Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 6:54

in my videos i talk a lot about hooks i kick off each of my reviews by looking at the key features of a game which are designed to catch the attention of consumers and retailers but is this reasonable or is it greedy exploitative and opportunistic i received a comment on one of my videos from a viewer who wasn't happy with the product design focus i'm using in my videos specifically the promotion of hooks this viewer felt that the premise of hooks was patronizing it was treating gamers as a shoal of fish easily grabbed by gimmicks it's sobering to receive negative feedback among the many many warm comments i receive both publicly and in email and direct messages i encourage feedback in every video specifically because i like to hear what you all think about each topic that i discuss so i thought it was worth reflecting on this viewer's criticism am i doing game as a disservice treating them as naive and suggestible nobody wants to be manipulated right i'm adam porter i'm a board game inventor from cardiff in wales and over the last few years i've made many videos about board game design and in the last year specifically i've focused heavily on games as products exploring topics like onboarding motivation customer journeys innovation and design thinking i've taken a new approach to my game reviews putting less emphasis on gameplay and more on design choices the concept of hooks is frequently discussed in game design circles but that term is not necessarily familiar to players so what

exactly have i been banging on about all this time well a hook is a feature which draws people in something that piques their interest and motivates them to stick around to learn more a novelist might start their tale with a particularly shocking passage an outrageous event to be unpicked later an insurmountable challenge for the principal character which readers willed them to overcome a hook could even be a single sentence which captures the overarching theme it is a truth universally acknowledged that a single man in position of a good fortune must be in want of a wife to be or not to be that is the question when pitching a screenplay for a television or film project the hook is pivotal it needs to be describable in one or two sentences and it needs to be gripping in music a hook has a similar function to quickly catch the attention of a listener but strong hooks also have another quality they're memorable they stick around in your head you find yourself humming the tune in the shower or on your drive to work a strong melodic hook can become an ear worm games work a little bit differently from novels or films or music in that they're interactive a player doesn't passively consume media they don't sit back and watch a narrative unfold they create that narrative and this broadens what a hook can be a hook for a board game could be thematic it could be mechanical

it could be physical or it could be contextual a thematic hook for a game is plain to see why did i purchase ravensberger's jaws game as fun as the hidden movement one versus all gameplay is that wasn't a draw for me the appeal was the nostalgia for the film i was keen to immerse myself in that story to relive some of my childhood memories in a new format a mechanical hook could be a little bit harder to describe remember a great hook only takes a sentence or two to put across quarto is a game with an incredible mechanical hook when it's your turn your opponent chooses which piece you play simple clear and yet it subverts everything we know about how board games are supposed to work the more complex the game gets the harder it is to put across its mechanical hook a physical hook is the closest to what we might refer to as a gimmick though the word gimmick is a pejorative and i don't consider a strong physical hook cynical or superficial think of the vertical playing board in connect 4 the pyramid dice shaker in camel up or the bird box dice tower in wingspan a strong visual and tactile presence helps players to engage a contextual hook encompasses anything else but it often relates to the reputation of a game or a game maker libertaria was a very popular game back in 2012 but it soon went out of print and for several years players were unable to get their own copy as time passed that game became more and more

desirable we always want what we can't have stone meyer tapped into this increased demand with a new version of the game with a reimagined setting reworked rule set and attractive components hekmek m kartenek or picomono the card game offers a new experience to fans of the original dice game a mirror image to game rights dice game re-implementation of sushi go and just as moviegoers flock to the cinema to see the 27th jurassic park hobby gamers who love a particular title will be keen to play a sequel or later edition of that same game but it's also clear that the word hook is used widely and inconsistently in different media its meaning is fluid and ambiguous in literature is something you experience when you open the book for the first time and read that first passage in tabletop terms this would be the equivalent of hooking a player with an incredible first play of a game in music the hook is less intellectual and more visceral it's about creating something memorable something which sticks in your mind in film as in tabletop games it's all about the pitch so if we conclude that a hook is intended to peak interest capture attention and engage a player then really we should acknowledge the enormity of that task as my commenter pointed out gamers are not a shoal of fish they have their own minds their own values attitudes and circumstances a hook for one player is a turn-off for another if you're going to devise a hook for your game you really need to

identify who you're trying to appeal to who is your potential audience and what are they looking for we're going to look at player types and avatars in a future video working with hooks is all about empathy it's not about opportunism a design thinking approach puts the end user right at the start of the process if you understand your player's needs at the earliest stage and identify your hook early you're far more likely to create something useful to players something of value and in making this video i hope i've offered something useful to designers out there i hope you found it valuable if so please do join in the discussion in the comments and let me know some of the best hooks you've seen in board games and don't forget to subscribe hit like and explore some of the other game design videos on this channel until next time all the best

Progress saved