Broken Meeple Podcast - Episode 103 - Grogan & Nehemiah
Transcript
you're listening to the broken meele show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everybody hopefully the intro is done right this time hi everybody Luke Hector here for podcast 103 this is a little bit late because of well one of the main topics I'll be talking about today which is of course I've been at gridon this last weekend for Paul grogan's convention back in Taunton so was kind of a away from Friday through to Sunday Thursday night I was visiting the parents who also live next just outside of Taunton and so I couldn't exactly be around to do the podcast by the time I got back yesterday I was knackered was exhausted
and then I went to play valheim online with some mates so uh couldn't exactly find time then but uh I've taken a break for Monday evening so that I can record this and I'll give you some you know Lowdown on the games I played and any fun little uh tidbits here and there but then I've also got a review for the second part of this episode where I want to talk a little bit about a game um Garfield games Ezra and Nehemiah because it's not a game that I've got time before um Christmas to do a full review for so I figured used the podcast as an excuse to do it because this isn't a review copy it's just a literally something I bought with some Kender credit that I thought you know what I want to try this game out let's just see what it's like but generally health-wise not too bad I mean my voice will hopefully carry for this particular episode but I have noticed that in the past it has had a little bit of a laryngitis feel ever since I came back from Essen and had that spell of covid it feels like I'm getting over it but then my voice was quite raw over the weekend because I made the mistake of forgetting to take my amprol tablets with me so for the period of a good 2 or 3 days I did not have aaol in my system which is the primary drug I use in order to stop myself getting volcanic levels of acid reflux and certainly Yeah by Saturday evening and Sunday oh boy the throat was literally bubbling like a volcano it was erupting like crazy so was in a bit of pain at that point thankfully I got back home on Sunday evening take one Monday morning take another one so hopefully that should now
subside but uh yeah it was a little bit on the uh weird side there but otherwise generally fine you know the voice should hopefully last work is you know I got three weeks before my cruise looking forward to that you know I think that's going to be a good break I'm going to try and get as many videos done before then as I can not just to air before I go away hopefully to air some while I'm away like maybe there'll be a few videos that I'll delay until the second and third week of December and then just air them during that period you know I maybe not going to be able to share them on social media I'll need to ask for your guys help on that one but at least I'll be able to time them so that you get a little bit every week so that you're not just flooded with them all in the same in the week before I go away because that would just be a bit too much to digest um PL Channel plans I'm not doing a top 10 of the year in December there's just not a tough time and I'm leaving before the end of December you know so it kind of uh defeats the point in trying to do a top 10 of the year when I haven't really had the whole year so will do that in January before I even think about doing a top 100 update so you know you can look forward to that list over there uh but in terms of the games that I've still got left to do there is plenty I mean inventors of the South Tigress is sitting right over there for me to plow through the solo mode this week because I want to do a full review on that one and I've played it multiplayer enough times I now need to test the solo mode before I review it uh not going to give away too much from uh talking about what I played at gridcom but but uh yeah you'll get some Impressions I'm sure but then I've got
other things like um Asian tigers is on the table layout below this so that I can learn how to play that one I can do a speed reviews um anytime now for King of Tokyo Jewel uh some of the emperor S4 stuff uh like um Tori I think it's called t r i it's a little abstract game um I've also got uh what else have I got oh yeah Galileo Galilee people have asked me to do that one there will be a speed review for that don't worry that one I can do any day now that should be coming out pretty soon hopefully this week uh what else there's got to be some of those um I have to think about that but uh yeah there's still some more content to come and I've even got games there that haven't even been you know looked at yet like Station to Station from alicat games uh Reef project I bought on a whim I probably won't review that until January um ancient knowledge Heritage expansion um which is a problem because I seem to have mislaid my original base game copy that's going to be a little tricky and even the name of tarot you know from yellow games you know that is uh on the cards as well and there's other ones dotted around besides you know even like more stuff from emess 4 certainly I'm going to be still busy on top of work but uh in terms of the channel itself yeah not bad you know we're up to where are we up to now that would help if I was on the dashboard 24662 can we make it a Christmas present for me to get that to 25,000 before Christmas that would be nice I mean you've got just over a month to to find me another 338 people to bump that to 25,000 that would be a nice Christmas
present to end what is mostly being a pretty of a crummy year really I mean there have been highlights for sure gridcom being one of them and Essen being one of them and my 40th birthday being another one but uh certainly the second half of the Year could have been better certainly from a health and stress and work perspective but light at the end of the tunnel good cruise family with Christmas and you know just 2025 January I think is going to start off on a really good note you know I think you know things are on the up and up but you know in terms of the content not a ton um I mean I got the unconscious mind review out finally so that's been doing quite well thanks for everybody who's uh watched that one cuz that was a belter of a 35 minute review to have to do an edit uh as well as the expansions nightmares and the modules you know glad to see that people are liking that one uh let's go to Japan I'm not one of the people who was jumping on the bandwagon for that one quite as uh highly as some other people so check out my theories as to why I mean that's done pretty well for a speed review uh lands of ever shade currently on game found I believe from awaken Realms their new RPG story based hybrid game uh I've done my preview thoughts on this and as you know me you know there's a lot of reviewers or a lot of people who basically preview like they preview and like well I don't like previews in general because they just feel like adverse but what they tend to do is only review games that they like and they'll preview everything you know regardless of what the game is I'm the opposite of that I only preview games that I like and I only review and
I review everything so it's the opposite way around so if I'm doing a preview for a game yes I like it but that's when I'm feeling more comfortable telling you the like what the game's about how it works pros and cons from First Impressions and suggesting okay give it a look and make your own mind up about whether you want to purchase it I'm not telling you to like here's a game go go by bye bye now byebye now you know nothing like crazy like that so b means to check that one out and lastly even for the crystal path I suspect a lot of you don't even have even full the game uh the view certainly may be suggest it but um by all means if you have even full and great you've got an expansion review there the crystal path and if you've never played it then by all means try and find a chance to play even for cuz it is a really solid game and you will enjoy it if you are into kind of a more meaty card engine builder it really is a solid piece of work but yeah all well and good so moving on quickly to what the the hell was I doing over the weekend well gridcom was what I was doing gridon 5 and uh you know yeah a little bit of plugging but you know credit words doe Paul Grogen runs a pretty sweet convention this is done in the Holiday Inn in Taunton so literally the one that's just off the M5 Junction and it's your typical convention here's a bunch of tables here's a bunch of people that you like go and play games except a lot of the people who come to of this convention kind of semi know each other because we're patreons of you know we're on Paul grogan's patreon and as much as I you know s say to people
this channel would not run without the patreons who support me well played and thanks to you um same goes for Paul and I'm a patreon of his channel as well as a lot of other people so we tend to meet up with a lot of familiar friendly faces while we're there and you know there's a good decent you know heavy games selection for the library people tend to bring their own heavy games certainly a lot of heavier titles get played at this convention I mean if you go here and only play light stuff you'll be able to there'll be some people who will but uh you're kind of mainly here to play those long games those heavier games the big table Hogs you know not you know and that that's more the general gist of what there is there's also his giant raffle this giant sort of Charity raffle which has the amount of games that Publishers give this guy for the charity raffle is beyond ridiculous it is insane but you know that's a good thing because at the end of the day it's for charity and a lot of people walk away with a lot of games and it's um all good fun so can't exactly knock it although I have yet to win anything off that raffle in the last seven years because I I basically buy a you know I I don't even care if I win games on the raffle because most of the games I've already played or don't need anyway but I always at least give some money to the raffle because it goes to charity so I'm at least doing that you know but it's nice to win every now and again why can't I seem to win Raffles I suck at Raffles when it comes to my luck but it's just pretty solid I I had a good time minus the acid reflux everything else about
the convention was great you know had a good time played with some really quality games with a lot of quality people and it just it was like exhausting on the mind because I had to basically come from that and then go straight to work on Monday morning so yeah uh it's a bit of a long few days but that's why I decided to take this evening off just to record this podcast and I'll probably go to the gym after this you know do a bit of cross trainer exercise just to completely myself out and then for the rest of the evening I guess I'll break out inventors of the South Tigress play a bit of solo and if I've got time before I need to go to bed I certainly would like to watch the second act of Arcane yes Arcane is back on Netflix and I've been singing the Praises of that series like crazy saying it is amazing it still is the First Act of the second season was great as well I'm hearing great things about the second act I cannot wait to watch it but I'm going to need a good 2 hours in order to do that so maybe I'll have to do it in bits but trying to avoid spoilers is an absolute nightmare so yeah hopefully I'll get onto that soon but what did I end up playing at uh gridcom well first of all I did do an well let's me take a drink first oh yeah I love these contego mugs these contego travel mugs you can just get them in ader like a tener or something or get them on Amazon for a bit more but I love these things drink just stays hot in this for ages and I've got honey mixed green tea oh it is very nice good for my throat good antioxidants and um
you know one of my patreons uh actually you actually gives me you know one of the viewers of my channel actually gives me honey he brings over uh honey from Greece you know on every grid con and occasional other conventions you know depending on if I've run out and you know I was just about running out from the last Dash all I've got is the like quite thick honey and he's brought like three more giant jars of like you know we're talking half a kilo each of honey and it's you know like honey with thyme Rosemary all sorts of different flavors and it's like ah man I mean just taking a spoonful of that to help my throat is gorgeous enough but I just love to mix it in some ginger tea some chamomile tea some green tea even mint tea now and again it's it's honey it goes in pretty much anything that honey can go in I love it so much m delicious but anyway windmill Valley so this was an official demo I did for Paul Grogan basically he does a few demos which uh he will teach but then he asked some of us to teach now and again I've never done it before at gridon I must admit so I thought this time you know I'll do one and maybe next year I actually might do a few you know because as much as I do go there and enjoy playing games you know what I do like teaching people games that I like and in this occasion I couldn't get my first and second choice unfortunately so I got my third choice which was wiill Valley not to say that I don't like wible Valley is still on my shelf and I still gave it a good review check it out but this was the official demo I did so talk four players how to play it and yep went down pretty well it's an easy teach it's an easy learn and they all tried
different things you know focusing on windmills or focusing on action Wheels focusing on particular tulips that sort of thing and uh everybody got a kick out of it um can't remember where the score was I mean this was quite early on so they'd only recently started the game I think to get to these points but I think one person got to about 110 odd and then previous ones were just below the 100 Mark and one guy was a bit further back so you know there was certainly a bit of a spread but you know windmill Valley is still a solid uh game from Bard and dice one of their easiest games to Gro and sort of get into which is kind of half the reason it does well for me I mean it's very pretty and it's very smooth it's a smooth thinky Euro which we don't get a lot of those yes it's relatively light but there's still enough depth there still enough customization to kind of do your own thing here and it looks very colorful on the table it doesn't take up a lot of space and it allows for different path to Victory so yeah I I still like this one and teaching it is kind of a breeze really but you know compared to a lot of other potential ones there so yeah by all means give this one a check and look at my review for more details but this demo went pretty well next year I'll get in a bit earlier and see what else I could demo you know cuz I do enjoy it you know just seeing people enjoy a game I enjoy is always rewarding all right what else we got uh next up uh yes was it inventors actually wait a minute no this is a solo no this was my learning game of inventors I'm going the wrong way in my things here we go black forest uh Black
Forest I played this twice over the convention one was planned one wasn't well I was meant to play Galactic cruise with some people as um yeah because some people had like the Prototype of it and unfortunately we couldn't find somebody to teach us the game and we weren't prepared to try and learn that monster osity you know from scratch so I had to pass it up so don't worry you know I'll get to play a full game of Galactic Cru I'm sure at some point in my life you know before it's released but for now I'll wait till it's released and give you my full loow down there but black forest yep played twice and why because a people wanted to play it and B because I love it this was a game I gave out 10 out of 10 and I said it's potential game of the year it could well be I mean it is just such a cool game I love this resource D mechanic that glass Road froze in I like the choice of buildings there's such a good amount of variety with the buildings like flipping them over trying different strategies the way that uh trades people are positioned and it's just such a smooth game as well and it's not a lot of rules overhead there's not a lot of rules to teach most of it is looking at all the options you have and trying to decide what to do so it is a bit of an AP nightmare at times you got to be a bit wary with a four player game but turns don't take that long so really it's more the downtime if people can't you know think before their turn as to what they're going to do but when people are taking their turns it goes at a reasonable pace and you shouldn't spend more than 2 hours with this in a four player game but you can get this down to like 90 minutes with like three players and that it is a solid smooth game it looks very colorful I love
trying different things out I mean what was I doing here um I built up an entire board uh full of like you know pwns and the corn fields and was trying to sort of do stuff with them I badly needed to level up my workshop at this point but I was doing well despite I think I won it but it wasn't by much it was quite an e um oh did I can't remember I don't know I don't really care it was good fun and the three people I was with enjoyed it so I don't think anybody I played this game with gridon actually had played glass road before which is something different cuz usually people are like oh I remember glass Road this looks cool now it's just people have heard the buzz about this game and just want to try it so they have no idea what glass road is so you're walking into these two dials straight off the bat but yeah I love it whether I try animals whether I try cornfields or ponds or different buildings or special buildings or ignore them or make glass make loads of you know you know tons of glass you know do animal slaughtering whatever level up my workshop 100 times I just I like this one it's good smooth fun good clean fun so yeah both games were good and solid for that one H what else we got we got to go left through here aren't we ah yes unconscious mind this was a big in one it and I got kind of fortunate with this because it was meant to be a four-player game but it turned out to be a three player game which for my head was probably a good thing because I was getting tired by this point on the same day after playing those other games and so an unconscious mind of four players where I was teaching it would have been quite the SLO but thankfully I got to at
least enjoy unconscious mind with somebody who had watched the video and one person who had played it solo but not multiplayer and yeah a good fun time as well it was a quiet room no background noise didn't throw in any extra or modules in because as I said in my other review I don't think most of them are necessary and I certainly won't throw them in that much with a new player so we just played base game and it was still really enjoyable you know this game is great it's great it's a great game in its base form base game retail components is all you need granted I have the deluxe version but that wasn't necessarily my choice and to be fair I do like those ink poxs but you know anything else could have been just the retail version I would have been fine I thinking this one our was strategy was just to cure as much as possible so I focused heavily on treating clients as quickly as possible so you know being hyper efficient with those and not doing quite so much on the map or with the notebook I mean everybody else was going notebook crazy you can see this guy in the opposite corner he's only got two spaces to fill out on his notebook I've still got five it's you know they were definitely going mad with that and I was just trying to munch in the bottom row actions as much as possible while getting stuff used the action spaces and some of the client routine client ones cuz I was focusing mostly on routine clients and their abilities were letting me get lots of cool stuff so yeah there was a little bit of cool fun with that but yeah just good ban turb good laugh you know you know having fun each other's you know dream cards and like clients that they've got how how the
opponent there was notebook mad and it's like are you actually going to treat any client soon or are you just scribbling notes and me just like basically in out in out you know I'm not sure the quality of my treatments are good but certainly I get results very fast is kind of the way it was working but yeah it's definitely a table hog it's definitely a slog in rules but if you can get PE you get fre players Max and you get you know just base game components it can still be really solid I mean I think this was the end game points uh I don't maybe it wasn't the end end game points I get a feeling that the other two were a little bit higher than this but yeah I did get to in fact yeah this is actually um yeah this can't be right oh no it is right yes it is right um I don't know if these two markers moved afterwards but I definitely got to this one there's a bright idea token underneath which means I lap the board twice that is 226 points I've got there I did pretty well um yes I got a lot of points from you know case study clients some stuff during the game published treaties and high reputation I was raking in quite a fair few points that's probably my top score I've had in this game so far so yeah did rather well but good fun nonetheless uh oh yeah this is the honey I mentioned the honey that got brought so what have I got there uh Mel migous um migous m e l i g y r r i s cre
migous crit I have no idea what this brand is I have no idea how to pronounce it properly but look at these Honeys I've got here I mean these are big jars of Honeys they look cool they're runny honey and what have we got there Forest honey Wild Wild Cherries and wild thy now I'm a little bit worried about that one because I'm not a cherry fan so I'm hoping the Cherry is like I'm hoping the fact that it's a wild cherry means it's not like normal cherries and maybe it'll just taste too much of honey that I won't really care the one on the right though definitely looking forward to that one organic Mountain Honey wild thyme flavor oh that does sound pretty good the one in the middle remember what that flavor was the labels on it but yeah more honey always nice right now this one I didn't plan for I didn't plan to play Ark over uh but I did uh I literally finished the unconscious mind game my head was slightly you know trying to stay focused and then I came across U you know mate of M Dylan you know from the convention and Lee as well and we just basic I saw them sort of getting out Arc NOA cuz I think they were planning to play a two-player of it with Marine worlds because the two of them know how to play AR over and they like to play a game quick so they kindly let me in for a third player and yeah we I mean could blind me I mean I watched a game of civui being played I can't remember if they were in the teaching phase or they'd already started playing we unpacked and played and packed away an entire free player game of AR NOA and when we walked away they were still nowhere near finishing their celution game yeah that game is long we got
through this one pretty quick like a 90-minute game or something you know I mean it is possible to play this game fast if you just get players who know what they're doing and take their turns it's you know easy enough to do now did I take a better photo of this H yes I did take some better photos here we go yeah so I went to Hollywood Hills and I didn't even get the Hollywood Hills um sponsor objective unfortunately my objective was to get a lot of reputation and boy did I get a lot of reputation um my marker maxed out on the reputation marker about halfway through the game if that it just went sick and a lot of that was because I kind of snowball um from all the sponsors I was doing I mean these animals I've got here most of these animals got played in the second no in the last third of the game for most of the game all I had was that first animal there at the top a single Cowfish that was it my Zoo just had a Cowfish and that was about it and then I just played maybe a couple of predators and eventually I got a BAL eagle and yeah not a lot of animals were really being played I was passing them off to do other things which was to play a lot of these sponsors I mean we had a bird focus in this game so got the orthologist got the bird sponsorship vultures but what I ended up doing was getting a lot of science symbols and stuff like the science lab the science museum medical breakthrough those were turning up uh I had the spokesperson as well so I was getting a green point and a rep point every time I played a
science symbol and even though a mate of mine was even though the other player was getting money because I was playing science symbols who cares I was just raking it in so God knows how many science symbols I got there was it 3 four five 6 7 8 9 10 so something mean like 10 science symbols roughly there yeah I'm went a little bit mad and as you can see we were using the asymmetric cards as well so I've got the association one that lets you do another action instead of the level five of associations that's brilliant because I wasn't really focused on Association I mean look I got one worker out and three um science and universities and that's it that's all I did for Association I got no partner zoos no donations no nothing this is the final score you know there's my marker over there the appeal marker on about 60 odd there's my green marker that's now reset to 37 so I think I was plus 30 odd plus 25 odd somewhere around that Mark um which is not necessarily the highest score I've ever had but in the time that we speedrun the game I certainly ended it at damn like quicker than red and blue as you can see from this slot but cool blim me yeah that Association card is nice when you don't want to focus on Association and for those people who say that you can't win the game without focusing hard on Association well I just proved you wrong um and on top of that the sponsor's card over here here we go Additionally you may discard a card gain four money or reduce the level of one played card by two now on the other side it's just gain for money so I did it occasionally on the other side but on when I flipped it it was my first card to flip holy smokes
is that reduced the level of played card by two strength really useful especially on Hollywood Hills I mean when you're on Hollywood Hills you cover those three hes all your sponsor cards are minus one strength if you can then also discard another card in this case animals to play to reduce the strength by two more you are just spamming sponsors out mean look at these sponsors level 5 4 4 five 6 six I mean there are some solid sponsors here what as our special assignment uh bird um Bard UT or whatever it is medical breakthrough spokesperson Science Museum there's just so much there and I never got strapped for money cuz I wasn't playing that many animals and I had a decent income anyway but man I was just getting a cards Galore I had all the bonuses at the top of my board unlocked so I was getting a lot of stuff in coffee breaks it was a pretty good fun game all around and even playing stuff like native seabirds and things like that which you wouldn't normally expect but yeah this was my Zoo for a while for most of the game for a decent chunk of the game I was saying I think all I had was this South American cot which I was reluctant to even play an animal I think it was only because we had Predators as the other thing but yeah Longhorn Cowfish that was the first animal I played and I had it just that for ages the only reason I played that was because it had the boost ability of putting my sponsors card on level five that was it I couldn't even find another sea creature to play to use that boost again otherwise I would have done it more but yeah it was a a weird weird setup I mean I managed to do the level five Birds objective
by having only one bird the rest of it was just sponsors so God knows what I was doing with scientific experimentations on these animals but it certainly wasn't running a zoo maybe I was trying to perfect the world's best L horn Cowfish by experimenting on all the other animals right moving on to inventors of the South Tigress I'm not going to say too much here cuz I want to do a full review and I played two games of this at gridcom because obviously I needed to you know give it the beans on top of other multiplayer games I'd already done but at least now I can teach this pretty well but yeah it's a very complex game for Garfield games it's definitely one of their most complex that they've done uh it's got a lot of moving Parts there's a decent amount of interaction because you are all manipulating these boards here in terms of inventing building and Publishing so they're definitely is a bit more interaction in this game than otherwise would be in A Garfield game normally but cool yeah there's a lot going on a lot you got to deal with and this is just like the stuff on the main board then you got your player board here with all the dice that level up into multiple areas and you're studying and you got these six craft people um why have I only got five where's my other one gone oh there he is up there so yeah six craft people you got a level up and then you got these workshops that you can customize holy smokes I mean one thing I will say about this game is that Garfield games really do need to maybe consider dialing it back a bit in complexity because I think they might be overstepping the mark now but suffice to say I still had a good
time with it I mean uh what was it in that game um uh here we oh no I had a score sheet a second ago where was it there we go yeah so that was a four player game 73 65 43 and 40 of which I was 73 granted um well this wasn't a teaching game actually technically two people the two losers there had played it two player enough times and the Rogue had played it solo enough times so granted it was their first big four player game but they had experience and certainly I only beat the second player by eight points but you know did all right there although not as well as the other time I was playing because uh you know on this particular game as you can see my workshop got rather large I focused heavily on boat movement H got to the very end and just kept creating Workshop tiles so I had quite a lot of shenanigans from there not to mention bonuses for completing columns but the other one I played don't worry you spoiler alert for all these other games look at this this was a free player game and it's full up all these published ideas all these built ones all these inventions it just got ridiculous with only three of us and both of these were four round games these weren't the short games but then here we go 84 6668 84 I don't think I'm going to be beating that score for a while yeah that was a pretty good session but you know I do like a lot of stuff in this game I mean the interaction is good it looks good on the table when you get used to the rules they are they do flow nicely
but it is a bit of a slug to learn them all the rule book is fine but they do this thing of explaining the Core Concepts of a few things before they get into the main rules although in this particular game's case I think you kind of do have to teach it that way because if you just jump straight into the main actions a lot of stuff won't make sense I feel like you have to deal with the Core Concepts first then get into the actions which is not normally how I like to teach a game but here I think it's the only way you can teach this game you know it is very sort of rules intensive but that being said there's a lot of clever stuff you can do with these di there's a lot of clever combos you can pull off a lot of combinations of uh styles of play with these Workshop tiles and just I love the main thing I kind of love is that these endgame objectives here all these inventions have got an endgame objective at the bottom if you have built or publish the item you qualify to try for that objective and then it's a case of if you meet one criteria you get two points and if you meet the other criteria you get four I like the fact that it's just a flat number of points two four no scaling number of points or anything like that it's just look do you meet it yes two right did you meet the better one yes then four you know that sort of thing nice and simple but it's cool that you can sort of jump on other people's stuff just because you invented it doesn't mean that you build it or even publish it you know somebody else might invent a card and it's like oh I could actually do pretty well on that objective I mean I invented this one here that lets me get points for Workshop tiles that are triggered by black Dy okay fair enough
not bad um I didn't even build or publish it um I think um I I got like pipped to the Post in it so I just invented it and never actually scored off it but I was I think I was playing yellow but then I jumped on actually was I playing yellow yeah I think I was playing yellow yeah I must have been playing yellow so I jumped in on boat Mo oh wait yes because this was um the other game this was the this wasn't the three player this was the four player this this when I was focused heavily on boat movement but where's the inventors I had later on um here we goop yeah the one where I got 84 so yeah I created this one here to level up my craft person uh uh mechanic dude to you know high level I got another one here for a different craft person I got the same one for Workshop tiles I published somebody I invented and published an item that scored me points for blue and back dice you know I'm getting at here is that all these objectives are there's an interaction with players because somebody might put out a card that works for you from an objective per perspective so you try to build or publish or even both for the particular T although honestly the only main reason I feel like you would ever build and publish your own thing or like the same thing is if you wanted to deny other people the chance to actually get points from it but personally I would usually build or publish the same item not both but I don't know maybe people can tell me otherwise from a strategy perspective but yeah there's a lot of moving Parts it's a fun game but it is long particularly with four I mean there is a
free round game variant to play if you want with new players and I do recommend you do that for your first game because it is certainly less of a slug than trying to go through the full four rounds but you know I feel like the game maybe could be shortened a little bit particularly with four but yeah the the stuff you do the main mechanics are very satisfying even though the theme is completely non-existent right what else we got then so this was inventors and as I take a swig that was the second game of black forest so what was I doing here then oh yes I bought a well which was mostly useless and an inn and an ale house that was about it and nothing uh veil of Eternity yeah played this game did a really cool combo with some green cards that basically let me uh gain points with a bunch of end round abilities and a few tick overs and focusing on green cards took a while I mean there was four of us but you know I didn't play artifacts the expansion because the artifacts expansion oh God yeah I've got to review that haven't I yeah I need to do a beyond the base game video for that well slight spoiler alert it's a good expansion but be very very warned if you're going to play this with slow people or four players because the artifacts might be worth leaving out of the box at that State but here just the base game good fun love this game such a cool unexpected Gem of an engine builder and then hemony oh yes aony hemony who doesn't like a game of a gy probably plenty of people but this one another one I got to play the state yet again
everybody else always wants to play a different class than the state and I know what they mean the state doesn't have a lot of action choice and yeah it can be a little bit annoying in that respect but oh sorry um a little yawn there you can tell I'm knackered but this one I got I still enjoy playing the state because I get to manipulate the other three players I get to see how the game's going and try and think right well how can I Scupper this player and you know Blue's not doing too well how can I get blue give blue a bit of a leg up while you know benefiting me as well and hampering others and here I've given some health benefits to Red mainly because red wasn't pulling their weight in terms of my legitimacy marker so I thought I'll give you a little bit but not enough you know and you we ended up with a situation where yeah you can see the two black markers oh I didn't flip that didn't flip that actually I don't remember us getting to a on there oh it must have switched back very quickly but um yeah I didn't flip that tile but I have a feeling that when it got to free healthcare it went back very quickly but the thing with this was that we ended up with like free education but I sold my education place to uh the capitalist who then sold it on after that so I was never producing any education after the working class had already made it free so it's like yeah education's free I'm not making any of it but it's free all the while the tax rate's high now it's not high here because annoyingly the capitalist brought it down to B how dare they but we did get it to nine at one point we almost had it on 11 so I was enjoying some pretty sweet taxes but oh
man do I just love this game I mean you know this game is just so much fun each time I love seeing how different players play I mean the middle class went for a pretty high Prosperity strategy and did pretty well I mean they stoed a bit in the very last round but they were doing well they were contenders to win and I had to fight them in conjunction with the working class the capitalist was a bit further behind but uh fair enough you know the capitalist is a harder one I think to win with in my opinion but yeah there was some good crazy stuff but what happened was that the working class on the first turn turned immigration off so they were enjoying Prosperity with very few people you know very little population and then at one point I basically used um one of my cards to propose all the way to top immigration here because I had all the influence cubes I made it pass and just before the last last round or was it the fourth round fourth for last round I managed to just suddenly kick their immigration into high gear and then they had all these unemployed they tried to demonstrate I opened my public companies set a few of them in only to then reverse the bill in the very next turn and Clos them all again just before the round ended so it's like in bird culture I believe we call that a dick move but yeah it's just good solid fun I really enjoy this it's another hit and yes I think I did win in the end yep quite quite a margin I mean there's blue there Red's only just ahead of them yellow breaches 100 there and I'm on 130 I mean I do find it easier to win as the
state some people I have seen tank the state but when I play the state I just seem to do very well with them now granted they should have tried to tank me at some stages they should have got the IMF on me um I did get away with murder on a few things but yeah I was just rolling in purple cubes and had a lot of money didn't have to worry about that kind of thing and just uh yeah probably got away with too much in this game but yeah I I say still really really enjoyable how are we doing for time uh 38 38 all right so briefly setti another fun game uh we opened up the you know aliens the one that look that I love the way that they described it they said it was a giant cigar spliff in space which kind of does look a bit like that and we had my favorite adens out who have the cards that you put the marker 15 points ahead and any trigger effects but this was another good fourar game although it did go quite slow um and as I say I still find seti to be a 10 out of 10 game I say a low 10 out of 10 game low 10 out of 10 high nine its main floor is its length the length of this game is problematic with four players and a lot of people agree that five rounds is too much I'm actually going to trial something um in the future I'm going to see maybe not for two or three players I think for two or three players five rounds is fine and certainly for solo five rounds is fine but I'm going to try out in four players
only doing four rounds because honestly you achieve a lot in four rounds the fifth round just feels like a winmore situation so I don't think it would unbalance the game that much if I did a five you know a four round game instead for four players so I'm actually going to try that next time and see what difference it makes because if it doesn't make any tangible difference other than simply making the scores a little bit lower then I'm going to do that from now on and cge if you ever listen to this episode when you're doing the expansion for this game just give me more adans just give me more cards don't give me more mechanics just maybe improve the two-player experience for the uh scanning action you know that would be uh cool you know putting some neutral player that messes around with the tokens but also just consider a variant where we have one less round with maybe asymmetric powers or some boosts that you get instead of the normal route cuz honestly I think that's the missing piece to make this like a grand 10 out of 10 game for me but you know minus the length still great fun still really enjoyed it and uh I can't remember where we ended up on points I mean this is uh not this is close to the end of the game but not F the end of the game we definitely like I definitely breached 200 so I definitely got to around this area on a 200 and something Mark but these you know we were quite close together at one point it was definitely anybody's game until we did the gold scoring objectives and then I did a lot better on those but yeah still
great fun still enjoyed it and everybody else at the table enjoyed it as well so another success for setti all right okay that's enough from gridon that is enough is there any more of those uh yeah just one there so uh was that end of the game did we do an end of the game photo I'm not sure we did I mean that was just two because I thought somebody's hand had got in the way nope no other photos for setti fine so let's get rid of these and move on to a quick review and sort of speed review this isn't like full full review but it is a review of Ezra and nemiah rebuild the walls and Temple for the returning Exiles of ancient Jerusalem whatever hm yes uh look at this description here you know it goes on gone for ages about in his first year as King of Persia Cyrus the Great issued a decree blah blah blah blah blah boring I never liked Ari at school God Of Heaven given me the kingdoms and any place survivors may be living temple of God Jerusalem as falling as sleep just trying to read it it goes on forever with this massive like history lesson of it right and then it says the first word about the game is the aim of Esra and nemiah is to be the player with the most victory points at game end you cannot give me this massive blurb with trying to decree that your thing has a theme and then start your explanation off with the game that you are trying to get victory points you just instantly killed the theme of this game and then honestly
I don't really care about the theme of this game the theme in this is mostly non-existent yes it makes sense of who these two were and kind of what you're doing in the game you're rebuilding what was it yeah you're rebuilding the walls and Temple um of ancient Jerusalem or something and I think that's it and it's just like whatever but you don't really care why you're playing this I'm not going through this game thinking oh yeah I feel like I'm I feel so much like I'm in the Bible or the book of Ezra or whatever the books are I I Know Jack about Christianity or you know or uh you know Bible or religion anything I mean I hated Ari in school so I'm very ignorant on a lot of this stuff but I wasn't really interested in playing this game because of the theme it was mainly because a It's A Garfield game which means generally I'm interested to play their stuff but also because a few people were saying good things about it and it was one of their sort of sub series like you've got the tigerish you've got the West Kingdom you got the South tigis West Kingdom and North Sea but this is like kind of like their spin-off game so I thought I would give it a shot well the first thing you'll see when you look at this game is oh my sweet heral Mary how bland it looks I mean yeah it's got colored pieces from players and it's not necessarily bad artwork but man I mean desert Jerusalem does not lend itself well to a very nice looker it's very it looks very generic I mean you've got colored cubes for the resources on a little grid here for the
temple building and then you've got you know people in slots uh people being put on the various books of the was it the J or something I can't remember what it was the the was it the cor or something what does it say rebuilding the temple rebuilding the city walls and Gates and by teaching the Torah right to the returning Exiles all right that they're the three action spaces as they call it but as you look at this oh my God is there a lot of iconography on the table I mean this thing is quite a bit of a fiddly game to play in terms of understanding what the hell everything is now there's some good iconography here and there but yeah it is plastered all over the place and it is a busy board for sure so how exactly does this game play well most of what it relates to to if I can find a suitable player board well this is like the board before you start building on it you've got all the wall cards around the edge that have resource cubes that are required to build those various spots you've got a temple track here where you can put people on in order to get more bonuses as well as build on this Temple for again complete walls and columns for bonuses noticing a theme here with the fact that this is a very abstracted game and also you've got these Tor tiles here which this is the blank sheet at the beginning but these will fill up with tiles which are basically in game scoring and like some special abilities and bits and basically if you have your person on there you can qualify for the points or the ability and so it's like other cool things to obtain but what you're essentially doing on your board and I need to there's a lot of insert pictures here I just want to find a
picture of the soding board come on how hard can and I mean player board sorry I mean how hard can that be and we'll stick with this one so nope nope I am going to find a better picture if it kills me uh this no no I'm not happy with that one either I am such a perfectionist well let's look at these cards as we'll do actually these cards are kind of like your bread and butter of the game you don't get extra cards you just have these particular ones and they've got these ribbons on them so the best way to kind of describe this game is Garfield games ancient hits because a lot of stuff in this game is definitely been jury rigged from other games that they've done like I'm not entirely sure there's a unique bone in this body because or an Innova bone in this body because it's all stuff you've seen before this is basically I think ripping off the paladins of the West Kingdom game now there's an element of uh VI counts here with the whole I've got three cards at the bottom and they score me symbols and you stack cards on them and you know those symbols will disappear but it's mostly a paladins thing these colored ribbons or Banners are basically there to power the different actions so if you want to do the temple stuff you need red you want to do the building stuff you need gray and if you want to do the Tor stuff you need blue and that's basically kind of how this works they've each got their own little special ability or like trade that they can do a particular location that they're associated with and you know you can do these trades to get more resources for money but the main thing is that you are trying to set up your card so that you can do the actions you want because they all have different
costs of how many banners need to be showing on your board and so you have to manipulate the cards in that way and that sort of thing is fun I mean it's not it's not like any of the mechanics in this game are bad but the feeling the overall feeling I got for this game is that it just feels very generic you know we there's nothing new in here like I've seen this whole you know pay resources and build cards around the outside before you know I mean it's not too dissimilar from the wolves and paladins but you know there are other games that have done this the whole ribbons thing with your uh player cards is essentially the paladins from paladins of the West Kingdom the fact that there's like you know three in front of you and you kind of cover them up and that is pseudo VI counsil the West King them you know there's just elements pulled from other games that they' done or other games that exist to create this and so what you kind of end up with is just another Euro game but one that has a lot of you know fiddly iconography in places trying to figure out what's what and doesn't really give you a decent sense of excitement I mean there's only so much interaction as well most of the interaction is you know just oh someone took that card before I did now your border has got some fun bits to it I do like these development tiles here where if you get the various resources you can flip open the flip over the tile and then it gets better and you use these meols in the slots to get yourself bonuses or get yourself extra ribbons that kind of thing you know that stuff is cool you can customize your strategy based on those tiles and how you choose
to play but you know leveling up this track play bread put a guy down get a cube pay bread pay more bread put a guy down get more better Cube and then the the Temple up here put Cube down get point or get requires this many ribbons get bread get coin get Victory point you know it's it's all just very generic and mechanical I mean even this you know you you put somebody in the bottom row of this tor and then in order then you have to go into one of the two above that one and then you have to trace a line back from wherever you're going to back to the middle so you can't just jump ahead to the top row you have to kind of build up in stages because theme I mean this is a pyramid scheme no not pyramid scheme yeah like a pyramid style action placement system with reading the Torah why um you know it's it's like the theme is just like yeah whatever this is the setting now here's a bunch of miname mechanics and it almost feels kind of Stefan Feld like and the last thing I want to feel like from A Garfield game is a Stefan fael feeling there's like no way Jose but the game itself is not bad I mean there's the season am of thinking as to it and you are going to be planning a bit on your turn and there's a sense of efficiency and there's some tactical opportunities when these cubes start clearing off to try and build areas but nothing about the game makes you go oh yeah that was a really cool combo because there's a lot of tightness in this game it is a relatively tight
game for resources and stuff that you're not really going to be creating such Uber combos all the time but it's just generic it's forgettable and that's its biggest sin cuz I will play it if somebody puts it in front of me and that's the choice for the evening you know and I enjoyed playing it solo you know the solo game was fine for it but I just didn't feel myself wanting to play it that much after I played it it's like I would play it and then I'm like yeah I'm done for a bit and if you were to say right I want to play A Garfield game which ones are we going to play I can think of several that I would pull out in a heartbeat before I Braken this one out so this is definitely not a bad uh Garfield game it's just not that interesting and that's kind of its a big sin you know it's a little D in places but it's still got some good thinking to it it's a bit Bland looking but it's still relatively well produced bit of a table hog as well and you know but there's a decent amount of thinkness you know the reference tiles that you've got are pretty good with remembering how things work and I do like the card system I do like this using the cards for multiple uses and developing your board in a way that's comfortable for you you know that fits with your strategy all well and good but I'd rather play VI counts or wayf farers or Architects or you know Scholars or inventors or Raiders and or ships I'd play all of those before I played this one and all of those are games that I would give a seal of endorsement to
easily enough this one I don't think is enough for me to give a seal of endorsement to but it's still not bad I'm giving it a six out of 10 overalls and above average game there's stuff to enjoy here for sure and I can see why some people would like it a lot if they are into these pretty much bone dry here's a bunch of miname style Euros you know pick a mini game spam it to hell and that is what you do for the game because you're not really doing a bit of everything you're focusing on one of these free things and you're sticking with it because otherwise you're just not going to be very efficient points-wise um oh yeah and I forgot that you've also got this like pseudo feeder people thing like at the end of the rounds you have to basically be able to get this marker as high as these two otherwise you get penalized for it um or is that just a Sol mode I can't recall but it's it's like I say it's mostly just a forgettable experience like when I get rid of this game and I do intend to sell it on it's not really going to be one that I remember that much afterwards it's like oh yeah that was a thing decent enough game but uh I'd rather play any of the what eight or nine other g games I've got on my shelf I mean how many have I got now I got three of those two of those that's five and I got two of those other ones that's seven I'm pretty sure there's an eighth on there somewhere um what would the eighth one be I'm pretty certain I've got eight Garfield games in my collection but yeah it's Different Strokes for different folks I can see people will enjoy this one but for me and I well it makes me
sound like I don't enjoy it I do like it I mean mechanically it's decent but there's no theme to draw me in there's no desire to play it after I've played you know all these other better Garfield game stuff the rules are going to be a bit of a SLO each time you play it because there is quite a few Niche rules here to remember and it's a bit of a admission to pack it back in the box as well I mean it really is a Tetris Style game so yeah it does the job fine the stuff to like but I can't really give it a seal of recommendation uh you know for something that I would rather give the seal to other games in their lineup this one's fine does the job I I recommend you try it if you're a fan of Garfield games or if you were particularly I say a fan of paladins um paladins and I don't know these dry sort of miname centric euros and sort of paladins of the West kingdom is definitely an influencer here you know if those are the sort of things that you really enjoy then probably give this one to look cuz I reckon there you know there are some people that really like it and I can see why I just kind of like yeah me it's fine does the job but that's about all I can say it does the job and that's just not good enough in this day and age so uh yeah I'm glad I tried it just not really a keeper so yeah there we go so that's a kind of like Speedy sort of overview of my
thoughts on Ezra and nemiah does the job just not overly you know memorable um and also a lot of games played at gridon so you know all those games that I very much enjoy you know eight out of 10 n out of 10 10 out of 10 games there you know it was a great convention so thank you Paul for running it I will see you obviously for gridon 6 next year guaranteed that is not going to uh you know change anytime soon and maybe I'll do more demos while I'm there and hopefully I might be able to turn up on the Thursday as well and go to sheepies and stuff like that so you know didn't have much holiday this year I more holiday next year so hopefully I'll be able to do a proper session for grid conon but yeah anyway I'm going to sign off my fruit is standy nerd and I could do with a little gym visit and just generally chill so I'll see you on the next episode after of uh what say there's going to be one more podcast episode this year because next weekend is the what 24th and then there's the 1st of December something like that so the 1st of December or whatever day the Sunday is is going to be the last podcast I do this year okay I'm not going to record another one for you know the holidays I know I'll stick to reviews on that front so the next one will be the last one for this year episode 104 and then the next time you'll see me on a podcast show like this will be in January you know as I sail around the Arctic Circle and hopefully not freeze to death so yeah looking forward to that I'll have to think of what to do for that episode I'm thinking of maybe talking about uh 2.0
games you know the fact that we seem to be flooded with all these 2.0 style games and you know like re-implementations of stuff that's fairly recent you know is that too much of a thing although I can't help thinking I did that on a recent episode so I might have to think of a different topic but I'm open to ideas and suggestions so by a means suggest your thoughts but until next time remember as always it's only a game so take care and enjoy the the cool weather enjoy playing games and hope you had a good time at gridon if you were there and hopefully I'll see you at probably handy con uh January handy con I should be there as well so if you're going to that one then buy means say hi means a lot to hear from you take care and bye for now