Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ask The Chairman - Board Game Q&A 8

Transcript 24:13

hey everybody and welcome to another edition of ask the chairman this is a board game related Q&A session where you can ask me anything you like concerning board games as usual thank you to everybody who submitted questions on the last Q&A and if you want to keep the series going then please do submit your questions uh Below in the comments and I'll be sure to answer them next time um if anybody did submit a question and I've not answered it this time um sometimes YouTube plays games with questions and they just don't appear to me so I've not deliberately avoided anything it's just the way that YouTube works unfortunately before I get started on some of these great questions I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor Kender do.uk uh if you use the show notes or use the code in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order but let's get cracking with the questions and we're going to start with a question from James and he's asked what is my favorite game that takes 15 minutes or less now I actually found it quite difficult to find games that took that time period or less cuz most of them sit around you know 20 minutes for a super fast game but I did manage to rustle up a few and some of my favorites are splitter quite a quirky little roll and right Style game uh cross Clues which is a nice party one uh quick sand a real time kind of almost dexterity game where you're trying to time these sand timers and flip them over at the right time and also Trio known as Nana as well some just some examples there of ultra quick games he's also asked what

is my favorite travel game um and there's two games that I tend to go to when um taking them overseas or on trips um number one being coloretto um really nice little pushy luck set collection style game and also battle line an older kitzia kind of a poker Style game uh these two games are great because they do manage to pack up in really small boxes they don't take up much space in your in your luggage so thank you for the questions James Tony um has asked do hi I have any techniques to distinguish colors from one another um that is because I am color blind and sometimes games don't come colorcoded or little don't have little symbols on them to help you differentiate them um normally it just results in me asking you know a friend or family member who isn't color blind to separate them those kind of components for myself and my brother who was also color blind so sometimes we just have to wing it and I don't really have any designated technique or anything like that um I've never gone to the length of say you know maybe putting dots or something on certain components because I don't want to ruin them when it comes to maybe moving them on down the line um he's also asked is winning important to me or is the gameplay experience all that matters um now I am quite a competitive person and I like winning um but it's certainly not at the Forefront of why I enjoy gaming I you know a lot of my favorite games I'm really terrible at and I've hardly ever won them so it definitely is all about that gameplay and that experience and

you know sharing it with the people I care about so that's much more important to me than winning despite me being a competitive person he's asked why has your taste evolved away from heavier games now this is also as by um Hudson and a few others of you as well um because you have kind of noticed over say the last year or two that I have steered away from a lot of the heavier Euros um and there are multiple reasons for that um I'm going to touch on a few of them because I don't remember all of them to be honest um number one you know I play so many games I have a lot of people games coming through my you know through my channel and you know when it comes back to re revisiting more heavier more complex games it becomes quite a chore to relearn them and because you can't memorize all those rules all those fiddly rules minua so that's one big issue I mean you know prevents from getting getting them to the table um life is generally a bit busier for me now as it was than it was a few years ago when I had a lot more downtime to learn these more complex games now I like to kind of learn a Ru bit quite quickly and get it played more quickly and it also means I can play more games on a gaming night because more complex games generally mean their longer games in their entirety and something I've also found just from experience is that just because a game is heavier it doesn't necessarily mean it's it has more depth or it's more interesting um a lot of the time now I find that these heavy games have a bunch of different

mechanisms kind of um executed to a lower standard than say a lighter game that will have one particular mechanism or two mechanisms executed to a very high standard so I much prefer to play games that are usually a bit shorter a bit less complex but have a one or two definitive mechanisms that really do shine but thank you for the questions Tony and hopefully that somewhat answered your question um Tommy chimaru has asked has your change or tasting games affected your gaming group uh no not at all um I play with the same people you know I've got my close group of friends and my family um so yeah I've got I've got no change there at all we'll play anything together we have a good time so we're not really game focused we're more group focused um it's also asked do you play with a different group or has their taste changed too no as I said before I do play with the same people but thank you for the questions uh brother toasty has asked if I were to go to Japan uh Which gems would I pick up now I actually don't have any suggestions for this question now if you asked me a couple of years ago I probably would have but it seems more and more common now that these more Niche Japanese games are making it over to um you to the west and becoming more accessible you know um I'm thinking of games such as you know Nana also known as Trio now uh games like wi the the film which has been reprinted as photograph and Rumble Nation you know these Rumble nation is a bit more hard to get and I would

recommend picking that one up if you can um but if I if it hadn't been reprinted I would have said um why the film again known as photograph now uplift has asked um have I tried any Cube rail games um such as Chicago Express or Irish guge um I've not tried any of those two you mentioned and to be honest I'm not quite sure if I can even Define a cube rail game is I assume it has something to do with using cubes as the rail track instead of tiles um if that's the case I haven't played a game like that I did have a quick search on what categorizes as a cube rail game and I only played one of them from that list and that game was Stevenson and Rockets which is an older Rino kitzia game and I did not like that game at all and despite me really enjoying ksia games um on the whole it was just a little bit too stop and start for me it was very um GR I thought but those other ones you mentioned I've not tried so I can't really give an educated answer um but if you could sum up what a CU game is to me in a in a line or two then I'd certainly look into it and hopefully increase my knowledge but thank you for the question uh Kevin has asked um what are my thoughts on whistle Mountain so I have played whistle Mountain um I like the concept of it I liked a lot of the mechanisms now my problem with it was and this seems to be a running theme with I think it's Luke Lori who is the designer um I find his games a little bit too loose I found whistle Mountain

too loose where you'd always be flooded with resources um you could always kind of do what you wanted to do and I found that with each play that I experienced with whistle Mountain so again I tend to like my Eurostar games to be a little bit tighter to have to work a bit harder to get your resource and to pull off those big moves this one just seemed a little bit too forgiving for me and that's what ultimately Steed me away from it now again mechanically I think the game is really sound um I like the game I probably rate it about 6 out of 10 maybe a bit higher um but I would have liked it to be a little bit tighter to make me work for those points he's also asked have I ever used proxy components to simulate another game uh yes I have the only thing that's the only game that Springs to mind is an easy one which is um Dixit I know I've used mysterium components to play Dixit now that's a very easy one to to proxy um but none other ones kind of spring to mind immediately but I'm sure I've done it before but thank you for the questions Kevin till has asked a couple of questions the first of being have I played bizans and what are my thoughts on the game uh yes I have played bazan quite a few times I used to have it in my collection uh it's I think it's a cool game I think it's quite interesting the way that it works um my only issue is it with it is it's I think it's a little bito too I don't know maybe a little bit too fiddly at times it doesn't flow as nicely as I would like it to um maybe I'm being hypercritical

there because I do actually think that now I've played so many more card games since bazan I think bazan is way higher quality than a lot of them that I've played um if you don't know what bazan is it's kind of a a hand management game where you're using cards not only for set collection but you're using them to bid on future cards as well there's also this kind of cool Market mechanism where if you are if you acquire fewer cards in this kind of bidding round then you get to take more cards from the market that other players have built up and I do like it I think it's a little bit too procedural to be one of the great card games uh he's also asked what are my thoughts on tore the Builder um and have I played at four players um I liked tore the Builder again it's been a long time since I played this one and I don't think I've played it at four players I think I've only played two and three players it's kind of like a an engine building Style game as you're constantly getting discounts and Things by playing more cards it does have a Alexander Fister feel to it cuz it is designed by him um I did like it but I felt a little bit soulless for me so it didn't really it didn't ultimately resonate with me that well um but I thought it was a good game uh Quint tenna has asked what are my opinions on the failings of rule books now if you'd asked me this a few years ago I'd be a lot more forgiving than I am now because I used to have quite an easy way way of just understanding and grocking what these Rule books meant even if it wasn't explained that clearly um now I've read so so many and played so many games when I read these Rule books um and there are

ambiguities I find it very frustrating because I can say well does it work like this or does it work like this it's not clear to me and I find that stuff really annoying and um I understand that they're quite easy to make these mistakes when you're writing these books um but yeah I I can't I can't deny that it does frustrate me quite a lot and I've played quite a few games recently actually that I found out real hard work and found out like pulling teeth to make sense of these rule books so I think at this point when there are so many games out there and the hobby space is getting bigger and bigger it's kind of unforgivable so yeah sadly it is what it is there's nothing we can do about it but again I do find it frustrating as I'm sure all you guys do as well but thank you Richard has asked uh would I consider a ranking game designers uh yes I would I have actually made a list maybe a few years ago now when I did rank my I think my top 10 favorite board game designers um and I'm sure it probably would change now if I made that if I remade that list because when I was making that list I was kind of really showcasing those heavier Euros from the Italian designers like know Chini and luani I still love those guys but I do prefer some purish designers more than that now like kitzia so maybe I will um readdress that um that list but I'm also going to think about doing some list where I will take a certain designer and kind of categorize where I put their games now I appreciate there's not that many

designers that have a big catalog of games but there are a few you know like Stefan felds the rosenbergs and you know the kitas the Poo moris the Martin walles so there are quite a few designers that I could do that with and um you know I've often found that I rate games quite differently than a lot of other players too so it might be a different take he's also asked do I have any games unplayed for more than a year or two yes I do um I'm trying to make that less of a thing um because I'm actively making a mental note of games that have been the longest played on my shelf to make sure that I play them first and put them at the Forefront um and I've also been kind of trimming down those games that again don't hit the table so regularly even if I do really like them because what's the point in having some great games if I never played them um that is actually his next question where he says does this factor into me moving them on yes it does and I do have a few of them that I haven't played in a long time and that's normally because they are smaller boxes they don't take up too much space and they normally require those higher player counts which I rarely have the opportunity to explore so I've had games like the resistance Avalon unplayed for a long time games like Tashan unplayed for a long time but I love them so much um that I would certainly not consider getting rid of them because when I do have those bigger play accounts I'd certainly love to pull them off the shelf and get them played and have them there ready and he's asked me am I going to the UK games Expo this year yes I am

I'm only going on the Friday um and he's asked what do I like about the UK games Expo I just enjoy the day out I think it's a good showcase always busy I like going kind of taking a punt on games I like going to the bring and buy sell to find some Bargains um so I know nor use it as a bit of a shopping day really rather than a gaming day um so again it's kind of just an opportunity for me to um take a I'll get a bunch of games that will keep me going on the channel for a little bit longer and maybe pick up a Hidden Gem or two or take a punt on a few games that I maybe wouldn't buy say from a from a website or something like that but it's normally a good day out I enjoy it um and just yeah it's just fun uh he's also asked would I consider bringing a game a game to the Expo that I want to share um I wouldn't actually because again I don't use the Expo to play games and if I was to do that then I would rather play games that I don't own so that I can try things before I buy them or you know try things that I wouldn't normally play so you normally when I go to games clubs and things I'd rather play someone else's game that I don't have or that I've not played before and I would use an expo for the same reason really um rather than sharing games that I already love but thank you for the questions Richard some really good ones there Alexander has asked what Feld game would I like to see reimplemented into the city collection um I'm not quite sure if there are any of them that I'd like to get um see reimplemented into the city collection

um because generally I'm not the huge fan of the way that the queen have handled the whole thing to be honest I think the the graphic design isn't the best I think they're way too expensive um and to be fair I'd rather another company reprint some of these old ones like so you know I saw that games like bruge were being reprinted I did I did end up picking up Hamburg but I'd rather another company have taken the Reign rather than Queen because I'm I'm not quite sure if I like the way they do business um I'm trying to think any other ones that I'd like to see remade I'm not quite sure I think I have all the ones that I want to play um maybe I think the only one is um straussburg he's also asked what fael game would I like to see an expansion for um interesting question now I think you on your question did say that you would like to see one for the Oracle of Deli that is one of my favorite Feld games and I think that is definitely has room to um put some expansion content in there maybe add some different missions and some different tricks and that you could pull um I've not really thought through what the expansion content would be but um again I can definitely see room for that game to be U to be changed maybe change him the god Powers up um and stuff like that so yeah orac Adelphia will be right up there for me um you did mention Amaro I'm not quite sure if Amaro needs an expansion but obviously you do but thank you for the questions uh Koji malasi has asked uh what is my favorite Legacy game um I can't really say any because I think

I've only ever played one and that was uh the king's dilemma which I didn't really think much of at all he asked do I enjoy deck builders um yes moderately so um I've not played that well have played a lot of them but not that many I've kind of fallen in love with and and deck building in general seems to be more popular with um other people more than it does myself now I'm definitely below the average gamer I think when it comes to liking that mechanism um but he's he's asked what is my favorite deck builder at the moment my favorite deck builder is the Quest for El Dorado a simple racing deck builder by R kitzia just skipping tiles and things to race to the end playing certain cards match terrain cards I tend to like deck builders when they are not so bloated and you don't need to constantly keep getting new material I understand that is kind of part and parcel with the mechanism um and I have done a deep dive into some deck builders before such as you know legendary I ended up picking up pretty much all of the expansions for legendary and end ended up coming so bloated that it was just unplayable really so I try to avoid those styles of games now and if I do want to play a deck builder I would go something a bit more self-contained such as the Quest for El Dorado but thank you for the questions uh the original Maverick has asked have I ever regretted a review I made uh yes um one in particular comes

to mind um I did review a game called hidden leaders which was this kind of tug-of War Style game um with some amazing artwork I actually did remove my video of that because in ret I was a bit blunt and I think I came across as a bit rude when making that video too dismissive and I think it was just completely uncalled for so um the designer did actually reach out to me and said you know was that really fair and I said no it wasn't I in retrospect I did just take it down because I wasn't that invested in the game anyway um and I thought yeah fair play this is someone's hard work they put a lot of work into this and who am I to dismiss their work other games um that I've that comes to mind are once when I first started the channel and you know we all know when we get into the board game space we're so enthus enthusiastic about everything we play um so I was putting up positive reviews about pretty much everything really such as you know dead of winter which is a game I really don't like at all now um I gave that on quite a positive review but at the time I was being honest because I was enjoying everything but it's not it's kind of offbrand now with the kind of games that I like so um more of a change of taste than regrets but again the only one that I really regret is that hidden leaders review uh he's also asked what happened to corporate card board so if you're not sure what corporate carboard was it was a show that myself and McKenzie Franklin um used to do together it was kind of like a variety show um the only reason that it stopped was because McKenzie stopped making videos um for his channel because he got a a job with conflicting interests so that was the reason why um

no other reason I love making corporate Caro videos I love working with McKenzie he was a great voice in The Hobby but he moved on to pasture new and um we couldn't do it anymore it was also becoming a bit more difficult for us to sort a timeout when we could actually stream together because you he lives in Colorado I lives I live in in England so we are like 7 hours time difference which you can imagine was quite different to difficult to sort a timeout to actually meet uh he's also asked do I assume rules when I learn them from the rule book and can this disappoint me if I presume something and it's not the actual case uh yes so I actually um this is kind of a follow-up question from the last episode when I said that I prefer to teach games than to be taught games because my mind jumps to places and I think well this obviously is going to work like this when in reality it doesn't now sometimes when I read Rule books um and I I think oh this is cool this is going a certain direction this has got a cool mechanism to be built up here and then it doesn't end up doing that so yeah I do sometimes do that I can't give an an example but I definitely have made a mental note of times when I have kind of filled in the Gap myself and that's not not been the way that the game actually works so yeah it does happen um I don't really feel either way about it but yeah it does happen but thank you so much for the questions uh Brett has asked is there a game where I prefer the first edition or do I replace to stay up to dat now I'm not sure if I've replaced

that many games over the years with the newer editions um one that I did do was I replaced Nova Luna with framework because I thought it was a bit more a bit more going on um even though I preferred the artwork of the original Nova Luna um games that I preferred the original on at least from a visual standpoint is libertalia I really hated that new stone meire version of libertalia it just looks terrible whereas the original lialia looked gorgeous so um I'm really surprised why they went in that direction maybe to make it a little bit more family friendly but I still have the original libertalia and I would definitely keep that one over the new one um I wouldn't maybe wouldn't necessarily call this a second edition but it is a reimplementation and you know I much prefer Chinatown over the waterfall Park whatever that one is um just terrible terrible retheming it doesn't make any sense um I suppose another one would be i' would much rather keep my copy of Bora Bora over getting say the new Queen version of kusco so um yeah I do prefer those older style games from the from the stepf city collection Believe It or Not which we mentioned earlier so a couple of examples there Alex has asked do I prefer to lose by a small or large margin or do I prefer to win by a small or large margin um both of the questions would be a small margin um it's not nice to get absolutely battered by your opponent and it's not doesn't feel good to batter your opponent either at least

in my opinion I would much rather the game be tight until the very end and um the winner just squeeze a victory and normally with me that is the case because the people I play games with the most um have are very similar in our kind of um experience and skill level so um we're always back and forth on who wins the games anyway so that's a good touch uh Dy has asked um have I ever played coffee rooster or Friday so two quite well well respected solo games there and I haven't played either of them unfortunately now if you watch my content regularly you might know that I very seldom play solo games and if there was a solo specific game then it's quite unlikely that I'm going to end up acquiring it into my collection or playing it at all um and I'm sure they they're good games but um I've not played them so the answer is no unfortunately um but that wraps up all of the questions so thank you to everybody who has submitted them some really interesting ones there I hopefully you've enjoyed the video as I said if you do want to keep the series going then you're going to have to submit some more questions below no worries if not we just um continue the series later on down the line but again if you do have a question please leave it in the comments and I'll be sure to answer it next time but for everybody else um I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved