Will we keep any of these new board games? - Keep or Cull?
Transcript
Hello everyone, this is Sarah.
And this is Johannes.
And you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings.
And welcome back to Keep or Cull, the series where we're playing all the games and we decide whether to keep them or cull them. These are mini reviews. If you haven't seen these episodes before, it's mini reviews and we decide if we want to keep or cull the game in the collection. And there's so many games that we can't keep them all. Many good games have to go and many good games have to stay. And also some bad games have to go because all of the double of the games that you play are that good. And also the bad games are not staying. Just No, don't say that. No.
No, okay. No, the bad games are not staying No. at all. So, we have 10 games today, 10 more games. I think all of these are fresh out of Spiel. We are working our way through the games. We still have like 60 or 70. I think we might have around still 120-125 games upstairs that we haven't played. We're working our way through them. So, we will see what's going to happen. Today, 10 more games. Do you want to begin? Yes. Let's do it. Let's start with Over Over Over
Over Over Overload. This is basically This is kind of like a cheat because we already own Order Overload, another version. This is a new Oink promo version from Spiel. Are you ready? Yes. One, two, three, boom. Oh, I meant keep.
I was thinking what's You are on like a culling spree always.
I am, but I love Order Overload.
Yes. Of course, the question is do we need both? Oh, I don't think we do. I think we might.
We might? And because this one is a like I The other one has better quality cards. These are kind of flimsy. Yeah. Uh this is like very very like made as a promo.
Oh, yeah. But this one had some pictures on the cards because what you're doing is that you're reading off orders basically and in this one it's only Oink games from 2010-2025 and you're reading them off and let's say I'm the reader and let's say we're around four four players, that's four cards per player, that's 16 cards. Yes. And I read them through them and I shuffle them up, give them out and then we all have to remember cards that the other players have and you try to get two people, depending on how many players, to get rid of their cards.
Mhm. So, it's a very hard game. The other one we have is the one with Oink Itten and Sascha and Sascha games. Which is so many different weird titles of these ancient games. This one is a bit easier. We have played a cafe version which I think was kind of almost harder. Oh, yeah. Because you had like double cheeseburger with fries, double cheeseburger no mustard, double cheeseburger fries no mustard. Like it was even more hard in that way. I agree and we can keep them both for now because they're so small and I will decide later if I need both of them. But in general I recommend over Order Overload.
Over Order Overload. Yes. Next up we have Puru Puru Paradise. This is a review copy from Daryl Chow which was here earlier this year. You can go and check our video. This is a Yes, we usually do the thing first and then we
Final forest. One, two, three, boom. It's a cull.
It's a double cull. This is a Yahtzee style game.
Yes. And with some like fun twists and some interaction. I would say like if you are a family looking for a Yahtzee game and you're okay with somebody kind of attacking you because you're rolling dice and you can roll again. If you want to roll a third time, you have to drip. Like pay a currency which you don't want to go to zero because then you lose. Yeah, you're basically you are the dessert and if you are dripping into water on the floor
like ice cream is melting. Okay, that makes sense. So, you are in but the the face of the dice that I have the most of, the other players on my side get. So, I'm trying It's kind of like a risk. Like push it like do I want to try to get No, I get all the positive things and you get them instead of me and I get the negative things. So, it was a fun little game but not one I need to own or play again. I agree. The like the mechanism with the the thing you got the most of, you gave to the other players was really interesting.
Thumbs up. Uh Catchy Cat.
Catchy Cat, a two-player trick-taking game. One, two, three, boom. Keep. What are you doing? You're like Do you Did you lose your paddle or something? It is like I put it in another room.
I'm rusty. Okay. Um What is going on? How is this happening? I'm choosing cull. What are you choosing?
it even though like the cover
is not the best cover.
And the cards are of horrible quality.
Yes. Like the worst. Well, I'm okay with culling it but I thought it was fun because you have a cat that you want to If he's excited the winner of the tricks, he goes to where and you want to have the cat in your lap or you want to win three times more than the other player kind of or three times. Yes. You get points basically and you just play rounds. I felt like from Do you have any more? Yes, because if he's like scared Yes.
scaredy cat then you want to lose a tricks and it change depending on like if there are odd numbered cards that are played and you want to see kind of when to change that and also try to see when you the low cards are good and the high cards are good. And sometimes you're really in a position where you can't really do a lot but it was a cool thing. I think it's fine. Like but I don't I don't think I would choose it over other games. It has kind of not the same mechanism but where you want to lose or win like Jekyll vs. Hyde and other trick-taking two-player games as well. So, I felt like this was on the lower lower edge of a two-player trick-taking game for me. I liked it. Next up is Regal Rulers.
Mhm. This is a push-your-luck game from It's Bruno Faidutti and Jun Sasaki. Okay, we don't usually It's Bruno Faidutti is pretty well known. Let's do it. It's an Oink game. One, two, three, boom. This was um
It sounded fun Yeah. in the description but it ends up being kind of procedural. Yeah. Like you are putting your hand into a bag and you're pulling out zero to four things. And those can be eels which are good or snakes, the red ones which are bad. And then everyone reveals and you put the snakes in the middle of the table. If there is at that point when you reveal, before you put them in the middle, a number of snakes depending on the number of players, then everyone who has the most things in their hand in that round is out of the round and the other players get points depending on the number of eels they have collected. So, it was not that fun. It was just like we did it and it was done and we were all agreeing that we would not want to play it again. And also I'm very happy because we almost played it eight players the other day and I would have slept half of that time because it sounded fun but was not that good. Uh next up is Fuchl for for Fuchslos.
Yes. Uh my German's supposed to be good. Yeah.
It was not. It was not. One, two, three, boom. It's a double keep. I like this one a lot actually. This is a trick-taking game.
What?
Uh which you have and the suits with both a negative value and positive value. And if you win a trick, you will add together all the numbers in that trick and go up or down on a track. And you want to be as close to zero as possible. Yeah. And so you will not get a lot of points. And so when the other players seeing that you are going down the track, they will try to push negative cards your way and the other way around. But beware, you will also want to win some tricks. But if you don't win any tricks, you will get 15 points and points is bad in this game. And like it's surprisingly fun. I would This was very fun, I would say.
a review copy, I forgot to say. It's a really good game. I feel like it is it All of the trick-taking games I've played lately, it's the one that gives me the most of that what we call in our like a cabin game feeling. Which is like a traditional game. Like we call cabin games, we call Yahtzee, we call like some card games like a normal deck of cards. This is simple enough that you can play it with everyone but it still is like a hobby trick-taking game. But it's kind of like it can be very harsh. You can be in a position where you get Yes, very
Yes, because you're trying to screw the other people over massively if you have the option. Yes. Oh, we're keeping it. It's over there. Really good game. Let's do another trick-taking game. I think it might be the last one. Do you have any more trick-taking games?
No, I don't. So, you know, this is the last one if you don't like trick-taking games. It's also the last one if you do like trick-taking games. This is Tricky Trix. This is a review copy and also it is by Tyler Bainer which we hang out at Spiel. So, you know that. We know the people that made it person people person. Let's do the thing. One, two, three, boom.
for me. Why? Because I was so bad at the game. You can't start culling games because you can't understand them.
I want.
Cuz you're a dinosaur.
Yes. Tricky Trix, twisty trick, tricky Trix is really good. I feel like it is but it is tricky It is. and it's twisty because you want to win tricks but then also you want to lose tricks by playing off suit. Because when you do that, you get the cards back card back as a false trick. And if you pair up a false trick and a trick, you get some bonus points. And if you manage to get exactly same number of tricks and false tricks, then you get some more bonus points. And then every round is going to be a scoring card that gives you points depending on what kind of false tricks you have. Then there is if you win a seven, you will get to get one of the bonus cards help you with these kind of goals. It And also you have a reserve of cards which you can draw from at the beginning of a trick. It is very It is not that rules complicated but it's one of the ones that is pretty complicated as a trick-taking game. I would say it's a little like offbeat compared to other trick-taking games, so you feel like you just a hard to prepare for what's smart, and also it feels a little unpredictable. So, I can have a a plan and be like, "Oh, it didn't work out."
But I didn't feel like what I did really enjoy about this game is
Most of the game. Yes, but that it you wanted to play things off suit. Yes.
Which in a lot of trick-taking games you will get nothing for that. So, being being able to follow a suit and not winning was like the worst. It didn't give you anything, but but at the end of the the round when it was nearly finished and I wanted just to be like smooth in there because I've matched up all my things, then I won the trick.
Yeah. And so, it's like, "Oh, it destroyed my plans."
But it's very interesting also because you have the five cards in the reserve and you kind of know like, "Okay, maybe I place only low cards there." And then in a position where I only have high cards in my hand, I'll be like, "I don't want to win this next trick." So, before it become a draw a card, and of course sometimes it's going to be like, "No, no, I can't follow." And I don't get the full trick, but other times it's going to be like it's going to help me not win the trick or help me in this kind of situation. So, I see this as a very interesting game to play more. I'm excited to play it more. It's an easy keep for me.
Yeah. And I think you'll like this.
it. I'll just have to get better at it.
Yes. Next up is Diver Go. It's a game show now.
Yes. Are you ready? 1 2 3 boom.
It's a double cull, but I enjoyed it a lot. This is No, you didn't. Oh, yeah. I liked it.
No, no, I liked it. I just don't see myself ever playing it again.
No, but I kind of don't do that with a lot of games that I enjoy. That is true. No, no. No, it's like that's why we're culling it. And it's not amazing, it's just like an interesting weird game. Diver Go, I can see myself playing with my family or something because it's a silly game. You are divers diving for treasure, and it's like a tactile game. So, you are in turn because you're grabbing these turn markers then and you're shuffling the board around and there's a lot of coins in there with different material. It's plastic, but they're it's pretending that it's golden and silver and stuff. And you get to look at it and then you need to take this diver's mask in front of you and grab the number of tokens that you're supposed to get and you look at them and you see if they are cursed and if three or more are cursed that you have in total, you will lose the cursed ones into negative points and you will not be able to buy points for them basically. It was silly fun. And it's like it's a it's a very interesting one. I feel like that it's not one I need to keep in the collection. I am speaking slow so I can get the next game. Next up is Tag Team, a two-player auto battler.
Mhm. Are you ready?
Yes. 1 2 3 boom.
It's a double keep.
I'm happy you're choosing to keep this one as well. Yeah. Uh this is one that I'm already excited for more stuff for this game.
Mhm. This is kind of it's in the I'm going to call it in the same category as Unmatched while being a completely and wildly different game. It's in that it's two players two you are basically choosing the heroes, drafting some heroes. You have two heroes, those are going to have a deck of cards that you shuffle and they're going to have a starting card each. And then you shuffle up those starting cards, you don't you choose the order of them. You place them down. And then it's kind of like an event game. You everybody flips their top card or the two players because it's a two-player game. Flip the top card, do what it says. Flip the next card, do what it says. Then you draw three cards from the top of the deck, choose one of them, place it anywhere you want in the deck, but you can never change the order of the two cards that's already there. And then when you place the next card somewhere, you can never change the order of those three. So, the one that's on top is always going to be on top, but you can place something like whatever you want it in in order of that. And the other one you place at the bottom. And then you do it again. You flip you flip you flip draw three more, add it you flip you flip you flip you flip you flip and so on until one character has zero life points, which usually has taken us about 15 minutes, which I think is a perfect play time for it. I tried to play it on BGA. Mhm. And I actually did not like it on BGA because even though you're doing very few things, I didn't like I don't don't know the cards enough. Like if I knew everything, I would be like, "Oh, I can see just a picture and be like, okay, that that that that boom boom boom boom." I I enjoyed the tactile feeling of it and flipping the cards something
about that. Um it's it's fun. I would say that this is I'm thinking now. Okay. I think it is my favorite programming style game because I feel like I'm programming something.
Okay. Yeah. And maybe actually well, we have
No, I don't like it anymore. So, I don't like programming games.
I like this one. Uh well, I I think we called Walk the Plank, but that was also a fun one. This is still completely different, of course, but it feels like a programming game and I liked it for all the reasons said.
Scorpion Mask makes some very interesting games and I'm always excited to see what they have next.
Yes. Next up
is
Borealis.
Borealis, is this your last one?
Yes, it is. Borealis, this was a review copy from Lucky Duck Games. Are you ready? Yes. 1 2 3 boom.
It's a double cull and [clears throat] the reason I'm culling this is because there's too many games I would say because I I did enjoy it. I would say that it has a really clever design. So, you're playing cards and those have different like vehicles and different animals on them. And they also have like a requirement for what you need in that location to play it. Basically, can I you just super quickly systematically what you're doing, you are looking at animals. So, if I place like a polar bear, it says which two of my people have to move from that location to adjacent locations to look at the polar bear. That's like the magical what you're doing, which will make it easy for people to understand. So, go back to
That makes sense. So, you have three locations and you have three different colored sign what you call it? Me me me me me me me me and it requires basically for you to have for example a blue and a pink meeple in that location and they have to move to their separate locations.
Yeah. And then you it has like a set collection thing where you want a lot of the same animal in one space and also want to have vehicles in the correct order to advance on some tracks. And also there is variable scoring sets that you can mix up as well. And I thought that puzzle of trying to have the right meeples in the right place at the right time was really interesting and fun. And the first time we played it, I Yeah, we thought it was a little too like random, but when I was like um thinking about like when I was going into it a second time, I was like, "Okay, this is the game." And then I was less bothered by it. But it does have quite a bit of like the randomness of, "Oh, the card I just needed came up."
Or, "Oh, it didn't come up." But it was a fun game, just don't need to own it.
Yes. Lastly today, we have probably I mean this is the biggest game for Keeper or Cull for a little while. Sanctuary, an Ark Nova game. We were thinking of doing a full review, but we're not. So, this is the short review that you are getting because there's so many games.
Yes. Are you ready? Mhm. 1 2 3 boom.
It's a double cull. Let's talk about Sanctuary. Yes. And before somebody says in the comment that you have to look at this as its own game, that's what I did. I'm not like coming from a point where I love Ark Nova. I'm coming it from a point where I like Ark Nova. I still have Ark Nova. You tried to cull it. I would still like to play it more because I think it's a great game. Sanctuary for me is not a great game. I think you liked it more than I did. For me it was a pretty boring tile placement puzzle that I've seen multiple times before, but done quicker and better in other games. The multiplayer of this game is no reason to play.
No. Like we played a four-player game, which took us 90 minutes, which you might say that's not too long, but it is. Because all of that time 50 minutes at least, I was doing nothing. Because when it's your turn, I don't care. I could care like a tiny bit. And we play a lot of games where you could would you would which you would call like multiplayer solitaire. But most of those games have some reason for me Here it might be, "Oh, you took the tile." Or, "Oh, you took that." Or, "You can't even take the space from me." It's the tile. That's the only thing. And but in many games I care about what you do because it might be interesting like the strategy or it might some common final [clears throat] scoring that you're all aiming for, which in this game you're just have your own stuff. For me, this game exists. Yeah. And I know people like it and that's awesome. I know some people really like it, but for me it's just like a very And also it's very luck-based because I know people say Ark Nova is that as well and I agree, but I feel like here and so I don't really compare them because I haven't played Ark Nova in years, but this one like, "Oh, the thing I needed came up." Or, "Oh, it didn't come up." But there's different ways of course to to take stuff or to take the tiles for to use the tiles for. Yeah, I said what I needed to say.
some positive things about this game because I I I thought it was nice. I thought it was nice at two players because it went pretty snappy and I don't see why you need other players in this game because it just makes the wait between my turns longer. And also I have to say Yeah. Some games like that where I don't really care, I can sit and think about my turn.
nothing to think about.
is basically I'm probably know I'm going to play these tiles next so I know my next three rounds and if not something randomly comes up, I can't look at everybody my turn. Mhm, yes. And I like trying to make tactical decisions about what to have in my what you call it sanctuary. Yeah.
And trying to have like a semi plan because you're as in Ark Nova you have these sequence of actions that if you do an action it goes back to one and then you have to like kind of build that up by doing other stuff in the meantime to do that again. So you're trying to be like okay I have a animal in this area that I need to play and then I'm trying to get something in another so I can play that and trying to see what comes out if it's some scoring that's relevant to me or not. I would say that it is very like simple and light and nice. So I would be if you are if you think Ark Nova is too
Like play spectacular. Yes. Yes, yes, yes.
tile placement game with goals and adjacency things like and so many of those games are already existing. The action tiles are boring, the upgraded ones are not any more fun.
It's not a great game, no. It is not. But it's I can see why people enjoy it but I agree with you Johannes when there is already existing super solid games, I don't see why you need this. No, and that is going to be it for today. How many did we call? We did call six. But also we called the biggest ones like there was this is the biggest game we kept and it's a very small game. So we kept four games which were pretty small what was your favorite and least favorite of this pile? I think my least favorite has to be um Ring old roulette, I agree.
Yes, because that was boring and also my favorite one oh I thought that fearless was really fun. I'll also tag team but maybe my favorite was fearless actually. I'm going to say tag team as my favorite then to be interesting and unique. Cool. That's going to be the end of the video. We hope you enjoyed it. If you are here you can subscribe because Sunova has this to say about subscribing. It's pretty awesome and you should try it sometime. Yeah and and try it. It's very different feeling to subscribe to this channel than other channels. It fills you with joy and also us. Yes. So help us reach a million subscribers. We cannot wait. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes. Sunova. And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings and bye-bye.