Skip to main content
Loading video...

A Curated Top 10 List - Produced by Tom Cohen

Transcript 28:05

foreign hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay today in the dungeon dive we have a special top 10 and this top 10 was produced by a dungeon dive Patron by the name of Tom Cohen so thank you Tom for your support uh this was a this is the second of the patreon produced top 10 lists and I'm not going to do them anymore because I have deleted that 20 a month tier from the dungeon dive patreon I personally just thought that I wasn't offering enough to justify twenty dollars a month so if you want to support the dungeon dive you can at like one three five or ten dollars a month you can go to the dungeon dive patreon and I really do appreciate it it makes all of this possible you know I'm still doing about 30 plus hours a week at the dungeon dive and I'm making a lot of progress on my game and the dungeon dive patreons the patrons are helping me get that game made by allowing me to have the time so this so This top 10 list is a top 10 curated list and it's a little bit of a weird thing so let's talk about that for a minute uh Tom and I we got together on zoom and we talked about some some topics he had some topic suggestions and

one of the topic suggestions he had was a top 10 kind of a desert island uh games and you know if I could only have 10 games what would I have and I wanted to modify that a little bit because I didn't want that to just be my top 10 favorite games you know if I was trapped on a desert island with only 10 Dungeon Crawl or adventure games I would pick my top 10 games so I wanted to imagine this list as being from the perspective of somebody paying me to curate a 10 game collection focusing on Adventure style and Dungeon Crawl Style game so you know if somebody some uh very wealthy game player came to me and say hey Daniel I want to pay you to curate a top 10 list what would that be and so to kind of move that away from just being my personal favorite games Tom and I came up together with some categories and then I came up with some other categories and so those 10 categories are as follows something with a narrative campaign something with an Overland map something with RPG elements something post-apocalyptic something science fiction something for the family something dark something small something with an old school Vibe and something unique so in each one of these buckets in each one of these categories I'm going to give you a few recommendations

and then I will let you know what my number one choice choices for this top 10 curated list so let's start with something unique something that a lot of people don't think about a game that often gets overlooked even by me sometimes as you'll see on uh these suggestions here so a couple of games came to my mind for something unique you know you want something in your collection that a lot of other people don't have or a lot of people don't talk about and I thought of something like champions of horror uh right here with the uh with the glare if you can see it behind an image there so champions of horror is a unique kind of game I've heard it been described as better Mage Knight if you can't believe that I know a lot of people really love Mage and I I am not one of those people and I really do like champions of horror also a game darkest night I've covered darkest night before I've also covered champions of horror Darkest Night is a game that I don't see talked about too often and it has a really cool kind of Co-op Vibe almost pandemic style but with a neat fantasy setting but the game I am choosing for something unique is Hand of fate or deals and that is the special edition from 2018 designed by brontos with art by Jesse Gillespie and Ian O'Toole now I'm choosing the special edition and I figured that if somebody was wealthy enough to hire me to curate a 10 game collection then they would also have enough money to track down

this special edition of hand of fate ordeals so it just comes with more stuff which adds more variety and more modes to the game play and it comes with the one mode that I like the most and that is the endless mode and the endless mode I've covered that before on the channel but it's kind of a rogue-like mode where you are just trying to survive for as long as you can moving from one level to the next so Hand of Fate ordeals is a deck builder but it actually feels like an adventure game and it looks it looks just absolutely amazing it has such a unique look a unique feel has unique mechanisms and there really isn't anything else like this you know there are games like Thunderstone advance and Thunderstone Quest and to me those games don't feel like adventure games at all there are games like um the living card game systems like the Arkham Horror card game but to me that's more of a lifestyle game not really a board game but I wanted to think of something thing where you could just uh you don't have to devote your entire life to the game it's just it's a board game you can set it up pretty quickly put it away store it all in one box and hey hand of Fate ordeals offers up so much you so many unique qualities that I don't see in a lot of games and that's why it is on this list okay so the next category is something with an old school Vibe these are anachronistic games games

that have fallen out of time and arrived in our modern day and of course two of the big ones in this category are League of dungeoneers and dungeon universalis both fantastic games uh League of dungeoneers is basically a kind of modern that's not it's not even modern it's kind of just a new Warhammer quest with some different systems going on and that will be hitting a reprint soon and then uh dungeon Universe Solace is basically a super advanced advanced hero Quest and that game is complete completely out of time right now and that has a lot going for it and tons of people like that but the game that I chose for something with an old school Vibe is dungeon Crusade finally released in 2020 designed by Roger Dearing now Roger during is a is an internet friend of mine we might be working together so I just want to be completely honest in our relationship but as time goes by I like dungeon Crusade more and more uh there just really isn't anything out there with a similar Vibe with its static boards it kind of feels like super hero Quest but it's totally Co-op and solo there are a ton of random elements events lots of things to do in in the dungeon from one turn to the next there is a ton of Loot and a whole Adventure game the Avalon Adventure board game that you play before the

Dungeon Crawl game and now with the lone wolf with the solo Crusader mode and with shorter dungeons coming the main issues that I have with the game are kind of being solved the game is way too long I usually play a third of a full game and I feel satisfied I play one Quest table so in a full game there are three Quest tables and each Quest table has three quests one main quest and two side quests I just play a game with one main quest best two side quests I truncate the leveling up where I let my Heroes level up in a shorter period of time and I allow my heroes to use more powerful gear before they level up and I have a complete satisfying experience when I play a game of dungeon Crusade like that so dungeon Crusade is my choice for something with an old school Vibe okay the next category is something small and you guys know I love small box games I talk about them a lot I have a whole dedicated playlist to small box games I am a huge fan of small box adventure and Dungeon Crawl games especially those that give a big feel or give a big thematic feel I think one good example might be something like fire of eidolon and fire of eidolon could have actually been a example in the unique game section just because I don't see people talking about it very often but it's a cool Dungeon Crawl game with a very strong pandemic Vibe and

then there is a game like escape the Dark Sector which is this science fiction kind of random encounter game and escape the Dark Sector is actually the advanced version of the game I am choosing for the small box category and that is escape the Dark Castle from 2017 designed by Alex Crispin Thomas Pike and James Shelton with art by Alex Crispin and my God that art it is so good this is a fantastic small box game all of the expansions everything for this game fit in that nice small kind of small the medium sized box if you ever see that giant stupid Deluxe box version and you think this game is a huge box game just ignore that that's one of the dumbest things that has ever been uh thrust upon the board game Community are these giant box games that that have a bunch of empty space and they're made to hold your your sleeved cards you don't need to sleeve all your games guys um but you had this game everything all of the expansions everything from that deluxe version fits in that small original game and uh Dark Castle is practically a party game and that's the way that I like to play it the most it's a great way to end a long day of playing more complex and involved games it's basically random encounter the game but you do need to work with the other players at the table to overcome the

challenges and survive it's got a fantastic black and white design that screams old school fighting fantasy Vibes so for something small I choose escape the Dark Castle okay now we're moving into something dark and dark can mean a few different things uh there are things that are Grim dark that are very kind of nasty and then there are things that are spooky but get under your skin for one recommendation in this category I would look at something like vagrant song I think vagrant song is a good choice for this and kind of an odd Choice it has an odd Darkness to it it's a cartoony Darkness but it is also effectively spooky and there are things about that game where after you are done uh going against a haunt or a hint is that what they're called a hint uh you will feel a little creepy because of what they represent I think that's a really cool dark and spooky game however my choice for this category is a game that I have talked about before and that is Machina Arcana Third Edition from 2019 designed by your eye billic um yeah I've talked I talk about Machina Arcana Third Edition a lot and it's well deserved it's a fantastic game it's such a great game it truly belongs in a collection like this it's a bold design with a great art and atmosphere uh the pulp style purple prose writing is

fantastic if you like authors like Clark Ashton Smith or a Merritt or Thomas legati you're really going to dig the the pros Vibe found in makina Arcana uh the game can be pretty demanding it's challenging there is a lot to learn and there are a lot of things for the players to do but it's also very rewarding adventurous and fun when I put myself in the shoes of the explorers in this game I start to feel a very real sense of dread and that's why I think it is such a great dark game okay coming up it's kind of like the opposite of that last category this is something for the family A light game and I don't just mean light and terms of mechanisms or in terms of upkeep or learning but light in the vibe that it gets and I thought of games like a glory second edition which is a really fun little Adventure game or games like horrified or stranger things the upside down uh maybe a game like seven moons there are a lot of games in this space and a lot of them are really good especially with this new kind of proliferation of high quality IP games that you can get at like Target and Walmart there are a lot of really high quality family light style games out there right now we're kind of in a golden age of this new kind of space of this this new kind of Gateway game space but for me the ultimate game in this group is Popper's ladder from 2019 designed by Paul Stapleton uh Popper's a

liner is such a Charming game and pure joy to play and experience the bright vibrant colors do a lot to create that mood but so do the various encounters that you have and the characters and the Pastoral setting it's an easy game to learn it doesn't take up a ton of time and it has everything that I look for in these kinds of games and best of all it fits in a nice medium-sized box so it doesn't take up a lot of shelf space uh poppers ladder really is a win-win-win all around and that's why it is something that I would recommend for the family weight category okay the next category here is something science fiction so I don't play a lot of Science Fiction games my wheelhouse is a fantasy but I love science fiction there just doesn't seem to be as many science fiction games in this space as there are Fantasy games so it just makes sense that I would focus more on Fantasy games but sometimes I will really crave a good Sci-Fi game and one example would be Star Wars outer rim with the unfinished business expansion and that game feels like a complete game now and it's super fun another would be Zaya Legends of a drift system it's a little light on the thematic qualities and flavor text and interesting encounters but it's got a great great space Vibe going on but for me for something sci-fi in in this top 10 list I would recommend Space Cadets

away missions from 2015 designed by Dan raspler and Al Rose uh Space Cadets away missions is just pure fun it's fast playing super easy to learn and teach a little long in the setup because of all of the hex tiles that you have to set up but um it's it's not too long it's it's manageable for sure it has amazing combat and and a dice resolution system where you get to choose extra cool things to do when you get multiple successes I absolutely love that it really makes you as the players uh feel like you are in control of these characters and the outcome um it's just so much fun I love the ray Punk theme this kind of NASA core these NASA men and women fighting Little Green Men from outer space just a classic 50s Golden Age sci-fi kind of thing and and I totally dig that it packs a ton of game into a single box and it's good for a long time hobbyists and families who want a little more complexity so for something sci-fi I choose Space Cadets away mission okay so uh kind of uh tan gently related to science fiction the next category is something post-apocalyptic I wish there were more post-apocalyptic games in this space but there are a few really good ones I think a couple examples might be Defenders Of The Last Stand and Fallout with both of the expansions uh both of

these are great kind of post-apocalyptic games that do different things uh Defender sometimes feels more like pandemic or more like a threat management or a tower defense Style game than a true Mad Max Style Adventure game but the theme is there Fallout needs both expansions to really shine but with both of the main expansions I think it's a really fun game but for me in this space a game that truly feels like a post-apocalyptic Adventure game is of course Fallen land from 2017 designed by Sean Cahill and John alondren and second edition is still crowdfunding it's coming out soon you could probably still uh pre-order it and I highly recommend it if you love Random Encounters if you love a flavor text if you love loot building parties of all kinds of crazy characters and you like rolling dice in the wastelands it just doesn't get better than Fallen land the games can be long but they have an epic feel and they always are engaging uh you're building up your home base recruiting people into your town building parties of survivors sending them out into the Wasteland to scavenge uh looking for vehicles all while avoiding mutants Bandits and radiation it's just this game gives me that post-apocalyptic Adventure feel better than just about any other game I

can imagine it can be super fiddly and there are a lot of rules however it has one of the best rule books I've ever read and great documentation so it really is just a no-brainer to choose Fallen lands for the post-apocalyptic group here oh okay next up is something with RPG elements now a lot of the games that that we love at the dungeon dive have RPG elements these are all kind of RPG substitutes yeah when we went to play D D and maybe our group get couldn't get together we would gravitate towards something like Talisman because it scratched a similar itch we had a character we had loot we had stats and we would go on adventures and a lot of the most of these games that I cover on the dungeon dive are like that but some feel a little bit more like an RPG um I think a couple games that I could have recommended were Destinies and mansions of Madness second edition now both of these games scratch that RPG itch mainly because of the app acts like a GM and so the players are just able to have the fun and not have to worry about running the game uh these games are huge hits with people whose only RPG experience is in the video game Space they are like video game RPGs on your table but for this category I wanted to choose something a little more traditional a game that you might play with people who have played D back in

the day but it's been a long time and they remember certain things about it and those certain things might be leveling up or Stat tests uh stories loot uh monsters that kind of thing and for this category I chose folklore the Affliction with all the expansions originally released in 2017 designed by Nick Blaine and will Donovan so let's get some caveats out of the way there are a lot of things going against this game the sessions can be too long the combat is not very exciting especially towards the beginning of the campaign when you don't have a lot of options the D100 system can be far too swingy especially when you are getting tiny little plus one or plus two bonuses this game really should have been a D20 system I'm not sure what they were thinking the balance for lower player counts is completely off and there is a lot of bookkeeping involved in playing the game okay so that's the caveats that's the bad stuff out of the way this game really does feel like an RPG in a box and one of the reasons why is with an experienced player who can act as the GM to house rule those issues away folklore easily becomes uh the the exact game that you want for your table for your players you can tailor it specifically for the kind of game you want with the adventure creation tool kit as part of that expansion you can easily run this like a full RPG and you don't have to change anything it has

everything you need to do that all of the stats and mechanisms for skill checks for leveling up for crafting it has Overland Adventures it has stuff to do in towns and expansive bestiary tons of map tiles for all kinds of different Adventures it has a deck of side quests a deck of Road Encounters of off-road encounters it has everything you need to really scratch that RPG in a box feel it can be a little frustrating because of how the good and the bad in this game conflict but people who really like RPGs are not afraid to tweak and house Rule and because of that I think the game works I have actually released my set of folklore house rules in a nice typed up version two dungeon dive patrons and I know people really like that okay so coming up next is something with an Overland map an Overland crawl and Overland Adventure game um I love Overland adventure games are probably my favorite kind of game I'm making one right now that I hope is a really good one uh a game like Touch of Evil or tales of the Arabian Knights or dungeon degenerates or fortune and Glory would all fit in this category and all of those would be great great recommendations however my pick for this top 10 is Eldritch Horror from Fantasy Flight games 2013 designed by Corey konetska and Nikki balance so this game along with a bunch of expansions uh Eldritch Horror truly becomes a globe trotting pulp Adventure game of the highest order it takes all

of the best elements from Arkham Horror second edition streamlines them just enough to make a difference adds some things removes some things and it's basically a recipe for adventure game Perfection it's got a ton of great art from the Fantasy Flight game archives it's got tons of encounters a modular like system for using expansions and it utilizes the pulp Cosmic horror theme really well now Eldritch Horror doesn't feel lovecraftian and that's fine that's something I talk about a lot on this channel and on my board my uh my book sister Channel all fiction is fantasy I think people put too much focus on Lovecraft when it comes to Cosmic horror when he was just another chain in the long here's just another Link in the long chain of cosmic horror that went all the way back to Ambrose Beers and is still being developed today so Eldritch Horror is far more pulpy than HP Lovecraft ever wrote it's more in line with Brian lumley's take on things and I think it's better for it so for an Overland Adventure game my choice is Eldritch Horror with a spattering of expansions and now the final category for today's top 10 is something with a narrative campaign so this is one of the most popular sub-genres of the adventure slash Dungeon Crawl genre uh this uh Niche is super popular in the gaming world right now people love their

narrative Campaign games games with hundreds of thousands of words to read or listen to I am not one of those people I don't typically play a lot of very scripted narrative Campaign games but I do recognize their qualities games like gloomhaven or Frost Haven jaws of the lion Madara oath sworn these are the games that most people who like these kinds of games absolutely love and put in the upper tears I think one game that I could have chosen for this category for me as a suggestion to somebody would be role player Adventures it's the one I almost picked it's a pretty fantastic game with a great feel but I have one one issue with it that I just have a really hard time getting over and that is the main theme of The Narrative and how your characters the player characters are working for the man I just can't get over that I don't like being these up like police in this world and so that automatically makes whenever I have a choice to work against the man in that game I automatically choose that choice and I don't even have to think about it so it kind of limits the kind of overall Adventure that I can have in role player Adventures I wish they would make that game and completely re-theme it to where you are just some mercenaries or some Bandits or something I don't know I just don't like working for the man especially when a man is some royal king or something but the game that I chose for this might be a

little controversial it is I believe the newest game that I will be mentioning today and that is a game that I have fallen in love with and I know that a lot of others have as well and that is Tales From The Red Dragon in 2023 designed by Jeff botan Jennifer kitsman Jeff Morrow and Sam Weller this is a narrative Skirmish game it's like a Saturday morning cartoon come to life on your tabletop it's super fun it's super easy to learn it's pretty quick to play and set up and it's just a joy from one turn to the next it's got a ton of great characters and a diverse cast of characters lots of strong female characters in this game which I've heard many people praise and I praise it for that as well the characters are like superheroes and they get to do all kinds of badass things from one turn to the next it's vibrant and colorful and it's depictions of its settings and in the story that it is telling it's not overly serious or dark but it's also not too goofy as to be uninteresting or uncompletely unbelievable it's got some gravitas to it even though it is also humorous if you think in terms of authors I think if you mixed something uh like from Pierce Anthony Terry Pratchett and Robert Aspen in term terms of tone but it also has some very well made serious and solid tactical Skirmish mechanisms it's a very very well made balance of all kinds of different things

and I think it's a fantastic game so my game for right now if I were to curate somebody's collection for something with a narrative campaign would be Tales From The Red Dragon in so all right you guys well I hope you enjoyed this list a little bit different a curated top 10. if you want to hire me to uh curate your if you're a board game collection uh yeah just just hit me up and maybe we can work something out so all right you guys well I hope you enjoyed this video and we will talk to you later bye-bye

Progress saved