Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 7 Board Wargames | With Designer Volko Ruhnke | Part 1

Transcript 48:43

Hi everybody, I'm Zib Blitz and welcome to another edition of Top Seven. Now in this series, we invite wargaming celebrities onto the channel not to talk about the top seven games that they have designed or worked on, but their top seven war games that they enjoy playing. And I'm happy to say that today's guest is none other than Voco Runki. Vo is an esteemed war game designer who has titles such as Fire in the Lake, Wilderness War, Nevski, Labyrinth, A Distant Plane. He's the founder of the coin series for counterinsurgency games so popular with GMT as well as the creator of the Levy and campaign series that has spawned a number of offshoot games as well. This video is sponsored by Noble Knight Games. Now, they're a board game retailer in Wisconsin that sell and buy new and used war games. So, if you have games you're looking to sell, they are a source for you to get some money or store credit for. But if you're looking for out of print games, and some of the games that Vocal will talk about in today's episode are games that are currently out of publication, they can be a great source for finding that odd game that is no longer available in your friendly local game stores. The link to Noble Knight Games is down below, and if you do use that link to make a purchase, thank you very much, as it does help out the channel.

Our conversation today wandered over a number of topics and went to considerable depth, so I've decided to cut this interview up into two pieces. There is a video link to the second piece at the end of this interview. And with that, let's get started. I'm joined now by Vocal Runi, who is our guest for today's show to do his top seven war games. Vocal, thanks so much for joining today. Hi, Mike. Great to be here. Great. Shall we jump right in and get started with number seven? Now, these are, just to clarate, these are top seven war games, historical simulations. And we're going to do a little bit of a twist here, too, right? It's going to be we're going to talk about the game and then we're going to talk about one play modification tweak that you actually make to the game when you play it too for many of them. Yeah. Sort of my adjustment to to taste. Um or others that I I've heard about out there, but ones that I do tend to use. Yeah. And they're not for all of them, but for for many of them. Yeah. Fantastic. All right, let's jump in with with number seven. All right. So I, you know, uh, when I do my favorites, when I think about favorites, I try to cover genres also, you know, so I've tried to sample them. So So starting with Crusader Rex.

So I so the the the Colombia style block games the way it that goes back what half a century or more you know and it's something that we we we know and we we accept and it's you know it's still it's so brilliant how simply with simple tools and clearly and effortlessly hidden information and attrition accounting for attrition are incorporated on these, you know, turning the blocks with the pips. And so this is the one, this is part of a trio that all involved the designer Jerry Taylor. Um, and this is of that trio, my favorite. And this is the one I think it's the block game I have played the most in my life. And that was true even before it was on Rally the Troops when when you know on Rally the Troops where I started to play it so much that it was one of the few cases in my life. This happened to me with Paths of Glory too where I'm like I'm playing this so much that it's like, you know, it's like wrecking my social account or whatever, you know?

I'm like I'm I've become obsessive. And so when that happens, I sometimes actually have to kind of go cold turkey and say, you know, so I actually like like purpose to stop playing this game because I was playing it too obsessively. Anyway, um so so another thing that the Jerry Taylor trio and a few others like Julia Caesar in this line from Colombia do in addition to using the blocks uh for limited information and easy attrition recording. Another thing that they do is they do incorporate action cards. So it is it is it is in a very lightweight way card driven and you can you can you know you can see the connections between the CDG genre and blocks that's melded in here. There's a few events. There's a ve you know one two or three actions from the cards. It's very light and not a not not a not oppressive. You're not really focused in on the cards the way you might be in a real CDG, but it's but it's there and it adds Yeah. Yeah.

Sometimes I call it card enhanced gameplay. Yeah. However, I would say here it isn't just like events that Matt your actions are driven by the cards. So in that way I think it's fair to say there's a card element. It's just a it's just very simple and and again and again clever because cards also determine who has the initiative in a way that works very well. And one thing that I drew from this one in particular is it uh the mechanics in Crusader Rex for castles and sieges and battles and the like actually influenced my own mental model of medieval operations involving castles and fortifications. So that shows up in the Levian campaign then. So that shows up in Levian campaign in terms of kind of what my assumptions are about these dynamics.

Um, you you'll see those similar dynamics in Crusader Rex, but presented in a much cleaner, more accessible way than I achieved in Levian Campaign. Well, you're going for a different thing with the Levy. And for people that aren't familiar with the Levian campaign series, what might be kind of a brief synopsis of of that series? So, so the living campaign series looks at uh medieval warfare at the operational level in different settings much like crusader crusader Rex does for the third crusade but with um more detail in terms of the feudal system and and command uh and also logistically um a and also somewhat tactically because there are different troop types that you're mustering. So there's a lot more uh emphasis on muster and I'm just give you an a quick example to contrast.

So Crusader Rex muster you're kind of drawing a random block from face down blocks or very simple you get a certain number and you you draw them and place them. Uh there's some some twists on that but very simple muster in Levven campaign you know is who are the lords and what what type of resources for their army are they are they drawing together you know this the levy part of Levan campaign there's there's more you know detail and flavor there. So you get a sense of how did these um these lords these leaders relate to each other socially matters for how they fielded armies right so that and then the logistical part where we are you know so in a typical block game if you you you're either in supply or you're out of supply and if you're you're out of supply you tend to like lose a pip something like that right very very simple logistics is in there but it's very simple in levian campaign you're actually um accumul ating and spending specific amounts of stuff of food which I in call you know proender or or or carts to move the move the food around that kind of thing. Yeah, I know for me too I I I like games that make logistics fun and make it a part of the game. And so that's one of the things I really like about I played a fair bit of Nevki and I've really enjoyed that where it's like the logistics are such a huge important part of historical simul just the history of warfare and most games simplify that to the point of and not that's a critique you you focus on certain things but it's yeah but but the idea that this is a

part of the game and it's fun and it's also a key determinant of who's going to be victorious in the end is really fascinating. Yeah I I'm the same way. I'm sort of fascinated and and more and more lately at the operational level in two things. Hidden information, uh, you know, reconnaissance and that sort of thing and logistics, you know, what's the stuff and how do we move it around and consume it. And the good news is while you're on Rally the Troops playing Crusader Rex, you can pop over to Rally the Troops Nefki and try that out. You don't even have to own the game or read the rules. You just play. Yeah. Well, I'm excited to try Crusader Rex now on Rally the Troops. I've not played it yet. So generally I've played it rules as written and of course if you're on Rally the Troops it's rules enforced. So so I do that. So I play it I play rules as written. It has a reputation that it's so it's the it's the um the crusaders and the the the the Christians who are already in the holy land and they're called the Franks in the game and then the sariss the Muslims who are you know counterattacking under Salah and it and the the reputation out there is that it's favors the Muslims right and so you can you can I have generally played it as is and I'm not such I'm actually I've played it a ton. I'm not a great player. So I tend to against an experienced player I tend to lose whichever side. So I don't really notice that balance question as others might.

But if you if you if you start to play it and you feel like gee the the Franks need some help, you know, you might start them with one or a couple crusader blocks already available. give them a head start on how quickly the crusaders arrive because the kind of the the the the clock on the the clock on the game is years. You're playing a certain number of years. But the the the the question is the C third crusade is coming. The Christians are there defending s uh the sarissens under Saludine are very you know potent and are attacking you and can you survive and hold out until the crusaders who are quite potent arrive from from England, France and Germany or some of those and they're kind of coming in as you draw blocks as they're mustering slowly in Europe. So they take a while to come in and how quickly that happens is a matter somewhat a little bit a matter of luck but it's also a matter of what casualties you're taking as the Christian. It's a very neat um simple connection, simply implemented but but but complex in in results, you know, sophisticated interaction between how well you're doing holding off the Sarissens and how quickly the crusaders because the crusaders, they don't want to jump in on a losing cause. You know, they're kind of coming to to to make something of it.

So So if you do better and you don't have as many casualties, you're actually more likely to crusaders anyways. So that's a key, you know, variable in the two sides. So you can you could you could help the Franks a little bit by giving them a couple of those crusader blocks starting out already. They're not going to be able to come in right away, but they'll come in sooner. Uh that that's what what I would do. That said, I have almost always just played it as written. Wait as is. Yeah. Should we move on to number six on your list? Okay. Very different. There's a genre called Hex Encounter you may have heard of. So I do want to I don't you explain what that's Yeah. And I will tell you although I used to and I grew up with him nowadays I do actually not play that many hex encounters. That's just my kind of just so people know what kind of my but this one is definitely that the burning blue uh by Libram Kumwood and uh from GMT games and uh it is about as you can see it is about the the battle of Britain uh you know the Luftvafa versus RAF fighter command and Spitfires and all that and so so what makes this one special so so Libra Kumwood who is a very experienced designer both from the board game and electronic games side is very disciplined also in terms of historicity. You know his model of what is historically I think the first integrated air defense system is very

loyal to to to the reality of it. That's number one. And he's very strict with who you represent. What do you actually control at your level? And so this is different from there are so many great um uh battle of Britain games but most of them basically do the battle of Britain right this is and this is or you're down at like down in flames you're at the tactical you know rise of the lofah you know dog fighting level this is at the operational level and it is at the kind of lower operational level and he calls this Lee Lee calls this raid scale R a d raid scale games and he's got several downtown which is which is also excellent which is um uh the Vietnam war over over North Vietnam rolling thunder and and linebacker. Um what he does is you are you're not running the battle of Britain, you know, you're running the you know the raids on Britain if you're the lufafa the raids on Britain for this morning. Here's your targets. Your targets are assigned. Here are your available squadrons.

you plan operationally how you're going to hit the targets with you need to with the planes you have available and on the RAF side here are your ready um fighter squadrons and it's up to you you know when to launch them where and you're guiding them right and if you imagine the control centers with the um uh uniformed uh um ladies with the long sticks pushing you know the markers around you're you're doing that and it actually even looks like that. So, he's really putting you in that command center. And uh and then from there, there's a lot of really cool design that it that you know, if I had read about it ahead of time, I said, "This is not going to work. It's just not going to be fun to play." But it is. I give you an example. So the Luftvafa player secretly draws these targets and there by the way all the there these little chits you can draw the targets from they are all actual historical raids like he tells you in there this raid occurred at 10:20 a.m.

on September 3rd, 1940. You know, I mean, it's right, but you're drawing them randomly. Obviously, the ally the the RAF doesn't know what's going to be hit this morning, right? Anyway, so you get these these these these raids and now you plot out like on paper um uh you plot out here's how I'm flying in. This is my way point where these bombers are going to turn. Here's where they're going to drop the load. Here's where they fly out again. All of that stuff. And then when you play, you're like on rails. You're basically as a low off player, you're just executing your plan against in essence, you've sent the aircraft up. You don't have control over them anymore. So it's kind The bombers are going to fall level of planning. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Right. Now, you have a little bit of control because you are are able to do some dummy flights over France to try to fool there's a there's deception in this um to try to fool the RAF and kind of wrongfoot them about where you're forming up to send your your bombers over. And then you have some control. you have some free fire, some some free um hunter uh messes that you can, you know, make some tactical decisions a little bit here and there, but for the most part, you're sitting there watching your plan unfold and your opponent across the table react to that because you're generally trying to fool them, right? You're trying to like I'm going to fly this suddenly turn here, you know, and now all your guys are flying over there and is it going to work? And so I thought, you know, that's not a lot of player interaction once I'm

there. It's to I love playing the lofafa because it's that aspect of I do the planning ahead of time, you know, and now I'm going to see can I fool my buddy, you know, and get him to send up too many planes or fly too many east instead of west or to to mistake my big swarm of mem for a bomber raid and engage and now I'm going to, you know, fight him and shoot him down because you can do that as well. And then there's a very original way of using cards. This is card assisted. I would say that Lee uses cards to determine what the RAF player knows. So the because the whole defense for the British is based on these radar sites, these early warning sites. And but the radars of course they're they're primitive radars compared to today. And you might, you know, you might see 20 planes that are actually 100 planes and you don't know exactly what altitude they are and so forth. Um, and it might be that it was just some air activity over France that was staged to fool you and they're not coming over at all, etc.

All of that is in there and these you're drawing card detection cards. The way that it does it is the lofa player, the RF player is getting the information, but the lofa player draws the card and the card will tell you what the error is in what the radars or the observers because they're also visual observers have detected and the lofa player, you know, is is then able to um communicate some like fuzzy information, right? I mean, it's all you're not making a decision. you're reporting what the card is telling you to do, but it's a s it's a very uh slick card assisted system so that the RF player gets a gradually crystallizing view of the raids coming in and it's a so it's a very cool experience from the RAF players because you get like these first initial indications and of course the battle of Britain is on you know that they're coming but is this real is this not is this big is this little um you know are they high are they low all that And as you go on, your detections improve gradually, right? Realistically, um, and it's just a it's a it's a model of So, I used to do air defense analysis as a living long long ago, you know, so I have the special this is right in your wheelhouse. Yeah, kind of. It is, you know, a different time, but yeah, different time. You know, downtown is a bit closer. Um, although also earlier, I'm not that old, but but a lot of the the fundamentals are there. And so it's very exciting to see it play out on the game table. And uh and and this is just

a it's just to me a you know a such a convincing um um explicit model. Uh and it's you know it's a serious it's a serious war game. You know it's a it's a heavy hex encounter game. And I will say when I first got it, I I read through the rules. I had to put it aside for about six months because I didn't it was so different at that time from from other Yeah, it sounds I mean the one I'm familiar with is RAF the Battle of Britain, but that's more the campaign of the Battle of Britain over the whole scope and span of it. This sounds more at that day level. The game is the day levels raids. And and I'll tell you, a day is a campaign. Actually like the second raid of this morning, you know, Tuesday morning's second wave. So it has a campaign element in it and you string it together. It's still operational. It's not tactical like down in flames, but it's raid scale. So it's like the lower, you know, and in that more narrow slice of level of warfare, Lee is very disciplined, right, about the decisions you're making, which just, you know, I I find so admirable. Um, and I then discovered, so I played this a lot face to face. I then discovered just playing it on Vassel is actually great because the first of all the Vassel implementation is great but then I discovered doing the Luftvafa plots instead of using different colored

pencils I just do them on uh paint you know in MS Paint and I make these beautiful you know here's your here's your attack plan you know and your eager and it's just and and it's it makes it even more because it's like a fun thing to plan out these raids, you know, even though you're doing it on your own ahead of time. Yeah. Well, I have I I knew nothing about that game, so this is fascinating to hear that. It's a completely different concept than I expected, and I'm I'm thinking too of games I've experienced, but there's there's not much I've experienced quite like that. And I'm picking up pieces of like the old Luftwafa game from Avalon Hill and some of the search elements of like Pacific Carrier Warfare. Yes. you can report false information or deceptive information or partially, right? And um fantastic. Yeah. And uh and if then if if somebody gets into the burning blue, then there's downtown Vietnam War and there's also Bomber Command, which is the British nighttime raids, you know, over Germany a little later in the war. Yeah. And so I do I do play with one um adjustment to to Lee's model. Um and it it and it it is that I have found over time that the RAF is a little too uh is a little under a little underpowered in my view and and there's one I think very clean um um adjustment that handles that sufficiently. So in

the game there are like large formations and small formations of planes and the premise is that large formations of planes have more durability and what's happening you know planes are being shot down here and there but the what's really important at this scale is dispersing a formation. If you disperse bombers they're not going to be able to bomb a single target effectively. If you disperse fighters they're not going to be able to do much either. And generally what would happen is a uh an RAF squadron would hit a Luftvafa formation. There'd be a bunch of dog fighting and when when you start dog fighting, you get spread out all over the sky into, you know, ones and twos and threes and so forth and then you just basically you've lost you can't be guided in on the target anymore. It's just a mess and anyways you're probably out of out of ammo and fuel and so you go home, right? So anyways, all of that is in the game. Um so that what's really critical is the disruption of the formations, right? But if you're a large formation, a large lofup formation, you can take three disruption hits before you're done. If you're a small formation, like just say four fighters or something or a half a squadron for the RAF, you only can take one hit. In between that are the the British squadron, I think they're like 12 aircraft represented, something like that in between those two. And as written, they also only take one hit. I think they deserve to have a durability of two, you know, so that the game play better. I think it balances the gameplay and it seems like a smoother curve of saying there are small and large RAF

units. The large RAF units should get more disruption hits than the small just like on the W buffer side. Right. Right. That makes sense. Yeah. Shall we uh shall we shift gears a little bit? Sure. And and we'll go for instead of jumping up quite to number five, I'd like to kind of go a little bit to your own designs. And the question for you is what was your hardest game to design? And then also kind of a follow-up, what was your easiest game to design? And you can define hardest and easiest as you like. Right. Yeah. That and that is I will say a tough question. Um I I I think I have to I have to for the hardest I have to split that into two. Mhm. Um because it depends on kind of what part. So I find and this may show in the quality of my work. So this is probably not a big surprise to people who know any of my games. I find solitire design to be extremely hard. Uh and and and I don't know if it just inherently is hard. I suspect it is or if it's just my, you know, particular mind set. And I did I I'm I'm kind of proud of the fact that when I was doing solitire bots to replace players, there was not a lot of that kind of thing already on the market. So I'm talking here about LA Labyrinth and then then the coin series and um there had been of course solitary games going way back and John Butterfield being the master of that and

then and then he so he has that capacity. He can do, you know, a Battle of Britain game that you can play two players and you can play it and all and you can play the RF and you can play the lif and it all works. I can't I can't do that. So when I did Labyrinth it was, you know, I'm interested in the two-player game. That's why I'm doing it CDG and uh that's what I was thinking. And it was Gene Billingsley who said, "Well, if nobody wants to play the terrorists, they have to be able to play the the US. that play the counter terrorists, the the good guys against the solitary, you know, if you've got the guts to design that vulo and I said, "Okay, I have to set that challenge." But I didn't know what I was doing. You know, I just kind of whipped up my little, you know, pencled out a sort of a here's a flowchart for what the jihadists might reasonably do and I put it in in the box and that was that. And Abyss, I think, is was the hardest for me in that regard.

Not so much the main game, the four player game, which I think to, you know, I fell into place fairly readily for me, but I had the ambition there. If I can do it for with with one extra one, you know, replacing one player by gum, I can do it to replace three players in in Abyss. So, you can play Andy and Abyss and if you want to, you can do it alone as if you're playing four different players and they're all going to be run by these flowcharts. Okay? And that but I was on my own. I mean, I didn't have at that point anybody helping me. How do you do this? And that was a thing being on their own. Later on, we did a lot more of them, of course, and they, I think, got better and better and and now they're totally different than they were back then, and they're much better using cards instead of flowcharts, etc. But that was all with other people either working with me or taking it on their own and doing things smarter than I could back then. This was really me, you know, and I'm like, well, the FARC is going to do a lot of marching around in Antinibus. How do they how do I march guys around, you know, in a realistic way? That took a lot of sitting and and that's also the first coin counterinsurgency game as well. So, you got system and the solo bots on top of that. That's a monster design. And not just designing those mechanics for saltier, but how do I communicate that?

How do I represent that on a player aid? What should the flowcharts look like? What should the cards do to amplify that? how do I explain it in the rules and not have it be this massive amount of rules text and so forth anyway and and I think it was like partially successful you know and that's the thing that if if I'm not succeeding fully and and and and reasonably happy with it then it must have been hard right so I think it was okay and people have used these bots and what what it did though was it started that collaboration labyrinth and then especially play and Abyss where people got interested in how do we do this better and it got better and now it's like it's expected like I can't you know if I do coast watchers it has to have solitire of course you know because everybody does solitire systems for you know well back then it was kind of you know it was it was it that expectation wasn't necessarily there I just kind of took it on as a challenge and did the best I could so that's Indian in terms of the overall design the other one I would mention is Nevski which not coincidentally is also the first in a series and the issue there. So I'm doing a lot of new things that are departing from anything else I'd done or anything I almost anything I knew I I was stealing some ideas. We can talk about that in a bit. Um in fact we will. Um but I was also on my own you know it was again where with Andy and Abyss when I was doing Andy and Abyss the core design I had Joel Topin as my developer and he

had developed um uh Labyrinth with me and of course Joel is a talented talented designer in his own right as well as being a talented developer. So I had a lot of help with Andy and Abyss and how we would do the core game from Joel. So Oneski I really was on my own. I didn't know like a lot of Russian war gamers that I could go out and I didn't know any um you know Tutons who had lived on the Baltic frontier. You know I'm reading the sources. I'm you know I I'm I'm I'm not a professional historian and I'm doing the best I can to think well how did this work? you know, how did warfare at the operational level on the Baltic frontier in the 13th century work to then, you know, um translate that into war game mechanics, right? and and there I'm I'm I'm very proud of not only um how it came out um but how it was received that that I thought this was a real specialty kind of you know who besides me cares about operational level warfare on the 13th century Baltic frontier you know it's kind of like insurgency and counterinsurgency Colombia you know what war gamer cares about that right and it was but it it it it had a great I thought for me surprisingly good reception surprisingly wide reception and of course now it's stood the test of time where we have again after that once I had done Nevki then other talent comes

in and we can go in new directions and it becomes we've got the whole levian campaign discord I mean there's just a community now of developers designers play testers you've got a whole neighborhood really to work with now which is so powerful you know and so Discord is such a wonderful medium for that kind of collaboration and and and we've now done things like Plentinet from from from Paco Gradia and soon to come out Seljuk you know from um Justin Fisino and I am I mean I was involved in those you know but they have solved problems in in new ways uh that make those better than Nefki right we're getting better as as we go and so that's easy for me Yeah. Hard is that first step alone, you know, into the abyss.

Yeah. And what about your easiest one? Is that is there So along those lines, I you know, I was thinking about that. Um what tell me if this surprises you. Fire in the lake. Yes, absolutely. Because to me, when I hear of um so maybe it's just a naive conclusion I'm drawing, but you know, when people talk about coin games, um people often mention how much they love Fire in the Lake. They often mention that it's one of the more challenging coin games to play and learn. Uh its complexity is perhaps a level higher than some of the other coin games. At least that's my perception of it. So when you mentioned Fire in the Lake as being the easiest, it seems they're contradiction there. Wouldn't a more complex game to design be harder be more of a a grind to put together? Yeah. And so so and the answer to that that is all of that help that's involved. Okay. because this is now volume four. Yeah. And volume two um you know I I uh I already had a you know a co-designer and I had somebody helping with the bots and so forth and so on. Then volume three this is now I'm going to focus on volume three of discipline plane because it's very pertinent to the ease of doing fire in the lake. So volume three of discipline is about Afghanistan you know round up to 2013 but modern insurgency and counterency in Afghanistan and for that among all the other help I had my co-designer Brian train who is you know to me the premier

designer of internal wars insurgency type war games so he's my co-designer and he picked the topic I mean I told him I said do do a game with do a coin series game with me, Brian. You can pick whatever insurgency you want. He said, "Okay, we're doing Afghanistan." I said, "Okay." So, so, so that makes that very, very easy because I don't have to have any expertise on Afghanistan. If somebody, you know, questions something, I say, "Well, go ask Brian, you know." So, it's very easy, right? Um and when we work through how the uh factions interact and particularly the the partnership between the coalition, the external expeditionary counterinsurgency and the government of Afghanistan, the domestic counterinsurgency. You think about that relationship as a you know a bad marriage. We worked a lot of that out in a distant plane. We get to fire in the lake now. I've got you know secret weapon not so secret Mark Herman.

Mark Herman, who who had read and forgotten more books about the Vietnam War than I even had heard of, okay, who had been wanting to do a Vietnam War war game for decades and not gotten around to it, you know, and here we now we're going to do it as coin series. And I think the the model that we had in the in the coin series and in for a discipline applied very well. Like we didn't have to change that much. Like I would say to to Mark, okay, here's how it worked and it isn't plain. You know, there's the government and they do this and the coalition, they that here are the victory conditions. And Mark says, "Yeah, that's like the US and uh and the South Vietnamese." And it it fits. Why? Because it's another US-led expeditionary counterinsurgency. And in Afghanistan, we're rediscovering all the lessons that we've learned in Vietnam, you know, and so it was easy to kind of back fit those mechanics and have them be loyal to Mark Herman's model, which is a highly credible mental model of the Vietn War. Right? So, we had that plus we have GMT, we have Gan saying, well, the coin series is successful. Mark Mark Herman's this is a Mark Herman co-design. Mark Herman's name is going to be on the box with Vulco, you know, resources, right? So, so he's, so you know, we were like, "Oh, we could do some more events because Mark is just thinking of, well, there's this event, there's that event. You can do all these cards." Like he would think of what these event cards would be. And I then

kind of took that me that interpretation of the importance of this thing from um from Mark and I kind of engineer and I did the under chassis sort of how do you engineer this into coin you know mechanics and text right so it was a good rhythm in that way and Jean just said well if you want to have 120 events go ahead you know whatever we'll like oh great well we can add another 30 events and that's easy you know if it's kind of like life you know if you have a lot of money everything's easy I I find you know you less money, everything gets harder, you know. So, same thing here. We had we had the resources from the publisher. I had, you know, you know, arguably the most, you know, influential war game designer, you know, working now, working with me. And I had all that fundament previous volumes, including uh, you know, an expeditionary counterinsurgency in a distant plane that was informed by Brian Train. So, you know, so the Brian Train Spirits is in Fire in the Lake as well. You know, a perfect confluence of resources and design and experience all coming together. That's fascinating. I would never have guessed that. And if I had and if I had failed at that, I wouldn't even be on your show now, would I? You know, I mean, I would be terrible. Of course. Well, it's obvious, you know, so many people mention it as being, you know, their favorite game or one of their favorite games and just or the, you know, of the coin series that's read so read so many accolades. Often when you ask what's your favorite coin game, people mention Fire in the Lake. you know, it seems to always float to the top of a number of conversations. So, clearly came out a great success. Yeah.

And of course, the um the US involvement in Vietnam, uh I I I mean, it's just such a fascinating, rich, well doumented, yeah, topic that people are, you know, that that that that our community of gamers is interested in. So, it's got that going for it as well. Vietnam, Mark Herman, GMT Games. Yeah. You don't like that? I mean, who doesn't like that? And it adds, I think, the political aspect of the the war, too, which is something that's harder to model in a traditional Hex Encounters numbers based game. And I will say I will say this, I think I think I learned a little better how to do that. I like the way Fire in the Lake does those political relationships a little better than the way a distant plane does. And that that's no knock on what we were doing in volume three. It's just I try to learn as I go. And so there were some I thought rougher edges in volume three that I had a chance to smooth with Mark in volume four in Fire in the Lake. And so I also think because it's a later volume, it does that better. But that kind of design refinement is not so hard. You know, it's again, you've got the great fundament. You're just, you know, you're just tightening a few bolts, right?

Yeah. The the the iteration is easier than the initial Yeah. surge of energy to get the thing going. That's it. All right. We jump up to uh number five on our list. 765. Yes. Angola. All right. So, Angola, here we go. Um, so this is just a monument to me, a monument to innovation. Not just because of what's in it today, but this is this design is from, you know what year this design is from? What would you guess? Do you know? 1999. 1988. It's that old. It's that old. Ragnar Brothers. And it was old. I didn't know it was that old. Yeah, it is really old now. And and you got to think of the 1980s and war games and like what topics were we doing, right? World War II, American Civil War, Napoleon, you know, um there isn't that much. And here's one on the the first year or so of the Civil War in Angola, 1970. So, it's not being done by a big house. Uh, it's being done of a it's not a very good-looking game, I have to say, but it's I would say a cult follow. And that was it. It was really notice for what was in it. And then thank you

MMP for doing this for produc in a beautiful you know to people. By the way, the counter art for this, you know who did it? I do not know. Lee Brim Kumwood, Burning Blue designer. He actually did the counter art and some of the card art counter and card art in Angola and it's great. It's just awesome. Anyway, so we have this oddball topic from an oddball publisher uh little known and it does some certain things so extremely cleverly and well that it is a crime that nobody stole from this design for so many decades until I did.

Um so one thing that so so so let's this first of all the topic Angola so this is a cold war cockpit right this is um the Soviet block and the US block and they're fighting the Soviets mainly via the Cubans um the the the the western the the free world block South Africa and you CIA and others anyway so they're battling back and forth and you kind of think about Think of it like Twilight Struggle as the context and Angola or some other low stability like a one stability I think right spot and the two players are like each one's like I want I need to control I need to control Africa so I'm going to put in a little more here a little more influence whatever um so that's what's going now take that idea in Tros and you're zooming in to operationally well how does that play out on the ground in that country that's Angola. The Portuguese are just pulling out. So it's the deolonization has happened and now all of the rebel factions are going to vive for wherever they stand after the war with Portugal.

Wherever they stand on the ground on map, they start vying for control of the country because they've been supported by these opposing cold war blocks and it becomes this cold war context contest. Okay, so that's in the game design and it says great great topic for uh game. This is a this is a four-player game, but it's 2v2. It's two teams, right? So you have the u the the pro-s Soviet factions and the pro-western factions and they're battling for the future of Angola. Okay, but four players that gets and and it's just really interesting rules for team play. Again, very innovative. But a cool thing for for for gameplay is that the premise is that neither side neither Moscow nor Washington are really that interested in Angola, right? They don't really care what happens to the people of Angola or to governments Angola. What they care about is not losing Angola on their watch. Okay? So that means if one side is losing and it looks like the other side is going to lock in control of Angola in in in in uh in Twilight Struggle terms then the other side kicks up the aid kicks up the covert aid.

Okay. So, so that you get like well you know we don't have to win Angola we just don't want to lose right so give us some more tanks or something right so that so so now think about that from game play you've got this tug of war going on you're battling for the different towns and cities and one side just and start other side oh you handy you know, you get the the cool units or whatever coming in and there so there's this historical selfbalancing mechanism, right, that keeps this civil war going. And in fact, of course, civil war goes on for years and years and years, right, for for that reason. So, it's it's also a kind of a cool commentary on the effect of the Cold War on these postc colonial internal struggles, right?

Well, I know it's showing up. I've seen it at, you know, conferences still and that's why I thought it was new. I knew it was an older game, but to go back that far in time, you see a lot of people I mean, when did MMP redo it? Let's see. I don't see the year on it, but anyway, but yeah. So, so re re 2012. 2012. Okay. Yeah. Great. So uh like Andy and Abyss you know we start it kind of you can see this door opening on different regions and how interesting the stories are that we can tell of these various underrepresented conflicts and this is one of them. Yeah. And so here's another really cool thing about uh about so you're so there the the idea is we're busted up in these factions. We're scrambling in the first months of a new civil war. We're shifting instead of being attacking the colonial overseer who's pulling out, we're attacking each other. We're scattered over the map wherever we happen to, you know, the war that left us. So, you start with this cool random situation at the time. And we're not really very good at this. Um, right? We're kind of fi finding our way.

We're just starting this new war against each other. And so our coordination between partners is not so great either. So there a lot of rules that have to do with how do the two players on each side work together. There's limits on kind of what you you know what you're communicating. And also there's a command and control system that limits how effectively you can plan what you're going to do in the coming turn. And uh what it what what it's called in Angola is column cards. So you have some cards, you play a certain number of them, but you basically ahead of the turn, you're secretly stacking them into a little deck and you select which ones. And then you've got columns, units A, B, C, and so forth. And you're going to stack this these column cards, and you're going to flip one up when it's your turn. And it's going to say column A. M and all you can do and all you will do on your move is you can move column A or nothing.

So first of all, as we're going around the four players, it makes it really quick, right? Everybody together plans their turn, stacks it, right? And now when it's your turn, you know, don't you, you know, don't you're not moving tons of units all up and down the map. Column A can move now if you want. Do you want to move or not? And that's and you move it. That's an attack, too. It's it's it's very very quick and simple. Um, but what happens is, of course, if I've put down seven cards and I get to my fifth card and sixth card and I flip over column A, the the the situation operationally on the map has totally changed. I'm locked into that plan, right? I'm not locked into what I do with column A, but it's column A's turn now. And right now, column A, well, column A got destroyed or or column A is um garrisoning an important city that is now under threat that wasn't before and can't move. It's got to stay there and whatever. Anyway, so very quickly your plan fails to survive contact with the enemy, right? And it's very vivid in this very simple, quick, evocative, powerful column cards planning mechanism. You know, like you think modern Euro games, there's a lot of like we're planning out different moves and there's like So, this is a 1988 historical war game planning mechanism that works beautifully that as far as I know, nobody stole until I did it.

Nebky, right? You stack all your lords together and then like you get halfway through your turn, it's like I don't want this guy to move anymore. But it's like, well, exactly. Right. So, and they have some maybe little twists on it that are not an angle or whatever, but it's the same thing. It's the same idea. That's where the idea comes from. I call them command cards. And here I'm not trying to tell you in Nevki um about what are the difficulties of coordinating a civil war in the third world when you know you you're just starting out um as a faction within an you know, within a larger movement. I'm saying it's the Middle Ages. You don't have radios. you do, you know, councils of war maybe or you exchange some couriers. And by the way, this is not a rigid military hierarchy.

This is a social system. There's a lack of trust between lords. You have your own fftom and the coordination is rough, right? And so I basically borrowed the same mechanic from Angola to bring across that inflexibility um of communications and command and control. um in the medieval operational context and I think it works works works very well anyways in Angola it's just delicious and and and uh and you know folks need to try yeah I this is that was a great the detailed look at it I hadn't I was not aware I know it's fantastically popular at conferences people love to play it popped up and and I have talked about a fraction of the cool innovative stuff in that game and it's not overroought I mean it's all simple rules. It's very accessible.

There's just like everything in it is like, "Oh, that's cool." Yeah. Yeah. Thanks everybody for watching the first half of this interview. I'll put a link to the second half as soon as it's ready right here. Have a great day.

Progress saved