My 5 Favourite Games: Honourable Mentions to #4
Transcript
this episode of brains on games we're going to start counting down my five favorite games of all time brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode like I said we're going to talk about my favorite games I had a request for a top five list in the comment section of one of my recent videos so I thought well maybe I should take a look at the games on the shelf and decide which ones are my favorite now uh it's hard to make those kinds of choices I've got so many games back here and what I'm going to say about my list is this there are a few honorable mentions that didn't quite make it into my top five and the rankings of those top five might change from day to day it certainly does depend on what kind of mood you're in what kind of game I might be interested in playing or my kids might be interested in playing with me
let's start by talking about those honorable mentions and the first game that I wanted to talk about is one that makes it onto the honorable mention list it is one of my favorite games of all time but it's one that I wouldn't necessarily do a video review on because it's not a board game it's a tabletop role-playing game this is a game called oh let me get this giant rule book up here and it's kind of glossy and reflective but this is a game called torg eternity this is a role-playing game you know in the style of Dungeons and Dragons that's kind of uh in Vogue maybe right now but torg is a game that I started playing when it originally the first version of this game came out in the early 90s and I ran a game of torg that lasted throughout my undergraduate years at school and then I was away from it for a long time and then recently this new version of the game came out toward eternity and my old roommates who I used to play this game with uh got in touch during the pandemic and we started a campaign with my roommates and some of their kids now why is torg my favorite role-playing game this is a multi-genre game the story here behind it is that Earth is a Nexus of possibility and all of these different creatures are coming to siphon possibility energy away from
Earth and so it's a story of an invasion who's invading are these people from different realities so you wind up with a multi-genre game where any kind of action movie scenario you could think of could happen there's uh it's it's a reality Invasion so you might cross the border into Victorian horror or sort of classic Lord of the Rings Style fantasy there's cyberpunk there's Terminator style uh Skynet Wars there's um you name it Hong Kong action movies if you can think of an action genre it is covered probably here in torg and so almost anything you could imagine can happen here in this game and there are some mechanisms that I really like uh for example in all of these role-playing games often if there's some sort of a combat that you have to get involved with you might roll a die to figure out who's going to go first but in torg it's a card draw the heroes or the villains are going to go first and if it's a particularly dramatic event the heroes are going to be at a disadvantage and it's the villains who are are going to maybe have some bonuses on those cards the other thing that happens with those cards though is that they have actions on them there's a list of actions that's going to be approved that will allow the players to earn their own cards so there's a lot of Randomness mitigation
in torg all the players have possibility points that they can spend to add to their die rolls and they also have a hand of cards that they can spend to give them ideas or add a bonus to their role or get a second chance there's all kinds of cards in this game and the initiative cards encourage things like well interaction style combat as opposed to you know physically battling there are Maneuvers that you can do that will give you a bonus you could intimidate uh your opponents you might be taunting or trying to persuade them to do something so there's all these other non-combat skills that become important in this game and if you look at their the character templates they've got anywhere from professional soccer players to Demons that are kind of reformed uh demons so this is a fantastic fun game it's the role-playing game that I played the most and I I think I tried almost every role-playing game for a long time but torg is the one that's stuck just because it's so flexible and you're rarely stuck with a bad role that's going to mess everything up for you in the game the next honorable mention goes to my favorite Cooperative game burgle Bros now from Tim Fowler's burgle Bros well it looks like the office building that you're breaking into or the bank that you're breaking into but this is a Cooperative Heist
game with artwork that is fantastic the cards and the meeples everything about this game is appealing we just love it anytime the kids come over and want to play a co-op game this is the one that gets pulled out because it's brilliant each character of course has some asymmetric ability they all have their own individual Powers they've got meeples with different shapes and little stickers on them so that so that you can recognize who's who you've got a floor plan where everything is hidden at the beginning and you're wandering through this place you're trying to find the stairs to get up to the next floor so that you can find the safe and eventually break into the safe and then you have to somehow Escape you're collecting gear along the way maybe you're setting off alarms throughout the game you've got guards that are going to be chasing you so it is a game with tension that ramps up as you play just like pandemic but the theme is way less serious than curing a global pandemic and it is I like heist movies and this is a game that gives you the feeling of those heist movies and we've had so many laughs playing this the only reason I think it's not in the the top five is that you know my kids have to be in the mood to play a Cooperative game very often they want to play something that's more competitive so it doesn't get pulled out as often but when it does we always have a great laugh and a great time playing burgle Bros now I have burgle Bros 2 on the Shelf but I've only
played that one once and it seems to be quite a bit harder than the original burger Bros so we didn't get very far in it in the game that we've played so far so it doesn't get the honorable mention yet because I really need more experience with it but this one we played dozens of times and every single time whether we win or we lose we have fun playing it the next honorable mention is Thrones of Valeria from daily magic games now Thrones of Valeria is a fantastic game such a surprise one of the biggest surprises I think since I started making these videos was Thrones of Valeria I had never played any of the other Valeria games but I do love trick takers and when this one was sent to me it just became an instant hit I swear I've played this game over 100 times now because I have lots of friends who are really non-gamers who don't play these complicated modern strategy games but they play card games like hearts and so a trick taker is something that that everybody gets and I did a review of this one and we just loved Thrones of Valeria the only reason I think it's not in the top five is that it is so new even though I played it a whole bunch of times I do recognize my own tendency to kind of be a member of The Cult of the new and the new things tend to be shinier and newer and and uh top of mind but uh I'm sure that this one is going to crack into the top five it's definitely my top ten right now uh because I love trick takers and this is
one where each uh each suit has a different ranking that changes every card that you play well I did a review on it so I'm not going to talk about it in super great detail but every card play has some reaction and every card play is um there's nothing ever wasted in this game every turn you're doing something and you almost I can't think of a time when you weren't getting something from a card play in Thrones of Valeria it's just such a a fun uh quick game and you can play it you know a dozen times yeah in the night and that's what's happened at our place because it does pull in the non-gamers who are who are okay with those card games the hardest part is learning the symbology on those cards but once you've played through a few hands and you've you understand those those symbols oh my goodness we've had so much fun playing Thrones of Valeria so that's another honorable mention and again like I said an honorable mention because it's so new uh I didn't want to put it at the top of the list the final honorable mention on the top five videos from brains on games goes to praga Kappa ragni now this gets an honorable mention because I've only played it so many times uh it's a longer game and a complicated game so teaching new people is a challenge and with all the other games that come in I don't always have time to pull out the the ones that have been sitting on my shelf so I haven't played this as much as I'd like to I was super excited to play a
game about Prague because my son was a soccer player in high school and he went to Prague and he actually was on a bridge that's featured in this that you're building in this game so what do I like about praga kaput ragni well there are a lot of things praga is a game where you've got many different paths to Victory there's lots of different ways that you can pursue those victory points in this game it's it's got one of my favorite action selection mechanisms where you have a rondelle on the board that turns every round and is going to give you different bonuses depending on which action you decide to take that alone makes it quite a fun interesting game the player boards are amazing on this game now I didn't pull every single piece that's going to go in here but you've also got these little rondelles that turn around and give your rewards as you get to certain parts you're going to have cubes that are moving around here on these player boards it's just such a fantastic game and like I said I think this is one that that ranks highly for me but I just haven't had enough opportunities to play this one in order to really get the hang of it where I could say oh you know this one beats out some of the others that I'm going to be talking about in terms of my five favorites the five favorites are games that I've played over and over and over again and just had great experiences playing so praga has a lot going for it but it is one of those more complex games where you've got all of those different paths
to Victory and it's kind of hard to know when you first start playing what's the best way uh for you and it just it had a theme that I liked it has great components I think the player boards are brilliant I love the rondelle with those action selections and I'll have lots of Graphics I didn't pull the whole board out here I'll have lots of Graphics hopefully that I'll be able to show you how uh how that board looks and and what that action selection mechanism looks like didn't feature praga on the channel again mostly because it's one of those more complex games and I picked it up kind of at the beginning of all of this and at that time I think I was focusing more on games that I'd already been playing with the kids and I wasn't there weren't as many new games coming in so this is a game that I I really do enjoy and it does get an honorable mention but didn't quite make it to the top five number five let's talk about game number five on the top my top five favorite games and and as maybe you could guess these are games that maybe they're not going to be your favorite games everybody's going to be different in this these are games where we have had such great experiences playing that I can't help but name them as my favorite games uh my number five game I think is only number five because it is one of those more complicated longer games so it doesn't always get to the table but it is a game that I've loved since the first time I played it clans of Caledonia from karma games it's
a game that I talked about early on when I started doing the channel because it is a game that I love so much uh but and and rumor has it that karma games is working on an expansion so I'm super excited to share with you clans of Caledonia especially since there is an expansion that's coming soon what do I love about this game uh well it's well let's get that Scottish theme so as a McDonald you know I can definitely appreciate that it's got a modular board so things shift every time every player is representing a clan and there's asymmetric Clan abilities what you're doing in this game is you're traveling around the board and you're putting dairy farms or you're going to plant wheat fields or you're building distilleries or you're going to make cheese once you've got the milk so you're putting these things on the board there's a little it's not really area control but you're taking spaces on the board and you're building certain things in different areas you're collecting resources that might be used to fulfill contracts or where you might be selling things and one of my favorite things about this game and this is what I focused on I think when I did the original video way back is this Marketplace which we had oh my goodness every time we play this game the marketplace is so fantastic because the prices is and costs are varying every turn if I need milk to fulfill a contract and I buy a whole bunch of milk
that's going to raise the price of milk and now the next time if somebody else has milk they can sell it on their next turn and then the price is going to drop so you find yourself you're trying to buy things when the prices are low but that's going to increase the price with the scarcity other players might be able to sell them uh boy there's nothing like watching another player collect all of these whiskey barrels that they want to sell and then selling yours first so that the bottom drops out of the market and the price goes down or raising the price is something that they want to buy so we've upgraded all of the components so of course you've got colored pieces that little meeples that show on the map whether you've got a Distillery or a wheat field and that's going to be in the player colors and then when you're collecting resources from those things we upgraded to the realistic resources because I just love the those games where you're playing with these realistic kinds of pieces so we've got little loaves of bread if you manage to build a bakery I mean look at the loaves of bread that the players will collect there's whiskey barrels and here's the cheese it's this little slice of Swiss cheese so we like playing with those things where now you're collecting all of these little things that that look like they're very thematic of course they look like the things that you're creating you've also got player boards that are going to make things easier in terms of what you're earning every single turn based on what you've built what you've placed on the map so this is
just a brilliant game it's pretty much a perfect perfect strategy game you know a real Euro that can be quite challenging but at the same time it's just so um thematic and with that Marketplace it's just a wonderful game so the only reason I would say that it's at number five instead of number three or number two we're even number one is that it is a little longer it is a bit more complicated for new players to learn so it doesn't hit the table as much at our place as I would like it to it's been a while since I played this one and just taking it out and looking at the pieces again and reorganizing the Box I want to play this game maybe when my kids come over this weekend I'll be able to do that but like I said with this Marketplace and the contracts that you're fulfilling uh and and the points that you're earning for doing that oh it's just a a fantastic game that I would play all day every day if I had other people to play it with and I had time to do so or number four on my list of my top five favorite games of all time you might even be able to guess what it is because there's an empty space on the shelf behind me but it is Scythe from stonemire games and we've got all of the expansions to site and we've upgraded all of the components for this one because we just love this game this is another one of those sort of heavier strategy games that I picked up before I
started to do this channel but the kids and I just love it it's an area control game let's take a look at the pieces again you've got these great components metal coins and things that the Miniatures are beautiful too each of the players has asymmetric abilities and you've got a little minis of a character and their animal companion that I don't paint these things unfortunately I don't have that skill but the Miniatures are beautiful and the the figures are going to be combined with these different mechs so I didn't pick the Nordic Mech but you get the idea here you've got these robots the artwork is great the theme is fantastic it's sort of an alternate history you've got these beautiful paintings and you're pairing up your faction with some action board that that varies these things are different there's there's a stack of these that you can draw from and they're sort of randomly assigned and so the way that the actions are paired up is variable and each turn you're going to be taking a different action on this board the boards are dual layer and as you're taking actions and upgrading things things are going to move cubes are going to move around on the board and that's really what simplifies things I think even compared to the clans of Caledonia board like you can really see what an action costs and what you're
getting for it it's very clear on these dual layer boards once you've got all of the cubes laid out on them so you're you're wandering around a board you're producing resources often one of the things that you're going to do on your turn might be to produce some resources and what I think is unique about Scythe at least in the games that I've played these these Euro strategy games that I played is that you're producing things but they stay on the map you don't have like a bank a container that's holding all of the resources that you've collected they stay on the map and if your figures move off of that space another player can come and take the resources that you've produced if you haven't spent them so it does create some interesting tension the other thing that I really like about this game it is an area control game and there's some work replacement there's it's a really great combination of mechanisms and like I said with great components and a board that has little Easter egg surprises on it if you look very closely and we use the neoprene mat so it's a great big nice flat mat that you can play on uh but the artwork on even the board is fantastic but we do like that there's some combat in the game because it's there's that area control element but the game itself sort of discourages combat and in fact there are some variations I don't want to spoil too much but there are some variations where combat is really discouraged so it doesn't give you any advantages necessarily so you're trying to earn as many of these victory points as possible and there's multipliers based on your
popularity and your popularity is going to drop if you engage in too much combat so it's just a really great combination of mechanisms it it has a bit of a learning curve but the player boards make it a lot easier I think for the players to understand what it is that you're doing in the game and it's clear what you're getting and what you're paying based on those boards so great design and there's a follow-up coming from stonemeyer game so I'm super excited I've got that one already in the mail it's on its way so Scythe is my number four favorite game but my top five does fluctuate let's be honest so some days maybe it's number one or number two foreign and that is the beginning of my top five favorite games of all time it really was pretty much more of a top ten when you count those honorable mentions that didn't quite make it into the top five but those are a number five and number four along with those honorable mentions next time we're going to talk about the top three uh if you have a top five list that you want to share if you have any comments or questions about the games that we've talked about you can leave all of those things in the comment section below the video or you can email me at Bryant brainsongames.ca brainzonegames.ca is the website that's where future episodes ago and the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones
you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time foreign