Bluffing and Lying in Board Games
Transcript
hi I'm adamin Wales and this is my board gaming Vlog and this is the second Vlog I've made in two days and the reason for that is because I thought I would make a follow on an addendum to my previous Vlog in response to a comment from Benji th on YouTube who asked me about where does bluffing fit into my 10 degrees of player interaction that I talked about in my Vlog yesterday um and I thought it was a good question and worth discussing so uh what I did in that that that Vlog yesterday was separated out interaction from essentially the games which have player pieces interacting with each other and game mechanics that interact with each other from the games where players interact with each other in a sort of more social way so in a game like chess that is deeply interactive in terms of the player pieces moving attacking you know what one player does directly affects the other but in terms of social interaction there's very very little it's often played in total silence and concentration once we get into the second half of my list of 10 degrees of social interaction and we start to look at negotiation games and auction games and social deduction games and party games these games become much more about personality and social interaction and that's where bluffing and lying can come into um these games now you'll notice there I make a distinction between bluffing and lying although the two things are very close to being synonyms within common gaming pilant there's a there's a subtle difference in
connotation between the two uh and in fact I would say that lying is a subset of bluffing you can Bluff in many ways and lying is just one of them lying meaning saying something that is overtly blatantly not true outright saying it speaking it where bluffing can mean implying it through vious different actions trying to lead people down the wrong path but if they go down that path that's on them they've they've made that judgment from my actions I didn't say that that was what I was doing and I think that's the the common distinction that people make when they use those two terms lying and bluffing and so there are games that feature one of those things lying and there are games that feature bluffing in fact I think spyall that I talked about in the video yesterday is a really interesting example as this is the only social deduction game that I can think of that doesn't feature outright lying it features bluffing the players are are sort of trying to Blindside their opponents through the questions that they ask they're not outright lying they they're sort of they're making statements that might lead somebody down the wrong path and that's unique amongst the other um social deduction games uh aside from I suppose the genre that spyall has created which are now coming through and we're starting to see a lot of those appearing ESS this year and things like fake fake artist in New York things that were essentially a development of this spyall um idea let's
take a look at the game Sheriff of Nottingham in Sheriff of Nottingham players take turns playing as the sheriff each other player selects cards from the deck and tries to maneuver sets of cards from their hands into their scoring piles easy enough to do when they're low-scoring apples or chickens but more difficult to go unnoticed if the card's an illegal item or contraband players Place their cards into a small pouch and declare its contents either truthfully or falsely to the sheriff the sheriff in turn can let their pouch go unchecked or accuse them of deception and open the pouch and players are encouraged to bribe the sheriff to make this decision a little easier for him if the sheriff is wrong then he pays the player gold if he's correct then the player pays him a fine after several rounds of bluffing and double bluffing players score their goods and the highest score is the winner of the game so Sheriff of Nottingham is not a social deduction game Sheriff of Nottingham is a negotiation game and it is heavy on the lying that the players are encouraged to outright barefaced lie to their opponents tell them things that are not true however it also uses bluffing in in as a sort of compliment to the lying so what might happen in this game is I might put Cards into my pouch and tell the truth to the sheriff this is three chickens and it is three chickens then I might Bluff by placing
coins onto that uh onto that pouch and saying to the sheriff please don't open it please don't open it I'll give you five coins I'll give you 10 coins if you don't open it and what I'm really doing there not lying but I'm trying to lead the sheriff to think that I have lied and therefore open the pouch and I'll get a kickback in terms of the sort of reward for being uh for being wrong accused so that is bluffing uh and and it's used there nicely to complement the lying that goes in the game of course a lot of games use bluffing um and auction was was one of my sort of player interactions and one of the key things in auctions is that idea that uh I might bid on something that I don't really want just to knock the price up a few notches and imply to the other players that I might want that thing essentially there I'm bluffing I'm pretending that I want it I'm not outright saying it but I'm pretending that I'm willing to pay a lot of money for this thing and I'm leading the other players to bid higher and higher you see this frequently um in the game princes of Florence where we're trying to gain different buildings to put into our various Palazo I don't know if that's a what the SE what the uh plural is for palat pazi let's say um so we're trying to put buildings into this to attract Artisans uh who are going to score us victory points but I might imply that I want a certain item in fact it's not true this is very very similar in motivation to uh what I talked about in my video as hate drafting or deliberate blocking where I'm doing something that could actually harm
myself but I'm doing it specifically to stop somebody else from getting something so I might even buy that item in that auction I'm taking a risk somebody might call my bluff I might end up buying the thing for quite a high price but at least I've stopped someone else from having it even if I don't need it myself that's essentially hate drafting in another form or at least the motivation for it is very similar uh other games that feature bluffing you'll see it in lots of card games trick taking games games where I'm playing cards I'm holding cards back in my hand and we're trying to guess what has he got in his hand and my various actions with my cards might imply that I have more than I have um we see it in poker massively bluffing bluffing rather than lying so my bids my bets here you know that gambling aspect of it how he's he's putting a lot of money in there he must have something good in his hand I'm not outright saying it not lying but I'm bluffing my actions are leading other people to think that I have something that I don't you see it in games uh board games uh one that I picked off the shelf just to show you is the game Mr Jack by Bruno catala in this game uh it's an asymmetric game where one player is uh Jack the Ripper and they are trying to escape from London and the other characters are are moving around and trying to land on the same space as Jack riper so one player is playing as Jack the other player is controlling the characters trying to land on Jack's space however Jack is disguised as one of the other characters so you don't know which playing piece is Jack the Ripper Nei only the player
who's playing as Jack knows that so the other player has to deduce from his actions which one of these playing pieces is the right one to capture and so you tend to see that players will uh the player playing as Jack rer he'll move a different piece just to imply that this one might be Jack and actually it's not he doesn't right say it he doesn't lie but he Bluffs by moving the wrong piece towards the exit and then the other one slips out the back when when the detective player chases the wrong piece so that's an example of bluffing in a board game uh another example is the game Stratego where we have lines of pieces um all with different values on them and the other player can't see what the pieces are so I might move a particularly weak piece uh but move it in a really confident way to imply that it's much stronger than it is thereby drawing my opponent into a trap it's not out right lying but it's bluffing and these are all forms of of player interaction so um anyway thank you for the question Benji uh and I hope you found this little addendum interesting if you did please watch some of my other videos uh or subscribe to my YouTube channel Adams board game Wales I'm Adam 78 on Board Game Geek and on Twitter I'm boardgame Wales thank you very much for watching all the best