Small Islands Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Small Islands
Small Islands is a tile-laying game designed by Alexis Allard and Aurélie Guarino and published by Mushroom Games and Lucky Duck Games. It supports one to four players, suits ages eight and up, and runs about 30 minutes. Reviewers agree on its core appeal: a gentle, attractive game with enough strategy to reward planning. They diverge on how it compares to older tile-laying designs.
The Broken Meeple makes the strongest comparison. In its top-ten list of games that killed other games, the channel argues that Small Islands beats Carcassonne, citing the archipelago artwork and the objective system. In a later video about games that fell off its top-100 list, the channel repeats the claim, describing Small Islands as a replacement for Carcassonne with a very good little solo mode. Board Games for One takes a more practical view in its father-and-son list, praising the beautiful artwork and lots of strategy while warning about runaway wins. A solo-focused review describes the game as very cute and not limited to solo play, adding that it plays better with more players. Meeple University's two live sessions present Small Islands as a relaxing game that is easy to enjoy once the rules settle in.
Core Mechanics That Define Small Islands
Secret Objectives and Island Scoring
Each player holds a secret objective that asks for particular symbol configurations on islands, such as lotus flowers or anchors. Board Games for One describes the rhythm of the game: at the end of each round, players try to satisfy their objective by placing one of their eight houses on a qualifying island, and whoever meets the criteria most scores the most for that round. Meeple University adds the detail that matters in practice. An island can be scored only once, and each player may hold just one house on any island, so the timing of a score matters as much as the size of the island. The Broken Meeple points to a once-per-game tile that each player ends the round with, which leaves a player exposed to the choices of others once that tile is spent.
Ship Placement and Anchor Scoring
Ships give the game its control dynamic. Every game uses four ships, with neutral ships filling the empty seats when fewer people play. Board Games for One explains that placing a ship ends the round. Placing early lets a player choose an optimal spot, while placing late sacrifices some scoring potential in exchange for control. The final player gets the last shift and can keep the game running until the tiles run out. Ship points come from the anchor symbols surrounding a ship's colored shield, and the Meeple University session shows how easy that rule is to overlook. One player had been placing ships without tracking the color-matching requirement, and the table only caught the error late in the game.
The Small Islands Experience
Relaxed Pace and Sudden Scoring
Most tables start calm. The first Meeple University game was slow to score because players focused on building as many islands as possible, with little scoring in the early rounds. Once the rules settle, the pace picks up, and the scoring arrives in bursts. A second session described the game as a really relaxing little game, and the cozy archipelago art reinforces that gentle mood. The result is a table that stays unhurried until a round of scoring suddenly lands all at once.
Tension at the Ship Endgame
Beneath the relaxed surface sits real pressure. Board Games for One warns that the ship rules can produce a runaway winner, particularly on the first play, when a competitive player can use the final shift to wreck a less prepared opponent. The same channel stresses that the danger is avoidable once the end trigger is understood. Meeple University's final tally shows how scores can swing on small reading errors. One player estimated that a correct reading of an advanced mission would have added only nine points, which was not enough to change the outcome. The tension comes less from direct conflict than from timing and from reading the table accurately.
What Makes Small Islands Stand Out
Archipelago Artwork and Objective Design
The Broken Meeple singles out the art as a major reason the game surpasses Carcassonne in its view. The channel describes building an archipelago as infinitely more pretty than the French countryside shown on the older game, and it argues that the objective cards give that building a purpose. Board Games for One pairs the art with the strategic choices that follow. A player can aim for one large island saved until the end or for many small islands built early, and each approach creates a distinct tempo across the game.
A Solo Mode With Personality
The solo mode earns consistent praise. The Broken Meeple calls it quite a neat little solo mode, and the DaniCha unboxing shows what sits behind it: solo rules on page 8 of the rulebook, an AI opponent named Alexis after the designer, and a set of mission cards. The box also includes 56 landscape tiles, cardboard punch-outs on five sheets, and bags for the tokens, details that the unboxing highlights as thoughtful. The advanced mode adds mission cards that combine objectives in new ways, which gives experienced players more to pursue after their first games.
Potential Drawbacks
Runaway Wins in the Ship Endgame
Board Games for One warns that the runaway winner risk is real when players are mismatched in competitiveness. The advice is practical: before the first game, agree whether everyone is playing competitively or playfully. A game whose outcome depends on reading the end trigger well asks more of new players than the box suggests, and the channel is candid that a first session can feel lopsided for that reason.
Dense Icons and Mission Text
Scoring depends on symbols, anchors, and advanced mission text, and reviewers repeatedly stumble over the details. The Meeple University players missed the ship-color anchor rule and misread an advanced mission, which cost them points they might otherwise have earned. The DaniCha unboxing notes that the solo-related cards were easy to sort upside down, which made the mission sides harder to parse on a first read. The rules are not difficult in principle, but the density of symbols means the first game often teaches as much as it scores.
If You Enjoy Small Islands
Players who enjoy the shared, tile-built map and the rhythm of scoring rounds will find a natural cousin in Carcassonne. The Broken Meeple treats Small Islands as the successor to that table, so the comparison is central to the community view. Players who want a gentler entry point with clear goals should look at Ticket to Ride, which the same channel names among the best gateway games for teaching new players. The two games connect through hidden goals, since players in both pursue objectives that their opponents cannot see, and Small Islands adds a layer of island-building that rewards careful placement.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Build up a map with very cute artwork, building up islands in archipelago this time, which is infinitely more pretty than French countryside."
— The Broken Meeple
"It works quite well at two players, it's a very interesting, it takes out the danger of there not being enough spots on an island. That's the one element of danger that you do get in the higher player game."
— Meeple University
"Small Islands beautiful artwork lots of strategy and how you place these islands you can make a lot of points by making one big island save it for the end of the game or make a bunch of small islands all kinds of choices."
— Board Games for One