City of Six Moons Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About City of Six Moons
Published discussion of City of Six Moons is narrow, but the two sources that cover it in depth share a common view: the game is more valued as a design idea than as a conventional solitaire session. Getting Games presents it in its Radar Vlog as an alien civilization game from Hollandspiele, designed by Amabel Holland. The reviewer says they generally do not care for solo games, yet they find the concept fascinating and hope people come to enjoy it once they start getting it.
Beyond Solitaire approaches the game from the publisher's side. In a podcast interview, Holland explains how the game changed the studio's situation and why it's seen as a time investment. Where the Getting Games reviewer is curious but cautious, Holland is openly proud of the difficulty, acknowledging that asking players to work this hard is a lot to ask.
Core Mechanics That Define City of Six Moons
Symbolic Rulebook Decipherment
The most distinctive system is the rulebook itself. As Getting Games reads from the game's listing, the box contains a rulebook written entirely in symbols and icons, and the player must decipher the rules before play begins. The listing also states that the designer will never answer rules questions, so the player cannot check their understanding against an authority. The reviewer points out that this means you will never know for certain whether you have gotten the rules right or wrong.
Getting Games connects this design to the way researchers study ancient games such as the game of UR. Scholars have a rough picture of how those games were played, but without the ability to ask the original players, the picture stays incomplete. City of Six Moons applies that same uncertainty to the act of learning the game.
Puzzle Solving as the Core Loop
Beyond Solitaire describes the puzzles as the main engine of play. Holland says that at release the puzzles were expected to be easy, and instead many players struggled with them. Holland also reports that people said the game usually took them between 10 and 20 hours, a timeline the playtesters did not match. That gap suggests the time a player spends on the game depends heavily on how they handle the difficulty.
The City of Six Moons Experience
Found-Artifact Uncertainty
Getting Games frames the game as a found object from a lost culture. The reviewer describes it as leaning into the feeling of a relic whose rules are only partly understood, and calls the rulebook an awesome thing to see. The same reviewer says the experience sounds both fascinating and potentially frustrating, because the player never receives confirmation of having solved anything correctly. That tension between wonder and doubt is the emotional core of the game as reviewers describe it.
Obsessive Puzzling
Beyond Solitaire paints a picture of a game that lingers in the mind after a session ends. Holland hoped players would get lost in the game and obsess over it a little, and was glad to hear that people were going to bed thinking about the game and the shapes in front of their eyes. Holland treats the game as a time investment rather than a quick diversion, and describes that as a feeling truly enjoyed.
What Makes City of Six Moons Stand Out
Commercial Longevity
Beyond Solitaire notes that City of Six Moons took off in a way nothing else from Hollandspiele has. Holland says the game still sells a copy every day roughly two years after release, a pattern described as unusual for a title of that age. Holland credits that steady income with giving the studio stability in an unsettled industry and with letting it slow its release schedule, allowing more time on each game.
A Bold Concept Reviewers Admire as Art
Getting Games spends much of its segment on the idea rather than the mechanics. The reviewer says the concept of a game built around alien symbols and an alien civilization is so cool that they are glad such work can be created and explored, even before they have played it. The reviewer's enthusiasm is directed at the ambition itself, which makes the game stand out as a piece of design writing as much as a puzzle.
Potential Drawbacks
Difficulty That Can Stall Players
The difficulty is the most widely noted concern, and Holland addresses it directly, describing a player who wrote in after working on the game for months, having uncovered only some of its numbers, and asking whether there was really a game to solve. Holland confirmed there was, but could not explain how to solve it. Getting Games raises the same point from a distance, noting that the uncertainty around correct play could feel discouraging to some players.
Solo Play Without an Outside Check
Getting Games states that the reviewer generally dislikes solo games, though they enjoy puzzle games and were tempted by this one. That personal reservation points to a structural issue: the listing says the designer will not answer rules questions, and the game gives no feedback on whether a solution is correct. A player who is less patient with open-ended puzzles may find that the solitary format removes any external reference point.
If You Enjoy City of Six Moons
Players who enjoy City of Six Moons's puzzle-driven narrative will find a similar sense of assembling a story from fragments in Her Story. Beyond Solitaire names it as the closest analogous experience Holland can think of, and the host confirms having played it. Both games reward patient searching through material that is never fully explained.
Players drawn to the feeling of holding an incomplete artifact from a fictional past can explore Swords Against Beginner's Box, Holland's newer release that Beyond Solitaire discusses in the same interview. It presents itself as a replica of an incomplete old RPG, so it extends the found-object approach that defines City of Six Moons. Readers interested in the rulebook concept should also look at the game of Ur, which Getting Games uses as an analogy for playing with incomplete knowledge.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The fact that you can never actually be sure if you got it right sounds fascinating and also potentially frustrating. I really don't know but honestly as a piece of art I'm so glad this exists and I hope it's fun."
— Getting Games
"I feel like this is a game that is a time investment. It's a game that I hope people can, if it is a game, that I hope people can get lost in and think about and maybe obsess over a little bit."
— Beyond Solitaire
"People told me Six Moons usually took them between 10 and 20 hours. Which is not what it was for my playtesters of Six Moons. But it was for the general public."
— Beyond Solitaire