Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 20
Transcript
hey everyone and welcome to another edition of board games i got rid of and why this is a series where i talk about all the games that have previously been in my collection but for one reason or another are no longer in my collection and i tried to give some rationale as to why i came to that decision because often it's not as bad as it sounds uh before i get into these 10 games i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda code uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk they have some fantastic loyalty schemes a great selection of games and if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but without further ado let's get on with the video okay so the first game i'm talking about this episode is robert knights which ironically featured on a top 10 list of mine recently that is top 10 games that are low rated that i still happen to like so this one is not considered to be a great game and it's actually by rudy gadon who is a very prolific and successful designer and this one was um i did use one of the mechanisms that rudiger dawn is most known for the idea of taking a stack of discs and dropping them off as you go as you visit different tiles and this one you are basically trying to have majority or have the final piece on the stack of disks on each tile to claim victory points however it's very abstract in the the way this game works much more abstract than dawn's other designs as you can try and block people off you can try and get the final piece nobody else can overlap you and there's some good talk placement there's some good strategy and some good forward thinking
in this game and in fact if you like abstract style games um this is probably one of the best ones i've played you know i'm personally i'm not a big fan of abstracts the people i play with aren't big fans of abstract style games so therefore these kind of games do not get to the table regularly if ever for me but that being said i could still really appreciate this game and i really do feel like this has a huge untapped potential on people who had yet to explore this one and could enjoy it so i think it's a shame it's not taking off as well as it could have but i suppose you could call me a bit of a hypocrite because i haven't got in my own collection but that's because i cannot keep everything i play and you know this one did stick around for a good time i played it a good few times way more than any other abstract game that i normally play so in that respect i got to give this one a lot of props but ultimately wasn't quite right for me personally long term the next game i'm talking about is a feast for odin which i'm more than prepared to get a bit of backlash on because this is considered to be one of uv rosenberg's best game if not his best game so this is a shoot a huge sprawling um style game very very sandboxy in the way it feels as you can do pretty much anything here any mechanism you can think of is um used in this game has some dice rolling has a lot of kind of polyamino tile placement and but for me the thing that stopped me really enjoying this game to the you know to the level that a lot of other people do i felt this game lacked a bit of focus i thought there was just too much going on it was a bit too sad boxy for me where i thought
if i was going to do one thing i pretty much neglecting the whole other half of the game i thought the card play was a little bit weak in it as well and it felt a bit tacked on and just ultimately i wasn't willing to invest that much time or effort into getting the most from this one you know this can kind of be a lifestyle game because there is so much to explore here and it just wasn't quite a good fit for my personal taste but i think even fans of a atheist rodent can appreciate that if you don't like you know so many options or have that sandbox you feel then they might even accept that this might not be the game for that style of gamer which happens to be the style of gamer that i am the next game i'm talking about is circle the wagons which is actually a pretty nifty little um button shy games you've got like 18 cards here and it actually uses this kind of drafting system um as you have three public objectives and you're trying to acquire these cards and have this kind of overlapping card puzzle where you're revealing and covering up symbols based on the layout and how you position these cards i thought this game had a very cool mechanism in it where you could skip over as many cards as you want in this rondelle to collect the cards you want but anything you skip over goes to your opponent and that can be used positively or it can be used quite negatively as you might be giving them a bunch of cards that you know they can't handle and cannot lay out efficiently so i thought that was a very clever design and to be honest the game in its entirety is well polished um ultimately the reason this one left the collection was because i don't get to play two player games that often um more
often i'm playing at three or four players the two player games i've acquired since and even before i'm circle of wagons i tend to enjoy a bit more so if i'm gonna play a two-player game i'm probably going to lean towards something like hanamikoji or mandala or even something like battle line or lost cities and i prefer all those games more than i prefer circle the wagons now that's no um that's no detriment to circle the vikings i think it's a very good game um but when it's pushed that far down the totem pole i just know i'm not gonna get it played anytime soon the fourth game i'm talking about is kodachi which is a strange hybrid kind of deck building pushy luck style game based with this kind of japanese samurai feel um and the idea of this one is you're trying to overcome all these different enemies either through strength or through stealth and those are going to depend on the cars you have in your hand so if you have all low cards you're probably going to go for stealth if you have all high cards you're going to go for strength and we're going to do is going to be revealing these enemy cards trying to overcome them with the cards you have in your hand and then deciding whether to stop or to continue and if you stop you can end up collecting currency and then buying new cars into your deck and getting points as you go pretty clever actually the way it worked um the issues that happened with this one was that it did feel a little bit convoluted um maybe tried a bit too hard to you know lean away from the luckier side of pushy lock games and also i thought that was a little bit too long and this might sound silly but the luck factor in this game was almost too much like often
you would have a perfect hand of cards you'd overcome a bunch of them and it would just work out for you then sometimes you might have a great hand of cards all low numbers then all of a sudden there's one that you just that's like a zero that's almost impossible to overcome unless you have this very specific card in your hand and then you'd automatically be forced to lose straight away even though you were in a good position to start with so that for me happened one too many times and it ended up becoming a bit frustrating and i kind of like to know what i'm playing with if i am playing a pushy lock style game you know i always lean towards something a bit simpler and just have that more visceral pushy luck tension rather than trying to gamify it too much the next game i'm talking about is brussels 1897 which is the card game version of brussels 1893. now despite being purely made up of cars this is like a worker placement style game as you are placing your workers which are cars that come in different denominations of money onto other cars based on these four different columns and not only are you trying to collect the um the abilities by placing your workers on them such as getting money or um getting new characters to to use stuff like that but also when you're placing these um these cards down you're trying to get majorities in these columns because whoever's got the majority in each of those columns gets another bonus and on top of that you're also trying to build up these shields because when you place your workers they all connect to each other which can give you another kind of a sub game within the main game which i thought was a really interesting touch and i'd love to see that explored more um there were however i thought some
rushed parts of the game for example there was this building mechanism that i thought was very obtuse and it didn't flow naturally and ultimately i thought this game did have a bit of an identity crisis for me because it was a bit too involved for a filler and a bit too long for a fellow because you're talking about maybe 45 minutes to an hour to play this one um but it was also like too short and not enough going on if you want like a main event experience so those kind of games to me normally struggle to get to the table because i normally want something really light breezy and filler style or i want my big crunchy heavy euro this one kind of laid in the middle of them which meant that again i struggled to find where this would fit into my collection the next game i'm talking about is augustus or rise of augustus depending on the version you have and this is essentially a gamified version of bingo where all you're doing is you're drawing these tokens from a bag and allocating those symbols to the different characters that you've collected and you're trying to match all the symbols as quickly as you can because when you complete them not only do you get victory points you might also get a bonus which will help you complete the other ones as well so it kind of has this domino effect where certain people will help you complete other ones there's easy ones there's more difficult ones um and you're trying to complete sets and get points in different ways um it's way better than it sounds on paper you might think this is just this is just bingo and yeah at the heart of it it is but there's just enough you know just enough tweaks here to make it enjoyable and i had fun with it is it gonna be something that stays
around forever clearly not because i had my phone with it and i was ready to move on from it um but i still think that if you really like simple games then you could get some fun from rise of augustus but ultimately for me it was one that i was happy to play and move on with pretty quickly next up i have carter hania which is another game that i actually have enjoyed my time with um but ultimately it just didn't have the legs to keep me coming back to it so this is a family friendly almost like a racing style game as you have a bunch of these pirates who've escaped from jail and you're trying to move them on this track by playing cards and matching symbols to get them to the escape boat i love the level of player interaction in this game as when you play certain simple cards you jump to the next available one and however if somebody stood that on that symbol then you jump to the next one so sometimes if loads of people are stood on the same simple with one single card play you could jump halfway or even three quarters across the track with a single card which is really interesting it also has this kind of economy where you quickly run out of cars and then you need to start moving your people back um along the track to acquire new cars into your hand and that in itself is very puzzly you want to block people off and slow them down you want to capitalize on things when the board is kind of in your favor with the cards you have in your hand and there's a lot to be had here very streamlined very few rules again for a family friendly game with with still still some interesting decisions this is a very good option i
played this on a good few times i had successes with it i think the best way to play it is shortening the map to keep it nice and snappy um but as i said earlier i think once you've got this out your system you've played it a few times there really isn't that much more to explore but i still thought it was good for what it was so that is cartagena the next game i'm talking about is spirit island which is another immensely popular successful co-op game this one is considered to be one of the best designs out there and you know what with my objective head on i can't disagree with that there's nothing about this game that i can criticize or critique in terms of its gameplay functions the way it works how clever the design is how asymmetric all the different god powers are that you can use and how well they work and synergize with each other um it really is a mind-blowing design i think it's brilliantly executed um however for me the best play the best way to play this game is purely solo by just having one god and doing all by yourself and trying to map out this puzzle and how to kick out these um you know these invaders and how to shift things around the board um but bearing in mind this game is designed to be played solo i thought it became a bit too confusing when playing with other people i kind of wanted to do my own thing and not worry about not worry too much about what anybody else was doing but to do well at this game you need to work together and to you you need to um you know synergize your powers with each other and i wasn't quite willing to put in the work to do that and if i was playing the purely solo it
would never get to the table because i very rarely play solo games and if i do play solo games i normally lean towards something a bit simpler and a bit faster so it was another one of those games where i just knew that was never going to hit the table to be fair i didn't really scratch the surface with this one i played it a few times this one requires a lot more effort to get the most from it because it is so deep it is so complex and rich and i can completely see why this is a lot of people's favorite game because it is genius and especially for like co-op games there's so much to explore here but for me co-op isn't really my forte no there are solo games and for that reason it wasn't right for my collection so therefore it had to go the second to last game i'm talking about is watch which i have to admit is one of those games that had me um most intrigued over this this last year or so has an awesome theme or concept where you are working in a watch factory however secretly you are also manufacturing these war munitions um so definitely out there it has a great kind of aesthetic as well this kind of propaganda style art i really wanted to like this one however i think mechanically and game wise it just was a little bit short of the mark and didn't quite reach up to winner what i wanted from it so this is essentially like a rondelle star game because you're moving your worker and can take an action spot as long as it's empty you are putting gears or getting these munitions um all of which to invest in final
scoring and that was one of the things that detracted for it for me was how confusing uh the scoring was at the end it was quite mass heavy and it became a bit too much to try and manage your head additionally there was a concept here that i thought sounded great on paper where there was a worker placement spot you could go to where you could almost try and guess where other people would go in the following round and if you guessed correctly then they would you'd have to accept a bribe or take a bribe from them so i had that kind of getting into your opponent's head and trying to predict what they were doing um however in practice that did fall a bit flat nobody really seems to go there already seemed to care about that part of the game and it became a bit of a game of going through the motions and just um you know building things selling things and so on and um the also the majority in terms of the scoring was a bit too dry it was a bit too transparent and it wasn't really much fun or very little to be had so wanted to like it i just thought it was a little bit flat and didn't do anything terribly special and the final game i'm talking about this episode is torres which is actually a former still de jars winner all the way back like in the year 2000 or so this is a pretty abstract game as you are trying to build up these huge castles and you're building up these castles not only by increasing the footprint of them by spreading it wide but you can also stack these pieces vertically and what you're trying to do is not only increase these towers you you are trying to move your player pieces onto these towers because your scoring is going to be the size of the
tower multiplied by how high up your worker is on that tower so it has some really cool scoring concept that i thought was probably my favorite part of the game um i almost had this action points allowance system um which kramer and keisling were known for um and i thought this game is another objective solid design but it kind of goes back to my thoughts on abstract games just not i'm gelling with me um and i thought this game was good i had a lot of fun with it i played it quite a few times i thought there was some good barriers as well as you use these action cards to kind of mess with the rules a bit and i can certainly see why this game is so highly respected because it's another one of those games where can i critique the rules not really you know these these designers are genius the game design is fantastic but it doesn't quite fit my tastes um if there ever was an abstract game i would have my collection this might be it if you like games like santorini where you like that kind of 3d aspect and table presence of a game then this is a really good one to check out because it scales well it plays pretty quickly lots of interesting decisions you could be a bit nasty with it but it was never coming off my shelf and if i was going to play a craymore keystone game there are so many i play ahead of this one but if i had infinite space in my collection i probably would keep hold of this one because i think it's definitely got its place um and i really do appreciate the design but ultimately i have to be cutthroat and it had to go so there we have it those are another 10 games that have left my collection if
you have enjoyed this video please be sure to hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too but for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye