Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:06

today's topic oh you got to try this game you'll hate it welcome to table scraps short discussions about board card and tabletop gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there everybody and welcome back to another episode of table scraps the live streaming show here where we discuss a topic about board card and tabletop gaming uh topics that are submitted by the viewing audience and we discussed them with the viewing audience and actually today is a special treat because joining me via internet wires is good friend Marty canel from the Rolling Dice and taking names podcast Marty how you doing I am doing fantastic I'm excited to be here today to talk about whatever we're going to talk about but I'm sure it's going to be really good whatever it is we're talking about you have higher expectations than I do at this point well today's topic actually was subed to us uh by a viewer on Twitter uh David uh who posts the question he asks what game would you make other people play even if you knew that they didn't like it and you know when I first saw this question I was like I would never do that you know and I almost put this question aside until I realized I've totally done that and uh and you were there actually so I I thought for sure that there's no way

that I would force somebody to play a game that I know they didn't like because I mean that that's that's the antithesis to what we try to do with this hobby you we try to bring people in being an evangelist we we I'm continually I don't know about you Marty but I'm continually trying to gauge I look at someone it's almost like a little Terminator scanner goes off and like all these little things come down on the screen it's like this person likes uh worker placement and they like um you know this type of game and they like cards and they do not like dice you know and then go through and scan my game library to figure out which game would be the best fit however the exception to the rule is one time I realized I did do this is was at Gen Con last year we were in the hot games room um and uh you know all a bunch of media creators were in there we were you got done with the hubub and commotion of the exhibit hall all day we're trying to relax and there's a game that whenever our group of friends gets together at a convention we love to break out and bring and have hit the table do you know what that is Marty uh I assume it's strike no no oh okay oh that's another exception I guess I'd make anybody play I would make anybody play strike as well but that no that's that's not the that's not that's another story no it's don't mess with cthulu uh the little card game social deduction game oh yeah yeah and your co-host from your podcast Tony McCree was there and I know I know I know that Tony hates social deduction games but all of us were there it's like you know once a year maybe that all of us are

together at this convention and we coaxed Tony into playing a couple rounds of Don't Mess With cthulu even though I know he hates that type of game and I did it just because we were all there together and uh he pretended to enjoy it but so uh so yeah I I I actually I realized I have been a victim of doing this very thing what about you Marty well I guess I should have gone first because my Victim was also Tony and it it's funny that um when I was trying to think of people that I can't think of many people that's like I just don't like this type of game and don't want to play except for Tony because he's so grumpy about some of the games that he plays now social deduction is an easy one I know he doesn't like that one but it I've we've uh test or reviewed games before make him sit down and play a game like anything that has a little bit of um AP to it analysis paralysis he's done if it's over two hours he's for sure done no is it is it because he suffers from analysis paralysis or he just has no patience for people who do he has no patience he has no patience for anybody that uh suffers analysis paralysis and with a game like detective where I knew it was going to be you know a few hours long and it's like okay you got you got to check this out I knew he he liked it

but when it gets a little long in the tooth and if you never played that game a lot of that game is just sitting around and talking he's not really into that he wants to Chuck dice move and and get things going in fact he'll get up and start walking around the table and go to another room go get something to eat is it my turn yet and it's what but with Detective it's always somebody you know it's never really somebody's turn because you're playing it together and so I knew is like yeah this just is not going to work that well for him he liked it okay but anything that's has analysis paralysis or more than two hours I know that I'm going have to put up with him and it's so funny that we both pick the same person to have this as an example with yeah I think that says a lot because I was trying to come up with an antidote with you of games you don't like and to be honest Chaz I can't think of games that you don't like I I I can maybe think of a game maybe you said you care for but I can't think of a genre or group of games that you just like I don't really care for this typee of game you know I I like to think that I can find something to enjoy in most any game uh you know and there are some genres where I will like more of that more games in that genre than others you know sometimes it's hard to pick one out but yeah I I very rarely I think have a gaming experience where I'm like just I this is kill me now I just can't stand this but let me let me ask you this do you know a of a particular type of game that I'm not a huge fan of and there's one let me give you the name of a game and see if if you give you a there's a certain element of the game I don't care for okay quacks of quacks of

quinber or your last oh oh oh no I not only know this I've experienced this firsthand with you it's the push your luck element I I have seen you I have seen you literally get this close to legitimately losing your temper at qua of klinberg it was uh yeah and is it because is it because the amount of risk or is it just because you feel you personally push yourself too far uh no it's the amount well it's the amount of risk so I'm always running through math and stuff and so if you've ever never played the game before the concept is is you have uh cardboard chits in a bag that you're trying to pull out and put on the board some of those chips are considered bad poison and there's values on each of the chips and if you pull out those bad chips and they exceed seven then your turn ends and that's it's not a good thing so over the course of the G you're you're putting more chits into your bag to where uh there's a lot more of the good stuff in there than the bad stuff so I know that there there's been times when literally I've had okay there's 10 chits left in here I know that of what I have on the board there's only one one that can make me bust and go over seven 10% chance let's go in there it is I have actually played quacks before last time I played I got to play with Rob davio and I told told Rob Rob watch this one out of 10 chance one out of 10 chance I reached in the bag I didn't even look look at the chit I pulled it

just H it to him did I bust he died laughing went yep you bust it there it is if that was anybody else anybody else telling that story I wouldn't believe them but it's you so yeah I agree Peter joins us to say the only time something like this comes to mind is if we played incorrectly or missed something really big last time so Mar let let me ask you in your experience if you have a game where you get the rules wrong and it ruins the experience and people that played it hate the game when you discover that correction do you tell the people hey let's give this game a second chance or do you let it just die no I I actually give a second chance because then I feel like that I haven't given the game the respect that it should get and if people didn't you know a lots of times I'm the one bringing the game to the table and if it's one of those things people just didn't care for it I Tred to explain actually I can't think of a good example but I have done this before where we played a game and we thought man something just seems off the next day it was our local game group and we had a chat going and a guy went and read the rule and checked something and went oh oh we were totally playing this wrong and all of us went oh well that makes the game so much better everybody had enough experiences Gamers to realize that's it that one little tweak that we got wrong makes the game so much better so luckily I've got a lot of open-minded friends that they have a bad experience and then realize the rule is wrong they're more receptive to play again Kabuki kid uh joins us to say that uh

her rule of thumb is to never make anyone play something that they aren't interested in you know if your friend isn't having fun how can you truly have fun I I think that's a really really good point just to put just to see them go through misery sometimes fun maybe you're sist I don't know okay I will admit I will admit with some of the games that I've been known to pick up thrift stores sometimes there is a part of me it's like we've got to play this because it looks terrible so but that's that's an extreme case you know that that's because I know what we're getting into so that that's a third example of when I will ruin someone's day with games wow I might be a worse person than I realized uh Christopher Hickman who um uh I know is a person I grew up with um takes the time to comment that uh he already tried to make me play a game called damage report but I weasel out of it uh and is that the game uh is that the Real Time game yes has all the sand timers to it yeah now to be fair to be fair Christopher when uh you finally did play it um with another person I believe the other person wished that they had weasel out of it too so I'm just I'm not going to say anything about bad about damage report I'm just saying that the experience is that perhaps in this case you're the one who is is the problem here and is making people play games that uh they don't care for so uh a damage report is uh the one of the first

games I got excited about in the first origins I went to 2011 or so I remember going with my family we demoed that game and uh we thought this is like the coolest thing ever having the real time element so that's I still have that on my shelf downstairs I never play it but it has sentimental value as one of those things that me and my family sat around the demo table at Origins and tried out yeah you know you were talking about games one game element that you don't like that you know I've discovering that I think real time um is an element that I'm finding I like less and less each time I play a game that has real time elements to it but uh do you ever play X XCOM uh I did XCOM was okay because it split it up but um Space Cadets St I want to like a lot more than I find I actually do I really love the concept but it I don't know uh Christian joins us to say I always try to get people to try a game at least once even if I don't think that they're going to like it so boy see that's something that I think is difficult to do if I know someone isn't going to like a game I don't usually take the try it you might like it try eat your vegetables approach uh I think that that can backfire more than it goes well again I got somebody my co-host Tony that I know there just a lot of games he doesn't like don't mess with the cthulu was a prime example I said look I know you don't like social

duct games but deduction games but try this one and just see if you like it I can't I remember he was being nice that day but I remember he said it wasn't as painful as other social deduction games but I I keep I keep doing it because you keep hoping that some sometimes you feel like people are missing out on something that they may like MH and it's like ju just give it a shot you know but I guess just after time and time again people just realize I just know I'm not gonna like that game plus you may have a mental block to it that is that is hey Marty I got this game where you're gonna pull chit side of a bag and something bad may happen but it's fun and I'm GNA go no okay so what we've learned today Margie Marty has a bit of baggage about cracks of quinber so fair enough Trevon joins us to say maybe if the game is a favorite and it's the one day a year that you play it because it's your only chance to do so like getting to play the game my wife hates on my birthday or something like that oo well you know that coincides with my example of that Gen Con how often are you know this group of friends that only see each other at conventions how often are we together is you know are we willing to make take one for the team to play something that we all the rest of us enjoy um you know and are there are there games that you save for special occasions Mary typically yeah so longer games so

when you and I and some of our other friends get together at conventions we always talk about before we get together okay guys what's the one game that we would love to play together and typically it's going to be maybe a longer type game 3 to four hours uh prime example of that was last year at or when um Jamie kegy from Secret gabal really wanted to play Thief is how pronounce it thief and um so I sat down with him and Rodney Smith and some of Jim's friends and we actually got sit down and play it and that's one of those things that number one I would rarely get to play here and I would never get a chance to play it with you know my friends that I only see at convention so for sure there are games that I think that maybe only come out you know with certain times with certain people uh we're gonna take our last question here from Halo x30 who says a friend of mine forgot to explain a rule in Monster lands uh I tuned out and left the table before the game was over because the exclusion of that rule just totally made me zone out uh and that uh kind of reminds me of what you said with Tony uh with how he gets up and walks around the table with games that have a lot of AP he just is out uh Z zones out of it uh I try when that happens to me when I when there's a game where I know oh my gosh I don't care for this game at all I try not to zone out and I try to give it my all for the remainder of the game but um that can be very difficult uh to do sometimes I think there there's sometimes on tell me Marty if this match

is your experience are there certain groups of Gamers that you play with that if they're just not feeling the game they will start to get more disruptive than other groups and uh will kind of Veer off in left field and you know that if you don't pick the right game for them it's just going to implode on itself before it's over yeah we we've already talked about him aside from Tony no serious wow that sounds horrible um he's not here to defend themselves that sounds really bad no um so I'm very fortunate that our whole grain group including Tony is very receptive even when they sit even when halfway through a game it's like you know it's just not clicking with me or whatever people will still finish out the game and I try to be the same way it's just being respective respectful to the people around you that are they're playing the game with you too so I'm very fortunate to have people that AR aren't really like that that's that's a good point okay so for uh it's it's fortunate that you don't encounter that too often but it's unfortunate that we are out of time for this episode but I want to thank everybody for watching and you are more than welcome to continue this discussion down in the comments below you know uh what are some games that you actually are willing to force on people even though they don't like it or is that a cardinal sin when it comes to gaming in your opinion is that a line you would never cross you know if why or why not let me know down in the comments and we'll continue the conversation there but until then I've been Chaz Marler

along with my co-host for this episode Marty canel from Rolling Dice and taking names and uh Marty if you want to give a cute sign off or tell people where they can find you uh then oh sure if you want to go check out our podcast you can do rchn names.com or just find us on utunes there's a new thing out there called utunes there's utunes atunes o tunes and iTunes just pick any one of those and you can find us on Twitter at Dyson names I really enjoyed this thanks for having me so much Chaz let's do it again sometime that is totally why I had you muted for the first 20 minutes okay so until next time I've been Chaz Marler with Marty canel thanks we'll talk to you again soon uh we're actually going to be talking about a subject today that um at first um well we're gonna this subject this is where I'll edit out part of it so that's cool even I don't think you should but go ahead but here I go click settings and do stream only and there that should fix it for when we go cut to you so um if you say some words right now I'm going to say some words right now and closing credits

Progress saved