Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cascadito, Courtisans, Mystic Vale, Pagoda, K'uh Nah Ranked and Reviewed

Transcript 13:59

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games and I rank and review them in order from my least favorite up to my most favorite uh before I get started on these five games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order and five I have Kar now this is a variant on the classic filler game no thanks and much like no thanks you are trying to get as few points as possible uh by the time the game draws to an end and much like no thanks on your turn you have the option to take a card from the senser or to place one of your tokens on it in order to pass it on to the next player now the main difference between this one and no thanks is that instead of all the cards being worth what they're worth face value this one each of the cars kind of represents a piece of a pyramid where um you are essentially trying to build a pyramid of cards and only the kind of Pinnacles of those pyramids will score you points so if you have say higher value cards you can cover up with a lower value card and therefore nullify the scoring of these two beneath it so you do have that kind of overlaying mechanism to the game which I thought was actually very cool in principle so I actually like the idea and concept of this one but unfort fortunately um the

tension is completely eradicated from the game when comparing it to a game like no thanks um because the actual consequences of your actions don't feel quite as strong because especially through the first say 75% of the game you're not really that hesitant to pick up cards because you know you've got enough time to cover up with lower valued cards also these the management of the tokens in your hand didn't really feel that tense um you know I never I personally ran out or came near to running out because I was never that fearful to take a card so all in all um this is so close to a game called like no thanks that I don't see any reason to play this one because it's subpar in every single aspect so unfortunately I can't recommend it that is kunar at number five at number four I have Coran so this is a kind of a set collection style game with a degree of commodity speculation because the values of the suits of cards that you're collecting is going to either be worth positive points or negative points based on what the other players do so this game each turn you have three cards at your disposal you're going to have to play one of them in front of you you're going to have to play one of them in front of an opponent and the other one is going to have to go on this banquet table which will show whether these different suits are going to be kind of in positive values or negative values so you have the option to play it kind of above the banquet table or below the banket table all those relevant suits if at the end of

the game there are more cards below it then every card that each player has collected of that type will be worth negative points but if again the above the banquet table outweighs the negative points then they're going to be worth positive points now there are a few additional um little tricks to the game for example you have these assassin cards that can eliminate cards from other other players or even from yourself so that's a good way of getting yourself out of tricky situations you've got these spy cards that could be played Face Down which kind of spices up the banquet table a little bit because you don't quite know with certainty of how these things are going to end up you have these Noble cards that will have double value um and you also have these kind of Shield cards that cannot be attacked by other players now again I like the concept of this game it reminds me very much of biblos know biblio you are divvying out these cards sometimes being forced to make very difficult decisions because you know you might have to give your opponent a quite a nice card he didn't want to give them but I thought that biblio did it in a lot more interesting Way by being forced to make that decision after every single card you draw so you don't know what's going to come up next whereas in qutis you have those three cards in your hand you can see them before you make those decisions so there's no kind of push your luck aspect of the game now some people might like that but I actually think that it takes some of the tension out because you think you know should I take this card for myself or will I get a better one later would it be better will it be worse and so on that is completely not in this game at all now I

love it visually I think the artwork is really nice it has this kind of like uh Golden Age Disney fil vibe to it with these nice um gilded cards um and I really wanted to like it but sadly it felt a bit pedestrian and it's pretty obvious what other players are going for so you know if your opponent's got a bunch of I don't know red cards in front of them you might want to start tanking those red cards again fairly obvious choices to be made there um and I was never really put in that position where know I was making really crunchy difficult decisions so if I wanted a Vibe a game with this Vibe I would play something like biblos over this one I suppose in its Advantage it is very fast you know only takes around 15 to 20 minutes to play again visually it is lovely to look at um but yeah sadly didn't quite stick The Landing for me uh that is cortis at number four at number three I have pagod is a two player only game where you and your opponent are building these pagodas communally so both you and your opponent are contributing to the same pieces here now it's a card driven game with a pretty interesting hand management system where uh five out of your seven cards are actually visible to your opponent so they can see what options you have but don't quite have perfect information because again those two cards are hidden now in this game it's very simple where all you're going to do is you're going to be playing playing these cards mostly to build these little pillars um you know yellow cards will build yellow

pillars and so on depending on the level of those pillars you are going to get that many points so on the first level they're worth one point second level two points and so on but the the kind of main Vibe of this game is to not give your opponent easy opportunities because you know if your opponent has a bunch of say blue cards in front of them you don't want to build a base that needs blue pillars going forward you know you want to be making sure that you're building pillar that suit your hand and not your opponents um but because you are forced to build at least one pillar each turn um you can sometimes be forced to make decisions that you don't want to uh want to do so it's all about trying to optimally optimally play those cards as best as possible there are a few additional twists where if you build a new platform you get a bonus power which will give you you little rule breaking abilities such as being able to play more pillars per turn or being able to play a two for one mechanism or even having more cards in your hand they're all pretty subtle and pretty underwhelming but they can help you if in the right situation um all in all despite me liking the concept of the game I thought that it was a little bit too card dependent you know you are really just you know top decking cards hoping you get what you want a little bit too Tactical for my liking I think that long-term decision- making isn't quite there I was trying to look for the depth in the game but I did struggle with find it if I'm honest and I think if you played this game once or twice you've pretty much seen everything the game has to offer and it didn't have

that longevity in in my opinion you know you might disagree with me I I don't know but for me it didn't quite it wasn't quite strong enough to um hold up to so many other great two-player games uh despite having quite a cool table presence so that is Pagoda at number three at number two I have Mystic Veil so this is a deck building game with a Twist in fact it's called a card crafting game so with most deck building games you might know you start with a very basic deck uh you get more and more cards as you go by you know buying new ones adding it to your hand shuffling and going round and round and ground until eventually you have quite a powerful deck of cards this one you only ever have 20 cards and instead of adding new cards to your hand you are kind of buffing those cards by purchasing these kind of acetate transparent slips that will go into these sleeves and make your existing cards more powerful um on paper that sounds fantastic that had me um definitely piqued my interest I wanted to see how the game actually played and it does work well um but unfortunately I think my my concerns became a reality because I was thinking is this game just a another way of presenting or repackaging um existing deck building mechanisms cuz in theory you are pretty much just doing the same thing here you know instead of having another card you making an existing card better and when you actually play it it does just feel like you're playing any other deck boning game which was sadly a bit

frustrating for me now don't get me wrong mechanically this game works excellently it it works exactly as it should I know it does a lot of things you'd expect for it to do you know build increase your currency to get better upgrades um some cards will give you sorry some upgrades will give you passive points um some have symbols or icons on them that will let you buy these more kind of endgame scoring cards or ongoing ability cards and so on I suppose the additional Touch of this one is that it did have a degree of push your luck because um on a number of these cards you have these little Burnt Tree symbols and if you reveal too many of those then you'll go bust so instead of having say a fixed amount of drawing six cards per turn as you do with a lot of deck building games this one you can have know sometimes 10 cards in front of you if not more than that um by not revealing those burnt trees or even ating those burnt trees with other upgrades so I like that part of the game for sure but the rest of it just felt very deck buery you know felt very generic for me and it didn't quite differentiate different differentiate itself from those sea of other deck builders and ultimately it boiled down to that card crafting system being a bit of a gimmick I think rather than an actual unique mechanism it's just again a different way of presenting a deck building game rather than being a a unique mechanism in its own right so still I know there's going to be a lot of people who enjoy this um deck building fans are going to like it sadly I'm generally lukewarm on deck builders and this was a prime example of that

still objectively a good game but know strong game but one that's definitely not going to stick around for me that is Mystic Veil at number two and finally at number one I have cascadeo so this is the roll and right version of cascadera which you might know recently I put a review out um which wasn't the most positive on cascadero and that is quite a surprise for a lot of you guys but also for me because it was my most anticipated game of 2024 I love R Kia games I love the premise of this game with the Track Climbing and the kind of roote building the amazing visual um visual look of the game but the you know the board game version fell a bit flat because I thought it was a little bit clunky a little bit disjointed and when I played that original cascadera I thought you know this game would really lend itself well to a roll and right game and here we have cascadeo this feels like this was the intended game and cascadera was buil after it rather than the other way around uh the mechanisms are well better suited to a Rolland right game um because your options are just limited and restricted rather than being able to go anywhere the board feels tighter even though you are only doing your own thing and you are still even Racing for these objectives um even though you're not playing on a common board and on top of that you have different maps you can play with with different rules that are quite subtle to quite extreme um and

that tension of the dice draft shines through much stronger in this one rather than the board game where you can just go wherever you want to go so um all in all I thought this game was really refreshing after not enjoying the um the core game as much as I probably should have and yeah this one much more condensed I think it's smoother I think you can take more ownership of your board uh the tension is still there while by Racing for those goals still has the cool graphic design um and even has injected replayability through those different maps you can play on so for me if you played cascadero and not cascadeo I'd definitely recommend looking at cascadeo or if you like the idea of the game but maybe you wanted a smaller box or you wouldn't sure which one to go for I would highly recommend choosing cascadeo over cascadero because because you get the whole experience plus more in a smaller condensed box a faster game and um yeah I think there's no negatives on the Rolland right game comparing it to the board game and and this is what I wanted it to be so definitely um like this one I'm not quite going to give it accommodation yet because I want to play it some more this is more of an initial Impressions review um but right now it's looking quite promising and this is what I wanted cascadero to be so that is cascadeo at number one so there we have it that concludes another ranking video five very different games here sadly nothing that quite came through with a solid Commendation but who knows with repeated

plays maybe cascadeo I could get there but despite that hopefully you have enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved