Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Games We Are Afraid Of

Transcript 27:05

Are you afraid? The board game is in this room.

It's calling me inside the house.

Tread lightly.

What's up, everybody? My name is Nick.

I'm Mike.

We are the Brothers Murph, and we're going to talk about games that we are afraid of. And what we mean by that is we, for the most part, have not played these games, and we're kind of just like terrified to play them for a myriad of different reasons. Because some games you just you don't

Oh my god, this game's going to be really big. It's going to be really complicated. I'm really scared of it.

We build it up in our heads sometimes, and it's just it becomes this thing where like I can't even get down the road of actually learning the game to see if it actually is that overwhelming or not.

Yeah, and let us know what we should play from this list, because I think a lot of times you finally play it, and you're like, "Oh, that was not as bad as I was expecting it to be." So, we really do need to get a lot of these games to the table. These are top 10 games that we are kind of afraid of.

First up for games that I'm scared of, it's one of the simplest games, it's Go. This is a game that's been played for thousands of years. It just has two colors of stones and you are trying to kind of claim areas of the map and surround and capture your opponent's stones and it's one of those like I wouldn't say one of probably the quintessential like easy to learn difficult to master games. People have been playing this for generations and thousands of years, literally. I think where it becomes scary for me to want to play is just like I know I won't have a problem grokking the rules. You're just placing a stone on a turn at a you know, kind of intersection of these spaces on the board. Uh but strategically like there's so many things you can do.

There it's so sneakily strategic that I'm like, if ever I try to play this game against somebody, unless they were also brand new at this game I'm going to get stomped. [snorts] And like that's okay. I'm not afraid to lose a game, but like at our local library downtown, uh in the lobby they have uh kind of like set up problems from Go. Like so they'll set up the board a certain way and they say, "Hey, what should you do to accomplish this thing?" And I'm always just coming by and looking at them like, I got nothing, you know? And so it's one of those ones that like I would really love to like dedicate time to and I know that truly I shouldn't be that scared of it. But like just where do I begin? I think I need to I need I need to challenge Nick in this.

At least then we're on even, you know, ground going in and so I really want to try it cuz I know it's simple, but I know it's also I'm going to be so bad.

Number nine is going to be Xia: Legends of a Drift System. Now, technically, I'll be completely transparent. Technically, I have played like a third of this game. We were at, I think, Dice Tower East or Dice Tower West way back in the day. Um, and a couple who really likes this game really wanted to teach Mike and I. And we were like, "Okay, great." And and we kind of we had allotted like two hours for this game. And then at the end of that two hours we had to go do something else. And that was nowhere near enough time. By the time we got through the teach, we basically played like a third of the game and then we had to like leave. And we were like, "So sorry, we have to go." But the reason So, I basically haven't played this game is what I'm getting at. Um, but Xia: Legends of the Drift System is this massive sandbox game. We talked about it on a a couple lists ago. We talked about sandbox games. This is like one of the epitomes of sandbox games.

You can kind of do whatever you want in this game. It's a big space game, kind of 4X game, but it's kind of like It's kind of like No Man's Sky, the video game, where there's just kind of everything in the game. No Man's Sky, there's like a procedurally generated universe, and so you can go to a completely procedurally generated planet. There's like something da da da quintillion of these planets. So, like, it's literally basically infinite. And like there you can like be a smuggler, you can do all this kind of stuff. Xia is kind of like that. There's like pirates and smuggling and all this stuff and stuff, and you can choose to do that or not. You can do this or not. You can do this or not. And it's just this kind of big sandbox game. And sandboxes are really fun to play in, but they're also kind of intimidating. It's kind of like when your teacher back in the day would be like, "Write a three-page essay on whatever you want." And you're like, "Can you please just tell me what to write it on?" And that like having a blank canvas is way scarier than having like a prompt. You know what I mean?

And so, that's kind of how I feel about these kind of sandboxy games. And Xia is like so well-known for this like open-ended sandboxness that it really scares me to play a full game of it. Someday I really want to cuz I just kind of want to experience it, but it hasn't in full happened yet. But shout-out to that couple of times that one time.

Next up is going to be Wilderness War. Uh this is a GMT war game set on the French and Indian War. So you have France and the British uh fighting it out and over North America uh prior to to us founding the United States. Uh and this is this is a game where I've been getting into uh war games specifically like the coin series uh a little bit and uh you know, really enjoying like Cuba Libre for example. Uh and as a result I snatched up a good handful of war games including Wilderness War. And then I'm just like, "Oh, I don't think I'm ready for this." Like when I first open it up and it's just like a map like a proper like folding map as you're like board and seeing all these different spaces and stuff and I was just like, "Oh, right. I don't know what I'm doing." Uh and so with Wilderness War in particular, um I just haven't I've done several times where I open the box and start to set up the map and I get about that far and I'm starting to to straighten it out and I'm like, "All right." And I

pack it back away and haven't even learned it. Now, again, this is another one where it's like I doubt it's as crazy as I think, but I do know it's like a 3-hour big war game. Uh

[sighs]

you know, where do I begin? Um I am interested in these kinds of games and so I'm happy I bought it. Um you know, I bought it used from a fellow war gamer here in the area. Um and so I know I'll enjoy it. I think maybe, I don't know. I really don't know. That's where I come down to every time I open it up to of take a look, I'm just like,

I don't know, but war games, specifically the coin games and stuff, uh this is a card, you know, driven uh war game with the kind of single deck and everything, um seem really cool. I love the kind of historical nature and using, you know, often these cards, their their event deck will be real events that happened and stuff. So, I'm really interested in those kinds of things. This is just one in particular where I'm like, this looks more like, you're on your own here, kid. Like, we're not going to hold your hand. And I'm just like, I got to work my way up to it.

[sighs]

Number seven is Warhammer 40,000.

Here is the thing. This is an interesting one because like, I'm terrified of this like, the tabletop game, we'll say. I'm very, very scared of the tabletop game cuz I know it's a mess. That's not an insult, by the way. Like, it's just it's just what it is. It's a massive game. It has tons of rules. Every single faction is different. You know, there and then there's you and then every edition things change, so you kind of have to not learn a whole new game, but you have to figure out how your faction works now and they change things and they nerf things and buff things, all kinds of stuff. It's just such a giant mess to get into that I just I can't I'm terrified of it. Which is kind of wild because like, I'm a massive, massive Warhammer like person in terms of like, the lore. And I'm a massive like, minis person. Like, I love to paint minis. I technically collect Tyranids. I have a decent amount of them. I am slowly painting them because I keep changing my paint scheme. I just I can't ever decide what I want. I've literally changed my paint scheme for my Tyranids for like, a decade. I'm not kidding about that. So, I I I have this desire to eventually paint my Tyranids and play with them cuz I like big horde armies. And I love, love, love the lore. Like, I've read a whole bunch of the different books. I know a a decent amount about the lore.

I'm not going to claim that I'm like, some 40 40,000 lore master, but I really, really love the world of 40K and that kind of grim dark silliness that it is cuz the world is very, very silly. And that's kind of the point in my opinion, that kind of satire. And so like, I want to play 40K. I want to like engage with this part of this giant hobby that is Warhammer in the way that's really meant to be. Like it's kind of the whole thing is built around this game ultimately and I just can't bring myself to cuz I'm just terrified of it. And it's like I want to make sure that like I'm easing my way in and not playing against someone who's just going to crush me and make me feel terrible for it. There's a real big problem with like the tournament scene where, you know, it's not always very friendly to new people and stuff like that. So it's like Warhammer 40K is just this massive thing that I'm terrified of, but I really love the world of 40K and I know a decent amount about it and I really like watch a lot of content, read a lot of content, all this kind of stuff about Warhammer, the novels and everything like that. I collect it, I paint it, all this kind of stuff.

Terrified to play it.

Next up is going to be the entire category of 18XX games. For anyone that is not initiated, these are economic games or largely set around uh building railway and railroad companies. And so these are going to be games that are going to often feature laying out track, building routes from cities to cities. Um and then running companies. So there's going to be a a heavy kind of stock element and ultimately you want to have the most money at the end of the game in order to win. So it's not just about the route building kind of ala Ticket to Ride or something. This is a fierce economic game where the person who has the most shares in the company runs the company, can, you know, make the decisions about stuff. You're trying to get out, manage your money, get your money out of the companies as well because if you have, you know, stocks and things in certain versions of the games, those will count towards your score. Other times you need to actually have cash on hand. So, it's much more about that kind of economy than the pure train game of it all. And that's something that for a long time I think kind of scared me off. I feel like now I'd be able to handle some of at least the more beginner-friendly 18XX XX games cuz there are a ton of them. Uh but it's just one of those like, am I smart enough to like do econ- economy, you know? I don't know.

But it is a a game I want to try. So, if you're watching, if you know some 18XX games, please, where do I begin? What is the best, in your opinion, first 18XX game to play? Because I do generally want to try these kinds of games. I think I will like them. But like, I I I'm I guess fearful of diving into the one where like, oh, you shouldn't have played that. That's the really cutthroat one. That was not a good place to start. So, [clears throat] I need to kind of parse that out and then just, you know, take a leap of faith.

Number five is going to be Through the Ages, specifically the physical version of it. I have played Through the Ages, the app, um which if you have not played, definitely play it because it is, in my opinion, the way to play the game. Um and the reason why I haven't played Through the Ages, the physical version, is because of the fact that like, I know the bookkeeping and and the kind of like upkeep and stuff of the physical version is a lot. I I It's one of the things where like, nowadays, I would probably be more okay with it. I I I kind of still had this You ever had this thing where like, it's like when you like, something scares you as a kid, so even as an adult you're scared of this thing, even though like, nowadays you really shouldn't be, you know what I mean? Cuz you're like you're an adult. You understand this is not scary, but there's that kind of like residual trauma there. If we're getting real therapeutic about it, that's kind of how how I am with Through the Ages, the physical game, where like the physical game is so intimidating to me because I think of it as this like massive difficult, like, oh my god, it's going to be so hard, all the upkeep. In reality, it's probably tough, but not like insurmountable. We play lots and lots of big heavy games. I'd probably be fine, but it just kind of has this thing. And it's one of those things where like the the upkeep is all taken care of in the app, in the digital version of it. And so it's so hard to like really want to sit down with the the physical game, learn it, figure out how to do it, and then do it when I can just play the digital version, which is so much easier. And it's still that great Civ game. Cuz this is a big old civilization game. Through the ages, you're going through the ages of the world. You're getting various, you know,

um leaders, you know, of throughout time, kind of up to like modern times and like computers and all this kind of stuff. The age of antiquity all the way through. Getting different industries, getting different stuff, culture, you know, the classic Civ stuff. It's widely considered one of the best Civ games out there. And it is. It's really, really good. I just I've only ever played digital. I want to play it physically. We actually got it physically a couple years ago. Still haven't played it cuz I'm just like I'm just so scared of it. And I understand that I probably shouldn't be. Someday I'll play it physically. And then, to be completely honest, I'll probably just play it digitally for the rest of my life.

Next up is going to be Arkham Horror: The Card Game. Now, to be fair, I have actually just started playing this a little bit, and I really like it. So, my fear at this moment comes from fear of what's going to happen to my wallet if I continue down this road. I I started with a new kind of core set. Um uh I figured that's a good spot to jump in. I've been interested in this one for a long time. Nick and I played uh you know, Lord of the Rings the card game in the past. We played some Marvel Champions. We've always heard that Arkham Horror the Card Game does this kind of thing the best. I played it largely solo so far. It does work fantastically as a solo.

But this is one of those things where it's like if I decide I like this and it's kind of you know, scenario driven you're you're uncovering stories and stuff. It's this is the kind of game where you are kind of pushed into wanting to get more stuff for the game so I can get new stories and new challenges and further the cards I get to kind of further my deck building and on and on. And that's not a that's not a bad thing. It's not me like knocking that, but it's one that I'm like, when do I have time for this? Do I have the money for this? Do I want this? But it is a really cool scenario based game set around you know, Lovecraftian stories and things in these kind of cultists and you know, otherworldly threats that are coming around. So you were going to be an investigator and you're going to be moving around to locations which are just going to be cards on the table per whatever scenario you're playing.

And you're going to be having to you know, fight baddies, investigate and gain clues. Depending on the scenarios, you know, interview and talk with people that are in the area try to get to the bottom of the mystery essentially. And while you're doing that, the game itself, the you know, these baddies, these threats that are that you're trying to figure out more about are kind of pushing their agenda and kind of pushing you toward a negative result. So as you go through a game, you're trying to complete these acts before the agendas of the baddies get completed and that will lead to a better or worse result. And then you kind of move on to the next scenario sometimes with new cards and things you have available. You also have the ability to kind of use your XP to purchase more cards and kind of deck build. And again, there's just this huge world, you know, both on a story level, uh which has been really satisfying, but then also on the kind of mechanical, building your deck, trying to have something that's really going to, you know, attack this particular problem, uh and the kind of skills and things you'll need for that.

There's just a lot of intrigue there. But again, with that intrigue comes cost. And so that is where my fear lies is like, I think I really like it. Am I ready to afford how much I like it? We'll see.

Number three is going to be Food Chain Magnate. Now, Mike has played Food Chain Magnate, so this is really just for me. And I am pretty terrified at Food Chain Magnate, mostly because this is like one of those games where like I really I think I just need to go into it knowing that like

I'm probably going to have not a great time the first time I play it. You know what I mean? Where it's just because this is one of those games where like in the first few turns, you can basically lose the game. Um where cuz this is a game where you are uh like a fast food vendor or you're basically um setting up advertisements, trying to sell your kind of stuff. It's got this really cool like, especially the newer version, it's got this kind of like old school diner-y 50s kind of vibe to it, which I actually think is quite nice. Um and and you're basically but it's really, really difficult. It's a Splotter game, so it's very heavy, very, you know, very tactical, very that kind of stuff. And this is one of those games where it's like if you have a bad start, if your first couple turns are not good, you will not be able to catch up. It's just the reality of the situation. So this is like one of those kind of pseudo lifestyle games where if you kind of don't know what you're doing, there is a a very high likelihood you're going to we a bad time. And it's like and it's also a big long game. It's one of the things where I didn't know what I was doing and I got destroyed, but it was like a 30-minute game, like whatever, I don't care. But it's like if I'm going to be in this for like a couple hours and playing this like big heavy game and there's just no possible way I can catch up, that's just hard and it's kind of very intimidating to kind of get into that game. Like I wish and maybe there is now with the new one, I'm not entirely sure, but like maybe there's like a solo version. This is one of those games where I'd love to play digitally against like computer opponents or solo so I can kind of learn the game and then start playing with real people physically because of the fact that like it's just going to be very difficult to like

get into it. Like I remember the first time Mike played Gaia Project, he was playing with one of one of our friends who plays Gaia Project a lot and he basically like after the setup a couple turns in, he's like, "I'm just going to let you guys know that like cuz he was teaching a couple new people, he's like, you guys set yourself up in kind of really bad spots for what you're trying to do. So you're you're probably going to have struggle." Is basically what he said. Luckily that game we were kind of all able to overcome it, but it's one of those things where it's like if you start start off really badly, it's hard to come back. And Food Chain Magnate, as far as everything I've heard is very much that and I am intrigued by it, but it just it makes me scared to play it.

Next up is going to be Blood on the Clock Tower. Now, I think it is very likely that I will have played this within the next few months. It'll be it'll have been done. So that is a nice thing. The end of the tunnel is here. I think it's going to get played soon. Um and I have built up this game so much in my head. It's a social deduction game, which we've played many social deduction games over the years and you know, in college days and things. Um and for whatever reason with Blood on the Clock Tower because it has this kind of prestige around it, people love it so much, it's already in the top 100 and everything like that, I feel like weirdly nervous about performing my role essentially in the game. This is kind of like a classic social deduction game where there are going to be demons, in this case the baddies, and the and the you know, townsfolk, but everyone will be a specific character with specific abilities. That's kind of the nice thing from the classic like mafia and werewolf where most players are just sort of vanilla and don't really have anything to do. Here everyone will be a specific character. You may be good, you may be bad, and you're trying to find out who the bad guys are if you're the baddies.

Uh and if you're the good guys or if you're the bad guys you're trying to kill everybody and stuff like that. So,

for whatever reason I get like nervous that I'm going to like come into this game and everyone here's played a million times, I'm going to make some sort of blunder and stuff and like the thing that's interesting is like that's on me. I've never seen a game of Blood on the Clock Tower being played and thought for a second that that's not a welcoming group. They're welcoming everybody all the time. I know the vibes will be cool and so I literally am just in my own way about it and that's why I'm on medication for anxiety. Uh so I need to get over that because I really think I'll enjoy myself and I want to know and experience this thing that I see so many people having so much fun playing. If you go to a BGG Con or any con for that matter, you'll see several games of this going on all throughout the night.

People having a blast playing one game after another after another. That's not an accident. You know what I mean? Like a game popping up and becoming so loved is for a reason and I really want to experience that even if it doesn't become my own personal favorite game of all time. I want to know and experience this thing that's brought people so much because I think that will give me joy as well. So, again, I think in January I'm going to get this thing played. I have it. I'm penciled it in. I should just write it in permanent ink now so I make sure it happens. But, for now I'm still like, "Oh, I'm just not quite ready."

Number one is going to be Mr. President, The American Presidency 2001 through 2020, I believe is what it is. Very long name. Uh this I have no idea why I am so intrigued by this game. This is a massive, I mean massive, solo game. It's this huge huge game where it's like two giant boards. It's like minimum eight hours to play. It's like this huge thing where you are the president. You're the president of the United States again 2001 to 2020. So, modern times, not kind of, you know, back in the day. And you are doing all the stuff the president does. You are You are doing relations foreign relations. You're doing trade. You're doing these things. I think there's like military stuff. You're You're You're running a country.

Basically is what you're doing. But, it is this massive thing. And I mean And it's I mean I I've read tons of reviews about this game. I've watched videos about this game. I've done, you know, reviews that are just like, "Cool, I'm 10 hours in and I'm maybe like a third of the way through. These are kind of my thoughts right now so far." I've read things like that and I'm just like, "That seems insane." But, for whatever reason I'm just intrigued by this game. I I the concept of I like Civ games, which is This is not like necessarily a Civ game, but it kind of games like that where like there's all these different facets of running an empire or a country or whatever and trying to figure all those things out. And the fact that it's solo just intrigues me. Uh not so much because I prefer multiplayer games as opposed to solo games, but the fact that this is just this massive experience that's just like you in the chair at the helm running this thing is just like fascinating to me in a weird way. And so this is one where like I have kept kept myself from buying this game multiple times. I have almost pulled the trigger like had it in my cart, was about to click buy and then decided you are not going to play this night. You are going to be so scared of this game that's going to sit on your shelf forever. There's no point. Let someone else have this damn game.

And so I've never gotten it, but I'm just fascinated by it. It's just It just seems It's like the fact that it's so intimidating is kind of intriguing in a weird way. But yeah, this is one where like I legitimately would honestly like to try it someday. Um and and want to overcome that fear of like, "Hey man, just like put it on my table and then just you're going to leave it It's going to be there for months. Like it's going to be there for months as you're slowly working your way through this game." I would love to play it at least once, but I am so terrified of it cuz it's just the sheer size again. It's like two like Ticket to Ride size boards next to each other and you're again you're just like at the helm running all this stuff and it seems insane. So number one is going to be Mr. President, The American Presidency, cuz it just is so terrifying. So those are 10 games that hey, listen listen.

I'm not afraid to you know, we're not afraid to say we're afraid. We're not afraid to say we're afraid to say we're afraid to say Maybe we should be afraid. I'll be vulnerable and say I'm terrified.

There you go.

All the time. Boom.

Just about this game.

Just about the world.

Mostly about just the whole world.

Yeah, exactly.

I have medication for that.

That's right. There we go.

Those are our picks for games that we have not really gotten down the road yet with because we're just a little like uh but we want to play them. So what for you has been that game? Is there a game where you're like, "Ah, I really want to try it, but it's so long, it seems so complicated." Uh whatever the reason may be, let us know in the comments below. And also as Nick said, from this list that we said, what are the ones where you're like you really got to go play that game.

shot.

Cuz I know we're missing out on some awesome stuff. So, let us know which ones we should prioritize first, and then uh that's going to be it everyone. So, I'm Mike, that is Nick. We'll see you all in the next top 10.

Bye, everybody.

Progress saved