Jon Auctions Games!
Transcript
welcome to John gits games today I'm going to talk about the games that are no longer in my collection recently I sold 27 games 22 of them went to a live board gaming auction and I'm going to discuss my top 10 most disappointing games from that overall chunk of 27 explain the reason I was excited to get the game and the reason ultimately I got rid of it and at the end I'll briefly tell you about the four games I picked up at the auction so let's jump right into it number 10 is bang the dice game now if you've been watching my channel you've seen that I a review of it and I was pretty unhappy and the reason this is way high on the list is because I didn't actually fully expect to like the game right from the get-go I heard really good things but in general I don't love games with lots of deception and potentially lying But ultimately that's not why I didn't like this game it was just too random too quick there wasn't even moments to really do tactics it kind of just felt like the game played itself we played it a couple times with my group and nobody liked it so I really don't understand where all the hype came from obviously a lot of people are enjoying this game out there but it totally flopped with us unfortunately number nine is a duel betwix us this is one of the many Kickstarter games that I've received throughout the years and I I wasn't really expecting to like the gameplay mechanics of this game I will be honest I bought it because of the crazy art and you've got that crazy cover and it's just wonderful stuff and ideas in the box from a thematic standpoint that you're both dueling and you're you know hitting each other with fish and oh now we're just going to throw our Shields at each other and really goofy stuff like
that and inside of it it actually had a really interesting um resource Gathering mechanism where there were three different values of resources and you could move your little workers according to them so you could get cheap stuff really easily but you could slowly move them to the higher value ones but you have to kind of invest your time so there's a short-term to long-term kind of thing you're doing there I like that and then right after that you go into the duel which I don't know it just felt really dry and kind of it just fell flat considering this game looks ridiculous and you would say the name of the DU but then you just look at your little number and their number and you see who wins and then you get rid of it it felt pretty anticlimactic and ultimately I think I really enjoy the idea of the game way more than I actually like the game number eight is archon glory and macation this is yet another Kickstarter that I've backed and I was pretty excited about it because it had a very cool worker placement idea where you have a bunch of regular workers but when you play them out you have a hand of cards and you play a card with it and the card says what kind of worker that is so you effectively have four different kinds of workers in the game and that seemed kind of fresh and interesting to me instead of just having workers that do whatever this is a special worker and it can like copy its thing or it can go where somebody else is I like that idea a lot but then I got the game and I put the board out of my table and my eyes just exploded out of my head because there is so it's so busy there's so much going on you can barely see where you can actually put your workers down and then there are four different resources in the game and they're gray black tan and brown and then the four player colors are gray black tan and brown they're the same same colors so you're like is that a
player color is that a resource is that black or gray and is it oh my gosh it was so confusing just to try to play and on top of that there was also a building that essentially negated allowed two of the four different roles to be the same thing so now you're picking from three it was the church and oh man I played it a couple times and it was a total flop each time it was it was it was way too much like hard work I really wanted to like it but the game really got on its own way game number seven is nothing personal yet another Kickstarter board game and I would was pretty interested in this one at first because has a very cool idea where you have this big deck of randomized thugs and mobsters and they go into a pyramid on the board and the higher up they go on the pyramid the more powerful they get and the very top is the crime boss and they're going to get killed or taken to jail and then everybody kind of shifts up and you don't actually own these cards you put your influence down on the cards to kind of temporarily Own It multiple people are influencing back and forth what ends up happening is it becomes very backstabby which should be blatantly obvious the name of the game is called nothing personal and I did not really enjoy how backstabby it is which is completely my fault and not the game I don't actually knock the game for any of its mechanics I think it's quite solid beautiful art and awesome component quality but it just didn't really work for me number six is Argent the Consortium yes it's another Kickstarter and if you've watched my BGG gcon Impressions from last year you'll see that I had quite a few problems with it it seemed way too long uh for what it was it seemed way too complex it was really really hard to strategize because
points came from everywhere there appeared to be some pretty broken combos that you can put together we just got steamrolled by one player who was able to place like all four of their people down and all of the bell tower cards before myself or the other opponent were able to get more than three people down it was just it just didn't work and honestly I never played it again I got my Kickstarter version and I just sold it fully punched I really hope the person who gets it is going to enjoy it I'm not saying that the game is bad it's just really didn't work with me and I think that I would have very much enjoyed it if it had been like 75% of what it was and I didn't really feel like trying to shoehorned in or make any variants to make it work instead now somebody else will hopefully enjoy it number five is not a Kickstarter game it is sale to India this is one of the many kind of micro is games that AEG has been putting out recently and this one was supposed to be a really quick Euro game like a 15minute Euro game and what it ended up being was was incredibly confusing incredibly abstract and really not engaging for me at all I came into this quite excited for it I like that idea maybe 15 20 minute Euro game get those gears going but now what I've kind of realized is that you really can't get those gears going in 15 minutes maybe there's a game out there that does this game tried and it just felt like it ended too soon but at the same time I already wanted it to end it just it has so many weird things going on where the cubes are so multi-purpose that you really don't feel any connection to the theme of sailing ships or selling cargo
or anything it was just really hard to teach and get into and ultimately I decided it wasn't for me number four is potato man and I actually talked about this one in one of my John gets excited segments I was very excited for this idea of a trick-taking game with asymmetric Decks that sounded so neat you know the red deck has all the high cards the Yellow Jack has the low cards but has a card that can kill the highest card and it also has this neat idea where you intentionally don't follow suit you cannot play a suit after somebody else what ended up happening is well first of all we played at five player and that completely did not work at all and I played the four player game a couple times and it just did not engage me and I'm starting to feel like I might just not like trick taking games that much I have diamonds up here and you know it was okay it had a couple interesting twists but I think that a trick-taking game with twists is not something that I'm really finding myself very interested in I'm going to keep diamonds cuz it does play up to six quite well and I've enjoyed playing it a couple times but it didn't really grab me and potato man specifically really did not grab me it felt like a really neat idea that just did not really work for us number three brings us back to Kickstarter with a stunni and emerald now the idea of this just totally blew my socks off you have this Sherlock Holmes lovecraftian Universe you've got deck building area control with hidden identities and you know you have this semi-cooperative thing where only the team that wins has the ability to have a specific person win so only one person's going to win but if your team loses you don't even have it shot that sounded so
neat and we got it to the table and what I ended up finding is that the game was like 15 to 20% deck building and then like 50 to 60% area control and then a little bit of that uh hidden rolls on top of it it was quite hard to disguise really what your hidden rle was it was relatively easy for us to figure out who each person was which was not that big of a deal but ultimately it is a big old area majority game with a little bit of deck building on the side and I just don't find area majority appealing at all if you look behind me you'll find pretty much zero area majority games uh one or two I'm kind of okay with but it's just not compelling and this game just did not work for me because of that fortunately I was able to sell it to one of my friends so it's still in our gaming group because a couple of my friends really enjoyed it I mean thematically it was great those cards are so interesting and the little bit of a deck building that it had seemed pretty fresh you had some kind of cool ideas is going on there but ultimately I just did not want to play a big long area majority game number two is our last Kickstarter game of the list and that is roll Through the Ages the Iron Age now I was super excited about this one I pretty much instantly backed it when it came out because you have this civilization theme plus you have Pusher luck dice mechanics I always wanted to play rooll through the ages of the Bronze Age but I never got around to it or I never really had the opportunity so this kind of felt like my new opportunity to do that now I understand that the Bronze Age was designed by Matt Leo and the Iron Age is designed by Thomas Leman so they're definitely different and when I ended up jumping
into the game I was very disappointed by what I found I actually didn't like this game so much that I never played it a second time and one of the main reasons for that and I know it's going to sound crazy because I only played it once is it really felt like the core mechanic of the game where you have ports and you have provinces it just did not seem very balanced now I understand that the game is probably going to be different with two three and four players I only played it with two uh and it's very likely that that balance is different with like four players but it was just so obvious to me that Port seemed better I wrote a post on Board Game Geek and a whole bunch of people responded Tom Leman responded and I don't think that they were necessarily wrong but they did not do a very solid job of convincing me to really give the game another shot I have so many great games that I want to play I have so many games I'm super excited to try that when the game comes out and it just seems so transparently obvious that you should do the port strategy instead of the province strategy that just isn't very fun on top of that even in a two-player game it seemed like it took a lot longer than I would like I would be worried to play a four-player game with this especially considering there's nothing you can do when it's not your turn there's no planning there's no strategizing I mean there's the Technologies you can kind of think about what you might want to do but it's pretty much just multiplayer Soler watching what the other people are going to do until it comes back around to you I ultimately had no interest in playing it again and I sold it off and now the number one disappointment from all the games that I sold and that is ukia now this is designed by Carl Chuck and I really like Carl Chuck's games I own
impulse Innovation I own glory to Rome and that's the biggest reason I was interested in econia the glory to Rome I have is actually inside this poison box right here because it's the original Cambridge Games edition that came in that terrible clamshell didn't even have a box so it's in a poison box for some reason and I was just very interested in the idea of Glory to Rome light where it was going to be a little bit easier to teach people and it had the this awesome like people and dinosaurs coexisting theme I was just sold the moment I heard about it I went out ordered it and got it and what I ended up getting was glory to Rome water down and that's a pretty big difference between light and water down unfortunately it was just not very compelling at all it really didn't have any of those awesome crazy combos it just felt like it just kind of played and you had these pretty pictures but I didn't really care what I was doing and I ended up playing it like three or four times and ultimately was just had no interest in playing it again it was just so blah and it really surprised me with that amazing art and theme and designer ultimately it is now gone and I think I will just find myself continuing to play glory to Rome also I've heard there's a rumor that there's a new Kickstarter coming out soon for a new glory to Rome light by Carl Chuck called monani I'm definitely going to be looking into that one but that is a tangent so I sold all these games and when you combine the store credit I got from the auction and the games to my friends I got way over $400 so that's pretty great I have a new little budget for buying new games that I'm excited about grabbing while I was at the live auction I did pick up four
games which I'm pretty happy about especially for the price I got them for and uh so briefly uh the first one that I got was Skyline so that one is over here and it is a pusher like game where you're building little skyscrapers that's all I knew about it I was like I knew that there were dice with little building symbols on them and it was push your luck so I got it for a very cheap price I played it once it was really light but I enjoyed it I could look forward to playing that one a couple more times uh the next one that I grabbed is Jamaica and that one is right here I've played a four-player game of it subsequently and I enjoyed it but I think I'm really going to want to play six players with this game I feel like you want more ships attacking each other I all I knew was that it was pretty and it was well-rated when I went in and bought the game for $21 which is a pretty good deal considering it's like $50 or $60 online so I'm very happy with that pickup for sure the third game I grabbed is Johari it's it's hiding behind my head up here and again if you watch my bcon wrapup I had a lot of things to say about this game I ultimately really liked it I was really looking forward to playing it again and I haven't yet but now I have the opportunity I did feel like the game played a little bit long when I played it at BGC con but now that I got the box and I read the rules I realized that we probably played it wrong at BGC con we played it with 12 turns when actually you're only supposed to play 10 so right there the game was supposed to be a little bit shorter than I thought it was going to that just increases my interest and excitement in playing it again and the number one game that I was so excited to grab was El gacho that one is
right here and I've actually just posted before this video a full run through of this game uh including that run through I played it three times and I'm just really into it I've been excited about this game since pretty much the first time I heard about it a few months ago and I was fully anticipating buying it with my auction earnings I was not expecting somebody to put it up for auction and for me to be able to grab it for only $20 9 bucks like 3 months before it hits Us distribution so that was definitely the really big winner of the auction for me so that pretty much wraps up this auction Vlog I hope you've enjoyed it if you're interested in watching more stuff like this more full playthroughs and reviews and all this kind of stuff I do please consider subscribing to my YouTube channel thanks for watching