Why I Stopped Buying EVERY Board Game!
Transcript
Over the past year, while learning how to parent for the first time ever in my life, I've been out of touch with the board game industry in a way that I really hadn't been for the better part of 6 years or so. I haven't been following Kickstarter projects. I haven't been backing every single thing that looks cool and is coming across the line with pretty minis or a promising story. I haven't been playing a lot of brand new games that have been arriving into the studio and primarily I just haven't been following along. I haven't read updates or concerned myself over how much tariffs are going to cost when it comes to new projects either in the future or in the past. I almost lost a full $650 pledge for a board game that I had paid every penny of, except for a $22 tariff tax that I'd somehow, well, not somehow, very, very reasonably overlooked. Assumed wasn't a problem.
Hadn't checked Gamefound in six, seven months, and it skirted on by. Luckily, the publisher has got back to me and let me know that if I get it paid, I will still receive my game. But I really haven't been paying attention. I don't know what the state of our industry truly is. And I'm kind of excited about that in a way because even when you're fine-tuned, even when you are paying attention to every single detail, every project that comes and goes, succeeds or fails, new ventures like Gamefound back in the day that spring up and slowly start climbing the ranks of the crowdfunding industry, even when you think you know it all, you're still not really aware. of everything that's going on, the pulse, the heartbeat, the rhythm of the industry as a whole. It takes some mixture of disconnected and overly obsessively connected because that is the fan base that we have. Our fan base is full of people who spend hundreds and hundreds, if not thousands and thousands of dollars on games that they don't play for a decade. All with the hope that one day they'll be able to get the right group, the right family or friends together, have the amount of time they need, have learned the game, and sit down to experience it for the first time in the way that they always dreamed they
could. We are a community full of people with maxed out credit cards cuz the next addictive board game on the shelf just needed to be purchased even though we haven't played the last dozen that came in or because we've backed 20 not realizing that they're all going to arrive in about a year and uh our satiation for brand new boxes is going to slow down in between then and now. We're not the same industry that existed before the pandemic. An industry when crowdfunding was a dream that publishers could use to make things happen. Where Kingdom Death launched without a semblance of what it was going to become, but beautiful art, incredible miniatures, and a promise of something special was enough to convince people to give millions of dollars to see it created. And that has succeeded and failed countless times and in numerous ways and at varying varying levels.
The pandemic, the shipping crisis, the taxes that we all endured when it came to uh paying for extra uh you know extra taxes over in in in Europe. I'm forgetting what they're specifically called. We we've been through a lot as an industry. We've seen titans that we think have established their throne like mythic games with Darkest Dungeon. We've seen them crumble and fall and failed to deliver piles and piles of games. I was just on a a phone call with a friend last night who mentioned that in the Darkest Dungeon Mythic Games Escapade, he's out over $1,000 between Anastere and a few titles and all the stuff that wasn't actually delivered.
We're not the same community. We're more hesitant, more cautious. we are more skeptical of crowdfunding projects that don't have history and age behind them. And honestly, I don't know as much as I should about this subject coming up, but with the news around and the swell of concern that Seimon's been going through, I think there's a strong likelihood that we're a community that to some degree doesn't even trust the big publishers who uh have a history behind them. I would have told you Sean was always a sure bet. Yeah, they might be a little bit too big for their britches or overextended here or there, but the profit margins are good. Their uh diligence and ability to deliver is uh steadfast.
And yet the the swirling that we've seen in the water speaks of a more risky b business venture than any of us had entirely guessed. speaks of maybe too many ducks in the pond or too little water flowing. And then again, I don't know. I've read a lot of headlines and see a lot of comments on Facebook and scrolled through some feeds, but I I haven't been reading or watching or consuming a lot of board game content over the last year. I've been focused on being a dad and figuring out life. And I've been doing a really bad job at that. Finding the balance. Not being a dad. A decent dad. bad at finding the balance of life. So, we'll just keep sticking our head as far as possible into each venture that we explore. And uh we're swinging back around for board games. I'm excited to play some games. I'm excited to back some games. I'm excited to showcase and advertise and have people come over and learn and grow and reexplore this hobby space with you all. But to do that, I kind of need to know what the state of the industry is currently from your perspective. So, I've got four quick questions that I want to go through, and I really, really want you to think through these questions and leave a comment for me to read and reflect on.
It affects the way that I approach content that I'm making. It affects the way that we approach conversations with publishers that are either bringing new games into the market, reprints that they're excited about, planning for the next, you know, 12, 18, 24 months. Our industry is at a point where the direction that we could go or that we will go is variable and I think fairly tenuous. And you all, the community, the people who buy, purchase, play, put your trust in, you are the people that we rely on to guide the ship. And if we or some publishers along the road get it wrong, a lot of harm can be done. Backers can lose pledges and games. publishers can lose businesses or watch their dream, you know, squander on the uh vine that isn't connected to the ground anymore.
So, let's talk about it. Let's have a conversation. Let's look at the state of the industry together and read some of other people's comments, too. Respond to them, debate them, argue with them. Let's get a conversation going. I will be reading every single and responding to every single comment on this video. Uh, and I'm really, really interested to hear what you all think. So, first question, are you still backing games or even buying games for that matter? Where are you? Are you feeling pretty secure in your job, in your career, in the finances that you have, or you've got a credit limit that you're not yet too concerned about? Are you buying games to play to store on the shelf cuz you still like collecting in the hobby? Are you backing games? Are you worried about tariffs, shipping costs, rising production, trade disruption across the country? And if so, how is that reflected or not reflected in your purchasing and backing habits? Maybe you're one of those indie game darlings like my friend West who will go out of his way to support a game because people are a little bit more nervous and a little bit less trusting.
Do you want to see new things come to life? Do you still have the nostalgia for what board games and board game crowdfunding was and you're still holding on to that dream, which I think is a beautiful dream and and probably one worth holding on to if you can manage it? I know for myself, I really haven't backed anything for the last year or so. I have some projects that are still floating that I backed a couple years ago. I have some that have come in that were the last ones that I backed recently and I'm not buying a lot of games either. Now, there are a lot of games out there that I want and there's a lot of crowdfunding projects that I desperately wish I could back, but I'm not even as gung-ho when it comes to aggressively backing games at the moment. Anyway, I'm sort of in the middle ground. Like, I'm skeptical of brand brand new publishers. I want them to see I want them to have a good prototype, a good working copy. I also want them to be uh at least confident in their communication. I'm not going to back something that is just making me promises and whispering sweet words. And then on top of that, I'm not so interested in backing the big boys right now. Like Sean's an obvious one if they were running campaigns, but even companies like Awakened Realms don't have my attention entirely.
I do want their games. I desperately want to get a copy of Dragon Eclipse, and I just got a copy of Tainted Grail: Kings of Ruin in, and I can't wait to play it. So, it's not a lack of interest or desire for the titles that they're producing, but it's a confidence that the big publishers are going to be going down one of two routes. They're either going to be delivering their games at such a high volume that I can get my hands on them eventually. I might pay a little bit more, but I'll be able to access them, or they're going to crumble and I don't have five, six, $700 to lose. At some point, I did. and and at some point I probably would have said that was okay not for you all but for me for taking the risk but that's just not where I am and it it's not where I feel the industry is. I'll tell you what I am interested in supporting and backing though. The midsize, possibly first time, more likely secondtime publishers who need and needed crowdfunding to exist in the first place, who don't have warehouses to store all their titles, who are creating beautiful games that are already proven on the table either through prototype form or first distributions.
I still want to see us and I still personally want to support those publishers because they're the ones that still reflect what I always thought and always hope the crowdfunding space maintains. an ability to see beautiful things come to life that wouldn't have the capacity to do so without a obsessively dedicated board game creator and publisher and a bunch of risk comfortable fans who are throwing a couple hundred dollars at the wall saying yeah boy make your dream come true. So question number two, industry disruption, is it affecting you? I I've mentioned a bunch of things here. Shipping crisis, the tax for the tariffs that almost cost me an entire pledge. Uh, I've I've mentioned issues that we've had like uh uh Sean shutting down and Mythic Games, but I don't really know if that's me being aware of the greater industry as a whole or if that is an accurate sense of of how people are feeling out there in the space. So you all, the fans, the backers, the community members, have you been affected adversely by any of this disruption? And if so, what has affected you the most? Is it seeing publishers that you admire, you know, kind of sit back on their heels? Is it uh a charge
that you didn't expect that you really couldn't afford or a game that you lost cuz you missed the window to pay the fee? or something else, something that I've overlooked. For myself, it's sort of all of the above and none of the above. I I would say that almost losing the pledge is is a kind of a big shock cuz shipping was already paid. Like, it wasn't like there was anything else standing other than a surprise bill for tariffs. And if I wasn't paying attention, well, I wasn't paying attention and I very easily could have continued to miss it for another couple months and then I I don't think I would have ended up getting the game in. But other than just a cooling impact on me, I I don't know that any other specific industry disruption has had a uh notable or lasting effect in in in my relationship with the space. It has more to do with with my personal experience as opposed to an industry one. Question number three, how are you currently experiencing the hobby? What is your average game group size? For myself, it's one, sometimes two. When we travel to friends houses, three, but I don't have an active game group at the moment.
And uh, as much as I would like one, it's hard to find the time and the space and the elbow room to make one happen. I'm not playing as many new games either. Even with the channel, I am, for the most part, circling back and playing the classics that I love or learning a new game and spending 10, 15 game cycles in it. I have a lot of games that I would love to play. We've talked about that. There's a ton of titles that are still in shrink or still in boxes on my shelf that I can't wait to explore. And some of them are solo. So, it means I will be able to do it soon. But I, you know, I don't really feel like I need to play new games cuz the ones that I already know and love are really good and and often not beaten by other titles that have arrived. When it comes to how I'm looking at the space and exploring the space, I'm still looking for stories, for beautiful artwork and environments and worlds and and and adventures that I can go on that are unlike other games. I'm still looking for unique uh mechanics, uh things that give me a puzzle that feels satisfying or um different from other puzzles that I have played and continue to play. So, that's how I am experiencing the hobby. I' I'd love to hear from you all. How are you My legs are falling asleep, so I had to I had to change my angle a little bit. How are
you all experiencing the hobby? Player count, size, type of game you're getting to the table, how often are you getting games to the table? Are you playing regularly uh brand new games every time you meet up, or are you playing just an old classic over and over and over again? And then finally, what are your future predictions in our space? Like, do you think we're on the rise or the decline? Are we a swelling industry and community right now? Are more people being exposed to the hobby like in the Wingspan era where it felt like every mainstream newspaper, at least newspaper in the space, had mentioned a board game, which was pretty cool. or are we declining? Is our hobby becoming a little bit too pricey, a little bit more niche? Is it sinking back into itself as people leave due to burnout or overcapacity or debt or family issues they're trying to deal with?
Are game groups growing or is the advent of AI Tik Tok scrolling brain content winning that battle? Is it is it driving people towards sitting down at the table or making it impossible for them to focus long enough to engage and play a game? I'm hopeful and also concerned. I'm hopeful cuz I want to believe in what this space is and and what our hobby space has always been for me. A place to connect, a place to discover new worlds and go on adventures and spend time with friends, a place to heal from the impact and disruption that technology adds into our lives that social media um seeps into our very soul. But at the same time right now in this moment I I don't feel like we're a growing space. That could just be because I haven't been overly connected to our space for the last year. Could be a reflection of my own and I'm sure to some degree it is a reflection of my own experience. But I do feel like we're stable. I don't feel like we're stagnant. I I think we are still changing and and moving in our in our own way, but I don't see us taking off or or or or or growing at a at a rapid rate. I don't see the
industry right now designing or developing or or putting out a title that's going to break barriers in the way that Wingspan and Gloom Haven and and Kingdom Death I think Gloom Haven and Kingdom Death step a little the way that Wingspan though did in its era. Now, next month we can see a game arrive on shelves that every family across our, you know, nation and across the world has to get under the Christmas tree and to the table. And I could be completely wrong, but I feel like right now there's a tightening going on in the wider world. There's a held breath and that reflects down and and and has to have an impact on the communities that we exist in. If our country and the world is holding its breath, watching and waiting and experiencing tension and conflict, then there's not as many people stepping out of their comfort zone, looking for new ways to experience the world. There's not as many people spending money on new games that they've never heard of before.
So, we'll see. It's my sense of things. Hopeful, but maybe a little pessimistic at the moment, but still hopeful. Still dreaming, still playing games and making content and looking forward to connecting with you all whenever and however possible. So, let me know your thoughts to those four questions. Leave a comment down below. What is the state of our industry? It's not something that I'm able to tell you this time, but it is something that I think we're able to observe through communication together. Whatever the case though, whatever you do, remember to do the important thing. Get out and play some games. We'll see you next time. Bye.