Which Racing Board Game is Best? VS. Series | Best Racing Board Games Ranked
Transcript
waai for me uh yeah remember when I was fishing for a compliment and you instead just complimented all men everywhere I roll you did what does my hair look like right now crazy it's nice see I give you compliments Jeff you look nice it's too late it's not worth winning if you can't win big from Kyle King and mine it's Michael Scott the man the my the legend hello everyone and welcome back to Foster the meele a Channel all about board games and board gamy things exactly did you think I was going to cut you off no cuz I almost did you just did there though when I was about to say my name my name is Jane I'm Jeff I didn't even get to finish saying my name my name my name my name isff Jeff yes my name is Jamie I'm Jeff and we're here today to do a different video something that we haven't done before but it came to me once upon a dream and I thought let's try it did you actually dream about this I don't think so okay so what we're doing today is we're going to be comparing all of the racing games that we played all of them all of them is there that many how many is there there's only five and we are going to from that that can't be right it is I've like looked at everything there's like no racing games it's crazy what did you just see what I did touchcreen it's not a touchcreen we are going to be comparing all all of the racing games that we have played in hopes to determine which one is best an objective list just kidding it's subjective so what we're going to do is we've put all
of our racing games that we've played into all five of them all five of them into Pub meeple and for anybody who doesn't know Pub meeple is a website that you can go to to rank and compare your board games it will match two board games from your list against each other and then you have to determine which one you like more Yep y it's very convenient it's very convenient I've only used it once but it was pretty fun so it's going to pop up with two of the racing games and Jeff and I collectively need to decide which one of those two is best until we get through all of them and then we'll have our list a ranked list so the rules are that we both have to what you spilled j a wrong ohaa
shut up nobody can see it doesn't I spell El Dorado wrong too anyways the rules basically are the two games are going to pop up Jeff and I have to collectively agree on which one is better if we do not agree on which one is better we have to have a discussion about it until we do agree so Jeff and I don't always agree on things this is going to be hilarious we thought that we would start off with racing games because there aren't a ton of them we haven't played all of the racing games obviously but we play played some and it's one of my favorite I think both of our favorite mechanics so we thought let's start here and then from there we can maybe grow this if you people if like it if you like it and you have any like some other like mechanics we could do maybe we could do a mechanic thing or like we could do all from one publisher like all games we play from ston Meer or AEG or roxley or whoever yeah this is really good idea this is a great idea thank you now I will say board game barrage does something similar they call it the bgb bgb Bob where but they are like debating so each will bring their own list and they're trying to determine what best I remember this is a little bit different than that so we have five games those games are camel up cubitos downforce with two hours jamaa what I did night we have downforce with two hours Jamaica but smell spelled jamaa and then we have quest for El Dorado El Dorado being one word which isn't terrible but this is what happened to you put me in charge so the games we
are yeah comparing is camel up cubitos down Force no down Force down Force jamaa jamaa Jamaica and quest for El Dorado so are you ready yeah I already know what my number five is though really I honestly oh I think I do know what yours might be okay let's go
rank okay seven comparisons so first up we have downforce versus cubitos which is a difficult one for me okay so downforce is a car racing game cubitos is a cube racing game but you're in the land of Cubes we should elaborate a little bit sure downforce is uh car racing but there's an auction element and you're playing cards bidd so you're playing cards to move your cars cubitos is a push your luck race game where you're rolling dice adding dice dra not really drafting buying dice to add to your pool rolling dice to move your character yes and the other thing about downforce as well is your car doesn't necessarily need to win you just have to be right in who is winning yeah so you're auctioning car types to start like colors yeah and then you are eventually bidding on who you think is going to win so it is beneficial for your cars to win because there are dollar amounts associated with being first second or third you're also bidding on winners and stuff so there's multiple paths a victory so down Force I love both of these games a lot this this is a this is probably going to be one of the most challenging this is a banger first uh match up yeah so we've played cubitos a bunch we own it we've played it what Own It We Own It just FY I don't be jealous but we do we played it a bunch we've played it at two players we've played it at three players and four players so it's a hit every time with every person downforce we've also
played it two yeah we've played it we played it many many different uh iterations of this so we've played it in person at 2 we've played it on BGA with the expansions the danger circuit expansion we've played it at like like a safari exion uh it's danger circuit that's what it's called uh at two I mean you might as well say 2 three 4 and up to like six I think maybe we've played it up yeah we've played a lot of downforce we've only played downforce one time in person everything else has been on BGA but we' love downforce so much that we have it on order with the expansion because this is such a great game okay so if we had to determine which is best which is best downforce or cubitos cubitos is cuter okay let's go on the merits okay what mechanic do you like better do you like the auction bidding card placement better or do you like the dice rolling push your luck element I think I like the push your luck element better mhm what about you I pref that's tough for me I prefer the card placing auction piece yeah because again with my luck no it's not but I this is going to shock you I think but I think I'm leaning cubitos on this I think I am too and I think it's because like I love downforce though we always have such a great time but I feel like there's something about cubitos that's just so like Lively and fun and it I think it has to do with rolling the dice and like see but here's the thing are we saying that because we've played cubitos at a higher player account live than we have downforce I bet you if we play downforce live like in person we would be this would be much
more difficult because when you play it on BGA it's kind of like you're just clicking picking and then there's not as much excitement yeah I don't know I think it also depends on who you're playing it with cuz when we were playing with like Josh Danielle and Max and we were like blocking each other in and we were laughing I think like the theme of cubitos has me more see D Force has me more right if you had an ideal player account let's say you got to play both of these games at an ideal player account in person mhm mhm so someone calls you and says hey I want to play one of these two games we have four people here if that's your primary player account right we have four people here you have to pick the game but ideal circumstances which one are you picking I think I might pick downforce what would you pick I'm this is stressful and I don't even know why I'm leaning I'm leaning to beos but I think if I had the same experiences of a downforce on the table with a bunch of people I would be picking downforce so I think I'm downforce so we have to say maybe lock it in so I'm going to say downforce and I'm locking I'm locking in downforce okay so downforce it is wow that was very diff it's going to get easier I think as it goes may this one's not great either okay we have jamaa J jamaa versus camel up C up so camel up is a once again a bidding and racing game where you are bidding on camels who are racing around a track uh hoping that you can choose the camel
that is going to be winning and the camel that is going to lose also you can bid on both of those and there is a mechanic where there are two camels going against the track yes that other camels can land on and then be carried backwards and that's a new newly implemented system in the revised Edition I think in the second edition of Camelot which is the one we have which is the one we've played Jamaica is a pirate themed race game where you kind of have a set of cards and you're playing cards and those cards allow you to either move yeah um grab like treasure I think which gives you new cards or new like purchasing ability forward yeah there's a lot of like manipulation we've only played this a few times but it's basically a big Rondell and the first one to get across or get get through wins basically so we've played Jamaica twice I think we've played it only with uh my brother so only at a four player count camel up we've played quite a few times we've played it with my brothers we've played it with my brother and my niece we played it with our friends Shannon and Jen once so we played definitely played camot more this is an easy choice for me it is for me too but the thing that I prefer I prefer Jamaica's theme I really like that pirate theme okay camel up has a pyramid that poops dice no no no the theme see this is what we always talk about the theme of the game I just prefer the pirate E theme over the cam them the Egyptian theme but camel Up's an easy po easy for Camel up is easy for
both of us this is probably the funnest game I can't see anything Sur planting really camel up for me interesting spoilers okay I'm locking in camel up ick camel up camel up okay next up we have downforce and quest for El
Dorado Okay so we've already talked a little bit about downforce quest for El Dorado is a deck builder it is a deck builder racing game that is just like the most pure form of race game that you could possibly have you are building up cards in order to move your people to get to the end of the terrain of El Dorado there are no victory points there are no like special win conditions it's literally you're playing cards to move your meeples to get to the end first yeah similar to kitos wherein it's really just whoever crosses the line first yeah El Dorado is definitely an entrylevel Game Y very much so which we do own yeah so you're you're essentially playing cards to get through different terrain types y so you're cutting down we uh cutting down jungle with machetes to get through the jungle you're collecting coins to get through the market spaces and then there's mountains and all of these things yeah water and etc etc this is another easy one for me yeah I think this is probably an easy one for me so quest for Al Dorado I think the downfall for this one is that we've only played it at two players yep I would love to play this game with more players number one and I would love to play this game with more new players like people that we want to get into the hobby oh yeah it's definitely an entry L I think that that would I think it'd be exciting to play with people who are like this is really cool like who haven't done deck building or anything I think the beauty of quest for Alder a is it's giving you two kind of mechanics to introduce people too that they could
latch on to one being the deck building optimizing your deck so that you're traversing this map as quickly as possible the other is just the racing aspect yeah uh Quest has a special spot for that purpose alone yes but I find for us it's difficult to compete with these other ones at this point I am going down force and I'm locking it in I'm locking in down Force as well zoom zoom I'm very fast have you ever won down Force jez Louise just a question asking for I actually don't know I don't think I have all right next up did you win the last time we played down no you didn't so get out of here next up we have cubito versus quest for El
Dorado another very easy one for me and I just think it honestly is because quest for Al Dorado is so simple I'd like to play with the expansions though because I think that does add maybe something into it yeah it's tough this is a bit more more difficult for me because I do prefer the deck building aspect of quest for alerado than I do the the push your luck aspect of kidos just because my luck is so be but yeah it's hard to put quest for Al Dorado in my opinion in these rankings because it is kind of the lighter one easier I mean easier to get to the table if it's new Gamers uh new to that mechanic but I love Kos love the theme I love the little dice I love the variety that it gives you the only thing I wish K to and this isn't really necessarily a knock just like a wish list and I'm sure you can maybe get them I wish they had like a dice tray oh dice trays oh indiv visualized di di tray TR for everybody but yeah this is an easy one for me it's cubitos locked cubitos locked in we haven't had much disagreement Jeffery okay next up we have downforce versus camel up now this is a tough one I know in my mind which way I want to go and I don't know that you're going to go the same way as me so I will I want to go yeah so do I okay you do oh my God we're like on the same page so why I've had again this is why I keep saying like I
want to experience down force and I really want that game to come in so that we can play with your brothers you can play with your niece and get the same shared experience that we've had with camel up I will say that Camel up I think that aside that experience aside the fact that Camel up has so many other little things you can do like you can choose to roll the dice you can choose to take a bid you can choose to do these things add a extra layer of strategy over downforce which is literally I'm going to play a card and move cars but there are special powers in downforce you mean the Boost card no like the other like you can be cunning you can be I know we have but we haven't played with those oh I have we we played with those in our time at boardroom Cafe but you haven't played with them but you're but okay but yeah fair enough there's special actions but you're still only just playing a C you're just playing I mean like you're not getting poop cop has the the pyramid that you grab and you you roll the dice and everyone's like what's going to happen like you got to sell me on celop blah blah blah I think it's again this is tough because I want the the table experience of downforce a bit more but C for sure locked in back that's a tough one to compete with for us fun all right downforce versus Jamaica jamaa
jamaa this is also an easy one for me this is actually closer for me than I think it should be yeah really you know what though like honestly we played Jamaica and I we had so much fun we wanted to like we were thinking about it we wanted to buy it we wanted to play it ourselves but then you know Zach was leaving for Egypt and we're like well we don't really have a ton of people to play with see it's been a long time since we've played it A and B we haven't played it as much as these other games and I just talked to Zach and they recently played it and he was like it's still so to your point after we played that game we were like this game is so good and I think that was actually that might have been one of other than camel up which I think was the initial race game we played yes this was the second one we played this was the second one we played and I think that's when you were kind of like maybe started to think that the racing mechanic was something you like a lot it's so fun the thing about Jamaica is it's so colorful and bright and the theme is excellent and you can really screw other people over like there's take that action in Jamaica now you can in downforce like you can block people in which is a little bit funny to do but I think it's a bit more in Jamaica I'd like to play more of both of these games I don't know which one I want Jeff wants jamaa I think I'm Jamaica there's really cute seagull cards I think I'm Jamaica but I don't know no no no I'm down Force no I'm down guy might be down Force too and that's I think that's just a product of how much more we've played it that's not a knock on Jamaica I just don't think we've played it enough yet J sha on it's very good but I I'm down Force so down Force
locked in yeah okay Jamaica versus cubitos cubitos locked in yeah I don't think we need to discuss that one I think honestly like cubitos is very quickly becoming one of my favorite games yeah it's very good it's so fun I love rolling dice okay here's one quest for El Dorado versus Jamaica this one's easy for me it's Jamaica yeah I just think of these games quest for El Dorado is on the bottom it is is you had your mind made up before we even started I agree though Jamaica it just and it's not because it's a bad game it's a it's an amazing game it's just it's too simple for us at this point MH we're so intelligent we're Beyond Quest forado Jamaica lock it in O that's it I don't want PayPal thank you okay so oh is that what you were expecting I'm not overly shocked I think two and three could probably just live harmoniously yeah I'm actually surprise okay so our final list because we only did five games for a very quick video our number five we should be no surprised is Quest for El Dorado and that is from Ravensburger designed by Riner kitzia then number four we have Jamaica you going to be able to list those ones off no do you want me to look yeah that was a silly decision so Jamaica from GameWorks Gameworks yeah Bruno cathala
Malcolm what is it BR Malcolm BR Sebastian poan Sebastian poan the crustation crustation from little that is Jamaica number four pirate racing yep number three we have cubitos designed by John declair published by AEG what I've been on my iPad so much that I keep trying to touch the screen stop putting your fingerprints all over my screen I walked into this thinking cuitas would be my number one over camel up no come on man over downforce though but then I picked downforce you did oh my God I was so stressed out okay then we have number two downforce from restoration games designed by wolf game Kramer Rob davio davio Jacob damn it Justin Jacobson John Jacob Jingleheimer that's my name too okay so that is our number two downforce and our number one game which I guess is really no surprise because the game love I think it's on both of our top 10 lists isn't it it's online it's not on mine maybe it's not not mine it should be top 10 no is it online I don't know Hamel up from ediel designed by stepan Bogan I think here I can't read that yeah Stephan ban yeah is there somebody else with name on there no a game by stepan boj I really like this I want to do this with like a longer bigger list it could turn into a long video though because this is a half an hour so that is our versus series number one racing
games with with camel up coming in at number one we have not tried but I desperately want to try flam flam flam Rouge I want to try flam Rouge I like to try that flam Rouge I want to try that flam Rouge isn't it flam Rouge flam Rouge what is it flam Rouge flam Rouge oh SE FR so I want to try that game which is a bicycle racing game and I really want to try long shot which is like horse Ring there's not a ton of racing games which is there's probably some we're not thinking of we were thinking about putting sheepy time on this list but it's not truly a racing game you're kind of racing against the nightmare but it's not really one of its main mechanics so didn't put that on there I have a hiccup that is our first of our versus series if there's another mechanic or something that you would like us to do one of videos on a publish mechanic mechanical publisher uh theme like space come on that's getting way too broad Disney Space theme that's like a million games Disney game we haven't played a million games anything like that let us know down below if there are any racing games that we haven't mentioned that you think we should definitely play also mention those down below let us know what you think about everything literally just tell us what do you think about everything like what do you think about the color blue sure that is all that we have for you guys today thank you so much for watching if you like what you see please subscribe thank you
Kyle King for that beautiful shirt Kyle king co-creator of seasons in a real sandbagging son sandbag and Son of a I don't think that we can leave that in real sandbagger more sand more sand more sand more need aisp more sand more more sand more sand moreand if you would like to join us on our Discord we would love to have you please definitely feel free to do that if you feel like supporting us uh on patreon you can can also do that all the links and information down below oh that was nice we have social media @ poost the mebon Instagram and Twitter if you'd like to follow us there if you would like to buy any of the games that we talked about today you should definitely start by checking your friendly local gaming store and for us here in Hell foxes boardroom Game Cafe say it with conviction where is itton located on barington exactly we'll put all the information right here as well as down below stop with that stupid finger thing I hate it other than that that's all we have for you guys today thank you for watching we hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye I'm not a crook goodbye you've never seen that Nicholas Cage movie no I don't know what I have no context for that enough spot can you people hear us one sec yeah thank you I knew something was it was hanging on there are you ready so basically how we're
going to do this you have me so confused why I know just did jeez must be a Monday I mean it is you said it man I know number three we have is it Pirates or privateers I can't really remember it's Pirates or I don't know if it is Pirates I feel like it's not Pirates I think it's just like like different ships I knew whenever we go up the people always show there goes John and Jacob J go I had to finish it yeah but I haven't even cut anything out though I don't think we need to we did great you barely paused it all yeah no y definitely didn't need to look up Publishers and designers and stuff either oh that's like normal fair I like this everyday Fair now there are some you just said number one camel up coming in at number one number one in number one nobody was aware of