Brilliant Idea - Perfect Execution: How to make a BEST-SELLING board game!
Transcript
if there was a formula for creating a board game that sells it might look a little bit like this in this video i'm going to make the case that it's not enough to have a fantastic idea when you're creating a board game you've also got to consider the execution of that idea as equally important
i'm adam porter and i'm a professional game designer based out of cardiff in wales board game designers value their ideas highly the most frequent question that i get asked by new game designers is how do i protect my idea and that question lays bare a total misunderstanding of the board game industry the truth is that there are tons and tons and tons of ideas out there publishers are overwhelmed with board game designers showing them fantastic ideas the tricky part is executing those ideas well and the two things combined are going to generate a successful product this formula puts the quality of an idea on one axis and the execution of that idea on another if you're in the red orange yellow warm areas of the graph then you're likely to be having some commercial success indeed if you're in that red box then you're probably creating a massive hit a brilliant idea masterfully executed this could be a perennial best seller further down towards the left you've got the green area heading into that sort of lighter blue area of the chart this is where the sort of moderate successes lie the good games well executed languishing with mediocre sales as we go further down into the darker blues then we're getting into the low sales and you're probably not even turning a
profit once you get into that black area that's disaster zone so what do i mean when i say idea well essentially we're talking about the core concept of your game the hook the thing that draws the players in and makes them want to play in my recent video on product design i talked about the way that game designers come up with their ideas and i mentioned that it might be through inspiration or it might be through experimentation but very rarely do i come across a game designer who's genuinely had the user in mind from the early stages and all throughout that process of design it's important to remember when using this formula that we're looking at an idea as a solution to a problem how well does it solve the problem that you've defined but equally we're looking at how significant was that problem in the first place was this a product that anyone was actually asking for what we're not talking about is innovation your game does not have to be innovative to provide a solution to a problem and in fact many innovative games don't provide any solution at all the purpose of innovation is to further the craft of board game design but that doesn't necessarily translate to commercial success and what do we mean when we say execution well everything else the aesthetics the accessibility the marketing the ease of play you can get a summary of all these things and many more in my recent video about product design now i'm going to take a look at some
examples i recently made a video of my top 10 favorite games of all time so let's have a look at a few of those first up we have dominion this is often touted as one of the most innovative games of all time and i'd agree with that not only is it an ingenious idea but it's extremely fun one of the best things about this product from a publisher's perspective is the opportunity to release endless new content dominion has more than a dozen expansions at this point in 2021. i think donald expecarino's idea was exceptional but i can't quite give it full marks for execution and the reason is because it looks a bit bland the artwork is a mixed bag there's no real storage solution for it the rules are not particularly intuitive for new players if you're an experienced gamer you're probably going to find it fine but somebody else is really going to struggle setting up the game is a chore and putting it away again is worse so the game sits in the dark orange section now that's enough to make it a really successful hit game it's a fantastic genius idea brilliantly executed next up is our toyville comrades from sarah and tanya engel this is a gambling game with poker chips instead of money it's all about pushing your luck pulling coals out of the devil's cauldron but trying not to reveal a demon now i love this game but i don't think it's a very commercial idea it feels like something that was born out of experimentation rather than a product that anybody was asking for
and as such it's only got a very niche audience the execution is good but limits its chance of massive success the poker chips are lovely but they're expensive and they necessitate an oversized box and to save on cost i suspect the publisher has given us not quite enough of them which means you spend the most of the game making change at regular intervals which can get a little bit tedious the pieces the coal pieces are made of wood so they're lovely and tactile but if you look very carefully you can see the differences in pattern in the wood grain on the back if you've got a good memory and you're that way inclined you can work out which pieces have which values and you're not supposed to know that information the gameplay is incredibly fun but it's unintuitive and it's hard to learn the game ends up on the border between blue and green a fantastic game experience but a weak commercial idea well executed by the publisher i suspect that its sales were limited uber rosenberg's agricola turned the popular video game harvest moon into a board game and that's a genius idea there's a massive audience for farming simulations on game consoles and i don't see why board games should be any different i love games where you place wooden pieces on the table to create a 3d representation of whatever world you're occupying and agricola is one of the best examples of this in tabletop gaming with fences and livestock and stables and fields growing vegetables and grain the execution is good but it's
limited in appeal because the game is much more complex than the video games that it emulates there are lots of rules to learn and lots of crunchy decisions to make and lots of resources to convert and convert again in order to score points there's also a lot of stress and tension in this game that you don't get in those video games like stardew valley or story of seasons you've got to feed your family in this game and if you don't you're gonna lose points now none of these things are inherently bad in fact for me they make the game a deep rich rewarding experience but they do limit its appeal for new players the game's very hard to learn not particularly intuitive to a new player and that's illustrated by the fact that lookout speeder released a family edition of the game a few years later and i think actually the family edition was flawed because it retained a lot of the complexity of its bigger brother and it didn't really make it simple enough for the young players that it was targeting and so agricola hits the orange section a very successful hit game largely because the idea at its core was genius dominique boden's witness is a perfect example of a fantastic idea executed very poorly the game involves collecting clues about a crime and then whispering them to other players remembering that information and passing it on ultimately players are left to deduce the details to the crime it's an incredible experience one of my very favorite games
the game is for four players and four players only you can't play it with any other player count and that fact alone destroys any chance for commercial success and ensures that it largely sits on my shelf unplayed the box is full of these thick heavy booklets there's one for each player there's another one that's full of different cases and clues there's another one that's full of questions and another one that's full of solutions this means the product must be really expensive to produce each of those books is heavy and full of artwork to add to the expense of the product there's a license attached to it the game is set in the world of blake and mortimer an intellectual property based around a comic book series in europe witness was very positively reviewed after its release but it soon went out of print and it shows no signs of resurfacing the concept of cooperative puzzle solving has been executed brilliantly in the exit and unlocked series of escape room games and this shows just what a strong commercial idea it is but sadly witness although a superior game experience for my money didn't manage to overcome the hurdles that the game designer put in place when they came up with this core concept ticket to ride is one of the best products in tabletop gaming the game is intuitive and immediate it's basically rummy in board game form and as such it's very very familiar that's a strength people look at this and they just assume
it's a step up from monopoly we've got a good old board with locations real life recognizable locations that we can make connections between we're placing plastic pieces onto the board okay they're not houses and hotels they're little trains but we have trains in monopoly anyway there are colorful cards all over the place and there's a single page of nice simple rules and let's not forget the game is endlessly expandable how many different versions of ticket to ride are there out there now of various different countries and cities maybe it doesn't quite rival monopoly for its reach just yet why haven't we yet had a star wars edition of ticket to ride making connections between endor and hoth and the death star i guarantee it's coming some way down the line we're gonna get there ticket to ride star wars you mark my words ticket ride is a perfect example of a genius idea masterfully executed and as such it goes straight into that red box in the top right corner of our graph as an experiment i've plotted hypothetical sales figures onto our graph now i can't pretend to have access to the sales figures for these games but i reckon this looks about right this is my understanding of what we can expect in the board game industry so if we plot the games that we've been talking about onto this graph let's see what we get so i don't know if this is accurate but it looks about right to me i can imagine that this is roughly
the sort of quantities that these games were selling and you can see that the games that do well aren't just games with fantastic ideas or fantastic execution but games that mesh the two things together and create a fantastic product of course the sad truth is that the vast majority of board games that are produced hover in this blue section of the graph or even down in that black disaster area i want to be clear the execution of the product is not just the responsibility of the publisher the publisher is limited by the parameters set out by the prototype given to them by the board game designer the publisher had no say about the player count in the game of witness they couldn't stretch it they couldn't make it playable by two or five or six players because the core concept by dominique bowden limited that the publishers of agricola couldn't make the game simpler more intuitive more welcoming for new players because to do so wouldn't be true to uber rosenberg's original design so the board game designers have a huge role to play here from the earliest stages of their design thinking about where they want to end up and how the product is going to turn out if they continue down this path i hope this video has been useful to you whether you're a board game designer or a publisher perhaps you could use a formula like this to help you to predict the likely commercial success of your product or your prototype if you enjoyed the video please come back and watch some of my others
i'll be releasing a lot more similar content over the next few weeks looking at product design in detail in the meantime please leave some comments below this video i'd really like to know some examples from you perhaps an example of a game that's a fantastic idea but really poorly executed or the opposite a game with magnificent execution even though the idea at its core is pretty weak don't forget to subscribe so you don't miss any upcoming content until the next time all the best