Skip to main content
Loading video...

Talking Games, Movies & Podcasting with Tim Dolloff of Board Game Hot Takes - TCbH Interview

Transcript 59:51

do you have any ambition to create games um I've you know thought about it a little bit but to be honest the reality is I'm not that smart welcome back to another episode of the cardboard Harold my chance to talk with creative Gamers and game creators and joining me today is the co-host and co-founder of the board games hot takes podcast this is Tim dolliff welcome back to the show kind of back to the show we'll get into it thanks Jack thanks for having me again yeah yeah we had some technical difficulties they were on my part uh some things fell apart we tried arranging this earlier things got screwy things got Haywire but now we're back to record uh another discussion a delightful discussion with another podcast host you're in like in that I have a terrible memory so whatever we talked about before I have no memory of it you can ask me the same questions different questions it'll be fresh for me okay excellent excellent I think we got like deep into Dune lore and then I I think there was some hijinks about like running in your climate versus my climate but I like keeping it fresh so why don't you tell me like what's new in the world of board game hot takes like what what's fresh on your mind what have you been getting to the table lately uh yeah so let's see this week while I just got frost Haven in the mail so that was fun exciting got a chance to unbox it and sort everything and I talked a little bit about that on our last episode otherwise we played uh endless

winter this last week that was our last episode that came out and that was a a surprise for me I thought I was gonna find it too bloated too clunky it was pretty streamlined surprisingly and we just got a little oldie but goodie back to the table this week and that was dungeon pets and that's what our next episode's gonna be on so uh yeah you know variety of stuff oldie but goody I like that and dungeon pets certainly is a classic one that I'd like to see more people play and that's something I think about a lot in our hobby is that we move on into these new hotnesses or I guess chillnesses coolnesses with uh Frost Haven but we pass by all of these games that are incredible games that are foundational to our hobby but they don't get talked about because of the zeit guy based and everything we don't really have like a Criterion Collection of board games someone should really start that at some point but like when you're reflecting on the games that you most want to play do you find yourself in a position where you are constantly feeling obligated to newer games or or do you find that you get a lot of time with the classics as well yeah no it's a blend for me I'm not at all committed to new hot hotness and you can see that you know our Channel we release a usually a recording about a specific game every week and we have a pretty good mix and I'd say we even lean more towards Classics things that were released prior to the current year than we do brand new games and uh part of that is just because it's the games we want to play

you know we're just we love the hobby we love exploring all these games there's so many great games out here and uh you know we don't need to be trying every new game that comes out we want to try the ones that people have been talking about for years and then once in a while a new one's going to catch our attention and we get excited about it and so then we'll try to get to that to the table soon but we you know we just recorded our top games we want to playlist for this year and we do this every year since we started the podcast three years ago and I would say probably 30 you know three out of five games that each of us had on our list were probably five years old or older so you know we're still trying to find all those Classics we haven't had a chance to play at explore them and some of my favorite games of all time were you know we're not new and you rely on uh playing things on tabletop simulator a lot that's where you go to for a lot of your uh gaming for the podcast right it's a mix but mostly online platform since our my co-hosts were all located geographically in different locations tabletop simulators where we can find almost any game we prefer board game arena and there's a lot of great stuff out there I mean we've been hitting a any hard it's in Alpha right now right recently uh what a great game to have on there so it's always great when we can when we can find awesome games on board game read and there's a ton out there a ton a ton of great stuff I still haven't played yet so that that's our go-to but you know you're not going to find everything there so tabletop simulator tabletopia Yukata any platform that uh that a great games on we'll we'll search it out was there ever any trepidation that you had at first like you were going somehow compromise the gaming

experience by playing on a virtual platform I know you're a magic the Gathering guy and so a lot of people who dip their toes into the world of tabletop gaming with magic kind of got that transition by switching to online magic there are certainly a lot of board gamers out there who are like the physical experience is what I'm actually looking for and they are still resistant towards virtual implementations yeah I mean that's a that's a great question the reality is we don't have that option so yeah we started this podcast it was right after covid you know kind of hit us we all decided let's be safe and we stopped gaming together in person and this is three friends that were hanging out almost every week started doing it online and we're like Hey we're doing this online let's go ahead and start talking about it online afterwards and then and we all moved to separate places so you know kobit kind of split us up and we made use of it and and this is where we are today so um you know it's of course it's not ideal like 100 like we we talk about that every time about how many plays we had what platform we played it on and we talk about what we know and don't know about the components and there's of course an element to that at the end of every episode of course we also cover uh you know games that have been on our table and this is usually each of us independently talking about the games we've locally been playing and so we can get into the context of the the you know the feel of a game and stuff like that and many of the games that we review as well one or more of us have at least played it physically in the past not always so we try to you know talk about that but we're you know we just try to be honest about it but sure absolutely like somebody has to pull question on

Twitter today you know what's your preferred gaming platform is it in person is it online and I said 100 in person even though probably 50 of my gaming is online whether it's async on board game Marine Arts with my friends to record the podcast every week gaming in person is is my ideal it's what I want to be doing but I've been doing it long enough as well I mean you know a 20-year Magic the Gathering player as you mentioned um you know now five or six years in the board gaming hobby I have a pretty good sense for what translates to a digital platform and what um you know what's missing there and I think we can talk about that to some extent well your physical collection has just uh doubled in weight I'm sure with the arrival of crosstaven tell me about your actual gaming group that you can play physical games with is Frost Haven one of these games that you're going to find the players to play with is this you know something you'll play with your partner is this something that you'll solo you know how are you going to get this game to the table because it's new easy task just to get that thing started yeah that's a great question Jack and I don't know to be honest when I bought Frost even two and a half years ago or three years ago I honestly bought it expecting to solo it primarily right and I bought it when I was still you know in my old home to my old town with my friends thought maybe we could get a plate but I was really expecting to solo it and then we all separated and moved away no I got a chance to play gloomhaven jaws of the lion and I soloed that and I had a decent amount of fun with it but for me the way to do it is going to be playing two or more characters and I found it a little bit too happy for me to enjoy

right experience so I don't want a solo Frost Haven um and I almost I actually try to give it away on our show and it took so long you know I gave it away to somebody and then it took so long to arrive I ended up feeling bad and I gave him a gift card they asked for that instead of waiting for forever but now I've got it I'm kind of excited about it so I've been here where I live now in Phoenix for like two and a half years started to put together a couple different game groups and what I plan to do over the next couple weeks is basically just talk to talk to some of my local Gamers about it and ask if they're interested and if I can get a three or four person group together that'll get together once a week or every couple weeks to do this that's my hope uh if not it may not stick around maybe I'll try a couple solo games of it and then move it on but I I am hoping to get a local group together I just don't have them picked out yet so you talked about the origins of board game hot takes as a podcast and then that happened during covet and you guys split up and now you're doing things primarily virtually how of your tastes as a gamer evolved since doing the podcast because I'm certain your exposure to games and also critically thinking about those games kind of changes how you view what you were interested in what you most want out of games what you don't like how do you feel about you know that that Evolution over the last few years yeah that's absolutely true now I would say it hasn't changed harassment I'll try to speak for myself and my co-host a little bit is that I was always kind of a Euro gamer a mechanism focused you know I I got introduced to a game that had cool mechanisms and I was like wow this is great and so that's where I was really

focused and I was never a big fan of high interaction um believe it or not as a magic player but that's a little different there's a long I could go into a long diatribe about why a a two-person one-on-one head-to-head game is different than a multiplayer game this is a podcast my friend there if there is ever room for a long diatribe it is this and generally though you know I I haven't loved the um the scenario of like area control games high conflict um uh you know uh King of the Hill that type of thing it just you know it's just my not my favorite but uh my friends on the other hand love that stuff they love the interaction they love that type of take that they love you know they love player interaction in a way that Euros often don't give you um and I think we've all shifted a little bit more to the center of that whole conversation over three years of playing a unique game every week and many many other games outside of those um you know I I what I have found is that even though I still love these mechanisms I still love Euro style games I still love my multiplayer solitaire games I also know that the most fun that I ever have at a table with people is when there is some kind of interaction you know it doesn't have to be mean necessarily but it has to be a way to have an impact on the other games to care what other people are playing and sometimes the most fun games are even you know like later games that are almost party style games and I've I've you know taken to accept that and and find more fun in those but um but I still love my heavy Euros so I would say

it hasn't shifted drastically what I have found though is just like anything when you get exposure to a lot of something you start to get a little bit more picky and you start to identify what's better what you know what's been done better before what is this doing better than before what's unique about this and so I definitely am not as um you know I don't know as gracious about how every game is an amazing game right there's a lot of games that I'm like I wish I was playing something else and so you know that that just happened so I think any time you really get deep into into a hobby and it doesn't matter what it is right right now I I wonder if this is something that's uh more common towards uh people who are in the content creating space the people who are putting on conventions you know the people who are really trying to share their love gaming with the masses that a lot of the love for games comes out of the experience of having other people fall in love with games like I find that a lot of the games that I love most at this point are not just the games I know that I can get played but I'm kind of like ambivalent to experiences so long as the people that I'm playing with are having a great time that's not to say that I there aren't things that I love or dislike in a game uh but I know that uh it's going to seriously wait a game in uh in the favor of me enjoying it if I'm sitting there in like my kid loves it or my wife is

absolutely into it or my best buddy is sitting over here and he's like oh dude I didn't get root before but suddenly I get root and then I'm like I know right now all I want to do is play more root do you find that you know like that was part of the the Instinct for you to dive deeper in the hobby is not just you getting to play games but shepherding other people into gaming yeah I think that's always been some truth I mean when I was uh when I really got heavy into gaming to start with I knew a couple people that were in it and kind of brought me into it and then I immediately was like we need more of this and I put together a game group and I mostly just brought in friends people that had no like they had no knowledge of the board game hobby at all I was like Hey Tuesday night come over to my house I'm gonna teach you a game let's try it and it was so fun when you start to see those people in fact this just happened with my neighbor down the street who I introduced to some games recently where they you can see them just get start to get excited and enthusiastic about this and that that obviously is great but that then it's going to lead you toward the games that are gonna make them happy and it's kind of like you know like you you introduced so you're like oh this is the best movie I've ever seen you tell a friend that and you really want them to love it you want to watch it with them and you want them to be laughing at all the right points and and it's kind of like a board game is the same way so I do really try to pick games that I think the audience I'm playing with are gonna have fun with and are gonna like right and my two most regular uh the people I play with the most are my wife and our really close friend Jen who spends a lot of time with us her kids are about my kids age and we spend a lot of time together and they

love gaming we we game every time we get together usually a few times a week and they have a little bit different taste in the games that they love so we play the games that they love because I want them to be having fun and I'm glad people are playing games with me but it doesn't mean that 100 of the time I'm gonna want to play the games that they want to play or the exact game that they want to play so you know you still have to uh you know you have to you have to take care of yourself a little bit you have to be a little selfish once in a while and say I don't feel like playing that game again for the 100th time can we try something different tonight right if I didn't do that right they don't want to learn new games they love the games they love but if I never did that they would have never been exposed to some of their favorite games because I was like wait you know let's try something different tonight I know you're going to groan about it but once they got through it they loved it so you know it's a little bit of a push and pull but it's I think it's good for everybody to for everyone to get a little bit of happiness out of it it's a unique copy I mean compared to other Hobbies you have a selfish a vested interest in converting new people to gaming because to get the best experience out of most of the games I mean solo gaming is better than it's ever been but the generally accepted best experience that you're going to have with most games is with other players and so unlike telling someone about like hey check out this movie well I mean that doesn't mean that I want to watch every movie with you I need to hook you as a gamer so that way I have someone who can sit down and play games with me so we kind of proselytize it was so funny you talking about your neighbor

or you know talking about uh you know these friends who had never played games before and have very little concept of it that's how do what we do right we we just kind of grab the nearest person where we're like your opinion on gaming hasn't been formed yet so I'm going blow your mind like you know co-workers and Social Service you know these like Child Protection Service workers who I'm like hey you want to play a board game at lunch or you know like going over to someone at the coffee shop or you know like any Gathering that I can get to with my friends or my kids as friends as parents or something be like oh yeah I thought I'd uh break out this game um it's called uh sprawlopolis it's only 18 cards but you might like it um we just find Opportunities to try to get these people to play games with us but it's what we need to do but I want to go way back like I'm talking way back because you you said 20 years of magic playing when's the first time that you recall having a game interest you as like a hobby unto itself you know something where you're like oh I want more of this well when I was a young kid so my I grew up in kind of a gaming family traditional though you know you know traditional board games you know this the stuff everybody's played um and I always liked games it's always something that was fun to us but I had a brother that was about a year and a half older than me and so of course we were

into everything together and we got exposed to the concept of Dungeons and Dragons now we never owned any Dungeons and Dragons materials but we started creating our own characters and we started making up our own stories about what to do we didn't know how the mechanisms worked but we kind of gleaned from hearing about it how it might work and you know it was way even back then where we were just like we need more of this like we need more ways to to create to to we started turning everything into a game we had Garbage Pail Kids and we put it into a war Style game we had you know like everything was a game Stratego was something that hit for us for a long time so you know those were some early ones but you know Magic the Gathering is is the one that really took over my my whole mindset about what what I wanted to be spending my free time doing and I got introduced to that when I was I don't know 19 years old 1996 probably shortly after high school and uh my brother taught it to me and I immediately got hooked and it's like it's all I wanted to do for 20 years until I discovered hobby board games to be honest which I feel like has has kind of deepened my love for what you can do on a tabletop just because of the variety the the unique experiences you can get out of it but yeah I would say magic is is kind of the one that really grappled me in but it's been there since I was a little kid do you still dip your toes into Magic I love magic but uh you know I don't have anyone local that plays with me I still have a cube I have an eight person cube of some of my favorite cards of all time that I'm just waiting for someone to say like hey you want to play Magic

and yeah we'll do a Winchester draft or we'll get a few people I don't know maybe it'll happen someday um I have a couple friends that will visit occasionally that I used to play magic with so we'll bust that out once in a while but that's about it I know that if I get into the arena world I will not stop and I I just don't have that kind of time so I haven't got I haven't dug into magic Arena um probably will get tempted one of these days and go deep but uh not too much anymore do you have a favorite Magic card oh boy I haven't thought about that for a long time so I'm gonna say no I'm not gonna say no I can probably tell you I could I've got a favorite set okay what's your favorite set because it's it's Invasion okay the first multi-color set and it was the first time I ever went and got into the tournament scene of magic and I just remember the love of that experience of going to pre-releases and then going into uh you know booster drafts and that's kind of where I really got into competitive magic got into sealed and limited magic in a significant way right and it was just a fun set to do it with yeah when I think about my favorite Magic card this is ridiculous because every magic player is going to roll their eyes at this but it came in at a very formative time in my life where I'd I was just discovering fantasy like I had been recently exposed to the 1977 hobbit cartoon film and that was so outside of the scope of anything that was in my household it was actually my uncle who kind of like corrupted me he had it on VHS and uh totally not my dad's style whatsoever and I was like oh

my God I want more of this and shortly after uh Magic kind of stepped into my life and myself and my older brother got into it and I remember that uh we had some cards from prior sets uh and it was right around the era of revised maybe into fourth edition and then ice age but specifically I can remember her loon Minotaur which I have a signed print on my wall that shows up in a lot of videos and people are like oh her loon Minotaur uh and sengar vampire uh which kind of like blew my mind because I was like young but I'm pretty sure there's something both uh grotesque and sexual about this card uh and the one that made the most impression on me was mons Goblin Raiders a 1-1 for one Mana what's impressive about that first off the artwork nothing looks like man's Goblin Raiders in contemporary fantasy like the things that were coming out at that time it was just a weird illustration and it was an apostrophe s and they filled that flavor text to the brim who is Mon and why does he have Goblin Raiders are these Goblin Raiders why do they kind of look like Khan from Star Trek I mean like it was so perplexing but my mind could not stop thinking about Mon and this is Goblin Raiders and who this was in the context of dominaria and then some suddenly I'm like

what is dominaria and it totally pulled me in every card pack the first thing I would do before I even looked at any of the mechanics because I knew my brother was going to beat me he's four and a half years older than me so he just used me as a punching bag I'd still play the game for sure but every pack that I opened for the first two years of playing Magic I would look at the flavor text first because I wanted to know what was going on and then suddenly this ice age was happening in the same world and who's Lim Dole the Sorcerer And all these things but I think that all started with man's Goblin Raiders and realizing that there there's some implication here uh and for that amount of thematic resonance to come out of some stupid 1-1 for one Mana is brilliant and the the sets continue to evoke all of these really deeply thematic concepts with quite abstract terms I mean the game is a very abstract game when you get right down to it but somehow they're able to convey so much with these cards so man's Goblin Raiders for me that's that's a story that I haven't even thought about in a while yeah it's in that that uh it's amazing how well they've managed to keep that going for so long and I know I Wizards the coast has made some missteps this last year right yeah with multiple properties magic being one of them I haven't been following it too much but you know just the amount of effort that they put into the art Direction into the

World building into the uh the mechanisms and the you know making that game stay alive and Thrive for I don't know what we're coming up on 30 years now at this point it's it's impressive and you have to I think every you know modern board game designer should play Magic if they have and most of them probably have you should be following Mark rosewater's design uh uh you know blog if he's still putting it out he was for a long time but um you know I learned it taught me a lot about the way I think about not only game mechanisms and what's interesting or unique about game mechanisms but about what's uh you know good strategy even yeah you know the way you wait how you value things has carried through from my magic days and and through learning about the design of magic into even modern design modern games did you ever read like duelist or inquest I'm trying to remember the specific magazine that would have the setups for like here's the situation you know you have four life left this is what's tapped and this is untapped and you have to be able to do X Y and Z yeah yeah these puzzles right exactly but I think that's more than anything what taught me because again I I was young getting into magic um what taught me to think think about like every action as a resource and that carried over into playing uh strategic board games which not to say that I'm like some phenomenal player or anything but it gave me a much deeper appreciation for how you're supposed to

contextualize every single interaction that you have with the game as a potential resource that you can spend um which I guess brings me to the next stage in the story you're playing Magic for 20 years and then someone is like hey you like magic let me show you this thing what's the game that kind of blew your mind and just overturned your pre-existing notion of what board games were yeah it was a little more complicated than that but um you know I was introduced to some Modern board games through the years while playing Magic I played Carcassonne and Katan and um you know a handful of other Battle Star Galactic I enjoyed all those plays but my my mind was you know my heart was always with magic so I didn't really get too moved into them uh and then I moved to a new city didn't really have one local that was playing so I was still thinking about magic but not playing it a lot and my wife met some people and said hey these guys you know these couples into board games you want to have them over for a game now I'm like absolutely we got to do this and they brought over and this is a current modern gamer if you walked into their house they had calic shelves with 300 games on them more games than I even knew existed but they walked in with Agricola in a Greek law was the first game we played which in my mind is a heavier game that I would typically introduce to somebody for the first time on a game night they brought it in and had a wonderful time with it it was tight it was hard every decision mattered and worker I got introduced to work replacement for the first time absolutely loved it um and so yeah I guess I have to kind of credit a curricula but I think I would have been caught it no matter what it

was and every game that it was me then after that like hey we played three games tonight what are we playing next week and it's like you know I just wanted to keep it going immediately so but I think it could have been anything it could have been anything so with a gricola one of the things that I look out for in that game is that it is so punitive like did you have any sort of friction with your first experience like or or did you you know like uh see the possibility like it's very tenuous to introduce someone to that game not because I think it's overly complex I actually you think a lot about the game as intuitive however if you aren't able to do it well then it will punish the hell out of you I remember it feeling hard uh you know to do that but I won that night so that probably happened yeah but my wife enjoyed it too and she you know she didn't and you know we were all you know worried about the the hunger tokens or whatever they are right and so it was a challenging first play and uh and what I remember to be more complicated to get into and why I think it's a little heavy is when you got those occupation and the um you know the Improvement cards there's just so much that people have to take in on a first play and I don't if I remember it I don't think we drafted he just handed us out of each so you've got 14 cards in your hand and you're like what am I going to do with all this stuff and you end up only playing two or three of them so that felt I remember feeling like this is a whole lot of information for not a lot of payoff

of course that's my favorite part of the game now but back then it felt like way more than you want to introduce somebody to on a first play have you played a curricula solo uh I tried it one time and didn't enjoy it very much yeah but uh yeah I have I avoid it so I tried it one time and didn't enjoy it very much until I played the campaign mode uh which uh I don't know if it was introduced in the revised Edition or not uh but it re-contextualized a gricola for me as a solo game because generally I don't like solo games where it's like get a certain number of points and you're like okay well that's kind of lame um you know you got X points and that doesn't mean you won you just did better than the lower tier that you could have gotten but in the campaign mode uh you have to meet a certain point threshold and you get to save one of your occupations which becomes persistent in the next game and then the uh the the point total that you have to meet each game ratchets up and having that sense of investment that you might play a card that would be sub opt animal of this game or go out of your way to set yourself up with something just so you can make sure that that's part of your Loadout pre-existing at the beginning of the next game uh was something that I was like suddenly Agricola solo it actually matters to me I haven't had much chance to talk to people about it so it was that sounds yeah that sounds super fun and I should get dig into it

but interestingly my relationship with solo games has been changing as well when I got into solo games I think it was mainly just in an absence of other players right I was getting to this hobby on buying games but nobody's maybe I'm getting a game played once a week but I've got all these great games I want to try and so I started getting him into solo just for the opportunity to get them to the table which was great and it was a fun way to explore them um my I still like the solo game but my choice on solo games has shifted a little bit I tend to be to go towards something that's either storytelling like I recently discovered Arkham Horror lcg oh yeah absolutely love it yeah and and that's fine one or at least something that's a little bit shorter and quicker things like under Falling Skies things like um trying to think like oh paperback Adventures is a game that I've been just absolutely loving solo lately uh the heavier Euro games I'm tending to not go to solo anymore just because I don't know I I feel like I like the experience more playing with with real people and the competition because it's real people I like a campaign experience though so the idea of bringing out a grika like that it's tempting you might have to give it a shot you you might give it a shot and plus it plays pretty quickly like especially if it's something that you could knock out a couple games and in maybe an hour and a half or something like that especially if you know what you're doing but okay so you know you you get into the hobby eventually uh you get to the podcast uh which is where you're at now like what what are the goals for the future like what do you expect out of this podcast are you

trying to make this a full-time job is this purely hobby um you know like do you want to evolve into different avenues like what are the Ambitions for the future I don't know how to answer that to be honest and I think about it a lot when we started the podcast my goal primarily was to have the opportunity to get to know some of the people that I was interacting with uh you know not really watching in the board game world people like yourself other content creators right you know board game designers board game um you know reviewers and and things like that and so that was kind of one of my goals and that's it's paid off it's been great I've built a fun community of other content creators I've gotten to have interactions with and chats with game designers that almost feel like celebrities to me and that's super fun I know you have as well obviously because you've you interview quite a few people um so yeah we accomplished that goal and uh you know we far exceeded what my goal was for how many listeners we could get to a podcast I didn't really know what to expect but we far exceeded that and right now it just feels like it's something I'm having fun doing and it's fun to continue to to try to to grow it and that's kind of my that's my ambition right now it's you know what I'm lobbying our listeners to get us a Golden Gate not geek nomination of this year is it going to happen probably not but boy that would be so exciting because you know I've been I've been voting for The Golden geek nominations for podcasts for six or seven years now wouldn't it be so cool to be one of the people that were nominated I I devote for you certainly

thank you well so anyway that's that's kind of my ambition right now is just continue growing it keep making something that people are enjoying it's so fun to have a community and we really do like we've got a community people that know each other now that interact with each other because they met through our social media channels or because they you know met talking about our show and that's a blast and we've made a lot of friends um both people who were listeners and have become friends other content creators that that we you know got a chance to collaborate with or interact with um so that's that's all been awesome and uh yeah I don't know there's no there's definitely no ambition to turn this into a job in fact I I um I appreciate what I one of the things that I feel like we do really well is we can just keep this fun and and you know we're never going after the money we're not monetizing we're not even asking for review copies although we do occasionally get some that we accept um we just want to keep talking about board games and have other people and the fact that people want to listen is just it it blows my mind do you have any ambition to create games um I've you know thought about it a little bit but to be honest the reality is I'm not that smart and so when I when I have I've tried to put I've done some prototypes in the past and I realized that they were terrible and I assume most prototypes are at first and they need a lot of work and then I realized I could be playing these other great games that that smarter and better designers have already put together so I don't think so it's it's something I think maybe you know I would like to retire early at some point that's one of my goals for my life and if I'm able to do

that or at least move to a little bit lighter career at some point and I just have more free time then maybe it's something I'd like to dabble around with or play around with right now right now I have so little leisure time that I want to spend it just playing the games that I love instead of instead of trying to make bad games that other people don't want to play do you ever find yourself you know kind of evaluating your hobby you know you're talking about having so little leisure time it's cool to be a content creator I like being a content creator and I'm not trying to do this as a full-time job but I'm cognizant of setting up obligations onto my my social time my free time and also the people that I most want to spend time with like by uh you know like reviewing games with uh physical games then I'm going to have to find people to play games with and then the the frequent thing to get to my table whether it's with my friends with my wife or with my son it's like here's a new game we gotta learn because we we gotta review this you know I gotta get it to the table I gotta have something to talk about and for the most part everyone's really good sports about that and then there's the other side of it which I think a lot of content creators experience where um it can be a real uh anxiety written to you know just see well why did that one get that many clicks as opposed to

that one you know like I put so much effort into this one and I didn't put that much effort into that one and I think you just kind of got to distance yourself and you know take take a step back and not worry about that don't compare yourself to other people just focus on evaluating are you having fun are you doing the the thing that you're proud of and not really thinking about the the the feedback loop and and over um analyzing things but you know like if you have such little leisure time do you find yourself evaluating like am I putting more pressure on myself through my hobbies yeah all the time but I have pretty strict boundaries and I think we the way the way we formatted the podcast was intentional it was very intentional because we're all um you know three people with with pretty weighty careers and we knew we had a limited amount of time around our families and our jobs and stuff like that so when we made the podcast we specifically made it to say we're not gonna devote a lot of time each week right the podcast is we want to play a game every week anyway let's just get on the show and talk about that game after we played every week it's a good way and yeah and so of course we're not going to get that in-depth review of like 15 plays and I can tell you what whether the game's gonna last like that's not who we are you know that's just that's not what our show does um but it's important because if we were trying to be that I think we all would have gotten burnt out and we would not be doing this still um so we recognize what our boundaries were and we set that now we've kind of pushed those boundaries a couple times and found that it didn't work for us for

example we started trying to uh get people onto our show interviews to what like what you do and we found that that tended to be more work more anxiety for us right you know get Pro the prep work and even though it was great and it was cool to talk to you know other content creators on our show and to have them on and I love doing on like I love being on your show I love talking with other content creators on their shows that's kind of my thing Chris and Adam don't have any interest in doing it but on our show it just it made it more work for us and so so we took a step back from that and then a couple times we reached out and and started to reach out the content to uh um uh Publishers and saying like hey you know if you have you know we like your games generally you want to start sending us review copies and then the obligation comes when you get review copies right and so that all of a sudden you're like man I don't really feel like playing this scenario I don't feel like talking about this game tonight because there's something else I'm more excited about and and all that obligation is just not necessary so we've mostly pushed that away and we we almost always reject any review copies we never ask for them the rare cases being a game that we know that we're super excited about and if a publisher happens to reach out and say you want to play this game and we're excited about it then we'll take it um because it gives us an opportunity usually to talk about it earlier and uh and so that but but just we're trying to just keep those obligations out of our life so it doesn't become a job it still is sometimes right um like every week we still are trying to talk about a new game and so oftentimes every week we're we're like man I got a busy week but I've got to spend two hours learning

this new game on Monday night so I can be ready to play it on Tuesday night and talk about it right so it still works sometimes but it's we're trying to keep it to the fun parts of the work the things I'd be doing for any game night um yeah so I think absolutely it's a risk I think it's a risk for any content creator you talked a little bit about you chasing the views right and how something you put a lot of effort in gets a lot of views something you put you know you don't put much effort in gets gets you know whatever it doesn't doesn't always seem to pay off podcasting I think is a little different and this probably isn't visible for most people um you might know this because you do YouTube and and podcasts but I've noticed our podcast is pretty consistent like it's just been a consistent growth we I can see where some content is going to change the number of listens in a week but it's not like a YouTube thing or something that's going to go viral right it's generally like hey we have a pretty steady group of listeners but you know some episodes okay a lot of people don't want to listen about an old game so we might drop 100 listens in a week right and then the hot new game might get a couple hundred lessons right so we can see little spikes and valleys and Peaks but for the most part we've got a consistent listenership that's slowly growing and so we can kind of just put out the content we want and I think as long as we're not pushing listeners away generally um we don't really feel that although like I've been watching our podcast store and I do pay attention I check it a couple times a day to see how the numbers are doing this week probably more than I should and over the Christmas holiday I noticed that wow listens are down this week and I just started to like really feel bad like

people don't like our show anymore what did we do why why are people losing interest and then right after the holidays it spiked way back up again we caught all those listens that were gone over the holidays because you know people are just not commuting saying they were busy they were with their family normal stuff so I can feel it and I'm glad I'm glad we're not in a format where I would experience it more than we do do you look outside of podcasts or outside of board gaming podcasts for inspiration like I find that in my own work I often am trying to reference things that I I want to accomplish within the world of war gaming but that outside currently and maybe that's not like a totally original thing but you know like if I'm watching Good Eats or something you know I'm like God Alton Brown really revolutionized this why don't I do sock puppets in my uh spirit Island video or you know like if I'm uh trying to sound smart in an interview and I'm like man well you know if only I could talk more like you know X Y or Z not that I'm trying to ape them but right the types of conversations that are going on or the types of podcasts or the types of videos that I see outside of the sphere seeing if I can use that to kind of hone my skills within it yeah no that's a great point and I I do to some extent right I I because I I love this hobby so much and I got I decided to make a podcast because I was enjoying podcasts and although I don't have as much time to listen to as many anymore

um I think when I do have free time I'm generally you know following content in in our hobby anyway so I'm not spending as much probably to a fault you know I used to enjoy a lot of outside things and I just don't spend much time with anymore and I'm definitely missing out on a bigger world view because of that but um let's let's derail this what are three of your non-gaming related Hobbies give it to me right now three not so running okay we've talked about a little bit in the past yeah we're both running um I one of us looks like a runner I'm not going to divulge which one looks like a runner but we both like right now you're bragging I get it um yeah so my other board game related Hobbies um yeah see that's interesting right because I I don't feel like a very uh interesting person because I I I've lost a lot of my old Hobbies now I still do love cinema right that's something I had a big passion for in the past um but in that way I think I I don't think I lost Cinema or the interest in cinema as much because of it being taken over by the board game hobby I think it's because I used it up like I I saw every movie that was on every top 100 list that existed and now of course there's still good cinema being made there's still good movies being made but you know I just I'm not finding as much evolutionary or exciting in that world so I read a lot I mean I don't know it's the normal stuff Jack I'm not in that interesting of a guy I follow politics uh probably more than I should right I uh you know I uh yeah so those are some

things that I spend my free time with that not nothing that I get too deep in them that's interesting that you bring up Cinema because that's something that I'm trying to become more versed in it's something I've always loved you know movies were one those things that I was explaining earlier the 1977 Hobbit wasn't my dad's thing well a lot of me became focused on sci-fi and fantasy much to my dad's dismay but the one thing that we could connect on is the latest John Woo movie or something you know like we go see face off together and I go see Gladiator together we go see in movies together and so I grew up loving movies and recently my wife and I have been doing these movie Nights where we you know are able to unilaterally pick a movie that we haven't seen um and so there's a lot of movies that we haven't seen even the classics people are like oh my God you've never seen X Y or Z well you know like there's a lot of movies out there so yes I finally saw Schindler's List or whatever but uh what's great about it is that either of us can pick um you know like tonight is my night I am going to pick this movie and you're along for the ride and you're going to appreciate it too and there's none of this just like well do you want to watch this I don't know what do you want to watch I don't know what do you want um and I'm trying to become more uh rounded out in my uh view of Cinema but having that deliberate intention to set aside one night a week to watch some new movie and that can be anything from uh

last week uh was 1940s Grapes of Wrath uh adaptation uh to um you know like uh yeah yeah uh Kimmy uh recent uh movie uh with uh Zoe Kravitz in it to you know anything in between just trying to pick a movie that's interesting and it both gives us something to do but uh gives my wife and I something to reflect on over the coming week which I think I'm having the inverse experience of you in some ways I still love board games board games are really interesting to me I've always loved board games since I had hero Quest as a kid and I've been into hobby gaming throughout my life but I have played hundreds thousands of board games at this point and um while it's still impressive to me viewing with a critical lens Cinema is something that's new and fresh and you know like intriguing I'm learning so much about it so that's interesting that you brought that up yeah I love it I mean I I often wish that I could go back and as for the fresh eye go through that experience I mean I did a lot of that in my 20s and early 30s and maybe you know it was great I think it was a great experience to get exposed to these things and it was very intentional um but now I missed it with the experience of being an older adult and and the life experience that could have

that I think I could have gotten even more enjoyment out of some of those films seeing them now so um I think it's great what I would recommend you do though and it's awesome that you can pick any movie what I find myself doing if I don't set some kind of goal is fallback kind of comfort food it's fun to watch a Marvel movie it's fun to watch the latest action movie it's fun to watch a comedy but it doesn't mean that you're going to get a groundbreaking or or you know really truly uh you know an experience that's going to change your life right go to a top hundred list of all time and start working your way through it even if it's like every couple movies you watch my dude my dude my wife has the AFI top 100 that's where she's working through right now uh and then I am just hungry for different things so my picks have ranged from uh kind of rounding out well I need to watch all you know get all the Wes Andersons in there but at the same time I'm rotating in what are some great foreign films okay let's go to Kira Kurosawa and let's uh you know um let's uh pick some trofo and Hitchcock you know there are a couple hitchcocks that I haven't seen I am going to some degree of comfort food in that I'm exposing myself to things that I already know but I'm trying to be cognizant of like what are experiences I haven't had and try to rotate through all of those so even if Wes Anderson is like I know I'm going to love every single film of his

that I put on as part of these movie Nights that might be every 10th movie I get to and I keep a watch list uh of the the movies I'm watching as well as the ones I want to watch and then I try to go what is the drastically different than the last five picks that I've picked here some movie that I've always wanted to watch and you know that's how we rotate through because I want something wild and I want something weird yeah it sounds like a fun exploration I wish I was right there on that Journey with you what's your favorite Wes Anderson film um you know I'm going to have to say uh going for um the Dark Horse Contender here Fantastic Mr Fox oh it's wonderful it's my number two oh yeah yeah uh Grand Budapest Hotel is maybe tied right there and being someone who has a close but also somewhat fraught relationship with Brothers uh you know like Darjeeling Limited is incredible but uh Fantastic Mr Fox is the one that I continually come back to it's the one that I probably quote the most in my house but it's also the one that I think I most often think about his speech about why he does what he does and he's self-reflecting with the water in the background and thinking about how he needs to impress other people the uh the the emphasis on what it means to be different uh and then the uh the wolf at the end I think about those

scenes all the time like it's weird how applicable it is in my life what's your favorite Wes Anderson movie Moonrise Kingdom is so good and then uh Fantastic Mr Fox and then uh the Dark Horse for me but I think most people don't have a really you know great view of it that's the Life Aquatic oh it's also so good yeah it's just the three movies that just charm me every time that just brings so much joy to me I was not a big fan sadly of um the uh the French dispatch yeah the most recent film um good some good stuff in there but it just dragged a little bit but but beyond that I've I've totally loved all of his films Life Aquatic is so Melancholy all of his movies are Melancholy but that one in particular is just like it hits different that is um in the set unbelievable I mean like a Grand Budapest Hotel is one of my all-time favorites and of course he utilizes Lee's incredibly intricate sets um but I think I haven't been so impressed by a set in a movie as I have with Life Aquatic that was just yeah In The Life Aquatic the music soundtrack is one of my favorite soundtracks of all time as well just a perfect hit throughout a variety of different tones in there but everything hits a couple couple perfect David Bowie tracks used yeah yeah you know I um I was playing keeper Europe have you played the board game Caper Europe I haven't okay so it's uh it's by keymaster games the makers of parks uh and the first thing that I

thought when I uh pulled that game out was oh my God these people have played or have watched so much Wes Anderson uh the uh the insert for it is the almost kind of like velvety uh it has this 1960s European uh like spy Chic aspect everything is meticulously Twee uh it is so Wes Anderson but not in uh like goofy parody way but in a legitimate loving way and it extends Beyond just the the uh the illustrations it goes into like I said the insert the uh components um and even some of the idiosyncrasies of how the game plays uh or communicates information is just like okay uh I know exactly tonally what they were trying to go for here you know it's so funny I think that's a great topic to talk about here when we're talking about movies or Cinema in relation I had again do a little bit of a conversation maybe a discussion with a listener on Twitter the other day because we often talk about theme and production and how important it is to us now I am more mechanically focused for sure but I think you can't deny that that having a great theme and and having that bra brought through in the production and it can be from the minute you open the box to what's in the rule book to every single component elevates The Experience oh yeah and you know and he said well would you ever you

know not not watch a movie with a great script because of the production that was like yes it makes a huge difference it's part of the cohesive whole exactly like a Wes Anderson film could still be a well-written film you know a quirky well-written film but if you didn't also put Wes Anderson's vision for the production for the style it wouldn't be a Wes Anderson film and it would have it wouldn't have been as special as they are right and that's that's the same thing with game board production as well like you can do it right you can put a great package and keymaster is is great at that and some of these some of these publishers and I think it really honestly has to do with the people who are running these publishing companies and what their vision is and some of them don't care and you know some of their audience doesn't care you can look at Alia and ravensberger in Germany right well their Their audience traditionally hasn't cared and so they've never put a lot of effort and you know time into the into the quality of production but um look at Scythe by still Meyer games yeah right that game just elevated what board games could be and it's still at the top because you know Jamie stegemeyer saw jakobski's artwork and said I want to create a game in that world and they brought that world into this game and you know it it's it's not side because of the cool mechanics and there's some in there it's side because it's this whole package of this amazing world and this amazing production with a fun gameplay on it as well I think that's one of the most frustrating things about the discussion in our Hobby

and I think that this is evolving but a lot lot of people are dismissive towards Euro games you know mechanic first games as being un thematic and I I think that's not necessarily true you know like you can have abstractions it's not like you have a warrior and they're literally swinging a sword but then again even in a mini game that you're rolling around it's still an abstraction it's still a little statue it's not like they're actually swinging a sword it's not thematic in the way that a video game is thematic and I I think about this a lot um like a good example to me is Lord's water deep is a game that a lot of people are like that's just a paste it on theme it's a pasted theme um because you know it could be any City or it could be any uh set of different four occupations but I I disagree the fact that it gives you a thematic context okay you are a quest Giver in a city you're going to recruit these missions that are quests that you're going to send these warriors on or or these Adventures on and then you're going collect the adventures and then cast them out onto that and reap some sort of rewards because it was beneficial to you that thematic explanation is also entirely appropriate as a mechanical explanation for the game too and I think that's

really the magic of a good board game like it doesn't have to be beautiful beautiful is a big part of it um and I don't think that it has to be like a really uh deep theme though that can be part of it uh but I think when there is a way of helping the player intuitively understand what's supposed to happen mechanically based off of what that mechanic is representing thematically is incredible and when that works out you know it absolutely elevates the game in the way that you're talking about yeah and I love your yeah you know using Lords of water deep as an example and one of the things that Lords of Water Deep uses as a mechanism is work replacement and I think worker placement is a wonderfully thematic mechanism because you literally have a figure that is sending out to do a task and then that task is producing something and you know grickel is another great example of that and Lords of Water Deep you know probably missed because of its era a little bit with some of the ways that it tried to represent that theme I mean cubes instead of figures made a big difference for a lot of people thematically right right and and the fact that you know modern artwork today on those Quest cards would have had the art you know a larger part of it or it would have made the the text more readable on it because right now it's hard to be part of the story when you you know when it's just uh you know a tiny text that you can't even read the the you know the the uh the flavor text on it and things like that so I think Lord a water deep 100 agree with you is

a great thematic mechanical mix they could have been done better and would be if it was done today absolutely so yeah it's a that's a great great uh point of discussion on this topic I think that we are just calling out for uh Lords of Water Deep revised Edition I mean it Hasbro you have screwed up enough at this point your salvation is in uh doing a revised edition of Lords of water Depot I mean 100 come on guys you're leaving money on the table here well man I could be talking to you about this all day but uh we do have to uh cut it at some point so let's end this with like what's on the horizon what can people expect over the next couple of months on the board game hot takes podcast do you have any previews of some games that you're really hoping to get on there any special episodes or Milestones the the next episode we're going to be doing I don't know exactly when this is going to release so you know this may be before that episode that the next episode that I'm really excited about is going to be we're going to cover two really hot new expansions one that I know you've already talked about which is um the the new expansion for dude Imperium oh yeah and so we're going to be covered bring that one of our hot take reviews where we play the game and immediately talk about it and the other is you Captain have it behind you but the new tapestry expansion oh geez you're covering that I wonder you know like yeah so I'm really excited about that this was our first opportunity to get one of these hot you know kind of pre-release reviews and so that

episode's gonna drop on I think it's February 20. you'll you probably know the date but I think it's February 20 is that is that embargo date exactly well I've never been part of an embargo so isn't it very special yeah very exciting so so really excited to talk about both of those expansions um I haven't even played immortality to do an Imperium one yet and I've been dying to get that played even though I have it here so that's going to be special for me uh beyond that we don't plan too far in advance our our show tends to be like what do we feel like playing this week and talking about so that's about the only thing I got to talk about I will say I think our format could use some freshening up and so I am hoping I got to talk with my co-hosts about this but I'm hoping to maybe put out a listener survey get a get a sense for where we should improve things get a sense for what we can enhance what's working what's not so I think we have an opportunity to to you know we've got a well-worn format at this point that's been pretty consistent for three years with slight adjustments and it's probably time to find out what uh what we can really do to get people excited and fresh it up a little bit sounds like a plan man well for everyone at home you know how to get podcasts you know how to find people you can find board game hot takes on anywhere you want to get podcasts and also follow them on Twitter because they put out a lot of information and are much better about engaging the audience than I am sometimes about this stuff I see so many intriguing polls and looking for

feedback and last of all make sure that you're going on to board game geek this is a podcast that deserves the golden geek nomination so thanks so much for coming onto the show Tim this has been a blast Jack thank you for having me I love being a part of it I can't wait till next time all right later man

Progress saved