Top 100 Board Games of All Time (2023 Edition) 30 - 21
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and this is our top 100 favorite board games of all time and today we are counting down the 20s and there is like a torrential rainstorm and thunderstorm outside so if you hear a big like don't worry about it it's just Thunder but it is it's crazy yeah we'll we'll see if our power stays on yeah but let's get right to it with our number 30 and you're kicking us off this time thank you my number 30 is draftysaurus and draftysaurus is just a game about drafting dinosaurs and you're putting your hand in a bag you're pulling out dinosaurs you're putting them out onto these things it's basically a rolling right game more or less but I'm glad it's not a rolling right game because then I wouldn't have a whole ton of little wooden dinosaurs and I think of the games we have this is one of the the game's like the most different sculpts of wooden dinosaurs as well even though it only has like six dinosaurs it has six wildly different dinosaurs and two more with the expansion that is true so you can have up to eight different dinosaur skulls and what I find surprising is that it was four designers to do draftosaurus yeah yeah there's four different designers on this including uh Antoine Bowser I believe in uh Teo Riviera who
do a lot of great games sorry I don't remember the other two but yeah four designers for this I can only imagine that they were like having like drinks somewhere and someone came up with it and then they all Rift on it I would be I'm fascinated to know what the design process was on this game because it's so simple but maybe that's part of it it's just it's so streamlined to like Perfection where you can explain the rules in like 15 seconds and people can be playing and no one's really gonna have a question they're just gonna like we've got the rules in French and we because we learned it from that and we're totally fine and have never had to look at them again so that tells you how simple this game is and it's my number 30. my number 30 is Guild of merchant explorers and this came out last year so first time on my top 100 list and this also feels like a flip and write type of game but instead of marking things off you put cubes out so a card terrain car gets flipped and then you add a cube but what makes this game so enjoyable all is each round you get to add a special power card and all of them seem like broken every time I have a card it seems like too good to use yeah like your special card does like as much as all the other cards combined and then by the third round you got three of those that are putting out like six or seven Cubes at a time yeah that part's great it is super fun and it really makes a
difference for what order everything comes out in I think I like games that feel a little bit like Bingo where you're really like oh I hope this one comes out no not that one not yet yeah this is very much like map Bingo and this one we played this like two days ago and I was like oh how did I forget this and I kept saying please tell me you have this on your list because I want to like add it but I don't want to take anything away please tell me that you remembered it um and she wouldn't tell me and so now I know and I'm very glad to see it on here it's because you always forget the name but my number 30 is Guild of merchant explorers my number 29 is architects of the West Kingdom and architects of the West kingdom is the kind of the easiest to get into I think of all of the Shem Phillips or Shem Phillips SJ McDonald games and it is the one that works the best at the highest player count as well and we generally play it too so that shouldn't be a huge selling point but with the expansions and there's now two or three expansions for this and all of them add to it and they just make it really a solid two-player game because there's there's other things that you can build now there's like these Wonders that you're making and there's um like crafting cards and they've added enough different routes that it seems like you shouldn't get in each other's way more because there's different routes but somehow you get in each other's way more it feels like especially on the cathedral because there's so many
reasons to go there now yeah the extensions definitely help the two-player game but if I was bringing in new people in I would just play the base game because the base game is a great introduction to and it's so easy to explain and it's it is really fun because one of the things that you're doing is anytime people have really put a lot of workers out at a spot you can then collect up all of those workers to make sure they don't get a whole bunch of stuff and even with just the base game as well it's got It's not quite modular but it's got little things that you can add to it like the reverse sides of all of the boards or asymmetrical but it really is a solid game any player count and that is my 29. my number 29 is near and far and near and far is by Ryan Lockett who does the design and the art and it looks amazing amazing it's the second one that came out in the arzium trilogy and it is my favorite of the bunch I think it does a really good mix of visiting the town where you get to stock up on your villagers and your animal transport be it like a tortoise or a Dodo we have two classic transports yeah exactly before you can then go on an adventure and try and go as as far as you can and there are lots of different ways to play so we had a really fun time doing the character campaign where you play a character and there's just these short little snippet story lines that take you through each game as you as you find out a bit more about your character
and it's it's just enough because I don't love winning game gets interrupted for narrative but they were like short and interesting enough that we were interested I usually have a problem with story and board game because usually the writing is awful but in this case it's actually pretty decent and it's nice it's like just the length you want like a paragraph and a half but the story ties together nicely even like within the Choose Your Own Adventure yeah this is I know you you want to play more dungeon crawly adventury games and I more prefer euroe games that are kind of void of story and this is the one this is like the peanut butter and chocolate that we can like totally agree on and kind of hits all those spots for both of us yeah I I do agree and that makes near and far my number 29. my number 28 is viticulture and there's kind of like a viticulture family of games now with viticulture world and bass and Tuscany but I think my favorite is firmly Tuscany I really do I like having the Four Seasons I like having the different ways to do all of the things you need to do because I think one of the real selling points of viticulture is it's this work replacement Euro game where where you are making wine and you have to do all of the steps of making wine and you kind of have to do them in order which I like because it thematically works really well and you can feel like okay cool I'm picking the grapes I'm
growing The Grapes I'm making my wine I'm aging my wine I'm selling my wine all those things but in like a mechanical sense as well it can kind of force a log Jam sometimes for the spaces but the nice thing about Tuscany is the cards give you other ways and you've got buildings that give you other things and so there's other ways to do all of the things that you need to do and I think it's just such a huge Improvement yeah especially for two players because you're just competing for the one open space I would be interested to try it at three players because then you have just more spaces between I think it's two spots for three of you so there's still competition but it's just not quite a head-to-head competition yeah it's kind of the opposite of the rule of Star Trek movies where only even numbers are good there in viticulture odd numbers generally are a little bit better but it still is my number 28. my number 28 is Ultimate railroads and ultimate railroads is a worker placement game and I think I say this every time I talk about it but it's so true I was just put off by the title of railroad being in the in the title of the game you think it's going to be such a like euro-y heavy like 18x I did too yeah exactly but it is really just this fun engine builder and combo Builder because you're building out these different tracks but as you go you're really trying to extend each of your rounds by how many coins
you have and how many workers you have as well and each of the tracks depending on which one you decide to go down will give you different bonuses so you're constantly debating like do I really want to like Rush this long track and that will give me this bonus or or do this other one that may not pay off long term but gets me a better thing short term and it comes we got the ultimate edition and that comes with so many different types of boards and basically different ways of playing and anytime there's modules we really love that because there's just a whole bunch of stuff to explore yeah and there is so much in this box like in the and I would say definitely if you're interested in this game just get the ultimate because there's like four different games in it plus a bunch of different modules and all of it is fun and all of it you can mix and match and we've just played so so much of this and it's it is interesting just how abstracted that is because yeah I totally thought the same thing oh this is going to be this like heavy train game and I was like ah people say it's good but I don't know and this could be anything like it just happens to be trains but you could take this game and just as easily make it be about like a haberdashery this could be about anything at all but it works really well yeah and it is really fun to see your school score each round just get drastically bigger and bigger oh yeah it's like three points and then your last round it's like 180 points it's crazy yeah and that makes ultimate railroads my number 28. my number 27 is
Barron Park and baron Park's just a classic Gateway tile Builder that I just never fell out of love with I just really like this game it's classic Phil Walker Harding and he's so good at this he's so good at finding a mechanism and then just finding like just doing that that one thing times like a thousand and just finding the heart of the fun in that one mechanism and here it's just tile placement and so when you place tiles you're getting more tiles and then you're placing those tiles and you're getting more tiles and everything you do leads to more tile placement and I really appreciate that that he's just like you know what I don't wanna I'm not putting anything else in this this is just the tile placement IST tile placement game where you're just placing dials to play Styles and I love it and the theme I just I like that it's a place that's just all different bears plus koalas yes yeah and you think you have spill Locker partying is Australian I think he was a little bit like I know koalas aren't there yeah it's in the rule book yeah yeah but they still included it and if you get the expansion you can include grizzly bears and so we love playing with the extension as well because it lets you place like even larger more like odd shape and tiles too although we barely use the monorails but I do like to just look at them and think about the monorail song every time if we use them every time it's just what's that monorails the whole time that we're playing with it so maybe that's why we don't use it but I do like it with the
expansion as well which also one of the best named expansions out there and that is my 27. my number 27 is kind of a tile placement game it is Isle of cats but I am gonna go with Isle of cats Explorer I knew that you would go up before I know I do love them both but I couldn't justify both of them being in my top 100 so I am kind of grouping them together but I really like the the flip and right version so instead of placing physical tiles you're drawing out the tile shapes but it they do such a great job of keeping it really simple but still interesting decisions because on your turn you just pick a column of cards and you get to draw or pick what's ever in that column so it'll often be cats but that might also be the lessons which are your scoring cards as well and it's just it's fun to draw little cats too yeah and you don't have to draw the cat this is a bit like the cartographers thing where in the rule book it just says to like shade it in in the color but there's no way we're gonna do that so we draw just the grossest worst like long weird cats you've ever seen uh and that is part of the fun but this it does do such a good job of taking what's fun in Isle of cats getting rid of the giant box getting rid of all of the setup it's just streamlines it so well and it means that you can take it away with you so much more easily which is a huge bonus and so that makes all the cats explore and draw my number 27. my number 26 is
root and root is kind of the like the go-to asymmetric game if anyone is talking about asymmetry root is the first game that is going to come up because it does it so well it's got all of these fantastic little animal factions that are fighting for control of the woodlands and it looks like it's really cute which is great because you can get people into it that maybe wouldn't be into this kind of game but really this is a coin game where you've got these adorable little very bloodthirsty and vicious factions and there are a few caveats to this game it's pretty hard to learn that is a big kind of well-known hurdle to it you almost have to learn four games in order to play this it does a good job because it's got like levels of rule book but the one you need to read the laws of root you feel a bit like you need like a law degree to read it but it is so worth it because this is a super fun game once you put the time into it and just get to use all these actions we've got like 12 of them now and they're just it's so fun to be all of the different ones and how differently they play yeah the different factions are really fun and what made me enjoy this even more was the higher leans expansion and what that does is for us it made the two-player game a lot more fun because the higher leans are just these like lone or just small groupings of animal types that hang out on the board and they take up space and then at certain points when you pass certain score thresholds they come to
your side and what's nice about them is if you're falling behind then your odds of being able to hold on to them for longer are higher because they're a bit fickle they'll only be with you for a couple turns or maybe three and you'll be able to use them to fight the other player but then like next turn they might switch back again so I like having a bit of a catch-up mechanic and it really makes it a lot better two-player game without having to run the mechanical root factions which these are great if you want to you know use that brain space and if you really know root but if you don't want to put the time into those this works really well for two players and root is mine 26. my 26 is another animal game but this one is more realistic and that is Meadow and in Meadow it is a card Tableau Builder where you're building out an ecosystem and the art is beautiful it's all realistic animals it's all like watercolor cards it looks amazing and I love how you're building out your Tableau because it does make like sense in terms of how nature works because they'll be like oh this Berry needs to go on top of a tree and it's so tricky because you're often covering up symbols that you then need to play other cards so you're constantly trying to figure out what cards you can play what you should cover up and it can lead to some real difficult decisions yeah especially because it's got this really interesting
drafting mechanic too how you get the cards so you can see everything that's out you can see like 16 different cards you can kind of plan ahead but you've got two problems one that the other players might take your stuff but the other one is every time you take a card you put out these little pointers on a row or a column that allow you to take from that row or column but that also means that it blocks off that rower column for other players and I like that it's it makes for a really interesting decision space in the car drafting yeah because that happens so so often even with two players it's amazing how many times you've blocked where I wanted to go by taking it I want a different card I just I can't get there and with the um Downstream expansion yeah I really like it it adds a little bit of play time a little bit of an extra layer but it's it's really lovely and it includes water animals and again the art is incredible and Meadow is my number 26. my number 25 is Village and specifically Village big box which has got all the village stuff in one big box I feel like we're talking a lot about big boxes we do like when a big box comes out for something and we were waiting on the village big box for a while because we played this game when we were on vacation we played this at a board game Cafe and I think you were okay on it but it knocked my socks off I loved it right away it was love at first play and then I saw that a big box version was coming out and so we had to
wait and it seemed like it took for forever and when it finally came it did totally meet my memory of it my expectations it's just it's so it's all that stuff we said about ultimate railroads it's so many different interesting ways to play and to bring all that stuff in and out and to play with the port and or just going around the normal town and to have the inn and to have the marriage thing which is new for the big box and I think works really well too yeah I'm glad we held off because you were so tempted it just seemed to take forever for the big box to come out and you kept being like oh I see it for sale now everyone kept selling off because they were getting the big bucks I was like no it's late let's wait and then the big box finally came and when we got the big box we played all of the different possibilities on that weekend so we played a lot of games a village right off the bat yeah it's and we still just keep playing it like it's one that I am so fascinated by and just that the cube and the resources and that their actions but also resources there's just so much interesting cool stuff in this game and it is my 25.
my number 25 is sea salt and paper and I think this is one of our most played games this past year or at least one of our most played card games we started playing it on board game arena because we saw the origami art and it is amazing to see origami penguins and sailors and it's just so addictive to keep playing it because depending on what cards are available you're just going to be doing different things because it's a set collection game so sometimes you end up with a whole bunch of sets of one thing sometimes you just end up doing a whole bunch of actions maybe you'll get a bunch of sailboats if you play a pair of them it means you get to take an extra turn so there's just all of these different routes that you can go down and it's really interesting because there's only like eight or ten different kinds of cards but just how they interact with each other it's just genius level card design and I want to keep playing this a lot more because I still haven't had a mermaid Victory so we will hopefully I'll get there one day and my number 25 is sea salt and paper my number 24 is welcome to and we really like flipping rights and rolling rights it's the thing we talk about a lot on here and we own a ton of them because we really like to we like to take them with us when we travel we like to laminate them we like to have a whole bunch in one box but welcome two is really the one that kind of got us interested in it and it just continues to be my favorite
it it seems like it's so simple but there's always interesting decisions to be made because all you're doing is adding a number and it just has to go in order with the other numbers that you've already written that's it which does not seem like it's that much but in doing that and adding that number you're deciding do I want to get this pool do I want to if I put the seven like a little bit higher up now I gotta get one to six exactly but I I got a lot of wiggle room on 8 to 15. it's just that doesn't sound interesting I know but it is it's really a fascinating game and having the different um all of the different pages that we've got for it as well we've got like the holiday ones the zombie one and welcome to the Moon which takes it and puts it into a campaign form and I talked a lot about good writing in board games this is not that this is the worst writing you've ever seen in a board game but it's still really solid that campaign yeah we kind of skipped over reading the text oh my God don't don't try and read it but it comes with eight different Maps so they already come pre-laminated which is great and each of them use the very similar system of adding a number to a spot but they all do it in slightly different ways so it was really interesting to play through the eight to see the little tweaks that really do make each game still still feel different and I think slightly different
is underselling it these are like wildly different like that how they just take these cards with these different symbols and then make them do such different things within that campaign it's fascinating so when I say welcome to I guess I am talking about the whole welcome to family of games and combined those are my 24. my number 24 is viscounts of the West Kingdom which is my favorite of the trilogy and there's a few different reasons why I really like it in VI counts you have this Tableau of cards but it's only ever three cards that are constantly shifting so every time you play out a card one of the other ones falls off and the cards are important because it gives you this the symbols and icons you need to do the different actions so you always have to plan ahead and set yourself up for future turns but those different actions that you can do all play a little bit differently because you can put buildings on the edge of the board or you can climb up the castle in the center of that Combos and lots of like fun ways or you can collect manuscripts and you could do a mix of them so we've had times when we've won because we've really focused on one of the strategies and other times we've done kind of a mix of everything because that's how it worked out to do whatever is best at the time with the cards you have and that works too and with the expansions the two expansions that came out because originally the castle was kind of the thing to do it felt like you just got so much stuff in it comboed so like nicely
and you it would just it would get you a lot of a lot of points but the expansions really built up the other two things now the buildings are a lot more interesting and the manuscripts now have this um have like special powers that go with them but I do think it's kind of like the best form of the game yeah we had kind of stopped playing it once we realized that the castle is really the way to go and so this has made us play it a lot more to explore those other options and that makes my counts my number 24. my number 23 is caverna and a lot of people say caverna is basically Agricola 2.0 and they say that because it is 100 true it is very much that but I do think it fixes some of the stuff in a Greek I know that there's some real Agricola purists out there and I get it because it's a terrific game but caverna I think takes what's great about it and just adds like a little bit of fun to it and it adds a cave so in caverna you are farmers but you're also cave Farmers so you're making stuff in caves you're Mining and you're dwarves and you're also going out on adventures and you're finding stuff on your on adventures and of course it's uve Rosenberg so you're also there's all sorts of animal husbandry and the animals are making love and making more more animals and you gotta find space for all those animals and all of that stuff that we love and it's got just little touches of silliness that just kind of brings it A
step above a lot of the other uvae Rosenberg farming games for me yeah and I think some of those silliness is definitely in in the rooms and because they do have some more serious rooms like what we call the S laughter house laughter room that's where you take animals just to laugh yeah so I think there still is one of those but there's also things like a cuddle room and the cuddle room means you can have like a lot of sheep in there because sheep are great to cuddle and so it has added in a little bit of those silliness through the types of rooms and the silliness as well one thing that I love in this is that when they have children they just wish for them they just they kept it PG there's only the animals are doing it the people are just wishing for children and then they just appear and it's just so silly and that is my to want to E3 my number 23 is viticulture and this already came up on your list so I don't have too much more to add but you did mention that it is following the wine making process so it makes a work replacement game really approachable because you have to first plant the grapes then harvest the grapes and turn them into wine and I really like the components that they used so the glass beads that go on the grapes that's as you age them you get to move it along and you can still see the number underneath and then as you turn into wine that again that goes has the same system I don't know why more games don't use glass beads because it it's lets you
see the number and it magnifies it and it looks really cool yeah that's one of those things that I can almost see that like coming up organically and like the prototyping or something because I've seen people use prototypes that use these sorts of beads because you can just buy these at craft stores for like super cheap or garden stores or whatever but the it's so smart because you put that on there and it magnifies the thing underneath and and it looks a bit like a gray it does and I think this one might be a smidge higher for me is because I also we both really like the viticulture world but I really like Cooperative games so I really like that this cam uh this Cooperative expansion that changed the competitive game into a Cooperative game and viticulture is my number 23. my number 22 is pandemic Legacy and pandemic Legacy was a lot higher on this list but there's just there hasn't been one in over a year we haven't really well we haven't played it at all in the last year so it has fallen back a bit but when we were playing pandemic Legacy I loved it this was our first Legacy game was the first pandemic Legacy and the second one does fall off a bit but I think it's better than people give it credit for but the third one I think is where it really shines pandemic Legacy zero which is like the prequel just just a terrific job of this like Cold War era thing mixed into the pandemic system and I am kind of when I'm talking about pandemic Legacy lumping the pandemic system and I I love it it's a Gateway
game for so many people what brings them in and we still we play Iberia especially all the time yeah Iberia looks amazing and it's interesting how many things they've done with the pandemic system because Clone War as we managed to play at a board game Cafe which was really good as well super different and super different and I've heard is it The Hot Zone one that is apparently fall of Rome a fall of Rome right that's what Apollo Mori version that we also still need to play yeah and the hot like there's so many different we were we've been trying to play every pandemic if we see one we haven't played when we're at board game cafes we always play it and we've played I don't know I don't know how many there are but we must have played eight or nine by now and it's just it's always a solid game and so that is my 22. my number 22 is wingspan and in wingspan you're building out a tableau of birds and I really like nature themed games and I think wingspan really helped push the modern board game into this direction because I think there were definitely some more nature themed games before but this has been like just a huge hit it's been an amazing Gateway game to bring new people into the Hobby and so I love the theme but I also just like the the mechanics because each round you have one less action Cube to play but because you have more birds on your Tableau you're able to do more things as you activate each of them and the Asia expansion has
helped make it a lot more interesting to me I think because it helps the two-player game and it just adds this other layer where you've got this board that's like a really light kind of area control thing and I think maybe some of the birds too like the newer Powers maybe are a bit more interesting but it definitely has won me over a little bit so it's it's starting to to get me one over just once they finally have that that uh flying reptiles expansion that I want so bad imagine pterodactyls and pterodons and all of all to be so great so once they have that I'm gonna be one over we'll see if a dinosaur version comes out in the future but for now the duet mode is nice nice to be able to add that extra layer for what card you might play and wingspan is my number 22. my number 21 is between two castles and this is just our ultimate Comfort game this is our absolute number one like if we don't know what else to play and we're just no one wants to think about it this is the the go-to this is just hot chocolate in board game form for us and and it's not supposed to be a two-player game as well and we have never played it with more than two players and I'm not even that interested in playing it with more than two players because we play the um the the special variant from the expansion but you can just play it anyway where you both draft so you're both drafting the tiles and you draft two tiles one for you and one
for the other players so obviously you would like one that is helpful and you want to give them one that is not helpful at all but sometimes it ends up being helpful because you're not sure what else they're gonna draft as well and they don't get to see it until they've chosen so you just give it to them upside down so there it so it fits the theme because it's meant to be these poorly built castles I really like that variant and you're so mean to me because every time I give you a tile I was like oh thank you so much this is exactly what I wanted and somehow too I mean half the time I think you're just putting me on but half the time I actually think that it ends up being helpful for you I don't care very kind in this game and I feel like you still you all please man just give me something I really don't want and so I'm just I don't know somehow accidentally helping you out all the time I think it really is just me killing her with kindness I know because she's so mischievously you'll hate this and she hates it so much we're like oh my goodness thank you so much it's such a like a passive aggressive uh way to play this game but if you haven't played the two player variant I highly recommend to do the one of the secrets and soiree's box but or just what we just said just play it like that and that is my 21. my number 21 is parade and in parade you have a lineup a parade if you will of characters and you add a card to the end of the parade and you might end up
having to take some cards because how it works is when you add the card to the end of the parade you count the value of the card and anything that's beyond that that's the same or lesser value or the same suit you have to take but you don't want to take cards and you especially don't want to take high value cards because that's how many points it's going to be worth at the end and points are bad so there's this building tension as the lineup gets longer and longer because you're likely going to have to end up taking something but you're also keeping an eye on your opponents because if you or them have the most of a colored suit you get to flip them and they're only going to be worth one point each so if I see that Sean has like three black cards I might try and then get more black cards than him so that he doesn't get to flip his yeah this game this is just such a like classic feeling card game even though it's got the Alice in Wonderland thing and it's got that theme and it does have that they're in a parade and that the scoring is reversed that all feels a little bit Alice in wonderlandy but this really feels like the sort of game that your parents might be playing this feels like the sort of game that you play like late night with a few drinks this is so that kind of like social card game that's just a classic like this could have been invented in like the 1960s and it would feel like that would feel totally normal to me that would feel like oh yeah of course this was made in the 60s and it looks really great which I think
definitely helps bring people in and want to play the game as well and that makes parade my number 21. hey and that is it that brings us just about to the end of the 20 so next time we're going to be doing number 20 and then counting down the teens and then it is the top ten and this next chunk I think it was really difficult for me because it's getting to do they make the top 10 or not so I had a hard time figuring out which ones would be in this next video or in the final video yeah I feel like my top 20 is my top 10. like everything in my top 20 feels so top 10 worthy it's uh it is really heartbreaking to kick so I feel like they have feelings and I'm making them sad but thank you so much for watching please let us know if you played any of the games that we talked about and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game