Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Pleasant Surprise Board Games - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 18:58

hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 pleasant surprises where these are the games where at the time i first played them at least um i wasn't sure what to expect and they were way better than i thought they would be sometimes that's because my expectations weren't there and sometimes it's because i didn't know who the designer was but i'll explain through each game as we go along so let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have pyramids this one's by matthew dunston um this is a game where i completely blind bought the game i very rarely do that but i just fancy doing it at the time and you know when you do that i i kind of appreciate that i'm taking a punt and the game is probably not going to be very good it was on sale but when i got at home and got it played i was really surprised about how well this one flowed and about some really novel concepts and ideas so as i said it's a filler game that only takes about half an hour to play um and you are basically building a pyramid you're building an obelisk and you are also trying to build a dungeon of all different types of cards but to do those things you are basically drafting a pile of cards depicting different types of bricks on them different colored bricks that is and i think you're collecting sets of two um at a time that is and then depending on your turn order which is like a a draft where you can either choose to draft a tile that will let you go or take the cards first but let you only build in one of those three areas or you can go last and build in all three so you've got that attention of being

you know short on what what cars you're going to get into your supply and be able to use but only being able to use those things for very particular uh for at least one criteria or you can say that you know what i'll take any card going but at least i can contribute to everything then all these different things are going to score in different ways so for example the pyramid you've got like a layer of i think it's four cards and three cards then two cards and a final pinnacle card and you're trying to connect all the different colors of bricks together try to make as long of a chain as you can for each color and get points that way the obelisk you're trying to get a different color of brick in every layer that you put down and for the i think it's the crypt again you're trying to get different colors um or be the majority of having each color in your pile and you're going to get points that way i i really love that drafting system of you know being going first but being able to do less or going last and being able to do more it really did shine through it scaled well and it was just a real joy to play so you know naturally my expectations were low for this one but that only worked in its favor so that's why pyramids is at number 10. at number nine i have tyrants of the underdark now this is a game that i would never of even crossed my mind to play but at a gaming group i was invited to um to play this one a couple of years ago and i'm really glad i did because it's a dungeon dragon steam game which is something i'm not interested in and it's a game that mixes deck building with area control because you're actually using these cards to basically increase your coverage on the board and try and kick other people off spots

and trying to kick off neutral pieces in order to control certain areas and get points at the end now that's the idea which is pretty cool in itself but the game actually had this really cool idea where the more powerful cards you'd get into your hand as the game kind of neared the end of the game you could start retiring those cards into this champions hall and get points for them or at least more points for them than you would if you left them in your deck so there's that extra layer of decision whether you know am i going to keep this card in my deck and hopefully it can cycle around one more time before i retire it or am i just going to say you know what let's be safe and retire it now for those extra points that's a really cool concept and it worked really well i didn't like the um the graphic design on this one it looked a bit bland and a bit plain but despite that the game mechanisms really did shine through and the gameplay was really strong so really impressed by this one again because my expectations were low um and i'm in two minds about how the the dungeons dragon dragons themes work for this one because in some ways i can see you know it would invite a lot of those a huge market in in terms of the dungeons and dragons players but for me you know being being a board gamer i would never have even thought of playing this one because of that skin so you know think about what you want ready but nonetheless it was a really solid game that impressed me that is tyrants at the end of dark at number nine uh at number eight i have rune stones uh runestones was a kickstarter from a couple of years ago by queen games and at the time i must admit i didn't know that the game was designed by rudiger dawn who if i didn't know that i probably

wouldn't have been surprised because um he makes ultra solid games this one is uh another game that kind of uses um card draft or card drafting and deck building as you have all these different colors of cards and you are using them to bring new cars into your hand you are then combining those cards together and getting rid of the stronger one i believe in order to get additional powers and you can buy these different kind of gems and then buy runestones to give you extra powers it's really fun it works extremely well it plays quickly it looks nice it's a great production and it's just one of those games where i think you know what this is just a really well tied together game that's clearly been designed by someone who knows what they're doing um and you know when i first played it i thought this this this is going to be another generic game and it wasn't it did stand on its own and um i think it's an underrated title to be honest that is runestones at number eight now at number seven i have tumble town our temple town was a game that came out last year actually in 2020 and it's a game where you are drafting cards and taking dice and then you're rolling those dice and you've got different colors you've got what colors that i think your brown ones which represent wood you've got your um your gray ones which represents stone you've got your wild dice and so on and you are basically using those dice to build buildings not only do these buildings require a certain amount of dice they actually require certain restrictions as well so they might say every dice in this building needs to be at least a number four or they need to be a number one two

three and four and so once you've got all these different ideas that you need to um that you need to decide on what you're going to commit these dice to in order to build these buildings and get points but as you as you acquire more and more of these buildings they give you lots of interesting mitigation tools to either you know re-roll the dice or turn them over to the opposite side or to con convert some dice into other color dyes so you've got this real little engine going as well so i really do like that mitigation and on top of all that really cool stuff you've got a player board which has a basically a blueprint of your town and then you are essentially choosing where to put these buildings down as you as you build them trying to adhere to certain criteria so this spot might say you know if you get a building that's at least three tall then you are going to get another another point if you've got a black dice here then you're going to get an extra point and so on and i really like that and it all comes together in a really neat package um certainly a game that didn't take off as much as i think it should have um but i suppose it's got a bit of breathing space now it's out on the market and maybe some good word of mouth can spread about it but yeah a game that i thought was gonna be a bit unpolished and a bit undercooked really but when i actually played it i couldn't see any fat on this game whatsoever the production let it down a little bit i think in terms of the artwork and graphic design maybe didn't make it look as you know as professional as it could have done considering how strong the actual gameplay is but nonetheless um tumbletown was a real solid game that just left me massively impressed and a pleasant

surprise at number six i have boom muntu now this came out a couple of years ago now this is an abstract game where you are navigating around this grid of tiles these are the credit tiles with all different pictures of animals on them and the animals or depending on which tower you start on because you've got your player piece you are going to move around that grid in certain directions and depending on how that animal moves and then you'll drop me from town to tower trying to collect these animals for a sec collection but the on top of all that which is cool in itself you have this scoreboard where all the animals score different points so one might say you know if you've got the most monkeys you get seven points and the second place gets three points and so on but as you take certain colored tiles the ones with the black backgrounds you can actually choose to manipulate that score track by shifting the animals values up or down spots and that can be really an interesting level of player interaction as you're collecting certain amount of animals and you know your opponent's collecting another one and you can just keep shifting them around making your animals more valuable and their animals less valuable comes together really nicely plays in about half an hour again and a nice production and um yeah just a welcoming game as well really easy to teach a little bit of variability in there because all the tiles aren't used from games a game and a again that didn't come out too much fanfare again and just left me impressed so that is boom on two at number six now at number five i have calico now calico probably you know as i'm recording this i can

this is a an immensely popular game that came out to so much praise last year um and believe it or not this one's actually designed by the same designer as tumbletown um kevin russ i think he's called i think he's a brand new designer um probably cons probably a big factor on why i wasn't expecting much from these games but now he's come out the gate that strongly um i i probably wouldn't be as surprised if he brings out another rock solid game but this one is a game about making a blanket um for cats basically a bit of a weird theme but you're doing that by drafting these tiles and placing them on your board trying to pattern build basically trying to make certain colors and certain um patterns on those colors um to to basically link to certain scoring criteria so one might say you know get five points for every row of four of this color or stuff like that and the way you've got so many different objectives and so many different restrictions comes together it makes for an extremely tight game with uh a small margin for error and i like that you can't really bite off too much and go for too many of those criteria because you just back yourself into a corner and you just can't do it all so you have to be quite selective and be a bit flexible as well about how you are going to or which which criteria you're going to go for and i really like that it's a extremely tight tile placement game that scales well really fun it's quick great production and um just a game that i think is going to be a bit of an evergreen and stay around for a long time to come

and because i wasn't expecting anything from it you know the theme didn't appeal to me but that game itself is fantastic that is calico at number five number four i have another game from last year this is nida velir now nida velia is a game that's starting to get a bit momentum now okay people are starting to understand it and get get onto their radar this one is a game where you are basically trying to collect different sets of cards um depicted by these dwarfs and they all score in different ways so some might just say like you know the more of these cards you get you get you get more points some of them might just score at face value some of them kind of multiply how many you have by the number on those cards so they'll score in slightly different ways but the way you gather these cards is what makes this game interesting because you have three different rows of cards out there on the board and then you are blindly bidding on taking priority on the card you want on those but at any time you always have two tokens left that aren't used and if you ever use your zero token which means that you're gonna basically go last in drafting a card then you combine the other two that you haven't used together to make a more powerful token to make you stronger in future rounds so you can get those higher bids in a great concept one that is almost one of those things where you think how hasn't this to be done before it's so streamlined it gets to the crux of the phone just from the get-go some really interesting powers as well that you can get and um it's just one of those games i think is going to be a foundation of the board gaming genre for a while to come

because it's just it strikes that weight of being accessible but still having interesting decisions so look out for this one it's going to be big that is nida valeere at number four at number three i have a really simple card game called ohanami now this is a card drafting game where you have a hand of cards and you're going to take two of those cards from that hand and then pass them to your to your opponent and it's going to keep going around playing cards down but basically this game you have the ability to play on three different columns and as you play on these columns you are trying to think about what cards are going to score because you've got your blue cards that score three points each from from the first round you've got the green cards that score four points each but only from the second round and then the final round all the card scores you've got your gray cards which score i think seven points and the pink ones which score in in set collection method so you've got to be that pacing is quite interesting whether you're going to get all the blue cards down early and score them three times or go for those big lump of points at the end but on top of that you've got this interesting decision because every single card is numbered from i think it's one to 120 something as you play on these different columns and you you bring new ones into your hand you could only ever play higher or lower than the um than the cards out there so the gaps in between cards that you've already played are just a no-go zone you cannot put cards in there and that restriction just gets tighter and tighter as the game goes on meaning that sometimes you just cannot place the cards you want so you've got to factor in you know do i want to score

this valuable card um and potentially um back myself into a corner and basically widen that margin of gap that i can't play towards or am i going to be a bit safer and keep the margins close so i can have that flexibility to keep playing cards down a fantastic game one of the best filler games i've played in years um that is ohanami uh just just a fantastic game that just blew me away at number two i have raccoon tycoon now raccoon tycoon came out probably a couple of years ago now and initially i think probably for the first year or so i wasn't even interested in going near it i'd heard some good things about it but i thought it just looked a bit too light for me i didn't really know what the game was about but again at a gaming club i was invited to play a game of this one which is i think it's a good opportunity to play games you haven't played before and um i just sat back and just reveled in my in in the fun of this game it was so such a joy to play so so much pleasure and just just a fun experience where you have this fluctuating stock market as you're playing cards and some resources are going up and down in value as you buy and sell them you are bidding on on cars to get pure points and set collection bonuses you're just a free auction which is just great fun in itself and then you've got these really interesting abilities to buy these buildings and invest in getting special powers that only you can have and nobody else can such as you know being able to sell extra goods or having more storage capacity and all these ultra interesting powers and

i think this game did a great job of making every single building in this game unique and interesting and just a necessity to have and i think when player powers come into a game you need to have that that you know lucrativeness and just that that lust over having that ability and raccoon tycoon did that extremely well i've had tremendous success um teaching and playing raccoon tycoon since then to a wide array of different players and i just think this is one of the best next level games out there and one that i really wasn't expecting anything from but mechanically just boiled down into beautiful simple decisions uh and just just ultra fun to play that is raccoon tycoon at number two and finally the game that surprised me the most of any game i've ever played about how good this is this is citrus at number one citrus is a game that i don't hear anybody talking about this is actually recommended to me by a subscriber of the show actually so thank you to him for um for recommending it this one is a tile placement game as you are basically planting these little orchards i suppose onto the board and every time you s you place a new orchard onto the board of a certain color you have to deploy a worker onto it as well and you only have a limited amount of workers so you can only have a certain amount of orchards and there's this real tension about when you're going to start pulling people off the board out or keeping them on the board because if you have more people on the board and you start taking people off you get fewer coins than if you have more people on your board

a bit of a strange concert but as you play it that that little twist um becomes you understand how interesting that is and some um difficult decisions that causes but additionally you are trying to surround these different uh buildings these thinkers in order to get area majorities and you can actually have this element of being able to spread around and link them together to maybe collect a certain uh you know a couple of these fingers at once and on top of all that interesting area control interesting tile placement and that economy of being able to take people on and off the board you've got this ultra interesting uh tile drafting mechanism where you have this kind of cross-hatching of of tiles based on this grid at the narrowest point i think is only two tiles at the widest point it's four tiles and you are either collecting a row or column of those tiles paying a coin each for each tile you take but as you take them you're obviously sliding the whole row off making the other rows and columns um alter so that either become they become cheaper because there are fewer towels on there but they also change the colors that are available great drafting system interesting tile placement has a slightly abstract feel to it whereas you know the information available was pretty good um at all times you know you know what's available and um there's no real luck or anything in the game but um just a beautifully put together game when i talk about being streamlined and i talk about games having nothing nothing in this game that needs to be there that this one has that it's just streamlined to the core

just beautiful clean mechanisms that are just ultra engaging that is citrus at number one again that blew me away and um i cannot believe this game isn't as popular as it should be just a great surprise for me so this concludes my top 10 pleasant surprises i i'm really happy to talk about these games because i like talking about games that not many people are talking about games that you know impressed me out of nowhere so hopefully they can do the same for you and it's just not the same games that the hotness and the games that have blown up so definitely check these ones out if they appeal to you i i really would recommend them so that concludes this video if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved