Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:17

today's topic board games satisfied welcome to table scraps short discussions about board card and tabletop gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there everybody and welcome back to another episode of table scraps the live streaming show where I discuss a topic about board card and tabletop games with the live streaming YouTube chat and the topics that we disc us are also supplied by the live streaming YouTube chat and today is no exception because today's topic comes from viewer Lucas who says what does a game need to do to give you a feeling of satisfaction he goes into detail saying I was thinking about some games that I've played and this question popped up it's not a matter of game length or genre preference but what a game needs to accomplish to you to be worthy I I remember when I played fairy tale it's a really neat drafting game but it felt like it was too quick I I could put a lot of examples in here games that take too long doing the same thing over and over again Etc but my point is what a game needs to do for you personally to give this feeling of satisfaction when I am standing in a game shop or looking online looking to purchase a game I know exactly what it is that gives me that sense of satisfaction of just thinking about it that that pushes me over to

purchasing it uh I know that if I picture oh I know who I would play this game with or this is the type of experience I would have with this game with this person I usually get I've mentioned a little thought bubble where I I think about like there's you know if I'm like with a certain game group oh this game group would like this or I would my daughter would like to play this game and playing this with her or you know my wife oh man when we actually have like some time on a weekend together or something if I can yet that mental image of sharing the game with someone or having a certain experience with someone that's what usually satisfies me to the point gives me that warm fuzzy inside to get me to purchase the game so do I personally get a sense of satisfaction when a game lives up to that potential that I imagined before I purchased it is that the factor that it has to reach that potential I've seen games that surprise me in in different ways and have had led to a different experience than what I was still originally expecting and they've still worked we're going to start off with a statement from Mike Jones who says for competitive games you know that's totally different those were only satisfying if every player had an equal chance competitive games must be balanced to be satisfying basically it sounds to me like everybody needs that fair shot to implement their tactics and their strategy and all things being equal the person with the best strategy is the winner I immediately thought about games like uh The

Godfather coron's Empire um which is on the Shelf over there but I don't need to look at it because you guys you guys can't see it but I know in speaking with Eric Lang who designed that game he specifically said that there are certain cards in the game and certain locations on the board on the map that are unbalanced and he did that specifically to uh encourage conflict within the game so if you get that if you get one of those good cards or you get one of those good spaces first you know people are going to fight you for it or you're going to be able to to do a lot of damage to your opponents and in that respect that is in a way unbalanced Jeremy who says a game for me to give satisfaction is what makes you talk afterwards games like Star Wars rebellion from Fantasy Flight each time I end a game I always talk about what we just did oh Jeremy I'm so glad you mentioned it because that was one of the other things that came to mind is having a story to tell afterwards I still remember this game of um betrayal at house on the hill that I played where I was the one that turned out to go crazy and was the Traer against the team but I remember at the end that the uh the house it turned out the house started to collapse in and of itself and all the rooms were being removed but one by one and everybody was trying to make their way Escape out of the house before I hunted them all down and destroyed them but uh it turned out that one of the players was playing the the little girl um character and I remember like the last turn or second to last turn of

the game uh that character was running down this Hall trying to make it to to escape and the like the tiles were collapsing right behind the character as she ran boom boom boom so we could just picture this last Stitch effort to run down this hallway as the ceiling is caving in behind you as you're sprinting towards the exit and even I as the traitor was rooting for the players go go go make it down theall way go go go and it left us with such a story you know I didn't even care at that point if I won or they won whatever we just wanted we were left with the story with this scene this moment of them running sprinting down the hall trying to make it out of this collapsing house and definitely it was a very very satisfying gaming experience because we were left with that story to tell so I think that that is a very very big part of it however however there are games like uh game Arboretum oh man Arboretum can really make your brain boil it's just a little card game and so you're not going to always be left with a story but you can have very very satisfying uh games of a game like that where it's just you have a puzzle to figure out or you have a strategy to implement and you do it and there's no real narrative to it but you're still left with that but no story but you're left with it so Kena who says the shortcut is is to deliver a sense of exploration for me but outside of that make it feel like I've accomplished

something win or lose have me build something in my own corner for example uh exploration and accomplishment if you have the players even if they lose like you mentioned if they're able to discover something uh learn something uh not and not just like learning how the game works but learning oh if I do this you know I could possibly win or I could come here's a combo I came up with here's a Str that even if everyone else in the same everyone else who plays the game even if they come up with that strategy if play if the player is left with the sense of I came up with this idea I discovered this or I built this thing that I think I agree can totally be a primary major factor in a sense of satisfaction playing a game David mentions I feel satisfied when there are clear tiebreaker conditions everyone shares the victory with a hug and a snow cone is little too t-ball for me when you go through a whole game and get to the end just to realize oh well there's no winner everyone wins so again what did we just do that for definitely definitely can agree with that jar prions personally it needs to get me involved with the quote unquote story and what I'm trying to get at and also how hard was it to get the victory when it's too easy it's bad and when it's too hard it's also bad oh very good point is that you not only have to accomplish something you have to have that proper amount of risk and reward in it um I worked for a company once um that made

video games and there was this whole big presentation that uh one of the lead developers gave that I was just riveting um he talked about when you're developing a game whether it be a board game tabletop game or video game you need to have the right types of carrots and rewards for the players to lead them through the game experience and keep them going because if the carrots the things that uh entice them are too dull or too boring you'll lose them and but if the rewards also don't match uh what they risk to get that reward the the carrot you know if they don't if the rewards don't match then it's also going to get lopsided and just like jarb said can be unsatisfying because it's too hard or too easy so definitely agree there is a balance definitely a balance in there that needs to be achieved Peter mentions a feeling of accomplishment doing better than expected beating the escape room all while it being enjoyable to play those bring satisfaction oh Escape rooms there is an excellent excellent example here every escape room I've been into the first 20 minutes or so in the escape room is just this feeling of dread of we are never ever going to figure this out there's just too much I'm overwhelmed and then you start get the little a little win and then another little win and another little win and before you know it you see the light at the end of the tunnel you're like we could do this we can do this and then when you do whether you have you know 15 minutes or 15 seconds left on the clock that and that building up of expectations or or

changing the expectations going from overwhelmed to we can do this to accomplishment that is an excellent example of of fighting a satisfactory experience for gamers Nick mentions satisfaction seems to be the minimum bar satisfaction for me means the game accomplished what it set out to do and provides enjoyment some games surpass this Mark in my description so far when I come to when I've been talking about satisfaction I guess I've been talking about exceeding expectations but true I guess there are multiple there's going to be multiple levels of satisfaction question back for you though Nick the games that give the minimum bar level of satisfaction do you find yourself returning to those games or do you put them aside and when the time comes to play something else H you choose something else instead hoping that it'll give you a greater level of satisfaction does that enter into which games you decide to play love to know in the comments below halfhand 83 who says more often for me satisfaction in a game comes from who I'm playing it with and whether or not they enjoyed it if the people I'm playing with aren't having fun neither am I that is an excellent point there halfhand and one that I'm glad that you mentioned so often when I am introducing a game to a group or someone else yes I absolutely agree my enjoyment of the game my satisfaction is directly tied to theirs if I look up and they're bored to

tears and they're not enjoying the game totally ruins it for me because I don't know if it's just being in host mode or just that you're sharing the gaming experience but um that definitely definitely can be a determining Factor Kabuki menion I am satisfied when I'm able to explore enough of the game before it ends Z played to 20 points is much more satisfying game than playing the 10 points you get to explore the game more plus playing the 10 never lets you even get to the bigger ships which is also quite satisfying oh there yeah okay there's a very good point in games with variable length uh variable Point totals or variable wind conditions or whatever uh that you can kind of adjust for different modes play that definitely can lead to a level of satisfaction uh again though the reverse is also true it is possible for a game to overstay its welcome um and by setting that too long or uh you know you could definitely sour the experience that way Stephen says sometimes I find great satisfaction when I barely notied that the game was over I played my first game of charterstone with my wife and Bam suddenly it was done it was great if you can uh immerse yourself and lose yourself in a game like that definitely can add to the uh the the level of satisfaction on it and even if it's a short quick game a bam we're done and I think there's a difference between that and feeling like the game ends too quickly mm's question which is talk about satisfaction he says

satisfying to me is much more subjective about the people and situation than the game itself there's another vote for it not really being the game itself but the people you're playing with that can really affect a level of a game satisfaction again totally agree on that Toyota mentions for me to feel satisfied with a game I must be pulled into the theme I want to have fun playing it more often than not games become too complex and not fun enough but I do like complex that's true again I I think it's about balance here we talked about the risk we've talked about know the carrots versus reward and everything and the level of complexity definitely factors into that if a you know and again it depends if that's you're looking for uh I've heard people talk about playing uh feudum I believe and feudum super mega big complex game but if that's what you're in in for and that's what you're looking for in a gaming experience that's going to really hit the spot jarb mentions what gives me satisfaction is actually the people playing the game with me of course the game influences that result but if the people are not willing it feels terrible no matter what the game and that is absolutely true when I was seven um I would visit my grandma during the the Summers and we would play Monopoly and I mean we would play these epic games of Monopoly I loved them they were fantastic we would play games of Monopoly we would sit down and play for like three four six hours of the day and the game would span like

three days oh they were just these huge epic Mega games of of Monopoly they were fantastic and then um shortly before uh she passed away uh I was talking with her one day and we were talking about those old games of Monopoly when I would come and visit her and she said yeah man I hate that game I never realized at the time but she endured these epic multi-day games and Monopoly with me because she loved me and that was the satisfaction she got out of the game with spending the time but the game itself absolutely not Mike Jones says now if we're talking about a game I'm watching then the satisfaction comes from the skill level and Mastery of Craft on display I want to watch The Impossible performed yes as a spectator you you want to see 100 overtimes and a million points on the board I I think which we mentioned last episode yeah you want to see the spectacle you want to see an event you want to go wow and that is true the as a spectator you definitely can have a different things that will influence your level of satisfaction in watching the game so that's a really good point too let's wrap up here with a comment from Tren who asks is there a difference between appreciation enjoyment and satisfaction I can appreciate a game that I will never want to play again there have been games that I get up from the table I'm like wow I can really appreciate what that game was

doing do I want to play it again oh heck no no I'm burning my copy of it but I appreciated it uh then enjoyment uh that can be wow that was you know a fantastic experience I just had you know the the UPS the Downs the laughter we had I really enjoyed that now that we're done you know I'm ready to move on to something else but I really had fun in the moment and then there's satisfaction which I think more is I've experienced satisfaction in gaming more when I get done with the game and I scoot my chair back from the table and it's almost like digesting a huge meal that feeling of satisfaction of chewing mentally chewing on the experience and going back over it and just being like wow I really enjoyed that experience I'm going to be thinking about that as something I want to experience again I'm really satisfied with how it went I I think in that respect yeah uh appreciation enjoyment and satisfaction can be totally different areas of the uh experience that someone has playing a game however that's just my definitions of those three things how would you guys Define appreciation versus enjoyment versus satisfaction of a gaming experience continue the conversation in the comments below and in the meantime for more board game videos and news commentary countdowns and whatnot be sure to subscribe I've been Chaz Marler from Parise Paradise thanks so much for tuning in I'll talk to you again

soon blooper time let me do that one more time so I don't look like a total troll exploration oh phone calls I don't know why I'm rubbing my tummy now uh because it's full of uh gaming food I guess and I was about to put a toothpick in my mouth

Progress saved