Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 21:15

hi my name is Marty con el with rolling dice and taking names and I want to talk about a game design aspect that I feel it's often underappreciated and undervalued is underappreciated under how you need the same thing and that is game box inserts you know this little plastic and cardboard devices that are inside your box they have little compartments to put all your bits and pieces and cubes and cards and separate locations to make them easy to find things or take out set up put away and have their own little places to go you know those things there are a lot of game box inserts that are very well designed and and take all the components into consideration and others not so much so I was going to look at some of the games i have today and just give my thoughts and some that i think are pretty good and some that are maybe yeah the first game i want to look at is the classic puerto rico puerto rico's your average looking box take the lid off and underneath it you are able to stack your player boards and game boards and rules nicely and neatly but underneath that is a plastic insert with several compartments for storing various things in here I happen to have all my colonists and resources and victory points and bags in this large compartment got a compartment here for some gold my buildings my rolls go in here my resource tokens go in here very easy to get things set up and put away

when I'm done with it puerto rico has a nice plastic insert with all the compartments to keep all your components separated and very well organized but i think there's another aspect of the game box insert that we need to consider and that is how does it handle travel many times our game boxes are not going to sit on the shelf and go straight to the table we're going to take them to some where we're going to to a friend's house to a game store to a convention in that case we're your game box insert do its job during all that travel because you never know what you're going to run across as you're driving you may hit a pothole or it may fall out of the bag in the back of the car you may be in a conventional accidentally knocks it off the table or it may get thrown across the room why would somebody threw a game box across the room or maybe you live in an earthquake zone and you know you just have a tendency for game boxes to fall off your shelves from earthquakes and gets that's for my california friends me regardless there are many times that your boxes are going to go through all sorts of things as they travel that might mess up the components on the inside so for test let's see how Puerto Rico holds up under just a simple little shake test you know a little shake here and there a little shimmy you know turn left turning right for some reason you're traveling and you turn upside down maybe you're in an amusement park or something like that so I feel all that shaking and stuff how does Porto Rico hold up alright let's see how you

did on the shake test take everything back out go straight down to the components not bad not bad at all I had one of these guys that was sitting here come out how to gold piece fall out that's not bad there is one more goal peas down inside here but still that's that's pretty good it does its job the player board sit nice and firmly on top hold everything in place in case things move around so what a Rico I would say is a pretty good insert so we just looked at the older game how about a newer game like Vikings let's see what kind of insert it has in its box Vikings looks like a standard game box take off the top again on the top we have the rules we have the main game board underneath we have the plastic insert on top of got a place for the player boards have a big department here that has the canvas bag that holds all the Maples have another plastic bag holding on my tokens and player 8 cards the main part is back here which holds the cardboard tiles that are used in the game that's the main component of the game aim plus the area for some gold over here now I'm concerned about the shake test I'm getting ready to do because if these guys get messed up on transport it's not the end of the world but it'd take a lot of time sorting and I'm kind of OCD when it comes to make sure they're oriented right so I hope it passes the shake test so let's find out a Viking is going to pass that shake test or not I'll please let these tiles get messed up here we go we'll shake here up there ok so maybe where you're an aerobatic airplane we kind of go

upside down here and there and maybe there's there's that earthquake we're talking about so let's see how it looks hi here we go not bad I won't see a thing out of place out of here great job z man that is a really nice insert there so hey it looks like Vikings is very safe for all types of traveling environment deck building games and card building games are as big as ever and as such publishers need to create inserts that are able to keep all these cards separated and organized easily for setup and takedown one such game that I just got recently is trains from aeg let's check out its insert and see what it looks like now granted trains isn't just a box for cards it also does have a game board in it plus the rule is obviously it is a plastic insert like the others we have seen before has compartments in here for holding your wooden bits and keeping them all nice and neat i have them in bags also what i really appreciate this since it's a deck-building Game you're using different cards each game they did include card dividers which makes it easy to find the card you're looking for and being able to put together your resources to buy out there each time now you may notice there is a lot more space in this box than the cards that I have the reason expansions so what they've done is they've included all this extra space in here in order to put the cards as you buy expansions so all the cards

can be kept in one box I really also appreciate these little foam bits in here because as I get the cards they can be used to provide tension up against the card so they don't follow and get messed up with all that extra space will trains be able to survive the travel shape test let's find out I really need them find something else to do during this time because I know this probably looks really boring so well that's probably good enough we'll see what looks like all right here we go let's see what we got are the cards all in place not bad actually that's really good the cards did shift a little bit over but they didn't fall out of their compartment if this hadn't have been here i think we probably would had a little bit more problems so again I appreciate the phone bits in here so a great insert for keeping all your cards together plus allow for future expansions hey since we're talking about card games and deck building games and we actually just looked at a game from aeg let's look at another one of their games smash up let's see how the insert compares in this one to what we just saw in trains now smash-ups box is a little bit smaller than trains it doesn't need to be as large because there is not a game board inside of it but inside we have another plastic container with little dividers in between for putting your different cards they don't have card dividers like they did in trains however these little compartments are good enough for segregating your cards they do have an extra space over here for expansions so if I was to buying

expansions I would put them here and be okay now the engineer is going to come out of me right here and just kind of concerns me a bit is how low these plastic dividers are right here this is going to allow the center of gravity on these cards to be a lot lower than what I would like it to be and thus when we transport these cards and they get shaken around a bit I'm afraid they're going to tumble out of their slots but there's only one way to find out the test all right we'll just survive the shake test let's find out wait a minute I got an idea how I can make this a little bit more fun

Giovanni jump I jump on it on it on it on it all right let's see how this bad boy did here we go and that is why right there I am NOT a mechanical or civil engineer because I did not figure that out correctly those cards are fully intact no problem they didn't move around at all so once again another good insert by AEG next up let's look at a game that increases the count of cards and components and let's see how well somebody can design and insert for that let's look at Lords of Waterdeep Lords of Waterdeep comes in a pretty large box but it needs to because inside is a pretty large game board and then as I mentioned a lot of components with the player cards all the tokens or meeples for the the workers of the agents the cards here there's multiple different types of cards or scoring tokens there's a lot going on in this box but if you look there is a spot for everything and this is one of my favorite inserts in a box one thing I think is unique is just how you get the cards out if you notice there's like a heel underneath here that allows you to take the cards and

basically push down a one in and then pick them up and there there's a compartment for a couple of the the flight the first player token and an additional people over here it works the exact same way another compartment there you have all your buildings nice and this on one compartment a slot for everything else down to the hundred point counter for each of the different colors all these fit in here nice and snug they've got the little player Marcus reach one of those your money 50 points and then like I said the wells for all the different components that are the workers that are in the game or agents that are in the game they're not workers these are the workers that's the agents don't tell Tony he'll get me for that so that's a lot of stuff in this box I don't know how this is going to go but there's only one way to find out we must apply science

let's see how this came out whoa not too good looks like we had cards sliding all over the place all the different kind of cards mixed up together yeah those victory point tokens didn't hold out too well now all these pieces stayed in place none of these shifted locations everything so it looks like it was just the cards it's not too bad but it's probably one of those things that you probably don't want to dance around with lot as your gaming not that people take their games out and dance that would be kind of weird so again I think it's a well-designed so it's a well-designed box but again you just do have to be careful on transport the next insert I want to look at isn't necessarily one games insert but it's a whole series of games inserts and that's the insert given to us from Fantasy Flight Games you might already know the one I'm talking about what I'm going to look at today is just like a lot of other fantasy flight games you look at that one from netrunner this is really about your standard size fantasy flight games box I've taken everything out of this box except for the insert because that's what I really want to look at is this guy this this this piece of cardboard here that's that so typically when you're going to gain from them don't have a bunch of cards or tokens may be sitting right here got to look under the flaps and find other stuff they get it

all in the box nice and neat and nice and and bags the problem is is getting it back in this box in that same sort of order and it's just it's insane I don't know why Fantasy Flight the one of the largest if not the largest game publishers continues to use this insert I know there's cost reason I'm sure this is very cheap they just use the same plan for everything but it's not very convenient for us as a gamer as we must find other means to be able to store games inside this style of box seriously what is this but is there is there any name for this an accordion but what so while I'm not going to give they shake test for the fantasy flight games I've got several games that are here four or five of them including games like eldritch horror and descent they had this this same sort of insert in here and okay okay I wasn't totally honest with you I am going to do another fantasy flight game and it's one that came with that same insert as before and that game is going to be eldridge heart and what I did was replace what was inside from Fantasy Flight with some custom inserts let's see how they look so if you ever get a game with an insert that just doesn't meet your needs you might have to go the customer out and make something yourself that's what has been done here so here's a pact with the ancient ones in it the rules the game board but underneath our custom trays and compartments made out of foam board

now what's so great about this are these trays are not only good for storage and transportation they're good because they can be taken out of the box and use during the game itself likewise this tray that we have for the cards if you notice there's no side to it again great for pulling out so you can draw cards during the game when you're done you put it back in here and there easily protected and won't go anywhere there's different trays with different sized compartments in it to hold dice and other tokens whatnot there's a section back here that's left so we can put up a bag that has our monster tokens in it place here left for cards and their sleeves so there's enough room left for that and by the way this also has the expansion in it too forsaken lore so there was enough room to even hold those components this particular insert was made by a good friend Robert searing who also helps out up the dice tower he does a lot of back behind the scenes work such as on the website and graphics and whatnot and what he's done is he's created an online store and custom-designed a lot of these inserts for different styles of games so when he came up with this one he sent us this one for us to try out and give us some let us give some feedback on it and we just really enjoyed it and if you want to look down in the description of this video and i'll put a link to his website in case you want to check out his other stuff but he's not the only one there are other companies that make custom inserts to maybe out of foam board or for wood or if your craft enough you can

do it yourself just foam board and some glue or take some wood and cut it and make session is here or just regular cardboard you can do that too so lots of times the custom way might be the best way for you for a particular game so even though this game has a custom tray in it I still feel I need to give it the same test I've given the others now I'm sure none of you want to see me do any more dancing or anything really ok ok one last time for you guys i'll give it oh ok whooping coming up stars

come stop Oh let's see if eldritch horror survived the gum go stop test here we go whoo we got a little bit of card makes up in here not too bad sand the tokens came out so when the characters came out yeah we got a little bit of mix-up but it's it's we can live with it a little bit straighten open it's good to go so for custom it's art it really held up on its own the last game I want to talk about is another you're a game with a lot of components that handles their insert is a little bit differently I'm talking about Terra Mystica let's see what they do so this box is big it's heavy we know there's a lot of stuff in here let's see what they did bags and components that's right there was no insert in here when I opened this game there was a lot of bags with the wooden components in it there were the sheets of cardboard that you know you have to punch out to get those components out of at the bottom was the game board the player boards and the rules on the bottom and that was pretty much it and this a collection of plastic

bags for you to put your poem components in that's right there's no cardboard insert there's no plastic insert just a bunch of storage bags to keep your stuff separated and organized and you know what I am a okay with this I have no problem because I can get this stuff out for out on the table give each person their own colors I have them separate in such a certain way so that the game board is easy to set up and when I'm ready to go I'll start playing when i'm done through everybody a bag they put their stuff in there throw it back in the box and i'm done now one reason you can do this is because there's no thin cardboard cards in here if there was this might be a problem because this get Bennett but these are a little bit thicker cardboard and so that like the little player age cards there they're not going to go anywhere so actually not having an insert is a solution for a game company and in games like this it works and I think it works just fine so there's my look at box inserts for games as we've seen there are multiple solutions that can be used in games some games use a plastic insert where they have a location for each one of their components so you can keep them all nice and separated there are some games that include plastic components or inserts so that you can accommodate future expansions with the idea is that you buy expansions you can put everything into one box we even saw one game company didn't it include insert at all instead gave us a lot of plastic bags so that we

separate out all the pieces and organizing that way and keep them in their own little separate bags whatever it is just recognize that there is somebody sitting at a computer somewhere right now designing an insert for a game on their cat system or never trying to make it it's easy for us to organize our games as possible so we need to just give them a little round of applause for for what they do for the going in the industry because they do help us out a lot many instances and I'm sure I've missed a lot of great inserts and so if you would kindly comment in the sections below and let me know what inserts I miss what inserts do you like that work really well have you danced with any of your games to see if they should survive the shake test and one last thing what what what is this called is there a name for this I mean is there an official name for this or is there like an accepted name because i'm not sure what it is and if there isn't one let me know if there's not one must come at once so we can reference this guy in the future because i'm sure we'll be seeing a lot more of it thanks for watching

so I am going to look at a fantasy fought game but i'm looking at Fantasy Flight game that had that same insert as I just showed you but it's been replaced with some custom inserts and that game is eldritch horror that's upside down

Progress saved