Skip to main content
Loading video...

Imposter Syndrome & Board Game Design - How many playtests is ENOUGH?

Transcript 12:08

i think i've got a great little game here i just don't know whether it's ready to show to a publisher well have you tested it 100 times and yeah with 100 different groups yeah i have yeah did anyone say anything negative no don't lie to me i'm not lying they all loved it have you done blind play tests yeah i've done loads 100 yeah yeah at least 100. but have you tested it with other designers yes i did proper established published designers yeah field is yarners winning designers yeah i did i showed it to wolfgang vorse but have you showed it to one of kenitzia no i i don't have his number no publisher is ever gonna look at your piece of garbage i'm adam porter i'm a game designer from cardiff in wales and today i want to discuss how you can tell when your game is ready to pitch as tabletop game designers we frequently put ourselves under insane pressure we set ourselves unachievable goals and compare ourselves to other professionals who work in a totally different context with totally different resources finances support and ability it's a recipe for imposter syndrome i've hung out in board game design forums and play test groups for the best part of a decade and i'm sometimes taken aback by the unrealistic and inaccurate advice thrown around in these settings i'm going to jump in straight away here and state very clearly that i love these forums and play test groups i've learned everything that i know from them but

i've also had to filter out nuggets of misinformation from time to time and that's what i'm talking about here today let's get it out there i'm a professional designer i have seven published games to my name and more on the way i don't play test hundreds of times my blind tests are awkward and infrequent i don't have rhino knits here on speed dial i do the best i can with limited time money contacts and resources and that's enough so when is the game ready and how much play testing do you really need well let's start with some basic truths you do need to play test your games a lot there are layers to this you should start testing solo play through a few rounds or even entire games if possible by yourself before you show the game to anyone else cards dice and scraps of paper are often all you need why waste your playtester's time by showing them a concept that's broken from the outset most of my designs fall at this first hurdle and they never get shown to another human being now you can run your games past your family and friends my wife iris is my harshest critic she likes what she likes and my designs aren't always to her tastes but she's very honest with me and i take her views on board my next challenge is rob fisher he's my frequent collaborator and an extremely talented designer also based in cardiff we've play tested a lot over many years and he's my second harshest critic frequently i will shelve designs that i previously felt positive about after rob

has shown me the error of my ways sometimes rob picks up the baton and gets stuck into fixing the flaws in the game and that's how our co-design compromat was born if the game gets passed iris and rob i'll open it up to other testers gaming friends and people i meet at play testing meetups but bear in mind your friends and family might not be mean like iris and rob they probably really like you and want you to be happy they'll tell you your game is great even if it's rubbish take their views with a pinch of salt robin eris aren't actually mean they're amazing i just had to clarify that in case they're actually watching our regular play test group in cardiff has been on hold throughout the pandemic which makes things more difficult but i still ensure that i've played my game with strangers in different settings enough times that i feel comfortable and how many times is enough well the truthful answer is it's a gut feeling and it varies it depends on the enthusiasm of the play testers am i getting a positive vibe from them did they enjoy the game though truthfully that might not be enough i want to see their eyes light up i want them to love it it also depends on how much i'm having to rework the game after each test if the feedback is coming back to me that the game is absolutely perfect in its current form and after several play tests no one's suggesting any modifications then that's a good clue that it's almost there the contrary is also true if every play tester is redesigning the game in their head then i've probably got some more work to do i may or may not join in with these tests

in the earliest tests i want in i want to see how the game feels from the inside regardless of the other player's views i want to experience the game first hand once i've played it a few times though i'm more inclined to sit out and watch groups play together if i'm not influencing the session i feel like i get a more honest picture of how the game is coming across and that leads me on to what is hopefully the final stage in the process the blind test this is where players learn the game from the rule book and play with no input from you as designer before they feed back blind tests can be done in a number of different ways i know major publishers like stonemire and northstar games have communities of volunteer playtesters hammering out blind tests and sending data about various card effects and interactions and outcomes to ensure that the finished product is as balanced as possible i have no such community available to me and frankly it's not the sort of feedback that i'm looking for i want to witness the emotions that players have when they play my games fortunately they're simple enough concepts that my games don't need extensive balancing blind tests for me are about eliminating clunky unnecessary rules which repeatedly trip players up and testing my rules writing to ensure that publishers aren't going to get the wrong end of the stick and we must remember most publishers aren't native english speakers i tend to be present at blind tests watching the session with my hand over my mouth and resisting the urge to jump in and correct the players or offer

advice or excuses it takes some discipline to stay quiet when the session is turning into a train wreck some designers ask players to video their play tests and then watch them back later and i've never done that it feels artificial and clunky to me for each of my games the number of play tests has buried so i'm going to try and make some estimates from memory big bazaar was tested a lot though it never really changed from day one it felt like it was a really promising design and i was super keen i remember my friend tom worked at a school and he took it in for the kids to play then he brought me an audio recording of their feedback it was great i reckon the game was probably tested 50 plus times it helped that it's short so you could test it a few times in a single session making changes along the way doodle rush was designed in an afternoon i probably tested it 20 times over the next few weeks and it never changed every test was a blast most players loved it and no one ever suggested any improvements it was a dream to play test ironically the publisher brain games found a number of ways to improve the product immensely proving that a supposedly finished product is never genuinely complete there are always more changes that could be made picoco was one of my earliest designs i probably tested it 30 or 40 times and tweaked it as i went along i played this one a lot with strangers i traveled to a lot of different play testing groups at the time and i got a load of really positive feedback but some players really bounced

off the game and gave negative feedback it was quite polarizing but i knew that i loved it every time i played and i trusted my judgment throne was tested a lot over a number of years and constantly adapted it included a host of different powers and they all interacted in different ways so there was a lot to cover to ensure that the game never broke i constantly thought of new exciting powers but ultimately i had to hone it down to 20 or so of the most robust powers which were clearer to the players and provided the most reliably enjoyable experience the feedback was even more polarizing than picocco and i think in this case i could have listened more to the naysayers i guess i probably played the game more than 40 times quasil was tested less than some of the others and most commonly just by myself and my co-designer rob it's such a simple concept it didn't need balancing we knew it was fun and the tests were really just confirming what we already knew i guess we probably tested it 20 or 30 times zuligans is a solo puzzle so i could test that largely by myself i played this solo many many times but because of the more interpretive clues it was still important to see what other players made of them they also ran the game past friends with children to get a sense of the difficulty level and how much fun they were having with it fortunately the kids i showed it to were totally hooked they just kept playing and playing this was really reassuring i played zuligans

more than any of my other designs it's hard to put a number on it because a game could be a single very easy puzzle or it could be a run of 20 or 30 puzzles on difficult mode in a single sitting it was really important to me that each of the puzzles had only one solution and that the graded difficulty was pitch perfect i'm very proud of this design it's a shame it's flown under the radar a little i guess rob and i played compromat 30 times or thereabouts the gameplay came together quickly and thereafter it was just about trying out different powers and seeing what was fun when it felt like it was working well we stuck with it and we stopped tweaking rob and i have been working on a much more complex euro game for several years i keep a log of my tests and our next test will be our 59th play tests for this game are time consuming and every new iteration between tests takes hours to pull together it's a different world to play testing a game like quasil or doodle rush and we're asking a lot of our play testers by putting it on the table again and again it needs to be balanced and thankfully it's really fun to play but we need to be careful that we don't take advantage of our friends good will let's do some calculations each of these tests lasts 90 minutes or so and most result in one to two hours of revision between tests that totals around 170 hours of thus far unpaid work for rob and myself on our euro game plus hundreds of hours unpaid for our testers i'd estimate that an

optimistic figure for the potential income from a euro game like this is short of 10 000 pounds split 50 50 between myself and rob so assuming that the game gets picked up and that's a big assumption we're currently working an hourly rate of about 29 pounds an hour and it's dropping with every play test if the game is never picked up we've wasted weeks and weeks of work this is where i think the standard advice about hundreds of play tests just doesn't add up so my advice to you as a designer is to be rigorous and honest and introspective do what you have to do don't cut corners make sure that you respect your play testers time but do play with lots of different groups and watch strangers playing your game be disciplined enough to sit through blind tests without interfering and read the room use your judgment your intuition and play test enough but don't try to live up to an impossible ideal publishers want to hear from you believe me this is the most open approachable industry that i've worked in we can't all be reinerkinicia and honestly with his massive output of games each year how much play testing can he honestly be doing anyway so you do it your way that's all you can do if you enjoyed the video please go back and watch some of my other game design musings on my channel let me know your thoughts in the comments below and please subscribe so i can keep you up to date with upcoming content until next time all the best

Progress saved