Five Board Games I Hate Most in the World!
Transcript
you know what there is enough positivity in this space generated around attempting to sell you the next game coming to Kickstarter so let's ditch the positivity for this video and instead focus on the games we we absolutely hate so rather than list off a bunch of games you don't know and can't buy or or crap on some guy who is self-publishing his baby I'm going to make a hard rule that the game must appear on the board game geek top 5,000 games and none of the usual suspects here like Katon or or munchkin or Monopoly oh and if you're a publisher please stop watching and do not Blacklist us we love you it's only natural to start with the game that inspired this list which is votes for women votes for women is a card driven game covering the women's suffrage movement in America imagine Twilight Struggle okay do you have that in your mind okay now imagine if you stripped that game of everything that provided it depth and enjoyment and just added random dice rolls game of the year I did a tier list for 2022 games and I just dunked on this game because I despised it I really really hate it and the praise it received just just freaking dumbfounded me I was searching around the forums like crazy trying to find another kindered spirit that saw this game for the sort of lazy mass of a design and boring experience that it was and I just I couldn't find anything I challenge you right now go check out the reviews on this game and try to find reviewers actually praising the mechanics of this game and not just the historical significance of the theme all of them looks Babble on about the history of the period provide like flowery pros and almost no men mention
of the nitty-gritty of the mechanics of this game and there is a damn good reason why they suck so it's a card driven game much like making of the President right you play the car for its effect discard for some buttons or discarded to roll some stupid dice and the buttons you get from the card isn't like the typical action point system you find in most of these games instead of carefully deciding how much and where to campaign I just I just roll two dice or you know maybe you want to use that card to petition Congress well to do that you just roll a six and you just you did it Congress gets its ass petitioned but you know what the best part of this game is it's the big dramatic climax where if the game lasts longer than six turns which it typically does you might just get the opportunity to experience a rolloff for each individual State yeah that's right a game made in 2022 that features a bloody rolloff to win the game you essentially undo and make redundant all the hard work you put into the game in the first place leaving you to feel that I I I guess the suffrage movement was just like total random which doesn't seem like the best message for the game to convey the entire game you're just hoping for okay cards and in good dice rolles and wondering if you're even playing a game at all or if you've warped back in time to when you were a kid playing game of life with your family I get that the theme has historical significance but the game it's attached to is a steaming pile of dog crap it's just a dreadfully boring and simple game every gift turn
had me cycling through what was the most obvious decisions possible I'm all for taking a game of Twilight Struggle and sort of like distilling it in that into an experience that's something a bit more palatable for people but man this game it just missed the mark and hell does both for women even capture its historical premise and make you think no no it doesn't at all you don't play as a single suffragette fighting for your rights you're some sort of like suffragette Master Commander rolling Dice and placing cubes you feel nothing playing the game because you represent s nothing it's so heavily abstracted from its theme that it feels like it was made by a history teacher for his class to remember and gurgitate key names and dates on a test I'll see this game sitting on the shelves in some content creators videos and I refuse I refuse to believe there are people out there that generally enjoy playing this game regularly I legitimately think at this point it's like this like strange Conversation Piece like I could picture a dude who is like single inviting a woman over to his place show showing her his board game collection you know as you do and then sort of leaning on his shelf and saying like see this baby that's right I support your right to vote we do sex now yeah it's it's a it's a it's a crappy game two out of 10 and next we have steam up a feast of dim sum steam up a feast of dim suum sees players taking actions like gaining and spending food tokens to purchase cute dim suum Steamers and play Fortune cards to benefit themselves nothing matters in this game at all just look at the cool Steamers and pretend there's a
game attached to those Steamers this is a game Kim demanded we try because she loves dim suum and I don't know she's Asian so I suppose she thought that like the ethnicity police would just show up to her house and take away her Asian card if she didn't enjoy the game uh with the cute little bamboo steamers I'm guessing anyway she didn't tell me that you'll have to you'll have to ask her sadly after playing my buddies deluxe version of this game this this really is just another boring set collection game there were legit moments in this game where I had to pause and sort of ask myself is this it police tell me there is more to this game than just this everything just felt it felt so damn random and uninteresting I I I think to call this a family game would be a disservice to families everywhere this is this is beyond light to the point where your turns are just so obvious which making the entire experience uninteresting and and just unengaging like the randomness is sometimes just so overwhelming because it feels as though you can't really plan anything and the game provides no method of adapting tactically on a turn to accommodate for that Randomness especially at higher player counts it feels it feels like a bloody mess every single turn and the player Powers just don't feel balanced at all like you have these determined powers like the dog or the Tiger um but then also powers like the monkey that are just pure Randomness and sometimes the powers are not even useful when the time comes to actually make use of them no game ever felt like this like tight tension filled race someone almost always took each game hand endly leaving everyone else at the table just sort of
like dump out it and wonder why they're there and that you know and that's fine in a game with really interesting strategic decisions but when it feels like your opponent is just sitting on lady Lux lap it's a it's it's a little Annoying all this to say that with all the asymmetric Play On The Rise and gaming these days this game provides a wonderful example to designers on what not to do the whole damn thing just left me thinking like who who is this game for because if you want a life family game there are hundreds there are there are probably thousands of light games that do whatever steamup is attempting to accomplish significantly better three out of 10 and next up we have the Gateway game that somehow managed to bring people into this hobby instead of making them turn around running and screaming Smash Up Smash Up is a dueling card game where players combine different wacky factions together to crush the most bases possible all in the game that takes way more time than it deserves and makes you actually hate all the cool art and theme you would have loved when you were an 8-year-old little boy this is one of those games is that I understand requires playing it a lot to to really know the faction decks the problem is before you even get to that point because I've played this probably a dozen times and the entire experience always felt like such a slog instead of the exciting beat him up I was expecting it just it sucked like tamam the downtime in this game is a bloody nightmare we play this at 4 probably most of the time and and it's just yeah the game lasted forever no I'm all for mean games in fact I prefer mean games but I feel like like this is more it's more K to munchkin in its meanness where
it just feels like this constant like unfun crabs in a bucket scenario every single game where you feel like you're taking a step forward only to have a few people make you take three steps back and then just and just it just makes the game drag on a lot longer than it has any right to and because there are so many expansions in this game anytime I play this game someone is loading their box with more and more content now normally that in a game that that's fine just requires you know it requires a bit of learning but honestly the more I play the more I find things to be incredibly unbalanced and there are just some really crappy factions in this game and it's not just that but every expansion seems to add endless waves of of tokens and just utter random garbage the entire experience just became more and more tedious every time I played trying to remember what all the crap does On Any Given turn was just it was just way too exhausting and typically the powers that it did add were they just they were not fun for me to tolerate all that overhead the game strategy pretty much just comes from the faction selection once you're finished that there's just there is no more strategy after that it's just all tactics and adapting to what other players are doing but holy hell is this game swinging like the board States sometimes becomes so chaotic every single turn that it just feels unfulfilling like the game provided no opportunity sometimes to set something up in between turns and add that to the fact that you just feel powerless when it's not your turn and you really you have no interest interest in other people's turns because there are not many cards that can be played that can
directly mess with them on uh their turn so you just kind of sit there and you hope that you just don't get destroyed I guess that's the only way the game can foster some semblance of interest between turns but out of every game on this list I do understand why some would enjoy this game specifically I think this one might anger the most people because I know that while it is old there are a lot of Gamers who who are brought into this hobby through smashup um but it's it's certainly not for me I you know I look forward to never having to recalculate base points ever again two out of 10 so my hatred for smashup actually leads beautifully into the next game Sentinels of the Multiverse Sentinels of the Multiverse is a Cooperative game where you pick a hero and then battle a villain with your buddies using special abilities and the power of friendship But ultimately it's a game designed for those who thought Excel spreadsheets could maybe make a pretty rad game if you just added poorly drawn comic book characters to the equation so you thought the bookkeeping and smashup was bad well Sentinels pushes that mind numbing irritating dial right up to 11 Sentinels is what I imagine it would be like to be Batman but during tax season I loathe Sentinels it's a game I purchased a quite a long time ago now and the more I played the game the more I started to hate it from the bottom of my soul I really wanted to like it I did I gave it so many chances your choices in the game are just they're always so obvious but the worst part worst part is the bookkeeping it feels less like a board game and more like I'm organizing some poorly slapped together spreadsheet
written in a different language the play itself is super simple you play a card from one of the four in your hand and you choose a hero power that part can be mildly enjoyable despite how simple the entire process feels and sort of lacking any real depth the primary problem though is the villains villains typically have a lot of text in their cards and you have to pay really close attention to all the instructions on their turn and right after that you go through all of the cards they've played to see for things like you know start of turn text and other instructions then you draw another villain card and you apply its effects to the table State and once you finish that you'll need to take a look at the the end of turn effects and with all out of the way you know you're ready to wrap it all up by reducing the assets Capital cost with a total in part 3C at line 8230 on this channel we talk time and time again in regards to medium and lighter games on how low complexity does not have to equal low strategy or depth here you have a game that feels relatively light in how it's played and somewhat shallow given the amount of tedious complexity the game throws your away like many Cooperative games there is no human opponent and so all you're doing is trying to solve a puzzle and the that puzzle in this game is not particularly interesting or engaging because just feels it feels so damn one-dimensional where the entirety of the focus is just is most of the time it's just on damage whether it's mitigating it or or doing damage yourself you there's no there's not a lot of sneaky positioning tricks or interesting status effects although that would add to the tediousness I guess or anything that just feels remotely strategic or or fun yeah I hate you Sentinels I hate you two out of 10
after giving this game the dumpster of the Year award my tier list for 2024 games I thought maybe I was missing something or that I was just like too hard on the game since a lot of the commenters came to its defense I started playing the game a lot more on board game arena like a lot more and it actually it actually never got better it never got better it just got worse I of course talking about harvest in Harvest you take on the role of a farmer each with your own Bland power drafting Sunrise cards and taking your whe B around town to gather resources plant seeds tend the land and do a variety of other actions that mostly just kind of feel the same until the end of the game and you wonder why you even bothered playing I think a lot of people will come at least maybe a little closer to to my opinion on this game as this game ages this is not a game people will be playing a few years down the road help people cly we're not playing the original Harvest so this this entry will likely draw in I I guess the most anger cuz it's the the latest hotness but what's funny is that most of the criticisms seem to Center on this being a light family game and hey that that's great you know these types of games are important but there are hundreds if not thousands of games that do worker placement just worker placement better and are still are still palatable for your average family gamer my issue with the game is how Bloody Bland and and derivative it is like it feels like a St strip down worker placement game in the worst possible way the actions themselves Beyond being fundamentally simple are so they're so incredibly samey there are very few things you can
do in this game and yet some of the actions and end up just repeating themselves and while that might be okay in a game like like a gria or or caverna it's not okay when there's like six actions that you can perform in a any given game and the player powers are exactly what designers they to avoid doing when it comes to implementing asymmetric abilities the powers of your characters should not feel as though you're railroading your players into a very specific strategy it's it's boring anytime you take away player agency you better have a damn good reason for it and I'm sorry I'm sorry Lin the Frog but but letting me start my bucket at uh a sixth space of water instead of the third space of water it's not fun and it's not interesting do you know how sometimes you'll watch a Hallmark movie and although it's not the worst movie of all time you still you still get a little angry at how Bland and unoriginal the film is and you begin to sort of like you just begin to despise it for purposely being so manipulative you know like like you know the exact part the film is telling you to cry or to laugh and after over time it just becomes obnoxious that to me is Harvest I can tell this game wants me to think it's some sort of like cute and cozy game but it's not it's bad and it is boring and it's a three out of 10 and that's my list I know you hate me now and you're upset that I just trashed a game you probably enjoy but don't worry I'm just one man with an opinion I just I feel with I feel with content creators these days everything is just so overly positive and while I certainly appreciate positivity it's important to
be a little real and brutal sometimes you know if you're passionate about something as I am with board games and as you are with board games well that passion it it kind of goes both ways and I think denying you guys one side of that passion it seems a little dishonest you know our goal with this channel has always been to treat you the viewer as if you were a friend who just sort of wandered into our house and demand we started talking about a game we played and with that perspective comes it very candid and sometimes colorful opinion on games there's there's there's no PR speak here okay we're never making a review video or or a list video to sell you something we do this because it's fun and honestly I hate to admit it sometimes even trashing games is kind of fun sometimes so hopefully nobody's too offended by this it was kind of fun to make let me know in the comments section what you disagree with or if you think there are games that you hate most I want to hear about them but no none of the usual stuff like munchkin and Katon give me some really juicy ones that a lot of people love that's what I want to hear all right guys we'll see you in the next one bye