Top 10 Engine Building Board Games - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 engine building board games so engine building happens to be probably my favorite element of board gaming almost every one of my favorite games has some kind of degree of engine building involved um if you're not familiar with what engine building is it's generally a kind of progression as the game goes on where you are accumulating more cards or more benefits or powers to make things more efficient and basically build up a kind of a network of actions to make things more productive there are a lot of games like this and i really did struggle to put this list together because there is so much competition so if your favorite isn't in the top 10 it was probably just off the list and no doubt in the future i will be doing another top 10 because there are so many good ones to choose from um however these top 10 are the ones that instantly sprang to mind for me the ones where i felt the engine building came through through the strongest so let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have deus now deus is a game that's almost fallen out of people's kind of sphere of um board gaming really i don't really see a lot of people talking about this one anymore but the engine building in deus is extremely impressive so on the face of it this is a pretty standard i suppose area control style game um a game where you're collecting resources and buying cards to play them and basically to put buildings out on the board and surround these regions to get points sounds pretty standard but the level of engine building in this game does shine through tremendously well because whenever you buy one of these cards of a certain kind of building type
you will allocate them to a certain spot on your player board and then it will trigger its ability but as you buy more and more of these cards than every single card you've built previously also triggers so you for example you might have a production style building where it will say you know every one of your fields is going to produce wheat and then you might have to say every one of your mountains produces stone unless you as you kind of imagine you can probably build more and more of these cars and when you take another production action you're getting a hell of a lot of resources in one single go and there are additional engines you can build as well such as buying and selling resources or gaining points for certain layouts on the board lots of different things even like military actions will let you navigate around the board quicker and surround regions that you want a really great ramping up effect and it does feel like this game does just take off and um some of these chains and networks you get especially by building cards in certain orders can really pay off and big pay big big dividends so a lovely degree of energy building really satisfying turns that is deus up at number nine i have res arcana res arcana is impressive because not only because of the engine building but the way it does engine building in such with such few components because this is a game where you only actually start with a hand i believe of eight cards um you get a special character ability as well and the idea is you're trying to play these cards by again paying resources um but you can kind of build up these kind of synergies and networks and
engines of cars by triggering them in certain orders so for example one might say you know convert one of this resources into two of these other resources and then convert two of these resources into something else and it's just compounding and getting bigger and bigger and you're eventually buying locations with them and converting those locations into points and it has this racing effect which i think i think engine building and racing come together really well and mesh just generally well as two pure mechanisms and rezakana is a solid example of that um it has some individual kind of things you can draft from round around um you can start the game with the draft by kind of tailoring your engine to how you want it to be and decide what you're going to go for but yeah the way these cards um line up with each other that domino effect really does shine through massively and it's just a really fun game that does a lot with such few components gorgeous artwork it has a magical mage wall kind of feel to it but for me it works really well and probably from the look of this game it doesn't look as euro as it might as it might kind of appear from the face of it but it really is all about those mechanisms and how you're going to string those cards together to build the best engine lovely game that is res arcana now at number eight i have kashgar merchant of the silk road this is another card driven game where you have basically three columns or caravans of cards that you're going to build up throughout the game so these cards are going to be used to again collect resources and you're going
to use those resources to fulfill contracts a bit like razakana you are going for a race and trying to be the first to reach a certain amount of points but these cars do lots of different things such as a a bit like rezakanna again where you are not only collecting resources but where you're trading in some resources for others some are gonna actually have to let you we're gonna have to use to actually fulfill the contracts in the first place um and but the cool thing about this game is that when you have these columns of cards you only choose to activate the one on the front of each of those caravans and then you're going to pick that card up and put it to the back and as the game goes on you're building more and more of these cards i'm adding more to these columns and you're going to have to weigh up or plan how you're going to or the order in which you're going to use these cards because as i said they're going to always go back to the back of the card so doing them in order is so so important and lining up your turns can be really satisfying and can leave you feeling very clever if you do it correctly so for example i might say you know collect this resource and then this camera is going to let me convert it to that one then i'll use this one and by the time this one's done my caching contract will be here ready to be used you can choose to build build really long extravagant caravans or build very tight succinct ones where i have a very particular need brilliant game very much a hidden gem nobody really talks about this one i don't know why maybe it looks a bit generic a bit beige but the gameplay is super fun and um very satisfying and a big part of that is because of that feeling of engine building that is kashgar merchants of the silk
road at number eight at number seven i have only on now orlian is a pretty popular bag building game so this is a a game where you are a bit like a deck builder where you do it with cards you instead of doing that you collect tokens put them into your bag and then from time to time your drawing tokens out allocating to different spots on your player board and potentially triggering actions based on the tokens you've drawn now this game is kind of broken into two or maybe even more elements of engine building the first of which tokens are you going to add to your board in the first place because if you've got a certain strategy you're going to have to make sure you keep drawing certain tokens from your from your bag um so first off you're going to have to lean towards that way a second off there are certain spots where you can choose to invest in blocking off certain criteria that you'll need to trigger an action so for example a certain spot might require a farmer and a sailor but you can take these cogs and cover up one of those spots so you no longer need the sailor you just need the farmer so you're getting things for cheaper and of course that meshes well with the bag you're building in the first place but on top of that certain spots as well let you invest in drawing more tokens from your bag so you're getting more actions from from round around so all these things work together extremely well you can end up building very efficient engines so what would initially cost you a lot or a lot of effort to do can eventually end up costing you next to no effort to take whatsoever and you can just do it cheaper and cheaper really good um the just the game that you're trying to
base basically travel around france um picking up all these different bonus multipliers traveling on this track and getting lots of points but the engine building is where it shines through on top of the bag building and it's just a wonderful euro game one of the best out there and um just just great fun that is all they are at number seven at number six i have newton now newton is another game that uses several different elements of engine building to to come into a an entire package really and a big portion of this game that makes it very unique in my opinion to anything else out there is that the actual points engine gen or the way you generate points is based on an engine so at the end of each round you're going to score an amount of points depending on certain kind of lines and columns of these books you've put on your bookshelves and the more and more these bookshelves that you build up the more points you're going to be generating from round to round so that and the face of it is great so the actual whole way you're going to gain points is based on an engine but on top of that from round to round you're building short-term engines by playing these cars and these cars are going to have different actions on them um you know such as traveling around the world where you're going to collect different knowledge you are going to kind of book up the money track you're going to invest in new technologies and things and research which can get you more powers and things so another element of engine building there um but the the kind of main part of it is that when you play these cards not only do you get the ability of the one you just played you also get the ability of each card you played previously in that round
so you get these compounding engine abilities where you can end up taking really efficient turns and at the end of the round you are going to take one of the cards you played and tuck it under your player board meaning that permanently from now on you are going to get an amped up version of that power and get it one strength stronger which can be really significant so i really love that a really different approach and said that the way you generate points in this game is fantastic and um just does a great job of differentiating it differentiating itself from a lot of games that are not similar to this but have the same kind of vibe as this one and um i think this is a tremendously strong game that doesn't get talked about nearly enough that is newton uh at number five i have coinbra now coinbra is a beautiful drafting game as you are taking or basically allocating dice onto or first off drafting dice and then putting dice onto these different kind of rows in order to collect cards but when you collect these cards you are going to be adding them to your engine which means at certain points in the game you're gonna get bonuses such as whenever you take uh this color of dye you get um you know you get some money or you get some points you get to climb up a track and as the game goes on these do really add together and ramp up and it feels like you're getting a lot done um certainly in comparison to what you're doing at the start of the turn the dice drafting element in this game is fantastic in in on its own right where you are not only considering the pip value because the pit values are good because they get you priority in taking the engine building cards you want but it means you have to pay more in
order to use them in the first place but the color of those dice is also extremely important because it relates to a corresponding track which will either kind of let you traverse the board and get new powers and bonuses or it will let you get points or money or military strength which is kind of another currency and all these things together just come together wonderfully a beautiful very inviting euro game that i think kind of throws the euro genre on its face because normally you you'll expect these kind of games to be very bland and beige but this one is vibrant it's colorful it's beautiful and um the engine building is very strong and i i think it's a really integral part of the game and what a big portion of why i enjoy coinbase so much is because of those compounding bonuses and different engine building elements you get throughout wonderful game that is coinbra at number five and number four i have signorier now signorea is a pretty um i don't really hear this one talked about very much it's quite an involved game um about pretty more of a euro trope where you are ahead of an italian family um you're trying to boost your um i suppose the the credentials of your sons by giving them these professions you're trying to marry off your daughters to these other families i'm collecting all these different sigils of the different families and things um but the way you draft these dice is really cool because first off you have to weigh up where you're going to pay because the higher dice basically give you discounts on them on the fee you have to pay but if you go
over a certain threshold then you're not going to get bonuses but whenever you take these dice you get to take one of three actions but one of those actions allows you to unlock a certain ability on another dice allocation spot this might sound pretty complex and it is quite an evolved game but all that essentially means is that whenever you take a dice corresponding to that unlocked spot then you're going to get an additional ability for free and it absolutely works wonderfully these abilities are all really interesting you're gaining money or going up tracks and things but it's everything is equally as good and you just want to invest in everything um and that again a bit like or a lot of these other games the compounding abilities you go throughout it's just fantastic man i love the way that this one you can't get everything done you need to really pick and tailor which things you're going to unlock for your engine in order to um to play well in this one a really involved game i can't really go too much into it but um the engine building in this game is extremely strong and i strongly encourage you check this one out if you do like diced drafting um wonderful game this is senor ea at number four at number three i have hanza to tonica the hunter teutonica is probably the purest example of engine building on this list because the gameplay in itself is extremely simple it's a route building game where you're trying to basically put different tokens on the board claim your claim cities for your own really build up a network of cities to get points at the end of the game
but a lot of these kind of routes that you build on the board relate to your player board and that will let you basically boost actions that you can take so for example if you complete a route between one city and another it will let you unlock a cube from your player board which will then mean you can take another action per turn and as you can probably imagine the more you do that you can end up taking quite a few actions per turn which is a massive difference between what you're doing at the start of the turn additionally you can unlock um engine building capabilities of taking more cubes back into your pool at once which means you you have to take less turns doing so or getting more points by building your network up or um yeah lots of different things even such as building in more kind of valuable spots on the board um so you get more points that way so everything you do in this game is harmonious with the actual engine building it's all about kind of weighing up which bonuses you want to do i mean which strategy you're going to go down are you going to go for something really early and then focus on what you're doing on the board or vice versa are you going to take a more balanced approach um great game this is one of the classics i think this is like an uh or a certainly a modern classic pure streamlined elegance but the fact that you can really ramp up your abilities as you go throughout the game make things more efficient um and certainly more productive then um that handsome sonica is just a great example of meshing those two ideologies because i think most engine building games are generally a bit more convoluted have a bit more going on um simply because there is so many different ways you can implement your engine
but this one is just fundamental to the engine and the clean gameplay and they just synergize with each other wonderfully um one of the best games ever made hands of detonica at number three at number two i have underwater cities now underwater cities is probably the example that has every kind of engine building you could imagine in one game um on the face of it this one is a worker placement game and i suppose a hand management game so you're going to these different spots in order to collect resources in order to build your little underwater cities where you're building these different domes and things building tunnels and you're doing that to basically get an income at the end of each round which can be points or more resources and things but whenever you play one of these worker placement spots or take your action you can play a matching card from your hand and those cards can do things such as take instant abilities but a lot of these things contribute to your engine or your tableau of cards which will bolster your abilities throughout the game um some of them will give you kind of ongoing abilities that are just triggered whenever you do a certain thing such as you know if i if i build a tunnel i get i get a point or whenever i build a tunnel i get a coin or something that will happen in production phases you know whatever you your you know your buildings now produce an extra certain or something else or something to make things cheaper and as these things are compounded you know every single action you take you're gonna end up playing another card um you can really build some efficient uh engines ones that just could completely transcend the original base game that you were playing at the
start of the game and the amount of cards in your tableau that you're going to have at the end is just absolutely astonishing and maybe weighing up all the actions that you've gathered throughout can be a bit taxing and hard to hard to remember what you can do but that it just adds so much mileage to this game it has so much scope for personalizing your strategy in tailoring what you're going for um and just it's just a wonderful example of um of card play and all the different elements of energy building as i said instant abilities um ongoing abilities abilities that happen at certain things or happen to the production phases new actions that only you can do all of this is in this very pretty simple i suppose um engine building and a worker placement game that takes about 90 minutes to play and maybe maybe a bit longer than that but the way it incorporates so much into this game is phenomenal and uh yeah just the the synergies the combinations upgrades are just absolutely mind-blowing in underwater cities so if you like engine building games this is one of the best ones ever made check us out and finally at number one i have lorenzo ill magnifico now from the face of this one you might think this one is yours typical euro game very beige very um generic looking but the engine building in this game is for nominal a bit like a lot of these other games this is all about collecting cards a work placement game is the is the core mechanism in this one but the worker placement spots are interesting because they're all dictated to by a certain die value so at the start of
each round you're going to roll three die and they're going to correspond to the workers that you have so for example if you rolled the orange died it was a five then your orange work is going to be worth a five and the higher values are gonna let you buy um not better cars but different cards and depending on the layout and you are using these cars to get set collection bonuses and things but two sets of these cards or that three but three one of these sets of cards is basically used to boost your previous actions such as you know whenever you take this certain card get a bonus so first off that's some really good engine building there and some good good little bonuses and little boosts that you can get throughout but the the other two basically correspond to an another or your individual player board we're gonna end up playing cards in this in this row which means that you when you go to a certain other spot you're going to trigger every car that you've previously purchased um depending on the on the dice value that you've um allocated there and as you accumulate more and more of these cars that can kind of generate resources or convert resources into points and convert or give you just give you money or give you um give you kind of military bonuses uh when you trigger these things it is absolutely just being showered in goods and i absolutely love that feeling is whenever you run your engine i'll take you know i'll take three stones this one lets me convert two stone into into four words this forward lets me convert you know forward into points and i absolutely love that kind of cascading mechanism um i think it's absolutely amazing so so satisfying um the only thing i think this is an
advantage some people complain that um when the game's over it feels like your engines just got really juicy and then the legs are cut out from beneath you and the game is over but for me that just adds more um more kind of incentive to go back to this one and it leaves me wanting more because the combinations you can get are so much fun and as i said that idea of being showered in goods and resources by taking a certain action is just absolutely brilliant um this one is in my top three games of all time um what i said absolutely 10 out of 10 gave me just a phenomenal amazing amazing game and um when i thought of engine building games this is the first game i think i'm definitely going to put this one at number one because this is the prime example of building an engine um and getting the most out of it so um brilliant game check this out no brainer if you like your euro game so this is just i said so many to choose from here could have could have made a list of at least 25 30 games that are all amazing um but hopefully this has been a good example of which games to check out if you like the idea of um of kind of a game that you progress throughout so if you have enjoyed this video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye