10 Games At Essen 2026 That I Was Disappointed By
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from BoardGameCo, and it's time for our third Essen video. I've done two of these already. I've done 15 games, five this fifth five this plus another five on top of it. 15 games I recommend you check out at Essen based on games that I've tried, enjoyed, and recommend. Then I done 15 expansions, some of which I've played, some of which I haven't, but all for a games that I like and recommend. And now it's time for this one where I'm going to be going over 10 games from Essen from the Essen list of games that are at Essen that didn't work for me and why. It's only 10 because honestly, I couldn't really get to like, you know, 15 without just trying to find tiny games that no one really cares about in the first place, which is not quite as exciting to be like, "Hey, you know that game that most people didn't think was that good? I also didn't think it was that good." This is not as exciting for me. So, we have 10 games to go over today. Before we do, first of all, I get these lists over at BGG. They have their Essen Spiel list over here. You can go ahead and filter, sort, do all the various things. I've gone through all 1,300 of these games to bring you the four videos that I'm doing. And number two, this channel is sponsored by All Play. Uh All Play has a bunch of games at the show. They have 14 games of their own at the show. And in keeping with what I've done for the other videos over here, uh in each one I kind of said my All Play expansion, my All Play most recommended game. Uh in this case, I'll give you the my least favorite from these was uh La Chocolatola over here.
It was fine. It was a I cut you choose kind of thing. I wasn't super impressed by that one. It was It was fine. It was okay. The others over here I think are much better. Enchanted Ivy, Mountain Goats Legacy, Container have to play to see my opinion on that one. Grunts I think is great. Uh but that's going to be uh All Play over there at Essen Spiel. With that, I do have these ranked in order from least disappointment to most disappointment. And we are going to start with number 10, which is the one I am least disappointed by. This is Engebe from Board & Dice. Honestly, there's not a lot wrong with Engebe. I just think I think the level of hype and excitement around the game is just a mismatch to my own personal feelings to it. I I mean, it's 7.7. It's a good game. It's not like, "Oh Oh gosh, the best game ever." But it's a solid game. I think it's sold out at Gen Con, if I'm not mistaken. And I I I think it's fine. I think it's good. There's nothing wrong with it. Well, there's one thing wrong with it.
It's a very intricate system that, especially a few plays in, really pays off as far as how it all connects. I think they did a really good job with that. But, I do think that it's too much rules teach and components relative to the experience you get out of it. That was my biggest complaint about it. I think that the game is too The game itself is actually not long. That's not the issue. But, it's a 2-hour game that the the rules teach alone is like 45 minutes, even once you're teaching it for the second or third time. It's not just about, you know, your first teach as a as a teacher. Even once you get up to speed, there's just too many things to go over. And then the components are a lot. And the experience you get out of all of that was a good enough experience. So, again, not a bad game by any means. There's a reason it's my number 10 over here, my least disappointing of all of these. But, that's going to be entry from Board & Dice. Coming up for number nine, we have Colosseum: the Grand Spectaculum from Fantasia. This is another one where, again, it's not super disappointing, because I mostly got what I wanted or what I thought I'd get out of this. I played the original Colosseum, or at least I should be more specific. There's the original Days of Wonder Colosseum, then there's the TMG Colosseum, and then there's the Fantasia Games Colosseum. I played either the TMG or the Days of Wonder. I honestly don't remember which one of those I played. And then I played the Fantasia one. The Fantasia one is easily the best one, because I think it's one of the original two. There's not much gameplay changes. Colosseum: the Grand Spectaculum has a little bit more cleaning up, small changes to quality of life, things like that. And it's definitely the best game, both in terms of the component the components, the table presence, small tightening up of the gameplay. Overall, it's a fine enough game. As you build your spectacular, you know, events, trying to slowly slowly but surely across multiple rounds, win more, so you can get more money, so you can then invest in more and more acts, so you can then have a better payoff across the rounds of play. All in all, it's a solid game that does
everything everything that I expected it to do. I just think that it is an older title that, to me, felt a bit more like an older title. We have Duel of Melok over here. This one is only as high as it is, as opposed to as low as it is, because I still think Expeditions is a fantastic game. And if I'm playing this as the Expeditions player, I'm having a fun time. Jewel of Mellac from Stonemaier Games, if you didn't know, is basically a Scythe meets Expeditions. They take the two games and they merge them together. You need Scythe and you need Expeditions. That's not true. You don't need either. I lied. I I'm mistaken with that. You don't need Scythe or Expeditions for this one, but if you have components from Scythe and Expeditions, you can make it more variable uh to mix up the gameplay experience more. As it is, it gives you a Scythe faction in the box and an Expeditions faction in the box and then you can mix whatever other components you want to improve the gameplay, but you're playing on a shared map and one player is playing as the Expeditions player and one player is playing as the Scythe player. I believe you can also play as Scythe as a Scythe and Expeditions as Expeditions, but I haven't done that. Uh for me, all this game did is made me want to play Expeditions. It didn't make me enjoy uh Scythe more. It didn't make me enjoy the hybrid. Do I Did I walk away from it feeling very like impressed by the game design? Absolutely, I did. But I think the target audience for this is someone who really likes Scythe and really likes Expeditions and wants to be able to play the two together. For me, as someone who is okay with Scythe and loves Expeditions, I'm just an I I usually think it's actually the reverse, by the way. But for me, personally, I thought this was a fine game that I'd rather just play Expeditions. We have Night at the Zoo from Capstone.
Night at the Zoo is designed by Peter Hollek. Uh Thomas Hollek, not Peter Hollek. Thomas Hollek. Uh this is a game that is basically going to have you trying to corral your animals back from being lost in order to get them into your zoo. You're going to be doing that by drafting various tiles that will go into your grid on the zoo as well as being discarded to move your animals. You're trying to combine the placement abilities of the tiles and the spots, the remaining tile left of them the round, as well as the tiles you draft in order to most optimize which animals are going to get to your zoo and how. And you also have the variability of different animals every single game. To me, my biggest issue with this one is I felt it was too complicated to be a light gateway game, as too like thinky, too much like trying to min-max everything to be a light thinky filler game, and then too too uh too light to be a game that I'm going to pull out and play at game night. It felt like a weird spot where I just don't see where I would actually table it. I liked some elements of the design, but I was not super impressed by it, uh which is a shame cuz like post Gen Con, there was a lot of buzz around it, and I just don't think it's for me. Ringo is an upcoming title. Again, there are a few of these that are prototypes that are not yet available. I think, uh, you know, uh, Coliseum, Ringo, and I believe one more later on the list is a upcoming not yet available. But, Ringo from Paverson Games is one that unfortunately, I was really excited for this one and didn't like it quite as much as I was hoping to. Again, like many of this list, it's not a bad game by any means, but I just think that as much as the intricacies of the game design, the decision space you're making, I can see all those things, I just didn't feel the uh satisfaction of pulling off clever moves ever really hit me in the game. You're basically planting various trees and trying to time when those trees are going to grow versus when you're going to harvest them as you build into your own tableau, building various buildings, gathering more samurai and workers to go
ahead and help you take more and more actions as you place a variety of different things down into your board. There's different ways you can build out your personal tableau. Overall, everything about the game works. If you're just looking for the, you know, a game that checks all the boxes mechanically, everything works great. I think they did a great job at that, but I never felt particularly cool as I played. I never felt that move paid off in a way that felt satisfying. When I'm playing a game that is this much level of thinkingness. Honestly, it's to a certain extent the same problem as That's the Zoo, but I think Ringo is trying to be a heavier game, and I think That's the Zoo isn't. But, the more time and effort I put into thinking how to make it all come together, I want to feel that sense of payoff, and when I played Ringo, I just never did. And so, it's one that I guess, uh, you know, I wanted to like more, and it was fine for me. We have Forage over here. Forage from Flatout Games is another one that, again, the biggest issue I have with this one is it felt like nothing really happens until the final rounds of the game. Which, don't get me wrong, in a lot of games like this, in a lot of, uh, flip and write games with cascading benefits, that's definitely going to happen where you have a lot of the payoff towards the end as the last things all come together, giving you that strong payoff, and everything just executing and cascading into other actions. For Forage, I just rather play a lot of other games that do things like this. I'd rather play Ganz Schön Clever, I'd rather play Kind of I want a bigger experience. There's so many different games that give you this experience. For me, Forage kind of it wasn't bad. Again, many of these games are not bad until you get to like the final two, I think.
I would actually consider batch for myself. Uh but Forge over here is one that I was really excited for, really wanted to like, and I thought it was fine. Arctica, another one that unfortunately did not work for me as well. Uh this is one that I tried several times because I I I first I felt that it was an issue where you need multiple plays. And with that 8.1 rating, although again, who's played it? It's available on BGA, so I guess you could play it there. Of course, play testers and all that. Uh but it's one that I was really excited for this one from this way. And then when it all came together, I think my biggest issue is it always felt like there were so many things you could do, and I never had a clear sense of direction as to what I wanted to do. Like, which things do I want to do? Which action do I want to take on the board? do I want to play? How am I trying to make this all happen? And I do wonder if it's simply too complicated that it requires, I don't know, 10 plays. I played this three times. Three times, and at the end of three plays, I was like, "You know what?
If three plays in, I'm not closer to getting that sense of direction and strategy, then I just don't think it's a game for me." There's a lot of moving parts going on here, a lot of parts on board as far as how you move the animals around, place them on various spots, move them around a little chain. There's a lot of card play that's going to be going on. Which cards do you play from your hand? Which bonuses do you activate when you try to go ahead and activate the various cards in your board which you're doing? How do you try to move your rondels and your gears to place things out? There's so much happening, and across multiple plays, I never got to a point where I was like, "This is the direction I'm headed." Usually with intricate games, I have that sense of I'm trying to do this, so I'm going to do that. I just never got that with Arctica, unfortunately. And again, I hope it's just a me issue. It could be a game that works for many others. For me, I just I I I could do stuff, and I could score. Like, I've won this game. I think two out of my three plays I've won. So, it's not that I don't know how the engine works. It's just that I don't get that clear sense as to what I'm doing.
I'm just doing stuff, and then the points kind of show up eventually because I'm doing things you're supposed to do with some degree of planning, if that makes sense. Number three is the Glasgow Train Robbery. This is one where again, I'm very happy to see the high ratings. I'm happy this works well for others. I think it has come up or come out yet already or is just about to come out, but the Glasgow train robbery from Salt & Pepper Games. I was so excited for this one. I was thought it was a very clever implementation. I love the art, love the components, the idea of working together to kind of uh plan your train heist from different aspects, uh different degrees of cooperation of how you can communicate and what you can do. Everything here, very clever, and I love the presentation. Ultimately for me, when I play this, and I only played it as a prototype, so I don't know any changes in the final game, for me, it just never fully came together. Ultimately, it felt like that you that most of the game really comes down to those last few rounds, and the rest of it is like the slow tedious setup only to see if you'll fail or succeed in the final rounds of the game. Again, it's one that I'm hoping it's just a me issue with that 8.0 over there. Assuming enough people are playing it, it probably is, but it's one that I really wanted to like this one. Uh Salt & Pepper Games put out some fantastic games. Uh some of their games have been incredible. Some of their games have been good. Uh this is one that I was more excited for, and then unfortunately I was disappointed by. Coming in at number two, we have Machi Koro Life over here. Uh this is one where again it's it's it's definitely one that I like less. Arguably, I like this less than the last one, but it's Machi Koro, and I never loved Machi Koro, so I wasn't as expecting that much from it. But when they announced the new version of Machi Koro, I was like, "I'm down for it. I'm always down to try Machi Koro." I like the dice rolling system of building up your tableau, getting more cards, rolling dice, gathering more things. If you like games like Space Base, Valeria Card Kingdoms, Catan, all those games, Bad Company, this is that kind of game,
and those games are generally fun. Getting stuff on other people's turn, usually fun. Machi Koro though has been one of my less favorite from those series in general, and while I was excited for Machi Koro Life, if anything, I think it's a worse version of Machi Koro as opposed to a better one. Just wasn't for me, unfortunately, and so this is definitely a strong disappointment. It felt like they replicated currency with like happiness or whatever you want to call it, but they didn't actually change the game, the heart that you're spending. Uh but the game didn't actually meaningfully change in any way, and the execution of all the ways the cards combine or do things just didn't feel particularly satisfying, even relative to Machi Koro. And then lastly, number one is Carcassonne Labyrinth. Again, I'm happy it's working for some people. This is from Ravensburger. It's a combination of Carcassonne and Labyrinth, shockingly enough, given the title. To me, I'd rather play this over Labyrinth, but I would not rather play it over Carcassonne. Carcassonne is a much better gaming experience. This takes Carcassonne and kind of takes a lot of the life from Carcassonne because you're kind of drafting tiles from a shared board, but you're putting it into your own personal display. So, you're building your own personal Carcassonne display, which removes the entire point and life of Carcassonne, which I was open to it. I was open to the idea cuz I heard that going into it and I was like, maybe they did it in a way that works, but they didn't. They didn't, at least not for me as a as a huge fan of Carcassonne. The the Labyrinth aspect was elevated cuz using Labyrinth to draft your tiles that go into your city, that to me was elevated from traditional Labyrinth. But, the actual Carcassonne element was just a much much much worse experience. Uh for me, I was relatively interested and excited for this one, and ultimately I I I can't see myself ever wanting to play this one again. Uh Carcassonne is a million times better in every way. There's so much good stuff about Carcassonne, and this was just a
elevated version of Labyrinth is the uh best thing I can say. Those are the 10 games on the Essen list that I was reasonably disappointed by uh considering uh what I was wanted in different ways. Some bigger, some smaller, but these are games that I definitely don't recommend, although they might work for you. In particular, Glasgow Train Robbery, Arctica, those have relatively high scores. Jewel of Mellok, if you're a Scythe and Expeditions player, even when a game doesn't work for someone, the question is why did it not work? So, for example, using Jewel of Mellok, if you don't like one or the other, if you don't like Expeditions or Scythe, it might be a simply a worse version to get you to play one of those games. But, if you like both of those, it may well be for you. Sometimes knowing what it is you like or don't like Colosseum, another great one. Colosseum is an example of if you like the original Colosseum, this is a better version. I'm saying that somebody who has played the original Colosseum. But, if you didn't like the original Colosseum, as I was kind of mixed on it, then maybe this doesn't do enough differently to change that. So, there's a lot of nuance into understanding why someone likes or doesn't like a game, and whether those reasons will work for you. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from BoardGameCo. Hope you enjoyed this video, and as always, I hope you have a good one.