Top 10 Board Games I Soured On - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 games that i soured on so these are the games where at one point in my life i really enjoyed them and for one reason or another my enjoyment of those games has diminished as time has gone on and that could be for many reasons so let's talk about those reasons as i go through these games so at number 10 i have citadels now citadels is a really popular game that's held up well over the years i think it's probably 20 plus years old now it's a game where you are drafting cards and these cards are all these different roles and you are basically selecting one of these roles in order to do different things such as maybe stopping up someone else using their ability or collecting gold or collecting cards and essentially you are then using money to build buildings trying to score points um and there's lots of different ways you can score points but the reason why my dream of this died down was because i recalled several um game sessions where it's outstaid its welcome massively you know i was first very much engaged with this game i thought it was really cool how all the different roles interact with each other it's a really good replayability because there is a lot of variable setup but as i said there the game goes on probably towards that hour mark and i think it should be half of that really um it just did have dragged on you know that last you know 20 or so um just seemed to just really just dig its claws in and just drag and plod along and just churn along and i just didn't quite enjoy that and i
could i could feel the um the energy of the room just dissipating as the game went on additionally on top of that i thought in terms of strategic gameplay a real strong strategy in this game was to just collect money and build what you can when you can and that really didn't give the game legs in terms of what it could do because a lot of the buildings did work well together in different ways where you could score a lot of points but a lot of that was just in vain because it was always a viable strategy just to build um quickly and just smash things out and that would often win which which again left me quite unsatisfied and after i played this quite a few times and experience experiencing that again and again it just it just left me feeling a bit tainted on it and not wanting to play it anymore so that is why citadels is at number 10. at number nine i have a game that sat really highly in my rankings a few years ago this one is goo gong goo gong by andrea steading who is a designer i think is brilliant it really did make me flip-flop a bit more than any other game ever has when i initially played this game i was just in love with it i thought it was great all the different mini games working together this is like a work placement game where you where you were using cards um trying to swap cards for other cards which gives you your kind of hand for the next round um i liked all the way the different mini games work together because i like games like trade in where you have that mini game aspect but the more and more i played this one i started to
understand that the depth wasn't quite there it was very much a wide game where you could do lots of different things but i thought the the linkage and the the synergies and the um just the depth of the game didn't quite match up to my initial expectations um and a lot of that was because of that new game feeling you know i got the nice deluxe kickstarter version and i played this just before one of my um one of my top 100 lists i think or top 50 lists and for that reason just because of timing it sat really highly but as time went on i started to think you know what i'm just doing the same thing here the strategies aren't too interesting you know just a a silly bit of area control um a bit of set collection and you can say that about a lot of games but yeah i just didn't quite have the the depth that i wanted it to and again a wide game but not particularly particularly a deep game and i still think it's solid i would still put it you know a six or six and a half but initially i think i voted i rated it about a nine or so and just for repeated plays it just didn't have that satisfaction remaining and that's why google is at number nine uh next up i have bang the dice game i seem to be talking about this game quite a lot recently this one is a social deduction game based with yahtzee as you are rolling dice um trying to shoot your opponents and things but everybody is given a secret role being the sheriffs the outlaws or the renegades and the objective is for the sheriff and
the deputies to survive and the outlaws to kill the sheriff and the renegade to be the last man standing and the reason um this didn't stay in my collec oh didn't um or my appreciation of the game went down and down and down as time went on was initially i thought it was great i thought the game was really well balanced you know everybody could just you know pull the wool over will over each other's eyes trying to bluff who's who's on whose team and stuff like that and that'll work absolutely fine but after 20 plus plays um i noticed that the renegade never ever won and for me that that was just a sign that that role wasn't balanced i never saw i did seem come close to winning but after that many plays you'd think you know it would at least stand a chance and on top of that it started to be uh that bluffing aspect of people choosing to be on what roles and things and trying to convince the sheriff you're on their side became less um palpable as a as a strategy it would often be just a matter of just saying you know what we're the outlaws let's all just admit we're outlaws and just pound the sheriff so and um again that that defeats the object of the game and when objective like a setback i think why wouldn't you do that uh i just don't see a reason to go back to it and that's why bang the dice game fell from grace for me next up at number seven i have lords of water deep this is an immensely popular entry-level worker placement game and you know what this isn't actually a slight on the game itself i think it does what it does very well
i recall my you know my first five pages of this or so being extremely excited about it as you're placing um your your workers on the board collecting different um adventurers and fulfilling these contracts but as time went on more and more of these games started coming out you know where you just place things down you know collect collect collect fulfill a contract and rinse and repeat this game does that and it does that probably better than most games out there um but my my uh personal uh incentive and my desire to play games like that has diminished rapidly i like to play more heavier worker placement games and lords of water deep is often a game that people want to play and suggest playing and my desire to do that just isn't there anymore you know initially i rated this about an eight or so um and now i put it about about six um because it is very very uh mediocre out there now although it does what it does what it does very well it still just doesn't have that extra edge to stick its kind of head above the pack really um and that's more of a personal opinion than a lot of these other ones next up i have unlock now unlock was um i suppose a couple years ago now these escape route room type games really did blow up reached uh tremendous popularity and initially i recall playing the first box of unlock and just being absolutely just amazed with what this game did
you know that mix of the puzzles and escape room with the small narrative going through playing through on the app and using the puzzles on the app i thought it was amazingly well done just simple um and just well implemented then i played some of the other ones and some of the other puzzles fell so flat for me that it left quite a sour taste in my mouth i mean some of the the highs and lows of these puzzles just are just huge and i think the level of consistency just isn't there to a point where i think playing a new one is just a massive gamble for me um i think the genre in general is it getting a bit tiresome for me anyway but i would say that games like exit do what unlock does better than unlock um but yeah it was a matter of losing its trust for me i particularly recall the the cowboy based um scenario and i just absolutely hated it it just fell so flat uh i don't think anybody enjoyed it some of the puzzles just didn't quite make sense the story just didn't quite add up it wasn't fun and um i just wanted it to end and for that reason um it's just left the whole genre particularly the unlock series as being quite tainted in my mind and um my my desire to play these unlocked games has just gone and i won't i won't be buying another one maybe if somebody suggested playing one of those i would i would do so but i won't be spending my own money on those games and that's why uh unlock is at number six and number five i have
code names now codename's probably one of the most popular modern board games out there um a party based game two teams are competing against each other try and help their team locate where all that their certain words on this 5x5 grid great concept uh worked really well again had had a lot of success in my initial board gaming years um but this was a matter of having a number of games that turned south quite quickly i think the the rules themselves leave a lot to interpretation well at least in the minds of the players um i always found that players when around the rules in terms of giving their teammates clues and different little tells in terms of choosing what their word's going to be um and that personally frustrated me being a bit of a rules lawyer which i apologize for um but the i thought that there was a number of games that came out after codenames that did what codenames does a lot better than codenames does games like the crypto games like cross clues and cross words i find those so much more fun and release a lot of that horrible play attention and also putting players on the spotlight like or under the spotlight like codenames does you know a lot of players aren't comfortable just sitting there having to give their clues to their teammates and the analysis process can go in the downtime in between turns can drag on a bit too long particularly you know if you don't want to use the timers which a lot of people don't like that pressure anyway so i thought there's just too many
obstacles and too many little things that just stopped at being as enjoyable as it should be and ultimately new games have replaced it for that reason and you know i i would never want to play this probably again i would play it again because i know people are so familiar with it but i would always recommend the other games over it and i just don't enjoy it nearly as much as i used to for those reasons uh next up i have emo tepe uh emo tech i'm not sure if it was a speeder jars winner or a nominee a few years ago this one mechanically simple game as you're collecting these different bricks and putting them on ships and sending them off to these different action cards in order to score different points such as scoring the highest obelisk or um building pyramids and things really cool concept again mechanically streamlined by a great designer in phil walker harding initially i started quite highly on this one i thought it was a really nice family weighted game easy to explain and had some interesting decisions then uh the more i played it the more i started to get frustrated with how much your actions were taken out of your hands um you know your whatever you did because you'd load these boats and with your stone putting them in any order you want you basically sacrifice your turn and lay up or lay it up for somebody else to sell that ship to a place that you didn't want to go and i understand that's part of the fun but it got to a point where no matter what you placed on you'd never ever end up going where you wanted to go um because it was always in the you know in the best interest of the
other players to sell you away to somewhere else rather than to help themselves and that became a bit a bit tedious for me it became a bit obvious and um again it's that that autonomous autonomy was taken away from the players and it became more of a matter of just screwing your opponent up rather than helping yourself and um the more and more that went on the the more i looked on this game with not the quite the not quite the gays as i did before just wasn't quite enjoyable um and just yeah my my appreciation of it just went down rapidly uh as games went on and um unfortunately that's why uh emo tech is this high on the list uh next up i have um widely acclaimed social deduction game in deception murder in hong kong this one played a lot of times over the years you know really did rack up the play accounts on this one and i think the reason for that one is because for a lot of social deduction games people don't like being put under the pressure and this one did a good job of eradicating that and giving you um quite obvious um scapegoats and alternatives to suggest to the people accusing you it's a game where you are basically trying to one player as a scientist trying to help the other players decipher who the murderer is by giving clues works well in theory the theme works great um the more and more i played this one and particularly towards the end of its life span i started to notice that people weren't enjoying it quite of the aspect they were before um it had a bit of a
meta game in terms of you know previous clues leaning towards certain things and giving people who played it before very strong clues based on that um and the it became more of a process rather than the whole um experience you know just um you know it's that clear therefore i'm going to put it here the here here and here um because of what we've done before um and for that reason the the energy of the game the theme of the game and just the what the game is supposed to provide was just um was just undercut really an undermined to a point where it wasn't that fun anymore um the the creativity of it was just diminishes game front on i think it's one of those games where you want to keep playing it with different people rather than keep playing it with the same people and yeah the reason why i did fall down was because i had too many of those games that just fell flat and um yeah i think i think the lifespan of this game just naturally is gonna it's gonna fall um maybe that's a personal experience but um i'm not well i haven't played this for quite a while now and nobody seems to be missing it let's put it that way next up is captain sonar and this one is probably the perfect example of a game that is super cool great concept of being a submarine vs submarine battle where you have teams of three or four um competing at each other with each other with asymmetrical roles one being the captain one being the kind of the navigator and trying to scope out where your opponents are on this grid trying to use weapons
to shoot and use them in technologies and things really cool concept basically are live action battleships the problem with this game is that the the obstacle of getting this to the table became a huge burden because you'd have to teach basically four different games to eat to two different teams and on top of that the game when it gets going especially if you want to play the full experience of being a real-time game it was so chaotic and people shouting over each other and you know not not respecting um you're stopping at certain points and things it became just a massive headache to teach and to govern and to play and ultimately if everybody wasn't in the experience and playing it and everybody wasn't playing in the spirit of the game it could just very quickly go off the train tracks and i i personally wasn't willing to put in the effort um after so many failed attempts now don't get me wrong i did have a lot of successful games with this one but at this point i'm not really willing to take that kind of scarce game gameplay time and which which is quite valuable to me in a game that's most likely going to fall flat and people aren't going to enjoy and just get caught up in and um just again just goes off the rails too often one too many times for me and um while i still play this maybe in a game club scenario where everybody wants to play it i wouldn't really play this one amongst people who i know aren't so aren't so keen on that chaos and stuff and i personally
am leaning away from that chaotic style game and i think there is any stronger example of that than captain sonar and that's unfortunate because as i said the game itself is extremely strong at least in the concept but just too way too much room for for going wrong uh and finally uh the game that fell um the furthest from grace for me is dead of winter now dead of winter was one of the games i probably played initially in the harvey one of my first board games i got a cooperative game with a the potential of a traitor as you are working together trying to overcome not only the harsh weather conditions the different obstacles thrown at you trying to fight off the zombies and trying to fulfill personal and public objectives great idea and i'm not a massive zombie fan but i did quite like the idea of survival and working together and things but the more and more i played games particularly more mechanically maybe involved games i started to just sit back and look at this game objectively and think what am i actually doing in this game and it became very apparent that all you do is go to a certain location and basically top deck of of a stack of cards trying to get the cards you want um there's a huge veneer of all the zombies going on and the story lines and interactive cards that trigger when certain people do certain things i know that's great but the gameplay itself um again the more experience i got became so apparent that you really aren't doing much in this game and it is pretty lackluster actually when you look at it um as i said just just sneaking off to a location
and basically searching for a bunch of cards to get what you want um and that's not really a good game in my opinion and yeah as more time going on i've as time gone time has gone on i realized that and again initially i voted this seven and a half eight out of ten now i put this probably at about a four drags on way too long and it probably goes on one and a half maybe even two hours plus to play this one and um and not just not for me anymore um i can appreciate why it's so successful a lot of people still do talk highly at this game because of those um thematic tie-ins and you know the the crossroads cars are very clever as people do things and you if they do certain things you read off a bunch of texts and the characters interact with each other and all these things um but again the the gameplay is the sole focus for me and this one just didn't hold up at all um hence why dead of winter is the game i've sailed on the most so um something a bit different here um not not the most positive of videos but sometimes i think it's important to get that balanced aspect not only to talk about the games that i've loved and i have really enjoyed these games but now i don't think so highly of them and i think that's important so uh again i hope you've enjoyed the video if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye