Best Games of 2025 Fantasy Draft | Results Show
Transcript
We're back.
Back, baby.
We're back with the results of the 2025 fantasy draft. If you didn't see that video about
stop, go there.
This will be really Look at that. Basically, a card or a link in the description stuff. But what did we do in that video, Jimmy?
So, what we did in that video is we drafted uh board games that were released in 2025, taking turns. We did a snake draft. We sat in these positions and sat in the exact same position starting with me and then blah blah blah blah blah drafted 10 games each.
Y
and then the way that we determined who the winner is is on BG there is a big metal list of all of the content creators who make uh top 10s I think when I checked this. So this is as of the time that I checked it. It'll be it'll continue to change but that doesn't matter because these results are final.
Yeah.
Um but when I checked there were 300 lists I think. So, how does this how does the scoring work? Cuz I was still never entirely sure how the scoring work.
The good news is every game because we're geniuses, every game that we drafted ended up on that list.
I think goodness at the end there were 138 games on the list.
So, a pretty big list.
So, the nice thing is because all of the games on that are on the list, we can just do golf scores where basically we add up all the numbers and whoever has the lowest number wins,
right? Because number one would be one point has the lowest score. I got it. I see what you're saying
because it it gets a little bit more confusing if one game isn't off there because then you have to do a different scoring style.
I don't remember what I drafted. I know I drafted number one.
So, for my first pick, I drafted the game Vantage by Stonem Games. Little uh exploration game.
Story game.
Stone is always a safe bet. I feel like
we played it since then. Enjoyed it quite a bit. I think it's safe to say.
Way more than I was expecting to.
Very good story game. It came in at number six.
Yeah, I was like, I think it's in the top 10. It's the top 10. Unfortunately, it was not uh number one. So, you know, a bit of a waste of a pick. Um,
did any of us pick a number one?
Yeah.
I also have a pick that is high Vantage. So,
okay, cool.
So, my first pick was Vantage at number six. Nick, your first pick was Elder Scrolls: Betrayal of the Second Era.
Yeah.
Which was ranked number 12.
Oh, wow. I was out of the top 10. I'm kind of shocked. It's such a big game. I wonder if not enough people had played it, but it was like one of those things where I'm like I think enough people would rank it high enough
that it would get in there. I guess not.
Yeah. I think with Chip Theory Games, it's like because they are such big games, they're expensive, obviously they are, you know.
Well, that one particularly. Yeah.
It's just like Yeah. Does it just not quite hit as many people's hands to be ranked? 12 is not bad, but you know, out of
138 games.
Yeah. Very good.
All right. And so, uh, Mike, your first, uh, draft pick was Lord of the Rings: Fate of the Fellowship.
Oh, thank you for the number one.
It was the NUMBER ONE RANKED NUMBER ONE.
WOW.
It was It was good use of a pick.
And
I would not have called Wow, you were dead. You picked number one to number one.
Well, here's where it gets interesting. So, Mike's second pick was Galactic Cruise, which was number two.
Boom.
So, yeah,
y'all were doubting my picks. I
I really thought Mike was going to be last, but then you're
on the pose of the people.
Of the three of us, I really I predicted I was going to be first. Obviously, Jimmy was going to be second, then Mike was going to be third. But the majority of the comments, cuz a lot of people in the comments that video predicted they thought was win, and I feel like more people were picking Mike than anyone else. And I was always like, really? Mike sucked. I appreciate the audience's belief in my
Wow. One, two. I'm a strong fan. Here's the thing. Here's the thing. I love Fellowship.
I'm fired up right now. So happy. IT'S LIKE 9:30 at night. We're at the studio late tonight.
We're We're fueled on Domino's pizza and brownies. No rules right now on a pizza.
There's no rules.
Um All right. So, Nick, your second pick
was Hot Streak.
This I think it was I think it was in the top 10, right?
Yes, it was number seven.
Okay.
So, not even not your highest pick.
Oh, really?
But a solid solid pick. Yeah, I was I was I was even though I picked Elder Scrolls number one, that was the one I was the most sure was gonna be in the top 10. Yeah,
same. I was I was like that's for sure gonna be in the top.
Yeah.
So, uh my second pick was Zenith,
which came in at number five.
Wow. That really
Yeah. So, that is my highest uh highest ranked pick.
Wow. Listen. Oh, mine's going to be hard to beat.
People agree, baby. People agree with me. Wow.
Suck it, Jeff. Dang, that's good. That's Wow. I I was like I didn't expect that at all.
Yeah, for Zenith, man. That's great.
The BGA factor effect.
Yeah, for sure.
Uh number my uh my third pick was Tag Team,
which came in at number eight on the
solid. You were dialed in,
right? I was like light games,
seven, eight. Yeah.
Uh and then Nick, your third pick was Old King's Crown.
That's right.
Which came in at number 24.
Okay. Sure. I think that's purely a just not not as many people getting their hands on that. That's a very much people who play it really like it, but no one's played it.
It's like us. It's like our channel.
Yeah.
Don't forget to like and subscribe.
THAT'S TRUE. PLEASE
FILL THE VOID WITHIN US. Um
All right. So, Mike, your third pick was Nemesis Retaliation. Mike, where do you think that came out?
People be loving these games. 32. It was ranked number 21.
Okay. Because I was like, man, I might have just spoiled my one and two with like a 98, you know. So 21. Okay, cool. I just know people love the Nemesis games.
They do. Yeah, people love those games
as proven here. Uh, and your number four pick was snaking this out from Nick Moon Colony Blood Bath at number nine.
So made it in the top 10. I'm sure we helped it because all three of us had it. And
yeah, we obviously contributed to the list. Yeah, that one. But we're like three of we're one of 100. If you
We didn't order our list for the purposes of winning this draft, but it's nice that it has helped.
I'm not surprised I was in the top 10. I I think that game's great.
Yeah. I wasn't sure when we picked our draft picks if if somehow we would figure out a way to to remove them from the end results. Uh we didn't do that. So
So now I'll know that going into next year.
My grand total so far, four games in 33 points. Feeling good.
Mr. Wizard with the brains.
I have no idea what I have. Yeah.
All right. Uh, so Nick, your number four pick was Molly House.
I feel like this is going to be low on this list.
It was ranked number 56. So it is it's the lowest thus far.
Uh, there's nearly a hundred games beneath that, man. You're
No, no, not when you've gotten like,
do you think any of us picked a stanker?
Anyone pick a stanker?
We'll find out. We'll find out.
We'll find out if there was any stanks to be had. So yeah, 56 coldly game. Uh, and then my number, where are we at? I guess I'm my number four pick was Sweetlands,
which was ranked number 25.
W Okay, that's pretty high.
Yeah,
I wasn't sure enough people had it to do it. Yeah,
I want to play Sweetlands so bad.
I also want to play Sweetlands. Um, and then my fifth pick was Fins Span. Another Stonemire game.
Probably.
What do you guys think it was ranked,
bro? It better not be in the top 10.
I'll be upset. 18. Somehow it's number one again. Mike, you are locked in because it is number 18.
Dude, I didn't look any of this up. I I know what people like and the amount they like.
Mike is the voice of the people, man.
Let's go.
Yeah. Get auto ticket or something.
I'm proud of myself right now.
You should be. Dang.
Yeah, that's
that's such an 18 game. It's crazy.
Nick, your number five.
I feel like I'm losing.
Number five was Flip Tunes.
Oo, this might be a rallying moment. I think it is. So, I think it's uh I think it's 29
is ranked 15.
Oh, wow. Really? Okay, that's good. I love it. This is easy, breezy, beautiful cover and it's also board game arena. So,
that's good. I I like that. I I thought that'd be lower.
Yep. Uh Mike, your fifth pick was Sanctuary. We all poo pooed it at the time. I don't think we hadn't played it. We were just sort of going off the vibe.
Maybe I love Sanctuary.
Okay. Uh oh, man. I don't know. Uh
you think it's in the top 10? No, I think it might be like 13 to 16 somewhere in there.
It is ranked 34.
Y'all haters.
I like that game a lot.
All right.
Lower than old King's Crown. Uh, number six, Mike.
Oh, so that's So, what's been the lowest game so far?
The lowest game so far is uh Molly House.
Oh, that's right. That's right.
On me.
I doubled my score with that pick. I'm
So, that's about to change. Uh, Mike, your sixth pick was Crafting the Cosmos.
Where do you think that's right? I think it got forgotten to time. I think it got forgotten in time. I think it's going to be like
dude like 90.
No, like 58. 58.
It is ranked 117.
What is wrong with people? That's That's unfair for that game.
That's just like a
It was a You're trying to release an Oscar bait movie.
When you picked it, I was just like I was like
that's too it's been too long. It's been way too long.
Wow, man.
Still keeping that math. The math has got a little harder like 170 now. So
your Yeah, your your score went down a lot.
Is that the lowest one?
Uh, let me see. Spoilers. This one. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No spoilers. Um, all right. So, that was Mike's sixth pick. Nick, your sixth pick was Toy Battle.
I feel like this is high.
Yeah. What do you think it is?
I think it's in the top 10.
It is ranked your highest ranked game at number three.
Whoa. Yeah,
I was proud of that pick. When I bid it, I was like, "This is this is going to collide."
I feel like Choy Battle, Zenith, and Tag Team. They kind of exist in a similar place in my mind for
I guess they're all kind of like dy games look nice, play well. Yeah.
Uh, so that was number three.
I was when I picked it, I was like, actually, I think this is going to be good.
You picked it so damn sneaky.
Sneaky pick. I think I I remember I was going to pick that like next.
Yeah, I sniped you a couple times. Yeah. So, my sixth pick was Aridia.
Oh, yeah. What was that?
Uh, so Aridia, big old Kickstartery game, expensive, painted miniatures.
At the time we recorded this, it was the number one ranked game of 2025 in terms of the BG ranking. That's true.
Which you said is one of the reason why you picked it cuz you're like, I don't know much about this game, but it's the highest.
But it's also, but if you look at this, like there is some overlap in terms of like how these things came ranked out, but it's not a onetoone. No, it's not.
Uh, so Aridia came out at 16. So, ranked 16.
I was worried that was going to be like really low. Yeah. Yeah. Really low. That's not bad.
Yeah. Not bad at all. Uh, my number seven pick uh which was the one that I took when I couldn't get uh
which not called hot dog racers. What's it called?
Hot streak.
Hot streak.
I might as well.
Um dog racers.
It's called mukbang running around.
Yeah. Right. Uh so magic magical athlete. My number seven pick is ranked 29, which not bad, but not bad, but I'm happy Hot Streak is higher.
Sure, sure, sure, sure. I mean, Hot Streak's a new game.
Yeah.
Magical Athlete is a is a new face on them.
You're like, I'm happy this one. CMYK is just like, I'm happy either way. I win either way. And they're like,
all that stuff. They won.
They Yeah, they really did.
Um, all right. So then Anique, your number seven pick was unstoppable.
Oh, I don't know. I can either see this being like in like the high teens or low 20s or like 60. I'm going to go with 21.
Okay, Mike, you got to guess
kind of with 17. 17.
Okay. Did I just say 17?
Oh, we No. Uh, Unstoppable was ranked 38.
Okay. Yeah. So, I was kind of split the middle with that. Yeah.
Great game.
That was one where I was just like, man, I don't know. I like this game. Sure. Sure.
Yeah. But not everyone likes solo stuff necessarily. You can play two-player and should, but I wonder if that maybe hampered it, but it's deserves higher than that.
I'll be curious to see is uh
Dungeon Crawler Carl a standalone game.
Yes,
stand be crossible.
See curious to see if that does any better.
Yeah,
next year
or whenever it comes out.
I think the Kickstarter will be this year. I know that.
We'll see. Um, so Mike, your number seven pick was Luier. Oh, that's a good quit.
Yeah, I remember I remember being like, "How is this still out there?"
Yeah,
we didn't have it. We didn't have it yet. That was the thing.
That's right.
Yeah,
it was ranked number What are you guessing? What's that?
No, I know it's ranked number 10.
Jim was either saying 13 or 30 something 12. 13.
13. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
I got it all on my own.
Yeah, I got it all. No help.
Okay. 13. Yeah.
R number 13 for sure. Uh, and then Mike's number eight pick was game beloved by all of us. Uh, Covenant.
God, I love Covenant.
Covenant is going to be in the top 20, I think.
Okay. It was number 19.
Wow. Okay. I got to say,
I was going to guess lower. Okay.
Uh, and then, uh, let's see. Where were we?
I kind of rallied here. I had some a couple bad picks in the middle, but I'm rallying now.
Well, you started so good, though, too. So Nick, your number eight pick was Origin Story. Another Stonemire games. You were you you're saying at the time you thought that this would be the highest Stonem game that you thought that this would be the success.
Oh, wow. I know. Or would be the worst by far.
You're right. Yeah,
it's still doing quite well. It's ranked number 27.
Oh, that's not.
I I was literally expecting it to be like 80.
Not as high as uh either
Finsspan or Vantage. Okay, cool. I I I thought upon hearing it now I was like, "Oh, Origin Store is gonna be way lower." Okay, that I'm actually very happy how well that pick turned out.
So, my number eight pick was Speak Easy
Little Val with Sera game.
God, that must be pretty high. Yeah.
Yeah, it ranked 17.
Yeah, I'm not surprised by that at all.
Um, and then my number nine pick, which was the one where I went the most rogue and I fell into my own trap because I was like, I'll set up these games that I have no intention of picking and then Shalice was just looking at me for the entirety of the time we were filming that. And so I was like, I guess I'll pick it. So I picked Shallow Sea for my ninth pick and it was ranked. What do you guys think?
It was on the list. I'm guessing 112.
What do you think? It was nine. I'm I'm feeling 62 or 47.
It was ranked 102.
Oh, one of them was ranked 112.
So not quite as low as uh Crafting the Cosmos, but quite low. This is interesting because both of you have had a really low one. Oh, I might be doing better than I thought.
Interesting.
So, Nick, you're uh
if crafting the cosmos sinks me, I'm going to be bummed out.
This the way we score this, it's like, yeah, one you could be like crushing it and then one really bad.
If you get the last place one, that's gonna really ding you.
Yeah.
All right.
So, uh Nick, your ninth pick Yeah. was wine seller.
Interesting.
What do you think?
67.
No, I think it's be like 31.
You think so?
Yeah.
Well, it seems like Mike is out of touch because it was 66. You're off by one.
That was close. At least
I've lost by one. He lost his way.
That's not good.
The crafting the cosmos has shattered your connection to the mind hive. Guys,
wine is great. Play wine seller.
Uh, so Mike, your number nine pick was Critter Kitchen. What do we think?
Uh, n in the top 40
is ranked number 23.
Wow, man. Y'all be blinded by that.
I don't want to be fool. I don't want to like be fool of myself and say top 25, but I knew it, right?
What? Really?
I'll be blinded.
And then Mike's final pick was unmatched Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
Oh, baby. This is like seven, dude.
Sevenctor dead. It was ranked 103.
WHOA.
YEAH.
WHAT?
GOOD.
Have you been keeping the tally of your score?
Oh, hundreds now. I've had 200.
Yeah. Your your total is I'll get to it at the end. Uh Nick, your final pick was you're in back again. A hobbit's tail.
Oh, I don't think that's Well, no. I think that's okay. I'm going to guess 41.
That's pretty close. It's 36.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. And then
I might I might have done okay here.
And then uh my final pick was Star Trek Captain's Chair
which is a little sibling action because that was a 35.
Oh, okay.
So we were right next to each other on that one. And so the final tallies are coming in third place is Mike.
That's with sucks, dude. With 342.
He got the number one.
Has to be a BETTER SYSTEM. HOLD ON.
MY MY ONE AND TWO NEED TO BE worth like 25 points off my score. Mike, you got to pick goodter. That's all I can say.
No, I picked the best.
I was feast or famine, man.
I was one or 100, dude.
That's Mike. Mikey be Mikey be rolling the best role of his life and he'll go over one more time and do it again and then absolutely bust out.
Man, my first two picks were elite.
I mean, you had that's incredible. I mean, really, it's astonishing.
You had three picks in the top 10.
Yeah. I mean, you really did very
Yeah. For all that was worth,
but then you went craft and cosmos and that was rough.
Why is this turtle so low? I think probably a combination of people not playing it and then also people being like, "Well, it's like an expansion or anti- amphibian."
Yeah. I think I think people Yeah, I think people that they won't think of it separately than of other
unmatch. Dude, I this next year's fantasy draft. I'm coming. Guns are blazing.
All right. In at second place with a total of 284 is Nick.
No, Jimmy won. And then coming in with a total of 261
is me first place spot. So manag
I guess I must have had a lot of
you had a lot of middle stuff. That was the thing that sunk you cuz I had one really bad one but then everything else I had was 35 or lower and then you had one that was 56 and 66 and then you had a 38 and a 36.
Wow. Okay.
Yeah. And you only had two picks in the top 10. M
two of my picks accounted for like twothirds of my score.
Yeah.
Yeah. More than two.
Oh, way more than twothirds. Yeah.
God,
the scoring system is,
you know,
it is worth it. Hey, man, the data don't lie. That's the point.
It is. Yeah. And if you if you have suggestions for how we could do this differently or whatever, drop in the comments or whatever. But yeah, I mean, it's it's like that thing where you're just like cuz it's like this.
You got to play it safe. I feel like it's like the best thing,
which I'm never going to do
kind of. And like honestly like
you really should be shooting for like the teens. Like shoot for like
you shoot shooting for like 30 to 10.
Like what like cuz I feel like those are easier to tell than like 10 to one or even the low ones. It's like shoot for that if you want to win. I don't care about winning. I just want to choose what I think should win.
Yeah. Right.
And um Wow though. That's kind of crazy. I'm not really surprised by crowd. Okay.
It was so funny at the beginning cuz you were like you were so jazzed. I'm like he's going to be absolutely destroyed. I'm going to go 10%.
So, okay. So, from from all of those,
both high and low, what would you say surprised you?
Crafting the Cosmos being so low
did surprise me just because it
What was your really low one?
Shall.
Oh, that would surprise me. Yeah.
Just because that one like really hit when it hit and granted us and everyone else I think kind of like played it a bunch and then forgot about it. Yeah.
And I was hoping that like well maybe people are reviewing coming back to it and it's just like no I think I think it really was one of those ones that like caught people's attention for a brief minute
and then it got recency bias is a hell of a drug you know.
Yeah. Dang. That one that one I was shocked.
What about you Nick?
I don't know. I I
I was surprised by like what were some of the other lowest ones?
The lowest ones were So the lowest was Crafting the Cosmos. The next lowest was unmatched Ninja Turtles. The next lowest was Shallow Sea. And then the next lowest after that, I believe was Molly House. Oh, no. Was wine seller and then Molly House.
I would probably I'm not The lowest one that I'm surprised about in terms of how low it was. It's probably Unstoppable. I thought that was what 50 60 something.
38.
Unstoppable 38. Yeah.
Okay. That was I thought it was lower than that. What were some of the highest ones again? Because there's a couple.
The one that I'm surprised is high. I shouldn't be surprised.
You mean high as in like ranked not great or ranked well?
Ranked well.
Yeah.
Uh the highest ones were So number one, Lord of the Rings, Fellowship. Number two, Galactic Cruise.
Uh number three, Toy Battle.
Oh yeah, that one by far far and away
was the most.
Toy Battles number three.
Yeah, you were pretty shocked by that. Did we? I don't know.
Did we not hit everything in the top 10?
I don't think we have number four. I think maybe take time was in there which was like two of the ones that I was considering that I didn't end up picking but it was fine because Star Trek counter was like 35 but I thought about taking Eternal Decks and Eternal Decks I'm pretty sure was if not in the top 10 it was very close
to the top 10 on my list and then I think the other one was take time.
Take time I'm not surprised at all. I think
had I played that I I would have picked that. I think I think that's going to be like a Bill Desar type game. Like that's just a game that is going to get played well.
Yeah, I'm I'm surprised. I shouldn't be surprised. I'm surprised Critter Kitchen was as high as it was. I I don't know.
What were you guys surprised by?
Yeah,
let us know in the comments below as you're liking it that metal list down there if you want to see the whole list.
And again, it might be slightly different now than when we recorded this, but you know, that's how it goes. It is a living document. But uh it was so fun to do the draft and
this was fun too
for a while.
I enjoyed seeing the
this was really great for a while
and then it and then it wasn't anymore and then it got good again for a second and then it got real bad. This was a roller coaster for me.
You had a Yeah. I feel like I was kind of the midway the whole way whereas you were just like
because at the beginning No, you were pretty low at the beginning and you were like oh no I'm coming last. I don't but you only were like 20 behind.
Yeah. I had the first couple that were like in the 40s 50s. I was like oh that's not good. And then you guys had some lower ones. I was like, "Oh, I might be fine here. This is going to be great."
Man, I'm just happy that none of us had one that was not on the list.
I know that would be bad for me calculating.
We would have to figure out Yeah. a different system. I feel like
I feel like what I would have done in that situation probably would have been like reverse scores where number one is worth 138 points and then like anything that's off the list is zero points.
Yeah.
Either way, well done, Jimmy.
Thank you, Jimmy.
Man, when I hit I hit and I really didn't any other time. Uh, if you like this kind of video, please let us know in the comments below. Give this video a thumbs up. It really helps it get sent out to more people. And if you are new to us, please consider subscribing. Uh, we plan to do kind of more of these little chitty chatty different things, not always with like a fantasy draft, but just talking about board games and stuff. So again, if that's something you want to see, please let us know in the comments below. Uh, and oh man, I can't. We got a ways to go. It's only February 5th, but I want to do this next year's real draft now. None of the games are released.
Yeah. Well, anticipate it now cuz then if we hit number one, we're going to look so smart.