Skip to main content
Loading video...

Impressions September '18 - Teotihuacan, Dice Setters, Western Legends, and 6 more!

Transcript 59:00

welcome to John gates games this is my impressions vlog for September 2018 where I will be covering my initial impressions for every new game that I played over the course of September as well as a couple games that I've played in the past but I haven't gotten around to in a while now I have organized them in alphabetical order so you can skip ahead to watch the ones you are most interested in or you can stick around for the whole thing and before we jump in I would like to mention that if you enjoyed this video you please consider clicking the like button down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel also if you would like to directly support the channel you could go to John gates Gamescom slash support to see a variety of ways with which you could do that and I would really appreciate it alright let's go ahead and start off with the list with game number one and that is gonna be a feast for Odin now when I look this one up I hadn't played it in I think a year and nine months and I got this one about two years ago and this is a gigantic goofy Rosenberg worker placement game that is somewhat famous for having this work replacement board that has over 60 different slots on it now as you are playing through this game you start with a moderate sized band of Vikings and every single turn you get a new Viking so by the end of the game you have all of these Viking workers that you can use and you're just gonna be placing them out onto this board and doing a variety of things like gaining food so that you can feed your Vikings getting a variety of different resources which take a variety of different shapes and then you will put those shapes down onto your board in a puzzling manner as you try to cover up your board starting in the bottom left and working your way up so that you can get more income and also score less negative points now as

you're playing the game you can get more boards like you can go out and explore new islands that you can put these resources on to get more bonuses and more income and more points and this game is just a it's a process of getting points for doing all sorts of things and trying to be very efficient turning a small amount of stuff into a large amount of stuff and the game gives you lots of ways to do that now I played this one a couple times when I first got it and I really enjoyed those plays and then the channel just kind of got in the way I kept playing other games and I kept thinking yeah I'm gonna get back to a feast frodan and then it almost two years went by and a couple weeks ago I was starting off a game day and a couple friends came over and they said what do you wanna play and I said you know what Frode I'm gonna make it happen as long as you guys are interested in and both of them had played it before so we got to sit down and do a quick refresher on the rules and then we jumped right in and I really enjoyed it again man this game is so much fun because it gives you such a wide variety of things that you could do now to a certain extent that could be somewhat intimidating like you look down to that board and there are so many options and you do have to pick one but at the same time there's kind of no bad options and if you are playing the game and moderate um knowledge of the game anyway if you're playing at a very high level of course there's gonna be better spots than others based off of the gaming games say that you're in and in this play I honestly felt like I was doing really well I was ramping up my income faster than both of my opponents I was covering things up a lot faster than both of my opponents but the big important that I stumbled was I only got one of the islands that you can go out

to and discover and one of my opponents had got two of them and by the end of the game my engine was going so well that I didn't have places to put all of the stuff that I was making and I was actually pretty inefficient with how I was end up getting some houses that you could put some resources on to get a little bit of points here and there and I ended up getting kind of blown out like a last by over 30 points in that game and I really enjoyed myself but I remember thinking like wow I really felt like I gave up a lead that I had in the early game and a big part of that involved not being able to get more of those islands because there were only four of them available I got one another opponent got one and then the person who won picked up two of them and they're definitely the more experienced person around the table they had played a feast for Odin more than the rest of us I think this is my third play and for one opponent it was their second play but overall I think that this is a game where you are definitely going to get better at it as you keep playing it and as you get more comfortable with how these things work the first time you sit down and play this game you will probably be confused as to how you will ever fill up your main board let alone other new boards but as you get more experienced you will find yourself in a situation like maybe I was in where I was making so much stuff and I didn't have an efficient way to actually turn it into points to put it down on to spots so yeah I'm really enjoying this one again and also part of the reason I wanted to make this one I get played is because they've recently announced that the there's gonna be a big box expansion coming up this one had s in this year and I wanted to know if this is something I should try and track down now I kind of joked when I first got this game that it already had like five expansions worth of content in there because there's just

so much stuff the box is like this big and you use every single inch inside that box to fill it up with stuff and after playing it with my friends I realized I don't need an expansion for this game there's still so much there for me I've only played the game three times that the idea of bringing in yet another action board and a variety of new different shapes of pieces that you can put down just doesn't seem necessary to me now I figure if you played this game 20 times then maybe an expansion sounds great to you but it's not one that I'm gonna be hunting out but I did pick up last year an expansion that had some extra islands and I decided not to play with them when I played a couple weeks ago because I just wanted to play the vanillin experience and now I think I am gonna try to play with those in the future because having more islands will definitely free that choke point of victory points up a little bit and yeah I'm looking forward to playing this one again with those new islands and it's just a fun game and it's one that I think is gonna be sticking around for a long time even though it takes up a lot of space on my shelf I hope to play this one again in sooner than a year and nine months like this is one I hope to play at least every few months because it's a good time and I think I said that a lot so let's go ahead and move on to game number two now this one is called brothers and to a certain extent it's kind of like the baby baby baby brother of a piece of rodent because in this game you do have little pieces that with different shapes on them and you are trying to make patterns out in the middle of the board but that's kind of where these similarities end now this is a two-player only game that is somewhat asymmetric but it's also a very light quick experience where you

have two different well I guess technically three different types of tiles in the game one type are these large pasture tiles and then there is a set of these straight pieces that are essentially three times longer than they are wide and then there is a set of angle pieces which are again effectively three units but in an angle now when you're playing this game it's slightly asymmetric because you're gonna take all of these straight pieces or all of the angle pieces but then before you play any of the mount you and your one opponent are going to take turns putting these pasture tiles together to create to the pasture in front of yourselves and then once that's done we'll take turns placing one of your pieces down one at a time so that you can hopefully put more of your pieces in then your opponent can put their pieces in now once you do that you score victory points based off of the amount of pieces you have left over and you do not want points in this game so I guess you sort of score a negative points and then you're supposed to flip things around and then if you played with these straight pieces then you play a whole other game with the angle pieces and likewise for your opponent now each one of these games that you're effectively supposed to play to of usually a well I say usually I've only played the game once but it seemed like each one of these games took about ten minutes maybe the first one probably took ten minutes and the second one probably took about five or six minutes so overall even though you're playing twice this is a very quick experience and I found out rather quickly then I was much worse at this game than my opponent Dave we played I think I had the straight pieces and he had the angle ones first and he got all of his pieces out and I had a couple remaining and I was like okay well I think I see what you did there so we swap things around and I tried to play the angle pieces like he did and

then he played the straight pieces in ways that I hadn't even considered and then totally blocked me out and I had a bunch of the angle pieces left over as well so I think that you can definitely attribute to my loss to a skill differential between us as two players even though both of us had this is our first play for both of us it definitely seemed obvious that my opponent was grasping the spatial combat that we were essentially doing on the board a lot better than I was because you're effectively trying to put your pieces down and you can put them anywhere that they fit in such a way that you are locking out certain regions so that only your pieces will fit there later and your opponent's pieces won't and both of these very quick little games that encompassed one full play of it we had a situation where we would stop going back and forth and then we'd just be like okay well I think we're done interacting so now we'll both just kind of put as many of our pieces down as we can because we kind of filled everything up and I think overall the game is fine like it mechanically works and I feel like especially if you were playing maybe with younger people it would be more engaging because a lot of these the things that you were doing in this game will feel a little bit more novel and perhaps a little bit more difficult to understand although I say that and I won I lost terribly so maybe I don't really understand how this game is supposed to be played and I'm not a person but I don't think that I'm particularly compelled by the decisions that the game was making to try and get better at it now I do think that if you are I do think this is a game of skill and you don't see games of skill very often with very short like 15 minute or so games so the game definitely has that

going for it and I think that a lot of people are gonna enjoy that aspect to it especially from a quick two-player filler perspective but I think from my perspective I didn't see enough that interest me that much and I didn't see it enough to make me want to really keep playing it and getting get better at it so I think that overall my verdict is I don't see myself playing this game again but I could see many people enjoying this one for what it is and just doesn't align up with my interest too much up next we now have game number three and this one is dice Settlers now this one is published by Anna scan games and it was funded through Kickstarter many months ago and I remember when the Kickstarter campaign came out I looked at the game and I thought that it looked somewhat interesting but I wasn't quite pushed enough to actually back the game now Anna's can games the publisher reached out to me and asked me if I wanted to get an early copy to try it out and give my impressions and so I said sure like I remember being interested enough in it so they sent that copy over to me and I'm happy to say right now that my expectations were easily exceeded like it's a much more interesting game than I thought it was going to be but before we go into my opinions let's talk a little bit about how the game plays now you obviously have dice in this game it is called by settlers and you are going to start every single round rolling a set of your dice at the same time as everybody else around the table now there are a variety of ways in this moment that you can spend resources to re-roll some of your dice or a surprising number of ways that you could spend other resources or die faces to set the value of your dice now usually when you have a dice game a lot

of what is going on has to do with the randomness of rolling your dice but I was instantly honestly surprised at how many ways this game lets you just say nope I don't like that die I'm gonna put it over to this face so that I can be exactly that in combo offer this other thing this game gives you a surprising amount of control over how your dice actually evaluate on the round so once you have manipulated your dice and you're all doing this simultaneously then everybody will go around the table taking one action until everybody has taken just two actions and this is a pretty interesting design decision that they brought into play here because when you look at these dice and you might be rolling like six different dice and let's say you got four different icon faces on these dice then you are going to probably want to do those four different actions because when you do in action you evaluate all of the dice of that specific die face and in general you do the action better if you have more die faces of that type now what this means is you don't just get to do everything that nice the dice tell you to do you look down and you have four different types of actions in front of yourself and you have to pick two of them and you have to decide which two are gonna be the best and you are essentially crunching through this as you re rolling and setting your die faces trying to mitigate the randomness of the initial roll that you did so that you can do things that you want to do on your turn now the way this game actually played out is you all of us we were playing a four full four player game with this I think four players is the max and as we started playing we started doing various things involving like settling new land there is a map in the middle of the table with hexagons on

them and you start off with a tiny bit of presence on a cup on one of these and one of the actions you can do is explore new land and put it out there on the map now when you do that you can then put your little Hut's down on top of that land but then anybody who is adjacent who is in a tile that is adjacent to the new tile can then also send their huts onto that tile that you just put down now if they do that then you get to put another one of your huts down on top of that so that you have more huts than them and on the face of this it feels a little bit clunky but what you realize is this works really well because it means that no matter what you will if you plan correctly I guess not no matter what if you plan correctly then you will always end up in control of that tile at the end of your explore action now the reason that I put a big caveat on that is because I did not play this game well at all now there are a variety of excuses that I could give I had worked a 20-hour day the day before and I got four and a half hours of sleep that night before so I was not in tip-top mental shape and I felt like as I was playing Thai settlers also this is the last game of the night I was kind of just exploring the mechanisms and not really worrying too much about - playing really well by the end of the game was kind of regretting just being a little bit loosey-goosey with my strategy but I found there were a couple times in the early game where I did an explorer action but I didn't have enough Hut's in front of myself that's kind of the thing I'm trying to get out here is that if you do inefficient actions like exploring a tile onto the board and then putting one Hut down and then your opponent puts a hut down and then you have no more huts then you're both gonna be tied for the control over that tile which means they're probably gonna have an innate advantage and trying to wrest

control away from you also use often times get bonuses for being the person who is in control of that tile which means you have the most huts on that spot so I did a bunch of really inefficient actions essentially doing things that I shouldn't have but when I didn't have enough huts and you get huts through other actions and there are a variety of other things that are going on in this game in particular one large aspect involves bag building now this is effectively a deck building game with a bag of dice so as you were playing the game you can purchase new dice and put them into your discard pile and then when you have no more dice in your bag you put all of your dice in your bag and then you pull them out and you roll them now there are several different types of dice in this game I think five or six going off of memory and your player board shows you exactly all the time phases on the different types of dice and you are only allowed to buy dice that match the terrain that you are already having presents in with your Hut's out on the map and so what this means is you are customizing your bag to be able to do certain things better than other things and I thought that that all worked really well now all these tiles have different bonuses on them some of them are just a one-shot bonus or when you explore it and other ones like I said before will give you benefits if you control that spot and yet other ones will let you actually remove your huts from that tile to do special actions now when you add all of these things together I found that the dice Settlers of a game of dice settlers as a system worked way better than I expected oh and I remember watching it the the initial Kickstarter go out and I watched a couple playthrough videos of it I remember thinking and this doesn't it looks cool like I like a lot of those

ideas but I don't really see how it comes together but then when I was playing this game especially when I was like 3/4 the way through the game and losing horribly I just remember saying I was like I am doing terribly I am NOT gonna win and it is totally my fault there are so many ways that you could control what you're doing and there's so many cool little decisions that you can make and I was vocalizing this and everyone around the table is like yeah I'm enjoying this game a lot more than I expected to like not that everybody thought it wasn't gonna be good but there was more depth here than I expected from from the experience now the Box does I think say ninety minutes on the outside and I remember going into it thinking this doesn't feel like a 90 minute game and I think it did end up taking about 90 minutes and there were there was more to think about and more interesting things to crunch through in here than I expected so yeah overall I'm quite pleased with died settlers and I am looking forward to playing this one more okay let's now move on to game number four and this one is fertility now this one is being officially released an essence feel in the mid to late parts of October but the publisher reached out to me and asked me if I wanted to get an early copy of it to cover my impressions of it before the show and I said sure I was already somewhat interested in this game because it looked like a vibrant streamlined and dominoe sort of euro style game like a definitely a lightweight game that supposedly played in about 40 minutes and it had a bunch of things in it that looked fun and looked engaging in that 45 or so minute time frame so they sent me the game and I was able to get this one played once and it was a believe for

players and it probably did take about 45 minutes or so to play now what you're doing in this game is every single turn you're gonna take one of these little Domino pieces that are twice as long as they are wide and you were gonna put it out into this public board and every single size that matches up with the Train type of the Domino piece that you just put down is gonna generate resources that match up with that terrain type and then what you have to do on your turn is spend those resources into these shop tiles that are in front of you now you start the game with a couple pre-printed on your player board but you can buy new shop tiles to put into your area so you can kind of cultivate the options that you have in front of yourself in these shops are essentially one shot set collection on the each one of these stop areas it'll have a variety of different conditions like one might say put a papyrus and a stone down here and that'll make you a grape and then you can use that great but to put it down into another shop which might just give you two victory points or something like that now there are other shop locations where you could invest resources in them and then they will give you victory points at the end of the game that are going like certain number points based off of how many grapes you have or a certain number of a stone that you have so you can definitely try to work your way towards building a bit of a victory point engine like you get a couple of those grape ones then you really want to be able to take the tiles then have grapes on them and you are very motivated to place them down so that you will get grapes to put down on your player board to give yourself more points now overall this game is about 45 minutes and that is surprisingly quick or at least it felt surprisingly quick when I was playing the game now the rules say that you were always gonna

play nine turns no matter what the player count is and you get through those nine turns surprisingly fast I found that as I was playing the game we kind of counted up and realized I was like oh my gosh I'd like two turns left I need to do a lot of things I do have a lot of shops and I need to fill and when the game ended I didn't end up actually winning that game but I felt like I was making some pretty good decisions and I also felt like wow there's a lot of time pressure in this game like there's a lot that you want to get done in a small amount of time which definitely increases the amount of decisions that you are making as you are trying to figure out how you put this domino tile down to get these resources or that resources also there are a couple of ways to get points in particular if you put your time on download' tile down on the board in a usually somewhat inefficient way to leave a single space open on the board then you could put one of your monuments down onto the board and then you will get victory points if you have the most or second most monuments on the board at the end of the game so that's another consideration the have when placing this tile out onto the board and when we played it there was a couple moments where people were actually able to get a decent amount of resources and place a monument down and there is a decent amount of player interaction with that board in particular you will find yourself wanting to put tiles down to take the most opportune locations so that the next opponent won't won't have that option but you are also trying to consider if you are setting in the next opponent up for a really good spot now when we played this one it felt like sometimes certain players were put tiles down that really set up the next player it's like oh my gosh why did you do that and then of course the next player puts down two gets a bunch of resources and

then it's my turn and ah there is no amazing spot out there on the board so I think this is the kind of game where you really are kind of leaning on each other to be self balancing if you put down this tile on to a spot that really helps out one of your opponent's you better be getting a lot of stuff for that so you have to be very cognizant of what's going on and that is a decent amount of stuff to consider in what is essentially a nine turn game you just gonna place at nine domino tiles out and then try to fill up your shops as much as much as you can it by the end of your turn by the end of the game that is now speaking of by the end of your turn I did want to mention that you have to use your resources by the end of your turn any resources that don't go into your shops are discarded so that is yet another thing that you are considering and I think overall that this was a pretty enjoyable experience and I taught the game pretty quickly the game took about 45 minutes to play I did not get back around to playing this one again over this last month but I do see myself playing this one again in the future because you know often times I'm in a situation where we have like 45 30 to 45 minutes or so to a play game and the fact that this one played about 45 minutes for four players means that it will fit very nicely in that kind of time slot and I think for what it was setting out to do it does a pretty good job up next we now have game number five and this one is eyeless guy but in particular with the journeyman expansion now this expansion came out last year at Essen and I intended to buy it there but kind of forgot to and then that continued to forget to get it over the course of the last year but then last month I went into a friendly local game store because I had

some store credit and I saw it on the shelf and I said you know I'm gonna go ahead by that because Isle of Skye is one of my favorite board games like it is just such a brilliant system of tile Lang and auctioning and now I'm not generally crazy about auctioning in games but the way that I love Skye works is every single turn every player gets three tiles and then they simultaneously set a price for each one of those tiles well one of those tiles actually has to be removed and then they put money down next to the other ones then you all reveal at your little shields and then everybody gets a chance to buy one tile from an opponent for the price that they associated with it and if at the end of the round nobody bought your tile then you lose that money and you have effectively bought that time for that price so you have this amazing decision set of do I want do I want this tile if I don't want the tile that I want to put enough money on it just enough so that it gets purchased away from me so that I get money for that being bought but if I really want this tile but I want to put enough money on it so that no one's gonna buy away from me now that's the basic gist of what's going on with Isle of Skye and the journeyman expansion brings in a somewhat significant module and when we played this it was not really the ideal setup for it because we were playing a four player game and only two of us had ever played Isle of Skye before now I mentioned when I sat down to play the game two of these two people I said you know you're more than welcome to play this game with us I will teach Alice Kai but I am gonna be playing it with this expansion and this expansion it brings in quite a lot of complexity if you're okay with that they said they were so I taught the full game and I said okay now it's time to bring in the expansion and what's going on

here is you have it this board that you put in front of yourself with which shows various statistics for your journeyman essentially the journeyman is this pawn that is out on your personal little tiling area and he is going to wander around your zone every single round and the places that the journeyman visits is going to interact with this board so that you can upgrade the various tracks on that specific board now the tracks might say you need to go to the northernmost tile in your area you also have to stop on a spot that has and the next one might be stopped on the spot with the ship and then another one that might have something to do with landing in a fully complete region in your zone now what that means is on your turn you have this entirely new phase after you have built out your tiles you put these little Waypoint cubes down on to your area and then your journeyman is gonna travel from cube to cube and that every single cube spawn you can evaluate the things and move your little tracks forward which might allow you to move your tournament farther you will have the ability to unlock more waypoints so that you can activate the journeyman even more and you are gonna get to a variety of victory points as well as increased income and lots of other things on this board there's certainly quite a bit going on here now overall I quite enjoy the game I mean obviously I love I love sky so I was predisposed to enjoying this expansion but it really does add a surprising amount more to the game and to a certain extent it detracts from some of the greatness of the original game so while I enjoyed playing

this game I'm not sure if I'll play it every time and the big thing that really stood out to me was income now as you were playing I love sky even the version you have a certain amount of income that you are making and as you get more of these little kegs of whiskey if you connect them up to your castle within your tie line area then your income is going to go up and there are a couple other ways to get income in particular there's a bit of income as a ketchup mechanic but money can be very tight in the base game of I'll sky but with journeyman there are lots of ways to increase your income and also just get influxes of money and we found that we just had so much money as we were playing this game that nobody really cared about the kegs of beer or connecting them back to your castle like it seemed silly to put effort towards connecting that up to get one extra income when I could move my journeyman over here and move it there and boom now I'm getting like two or three extra income for that position for the rest of the game now at the very end of these tracks or near the end of the tracks on the journeyman board there are these three super-powerful abilities that are randomized every time you play the game and they add into this this money problem even more because one of them says that you never even have to pay for the towels that you take anymore you pay with the bank so you're still gonna give money to the person you take the towel from but you don't even spend your money so you already had all this income and now you don't even need to spend it and obviously well not maybe not obviously but at the end of the game your coins can be worth victory points as well so hoarding money is good but there are there's another title that lets you purchase two different titles from opponents which I guess means you will be potentially spending some of your money unless you have both of those

combos at the same time and then you just bind tiles like crazy with not your own money and honestly in this moment I can't remember what the third super-powerful thing was but either way you probably get the idea that journeyman adds a lot to this game but what that means is some of the tightness and elegance of the original game it's lost of it by all of the extra bonuses and bobs and whistles and things that you get with this new module that you added to the game so I think that I will certainly play journeyman again in the future but I do not think this is gonna be and every time had I think there is still a lot to be said about playing Isle of Skye with just the base game and I'm honestly not sure if I would recommend to somebody that they get a journeyman if they're in situation like me where they have store credit that they feel like spending then sure give it a shot because it does add some pretty interesting decisions and a lot more meat to this overall game but it's not really a game that seemed like it needed it so yeah overall I have a bit of a mixed opinion of it I do plan on playing it again in the future but just not every time let's now move on to game number six and this one is lisboa now I've covered this one before on the channel but I played it over this last month and it was the first time I've played it in about a year and I figured I wouldn't mind talking about it again right here so what's going on here is you have a very heavy game that's designed by Vitaly Sirte and it's all about rebuilding the town of Lisbon after it was hit by an earthquake a tsunami and a fire all within the course of a week or so and from a mechanical perspective there's a lot going on here and I know I've talked about this game a couple times on the channel so I'm not going to go into all the nitty gritty but the basic idea is every turn you are

going to play a single card and you're gonna play it down either into your own tableau and tuck it in to give yourself one shot or ongoing bonuses or you'll play it out onto the board and then activate it to do a variety of different things now this game gets at several different actions from a couple different ways like you could tuck a card in front of yourself to do an action on the board or you could put the card down onto the board to do that same action but you're gonna be spending different resources to get at similar actions to evaluate these different things now what this means is this game is a pretty big thing to teach like it is not an easy game to learn at all and when we had a game day last month in fact it was right after we played a piece for Odin one of my friend said I want to play lisboa and I said you know I wouldn't mind playing lisboa right now as well I looked at the clock and I was like yeah I know this is gonna take probably three to four hours including the teach but we have enough time so let's do it and I felt confident in that moment that I would be able to teach the game because I had played it like three or so times in the past and I remembered feeling like the iconography kind of lend itself towards the mechanics like you go here and there's little icons to show you what you can do so we started setting up this game and swiftly as we were putting these pieces out and setting everything up I realized that I remembered nowhere near as much as I thought I did about this game even basic ideas were actually non-existent in my brain and I I'm used to remembering most of the rules to game so I guess this one just left my brain a little bit quicker than I expected fortunately one of the four players that we were playing with had played before as

so combined with the two of us and this extensive player aid which is like a multi-page booklet we were able to work our way through the rules and it actually only took us about 40 minutes to teach the game which is surprising considering how rough I was about how the actual game worked now from that point on we proceeded to play and I think it took about three hours which is the amount of time I've seen this game take in the past because there is just a lot to consider as you're playing this game analysis paralysis is definitely a thing and there's a lot of subtle ripple effects like you do a thing and you don't really realize that what you're doing is allowing this other thing to happen and then this other thing to happen and it opens up good opportunities for your opponents and there are certainly many ways that you are interacting with your opponents some in a positive way and some in a negative way for instance if you buy ships then you can if somebody one of your opponents buys a ship then I can sell my goods onto their ship and they're gonna get a victory point for it but I'm gonna be the one getting the money for it so there's a positive interaction going on there but then the actual town of Lisbon that you are building up in it is only so big and as you were playing the game you were building private buildings and public buildings and there were several times where an opponent got in my way and did something right before I was about to do it and on a couple of those occasions as I was playing I realized I could have done that last turn why didn't I do that last turn if I done that last turn then I would have done it before them and then I would have gotten these things which I really needed and definitely a lot of head smacking moments as I was playing this game which is not too surprising considering there's so much to consider now as we

got deeper and deeper into the game I found myself really enjoying the play like I've enjoyed this one in the past I really liked it the first time I played it and then I cooled on it a little bit which is part of the reason why it hasn't been played in a while mostly it hasn't been played because it takes so long for us to play it but I found myself really enjoying this play I'm really glad we got to play it and I did feel like I was in contention to win this one I had spoiler alert I didn't but it was somewhat close there at the end and what's going on here at the end of the game is there are these decrees that you can pick up as you're playing which give you victory points at the end of the game based off of so many different conditions like how much rebel you've picked up how many houses are on specific rows and columns of the board there's just so many different things that are associated with these two and conditions and in the past I remember I always felt like I lost because I ended the game with like three or so of these decrees and the person who won had like eight so I all throughout this play I was like I'm just doing everything I can to get these decrees I ended the game I think with the most I had like nine or maybe even ten decrees in front of myself at the end but I still didn't win all of these decrees just because you have a lot of them does not mean that you are gonna get the most points for them some decrees will give you five points and then some of the other ones I had only gave me one or two points because the conditions didn't match up to that well so overall it was fun everyone around the table and joyed it this is a game I do want to continue playing in the future although it wouldn't surprise me if I end up playing this one less than one time a year which means every single time I sit down to play this game I'm gonna have to sort of relearn it myself as I'm teaching it which is definitely a barrier to entry unfortunately but at

the end of the day this is a satisfying heavy game that unfortunately just gets in its own way as far as actually being able to hit the table that often it's now time to move on to game number seven and this one is sword crafters now this one was sent over to me by the publisher of the game in fact they sent me the extended version of the game that comes with three expansion modules that you can work into the overall game and what's going on here is you have an I split you to style game where you are literally building a sword now when I say literally I mean you're not to like adding tiles to a little sword that's face up in front of yourself on the table you have a three-dimensional sword with a three-dimensional pommel that you have in front of yourself and you add these these square tiles into your sword as you build it up in these four different signs so it's essentially a a rectangle a long extruded rectangle of a sword and these tiles fit together really well with each other so you make a surprisingly solid sword and from a toy perspective this game is quite enamored right as you are going through the game you're building this bigger and bigger sword and everyone's like looking at each other swords and playing with them and spinning him around and as other people were walking by the table they definitely stopped him well what the heck is going on there we said we're building swords it's a game called sword crafting and so here we are actually crafting them now from a mechanical perspective what you were trying to do with these swords is match up the different gem colors with each other each side each of the four sides on your sword is going to score for its set of adjacent gems so you are constantly thinking about trying to get you know your purples texture your

purples and your reds next your reds but it's not as easy as that necessarily sounds because the main mechanic for the game is I split you choose and in a four player game which is what we played you have a four by four grid of these tiles in the middle of the table and the starting player is going to split that pile into two piles and the next person will split one of those two piles into a third pile and so on until everybody has done this and then the start player will take an entire pile of these tiles and just start adding them into their sword while everybody else came to use to grab them until the final person has an option between two different piles to add into their sword now what this means is you are trying to cut up this chunk of tiles in ways that won't lend aid to your various opponents but you do have a somewhat semantic restriction and that you have to cut in a straight line through these piles it's effectively like you would take your sword and you actually cut right there so you can't take a tiny notch out of a pile you have to do row or a column as you break these into smaller chunks and what we found was as we were playing the game this actually was a bit of a hindrance on some of the ideas that we were trying to put together for how we split this up because it seemed like every time would come around to the last player there would be these four different chunks of four gems and they would have to either choose one of these four and turn it into a 1 and the 3 or a 2 and a 2 and they would just know that that was going to be their options they were gonna have the option between that one and those 3 or the 2 and the 2 because it seemed like every time it went around the table people always went after more tiles

versus going after that smaller chunk that might have the tiles of the gems that specifically match up for them now part of this might be just groupthink and we weren't really paying as much attention to what was going on as we could but part of this also has to do with the overwhelming amount of stuff that you're trying to consider first of all you were trying to consider how you're going to be building up your sword in front of yourself you might look down and say I want I have two purples already I want to get two more purples next to each other but they're next to each other in the length of the sword which means you actually can't just put two Purple's in there you have to put a purple in there and then something else and then two more something else's and then you can put another purple in there as you are kind of Lincoln log style building this sort out in front of yourself so you were oftentimes trying to take the big stack of tiles that has maybe the two colors in it that you want so that you have fodder tiles to put in so that you can line up the tiles that you want also we play this game with a couple of the modules one for the base game and one from the extended part the base game one it was sword magic which was essentially at the end of the game the person who has the least number of this type of gem is going to get a certain number of points and the person has the most number of this other gem or this pair will get this other subset of points so now you are considering how many of the different gem types that you have compared to your opponents and again these are three-dimensional swords so if there are four different sides you can look at and the rules specifically say you're not allowed to ask your opponent to spin their sword around so you can look at the different sides and the other module we were considering or that we used is called sword tips where you kind of put it at the on the end of your sword at the end of the game and you will get bonus points if one of the phases of your sword matches up with the

restrictions on that specific tip so now you're trying to consider that amongst everything else and it seems like maybe we just kind of gave up on some of that analysis and just went for the most of these tiles because you also got bonus points for having the longest sword at the end of the game so it definitely seemed like the person in last place was in kind of a bum spot and because of that they the first player marker changed quite a bit and you never really wanted to be in last place as the game was going along and I couldn't help but feel like that thematic idea of cutting in a straight line was somewhat restrictive to the strategy of what we were trying to do in it and that kind of enforced this situation where the last person oftentimes had these four different chunks of four different tiles instead of having like a two and a three and a one over there that never seemed to organically happen well when we were midway through the round and at the end of the day we finished the game we added up all the points and everybody seemed to enjoy the experience but everyone also seemed mildly fatigued add all of the decisions that they had going on and I guess if the idea of all these decisions sounds exciting to you then this is a game that has a lot of decisions for you it certainly was not a long game it was less than an hour and there is a lot to think about within that give an hour but to a certain extent for us it seemed like we almost stopped paying as much attention to the analysis as we maybe should have because we didn't want the game to necessarily grind to a stall I think that my opinion of the game one when it is now over is that it is very

likely that I'll play this one again because it was pretty cool building up these swords it has a great novelty factor there and I might I might not use the sword tips next time I might use one of the other modules or just one module instead of having to to try and simplifying some of the decisions that we have making that we're making as we're playing the game and see if I enjoyed that experience more but I couldn't help but go away from this feeling like a game like animals on board that lets you do this I split you choose thing but with less of that line restriction lends itself more towards creative bundles of different tiles that you can take then in this one where it seemed like people were oftentimes just going to try and have the most tiles so yeah overall and I think it was a fun game it was not necessarily as fun as I was hoping it would be but it was a good time around the table and it is definitely a new addition into the I split you choose genre of games that is somewhat crowded there are a lot of good options out there and this one is certainly the most novel out of all of those when it comes to actually constructing that sword up next we now have game number 8 and that is Teotihuacan now this is a large heavy euro game that was sent over to me by nsk and games and actually got it in order to make a full playthrough video which I posted last week now I've played this one that three times over the last month including that one playthrough that I recorded and there is a lot going on in this game in fact I played it for the first time in demo form last March at gamma and it was largely the same game although there were some tweaks and differences that I

saw here there now when it comes to actually what you're doing in this game I'm gonna be brief because it well spoiler alert the teacher can take a while the first time I taught this game it took me like 45 minutes to get through everything which I felt a little bit bill T about the people I was playing with were somewhat fatigued at the end of that but either way what's going on here is you have a board in the middle of the table and there are eight different locations that ring the outside of the board now each player has three workers which are used with dice on the board and you'll never roll these dice instead the the dining just shows you the strength of the worker now when it's your turn all you're gonna do is choose one of your three workers and you're gonna move them one two or three spaces around clockwise these eight different locations around the board and when you land on that spot you can do three different things you can either gather cocoa when you get more cocoa if there are a variety of different colored workers that already you could also worship on that spot which locks your worker in for a bit and the other thing you could do is just evaluate the main action now there are eight different locations and three of them work functionally the same way but that's still a lot of different action types that you have to compute and understand when you're playing the game and they do a variety of things consisting of giving you a bunch of resources and letting you spend resources to build up to this pyramid in the middle of the table and as you add tiles to the pyramid you're gonna gain victory points based off of how the symbols match on those tiles but then certain symbols are colored and if you match a colored symbol and you get to go up one of the three temple tracks and there are a variety of other ways that you can go up these temple tracks and

every time you go up them you get the reward that's listed on it whether that is Coco which effectively lets you move your workers around victory points or resources that you can use to do things like building the pyramid now there are these three temple tracks but there's another track a fourth track called the Avenue of the Dead and you're gonna go up this track whenever you build noble buildings which cost wood and also every time one of your workers a sense now this ascending is one of the key attributes to the game whenever you evaluate a spot you are almost always going to upgrade one of your workers that did to that action and you instantly increase its value by one now whenever a worker goes from a five to a six they immediately ascend and you will gain a bonus you will also go up once on that Avenue of the Dead track and that worker will turn back into a one and start back out on the board so it's kind of like you've got rid of that worker they've ascended into the heavens or you know whatever and then you gain a new acolyte out there and the palace on the board now as you're playing this game you get victory points for doing all sorts of stuff involved like with the temple tracks you get points for some of those you get points as you build up the pyramid you are going to gain point modifiers as you go up that Avenue of the Dead tract because three times a game there's gonna be this large scoring that's gonna give points for how well you built up the pyramid that round it'll score your Avenue of the Dead at times a modifier that will decrease as the game goes on and you will also get points for these different sets of masks that you can acquire through a variety of ways and I think at this point I should probably stop talking about mechanics because you

should have a decent idea that there is a lot going on with this game and many of these things kind of interconnect now I've played this one like I mentioned three times the first time was four players and it took a while it took us almost three hours actually it was pretty much three hours on the dot to finish that game and that was longer than I think all of us were wanting in that exact moment downtime was certainly rearing its head with that play but part of that is analysis paralysis between players and I know that I can definitely suffer suffer from analysis paralysis in board games in general and a couple of people I was playing with are also not the fastest players in the world the second time I played it was three players and we finished that game in two hours and I have no idea how long the third place you took because obviously that was like two full days of filming but that's not really a factor either way this is not a short game overall and there is a lot to calculate and I've enjoyed the process of playing through this game but I felt like downtime could sometimes be a little bit more than I wanted and a big part of that has to do with the amount of planning that you have to do in this game now the planning is not poorly designed there's just a ton of planning that are injected into every single action that you're doing since the way this game works is you activate a worker and you move them around the board you can easily and you probably should plan out multiple turns in the future like I'm gonna put a worker there and then move this one there and then join them up together or there to do a more powerful action but the thing is that almost everything you do is going to cost resources in general cocoa and there is this feeling of getting nickel and dimed as you are

playing this game because you are gonna move this work over there and okay that costs to cocoa for this and you want to do that which will get you this and that and the next journey I'm gonna go over there and that's gonna cost one or two and then I'm gonna do a double activation which would give me another cocoa for this and then the third turn I'm gonna need cocoa for that but wait I crossed over the threshold and I have a technology that activates when I go over the spot to give me extra cocoa and it feels like you are just swimming in the sea of small number as you are adding and subtracting one two three back and forth up and down and the resources in this game are pretty tight you will have times where you activate a resource spot multiple times and have just so much stone and you're like I will never be able to use all this stone and then four turns later you'll like I need more stone used at all and that definitely comes into play with the cocoa as well because again you have to spend a cocoa when you land on locations with other workers on them including your own workers and you want to activate those spots so it seems like having to plan ahead and math all of that stuff out and consider how much the stuff that you have in front of yourselves and also considering the fact that if you're off by one your whole plan can come crumbling down means you have a lot to think about and you can obviously be thinking about this when it's not your turn but your opponent's moving the workers on two spots might increase the cocoa cost for that location which means that you now need to reassess your math and maybe change up your plan I think that's overall but my overall feel up opinion of the game is that I have enjoyed playing it and I am actively looking forward to playing this one more there's a lot of depth there but at the same time I can't help but feel like the game is a little bit

heavier than I want it to be and maybe a little bit heavier then I feel like it should be there are so many different bells and whistles and stuff going on in this game that I feel like some things could have been trimmed out in particular the avenue of the dead track you go up that again every time you ascend with one of your workers and also every time you build these little buildings but all that does is give you a point multiplier against the number of buildings that have already been built out so it's kind of like a tacked on extra track and all it does is give you points and there's so many ways to get victory points in this game already that that is just one example of something where I feel like I would rather play table to con without that fourth track like three tracks is more than enough you can do so much stuff with those and you know when you ascend a worker you could just say that you go up one of those tracks or there's other things that you can do I just feel like that is one example of a mechanic that's kind of grafted in that doesn't necessarily drive with all of the other stuff that's going on also when you do these worship actions that kind of lock your dice in you usually have the option I think always actually of doing one thing or the other or you could spend one cocoa to do both and this is another case of the nickel and diming where you have to consider the cost of that extra cocoa to do both activations and you usually want to do both activations so I personally feel like I would rather the game had been designed in such a way to get rid of that and just every time you worship and lock in a worker you do both because you're almost always gonna want to do that anyway and it's just one less thing that you have to add into this equation that you are constantly running as

you're planning out your turns now I don't want to sound too harsh here I think all of these things work just fine this is just my personal feeling like if I had been developing the game these are the ways that I would have pushed the game in that direction maybe then the direction it actually ended up being but where it actually is is a really solid game at this point I'm not sure if it is a great game but it is certainly a good game and there is so much to delve into as you're playing the game and a decent amount of variability that you can change up from one plate to the next that I am looking forward to playing this one more I just feel like the play time is also gonna make it a little bit of a factor for how often it comes out I don't think every four player game will last three hours but I think that most three player games will last probably the two hours and the four player game maybe can get shortened down to like two and a half or so based off of the players that I'm with and that's a decent amount of time and so I am hoping to play this one more it's just I guess at the end of the day a little bit heavier and a little bit longer than I was hoping okay we've now reached the ninth and final game I'll be talking about today and that one is Western legends now this one was a Kickstarter game and I think it recently got sent out to all of the backers and one of those backers is a friend of mine and he brought it over to a game night last week and I saw and I said I want to play that one and the reason I said that is largely because I'm very good friends with Eska who is half of the no pun included YouTube channel and we've been chatting back and forth for the last couple weeks and he's mentioned several times that he was excited to play Western legends and then

that he was enjoying the things that he was seeing in that and actually this is a good moment to mention that they just published a full review of that game so feel free to check out the no pun included review of the game they go into some great detail of the positives and negatives for the game from their perspective from my perspective I wanted to give it a shot because fqo was mentioning that there was some interesting stuff happening here and so we got it to the table and we played a four player game of it now what you're doing in this game is you are effectively trying to be a legendary cowboy out in the West and there are so many ways that you can gain legendary points and that's gonna be the way you win the game just having the most legendary points it's a bit of a sandbox game because you can go in tons of different directions you could become a robber and you could rob the bank and you could do a bunch of other negative things to the board you could rob other players and you will actually go up this wanted track which will give you a legendary points every single turn or you could be a good guy and actually like a really good guy and be a marshal and you can do good things like delivering cattle safely and actually hunting down bandits and that will push you up the marshal track which just gives you which just gives you a smaller number of points at the end of the game so obviously you are incentivized to try and be bad because it gives you points that return and in the normal-length game you play until 20 victory points and then count up with the rest of the points that you get so gaining two points a turn is somewhat significant now you can do other things like you can gamble in order to play a little game of sort of poker against the house and or

your opponents that happen to be in the same town and you can spend your money to go buy a bunch of a pieces of equipment which might make you move around faster and get better guns so you can fight your opponents as well as the bandits better and you can also also go to the Cabaret I think and spend money to just get victory points there now overall this leaves the this leaves you in a somewhat daunting position in the very start of the game where you trying to figure out what you should do and I guess a daunting might be an overstatement but they're just so many directions you can walk and just spin around and then walk in one direction and odds are good you will find legendary points in that area but you might not actually have fun with that thing that you're doing so at the start of the game I decided I had a character who gets extra bonuses if you are a marshal and you do I think marshal things or if you're wanted and you do want to type things and I was like I'm gonna be a marshal type player I'll be good and I'm gonna deliver some cattle from one point to the railroad I'm gonna get more marshal points for that and that's gonna be kind of the thing that I'm doing while I'm doing other things and what I found out was that was actually pretty boring it meant I was moving to a spot at picking up cows and then spending like a full turn to move to the other spot and drop the cows off and then I guess spending actions to get back over and pick up more cows obviously the game does not want you to try and do the same thing over and over again it's trying to incentivize you that while you're over there visit the mine and kill off some bandits and get some extra marshal points for that and while you're at the mind maybe you should do some prospecting and you know it has that kind of thing going on and I realized that pretty quickly that I shouldn't be just trying to do the same thing over and over again I should branch out now I did branch out to a certain extent I

went to prospecting and when you prospect you roll a couple dice and you're gonna get gold nuggets or other things like honestly can't remember because what happened for me is there's one I believe one X on each die and I roll the die and I got two X's which meant I got nothing and and then that was the only time I prospected all game on now there is a piece of equipment you could buy to make to give you rerolls when you're prospecting and that was some pretty bad luck but overall is like okay well I'm not gonna be prospecting anymore and all the while I was kind of bumbling around trying to do this and do that one of the players was just doing the same thing over and over again and it really felt like they were kind of breaking the game what they did was at the start of the game they bought to a 10-gallon hat which i think is pretty cheap it's a piece of equipment that says that whenever you go gambling when you gain an extra legendary point and if you lose you get 10 bucks back and it costs 10 bucks to anti in so you effectively get everything back if you lose the at gambling now when you win at gambling you already get a victory point and what this player ended up doing is they would sit at the gambling spot and every single turn I believe you get three actions don't quote me on that but you get a certain number of actions it was three or four and they've just sat there and they just gambled and then gambled and then gambled and then they would head over to the Cabaret spot and then spend all their money into victory points and then they would go back and then gamble gamble gamble in cabaret and these two locations are literally next to each other so you could just gamble game a gamble walk spend at a cabaret gamble gamble gamble and you might say well this is a game

where you should probably be balancing between the players like if this person is gambling like crazy you should go over there and you should fight them and steal half of their money but the problem is that you get so much money just for gambling the the house puts 50 bucks down into the pots right away and then you add your own ante on top of that and then if other people play then you even more antes go in there and you have a hard cap of 120 money so it seemed like he was able to gamble twice against the house both times the house would put 50 bucks into that pot and then if he won both times which it seemed like he had good cards he was consistently winning he would max out right there and then head over to the Cabaret and then spend the money all the way back down to zero in order to get some points and there was one moment in the game when we were probably I don't know 45 minutes to an hour in where that one player had 17 legendary points and the next person had seven and then six and then I had four I had for legendary points when somebody had 17 because all they were doing was this really boring gambling cabaret thing and at that point they honestly could have won but they got so bored with it that they decided well before the game ends I want to try doing something else so they went off and they did some other things and that actually let the rest of us get a few more turns and that person did not end up winning but they effectively let go of the win because they got so bored they could have easily ended the game like four rounds before the game actually did end and in those intervening four rounds one of the players was able to get a bunch of other things together which got them a bunch of endgame victory points and they ended up winning by just one point so I guess at the end of the day you could

say well but that person didn't win but that's because they just got so bored now at this point I realized that I have glossed over the coolest mechanic of the game and I probably should mention it and that involves this deck of cards now I mentioned that you were going to be playing poker as you're playing the game and you have this 52 card deck of cards actually there were a couple Joker's in there I think so maybe a 54 card deck and every single one of these cards has an action that's printed on them now for an action on your turn you could spend one of these cards to do the action printed on the card or you could hold onto these cards and then use them when you're playing poker or you could use these cards when you are dueling with bandits or with other players now the way the cards work is it seems like the higher value of the card so you know like king queen and ace they have one of some of the most powerful effects so that when you draw that card you feel incentivized to well or you feel a push and pull where you like I should hold on to this because I will win at poker or win a duel with this ace but if I play the ACE then I'll get this really great effect right now so let me do other things and the lower value cards also every card had actions on it but it seemed like some of the lower value ones were also quite powerful like they would let you kind of teleport from town to town or one of the one of the two's is a cheat at poker lets it be a wild card but it seemed like the mid-range cards were much more situational and less less impactful and there was one moment where it seemed like that one player who just kept winning at poker maybe one of the other opponents just said I've never seen any of those cards they're just like I've gone this whole game and I've seen like four is through nines and when you have

a four through nine you're not guaranteed to win at poker you're certainly not guaranteed to win at a duel because a higher value card is gonna win at do it the dueling and they're just like I've never had one of the teleporting I've never had that gained two extra actions like I want those cards and I keep drawing from this deck and I just keep not getting those cool cards and they were feeling a bit frustrated that it felt like they were just getting bad luck from that card draw whereas another player was getting good luck from those cards and they were doing very well with it so overall I think that card mechanic is cool like it's definitely a great idea the way that all bundles together but from a luck perspective it does seem like sometimes the grass is greener where you just like man my card good how that other person is doing so well so overall this was just one play of the game and I have to admit that I feel like I want to play this game again I feel like that most of the people around the table there was this general level of frustration as we were playing and I think part of that was because we didn't feel like there was anything we could do to slow down this player who was racing up the track even if we had tried to go and fight them we would have stolen half of their money and they were just gamble and give it all back again with one action potentially of course you don't always win at gambling but they did seem to be pretty good at it and it just seemed like why waste all this time trying to hamper them when we could try to maybe do other things now one thing that we didn't really do was explore that Wanted track where you get points every single turn I do do you think I want to play this game again and part of me wants to just try and be as wanted as humanly possible to get way up on that track and do lots of dastardly things like robbing banks and whatnot so that I get points every single round while doing some other things like rest rest

wrestling some cows or rustling I can't remember there's two different terms one of the things is bad with cows and one of the things is good but I think there is a lot to explore here and I think if that friend brings it around again I will be interested in trying it again because it's it's it is kind of an interesting sandbox it just seemed like the play that we had lent itself unfortunately tubing to frustration for everybody and I'm not sure if that's gonna be every single time we sit down to play the game or if this was just one somewhat negative play experience overall so yeah I I'm hoping to get another shot of giving this one try okay that's gonna wrap up this impressions vlog for the month there were only 9 here and I think that next month there will probably be a lot more because there are quite a few games that I know are heading my way and just a lot of games that are coming out so I hope you found this one interesting and if you have any questions about any of the segments that I just talked about for any of these games then feel free to comment down below and yeah I think that's gonna wrap this one up as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including all of these producer level patreon backers if you two would like to directly support these videos and please go to junkets Gamescom slash support to see a variety of ways with which you could do that also if you enjoyed this video please consider clicking the like button down below as well as a subscribe button thanks for watching

Progress saved