Skip to main content
Loading video...

From History to the Table - Interview with David Thompson and Trevor Benjamin

Transcript 53:32

do so so do

do do do

so so

hello everybody and welcome to our panel discussion from history to the table from the sd hist con and i am so excited to have with me uh two designers here whose games especially two players games i have loved over the past several years david thompson and trevor benjamin who are designers of war chest and also the undaunted series which has got a lot of talk uh over this weekend so gentlemen uh welcome to the stream yeah thanks for having us yeah thanks big pleasure to be here now i've talked to uh you david several times but trevor this is the first time i've had a chance to talk to you and so i just want to let you gush a little bit i have really loved the games that you and david have worked on war chess undaunted uh they've won awards on our show rolling dice and taking names for for best squirrely so uh thank you for giving us these treasures that i still love playing today oh thanks and it's a it's a huge honor to to be here and and i'm telling you the squirly awards awards are the ones i'm the most present the only one that matters yeah exactly i've got you know exactly and uh for those that uh who are listening if you wouldn't mind uh you can use the chat ask questions i'm going to just kind of get the discussion going but if you have questions specifically you want to ask these two gentlemen please put them there if there's any technical issues with video sound or etc just pop them in the chat and uh even possibly in the discord channel for sd hiss which is this is

also happening at right now and david said he'd be glad to monitor that for me because i've got like 12 other things i'm having to monitor over on this wall over here so uh all right let's get into it so the the title of this panel is from history to the table and this was interesting to me because uh as i'm starting to get into a lot of more historical games and i was on with you david on friday night talking about how this i'm really just going to get into different types of historical games and i love the idea of having these historical events that come to life on a game table it's very interesting to me about how what kind of research do you do to be able to get everything that you need historical facts events people and implement those in a play form and put them on the table and i've used our show as a platform to get other people into historical games and i've used your guys undaunted series as a great way to kind of jump into this historical games pool because at its core it's a basic deck building game if you've played dominion etc you'll you know what a deck builder is this just has a theme of a world war ii theme so now i'm getting ready to shut up i'm going to let you guys talk so i want to start with undaunted so when the idea came up all right how did it how did it come up it was like i want to make a deck building game let's do an historical theme on there or hey i want to make an historical theme game but

make it approachable and make it a deck builder and i'll just let you to to ping pong back and forth if you want sure yeah yeah um so i'll start us off i guess because i i was it started with you so with that we'll let trevor tell the story of of the or no so so it started kind of a fusion of the two of those marty um and that's not always the case but in this in this instance it was it was it was a really fortuitous timing where uh i was i was really just starting to get into gaming uh i had only been probably playing board games for a year or two one of the games i'd played and the first deck builder i ever played was a few acres of snow which is a very very strange game to introduce you to deck building right so unlike like you said dominion or ascension or something that's very straightforward um it like undaunted you know it's deck building is driving the action on the board right and so i really like that and i thought uh you know i'd like to try something like that someday and about the same time is when i moved to the uk and i was visiting normandy um and i was visiting the the places where my grandfather's unit the 30th infantry division was and i just had this idea hey you know i want to make a game about my grandfather's unit um it'll you know follow along in their footsteps what kind of what can i do to to to simulate this platoon level action and i went back to this idea of you know deck building driving the sort of command and control of the platoon um

but you know having the the board the spatial sort of world war ii skirmish theme applied to it so now that's different and we can you know talk about some of the differences and similarities with some of the other games where they come from but for undaunted specifically it was sort of a combination of wanting to have that mechanism into the background with the theme trevor what you got to add to that how did you looked up into this and yeah well how did i pop it now very good question so um so david had um designed the sort of the core of the system um and you know had the sort of like the basic structure of the two sides and in the units um but he hadn't done any of the sort of scenario developments which of course is a big part of the game um and he the the the publisher who we were talking to at the time who was not osprey um was very keen for it to be an un uh for it to be scenario scenario driven game and so that's that's when i came in so um i did some some development on the sort of on the core like i ironed out a few a few wrinkles here and there and um but most of it was basically working with david to do the scenario developments um and it's also worth mentioning so yeah david and i have now worked on i don't know too many games lots and lots and lots of games and this was the first one so this was like you know we we knew each other because

we've been going to the same sort of meet up play testing group but this was the first game that we started working on so david said hey i need to you know i have this game i you know i played it a few times um and he said you know i need someone to help me with this would you be interested in doing it and i said yeah sure so i jumped in i mean i so just full disclosure so i mean you know i did play when i was younger one of the i mean i i'm a bit of an omnigamer but i did play quite a few of the old sort of avalon hill historical games so i'm not like um i'm not you know these things aren't foreign to me but i'm certainly not a historical gamer or a you know war war gamer like like in in in the same way that that that some of the other people who are watching this are and and even in the way that david is um so i i came in sort of with with a developer hat on um for this four undaunted um and and but but what really interested me about it was i mean david seemed like a nice enough guy i mean i i learned my lesson after real quick but he seemed like a nice enough guy and you know just at that stage you know we were both early on and it was just any chance to to work on a game and especially one that that you know it it looked interesting to me because this mashup of deck building and a skirmish game is something that

i'm not like i had had an idea for how to do how to mash those two things up um after having seen a few acres of snow as well but um it wasn't it yeah it didn't have the core the great core idea that david had which was this idea that the cards in your deck each card represents the sort of the sort of the health or the efficacy of a unit on the board which was the to my mind the real stroke of genius in the thing and and so yeah i mean i was i was keen to jump in and help and so that's that's how i got involved and uh i believe for timing purposes even though the game of the game that y'all worked on the non-historical game war chest came out before undaunted but david i believe you told me that war chest was like a offshoot or offspring of the undaunted but war chest just happened to get yeah first yeah so that was basically we did all of the i mean so so undaunted started like 2014 right so it was in it was in some period of design and development until release that it was released in 2019 so like five-ish years in the making and so over that that time um it became clear and like i think 2017 is when we signed it with osprey so it was going to happen but while that was underway um trevor had the idea of like okay let's take the dna of of undaunted but we're gonna strip it down to its core and make this sort of elegant

minimalist version of of undaunted which is which is where war chest came from um but one thing i want to mention and so talking about trevor you know coming in to do the development work and the tonight design work on the scenarios with me um i often like to say that like trevor took a good game and made it a great game or maybe it was an okay game and made it a good game because and this is what i think is really important to this discussion so i came at the game from the perspective of like i needed to model a us rifle platoon that's my goal right and trevor came from like well we need to make a good game so you know when you have two people with when we have a shared goal but we're approaching it with different sort of you know um perspectives right i think that i think in the end that's what made it successful and popular right is it kind of neither one of us was willing to sacrifice some of the things we cared most passionately about like we had you know arguments if you will about well it well it has to be five rifleman because there's five riflemen in the platoon so there has to be five rifleman cards i mean come on now so those are the kinds of discussions we would have you know what but does that make it a better game and so that i think that going back to this idea of you know history it's it was awesome in the in the terms that it started us with these built-in constraints we had this design goal of like hey we're going to make this thing about platoons and these are scenarios we have to be able to recreate but at some point you have to make a decision well ultimately it needs to be it still needs to be a good game

for those again who just now joining i've got david thompson trevor benjamin who designed the game undaunted and we're talking about from history to the table taking historical game and making a game out of it and so you mentioned units so let's go ahead and start there so you have a deck building game you want it based around world war ii theme uh david you said i you know i know that a ruffleman platoon has has five so you obviously started doing some research from well what kind of units were available in world war ii how powerful were they how did they work so and you've done several historical games so if you want to bring in some context from other games of just talking about here's the research that i did uh to to that i did to go into this game and then maybe trevor can jump in it's like well great you've done all this research but like you said i gotta you gotta make a good game out of this so maybe there's some compromise to where it's like this isn't exactly historically correct but it'll be a better game if we tweak it just a chat tad but try to keep it as historically accurate as possible yeah yeah i mean for sure so let's let's talk about you know start with undaunted right so undaunted normandy specifically so you know most people are going to play undaunted and they're i've had people i've read comments for like oh i was i was commanding my battalion well okay battalion has like a thousand dudes in it so you weren't commanding your battalion you know or my squad or whatever and so he's like he's like the grammar police on twitter except the historical police yeah exactly yeah

so so um so many most i don't know some some significant percentage of undaunted players is never going to get that like oh i'm i'm commander of this this rifle platoon and this is what it's got in it and you know the numbers are accurate but if you start peeling back the onion you'll see like i said you know you have five there's a reason you have five riflemen there's a reason that you have a machine gun team that has three guys in it and they're working together you know all of this stuff reflects the actual platoon um but i mean the most obvious example if i just go down this path is the game you you have three scouts in your squad three scout cards but there's not three scouts there's actually two scouts right but the game breaks it's at a certain point and so you make these sacrifices and and trevor i don't know maybe you can remember some some of those conversations so the i mean there's two that pop the pop into my mind the the first one is are the snipers right so um you know snipers are almost by definition alone okay okay sometimes you have two snipers working together like a spotter and a sniper but essentially you ha you know and in the undaunted that in the original version that david brought there was one sniper card because there was one and there was a sniper unit on the board and had one card associated with it and you know you could bolster that into your deck and then you'd have this one card but it was terrible when your sniper

got shot because it's like it was just it just felt it just felt awful and and also you know because it was just that one card in a deck that is 17 18 20 cards sometimes like you know it just that it just the the unit didn't really work that well and so i had to kind of just you know again this was back when i didn't know dave very well so i had to be polite um but it was it was just a case of like well you know can can we make a concession here and just say you know sort of wave our hands a little and say it's a group of a group of three right because it's three for a couple reasons three because as david said even with two cards in the deck in terms of gameplay it doesn't really print three is also good because most of the other units in the game except for the riflemen have three right so it's five or three and that is a nod to the sort of sort of learnability of a game right like the more obviously there could have been units with four cards and some was six and some with two and whatever but it just that's an extra burden to put on people to have to to have to learn that and so you know it's a general game design points you want to make things as consistent as you can just to simplify the the the sort of that that learning aspect of it um and so yeah we had to make a concession there and a second example is um the game has um

three squads in it so squad a squad b and squad c and um squad c shows up later in the game and it does allow us to have some more um sort of wide open and sort of um strategic um scenarios in the end but in the back of my brain i was you know and many times like do we really need a squad c it's a lot of it's a lot of con like a lot of material again i'm not a publisher but just thinking for like it's a lot of cards and a lot of cardboard just to support a lit like we could have i think we could have delivered something very similar without squad c but david was adamant um and probably he was on this case he was probably right that we you know that that you know there are three squads like it you have to have three squads and so there we have you know we had three squads so they're so again you're you ha you're always making like you know the creation of a trade-off exactly and it's a trade-off between his the the historical accuracy game play and like the fact that this is a product that will exist in the real world and so manufacturing and cost and and an art budget right because like squad c you know like there's you know every single soldier is unique so that's a lot of art for for these these cards which are

used but often probably we could have gotten away without them so it's that it's that sort of stuff that you have to balance i guess and uh not only uh units uh but you guys uh especially with the north africa uh release introduced uh a lot of vehicles and and everything and in north africa normandy are different normandy is the idea of like a bigger scale battle right where uh squads and stuff could be replenished north africa has the concept it's like that's it once they're gone they're gone because it was a smaller scale battle so you also had to look at vehicles and terrain and how they managed terrain and then come up with stats for these cards so how did you do the research to look at well this type of tank should probably have these sort of stats and this vehicle should probably have this sort of stats and then make that work within the game so it doesn't break anything or make something too op yeah i mean i would say so so the design for for north africa was interesting because we actually when when ospreys when we signed normandy with osprey we actually as part of the same contract signed north africa and so what we didn't have was the benefit of seeing what the community's response to normandy was before we designed north africa we actually finished that design and gave it to osprey before normandy was even released um fortunately we had the wherewithal to think through hey let's add more asymmetry to the game

um let's add we wanted to play very different right neither trevor nor i are interested in re-skinning a game and just putting it out with a different name like we wanted it to play very differently and so when we settled on on the north africa theater we could approach it from a few different ways and we thought at least for me when i think of the north africa theater during world war ii things two things come to mind like these big desert tank battles or these like small scale commando raids and i think that we we felt that undaunted was was like at the personal level right we had all this art that was of the individual guys and stuff so it seemed to fit better with this idea of commandos and when we went when we decided and then we decided well do we do the sas or do we do what it is it's a long-range desert group once we settled on that it made a lot of sense to just have it at the individual guy level um so just like normandy all the scenarios are inspired and i'm gonna i'm very specifically using the word inspired rather than like modeled or based on real scenarios because they were just inspired right hey this actually happened let's let's come up with a scenario that kind of evokes that historical idea but we're not going to be a slave to the the actual the actual historical accuracy um i mean the most obvious thing in north africa is you've got these long-range desert commandos that's fine that makes sense but they're fighting a handful of italians so we we sacrificed you know realism there right because it should have been large groups of italians

um but to get back to your actual question about like stating the vehicles i mean essentially what our process is we need to achieve a goal right so we needed the long-range desert group to have these quick fast vehicles that could go in fast and smash stuff up and we needed the italians to be able to fight back and so how do we accomplish that oh well maybe the italians have a tank okay well if they have a tank what kinds of tank could they possibly have right and so you start just kind of slowly chipping away at what's our goal okay what can we do to get there and then we just keep looking until we find okay this tank makes sense because this tank is strong enough to pose a threat but it can be damaged by the relatively light anti-tank weapons that the long-range desert group had access to and so you just you just kind of keep looking until you find you know the thing that allows you to make the game you want to make yeah that's right and it's also it's also just to add to that one one thing that we um we were working under the constraints of the fact that this was the undaunted system right and so this was the second game in the series and um you know obviously we wanted to add new elements and so there we you know had to deviate from the sort of normandy core but at the same time it had to be an undaunted game and so that when it comes to things like stats or powers or whatever like you know we had the level of granularity that we had

and we couldn't really get beyond that so what i mean is that you know like for example if you look at normandy it's like you've got you roll one one to four dice for combat right and and the defense values go from four or five or six right so those are the sorts of ranges that we could work with and so you have to just you know make you obviously you want to start from from from history and and like you know once we've selected the tank that we were interested in or you know but but we didn't have any more granularity than is it a one or a two right like that that's the level of granularity that you can that you can work at in this particular context and but when you know when you're designing a new game or a new system then obviously that sort of things you have to decide is how much how much granularity do we want to incorporate into it what aspects of the historical context do we want to incorporate and model into the game and and undaunted is a very abstracted system and that's intentional because we wanted it to be you know as approachable and streamlined and stuff as possible but that's always one of the decisions that you have to make and then yeah and then obviously a follow-up game adds the con the extra constraints that you've already just made most of those decisions up front so you have to be

yeah you have to be cognizant of that i guess and uh david you said you brought trevor uh in when you was talking about the idea of scenarios now uh if people haven't played the undaunted series it's really interesting because there's different scenarios that you set up where you set up the map and uh the the units that you have access everything are supposed to simulate somewhat actual events in history so when you guys started looking at scenarios did you just start googling like what kind of battles happen you know dear enormity what kind of forces were involved against here what locations had battles same thing with north africa what kind of research went into the scenarios that you made and then how did those scenarios end up having to be modified change and everything to work within the context of your game yeah so um for for normandy it was it was basically given to us right so we we wanted to we knew we needed somewhere around 10-ish scenarios wound up being 12.

um but we you know i told you at the start that we it follows my grandfather's unit so it had to be battles that that unit fought in now when i say his unit i'm talking about at the division level so much much much larger than the platoon right and so what when we were doing the history it was basically let's go look at every single engagement the 30th infantry division fought in and we'll find any instance that we can find that there's a record of some sort of interesting engagement that realistically makes sense from a platoon at the platoon level to be involved in so we're looking for you know sort of interesting small scale examples of of conflict you know at the platoonish level for the 30th infantry division and it needs to be in normandy right so before they get to belgium and the netherlands and germany etc and so it just kind of constrained all the opportunities and so ultimately i went and visited all the battlefields that that are in the game um but generally speaking and this goes back to what i was saying before it's a game that's inspired by those right and so one of the best examples of that is there's a scenario in in normandy where you're fighting around a town now a platoon the the area that a platoon is actually going to be engaged in at any given point is really actually pretty compact right and so in the game we're doing all this combat all around the town well i mean there's no way that a platoon is going to be engaged in something that large so you basically find the scenario find the history

okay cool they battled for this town but we'll we'll abstract it out so that the board is more interesting from a gameplay perspective if that makes sense so you make some sacrifices there um it was similar for north africa right once we settled on the long-range desert group it was let's find every instance we could ever find of them doing some sort of action that's fun to play right so there's there's lots of things they did that were not fun to play let's drive across the desert for 2 000 miles it's not fun let's sit let's sit and watch a highway yeah um for like you know 72 hours straight without sleep it's like that that doesn't sound like much um so yeah this is that and and and that's that's definitely it that's you know we're we're being very selective in in the things which which we're which we're presenting because again you know we're just we are designing a game and obviously we want you know it is an homage to to the history and we want to bring that in and people let let people learn something about about the history through the game but you know i don't think there's going to be that many people who would be interesting if we had simulated some some of some of these some of this action like it just yeah but it's like it's like any other medium right because you know if you read a book or watch a movie or whatever it's you know we're not going to take you for a year of action right and and show you every excruciating detail right so it's finding the things that

that lend themselves well to the game um and and for those again who are watching we've probably got about uh 20 minutes left if you have any questions for these guys on any topic uh just please throw them in on the chat and youtube and and we'll um talk about it now uh so you guys have been uh talking about and playing through uh reinforcements the new expansion that's gonna to be coming out tell us a little bit about that what what does this bring and i think this is a true expansion right you need one of the base games in order to play reinforcement so um what does reinforcements bring to us gamers and what kind of research and stuff did you go into uh bringing those new con that new content and there's new scenarios and units and everything you want to start us off trevor yeah so in terms in terms of in terms of content so there's um the sort of high level that changes or let's change the things that it brings the first thing is it brings in two new game modes right so i mean both undaunted north africa and normandy are a two-player head-to-head game right so in this we wanted to bring in um an opportunity for you to play with more people and to play with less people so um for the more people we created a two versus two team game um and and then we also added in um a a solo mode um and this to be clear the solo

mode was not david and i who designed this it was um the two other david's uh it's turtley yeah it's turtle does this guy like make another solo motivation when does this guy sleep well here no but this is important this is david turtsey and david digby right so tertsy has now because he's just you know he has a group of people that he works with so dave david so turtley came in and came up with the sort of the the the core structure for the solo game and then um david digby came and um and did did most of the donkey work of actually like because yeah so i mean it's incredible the amount of detail that this that the solo mode goes in this like this is like a proper solo mode like you know every every scenario has so there are cards for every unit and every scenario so well i mean there's there's some overlap but essentially you'll have like this is the the ai card for snipers that gets used in scenarios three five and nine this is the sniper card ai sniper card that gets used for scenarios six or did i say six three other scenarios or whatever so it's an incredible amount of work so that so that's so that's the two key things that it adds right so it adds a it adds a

two game mode so there's two versus two a solo mode and then we've added um new content for the two so new new units um for both normandy and north africa and then four scenarios for each so four scenarios for north africa four for normandy and the the the solo mode can be played for all of the old content for normandy and north africa and all of the new stuff and it works on both sides right so you can play as the germans as the americans as the lrdg as the italians um and yeah so i mean that that's that at the high level that's it so i mean david you want to talk quickly about the the bringing in the history yeah sure sure yeah i will say real quick to tackle what trevor just said for the people out there who are solo gamers who just heard what trevor said that means there's 62 different ways to play undaunted solo mode if you if you have all the content right 62 different solo experiences so it's a little bit mind-bending um yeah so one of the things that you know when i mentioned earlier that uh we didn't have the benefit when we were designing north africa to to hey what what what do people want and what's interesting is i went back and looked at this there was enough buzz being generated in the lead up to undaunted normandy that osprey actually came to us and said hey we want you to go ahead and make another x another game it would be reinforcements another expansion um so

they actually had decided that before it was released but we had the ability to get at least a few months of feedback from players and one thing that the players wanted we thought when we were designing normandy that between the starting decks being different between the players the supply being different the scenarios being very different we thought there's enough asymmetry in the game people will be happy but one of the very first things we heard was no in addition to all that asymmetry we actually want the units to be different too now obviously north north africa has that in spades right sure but people wanted their toys to be different so um we introduced a couple of things that are thematic like sort of stereotypically thematic to us and german platoons right so the the americans get um grenade mounted rifles a grenade launcher and and the germans get submachine gunners and then we also added uh tanks to both sides now the tanks are not symmetric so the germans get panzers and panthers and the americans get shermans and stewards and if you if you know anything about tanks you'll know that if one side gets a panther one side gets a steward there's some serious disparity here and so in like we needed the tanks to be realistic from the time period right so it had to we couldn't just say well let's just get two roughly equal tanks and we'll throw them in there so we don't have to worry about you know balance um they needed to be historically accurate they need to be realistic on the on the western you know the western theater so we ultimately just you know decided on these and they are very

asymmetric and so we had to choose tanks that were historically logical we designed them in such a way that they made sense mechanically to the history which then meant okay now it's on us to design scenarios in such a way that allows for us to have the germans with their better tanks if you will right against the americans so um i just came from a demo where we were i was demoing the first one and a guy made that comment he's like well i've got panthers and panzers let's see how the stewarts and the sherman's gonna hold up but as you can imagine in the scenario design it it balances for that so i mean yeah it was another example of fans want something they want more asymmetry they want toys okay cool that's our constraint let's go back and what makes sense from a historical standpoint okay now we've got that answer okay now we've got to model it in the game and make it work from a gameplay perspective right nice now we have uh about uh 12 minutes left and we did get a couple questions so i want to make sure these get answered before we run out of time uh henry asked have you considered using this system in a different era of war yeah do you trevor do you want to talk about this you want me to uh a different sorry i didn't hear the different era yeah using this system in a different era um so i mean we have discussed it um and it's certainly something that um yeah it's something that we may do down

the line um but yeah that's pretty much i think as far as we've gotten i think yeah i would say okay so a few a few things um so there's been a lot of interest in that a lot of people have asked about that there's even a fan-made version of there's even a fan-made version of vietnam i will say that there is some some errors that i'm not comfortable making right so i personally would not be comfortable making like a modern day version of undaunted um unless it was super abstract right um here's the issue right from a practical perspective osprey is probably going to want to continue to have one undaunted title per year ish trevor and i only have a finite amount of design time right um if they i mean i think i mentioned this before i can't remember we're not really interested in designing something unless it's different right we don't ever get in a situation where we're just re-skinning things right so it wants to be different it has to feel different it has to still be feel like undaunted um the next couple of years have already been planned out and designed so you know for us to to go to a different era it would either have to be kind of in the future and us have okay let's let's change it up or maybe come from a different designer and pitch it to osprey you know it's something like that but it's i'm certainly not opposed right yeah well i mean so in historical i didn't mean to cut you off trevor just throw this in real quick almost like uh

what gmt does with coin right so volca designed a coin system and look how many designers have taken it and done their own thing with it and it could be the same thing with you guys hey we have an undaunted system that trevor and and david design somebody else would come in oh this is great i want to do a revolutionary war version of this sort of deal yeah and we've had people i i know i'm sure trevor has too i've had people come to me and they say hey i wanted to do a undaunted game about xyz and i'm like that's cool go to osprey and pitch it to them because we don't have we can't say yes or no right it's not it's osprey ultimately yeah i think it'd be cool to see what other people could come up with though using the core system for sure brought you off what were you going to say uh no i mean that that that's pretty pretty much pretty much the same as david i mean it's yeah it's it would be like we'd like to do it it's just again we we're under the the you know we only have so much time but we would you know by all means if people have ideas um then you know by old means speak to speak to osprey and i'm not obviously privy to any information that says you guys got this planned out over the next couple years so you know in my mind i mean probably people could think of wow you know there haven't been ships yet there hasn't been the pacific theater there hasn't been uh airplanes yet so i'm sure there's a lot of stuff that you guys have probably been playing with i can't wait to see what happens uh another question came in uh russ asked have you guys played the solo and how does it feel compared to

playing versus a human opponent go ahead david i have not played the solo i have um so what we basically did is trevor and i designed reinforcements everything but the solo system we designed everything we delivered to osprey they took that and they gave it to david and said here design a solo system for this and everything before it and so they went up and did all that work um they would every once in a while we'd hear from osprey about hey this is what's going on and it was just kind of like cool i mean we you know we basically when we talk when when we and when i say we i mean me trevor and osprey decided we were gonna do a solo system for undaunted we told them hey we're not interested in doing it right um i i if i'm gonna design something solo i wanted to be solo from the start right and so once we said hey let them do it we just let them do it um i've seen paul grogan has played it he's done a play through solo so i've watched that to get a sense for it i've read the rules i've seen the cards i will say that i personally think it does a good job of of evoking the experience of a multi of a two player game um there's a bit of crunch to it there as as there are with any kind of ai but i think once you've played it a few times and kind of got okay this is this is the general uh ai approach i think it'll click pretty easily and uh so the last few few

minutes again the uh for those who are watching we're talking about from history to the table about uh taking historical events and bringing them to the table and and maybe this is directed more towards david david i know you've designed several historical games like pavlov's house i'm looking at your whole list here you know soldiers and postman's uniforms so just just out of curiosity and and some games like that is that one of those things where there was this historical event that you read about it's like man that'll be cool to see simulated in a game form or did you have an idea from a game it's like what history would kind of fit this so you take either those both of those other ones and just could you tell us how that works yeah those are very different right so i was very uh specific about using the word inspired for undaunted that's a very different thing so in each of those cases honestly it's usually about six months to a year of research wow before the game design starts um i i did a demo yesterday of lanzaroth bridge which is the fourth part in that series the valiant defense series and this wasn't the intent but it kind of turned into just a question and answer session about some of the rules and i would i would teach a rule and i would say okay the reason that this rule is like this is because this is what actually happened historically so literally like every single element of the game was derived from a historical thing right whether it's you know moving ammunition from a machine gun or why does this you know whatever it is any aspect of the game uh

ties back to some historical thing and so what that usually looks like is i'll do the research cool i get i get a feel for the for the historical event then i'll re-read everything and i'll note okay this is the thing that can be modeled this can be modeled etc i'll kind of settle like these are the things that i want the player of the game to take away like i think you've got soldiers and postman's uniforms now right you've got a copy of it got it so when you when you play it i want you to think i can't win right we'll we're not going to be able to we're never going to be successful we just got to hold out that sounds like a great way to start a game david super why am i playing this because i can't win um i desperately want my non-combatants to live right like there's a a a janitor and his wife and their little girl i do not want those people to die at all costs if i can i want to try to let people escape like there's some things that you as a player are going to want to do right passionately and that ties back to the you know what the the feel of the being there you know in the actual historical event right so that's it's a very different goal it really does come down to like modeling trying to model an experience or a feeling rather than just a general inspiration for for an idea gotcha and it's funny uh that you mentioned that because uh yesterday i i played my first very short game of neski uh from volca uh with ignaci from portal oh that was a mouthful um

and uh so as we went we played through a couple of short scenarios and i had some questions uh for volca and and he said dm me and i'll answer them and and one of them was uh ignacy who was playing the teutons had a stronghold under siege and it's like i need to come help so i brought a russian unit in there and i so i asked volkow and i said i didn't understand the rules i said can i just battle then get back into my stronghold you know i need to face him once and hide my stronghold and went no he said think about this historically he said if there is a castle under siege and you bring in forces you must beat through the siege forces to get into your stronghold if you feel that you can't you don't get to retreat into your stronghold you're on the wrong side of the line you have to go back from where you came away oh that makes totals excuse me and then of course references the rules that's in 4.3.2.5 you want to go real for yourself but no i thought that was really cool it's like thematically it's i see what you're saying here i want to make it as close and accurate as possible which is what vocal did with this but in undaunted it's like well we need to make some concessions here and is is the is the reason for making concessions to make the game more approachable or did you just feel like making it too historically accurate would be too difficult

no in this case it was definitely for approachability right absolutely so every single every single decision that's made about his historicity versus approachability right that's a that's a question you have to ask yourself and every game is different the answer's gonna be different based on who the audience is right so undaunted as a very different audience than soldiers and postman's uniforms right and so the the decision point is going to be very different okay now with a couple minutes left to go just let me ask when is reinforcements coming out uh november 25th is the release day so yeah shipping gods be you know willing to say logistics lords you know yes if they bless it or whatever uh so i know you probably can't say anything but do you know when osprey is going to be able to say by the way after reinforcements you can look forward to blah blah blah oh yeah so we the announcement okay so yeah david and we've answered this question before so if you look back through history the last few years history um and see when undaunted games come out they tend to this year is different because perfect you know but but generally games come out in the sort of summer you know gen con to essen sort of that that sort of time uh so yeah it it's been that way for the last

three years so we can expect that perhaps to happen in terms of when the announcement will be um so we we we expect that there'll be an announcement coming sort of early next year okay um as to what as to what will be coming um coming for the next one and the very last thing do each of you have anything uh aside from undaunted uh that you want to get us excited about david i know you have a new kickstarter that you can talk about uh anything else and then trevor so david we'll start with you then jump to trevor yeah in in the immediate term you mentioned that already so and i talked about earlier lanzaroth ridge which is the fourth part of the valiant defense series um that'll be on kickstarter next month that's about it's like the first day of the battle of the bulge you're taking control of a very small unit there so yeah that's that's my next project okay trevor yeah um and for me so i'm just trying to think so david and i have a couple things coming out soon so we have um a dire alliance horror which um the the kickstarter happened earlier and it it should be shipping it should be shipping out to backers soon so we're really looking forward to seeing that it's the first miniatures game that dave and i've ever done so we're excited to see little you know the little gorgeous um and in terms of new new stuff um there isn't actually i'm just trying to

think there isn't i mean there's a few things coming out next year but nothing you know very imminent so yeah yeah yeah that's right one thing i would one thing i will mention and it's a ways off but it's exciting because we're working on it together with with another one of our co-design partners is we've got a game command called resist which is about the spanish maquis so that's a super niche topic most people think of the maki they think of the french monkey during world war ii but there were actually spanish resistance fighters too but it's actually not during world war ii the game is focused on their effort to retake uh spain against franco post world war ii and i just want to mention that trevor and i are working on it with my friend roger tankersley who i designed uh sniper elite with awesome and who's that going to be coming out from so that's actually coming out from a spanish publisher called salt and pepper so they're they do localizations um they're mostly known for like they do localizations for button shy games they've done watergate etc they actually reached out to us and asked us to design i i think it's going to be their first non-localization like their first original design so they asked justice to do something for them and we thought it'd be cool to have something that tied back to you know them being a spanish publisher so that's fantastic and uh if people want to be able to find you online etc where can they do so trevor so uh twitter is good um it's at trevor m benjamin um and then yeah board game geek as well so um you know you can just find me on

board game geek it's trevor m benjamin as well um and yeah by all means feel free to shoot me a message awesome david yeah same thing twitter's d jack j c k thompson and on um and the other place is board game geek probably twitter's the the easiest quickest gotcha david trevor it has been a pleasure uh talking with y'all and i really do enjoy any games y'all come out with when i see a game coming out with both your names on it i'm all over it this is the first i've heard about uh this spanish game that you're talking about i will be all over that the the miniatures game i'm excited for that to come out i can't wait to try it so thank you so much for taking time in this busy uh weekend to come and chat with me and thanks for everybody who uh watched through this make sure to go follow them and uh if you enjoyed this make sure to subscribe to the channel give it a thumbs up share it david trevor thank you

Progress saved