Skip to main content
Loading video...

A Scythe LCG Is Looking More and More Likely! - The Mill

Transcript 18:50

hello and welcome to the mill I am your host dusty crane and this week I want to talk about the fact that I think we're getting closer and closer to a side LCG now let me explain jamie has been talking an awful lot about lcg's this week he did a Sunday sit-down video last week and he did he talked quite a bit about it in the the Wednesday Facebook livestream now it probably talked about it a lot on Wednesday because people were commenting on Sunday it's been one of his more talked about videos recently where people you know he has to lot of questions in his Sunday sit down and it seems to be pointing towards if he made an LC G what would it be about and so this week I went ahead and took some clips from the Sunday sit down and I took some clips from the wind Wednesday livestream to just kind of make my case for why I think he's really planning a scythe or more specifically world of 1920 plus game that is an LC G or a card game expandable card game since LC g is a trademark term of Fantasy Flight so let's go ahead and I'm gonna go up to start with the Wednesday livestream so I'm gonna go ahead and take this clip from Jericho you a clip from Jamie and let's go ahead and see what he's thinking in terms of his aisle seat LCG the thing that I'm trying to consider

from my LCG if I end up making one is it would be a little different I think than the health studies that are out there in that it wouldn't be a 1:1 on one dueling game it would be competitive but it would be more like a deck building game with a quarterly release schedule for for new stuff that you build into the game so each player wouldn't be obligated to buy their own stuff I think that's one of the barriers to entry with a competitive LCG in particular they have multiple players buying the same stuff so they can make the deck that's best for them so be more like you're buying more stuff for the same copy of the game that you're sharing with other people and if you don't have everything that's fine like you it won't be a game that relies on you having all the expansions that's kind of the module for summer games in general that you can send that's various expansions okay so Jamie's talking about a competitive deck builder a new expansion every three months or so and probably most important if you are dipping your toe into an LCG or a expandable card game would be no need to buy multiple core sets that's something that I had a co-worker give me a copy of the Lord of the Rings LCG he was done with it and when he when I was done with that he said hey trade it sell it whatever and one of the questions that came up when I was trying to find someone else - there's interested in the game was how many core sets do you have and I totally did not get the reason why but I understand now is that sometimes you

know you want to have multiple core decks put together or you want more than one of a certain card and there's only one in the core box set but to really you know have a great deck you want to have two so it's nice to hear that right from the get-go in Jamie's design philosophy is no need to buy multiple core decks let's see what else he has to talk about how was the else to do that I'm considering designing different than Dominion ascension or storerooms models would you consider any of those lcg's that's a good question I don't think they're too far off I don't know the exact release schedule for those games although I think that meaning releases like maybe one expansion a year I think this would be little modules like a new faction or something like that that you inject into the game every three months so it'd be a much more regular release schedule I think that's a crucial part of a definition of an LCG they released a new content on a very regular basis otherwise it is really similar to those I think the other small element is that there would be an element of deck construction before you start playing the game not a big amount I'm looking more the Marvel champions taking a few modular decks kind of a smash-up module to module model - and putting those decks together at the beginning of the game and then playing so it's a maybe a little bit like smash up it means a deck builder meets I can type Odin being a game that you are changing your deck during the course of the game as well meets a living card game where you have regular releases regular new factions or packs coming out on a regular basis it's

so new modules or factions debt construction is gonna be a part of it you know before the game starts but not you know not really heavy-duty deck construction it's not like putting together a magic deck that you want to be competitive more than Marvel champions where if you're unfamiliar with Marvel champions is you pick a hero and it has a certain amount of cards in it like 15 or something and then you choose an aspect so maybe it's justice or aggression or leadership something like that and then you put that deck you add that to the deck and then that's your your cards that you're playing with you also have some basic abilities so you toss in there these are things that are just kind of like a way to spend resources so you might have something like the Avengers mansion or the Helicarrier something like that or there's just generic ones like energy or strength or something and you know those those would be recent resource cards you can only have one of in your deck and so the whole idea is you take your hero you take an aspect you take a few basic cards smash them together and that's your deck so that is what he's looking at he described it as smash up meets a deck builder meets an LCG with regular factions and packs coming together so I'm not familiar with smash up maybe you guys can comment in in the comments and let me know kind of how that works I mean I know that there's just a ton of smash up expansions so is it I mean just based on the box is it like a train

asaurus rex versus space aliens or something like that I guess I can look into that especially if that's going to be an inspiration for whatever Jaime's certainly not Sai LCG might look like let's go ahead and take another question from the live stream when I talk about this living card game plan it sounds like you'll have another empty box to sell or might you sell it in a box with room to fill yeah so this would be I would plan the or box for the game to hold all of the stuff that we're gonna create for the game now it's tough to do that 100% cuz plans don't always like when you're planning the games three years out things change over time but I would be designed if I design an LCG I would design the core box to hold all the cards that would ever be released or all the components I would ever be released and of course slave cards it would hold sleeve cards so everything would fit into the the box and the insert designed for that original box Simon said that you said you would design a large box for game to hold everything that would be released for this is specifically for the living card game this isn't something that I usually do I I don't like to have a lot of empty space and boxes I let have enough for an expansion or two but I'm not gonna put a giant box out without knowing how well the game is gonna do there's specifically for living card games okay I'll worry the rest of your question now Simon Says what this mean that you would cut the packaging to almost none for the subsequent things to be released for it and yes the answer would be yes there that for trying to

find a way that to have very disposable but somehow hopefully environmentally friendly packaging that you could just when you when you buy the new faction or whatever it is that you throw away that the packaging and just toss the cards into you into your box and the insert where where I've designed the slot for those cards another big box to hold all expansions now I think this is ambitious from this from the standpoint of how do you know how many you know expansion is your to do now Jamie has mentioned a couple of times now that he in his mind he's envisioning a three year game he and having it be quarterly releases so if you do something like and I'm gonna speak to Marvel champions because it's the only LCG I know really when when you look at those it's the hero packs kind of have the same number of cards the story scenarios kind of have the same number of cards and then the story boxes as I understand those haven't come out from Marvel yet but as it relates to Arkham Horror and stuff like that we have a certain number so if you have if he already knows it's going to be a three year plan and here he knows that it's to meet quarterly then you can and you are gonna have the same set amount of cards every time I think you can go ahead and plan ahead to have this this big box that will accommodate everything but it kind of reminds me of is my friends over at Van rider games their expansion hostage negotiator crime wave it was a standalone expansion but it was a big

box and if you've ever played hostage negotiator itself I mean it's it's a small box you get a lot of game in there but it's a small box and then they the crime wave negotiator or crime wave hostage negotiator crime wave it's just the you know the the game but you could actually fit the original box in there and there's enough room for all of the the packs they'd made so far and the promos and on all the tokens and stuff like that it was a really cool design and let's go ahead and take the JT here Jaime's next question Gerald says for my living card game what I consider doing three stories instead of one like three packs per season so customers gonna can think I only have to buy three packs to get a full story I have thought about that a lot people mention that it becomes of the video and I completely love that idea that you have maybe a little campaign arcs little story arcs I'll have to see what's best for the game that I'm designing what I might do is have little story arcs and then but just to say if you want you can put everything in anytime that you're not limited to those story arcs miniature story arcs I really like this idea because as I understand it Arkham Horror is just very deep story very thematic very well like I said it's it's story driven and so you don't want to get invested in a story where there's like 15 expansions and maybe you're only gonna get through the first two or three and then you know what happened I so I'd like the idea of there being a bunch of mini arcs in whatever this game is to

become Jamie's next question was Joshua says what are some creative ways to fill the living card game base box so it has room for three years of expansions but doesn't seem empty when first purchased this may be too pricey but my first thought is a traveling trophy that never needs to go back into the box and that's interesting you can also just use foam foam is actually surprisingly expensive but but foam can take up quite a bit space in the box before you need to fill it up but I love them more creative version that you thought of there too what do you think do you like the idea of a traveling trophy for filler or do you think that foam makes more sense though is expensive as Jamie says foam is are surprisingly expensive I think it's probably cheaper than a trophy for filler but I like the idea that maybe there's something that's in that box that you know maybe is I don't even know if you do like a collectible like if you if it is size related like if you had like one of the side mechs or something like that that would be really cool there could be a your trophy or whoever ultimately wins the the competitive game there could could take that trophy home and you wouldn't keep it in the box because you know you're gonna be filling it with new cards so that's a pretty cool idea for the next video I'm gonna go ahead and get into the original Sunday sit down the designing of an LCG this video I didn't want to pull too much from it because there's a great discussion that Jamie has there and he asks a lot of questions in his community so I you really should check it out if

you haven't already it's it's a really good one but the design video this is one of the the clips I pulled from it if you play Marvel champions you're not gonna have more than one Iron Man you're gonna want to amend and play so you don't need to buy more than one Iron Man from the game that I'm thinking about designing around this LCD system it wouldn't make sense for more than one player to have the same faction or the same character that doesn't make sense I like the time story said from from fairly early on that there's an end to this and that element I am really intrigued by for the LCD model could you go into an Elsa you could you enter the market with a new LCG or expandable card game and say we're gonna put out a new pack every three months for the next three years and that'll be it our story will be complete after that your experience will be complete I am leaning towards a competitive LCG for the for the specific theme that I'm looking at a competitive works better than cooperative so some factions wouldn't make sense a finite story and competitive over co-op it doesn't make sense all of these things really really point me to the scythe IP I mean the world of 1920 plus it doesn't make sense to have two of the same Pallotta new character with you know with their armies or with their companion animal it wouldn't make sense to have two rusia players and so I

understand that it's very easy to kind of shoehorn in we have no idea what the theme is but a cooperative scythe like I don't even know what that would really look like unless you know the parties are have you know something else has happened in the world of nineteen twenty plus and and all of these factions have come together and to battle it out what that might look like that's the only aspect of cooperative that makes sense to me so I definitely see the the combative nature the competitive nature being something that stands out so yeah I just I think all signs with with Jamie mentioning his willingness to go back to the world in nineteen twenty plus with Jakob working on his realtime strategy game iron harvest and the fact that they probably had to build out the world a lot to to work on this video game to see there's there's new mechs there's there's probably the same faction so there's other stuff going on there I'm not familiar with iron harvest but it just seems like scythe is a very important IP to stone layer that it gives you an opportunity to revisit that world without Jamie doing the exact same thing I think I think that seems to be kind of a trend is that it doesn't seem like he retreads the same ground very often I mean there's there's there's

tweaks and stuff like that so I think just a side to with new factions probably wouldn't work and probably wouldn't be terribly interesting to him I would be on board but one other thing that I thought about here is it really one of the earlier questions that came up was and I think it also ties into kind of some of the wingspan conversation in terms of how do you deliver expansions where you already have a box or you already have containers that are meant to hold cards like what does that look like so I kind of went through my collection and found a couple things to look at here so here is a marvel champions expansion this is the Green Goblin scenario pack and it comes with 78 brand-new cards there's two decks of cards in here and it houses new encounters and scenarios and things you can you don't match together to make new challenges new story but not terribly environmentally friendly with the plastic pack in the plastic shrink inside so maybe not what Jamie is looking at I did remember a while back I had bought an expansion for portals 51st state and this is just a cardboard pack there may be plastic shrink wrap cards inside but that's significantly less waste then you know this full kind of clamshell case around these cards so

51st state allies here cardboard it actually says it has 50 cards 24 tokens in one rulebook so I think something like this is probably more along the lines of an expansion pack for Jamie's possible LCG and yeah I that's that's really all I had for you this week it just seems like it just seems like there's way too much smoke for there not to be fire you know what I mean it seems like there's entirely too much talk for just something that he's not seriously considering I mean I already have release schedules and you know what he wants to the box to look like in in story arcs and stuff like that I will say this what I would love to see in a side LCG if there's gonna be story based content at all bring back Ryan Lopez the work that he did in the rise of Fenris is fantastic and I would in his writing style really matched up with you know the world of science so if there's going to a world of 1920 plus I would love for Ryan to be involved again I think that the the writing skills that he has obviously he's demonstrated just just fit so nicely it brings it nice consistency to you know the writing and the story that might be there so it'll might also be an interesting challenge if he if he has the time - you wrote bigger a little bit bigger long-form stories they're like can you break it down to a card and it still be you know interesting so that's that's what I have

for this week what do you think if it is size related are you still excited having heard you know the stuff Jamie's talking about let me know in the comments that's all I have for you this week thanks so much for watching take care of yourselves and each other bye

Progress saved