Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 24
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another installment of board games I got rid of and why so in this series I take a look at some board games that I've previously owned in my own collection but for one reason or another no longer do and I tried to give some rationale as to why I came to the decision to part with them now before I get into these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order the first game I'm talking about is boo muntu now this is a pretty straightforward abstract strategy game as you are skipping around this grid of these rather nice plastic animal tiles and trying to collect them because if you collect the majority of certain sets you'll get more points but the Twist on this game was that these are animals not only do they move in different ways when you landed on them on the board which means you could plan turns ahead and try to you know manipulate the board to benefit you to get the animals you exactly want but it also meant that you could manipulate the board State and what all these animals are worth so for example at the start of the game the elephants might be worth the most but as the players manipulate that board State maybe the the monkeys will be worth the most at the end so you always have to be aware of that and hopefully that you're the animals that you're investing in aren't going to slip too far down at the scoreboard now I thought the game worked well for what it was it certainly had a certain charm to it very nice to look at but I thought the game was slightly one note and I think there's a glass ceiling on how many times you could play this
one and enjoy it and I also thought there's a little bit of imbalance here because there was an alternative way to collect points by collecting these masks which would score you points based on a sliding skill and I always thought that was a really strong incentive to get those because the the weighting up the scores or the points you could get seem to outweigh that of collecting other things so I also thought that was a dominant strategy if you let someone run away with it but it was fine it's just not quite my cup of tea and despite playing it you know probably five to eight times I thought that you know my time had come to an end for it with it and I didn't really have the does desire to go back and play it any further the next game I'm talking about is Meadow so Meadow is kind of this little Tableau building game as you're playing cards out in front of you and the better and better these cards get and the more prerequisites they need based on things you've already played um for me this game kind of is a sign of the times really because this last couple of years there's been a ton of these kind of gateway gateway plus level games that have a beautiful visual appeal to them and this one has lovely kind of watercolor animal and Wildlife pictures on them and for me that did kind of trump and supersede the actual gameplay itself because the gameplay here was quite standard and quite vanilla for me it didn't it did feel like a ton of other games out there and I think it's been propped up to a level that doesn't quite relate to the actual gameplay simply because it looks so nice so maybe I'm missing something here but I definitely didn't feel that this game was anything special I didn't really feel the desire to explore any further maybe the expansion material added more but for me yeah I just felt like I was doing the
same thing from start to finish I also felt like the game went on a little bit too long at this lower play accounts because I remember playing a two-player game on this and I thought you could have easily shaved a round or two off and you still would have had the same experience so yeah maybe not maybe I'm not the right market for this one but I certainly didn't quite understand why it got so popular so that is Meadow next up we have Point salad so I actually am quite a fan of this simple card drafting game as you're collecting these vegetables and trying to tailor them towards these objective cards um next to no rules overhead in this one and of course you are sharing a communal pool of cards with the other players meaning that sometimes the cars you want are going to get taken from you before you get your chance to have your turn um that's pretty much the extent of the game you're just trying to get as much points as you can some of these cars are going to work against you some are going to work with you and it's all about trying to get the maximum benefit and output from each card that you draft it literally takes around 10 minutes to play so it certainly is that true filler game now the quintessential filler now for me despite really liking this one and not having much bad to say about it I never really found myself leading to pull it off the shelf and I'd normally reach for something maybe a little with a little bit more meat on the bones and I also thought a slight thing working against this one was that when you scaled this to different play accounts you had to mess with the deck of cards quite a bit which would add more setup time and that could become a bit a bit of an obstacle to get this into the table especially considering how light and simple it was but I believe my friend still got a copy of this one so we can still play at any time and maybe
one day I will get this one back into the collection because I actually think it does a great job of doing what it does but yeah ultimately I never really found myself picking it up amongst other fillers out there so that is point salad next up I have Mr cabbage heads Garden so this is a weird looking game has some of the quirkiest artwork that I've seen and probably ever um but this is like a puzzly game as you're playing these cards out in certain patterns and formations on the table in front of you you have tons of games do do this but this one was maybe somewhat more restricted because it was only for one or two players now if you watch my content regularly you might have noticed that I'm not a huge solo gamer in fact I very rarely play solo games but this one I could certainly see the appeal of it as you're managing these bees which are gonna dictate which cards you can draft at any time if you're trying to put these cards out as optimally as you can but the Twist on this one was that every so often these kind of neighbors would come out and bother you and mess up with your or kind of mess with your puzzle and you do that by flipping over these random tokens which will give you an idea but not a concrete evidence of what is going to happen next and I tend to like games that have this threat that works against you you know some of my favorite games has that mechanism such as polypanese and Cilla but those games do it better than this one does and of course those are multiplayer games so I had this on my shelf for quite a long time thinking there's bound to be a time when I want to play a simple little puzzly game by myself and that time very rarely happened so now I enjoyed my few plays on this one but am I gonna go back and play it anymore probably not so um
yeah that's why I parted with Mr cabbage heads Garden next up I have steam time so I actually really like the idea of this worker placement game where you actually build the working placement spots yourselves all the other players do as the game develops and you can make these really creative and really powerful spots that are inviting to the other players now the issue I had with this game was that because so many of these spots are being built by the players it's quite overwhelming and difficult to keep tabs on what all these spots do because the tiles were quite small and the iconography wasn't great and again a little bit overwhelming and I tend to prefer games where I can see all my options at a glance and I don't always have to kind of recalibrate each round and have a look everywhere to see what my optimal move was so I thought some of the actual practicality of this game took away from the experience but the game itself was pretty decent but those those things all those issues I had with it were enough for me to not want to play it anymore because of course we are spoiled for Choice nowadays so that's why I decided to part with steam time next up I have last will which just another worker placement game and this is a Vladimir Suki design and if you know me you might know I'm a huge fan of his games this one might be one of the nearest misses that I've ever kind of not added to my collection and I love the idea of this one as you start with a ton of money and the objective is to try and burn through that money as quickly as possible when you do gonna do that by making tons of really poor Investments and by you know hiring people by buying property High selling
it low all these kind of things has some very cool thematic ties here and that was almost enough for me to um to keep this one around now I thought this game was slightly a bit light in terms of what I like from worker placement games that I think the worker placement genre is so saturated that I tend to enjoy working placement games when they have a little bit more meat on the bones and are a little bit more complex than this one was um and ultimately the reason why I got rid of this one was because I have so many work placement games that this one would simply or just by default be quite far down that pecking order and I only want to have physical games in my collection that I know I want to play and will play relatively soon so unfortunately this was simply a victim of having too much competition so that's why I got rid of honest will next up I have 10 which is a pusher luck and set collection game where you're playing cards in front of you try not to go bust by going over a certain value or of course you can stop and collect these cards in front if you're trying to create runs of numbers I quite like games like that you know I tend to enjoy like games for me this game tried a bit too hard and reached too far to be different and added one too many mechanisms in that took it out of that really accessible level like for example every now and then these wild cards would come up and they would instantly stop the game and break the flow completely and then you'd go to this kind of auction phase where you'd spend these tokens you collected to acquire those cards for me that felt really jarring and unnecessary and actually hindered The Experience so it goes to
show sometimes less is more and another example where there are so many great pushy like games out there this one was a good one but those things just made it you know just took it to a level that I wasn't really willing to explore any further because I'm always going to reach towards games that I know are bankers and people are always going to enjoy and always going to be more engaged with because you know with games this Punchy and this um you know that's supposed to be exciting you don't want to keep on being frustrated by the game keep stalling by going into an auction phase and unfortunately that was enough for me not to want to keep 10 around anymore the next game I'm talking about is Lancelot and which I'm sad to say was straight up boy boring I did not like this design at all as you are traveling around this rather cool looking board and collecting pieces of weaponry and armor and then trading them into complete missions essentially now that's pretty much the gist of the game but there was a cool concept or two in this one where you were somewhat incentivized to make it around this rondelle as quickly as possible and reserve your spots because as long as you were there and other people were still taking their touch you could generate points which I thought was really cool and could have been exploded further now unfortunately this is one of those games I thought you could get too much done where like if you're going to do one thing now somebody else will probably do it later um and it just felt like you were doing a lot of work at times to get next to no points in return so it felt like you were jumping through a lot of Hoops and not ever getting any excitement or really feeling the game of this one so yeah I thought it was purely mechanical and it really did struggle to reach and find where the fun and where the game was so yeah big big Miss for me that is
Lancelot the next game I'm talking about is Merlin and I do so with quite a heavy heart because I am a big fan of the game itself um in this game you are rolling a bunch of dice and you're allocating them to remove these pieces around this rondelle you're collecting items completing objectives fighting off these threats you know a real Point salad Style game as you'd expect with a failed design now you might ask if I like the game so much why did I get rid of it from my collection and that is because to get the optimal experience with this game you had to pick and choose from a bunch of different expansions and a bunch of different modules and that made the setup time a real pain and made it a big obstacle to tear the game down and it made referencing rules really difficult because again you'd have so many different pieces of the game from different different expansions that it wasn't a quick glance you could go and find rules that you were looking for and all those things added up to make it a game that I never really felt like pulling off the shelf and filtering through so sadly I think this was a victim of its own bloat which was you know a bit of a sad thing for me to say because you know I love stephenville's games so yeah unfortunately as my you know my time of the hobby is it has come along in time my tolerance for these things is next to nothing now and I want my games to be a bit more intuitive and I can just play without having to reference so many things and I don't want to spend you know as much time setting up a game as I am going to play it so sadly for all those reasons I had to pass on or have to had to part with Merlin and the final game I'm talking
about today is ominos which is a dice driven abstract game as you all the players have their own face of a die that they are trying to put together in group centuries so you're trying to align four dice of your color together in order to get a certain amount of points however you could only ever move pieces that you roll with a new dice that's on you die that's added each round and what that meant was that sometimes you would not roll your own face of course and that would mean you'd have to move dice belonging to other players and the choices because of that were really obvious where if you wrote someone else's dice then you are obviously going to start separating their pieces if you were on your own you're going to bring them together and that's pretty much the extent of the game there was no real interesting decisions to be made and it became quite frustrating at times when you might not even have any of your own pieces on the Pod and you were just completely out of options so I thought this was it had a certain charm to it it was a bit of a throwback but the gameplay itself was pretty weak to be honest and obviously for that reason I could not keep it around so there we have it that's another 10 board games that have left my collection hopefully the rationale and the explanation to these games has given you a better idea as to why I decided to part with them and apologies has been a bit of a break in between this video and the last one of the series that I'll be looking to make this more regular going forward if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye