Skip to main content
Loading video...

Friendly Ties - Union Station Discussion Podcast

Transcript 1:01:10

welcome to the friendly ties podcast uh today we are gonna be talking about union station uh this is a new cube rails game that's going up on kickstarter soon or now or maybe it happened in the past if you're listening to this later on uh i'm joined today by my friends anastasia nick and travis and travis in addition to being my friend also designed this game so that's a little bit of context for you um before we uh go into all this i want to mention that we did film a full playthrough of this and we're gonna spoil that play through a lot like right from the very beginning so if you're at all interested in uh in watching this then i suggest maybe you watch that first and then jump into this um yeah so let's actually start this thing off real quick before i jump to other people with like a one minute overview of what this game is for a little bit of context um in this game we are just buying and selling stocks in five different railroad companies and we can also lay track which means we put cubes on the board and when they hit certain spots that increases the stock price so on your turn you buy a stock or you sell a stock or you lay track and um yeah that's that's pretty much the the gist of the game you want to have the most money when the game is over and every stock is worth the value that it is so you want to have high value stock and you hope that people don't sell your stock uh so with that in mind i think let's um start actually talking about this game um i want to actually throw the ball to anastasia first because this is not only the first time you've played this game but it's the first time you've played any kubril's game or potentially a train game period right right right i mean do we count do we count ticket to ride as a train game it depends on who you talk to yes it has trains yeah i played snowdonia

but no this is definitely my first cube rails game which is of course if you've watched any of john's content for the last six months or so or been his friend for the last six months or so you've heard a lot about cube rails games and so they're they've kind of become this like myth mythical creature you know like when are we going to play a cube rails game um so i was really excited to play this and i'm really curious we talked a little bit about this in the play but i'm like really curious to hear how this differs from the traditional q bros games you guys kind of intimated that it is sort of different from them um but i mean i mean i thought this was fabulous i had a really fun time i know that i think i played it a little bit differently um but i'm what i'm most curious about is i so if you watch the play you'll see that um i i just bought and sold stock the whole game right and that's all i did no track length um no track lane which am i correct in understanding that track lane is kind of the point of a cube girls game i feel like maybe i didn't play a q browse game i think maybe i'm not i haven't i still need to do that i think the stock is the point and the the laying the track is the vehicle that manipulates it so you're not i i don't think that that's as far off or as strange as it might seem um for games but one thing that's maybe not different about union station but it's in the certain classic there's a lot of cube rails games where the

stocks are static or they only ever go up or they have kind of fixed prices um and this one is is one that's like out for blood right like if i sell my stock it devalues all of your stocks and so that i think aspect of it allows you to play the stock market game and just lean into that explicitly in addition this game also rewards you for buying stock it increases the stock price of that and i think one of the things that's unique about union station is that that how much your stock share price goes up is variable based on how long that stock has been sitting in play for and so that uh makes it actually pretty powerful to buy stock so i think that it made a lot of sense for this game but it depends on how they're structured now people listening to this might be familiar with nick and anastasia from the one single episode that we've put out before this but we also have a guest here that is travis thank you so much for joining us hey thanks for being here thanks for being here that's not right thank you for being here thank you for playing with me and inviting me to come on this show yeah i've played obviously i've played a bunch of cube rolls games right um and so just to kind of go back to your original question about what makes it different i mean really there are goodness i mean you can't really categorize like there's there's sock games and they're route building games but i mean globally that's kind of what it is right so a lot of cube rails games are either one or the other um route building um would be you know things like chicago express um ride the rails those and then you have ones that are really that are stock driven um recent

ones would be iberian gage from amabel and capstone um union station came about as i wanted something that had like this kind of funky weird uh stock value manipulation stuff um because i would i funny enough i was actually uh designing this game in tandem with another game that was almost all entirely route building and so i was like i want to go whole hog the other direction and i want to make it very much about stocks and um the way all this came about is that there is there's this cube rails right so we talked about cube rails earlier uh whatever we're recording about how cubrills is kind of this very loose genre of games that come that john bohr kind of made popular with winsome games um and the intro to this is because a lot of this came from this game called the erie railroad which um is kind of loosely a cube rails game in the sense that there are stocks but there's actually not even a map or and there's actually not even uh cubes in the game or whatever right so this is the weirdest genre of games like every time i don't understand every time you guys talk about cube rails you're like okay q bros there's cubes and railroad track and then you start describing it to me and you're like well this game's all about shares and oh the first one didn't even have a map like i'm like what it's still magnetic and so all of it but it's true though and so but but all of um but like area railroad is this game that it just has like 30 shares that are

just shuffled face down and it's just this weird auction game and i absolutely love it it is bonkers and mean and everything all put together but i thought what if what if there was that game that actually had route building and actually you could see the value of the company increase and decrease as you go and kind of had some more play with that um and that's really where a lot of union station came from was just this idea of let's see let's see kind of this weird auction game but the interesting thing is that i play with a lot of people who um who hate auctions and they hate auctions because they can't properly um evaluate a company so if you have an opening auction and you're just like well it's going to be i got 30 bucks i'll i'll pay 14 that's it that seems like a good amount well part of the reason why union the way that i designed union station was because of where the dividend payouts are are pretty strategic in the sense of you kind of you know you kind of set the initial value for that company a couple below then maybe you could do a load of building and go in there and then you get a payout quick and easy and just stuff like that so it's just a lot of it was very intentional because of the people that i game with um didn't like how a lot of cube rails games played out because of auctions and i really kind of wanted to make it a little more to their liking maybe i could play games with people that i played games with in person but you know all this came about over quarantine so i didn't play games with them anyways yeah that's um that's a really interesting point um like from a general perspective on cube rails i mean yeah it's a very loose things uh some of them

have cubes some of them don't some of them well i guess they all have rails but like to catch the big bucket most or many cube rails have auctions the question is how many auctions do they have many cube rails i think pretty much all of them have stocks although that's not truly the case there are a couple that don't um most of them have track laying but that's not necessarily always the case and some like eerie railroads and also dual gauge on the other side of the spectrum don't have cubes at all one of them doesn't have a map and the other one has you laying like individual pieces of track instead of cubes uh i remember reading somewhere online when i first started this deep dive down the rabbit hole about like what is a cube rails game i found something that said uh cube rose game is one with a map where when you put a cube down or a token or a disk or whatever it's it's railroad connected to all adjacent spots and i think that's a big difference between this and more complex um train games like age of steam as well as 18xx where you put down track tiles that have little you know like a straight track or a little curve track and you're like making this webbing network but in general in cube rails games where most of them have a map you put a token down and it's it's essentially a six-way star everything is connected to everything else that's touching it and that kind of opens up the play space to a certain extent um but also just like as a general thing in my perspective i'm abstracting it even more than that cube rails games are stock market manipulation games with shared incentives that usually take less than 90 minutes that's essentially my definition of a cube rails game which doesn't have the word cube in it at all but again i've played like 22 of these things now and i've seen quite a breadth

of them uh and that's kind of where i'm at and again even that kind of breaks things there's a game called iberian railways that it's pretty much just a majority's game like you have cubes in a map but there's no stocks and it's kind of hard to say if there's shared incentives i don't really think there are so like you know but it makes sense right you know people aren't going to want to design the same game over and over again like designers are going to play stuff enjoy stuff and then want to iterate and tweak things and then you get this wonderful variety no it's interesting that you guys talk so much about the auctions and the shared incentives because that was what when i was watching the teach for this and i was looking at it i was like this is a pretty simple game there's only three things to do on your turn there's there's enough going on but there's also not a lot going on i mean you lay track there's five companies and they all have shares that you're buying and and i could see that this shared incentive idea which is kind of what i have attributed to the cube rails genre having not played them but understanding you know listening to you talk enough about them that i was like okay this is going to be a very different ecosystem than i'm used to you know i primarily play euro games i'd never played one of these i actually don't really like auction games i don't really like stock games either and i say that tentatively because i haven't played a lot of them so you know you can say that you know kind of off the cuff but then it's like well how many have i really played you know you know i think i'm trying to think i'm like what's the last auction game i played like biblios and i actually love that game so like i don't

know and that doesn't really count right so it's it's interesting because i was initially put off by that first auction my first thought was like how on earth am i gonna know how to value these stocks and i was so grateful when we sat down it was like john was like oh travis is gonna go first i was like great so i don't know how much you know our triple r is worth you know on the first turn like and and i don't like overpaying for things just in general which is why i passed a bunch and then um you know if you watch the play you'll see that very early into the game which is like i think the first or second turn every all of them did something smart they like um they they bought and they were able to almost immediately get a dividend and i wasn't and i was just like really bummed and i was like what am i going to do like they have so much more money this game is tanked for me i'm going to spend the next 65 minutes trying not to sound like you know that you know the player that's miserable because they're losing but they're like trying not to be a debbie downer like on the thing and like we're being recorded and it's horrible and then like once the share you know suddenly the share prices are going up and down and things and like i mean i said this multiple times where we're playing it was like this roller coaster because of the shares that you would have seven money on when you you turn in and you come back around and you'd have 45 and you'd be like how did that happen and i i loved that i thought that was so fun

that the way there's so many different ways for you to get money in this game that everyone else is kind of promoting that that initial auction even if you don't like auctions you're not really you know it's like it immediately fades away because it's just it's just a way to start and then kind of just dive into it that arc of the game and the like flow of money i think is something that's important to talk about and like the for for me the emotional feeling of this game in the beginning i was struggling at the beginning i was like oh i don't think i'm gonna like this game very much and it grew on me a ton um i think there's a couple of reasons for that and let me say first like what was hard about it at the beginning one is i felt anastasia like you were toast like i felt i was also worried

the fact that the game has the resilience and the elasticity to have you like rubber banded to you and i had very close scores at the end i don't remember exactly but they were very let's not talk about six away and it was six away but nick was still on top and and i don't well to clarify john one so on top is pretty relative it's true it's true there is no other player there is only nick there's only nick beating me no but it was because you know there was all those moments where i was choosing you know to what travis was just saying i was choosing do i make do i tank do i take points away from nick because nick and i had a lot of the same shares so i was like just deciding how how do i help or or or take away anyways yeah yeah right interrupted but the thing that happened in this game that was that like and part of it too and this happens in so many cube rails games is you're so broke at the beginning that you can only do so many things and in a lot of games there's more of that root building that you were talking about earlier travis right whereas like this one has like a little bit of root building and as soon as someone buys into your company you're like oh man i feel really crabby refilling right now because it's just as good for you as it is for me and that's normal but the thing that i think actually started putting this game about like at head and shoulders above um some of the other q rails games that i've played is that union station dividend payout thing because all of a sudden and this is i think part of the roller coaster that anastasia was talking about we would have money and then there'd be like an extra influx of cash not just from selling your stocks but from or for paying dividends like

the normal things like you would have like we've passed to this point and now everyone at the table is just a little bit richer and the game for me i thought was the most tight and the most interesting between like if i could break the game into four phases like the first phase is the beginning of the game and then like every union station payout as being a separate phase of the game those like second and third phases in the middle where like money was tight but it wasn't so tight that you didn't have options so there was a lot of like push and pull between like oh if i buy this i know i can't buy a thing next turn but i'll be able to expand this rail because i'll have the most and i can see the board what it looks like no one's going to be able to like buy into this company in the same way that i have um and if they do it's going to suck for them compared to how good it is for me so great i can make my plan off of that and i really liked that that flow of the game um i was i was impressed at how it like pulled us out of what felt like a a rocky first couple rounds a spiral you're you're doing a downward spiral at that point yeah well and the the the issue the issue with union station that that a lot of like hardcore cube rails train gamers don't like um is because all the shares are shuffled together face down and traditionally you know in traditional cube rails games everything is available you know what's going to you know what's out there you can just pick from any company that you wanted that's it and so my goal was to try and mitigate how detrimental it can be that a company doesn't show up until close to the end like you getting alton the black company

which only has four shares in the entire game i've seen games played to where one person has that company and they're the sole owner of that company until like the last six shares come out now that doesn't necessarily mean that they're going to win but that does mean that they have a lot of money just kind of pouring in and a lot of people don't like it a lot of people don't like the fact that you can that that just kind of that unknown factor of what's going to happen and whenever those shares are going to come out and the amount that the value is going to increase um but to mitigate that having a little more influx of cash so that people can you might not you might not get the company that you want but you can still get another company that could be not near as valuable but in the long run you're not the since you're not the sole person that is pushing that company you could buy it like there were a couple times in here to where one of y'all bought something and then someone else built it into something else which didn't trigger a dividend payout which then you just like anastasia a couple times were like hey and it was it was flush i it was like i spent no money and i got it all back and now this company at the end of the game is worth this full value that is worth even more now yeah this is great yeah there's two things i'd like to to to reference um and i'm gonna find myself probably in this discussion continually pulling back because i am currently just absolutely in love with cube rails as an overall genre and i love comparing all these things and um there's one thing i want to talk about how this is similar to many and there's there's two things i want to talk about how they're different the first thing is the initial auction which

anastasia was talking about a little bit earlier um before we started recording i was so tempted to pull you aside anastasia and and give you a primer on what the initial auction is like for cube rails games because um a union station it does nothing innovative with that um a ton of cube rails games in fact probably most of them start with an initial auction just like this where you and you often the only randomness in the entire cube rails game will be the random order of those stock those stocks being purchased sometimes it's not even randomized but i decided not to actually give you a primer because it's your first time i just wanted to i just wanted to see you jump in and that's why you know we had you bid last and it worked out pretty well uh i just figured you know adding bumper rails to you is probably not a good idea but my my opinion on the initial auction is well this is what scared me the most when i first started getting into cube rails games actually before i even started getting into them um the very first cube rails game i really became interested in was trans siberian railroad which was um sent to me to do a sponsored video uh for my channel and i was terrified because i know train game people love their train games and i don't like stocks or at least as of february 2021 i didn't like stocks and i didn't like auctions and i was like i was really sweating it i was worried i was gonna botch the video and just show this really poorly but then i read through the rule book and i was like that seems fascinating i read it a couple times then we actually played the game and as i proceeded to play more and more of these i realized that initial auction it's just a setup randomizer like there you really can't know what things are worth and in fact it's

kind of like a like an initial seed you know a lot of video games like procedurally generated video games have like a seed number that that creates the world so it's different from one to the next and this is just a player-driven seat it's almost like you know everybody put out a number between one and three at the same time simultaneously you all do it and then that like randomly sets the situation and if you have a game where everybody auctions high that's gonna manipulate the game in a certain way and if everyone goes for low that's going to be different and it's just a randomizer and there's you can mess up in some of these games but rarely is it easy too so that's like the big thing i wanted to say um there's a couple other things i want to mention but does anyone have any comments on that long essay i just said well i'm just curious because you you you say that and you say that that's kind of the starting of a lot of cute browse games but is is it my understanding and maybe travis you can speak to this that in this game it's different because of those dividend payouts because it did feel like you needed to be a little bit more strategic with your auctioning that's how i approached it to be honest with you was was kind of what you were saying john where i was just like okay i can just throw out any number and i want to be cheap so i'm going to pass on the first two and kind of like wait for everyone else to get poor and then hope i get some good deals at the end but i wasn't really thinking even though travis had kind of pointed it out that you know i should consider paying less than the dividend spot or i should consider kind of like you know how that was gonna going to play out and and my understanding is that that's unique to this game is is that is that correct yeah yeah the the other interesting

thing just to kind of like hang on what john was saying is that is that there's no company money in this game so a lot of cube rails titles the the money the the money that you initially bid in that in that intro auction um goes into the company and then the company spends that money to lay track across the board right so you place a cube and hex this one costs two dollars you place the cube in this hex it costs five dollars and so and so you can and so in a lot of games there there is some of that that strategy of okay well i need to i need to spend i need to pay 15 for the share in this initial auction because i can lay three track and it costs five dollars a hex for me to lay here here and here so cool that's how that works out um the money in in union station just goes away it just goes to the bank right so whatever money gets paid it just goes away so instead of focusing on uh the track lay on the amount of money that you need for the tracks you're right the money that gets spent in just directly needs to kind of position you in a good place so that that first one or two turns that you do that gives you that dividend payout i do think that the initial sort of setup of the auction in most of these cube rails games and in union station is tough i think that they're not hard if you play a couple of the cube rails games you like have a sense of what they're doing but they're not very welcoming towards players who have not played them before in order to make sense of them some people i think like that brutality almost right the like sense

that you you have to make a decision even from the beginning i think that these games if anybody wanted to would be more accessible if those initial auctions had john you said three starting states rather than what feels like 30 starting states but really because i can buy multiple stocks like 900 starting states you know like it could be like um pretty overwhelming for starting the game yeah that makes a lot of sense i want to go back and kind of add an answer to it anastasia's question as well about like is that dividend thing unique for how it adjusts the initial auctions i know we're hopping on this a lot but i think it's really fascinating to talk about uh from my experience most cube rails games have their own little thing like yes the the dividend payouts on this track is something i can't remember seeing in a different game but each game has its own subtle thing like travis just said like many of these have a treasury so you want to make sure you bid enough money so that that company can do stuff you have other games like iberian gauge that does not start with an initial auction there's zero auctions in iberian gauge at all but the first time you buy a stock in a company you decide how much money it's gonna be worth in that game if i remember correctly there's about like eight or nine different options so it's not 30 or 99 like nick was saying it's like eight or nine and from my experience it's more like three or four if you go too high up on that you're going to be in trouble no one's no one's going to buy exactly and that's that's really the uh the influencer from one game to the next like a beard engage it's all about cooperation if you go too high then nobody else is going to buy it and you're going to have trouble i'm not going to go into the details for that

one trans-siberian railroad has an initial auction it has those separate treasuries and a big part of that one is spending enough money so that you can maybe do a double buy on your next turn so like in each one of these games they have their own subtle thing that you can think about but i totally agree with nick that that can be intimidating to somebody who hasn't jumped into all this and i guess my big overarching opinion is is trying to yell from the mountains like the initial auction doesn't matter that much don't don't worry too much you know just like get past it and get into it i'm glad that that's how that worked out i mean that is a credit i mean as nick said to the elasticity of this particular game um you know that that was the case because you're absolutely right um you know that it having felt that i flubbed the initial auction if you will i could feel that unwelcoming i could feel that sort of like oh boy i don't i don't know how you know i mean not to harp on that but you know sort of not sure kind of where where this was headed and i can see that it very quickly kind of resolves itself and that's actually something i wanted to bring up which i also think is sort of unique to this game if i'm correct and again i like i'm pointing this out and i i this is my first and only uh cube rails um though i am intrigued to to play uh more and i know that that that john's gonna make sure that happens um don't worry i haven't been i i'm ready to you know he was he was saying he was like i'm nervous that you know you're not going to like cube rails and um you won't get

to kind of see the depth and i really do want to see more of um the genre because it's it's cool and this was a great taste but i want to hear like how does this i think you guys said that the selling stock is also unique to this and i loved selling socks so actually i'm a little bit apprehensive to play other keyboard games where all i'm going to want to do is sell stock and um i might have already said this but in this game right i didn't lay any track in fact in the middle of the game i asked travis i was like has anyone played this before in any of your play tests and not laid any track and he said i don't think so i am i'm gonna do that then um that's what i said in my head and there was one point where i almost did and it wasn't gonna pay me out and i was like not valuable so i loved just loved selling stock in fact i was i was a little bit bummed i didn't get to do more of it at the end and and who will know if i could have i could have edged nick out those six points it's not about winning guys thought i wouldn't even it's about getting second place um because i was there was always this really interesting tug between do i do i sell the stock and thus devalue it but then make it cheaper for other people to buy into it and then it was it was kind of fascinating too just that there was different numbers of each of the stocks so you were always kind of trying to calculate you know is this going to come out is this not i actually love the randomness i totally hear that

people would hate that but i thought it was kind of representative of a market where you just you don't know what businesses are going to do and they're going to come out and when they're going to be more stock available and i i thought the selling was so much fun even just considering selling was so much fun because of the drop and looking at that delta and being like well if i sell now and who will know there was a moment where if i had sold nick's shares would have gone down at least 18 money i don't know nick would you have sold at that point in that middle of that game before we get to the sharing but just on this game would you have sold if i had if i had dumped absolutely not yeah you know you when you sold those the idea was that um i would dividend again there was a there was a that plus eight put me into a position where i could maybe dividend again and if you sold i could definitely dividend again so i was insulated against that um and i actually kind of want to expand your question about stock selling um in this game and i want to talk about like meanness in games right and so i enjoy this right i enjoyed like the playing defensively and thinking about that that tapped into a really fun part of my game and you know travis i don't know you very well but from what you said earlier and the fact that i can see like root and oath hanging out in your background right there um you know you clearly are into playing a game where it's like you're gonna fight somebody but john and anastasia you know the two of you i know you'd be more like euro players and anastasia especially like you don't want someone to kick over your sand castle and i'm curious you know what you're you're the both of your thoughts um are about that meanness in these games and how that sort of like

translates from what your general preference is in other style of games and and you know anastasia you're gleeful about the like the cruelty that you inflicted upon me in this game right i mean that's a great question uh for my part in that because i actually have to ask myself if it had been someone else you know would i you don't know i i i am gleeful about how much money i could make off of your stocks nick um but i didn't feel like it was mean and i i i never felt like selling shares was mean for exactly the reason that you just pointed out nick which is that if there's this point in the game where nick had three shares or something i had one and if i sold it the stock the stock price was gonna drop to the next row down which is a i think a minus six so he would have lost 18 money if he had then sold but to his point there was a dividend spot right next to it and he could have very easily gotten there by laying some track and then he would have made and been and there would have been one less share out in the world i think there would have been four at that moment and i think it was the 25 spot and with the delta he would have then you know made back you know that money in that moment and so it's like that thinking and that kind of pull made me feel like i was never mean to sell stock it was like i'm gonna sell it i'm gonna bring it down but then you're gonna immediately dividend so you know you could almost argue that it's not advantageous to sell stock i

mean i think it worked out for me i didn't lose by you know such a terrible amount um well john had a lot of points but it it still didn't feel like it you know the strategy didn't work like it clearly worked on some level that was the scores were tight but i love that that it i was like well it's it's only sort of hurting you considering how quickly the shares moved i mean you watched that game money was like flowing it was going out it was coming in and everything was moving so a lot of i'll give you some insight right so early play tests when i was play testing with some uh very pro train gaming super mean type of players they're like so whenever you sell multiple shares does it drop one row or does it drop a row per share um which that is that that's just cruel beyond all belief right because every row is only worth six right and so if you get to this point where you go well i'm gonna i have i have three shares let's say uh right the white company has eight shares for the entire game and so if if it's if you have two or if you have three and then other people have more you can just you know you could just dump the whole thing and go well look you you now lost 18 per share that you own and now that you own three shares hey you know that's that's 54 bucks that's that's that's really bad for you um that was early that was early on and it took one play one play of that game for me to go um no this just doesn't it just

doesn't feel good yeah um which isn't interesting because then on the back end so people go well then why do you why even have that be an option well well early on you know early on in the game you sell shares to make money to to you know there were a couple times that early on it was just like you got four bucks i'm going to sell this puny white share for 14 and i'm gonna have 18 bucks now i can actually buy something or at the end of the game which is what everybody did with the green company of green is maxed out value can't go anymore it's as high as it can go and then all of a sudden let's dump a share let's dump a share and then that green value drops and then i come in last place um and that's just how that ended up working out which is which is fine but once again you know selling chairs just kind of doesn't doesn't happen in most cube rails games because it's just weird like it's kind of this especially with it with this one it's it's weird because you sell a share but then you could immediately reinvest in that company which i did multiple times you could reinvest in that company and all of a sudden you're like oh well hey i got it for cheaper and then it might pay out more but whenever you sell a share just like you said it um it is removed from the game so it's not included in any of the dividend payouts so it's strange because you're dropping the value of the company but then the shared incentives become smaller and so instead of five shares out now they're only four shares out and it could be

that it's equal for the other player but the issue is that you have now made more money and so it's it it's a weird thing i've played games to where nobody has sold anything whatsoever and then i've played games like this to where it's just people are just trashing stuff left and right and everywhere in between and really it's it's entirely player dependent and i it's funny because i know people that have played this to where at the very end they just dump all their companies before you get to before you get to that 18th dividend payout right so you're just like let's just dump everything and then they they end up coming in last and they go well selling chairs is bad it's like no maybe you just did it wrong but that's the fun thing is that i don't know what's right or what's wrong in this stuff you know i just i honestly truthfully i just wanted a third action right so you can lay track you can you can buy shares i needed something else to kind of manipulate and if this was all going to be about this was all going to be about stocks and valuations then let's do it so that it can get knocked back down but you can build into a dividend i mean it's just there are a lot of different kind of fun things to play with yeah regarding anastasia's question about meanness this game was a lot less maine than i expected and for the reasons that you said i'm not gonna rehash it um but like when i first heard about the selling it's like oh wow it drops by six that could be devastating but you know the dividend pickups and and all that kind of stuff is is really cool i mean comparing this to other cube rails games i would say this is one of the least mean that i can think of like

there's a game called iberian gauge which i've talked about a couple times i love that game um where that game is super about cooperation all the way down it's an amazing cooperation game but there are certain times in certain games not of not every game where somebody can just devastate half the table they do a turn they bankrupt the treasury of one of the companies and then you know half the people just throw their hands up in the air and and that can be that can just knock you know those people out of contention entirely and you know yeah that's pretty mean but these games usually last 90 minutes or less and that's a big part of why i've fallen in love with them because they can be mean and you can have super consequential moments where you're like do i whack over here do i whack over there and you know if your game gets turned upside down it's probably almost over or there's not that much longer or maybe now you spend the rest of the you know 30 minutes or whatever half the game spoiling it for the person who did that to you or something like that you just kind of get into it and that's fine um compared to 18 x games which again i'm not going to go into detail about here but you can as far as i understand always sell stocks in those games um i've only played three of them but uh in a big part of those games from what i've heard from people who really love them is is about selling stocks at the right time to quote unquote dump a company on somebody so like oh i sell these stocks now nick i've dumped it on nick nick is now the president that company is awful and he feels bad and i feel good because i i made this company bad and now it's super bad and now i don't care about it anymore and um and then you have three more hours to

play or something like that or maybe two hours of play if you're really good and that's a huge difference from an emotional perspective i think the amount of time left after potential mean plays sure yeah and i should also caveat that is like in this play i was being the mean player but i also wasn't the one people were being mean to right because you know you make your rant in the middle about how i was going into boardrooms and like you know hatcheting up companies that's like i was the one selling stock like i had the ability to do that and i wasn't trying to say try and like you were you know you had three orange you know three stock of the orange railroad what's the name of the orange railroad a pfw and c p f w and c okay so the orange railroad no uh pfw cnc um but you were trying to get that one across the map right and and over several dividend spots and and get to its get to its home station and i wasn't trying to do that and so the tension i think you were feeling at certain points where you're like okay this is you know is someone else going to take my stock we didn't have a mo i thought the whole game we were gonna have like a run on stocks like that was always my thing it's like are we gonna have a run on this and then nope you know that didn't actually happen i think john you sold stock once but i think i was the only player who sold stock like the rest of the game i think so six stocks were sold over the course of the game i sold one of them and i suspect you sold the other five yeah so so anyways the caveat to all of this is

like i don't know how that would feel you know i always have to kind of add that is it i think it's easier in games to be the mean player than to be the player that is being kind of piled on and you know i want to acknowledge that in this because um i'm curious to see how i feel about that meanness in other games kind of to your point john i don't i don't like games where you know halfway through i i don't know what else to do um and i actually i did think it was fun that it never really felt like anyone was really tanking anyone else no matter what they were doing in this game it really felt like things were moving but they were they were always moving up and down very flexibly yeah i think that meanness in a lot of these games and in union station is actually part of the ketchup mechanism because these games don't tend to have catch-up mechanisms right and one thing that's cool about union station is like i leaned into that orange company and i said i'm gonna make my money here and john and anastasia both have the opportunity to to really like cut my legs out from under me um cost me a fair amount of points but i think that i'm not doing well and i think that other people think that i'm not doing well and so therefore they're going to take their action to do something positive for them rather than sell this share because i was sitting on three shares and the two of you on one for many many many rounds and uh you you both of you just you sat with there with them right and didn't end up selling them so i do think that that that meanness is part of that like that it's that player interaction that you want to have in games right like who's paying attention to what and i think that um you know travis really felt like he was doing super well at the

beginning and then i think he got just devastated by the the the green selling yeah well and i just bought fewer shares just overall i'm looking at it i mean i apparently only bought five shares and it was hard because i was the majority shareholder in four of those five shares like two of the three companies i was the majority shareholder and it just it just it just didn't work out for me and that's okay yeah yeah you were doing too much work and not enough uh profiteering yeah that's actually really interesting to look at travis had five shares john you had six at the end but you sold one so you bought seven over the course of the game and of course after the end of the auction you had two because of the way the auction went down and nick you also had seven i believe at the end and didn't sell any but given the five i sold and the six i ended i had 11 over the course of the game so that's really interesting the way that that played out i mean i i am curious um to know and and this is just the way these these games may be or this game is but it did seem like there was kind of a wide gap i mean we john won with 331 uh points and then nick was 30 below that he had 301 i was six below nick at 295 but then travis you were down at 254. so that's that's a pretty wide gap um is that sort of normal for this game to have kind of like those scores or even the genre to have scores kind of all over the place like that i was surprised at how close nick and i were

um given everything but still we we were right in the middle when i say close we actually weren't that close we were close to each other but not not to the leader or or the tail yeah it's pretty it's pretty common whenever you're looking at not just this game but just kind of cube rails in general especially with games like this where you get the full value of the share at the end of the game because not not every game does that right it's like chicago express at the end of the game it's the amount of money that you have on hand um but with this you just totally divest of everything that you have at the end and you take all that money and then really truthfully it is about the number of shares that you have so i find it really interesting that john eeked out on top beyond nick because nick had one additional share but i think john had more cash on hand at the end and then plus just like and it's hard because orange was the most valuable company at the end of it and nick had three shares but i think it was just cash on hand is what got you at the end for those extra 30 bucks yeah absolutely i think so too um going back to before i mentioned there were like two things i wanted to talk about one was selling which we've definitely covered the other one was the randomness of the draw deck at the beginning of this episode travis you mentioned uh erie railroad being an inspiration for this and i think the first night that i played train games with you like six months ago um you and a couple of your friends were like let's play erie railroad so you you taught it to me and we played it and and i loved it i really had a wonderful time and i could totally see that inspiration here in union station and most other cube rails games don't have

randomness like that like that's kind of probably the biggest difference like i say you can't sell in most of these games and that makes us pretty different but that random draw deck for the stocks is is a huge divergence and i like it i really do like it i like it in the area railroad and i like it here because of the the situations that it makes and it like sure that randomness could end up swinging the game a little bit towards somebody one person versus somebody else but i also think it probably levels the playing field and makes this even better a starting off point for people who haven't played very many of these games um like i think i'm actually quite happy that this is the first one that anastasia got to play i think after playing it this was my first play i'm like yeah i think this is a good game to introduce to the genre you don't have separate treasuries you can deal with that if you like this and you want to play more slightly more complex games it's a really good entry point to it and um frequently i've heard people talk about irish gage being a great entry into uh cube rails games um i personally don't agree with that i'm not actually not a fan of irish gage but that one also has randomness in a way that most of these don't but for irish gauge the randomness is you pull a cube out of the bag to dictate which companies pay out whereas in this game you pull random cards to see which companies do you buy and it's like a difference of input randomness versus output randomness in this one it's it's input randomness you know the companies on offer you make a decision to buy them or not um and and i really actually dislike the output randomness of pulling dividend cubes for irish gauge so i think this is a great entry point because of that i made this i made this statement in the middle of the play that

the most boring games of this i've ever played is whenever people just laid track because one of the three in-game triggers right is that all the companies run out of track and the reason why i find that boring is because we actually had a really good interesting play that two of the three in-game triggers were right next to one another yeah right so if a couple more dividends got paid out just literally if one more dividend got paid out then then the game would have ended or so it could have been like maybe somebody didn't do maybe somebody didn't buy those last couple shares which wouldn't have been the right decision i think um somebody not buy those last couple shares and then maybe do a couple of builds and then the dividends pay out and then it all shakes out that way um but the reason why i say the boring plays or whenever people just lay track um it's because you don't get to see most of the shares like there are uh there are 25 shares that are shuffled up face down and i play games to where only like like we had an interesting we had an interesting point in this game that the that the white share was on that plus three space for sixty percent of the game i've seen that i've seen that clog up the offer cue so much that no one buys anything that no one realizes that no one realizes oh maybe i should buy something to open up more space so that other things can show up and instead everybody just goes to laying track and then now you have it to where only 10 shares have come out in the entire game

and then you you get towards the end everything's big every uh all the companies have have built all their track and then you do final payouts and it's just kind of like yeah you own the majority share of this company you own the majority share of this company and we all had one each and there you go and it's kind of boring but what's fun is that anastasia she was like i'm not going to deal with that i'm going to dump companies which then influ which had more of an influx of cash for her but then lowered the value and then people went but if i bought that plus one then that's going to pay out a dividend which then it's going to pay more money and so it's it's a lot of times that people just go well i'm just going to lay track because i don't want to sell shares and then people automatically think i just don't want to sell shares and because of that what ends up happening is that that gets clogged up at the top that randomness happens because at the beginning of the game we had the three white chairs up there at one point and it was like this is really kind of garbage and i thought it was gonna be garbage to you i won't lie after the initial thing and two white companies come out i was just like oh oh this is it this isn't going to go well um pleasantly surprised um that it that it did and so there we go i'm curious though to that so i was just you know kind of looking at it and i was thinking you know in my last play i bought the lap after all that i bought the last white share and uh it had already dividended uh dividend dividend paid its dividend whatever they'll go with it dividend uh so there was no there was no real nothing happened other

than the value the share increase which i actually want to comment on too you know in a lot of games shares get more expensive and then this is actually not that there's more buy it it took me kind of a beat to realize it's not that it cost me more it's how much further they're they're gonna go up several times i was like why are you guys buying the more expensive one and i realize no no they're not they're buying the one that increases the share price more so anyways i thought that was cool um but my point here is that i bought this share it took the share price up three there was no dividend but so my delta if you will was you know i paid 25 money and then at the end of the game i got 28 money but at the same time i gave john inherently six more money because he had two shares and i also gave nick the amount he beat me by six money so i'm kind of curious you know from a design perspective but that was really all i could do now that's because i had not like tracked the whole game and by this point there was no track delay i mean there was you could have played track i could have laid white track um but there was no value to me doing it was pretty much the only thing i could do um i imagine actually i i don't can you pass in this game i don't know i don't i think i had to buy that right i didn't really have a choice well laying track would have effectively yeah yeah lane track would have been passed sorry um but she wasn't going to lay track no but i wasn't going to lay track i had to buy that share because i wasn't going to lay track because i didn't want to but also because i couldn't sell and so i'm curious what led you to and the reason because of that is in the game after 18

uh like on the 18th dividend the last three dividends that pay out you can no longer sell stock and i'm just curious travis why that why you decided to do that i would have loved loved to sell at the end there i think that would have actually been far more beneficial for me um in those last few turns and so i'm curious yeah um on it honestly it's because part of it is because of the meanness factor right because you get to the point and what i could what i could also see happening at the end is it's once once you know the end is about to occur then it's real easy to go well i'm going to i'm going to get rid of all my orange shares okay and then you're gonna get rid of your white ones and then you're also gonna get rid of your orange ones and then i'm gonna get rid of my blue ones um and then i have i have one green chair but john has three green cherries i'm gonna dump my one green chair and then he just kind of like i played a couple games early on that involved like three rounds around the table of people just dumping chairs and it was just it was just kind of gross it was gross feeling it didn't feel that it because when you when you sell it feels like it feels like you're taking a step back even though you're getting money it kind of feels like you're not progressing the game um and then this way this way it kind of at least pushes you to the end of okay you you have to you have to finish this game you're on final approach you gotta land the plane yeah no i know it's cool and it's cool because i wasn't laying track and because i wanted to sell more

i was very acutely aware of where that track was where that dividend track was and i was i did feel the tension of like okay no stocks will still pay out but you're you're gonna be frozen here there's gonna be they're gonna shut down the stock market for a few days so um you know figure it out and um yeah i mean it doesn't matter i mean like it it was what it was in that moment but i yeah i was just curious about that at this point i i want to mention like this has been a total love fest so far and you know uh maybe part of it's because travis is here maybe part of it's because travis and i are friends but um i've really enjoyed this whole experience i've been sitting here thinking like if i was to be critical about something that i didn't like about this play i'm not really coming up with much and maybe you know we got lucky and the the way the cards dealt out and the people that we're playing with um just made this into like an ideal first play of it because i i know i've heard um from other podcasts and stuff that some people are more lukewarm about the game um than i am currently feeling and i feel like the rest of us around here but i just kind of wanted to be vocal about that that you know i'm not sitting here saying this is the best cube rails game i ever played but i am sitting here saying i quite enjoyed it i also won i also won you know um so yeah that's just kind of a i don't know an asterisk i wanted to mention but also i'm having a hard time finding something that rubbed me wrong while i was playing it beyond my initial terror that anastasia had completely gone down in flames after the initial auction i was right there with you and i was like it's her first time first time playing one of these games she's gonna hate these and never play them again

uh and i was i was really happy to see that you came in a very competitive second place and yeah third place third place third place that's not competitive third place it's okay it's okay not bitter um i did mention it earlier the only the sticking point for me was the beginning of the game and um just in terms of like feeling that and i think i i didn't really pipe in about the the random stock part of it because i think that i would need to play it more to see but i suspect that there's some number of games where the way that the stocks flip out and you were basically saying this travis just kind of like makes for a very odd or or more rigid flow um so that's definitely something to to be aware of in that i did think it was exciting and like i said for me i started off in a place where i was like ooh i'm not going to like this and then it unlocked and i think that comes with we had seen enough things that right there's sort of the like law of averages and it starts like opening up the game and um that that was really what worked for me uh uh and and playing this yeah yeah i think i agree with both of you and i mean if i had two sort of question marks and and this would come out with more plays i think the first is it's just that i do worry that this could be very ap heavy for a certain type of player like i could see someone who would want to sit and calculate you know the delta on every move that they make especially with the urge too especially with the cell actions to try and figure that out to

and you know i found myself doing that and you know of course i you know i was trying to push myself away from that but like i i could see that happening and i could see for some players that being sort of difficult to know that was possible and not do it um could be kind of kind of a little bit of a sticking point and then i think kind of to that point you there maybe that that kind of player um who likes to kind of calculate things out and in different ways might find themselves in a few instances and of course please travis speak to this where they might be frustrated that there there is no good play like i think if i had thought too much about my final play there realizing i'm giving john and nick each six points and i'm only getting three points i might have been a little frustrated in that moment because i would have been like well there's nothing good for me to do and i'm just helping everyone else and of course that's an inherent nature of shared incentives and blah blah blah and they helped me and i helped them but um i do want to say that you also got six points there it was actually a wash for you me and nick because you had two white that was your second white so you netted three on the one that you bought and then you also netted three again but also like that's sort of a pass like your final turn just pushed it essentially gave travis negative six points right okay travis which i definitely you're absolutely right you're absolutely right john i'm sorry look at that see i can't even i can't even ap my own turns here um because you're you're absolutely right so ignore everything i've been saying um

what is totally accurate though yeah yeah that still would have been a wash but yeah yeah it it i mean and it is and uh when speaking to the point of not being able to make a good not being able to make a good play right so sometimes you're just kind of like well this is this is all i can do yeah and that kind of happened to me early on too right there was that one term where i was really kind of stuck and i was like what do i do that is good it was like your second it was quite literally your second life you're like well i guess i'm just going to do so yeah john was like do you want me to cut out all this ap i was like well let's see how bad it gets like let's see if this is all i do is freak out about this well well what's interesting with with with a lot of cube rails titles is that whenever it comes to q bros games typically you can only do like three things on your turn right so if you're looking at kind of the more traditional cube build titles um oftentimes it's put a stock up for auction or it's uh build some track or it's do some other funky third thing because most cuberle's games have like this funky third thing that you could do mine was selling selling stock um in an irish gauge it's uh it's placed like a special interest marker or it's actually make dividends occur you can actually make dividends happen um in chicago express its place um i never know what those are those those things those improvement houses yeah improvement houses yeah yeah i forgot what it is um so it so it's one of those things right um but oftentimes in those games

you get to a point where you go well there's nothing good that i can do there's there's nothing good and you're just kind of stuck there okay well i could i cause like there are times in games where you go well especially in games that have auctions you sit there and go well i guess i could put this up for auction but i don't have the most money so i'm not going to win it and plus this is actually like i can only afford this one company and so i guess i could put that one up for auction but john's going to win it because he's the most money and plus he already owns two shares of that company so he's going to get it so that's a bad action um i guess i could lay track over here and if i lay track well you know that that that reaches that place but then that helps everybody else because everybody else shares in that company or i guess i could just waste my turn and place this special interest cube in this one place an irish gauge or i could or i could place this investment house in this one which is going to give me two dollars hooray you know um so there's always kind of that one like that there's a couple times in a game that you always get this stuck moment of well i guess i'm going to do blank and it really either it helps everybody or it just kind of pushes me on a little bit like i like i see that with my play a whole lot like towards like not even towards the end but like i built track in green and in black because i was the majority shareholder and i built track and i was like i'm just gonna lay track this will be nice easy going and it just didn't work out for me you know um and it wasn't the best thing that i could have done on my turn but once again because of the randomness and the shares that come out you can't

really optimize what you're doing you can do it to an extent you can optimize it to know that hey there are two more chairs left in the deck but you don't know when those are going to come out and so there is this kind of weird sticking point that you're that you're stuck but i will tell you in most instances they build and i love that you sold because you're like forget it i'm going to i'm going to tip the balance a little bit and that's actually a stronger play because most people go well i'm going to spend my next three turns laying track and then eventually it's going to pay out and then hooray but you were like no i want an immediate influx of cash i want money that a lot of that a lot of people just don't do because they're like well i'm stuck i guess i'm you know going to be resigned to lay track and it's like yeah sure you can do that or you could do something fun with it and john was talking about this earlier my favorite part about cube rails games is that they're they're 45 to 60 minutes and so you can just do whatever weird ridiculous nonsense you you want in these games and then you're not sitting through a 30-minute teach a two-hour play and then at the end of it go well that was a thing that i did by the end of it you can go oh that was that was just kind of wild and silly and fun and whatever and then we'll go on to the next one at that point yeah i actually had that thought at the start when i thought i trashed my game i was like okay well if it's real bad maybe we can play it fast enough then we'll get a second one in because i can't like we'll be like halfway through i'll be like guys guys we can't no but it was uh yeah it's it's fun and fast and and um i

don't know if it says how much i wanted to have fun or how much i didn't want to help the rest of you i don't know what that says about me but i you know in those moments but i think that's gonna wrap up essentially everything i have to say about union station beyond uh i had fun and i'm certainly looking forward to playing this one more yeah thanks for joining us travis was really great playing with him yeah oh it's my honor thanks this is a lot of fun well and tell us so this game is on kickstarter obviously if you're listening to this in the future you missed out but tell us what's the deal with what's the deal with this right now yeah so so new mill industries um they're the ones who put it out on kickstarter um obviously depending on whenever you listen to it it went live it goes live on kickstarter on october the 12th um and for per my understanding it's going to be on for three weeks um it is shipping internationally as well you know based off of international shipping and all that other mess that's going on um new mill is great in the sense that they do very quick turnarounds on games so they're they're actually anticipating being able to start shipping this in january or february um so within three or four months and having seen three other campaigns from new mill that is quite on track they'll be able to get things out pretty quickly um it is a really small game it is bonkers i played with it in person for the first time it actually fits inside of one of those prior those small priority mailboxes like it fits right in there and so everything's kind of it's kind of like

itty bitty and compact which is really adorable um but i have but i also love it because because it's highly transportable i mean you can toss that in with everything else you can have a 45 minute experience of of stabbing each other whatever you want well this has been a really wonderful discussion uh and just a fun thing to do a a great way to spend some time so thank you for joining in especially travis i'm really glad we were able to have you on as a guest this is something i'm kind of hoping we do more in the future if possible because being able to pick your brain while actually playing it was was a lot of fun all right well that's going to bring this episode to a close thanks to everyone out there for listening i hope you enjoyed this discussion and if you have any questions or comments about anything we said today then leave those as a comment on the youtube version of this podcast episode you can find a link to that in the description of this podcast as always i'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including these producer level patreon supporters if you too would like to directly support the channel in the creation of future videos like this one then please go to johngetsgames.com support also if you enjoyed this video please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved