"Safe Space Cozy Mode" is not good board game design! Your YouTube comments... and my responses.
Transcript
Oh my god, why's so against competitive with chance in modern board games? Lol. Games teach children that life is not fair. This safe space cozy mode is just your desire to retreat from your daily problems, which is fine, but not good game design. So I'm Adam Porter. I'm a board game designer from Wales. This channel is full of videos, most of which are scripted, all about different aspects of board game design. I try and give you my advice, my experience, and my ideas, my thoughts. They're my opinions, right? And you can see that sometimes my viewers don't necessarily agree with everything that I say. I'm sure that's true of everybody who's posting their opinions on YouTube. I like to use these videos, these more casual chatty videos, to discuss some of the comments that I've seen and respond to some of the more interesting ones, perhaps elaborate on them a little bit more than I could do in writing. So, um, that was an interesting example from the start, and we'll come back to a similar comment later, and I might touch on some of the themes from that comment. So, let's start off with a comment from a video called how players and publishers choose between good board games, which was a recent video that I made. And in that video, I introduce a model or a tool that you can use, which I called the meta hooks model, to break down your your hook into various different categories. you a quick clip, and then I'll
I'll talk you through the comment. Over the last few months, I've been developing a design tool to help answer exactly that question. It's called meta hooks. The framework invites you as a game maker to view your game through four different lenses: a mechanical hook, an experiential hook, a thematic hook, and an aesthetic hook. And the goal is simple: identify why someone should pay attention to your game. Why should a publisher take notice? Why should a retailer stock it? Why should a customer choose it over dozens of other alternatives? So, I had a few comments on this video which said similar things which indicated to me that people were struggling to um to delineate, to separate those different hooks. So, that there were different ones. This one says, "As for the experiential factor, that tends to just fall out of the connection between the themes and mechanisms if it's strong enough in my experience."
Another comment said, "Aesthetics seems somewhat irrelevant when you're never going to have art or graphic design for games that you're pitching. But all the other questions are definitely helpful to ask." And finally, we've got one here which says, "I'm curious to separate out the experiential and the aesthetic hook. Aren't they pretty similar?" I think each of those hooks is different and I appreciate people's struggle and I think part of it is because we've been accustomed to talking about game design in terms of are you theme-led or are you mechanism-led? Um you know, what do you design Designers always get asked this. What do you design first, the theme or the mechanisms? And people often leave out that element of the experience or the presentation which can equally be a selling point for your game.
So, let's start with the presentation. Is it worth a designer thinking about a an aesthetic hook a presentation hook while they're designing the game considering that they'll probably have no control over how the game eventually looks, the final product? Well, I would say absolutely. I would say there are many, many game concepts which rely 100% on that presentation, on the aesthetics, even though the designer is not the person who's ultimately going to implement them. So, think about a game like Dixit. Okay, the game mechanisms do not sell that game. The game is sold based on the artwork, the presentation which the game designer will not have had a huge amount of control over. They will have had a a in their mind and later they will have gone to work with a an illustrator to to realize that. Um another example would be a very different example would be the game Connect Four. So going way back to was it the 1970s that game was created?
The idea there was to take a horizontal board and create a vertical playing space instead which would stand out so you could see it across a room. It would stand out in television commercials or uh in in catalog advertisements as you know in the days before the internet. So that game is sold on its visual appeal first and foremost not on its mechanisms. Um what other examples could we think of? Well, how about something a little more in our wheelhouse? How about something like Wingspan? Elizabeth Hargrave did not sit down and draw hundreds of pictures of birds, but her concept was absolutely that this game would contain cards with hundreds of illustrations of birds. The presentation is a key selling point for that game and it was from the very concept. If the game was described by mechanisms alone, it's actually quite hard to find the hook. The hook is all about that that that presentation.
Um there's no narrative, there's no theme to it, there's no story or characters. It's purely presentation. I shouldn't say purely. There's a lot going on in each of these games and that's the purpose of the meta hooks is to combine these things, work out what are your strongest hooks. That's not to completely um ignore the fact that you have other hooks in your game as well, but create a hybrid hook that brings in the strongest elements of each. What about that other question that was asked by my viewers then? The difference between experiential and presentation. For this, I think the best example is The Mind. So the little card game The Mind has very dull presentation, frankly. It's just a bunch of cards with numbers on them. And if you describe the mechanisms, it sounds pretty boring.
You're just playing numbers in sequence while not being allowed to talk to each other. That's not a particularly exciting prospect. But when you play the game, it comes to life. What is the experiential hook for the mind? It's all about getting in sync with the other players, working together as a team, becoming one mind. That's a great experiential hook. Okay, that game is sold on its experience. To a lesser extent, let's use the example of Magical Athlete, a massively successful hit game of the last few months. If we look at the mechanisms alone, that game is using a mechanism which is widely unpopular, you know, roll and move. That's a turn-off for many people, so it's not being sold with a mechanical hook. In terms of its theme, well, that's confusing, right? There's There's no story that we're being sold with Magical Athlete or nothing particularly coherent. Um so, it's not a thematic hook that's selling it. Presentation is great, okay. The presentation's lovely, it's a bit weird, it's a bit unusual.
But the game itself is actually pretty flat. I mean, too horizontal, right? There's not much in the way of table presence there aside from the fact these drawings are a bit weird and wacky. So, the game is largely being sold on the experience, and that's being spread by word of mouth um everywhere. So, there's an experiential hook there which is about chaos and laughter and rivalries and variety. Okay, so it's got this great experiential hook, and that's why it's spreading. Now, there is one other element to uh Magical Athlete, of course, which is not um which is not incorporated into the Meta Hooks model because you don't have much control over it. And that's the contextual hook, which here is about Richard Garfield, the designer, being the same designer who made Magic the Gathering and King of Tokyo and Bunny Kingdom and numerous other games. So, that in itself gives the game a little bit of a a head start, a leg up, right?
It gets it up and running and then word of mouth spreads and people find that they love the experiment. So, I think there is a key distinction between each of them, but the job for you is to really try and and separate those things. So, your experiential hook should try as much as possible not to talk about mechanisms. Your presentation hook should talk as much as possible not about the theme or the narrative of your game. It should only be about the way it appears, the way it's presented and so on. And then you can rank those hooks and combine them together to create one thing. Anyway, I've pretty much gone over the whole content of that video. So, I'll I'll cut it short here and move on to the next comment from a different video. So, this one was expert tips for pitching board games to publishers. Immediately before the pitch, you might be feeling really nervous.
Whether it's a face-to-face meeting, which often happens at a convention or at a trade fair, maybe you've traveled across the world, right? I traveled to Germany. It's not really across the world, is it, coming from the UK to Germany, but maybe you have. Maybe you traveled from UK to America or vice versa. You could have gone to Asia. Go to Tokyo Game Market. I don't know, right? You've gone a long way for this pitch. You might be feeling really nervous. You might be feeling really nervous before a virtual online pitch. But I want you to zoom out a little bit. Think about the broader picture. Okay, how important is this really? This one meeting. In the grand scheme of things. Look way ahead, years ahead. Are you going to remember this meeting? Probably not, okay? It's not that big a deal. And I really want you to try and get yourself into that mindset because I need you to relax. I need you to be calm going into that pitch. Nice and relaxed so that you can think about your breathing, think about your body language, and think about your message that you're putting across. So, the comment is, "I submitted to several publishers online and surprisingly I have two that requested prototypes. I don't know how common this is. At what point do I tell them to that I have another company looking at the prototype?
Okay, so let's answer the first question. How common is it that you'll have two companies that will ask you for a prototype? Um It depends really. It depends on how strong your hook is, how good your pitch is, how good your presentation is. I can talk from my own experience. I tend to find that I can usually, if I take If I think a game is good enough that I'm going to be pitching it to publishers and I take it off to a convention, maybe I arrange I don't know, 10 meetings for for that game, okay? And I've got 10 publishers who say yes, they're happy to have a look at it, happy to meet with me. I tend to work on the basis that 50% will take away a prototype. So, I might give away five prototypes for each game that I design and hopefully, in most cases, I might actually get a contract for one of them.
Not always. Maybe that's 50% of the time. Okay, but that's my sort of hit rate, okay? Email a ton of publishers, maybe get a response from about 50% of them. Have a meeting with those 50%, maybe 50% of those take a prototype, and then I might get one or two offers if I'm lucky on that game. Now, I do know that that is not the common experience of every designer. So, um I I guess that means I'm doing something right. Um and some of those other designers, I think maybe need to work a little more on some of the development of their games or on their pitching technique or on their approach to publishers or or something like that. There's something that's not quite yelling in the process. And that's a learning experience, isn't it? That's what it was like for me right back at the start, absolutely. You know, you learn with every single step along the way and that's what I'm trying to show with these videos really is that entire journey. I've been making these videos for 10 years showing you my entire journey through the process. So, what's the second question? At what point do you tell them that you've got another company looking at the prototype?
I will tend to tell them pretty soon. I mean, I see no reason to hold that information back. It's honest, it's open, it's transparent. Most publishers expect that. Um I do occasionally come across publishers who want exclusivity. You know, they want to look at it without another publisher looking at it, but frankly, I will tell them, "I'm sorry, I can't offer that." And if that means they don't want to look at my prototype, that's fine. But I I don't have the time to wait for one person to or one publisher to look at my prototype for 6 months or however long it takes before they say no, and then I've lost that 6 months when I could have five publishers potentially looking at that game at the same time. Um it's not a lucrative thing making games. It's not a quick process, and so you don't want to add anything in there which is going to slow you down. So, be as open and honest as possible, and you may even find that letting them know there are other publishers that are also looking at it might speed them up a little bit if they're really keen at looking at your game. Certainly, if you're getting to the point where you feel like one of these publishers is about to make an offer, it would be worth reaching out to the other publishers and letting them know that you are going to be making a decision pretty soon, and um you know, if they could let you know as soon as possible, that would be great.
Lots of different considerations there, but the foremost thing is open communication, respect, respect the publishers' time, transparency, and honesty about what you're doing and how you're approaching it. But remembering also that, you know, you're running a business, you're a professional person, and you know, you can set your own expectations of of how you want this process to work, and they can either work with you on that or they can decide to go another way, you know, respectfully and amicably. Okay, next question then. This one came from uh a video full play-through of Flip Pick Towers, and you can play, too. So, I'll show you a quick clip. Hello, I'm Adam Porter. I'm one of the designers of Flip Pick Towers along with my co-designer Rob Fisher and this is by Osprey Games. I've recently made a number of videos about Flip Pick Towers, so I'm not going to talk at great length about the game itself. In fact, we're going to just play and you can play along with me. And the question was, "Adam, can we please see your beautiful doggo more often?"
And so, um, well, I'm not going to show the dogs in every video. They're a pain, they bark, they they whine, they scratch at the door, it disturbs what I'm doing, they'll knock the camera over. So, the answer's probably no, you won't be seeing my dogs very much. Um, but uh, it's very nice of you to ask and they are beautiful. Um, I am uh, very very fond of my dogs. Uh, Bella, a spaniel, Fawn, a whippet. I used to have another dog. I made a video about them. Let me show you a clip from my video about dogs. So, hopefully this will um, please this individual. It was a very This was one of my favorite videos on the channel. Essentially, it was a a humorous video where I was talking about dog puzzles as if they were board games, reviewing them as if they were board games and using my dogs as example [snorts] players. I'll show you a quick clip. Now, alas, unlike the average 5-year-old human child, our dogs struggled with the complexities of Scythe and even My Little Scythe was a stretch. So, I've had to venture out into the unfamiliar world of board games designed for dogs. Now, trigger warning here. I'm going to be showing you something that might be quite unsettling for you if you like to keep your cardboard components, your snacks, and saliva very much apart. If there was any justice in the world and if it existed, then Trixie's Flip Board would win the Hund Spiel des Jahres, which would be awarded seven times in every human year.
A classic Euro, as you can tell by the German writing on the box. This one's a point salad game. In Flip Board, you get to explore a myriad of different strategies, pulling different levers, and pushing cubes or treats around the board. Of course, it doesn't really matter which strategy your dog chooses because they all dish out copious victory points or treats. The aspect of lifting components to reveal what's underneath is borrowed directly from the blue orange classic Goblet, but Trixie's general approach is much more along Alea lines. Affordable, less than a tenner, with fantastic mechanisms, but it ain't pretty. This game from Chinese company Adogo is essentially a streamlined version of the same game with an updated aesthetic. If Flip Board is Azul, then this one is Azul Summer Pavilion. This iteration features a central rondel mechanism, clearly inspired by Matt Leacock's Navegador or Imperial. It's a slightly less challenging game than Flip Board, ideal for a slightly more intellectually challenged canine like our Whippet fawn. It's my hope that the European release of this game will have a slightly less minimalistic box and a slightly less literal name. Alas, for now, the publisher Adogo has taken their lead, no pun intended, from NSV, the creative team behind the factually accurate moniker of 2015's The Game.
Sadly, until Adogo come to their senses, we'll have to live with the less than exciting title of Dog Puzzle Feeder Toy. So, I hope if you do go back and watch that video in full, you'll enjoy it. I think it's one of my most underrated videos. It's one of my favorite on the channel. Moving on, I'm sure you're not here to talk about dogs. Moving on to the next uh topic, how not to design a modern board game. You'll have seen this come up in every one of these videos cuz I get comments about this video over and over again. This video went viral. It was seen by 100,000, I can't even remember how many people watched this video. A lot of them didn't seem to like it. Totally understand why. Maybe I said some things in there which I didn't think they were controversial, but I was a bit critical of older games. I didn't mean to be. I love older games, right? But I was trying to show the sort of things that you might not want to do if you're designing a modern game. Let me show you an example. Snakes and Ladders is a game entirely without decisions. It plays itself. On your turn, [snorts] you roll a die, and you move where it says.
You might land on a ladder and leap far ahead on the grid, or you might land on a snake and move back. But, whatever happens, you had no choice in the matter, no agency. Designers of the past seem to struggle striking a balance between luck and strategy. Many older games feature a high degree of chance. So, in Game of Life, you spin the spinner, and you move forward, just as in Snakes and Ladders. Now, you might occasionally make a choice to go down one path or another, but the game is dominated by randomness, and generally the winner will not be the most strategic player, but the luckiest. And the comment says, "Half of your video is about making sure that nobody is royally screwed over. I really disagree with this premise, because totally crushing your opponent is fun. Seeing your opponent move from winning position to losing position is fun. Actually, I'd argue that games should be fun also for losing players is bad design, because this means there's no real punishment for losing, which means there's no incentive to win."
So, this harks back to the original comment that I showed you right at the start of the video. There seems to be a group of players who genuinely enter into playing a game with somebody else with the intention of making that experience as miserable as possible for the other players, because that's what gives them their enjoyment. Now, I tend to try I I'd like to try and be an empathetic person. I like to try and put myself into the shoes of other people and think about their mindset, but I do struggle with this one. I can't really imagine sitting down to play a game with somebody and hoping that they have a bad time. I certainly want to win. I want them to lose, but I don't want them to hate the experience, because I'm hoping they might play games with me again. I'm hoping that we might be friends, that we you you know, um our relationship might develop, grow as a result of playing this game. You know, I'm looking for a positive social experience, and that usually means I don't want the other player to have a miserable time.
Even if I didn't like that person, if I didn't like that person, if I thought they were a bit smug, if I thought they were a bit arrogant, I might want to bring them down a peg or two, maybe. That's not a particularly positive way to approach your life, is it? I'd probably rather just not play with them than try and destroy them in a game. That said, I don't think it's completely unreasonable what this person is saying. If you enter into a competitive process, let's say you're playing for money, you're playing professionally, you're going into a a tournament, yeah, absolutely, you want to destroy that other person. I can't imagine a boxer getting into the ring and thinking, I really hope that the other boxer has a lovely time. You know, they're looking to destroy them, aren't they? What about if you're playing a a game of football against another team? You know, you're you're not hoping that they all have a great time. You're hoping they have a frustrating, difficult time, and that you get the ball into as often as possible, and thwart every different approach that they take, every different shot on goal.
You're hoping they miss, right? So, I get it. But, it's not really what I want from a board game. It's not really what I want to design, and I suspect it's not what the majority of the market wants. Frankly, it's not a great prospect as a designer to make a game that three-quarters of your players are going to hate. Three out of four people playing that game are going to have a miserable time, and one is going to love it. That's not great. 75% of the people who play my game hate it. It's not a good outcome, is it? It's not going to generate sales. So, yeah, I'm struggling with with agreeing with this one, but, you know, everyone's entitled to their opinion. Okay, which tabletop games truly created a legacy? This is a video about one of my recent books. So, I'll just show you a quick clip from the video. 5,000 years of tabletop games, but which of those titles were truly influential? Which ones impacted on future designs? Their themes, their mechanisms, their presentation. Which ones changed the industry? And which of those games really left a legacy? This is design lessons from history's most influential tabletop games, and it's a big book. I mean, if you look at it compared to my book about playtesting, this is massive, over 500 pages. And this is available as an ebook or as a physical book from Amazon. Now, in this book, I've picked out the 100 games which I feel have been
most impactful, most influential throughout history. And the comment doesn't actually come from the video itself, it comes from an Amazon review of the book. And I thought this Amazon review was interesting. So, it says, "This is a comprehensive resource for game lovers and designers of all levels." So, thank you for the positive feedback. "One thing I learned as I turned the pages is that the field of game design desperately needs more women. Of the dozens of games profiled, only a handful are by women, and most of these had a male co-designer. This is not the fault of the author's selections, it's just a fact of the hobby. As indicated by the success of woman-designed Wingspan, mentioned towards the end of the book, increased participation of women may be the key to not getting more games involving war, Middle Ages, Middle-earth, space, commerce, or zombies, which have dominated for a long time."
So, I had a little look back at that book. I mean, I I I know it's true. I didn't have to look back. It's It's clearly a very accurate comment. I didn't have to do much research. But looking back at this book, I talked about 100 different games that have been the in my view the most influential games throughout history. About 28 of the 100 games that I chose do not have a named designer, mostly because they're ancient games or very very old games. Um not many of modern games. I I guess about the most modern one that doesn't have a designer is probably something like Battleship, which is based on public domain, you know, pen and paper stuff. So, who knows who made that game. Okay? 28 don't have a designer. Five of the 100 were exclusively designed by a female designer.
Uh five were by a husband and wife or uh boyfriend and girlfriend team. And then another two had a female designer working alongside a wider team. So, that's 12 games out of the 72 that have a named designer that have a credited female designer. So, that's What's that? One in six. Okay, it's not a great ratio, but actually, when you look back through history, what you see is that things have got worse in this regard rather than better. It was a woman who designed Doctor Busby, which is basically Go Fish or Happy Families. Um uh This is This is a very popular game all around the world, but the game that really sparked the board game industry in America in the mid-1800s, one of the first commercially printed games, was Doctor Busby, and this was by a woman called Anne Abbott. In 1904, Elizabeth Magie created The Landlord's Game, which was later adapted into Monopoly without her input, I should say. But she created that. So, it's clearly not a case that women are not interested in board game design or not inherently, you know, they don't inherently tend towards board game design. Actually, a lot of women have been involved. Other examples from the book, Rook in 1906 is credited to George and Grace Parker of Port Parker Brothers. That's a husband and wife team. Clue or Cluedo in the UK, 1949, is credited to Anthony and Elva Pratt.
Candy Land is one of the ones that is exclusively designed by a woman in 1949. So, this is a woman called Eleanor Abbott, who was uh on a polio ward and designing a game for the children to play based around um movement and and allowing freedom of movement in a in a ward where children wouldn't be able to move. Um next then, Guess Who? in 1979 is by a husband and wife team, Theo Coster and Aura Coster. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective in 1981, Suzanne Goldberg was one of a team of three and I believe one of that team was her partner. Scotland Yard in 1983 by Dorothy Garrells alongside a team of five men. Okay, so a lot of people credited for Scotland Yard.
Jenga in 1983 by Leslie Scott, Balderdash in 1984 by Laura Robinson and Paul Toyne, which is a Canadian couple, at the time a couple. Exit the Game in 2016 by Inka and Markus Brand and of course Wingspan in 2019 by Elizabeth Hargrave. So, those are the women that I think have had the most impact, right? Made the most influential games through history. And most of them were in the mass market, but that's because the hobby didn't really exist throughout most of that period. Most of the games in this book uh relate, you know, pre-Catan. There's a substantial amount of games in the book that are post-Catan, but a lot of the history of games is is pre that period. And women were very They were you know, there were fewer games coming out and the women made up a bigger proportion of the designers.
What I would say now is that I I haven't done the research, but my perception is from working in those sort of lighter categories of games. I I do make larger strategy games like Ember Hearth, but I also make a lot of very simple games and children's games. Um I think there's a lot of women who are working in that sort of area, in those games for families and games for children. Um and perhaps that's just I mean, that's the way our society is, isn't it? Rightly or wrongly. Women uh will often be the primary carers for their children and so on and they may have a particular interest in creating games that facilitate play with those children or educational and so on. And so we don't tend to see women creating massive strategic games like Vital Vitala Serda style games or you know big economic train games or massive war games and you know that it's that side of the market where the women really aren't breaking through and and and having you know aren't prominent, okay?
But they are certainly designing. And the other thing I would say is that my experience of pitching to publishers and working with publishers is that there are a vast number of women working in the industry just not in that design role. So very frequently when I'm pitching games, I'm pitching to women working for these publishers. So women are often working in inventor relations. And very frequently I'm working with women as project managers within those publishers. So they are the primary person either developing my game or working with developers and overseeing the the entire development of the project including you know working with the artists, the illustrators and and so on overseeing the whole thing. So it's not the case that women are excluded from the industry. They're not, you know, they are involved but there does seem to be a problem a block somewhere which is preventing women from you know pushing through and and and designing games. A food for thought, I'm going to leave it with you to mull that one over and yeah I fully I fully welcome any women who watch my channel. I know from the analytics that that is a minority of my viewers but any women that watch the channel and take great inspiration and and bring it into their designs. I really hope to see more of you you know rise to the fore and uh and and and move forward with your design. So, if you enjoyed this video, please go on and watch some of my others. Maybe you want to revert back to some of the other conversational videos that I've made in
the past. And uh I'll continue to make these videos as long as you keep commenting on my videos. Until next time, all the best.