Skip to main content
Loading video...

Civolution, Black Forest, Peacemakers, Hitster, Sides Ranked & Reviewed

Transcript 18:43

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games and I rank and review them in order of preference now I've got a good mix here with some heavy euros and some parter games and even a co-op game but before I get into the games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number five I have peacemakers horrors of War so this is the newest game from the peacemakers line and the first of which that I've played I've not played any of the previous deck builders and this one does however keep the same theme where you are kind of a neutral party of these kind of Woodland Critters and you are trying to intercept this ongoing war between different factions to try and kind of demotivate them to continue fighting so you are kind of being the peacemakers and trying to stop anybody from dying so I like the way that the the game is tackled or that theme of war is tackled from a different angle and it's quite a creative concept now this is not a deck builder like the previous ones but it is still card driven and the the way that each round or the the game is broken down is pretty simple where you and your teammates cuz this is completely coopertive will'll use these decks of cards or these cards in your hand to do different things so you have like move movement you can barricade

around certain troops to protect them from know from attacks uh you can spy on the Waring factions deck to make sure that you know what's going to happen or you can use the card for The Unique ability on the card as well which will kind of give you different tricks you can do to manipulate the state of play now once you've played your cards the armies will resolve their actions and each Army has two decks and which will show what they do and the speed in which they do it and this going to be really important because certain events will affect other events so for example one faction might attack but if the other faction kind of um blocks or you know takes cover before they attack then they're going to mitigate that attack and take less damage so it's quite cool how the initiative system works in fact is a very creative um and there's even ways you as the players can uh kind of tip the different factions up to off to try and make them act faster and so on um the way you win the game is that you arey trying to demotivate each of the factions to a certain kind of parameter on this track and if at the end of the round their motivation is in a certain Zone then you'll win the game but if one faction gets demotivated too quickly then the other faction will win and you as the players uh will lose I suppose my my biggest takeaway from this game is that combat system I think it's super cool there's some cool like um cascading things that can happen and some good manipulation you can do as you you can swap cards around and put them at the

bottom of the deck so you know what's coming up um as you'd expect with these kind of co-op games and again I do like that concept of kind of sitting in the distance watching things play out and trying to just you know turn this little screw here or there to try and make you know manipulate the situation to your uh benefit that being said I do think you need to go into this game PR prepared that sometimes you will not be doing a lot because you might have the board stay exactly as you want it it and the best thing for you to do is to do nothing so it kind of feels like you're a true fly in the wall and just not really playing and letting letting the game play you and intervening at just at the right times and sometimes doing that thing isn't much at all so it can be a little bit plotting at times and you can wait for the game to play out and sometimes that can even work without much intervention at all so and the pacing is a little bit weird with this one I'm not saying it's bad and certainly in interesting concept um but be prepared for some lulls in play where you don't need to do much but some rounds where you need to truly intervene and really protect someone or do something to foil one of the faction's uh plans uh you have six different scenarios here all of the different landscape of different factions fighting each other have different cards come into play and so on so there's some good replayability here and you can definitely go back and revisit the old scenarios you have played because every time it's going to play out differently um all in all um I like the concept I

think more than I like the game itself that being said please do um take my comments with a with a grain of salt because co-op games generally don't work for me um I prefer competitive games but I thought this was such a a fresh take on the co-op genre that I wanted to Le at least give it a try and I'm sure a lot of people are going to like this one but if you have kind of you know itchy feet and you like to jump straight into a game and maybe you aren't the most patient of people this one might not be for you um because sometimes it together it does feel like a simulation and two aut automas basically fighting each other um because it is that um yeah that might not be for you if you don't like the idea of that but if you want again a different style of co-op games with some good little sneaky things you can do then I would give this one a look especially if you have maybe a younger family I mean the gaml is still quite gamey but it's got a lovely visual design the mles are are gorgeous looking it's very Charming artwork great table presence I have to say that um and some again some really Dynamic combat systems which unfortunately you're not directly involved in and but still interesting to see how it plays out so game where objectively and from a distance I can see it's really clever but is it one that I'm going to go really um deep on and keep going back to I don't think so sadly because I just want to be more involved on a personal level so that is

peacemakers horrors of War at number five at number four I have hiter so this is an extremely light party game where you are trying to put these different songs from history uh in order in terms of when they were originally released so this is pretty much a carbon copy of a game like timeline if you're familiar with that one but instead of historical events you are doing again pop songs or rock songs and so on I think the the fun factor is Amplified with this game because in order to discover which song you're doing you actually scanning in a QR code and which will actually play the song out loud so everybody can kind of sing along and join in and it does again it increases the energy levels and makes it a much more fun experience rather than more taxing one and but you know if you like your music trivia and you want to be tested um then this is a good example of that anybody can play it you can play in groups it can tailor to a lot of people so it is what it is really you know you can fully understand what this game is just by my brief explanation here but it works and you know I generally like that timeline idea anyway I like the original timeline this is just a slight spin on that so that is hiter at number four at number three I have another party game with sides so this is more of a traditional word association game and I tend to like word games I have a lot of them in my collection this one is a bit more of a Mass Market feel um as you are trying to

get uh the person in the hot seat to guess the correct word by giving Clues The Twist on this one though is that you have these uh this row of cards and you can only give Clues Associated to the letters on the extremities on those on that row of cards so know if you have a really good clue but you want to use the letter T you can't do that until you might use the letter C or D and so on and you're trying to be as efficient as you can try giving try and give the best clues in as few letters as possible um extremely versatile very um approachable you know you can teach this to one to anybody you know elderly family members younger family members and so on so it does again have that real broad approach where you can play with absolutely anybody um but it works for what it is you know again I personally like these styles of games it worked well for my family at Christmas um so if you want a an easy to pick up and play Party game then then sides is a good option so that is sides at number three at number two I have black forest so black forest the newest uve Rosenberg game and if you've watched my channel over the year or ever watched any of my uh videos about My Games Collection you might know that I have pretty much no uh U rosenberg's games in my collection with the odd exception and those exceptions are not the Farming Simulator Style games that he's most known for so I have played a lot of them but none of them have really

worked for me one of them that did kind of sit on that boardline of me keeping it or not keeping it was glass road now I really like glass Road um especially that resource system where whenever you gain certain basic resources you will automatically automatically generate the more kind of luxury resources and when I heard that mechanism was coming back in a new game Black Forest that did Peak my interest especially when the rest of the game was kind of built from the ground up and was built on more traditional Euro Concepts rather than the car driven concepts of um of glass roid which I thought was cool but I thought it was a little bit gimmicky and didn't really stand up to repeated plays I found it a little bit too experimental this one again more of a traditional Euro Style game as you are moving around this map with your worker visiting different people on this map getting resources conver resources building buildings all the Euro goodness that I tend to enjoy now the game itself I think is really well done I think it's a polished game as you'd expect with a designer like oia Rosenberg I thought the actual main worker movement board was really cool as you know you are spending Provisions in order to move from town to town so you're trying to plan your routes efficiently as not to waste anything you can even manipulate the board state by moving different kind of traders to different locations to try and suit you there's a race to get certain kind of um contracts done so again lots of traditional Euro things that I tend to

like and I thought that was executed really well um much like the original glass Road I really enjoyed that resource wheel where you want to very meticulously get the right resources because again you do automatically generate um the luxury resources which can actually ruin your plans if you're not careful loved all of that um there was one thing that I found a little bit clunky though or maybe not clunky more overwhelming and that was the sheer variety of options here now I know that some people will look at that or hear that and think excellent there's so much you can do here and that is true but I found it a little bit daunting and a little bit too much to take in because I think every single game here you have like I don't know 50 buildings or something and you got some big ones as well as a ton of the smaller ones they are kind of organized in a way that you can break it down into the different resources but there is a lot of cross-contamination and what I found myself doing a lot of the time was just collecting random stuff and then looking at the um at the Resource Board and then building whatever I could build rather than working towards something so I felt that this game lacked a little bit of direction I think it would have been better if there was maybe round by round objectives or something you can try and go for to get some bonus points just to put you on the rails a little bit I found it a little bit too too sandboxy and just too many kind of conversion tiles where you could turn this into this into this into this again I like

the idea of that but in practice it was like oh I don't know just pick one of them and hopefully uh it will work out um there are some good different strategies you can go here as you can focus on you know really densely populating your player boards or keeping them bare um again lots of different ways you can get points but again I found the points a little bit a little bit minor it felt like you're doing a lot of work for very few points in return um and all in all um again despite me objectively liking a lot of things that went on here I found the game a little bit too Meandering and a bit too plotting um and just like lacking that little bit of drive and that little sense of urgency that I would have liked to have seen and what I tend to enjoy in a lot of other Euros this one was is a little bit too foot off the gas and just hopefully things will work out and so on so maybe I'm just really bad at this maybe well seems to be a running theme with u Rosenberg games I just find them I don't know they just don't gel with my with my play style too much and this is sadly another example of that despite me thinking it would be the polar opposite just again too many things going on in terms of these buildings and it feels like you're pulling teeth in order just to get a very small amount of points in return for that now that being said I'm sure if you like UV games then you're going to get a lot from this one because it is a solid design objectively it's just one that didn't quite work for me and um even the people I played it with actually agreed with me so maybe it's not just just me saying that and if

you're if you are tried and tested in terms of playing uve and enjoying uve games then you'll like this one if you don't then I don't think this is the one to change your mind so again objectively a good game but just one that's not right for me that is black forest at number two and finally at number one and the only game at this episode to get a commendation is civil so Stephen Feld kind of the polar opposite of U Rosenberg to me almost all of his games gel with me you know they fit like a glove because I tend to like the way that he thinks and Designs games uh this one kind of borrows a lot from his other games but it's a much more grandiose more ambitious design with much more going on as the name of the game would suggest this is kind of a civilation game or civilization game I should say where you are in improving your technology as you go and this game certainly has that um but it is more built on the foundation of you know Euro trappings um dice manipulation moving around the map spawning new troops uh controlling areas this kind of thing rather than those traditional civilization style games so as I said earlier this one does borrow a lot from other stanfeld games for example the the main driving system of the game is Dice which works a lot like the dice system system in the castles of burgundy but instead of using One D in this one you're always using a pair of dice to activate a particular action you

have like 20 odd actions here like 25 actions or so that you can take and that sounds a lot and it is a lot but when you actually play it it's not too bad because all the actions broken down are very logical and easy to resolve for example move your tribes around or know create a new tribe or play a card know they're all pretty simple and what you can do but it's the the magnitude and the sheer Buffet of options that you have at any time that makes this really crunchy and I don't want to understand it in terms of just being Broad in terms of your decisions the actual layers of the game play here is really rich as well because you need to prioritize things at the right time because you have end of round objectives that can give you huge benefits if you beat your opponents to them but also uh each game is going to have a different kind of ratio or return on different strategies that you take in terms of the return of points you get by following those particular strategies so tons of variability here I love the way you can tailor your engine to do different things and maybe this game you want to be really good at exploring next game you could be really good at hunting and so on so you are spinning a lot of plates here but I like the way that you can't do everything at all times you need to best utilize the dice that you've rolled now one of the main criticisms you'll get from this game is that for such a heavy game and complex game you are pigeon hold by the dice

that you've rolled and yes that is true but if you are in that position for a lot of the game then you have kind of done that yourself because you always have an option to take these idea tokens which essentially work as your your workers like in the castles of burgundy that let you mitigate the dice to what you want them to be you could take these Place markers that can act as basically dummy dice so there's lots of mitigation tools here and every time I've seen anybody sulk about this game not going their way it's always because they failed to take those mitigation tools as an option because they see that as a wasted move where in reality that's a great move to make um because they've just saved themselves making several suboptimal moves uh in the future so much to talk about here this one when I first played it I liked it a lot lot um but of course you'll still get into grips with things and seeing what what happens when you pull certain buttons or push certain buttons the more I played this one the more I'm starting to really appreciate the layers of gameplay here uh just the the amount of different ways you can tackle it is is fascinating and for such a complex game it is remarkably smooth and easy to play now I taught this one recently to my girlfriend who's basically dipping a toe into board games and she had a great time with it and managed to get to grips um quite quickly apologies for the siren there um so yeah this one I had very very high hopes for

and this one lived up maybe even exceeded my expectations and is definitely one of my favorite games of the year and one of my favorite Stephen Feld games which is saying something so that is cilu at number one so there we have it that concludes the video a nice variety of games here I hopefully you found some value in this if you have please hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved