Skip to main content
Loading video...

TDG: Cody Looks Back at His Top Ten Games of 2016

Transcript 20:16

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I once had a girlfriend who borrowed $100 from me. A few years later, she returned exactly $100. I lost interest in that relationship. Today ladies and gentlemen, we're going to go ahead and take a look back at my top 10 games of 2016.

All right ladies and gentlemen, we're going to go ahead and take a look back at my top 10 games of 2016. Am I still playing them? Are they still in the collection? Let's see. So, we're just going to jump right into it. Now, my number 10 from 2016 was Game of Thrones The Iron Throne. Now, Game of Thrones The Iron Throne was essentially a riff on Cosmic Encounter. It was an IP fantasy version of Cosmic Encounter. Now, I was never a big fan of Cosmic Encounter. In fact, I really don't care for it. If somebody suggested we play it, I'd be willing to play it, but it's nothing I would ever suggest. It's just not my cup of tea. And I love negotiation games, but something about that just made me, I don't know, don't like it. But, I actually kind of enjoyed Iron Throne and I couldn't tell you why. It seemed like they did tweak a little bit here and there. I barely remember the game, but I remember liking it better than Cosmic Encounter. But, critically, I did not hang on to it. In fact, when I moved from Texas, I played this game, I know, with uh my friends Eric and uh Clarissa and uh some of my friends over there, Clarence. And when I moved to Texas, I gave it to them because I just I I felt like, "Yeah, I I liked it. It was fun. I enjoyed it, but I just remember thinking when I gave it away, I don't know if I'm going to play it again." So, I gave it to them. This one's no longer in the collection. Haven't played it in years.

So, that is Game of Thrones The Iron Throne. That's from Fantasy Flight Games. That was my number 10. All right, my number nine, this is Doom the board game. Now, Doom the board game is a kind of a sci-fi dungeon crawler adventure based on the uh the IP, right? The the computer game. And I remember playing this game and really enjoying it. I remember, you know, it's a kind of a modular board and I I I like that, but you know, great minis, too. But, the thing that really stuck out to me that I really like is this does something that I really enjoy in games, and that is when games you never know whose turn it's going to be. And in that game, you never knew if it was going to be one of the heroes' turns or it was going to be a villain turn and the villains would activate.

The the enemies, the monsters would activate. And I really like that because that way you can't really prepare the way you want to prepare. You kind of have to be a little bit loose and flexible with what you're doing. And I really really enjoy that system. There's a lot of great games that do that, like 1775 Rebellion, which is an awesome game. That does that. I really really like that kind of game, that system in a game, that mechanic in a game. And this that one did it very well. I remember enjoying that. I had a lot of fun with it. I played it a few times, but again, this is I think another one I got rid of when I moved away from Texas. I just I couldn't keep them all. But, I remember this one hurt. Uh I uh when I moved to Texas, I gave it away. Uh this one hurt. I I I I really like the game, but yeah, I just I couldn't take everything with me. So, that is uh my number nine, Doom the board game. That also was from Fantasy Flight Games.

My number eight is Hit Z Road. Hit Z Road from, I think it was Asmodee, if I remember correctly. Um but, Hit Z Road was a Martin Wallace game. And this was a game that was kind of a post-apocalyptic road travel game. And you were moving along these roads. You're being attacked by zombies. They're kind of as far as I remember correctly, there's kind of a push-your-luck element to this game as well. I loved the aesthetic of this game. You know, like I say, it it it it almost had kind of a Fallout vibe where it was kind of this kind of post-apocalyptic but retro 1950s look to it. So, the game looked really cool. Um but I remember that that you know, rolling the dice and really enjoying it.

But again, this is another game that I just I think I gave this one away. I can't remember what happened to this one. I I I'm probably gave it away during the purge when I moved to Texas, but I I don't remember. And honestly, I don't remember how much I I remember we played it for the review and maybe once or twice after that and I don't know that I really invested in this a lot. And it's interesting too because I look back at it now and I'm thinking, man, I probably had more fun with Doom than I did with Hit the Road, but that's what I selected. Um Martin Wallace, he's he's done some stuff I've enjoyed, uh but he's he's not one of my favorite designers like he is for a lot of people. But I remember when I played this one, I I remember thinking to myself, "Oh, this is a Martin Wallace game I really really enjoy." But that was Hit the Road, that's my number eight, and that is from Asmodee, I believe.

My number seven is from a family of games that I really enjoyed. This was Legendary Encounters: Firefly. Now, I love the Legendary and Legendary Encounters games, and Firefly, of course, is just a tremendous IP. So, I was really excited when this came out, and I don't remember it it making a tremendous splash, but I really enjoyed it. Now, I still have this in my collection. And this is one I don't know that I would ever get rid of all things being equal. But I haven't played it in a long time. In fact, I think maybe the last time I played it was in Texas. So, it's been a few years. It's one I I was thinking the other day, I got to get out and play it because I love the IP and I love the gameplay here. Uh but I liked how you pick a crew member. All the players pick crew members and then the the the decks you choose from are the other heroes in the show. So, I thought that was a very interesting thing. But like all the great um Legendary Encounters games, you got these cards coming at you, you don't know what they are, you got to scan them that to see them.

Uh great great game. It I remember thinking it was really thematic, you know, the Legendary game is really thematic. I love deck building and I thought they did a fantastic job with it. So, that is uh Legendary Encounters Firefly. That was my number seven. That was from Upper Deck. My number six is a game called Conan from Monolith. Great fantasy adventure game based on the Conan the Barbarian series. And this game has to this day, I think, one of my favorite mechanisms of all time. And this is the river system. And the river system is you've got Conan and the heroes and then one player is playing against them and they've got the river. And the river is the system where, you know, you got to pay cost for activating units on the board or groups of units on the board.

But every time you activate them, you slide you you well, you take it from its lower cost and you put it at the end where it costs more. So, you can theoretically keep activating it, but it's going to cost you a lot more to activate it if it's at the high end versus if it's at the low end. So, it's just this great way of Oh, I want to activate that guy, but it costs too much. I love that system. It was later adapted into Batman Gotham City Chronicles, which is another really fun game. But I I still own this game. It's still in my collection. But again, this is another game I have not played for years. I got to get this one to the table again. I was I get This is another one I was just thinking about the other day. I'm thinking, I got to play Conan again. It's so good and I haven't played it for a long long time. But it is still in the collection. This is another one I really don't think I'll ever get rid of. It's just that good. I got to play it again.

Uh you got you got different sides of the board that you can play. Uh, as I remember there's different scenarios, but just the the way even the heroes have to spend kind of these energy cubes and stuff. It's just awesome. Love love love Conan. So, that is my number six. That is from Monolith. Now, my number five is a game that was actually designed for one purpose. It was designed to replace another game. And it on that level it doesn't succeed. But, this is my number five from Fantasy Flight Games, New Angeles. New Angeles was designed to kind of take the place of Battlestar Galactica. After Battlestar Galactica it kind of run its course and it had um you know, the IP I I was probably no longer available. So, they made New Angeles, which had a hidden trader mechanic in it, but it's a very different game. And essentially what it is is every round two players are making proposals. And then everybody's going to kind of vote on this proposal, but you can make deals and bribes and stuff like that. And then you enact the proposal.

You're in the city of Los Angeles, the cyberpunk. It's in the Android Netrunner universe. It's kind of an island now, Los Angeles, New Angeles. And you're just trying to administer the city, but you've got all these problems that are going on in the city. And critically one player works for the federal government and they are trying to uh, take kind of take direct control over New Angeles. But, it's a very fun game. This is a game though I have again I have I think Texas. I was in Texas the last time I played this one. But, another one I need to get to the table again because it's great. Not nearly as good as Battlestar Galactica. Don't get me wrong. And it didn't in any way approach Battlestar Galactica, but I still really enjoyed New Angeles quite a bit. So, that is my number five, New Angeles. That is from Fantasy Flight Games. My number four is a game that is um fantastic.

Uh, it's a game I'll tell you right now I am still playing Well, I haven't played it for probably a year or so, but I I love it. This is Mansions of Madness second edition from Fantasy Flight Games. Mansions of Madness second edition um, first of all, trumped the first edition cuz the first edition uh, one player was the keeper. Essentially, everybody was playing against the keeper and the keeper had to set up the board and it was a very intricate setup and if you screwed it up a little bit, it ruined the game for everybody. And what's cool with the second edition is it's an app. You just play with an app and that solves all those problems. So, that was really cool. But, this is one of the great Cthulhu mythos games where you are investigators, you're moving through a kind of a procedurally generated area on the board and you're finding clues, you're finding uh, you know, you're talking to different people. It's such a good experience. My wife um, we played this game several times and for a long time this was her favorite game. It was ultimately replaced by uh, My Father's War, but Mansions of Madness is just amazing. Such a good game. We really really enjoyed this game quite a bit. I love this game. Like I said, it's it's my favorite I did my uh, Cthulhu uh, mythos list. This was my number one on my Cthulhu mythos games. I love love love Mansions of Madness second edition.

So, that is uh, number two. You're sorry. Sorry, that is number four. Mansions of Madness uh, that is the second edition from Fantasy Flight Games. My number three is a game that was kind of a a cousin of another game that I absolutely love. Uh, this is from GMT Games. This is Talon. Talon is just a great science fiction space combat game. Essentially, it's like a hex and counter game, but your your spaceships take up the whole hex and they're like big hexes. And you actually write with a dry erase marker on them to create their power curve and you've got an impulse system. So, as you're you're activating them, different aspects activate um as you as you use them. And you're trying to steal initiative from your opponents, but you're attacking and you've got shields and you're trying to get through the shields and try to get through their armor.

And it's really just kind of a space dice combat game, but these are capital ships, and so they move and they've got kind of inertia. They take a while to turn. Uh it would The game actually really remind me a lot of like Star Wars: Armada, but where Star Wars: Armada you have the the minis and the huge setup. This one is just a very easy setup, very easy game to play, uh much easier game to get to the table than Armada, and a lot of fun. This is the younger cousin of Space Empires: 4X. In fact, there's a way you can play Space Empires: 4X and then distill the battles down to play a game of of Talon. I don't think I'm ever that quite am that ambitious, but it sounds like a fun thing to do. But that is uh my number three, Talon. That's from GMT Games. Now, I remember in 2016, early in the year, I played my number two and I was convinced it would be my number one game of the year. No question. This was going to be my number one game of the year.

But ultimately it got number two. And this is Star Wars: Rebellion. Star Wars: Rebellion is a fantastic game. An absolutely fantastic game. Incidentally, Talon is still in my collection. I still play it. I haven't played Talon in a while, but it's still in my collection. Uh Star Wars: Rebellion, of course, is still in my collection. Um it's been uh a little bit since I played The Last Time I had played Star Wars: Rebellion, but it is such a good game. I played this game many many many times. Now, my only caveat to that is well well, first of all, it's a game where one of you is the empire, one of you is the rebellion. And the empire is trying to find the rebellion's hidden base. So, there's hidden information. Now, the empire has this massive military, but it takes them a while to get around the galaxy.

Meanwhile, the rebels don't have much of a military, but they have got uh you know, these these missions that they're going on to perform sabotage and to try to take down the Empire through other means. Now, what is super cool here is you are sending all of your you know, the the you the Empire has characters like Darth Vader and Boba Fett and the Emperor. The Rebellion have characters Lando Calrissian, Luke Skywalker, Mon Mothma, etc. etc. And you are every round assigning characters either to move fleets or to go on these missions. And it's so much fun as you are trying to essentially play through the original trilogy of Star Wars. This is This is the OT in a box. It really is. This is like far and away the best Star Wars IP game I've ever played.

You know, I I I played a lot of good ones, but this is far and away the best. I really love this one quite a bit because you can take the the OT and you can turn it on its head. You can have so many kind of alternate history stories here. I played games where where Princess Leia got captured, taken before the Emperor, and turned to the dark side. So, you've got this like dark Leia Jedi that's out there trying to cause problems. Played games where Lando Calrissian became a Jedi knight. I mean, there's just so many fun different things. You can see the the Empire can build Death Stars and destroy planets and it's it's awesome. Really really love this game. So, that is Star Wars Rebellion which I still have. Haven't played it in oh a year or two, but I still love this game. And again, one I will never get rid of. This is my number two Star Wars Rebellion from Fantasy Flight Games.

All right, my number one, the game that ultimately dethroned Star Wars Rebellion. This was a game that Asmodee uh reached out to me. Fantasy Flight Asmodee reached out to me for this game that they were handling the North American distribution for. And my contact asked me if I wanted to play it and I said sure, but she goes, "Okay, you need to know, you really need to find eight players for the full effect." And I'm like, "Yeah, okay, well, I'll figure it out." So, they went ahead and they sent me Captain Sonar from Matagot. And I sat on it for a while because it took me a while to get eight players, but I finally got eight players. And the night we first played it, we played I think four or five games cuz the game takes 20, 30 minutes tops.

[snorts]

And we walked out of that gaming session just going,

we all had the biggest grins on our faces. Captain Sonar is a real-time team battleship type game. Essentially, you are two submarines that are trying to maneuver around a map, a common map, and you are firing at each other, you're shooting at each other, but you each have on each submarine you have four team members. They have different roles. You have the sonar man who's listening to the other captain give orders to try to plot a a course for where they you think the enemy is. You've got the first officer who's got to make sure that that that everything is functioning, that all the systems are functioning before you execute certain maneuvers and keeping the captain informed. You've got the engineer who essentially is every time you move something can potentially go wrong. And the engineer has to make the best possible decisions to keep that off. And then there's a certain point where you have to surface and try to circle your ship and and uh make it work uh so you can still continue without any more problems. But then you have the captain and the captain kind of has to collate all the information from the different stations and make decisions about weapons and when they're going to fire well, where they're going to move certainly, but also when and how they're going to fire at their enemies or drop mines on their enemies. It is such a good game. There was these moments in this game where if you're the captain and your sonar man says, "They're right there."

And your first officer says, "I got a green light here. I got a green light here." Engineer says he's good and you say, "Okay, we're firing a torpedo at this location." And you find out if they do. We the first game we played, and we told the you know, we're we're playing against the enemy captain, and we fired, and we got it, and our team just jumped up and cheered. We were so happy. It is such You know, you know, this is one of those games that seems it almost kind of transcends being a game and becomes just this magical experience, as stupid as that sounds. That's what it feels like. I love this game so so much. It is uh my original copy that I had, uh I think I ended up giving that to Ray? I can't remember. I gave it to somebody uh because it would the the box was kind of falling apart cuz we used it so much, and I ended up buying I was actually in Cedar City, Utah, of all places, and they had a copy that I bought down there.

Such a great game. I absolutely love that game, and I actually haven't played with my new copy yet, but I'm going to. So, that is uh my number one. That is Captain Sonar, and that from Matagot. All right, ladies and gentlemen, what do you think? Do you like these games? Do you not like these games? Are you still playing these games? Uh are these games that you think are still relevant and important here? Uh I should point out that Captain Sonar, they're coming out with a Star Trek version of that, just a four-player game, which I'm really looking forward to, so we'll see how that one plays out as well. But, I uh like I say, that's a great game. There's so many great games on this list, and some that frankly have been forgotten. I certainly don't play anymore. Well, I really hope you like this list, and I want to hear what you have to say, so please leave a comment here on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on Facebook, on X. Really, I want to hear what you think of uh these games.

Also, too, uh if you uh we Well, we would ask you to like and subscribe to this channel if you haven't done that. And you can also check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about military history and books on history. I post some of my lectures on there. Um it would mean the world to me if you would subscribe to that channel as well. And uh if you do really like what you see here, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, I got food poisoning from that German food truck. It's the worst.

Oh, that's out. Tell me we got weapons. TELL ME WE GOT WEAPONS.

YEAH, WEAPONS.

ONE, TWO, THREE. Definitely firing torpedo. DETONATING AT D6. YES. YES.

Progress saved