Skip to main content
Loading video...

Overlooked & Underrated: We Love These Lost Games! - Lost In The Shuffle

Transcript 19:55

Today we are going to discuss some games that we absolutely positively will not let be lost in the shuffle. I as a fellow board gamer an enthusiast a connoisseur if you will of board gaming and tabletop activities

I'm assuming there's got to be at least a few games that you've come across in your time that you have gone wow more people need to play this game. Oh, absolutely.

We're in a hobby where we find something, we like to discover.

Yeah.

And then we'd like to share those discoveries with other people,

right? Hoping to get as excited as we did about it.

Exactly. Yeah. And they want to play again.

Mhm. And Yeah. And and there's that fulfillment in not only finding something that you like, but also making other people seeing them be happy about something you like. I think that's part of it.

Absolutely. That's part of the human connection. So, in today's episode, we're actually going to put this theory to the test and see if all five of us, me, you, Paula, Matthew, and Grant all have a game on our short list that we could draw from and say, "Yeah, that's a game I champion. That's a game I think I was really happy to discover, and I'm happy to show it to more people because I think more people should be playing this game."

Right on. Okay. I love it. There's Champions of Midgard. There's Marvel Champions. There's

I I should have briefed you about this episode beforehand. Oh,

that's that's

on me. But it's all right. It's all right because we got Grant, we got Paula, we got Matthew. All have an example for us. So, all we have to do is somehow determine which one of those three people to watch first.

I have an ancient magical gaming artifact.

Is it our friend, the Star Wars board game spinner?

It is.

Let us behold it and allow it to show us who to talk to.

She'll bring it forth from the sacred ark.

Look at that. There's got your little spinner. So, we got Grant will be one, Matthew will be two, Paul will be three. Give the spinner a spin.

Who we got? We got a number two, Matthew. So, let's turn to Matthew and find out which game he's going to champion for us first.

Okay. Look, there's lots of games I have championed over the years. I like to think I've made a great impact on the board game hobby. Me, Matthew. Hello, by the way. That's my aim. Without me, would tricktaking games have taken off? I doubt it. I was the biggest champion of trick- taking card games before it took off. I stand on that. I tr I do actually think that there's always going to trick taking card games, small little card games. And then this revival happened. But there's a few games that I've championed over the years and been right about. One of them is Chin or Kin Q, which is a rhino kitia game. People call it Tigris and Euphrates Light, but I think that's doing it a disservice. And I was like, this is a fantastic game.

Everyone should play Chin. It's really good. Trust me, believe me. And now it's been reprinted and it now it's called Gazeos. I do kind of like the the the aesthetic of it before, but they've made improvements on the game, Bitewing Games. I talk about Bitewing Games a lot. I love that company so much. They don't tell me to talk about them. In fact, they've asked me to stop, but they've made gazeos. And I was so I was right. And everyone's like, "Oh, this looks like a great game." Yeah, I've been telling you that for ages. Chin. Play Chin. Play this obscure Canitia game. Talk about obscure Kitia games. Horrible Guild made a game called Sunset L. I'm angry actually. Now think about it. I'm an angry champion by Horrible Guild. They made a game Sunset Lane and I was like, "Yeah, that's Rondo." Rondo abstract game by Kenitia with it all clicky clacky tiles. I've always told people it's great. In fact, I think Rondo is better than the reprint. I I do. I think it's just for me just a bit more lovely. But that's a game I championed.

Speculation. That's a great I'm looking at my things. Speculation. Champion that. What else? What else is everyone wrong about? I'm angry now. I find myself in that situation a lot of the time where I'm trying to I find a continual desperation to convince people that the games I enjoy are good. I feel like I'm a a champion for board games. But yeah, we'll go with Chin and we'll go with Rondo. Both Kitia games that I think are criminally overlooked. But then I was right about because they got reprinted.

Well, yeah. I'm I'm actually kind of glad that Matthew went first because I I assumed that he would have quite a list to choose from there.

Yeah. I was kind of like, okay, which game would you not

champion, Matthew? Might be shorter. I'm just saying. No.

Yeah. Now, one thing that was interesting from his list is that, you know, Matthew is a huge RER Kitzia fan. Riner Kenitzia has developed so many popular games over the years, there actually can now be little obscure ones that fall through the cracks of his that need to be championed.

Yeah. Right. Absolutely. Absolutely.

Enter Matthew to do just that. To do just that.

Were there any games on Matthew's list that you've played?

No.

To be perfectly honest.

Yeah. Well, that's why they need to be champion, I guess.

Yeah.

I myself I have played speculation. Okay. and I really dug it. I like stock games and speculation. I've only got to play it once. I've been trying to find a copy of it ever since. And it it is out of print, so sometimes you can find one for sale, but the ones I have found have slipped through my grasp at the last minute. Then then I've gotten that

Bob kiss.

Yes,

that's the technical term for that.

Exactly.

Yeah. Yeah. But fortunately, there are plenty of other games in the sea to dry off and play, including the game that I would champion for this episode.

Okay.

And the game that I find myself championing more often than not is this little guy from 2015, Cosmic Run. This is a nifty dandy peppermint candy little game where you have uh several different planets that have tracks that you little everyone has a spaceship on each planet's track and you'll roll dice, play cards, and stuff and you'll go up these tracks. And it's a race game, but you're managing all these other factors. You know, which track do I go up? Do I stay ahead of you? Do I let this track fall behind and do this other objective? And to me, this fits the definition of a game that you champion because it's one that I feel like, oh, I discovered that game on my own.

Right.

Another little interesting tidbit about Cosmic Run is this is the version from 2015. There was actually a second edition of it that was created that actually has a board and some other little tweaks. And I appreciate the new version, but I prefer the original even with its rougher edges.

That is that isn't very interesting actually. But how much of that would you attribute to nostalgia? I'm curious.

Oh, well, I think I've been able to remove the nostalgia guts.

Okay.

I've been able to look clearly putting nostalgia to the side and evaluate the two games and decide on my own which of the two I prefer. Personally, I actually think I have the opposite problem. I am one of those people that when I get a game where a new version comes out, I fall into that trap of, "Oh my goodness, do I need the new version slightly better, slightly refined, slightly newer? They made some improvements and being watchers too, shinier version."

Interesting.

Cuz I found like with the Gricola.

Okay.

I still have my copy from 10 plus years ago and there's been all sorts of newer shinier versions, you know, and and the one I have is a newer, shinier version of the original, but I just won't upgrade. I I think it's part nostalgia. I think it's part OCD

because you get a new version and you're like, "No, that's wrong.

I I know they made these changes to improve with the game, but that that's not how you play the game. That's wrong." You I felt that way about Seven Wonders and Seven Wonders Duel.

Oh. Oh, yeah. very very similar mechanisms. But I mean really really but slight differences in the way that the the the uh traits work and the the war works you know and it was just this like having played one then going to the duel was just like

wait the it's really interesting though how these discussions on games can lead to so many different aspects of the hobby

right

but but perhaps we should get back on course and give the spinner another another spin and see between Paula and Grant who's going to be next up to share the game that they champion. Hey, we'll continue on in just a minute, but first I wanted to mention that this entire week's worth of episodes is made possible in part by Shallow Sea from Bad Comet, a puzzle board game that's inspired by the breathtaking beauty of the Great Barrier Reef. Dive deep into Shallow Sea and create vivid ocean landscapes by strategically arranging an array of marine life, colorful fish, and corals. Shallow Sea offers a multi-layered puzzle system. And unlike typical puzzle games where pieces merely stack up, the elements in Shallow Sea can activate, deactivate, and even move around, creating exciting combos and thought-provoking dilemmas that will keep you engaged and challenged. Choose tiles showing fish, coral, or sea life, and then place them on empty spaces on your board. When fish surround a coral of the same color, the completed coral flips over, which becomes a home to one of your fish. And that is just the beginning of the fun that awaits you in the shallow sea. So follow the link in this video's description to wade on into Shallow Sea, which is available now on Bad Comets website and at local game stores.

That was a great spin, by the way. If you caught that, you can see that in slow-mo. That is Paula.

Paula. All right, Paula, you're up. Or you're you are up. Not you're up the con.

The final countdown. Paula,

this is easy for me. I would champion the game in Taria. It came out in 2024 and I love this game, but I have seen some other like reviewers, some big-time channels kind of pan it. And I have some friends who straight up did not like playing this game, which made me feel kind of bad cuz I was like, I really liked it. And if you played it based on my recommendation and you didn't like it, that makes me feel kind of bad. But I think those people are wrong. Like other people seem to not love the game as much as I do. But if you haven't tried it yet, I would really encourage you to because I think it's really good. It's a Michael Keysman game. So it's the same designer as a Zuul. And I tell you what, I would play it over Zu. Like if you put AUL and Entaria on the table and asked me to pick one, I would pick Entaria genuinely. Like it baffles me.

It's It's baffling to me that there are people who like bounced off this game. It's got combos that extend your turns. It's got like order fulfillment and set collection that gives you like bonus points. It's got really lovely wooden pieces that you like fit together on your board. at the end of the game, you've made something actually beautiful, like physically in front of you. I love that. I think it's really great. I love laying tiles. I love making something pretty. I love having like a goal to work toward, which those little like kind of contracts that you can fulfill that then you set collects that give you points. Like that gives you some of that direction to work toward. Like, I think it's really nice. And if any of that sounds good to you, I would really recommend you check out Entaria. It was one of my favorite games from 2024. I will be its champion.

You look pensive onward.

No, I just that I had not heard of the game and I really enjoy Azul and I think that's a great recommendation. Paula, thank you. It's the game I'm going to go check out now because it just sounds like a lot of fun. I can see why she's choosing to champion it.

Mhm. It completely passed me by too. It's just from last year and there's what 3,000 to 5,000 games released every year. You can't keep track of them all, right? It's impossible. And and you know, the big shiny ones get way more attention.

And even those big shiny ones get their attention for shorter and shorter amount of time, it seems.

Oh yeah, absolutely. It's a constant game of King of the Hill,

Cult of the New.

I'm sure there must have been something though that stood out to you that you would champion. So, let's move right on to what your answer to this question is.

Okay. Absolutely. Um, there is a game that sat on the shelf while I worked at the board game store and it it sat and I knew of it. I'd heard of it. I'd actually met the designer at a proto before. Um, and that game is Lunar Rush.

Um, and we've talked about this. I've talked about this before. It is it is a game that I feel just went under the radar. Um, there's a lot of really nice strategic choices to make. Um, I've mentioned this before. where it's got a really cool like auction uh first person bidding mechanism where you are actually bidding your victory points

in order to secure first position.

I love games where in order to make progress in something, you have to sacrifice something else and balance it out.

Yeah, the strategic nature of it is really cool because there's also um three different types of rocket ships going from from the Earth to the moon in this, right? You're taking people up and building stuff and then bringing resources back is the whole point. But these ships all travel at different speeds,

okay? So, you can get on the fast ship, which will be there next turn, but takes very little cargo, or you can get on the slow ship, which it'll take two turns to get there, but you can carry more, right? And everyone's vying for which ship they're going to be on, and then there's the reverse ships coming back to Earth with it. Um, so you really got to kind of think several turns ahead. Okay, I'll have these resources on the moon in two turns, and I'll be able to build this, then I can ship these and build this back. So, I just I just think there's a lot of great choices and decision-m to be made in it. So, it was a slow burn to go, "Okay, yeah, I'm I'm jumping into this game." It wasn't an immediate saw, love it at first sight type of thing.

Yeah. And and I think part of that was because I had not met any other champions of the game besides the creator of the game. And and so like again, I'd never talked to anybody who owned it, who had played it.

You know, there is that psychological phenomenon of that kind of reluctance to be first sometimes,

right? Yeah. And that and that's hard especially with board games because but that is where you find the games you're going to champion is when you for me at least usually you step outside of the okay everybody's got this.

Um we've talked about this in previous videos where I don't have a huge collection because everybody I know has huge collections so I don't need to own them all.

Since your board game collection is purposefully kept small because everyone you know has so many of these games. Does that mean that your board game collection leans towards the games that you champion?

Absolutely. I mean, that's kind of my criteria of my collection is

okay, I I I've removed the nostalgia like you were talking about for the most part. That's that handful of games that are stuck for nostalgia and the rest is like if I'm not going to bring it out, I have no reason to hold on to it.

Okay.

I mean, that's my own personal kind of metric.

Your approach versus my approach are different yet complimentary. just I it's so difficult to wrap my mind around the concept that someone else could possibly think differently than I do. It's just what that doesn't feel right. The the concept of contraion on what you're looking for.

This is becoming whole by finding your opposite.

Wow.

Right. So this is this is balancing the force right here. I only need to have 70 board games because Chaz has

10 times that. As mindopening as that is, I think it's still possible to find a fifth different perspective on this with Grant's approach to it.

I'm willing to bet Grant has a completely different approach to this. Let's find out. All right.

What's a game that I champion, a game that I seem to like more than anybody else does? I think Obscurio qualifies. I love this game and I still play it fairly regularly. This game is similar to Mysterium. And part of the reason I feel like I don't see people talking about this or playing it uh nearly as much, maybe they don't like it as much as I do, is that I constantly see Mysterium still. I see it at local game stores. I see it at conventions. I see it being played by people fairly regularly. And I think Obscurio is similar to Mysterium, but I think I like it better. I think this is just a better game. So like mysterium you are one person is playing as the ghost and in this case you are playing as the sort of grimoir and you are giving clues to other people in the form of abstract beautiful artwork cards and they are trying to interpret those cards and figure out some information. But in this one there is a hidden trader and I just love that aspect of the game. I think it adds this whole level of a layer of intrigue that is really fun. And you know, I think sometimes people hear like, "Oh, hidden trader." And they go, "I can't lie. I'm I'm not going to be good at this." You don't actually have to lie as the hidden trader very much in the game. Essentially, everybody closes their eyes. the hidden trader gets to open their eyes and choose a card or two to shuffle into the deck of cards that

everybody will see. And so you're you're trying to sabotage the group by putting in a card that they might pick instead of the right card. And so, you know, it's it's it's a fun hidden trader aspect without having to just lie through your teeth the whole time. And you know then eventually people are going to call for a vote and then you might have to lie a little bit but you know for most of the game you don't have to do a lot of it. It's like a cooperative game but with that hidden trader element makes it really fun and just adds a level of strategy that Mysterium doesn't have. For me

uh what was it that we were just saying earlier about thousands and thousands of board games are released every year.

Yeah. And as a result of that, there are going to be those that rise to the top of certain categories and become the game like Mysterium and all these other games kind of fall under that umbrella, but get overshadowed by a game like Mysterium.

Yeah, it's a signal to noise ratio, right? You what what you focus on expands. So, if you're interested in this type, you're going to look for those, right? But as such, you might miss what's out here. Do you think that makes a game like Obscurio have even bigger hurdles to overcome to, you know, get market share or table time?

Whether you were first to market or not, you gained market dominance share. Right. If you get one that rises at the top of the category, that is now what everyone is referencing all of them to.

Right.

Right. Whether it's the best one

is a completely subjective thing, of course. Yeah. Right. Every deck building game is compared to Dominion. Right.

Right. Period. That's just forever going to happen,

you know,

probably. Check back with me in forever and I'll let you know if that happens.

And I'm a huge fan of like, you know, Hidden Trader type games, but I honestly don't know how I feel about that in a game like Obscurio, Mysterium, and The Elk.

Just because we can do a thing,

must we do that thing? Yeah. I like the way we're going to describe the way they did that thing. It's to distract them or lead them off in a different way. So, it's not quite take that so much as it is like a magician like look over here.

That's a kind of randomness output I actually appreciate. It's a misdirection.

Yeah, that has a little more nuance, a little more texture to it.

Yeah. Yeah. I like the approach that Grant described to that.

Nice. Well, how about you? I'm sure that you, the viewer, have some games that you would champion that would really surprise us as well. So, feel free to let us know down in the comments and uh perhaps we will revisit this in a future episode. see what other games are being championed out there that maybe went under our radar as well.

Yeah, please let us know. We're always looking for great new games.

Yeah. So, there we accidentally given you some homework. Uh so, as you work on that, we'll wrap up and we will talk to you again real soon.

Progress saved