base game is already a heavy worker placement game with nuances that take time to learn. Another reviewer said they need to play the base game more before they start using the expansion. Players who value the tight feel of the base game may find that the expansion softens it, and reviewers suggested that these players should try a few games before deciding whether the change is welcome.
If You Enjoy Paladins of the West Kingdom: City of Crowns
Reviewers drew a small set of comparisons, and the recommendations below follow the reasons they gave.
- Agricola: A reviewer used Agricola as the contrast point for tightness. They described it as tight with no choices, which highlights why City of Crowns is appealing to players who want a tight game that still offers meaningful options.
- Architects of the West Kingdom: One reviewer ranked Paladins as their favorite title in the West Kingdom series and said that Architects "just isn't for me." Players who like the series should know that reviewers place Paladins ahead of Architects.
- Viscounts: A reviewer said they need to play Viscounts more but remember liking it quite a bit, which makes it a reasonable pick for players who want another title in the West Kingdom series alongside Paladins.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I am happy that expansion didn't lengthen the game in my opinion all that much. No, not at all. No extra turns or anything crazy like."
— Board Games UnLocked
"So I felt like it balanced it out. I didn't feel like I was as behind because I knew I was going to get to negotiate."
— Board Games UnLocked
"This expansion opened up so much in terms of strategy that it was absolutely on the list. This is a phenomenal expansion."
— Board Games UnLocked