It's Over.. What Happened
Transcript
thank you this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody Welcome to the final installment of the what happened to series now if you've been following this series along in real time you'll know that I'm sort of cutting it one week short although I'm still ending up with 10 videos in the series which was my initial goal to set out now if you're just happening upon this video you don't know what I'm talking about this was a series where I went back to 2010 I went to board game geek looked at the most anticipated games geek list for that year 2010 and in the following week I did 2011 2012 and so on now these geek lists were compiled by a fellow named Rick Vineyard and uh he you know got all the nominations and votes and everything compiled it and he compiled several geek lists after a while I don't remember which year he started doing this but you know we'd have like the top 20 Fantasy games that were anticipated for that year top 20 Euro games top 20 this and that but I was looking at the top 20 overall and so I started like I said in 2010 and worked my way forward so I'll have uh links to all this stuff links to a bunch of geek lists and stuff that I'm going to mention here in the video description uh but I basically started 2010 I did five videos and I kind of paused and did kind of a summary video which I'll have a link to below kind of Midway and one of the things I did was I did not look forward uh to the following
week or the following year until I was done with that year just to try to keep it somewhat you know pure in a sense now of course I've lived through those years and been involved with you know gaming and stuff for those years I had a sense of what they were but you know I didn't really ever specifically recall what was in and not in these different lists so you'll see if you remember from last week it was probably like I would say from my perspective my worst list because there was a few games that I hadn't played you know I wasn't really aware of in a lot of ways until I looked at the 2018 list which was going to be this week's I was going to do 2018 and then 2019 and then maybe a summary video um so and it was it was even worse it was a lot worse it was probably about half of the games I was like what the heck are these things now I did look ahead because I it really gave me a lot of pause I looked ahead of 2019 and then Eve which was going to be my last one was 2019 because I was just going to do 10 years worth and I kind of thought like you know doing 2020 and 2021 that's too recent so there's not really been any you know significant amount of time to process what happened to those years but I went ahead in this case and looked for looked ahead to them and those are much better than the 2018 list at least from my perspective and the problem with the 2018 list in the 2017 list and less so with the 2019 list and definitely less so with 2020 was the rash of kind of one-off
kickstarters that populated the list of anticipated games and I've made mention of this before with the idea that it seems like and I know this is the case I can't speak to specific games in which and did it and which didn't do it um where they drum up support and send their backers to the anticipated geek list and try to drum up the votes which there's nothing wrong with at all I mean that's good Marketing in a way kind of sort of faux Gorilla Marketing it's a little bit disingenuous to say it's like you know viral or organic for sure because it is driven by the publisher directly but that's not to say a certain publisher that doesn't have a Kickstarter could put out a newsletter like Fantasy Flight or GMT games and said hey you know we've got these games coming out this year one of these is nominated for most anticipated go check out the geek listen to vote for it same idea same difference um but in terms of like I said an organic sort of emergence of what is actually anticipated what has kind of caught the collective you know froth and fever for the upcoming year it kind of throws it off it kind of throws those lists off and it kind of taints those lists you know regardless if it's ethical I don't think it's unethical necessarily you know whether or not it's you know it is Sinister in some ways I don't think so maybe a tiny bit right but I will say it does taint the list
because you're trying to you know from my perspective as I'm trying to go through this list and try to get a good sense of okay this was kind of the hotness this is what collectively people kind of wanted and what they were expecting to come out of the year and then see which those kind of lasted it gets a little bit tainted when it's sort of like you know you've got one sort of Behemoth that's just driving their one thousand two thousand three thousand backers to go and check it out when those backers have sort of a financial incentive in a way or some kind of incentive to see the game do well because they've certainly the kickstarter is kind of an investment in a way you know a little bit more than just actually buying a game because those games aren't finished you know when you have a Kickstarter it's nine times out of ten is not complete you know rules aren't complete arc's not finished uh prototypes aren't finished you know the production uh preview copies where the publisher gets a copy checks out the components that stuff's not finished so it's a little bit there's a little bit of an investment mindset there and so I think it really threw off instead of making a video of like me going well I don't want to know this game I don't know this game this game is no longer around and what is this nonsense you know this looks terrible uh which some of them did now there's some good games on you know even the 2018 list like I said about half the games are really great I remember barrages on there um that's all I want to sticks out but uh there's a lot of other ones too that were on there um that uh that are still around still popular so myself in my collection barrage being one of those so there's plenty of good ones too that don't
suffer from this sort of symptom of kind of the kickstarter thing and I was discussing it with some of my media friends about this and I was like man you know this is not a big deal but it kind of ticks me off because I had made this um series and I thought it was an interesting way to kind of look at things I've been getting great feedback from you folks um about it and kind of reminiscing in some ways and kind of you know some of the discoveries just kind of going and looking back at it in this way was kind of interesting you know some things that you know maybe I should have expected that I didn't expect or some things that were definite surprises to lots of people and just you know what lasted what didn't that kind of thing how the Hobbies changed you know over the last like 10 or 12 years or so and some of just the way the Hobby's grown in certain ways and expanded and certain parts of it have shrunk down and different companies have changed all that stuff's been really cool but the one they just kind of irritated me because even though this was kind of part of the discovery was like oh okay things kind of got off the track off the rails around 2017 2018 2019 with the whole Kickstarter like just hype machine in terms of this this from the guys of this list now we can get into other ways that you know people do have problems with Kickstarter in a way some I think are valid and some aren't but the process of that
still bugged me and I was I told this to some of my media friends but I was kind of debating like I don't want to like come out and make a video and be all worked up about it because it's just board games you know but it's also like the other side of that coin is like it's just board games it's like who cares like and I don't want to make a video where like no I don't really care anymore about this you know this particular angle that I was going on because that's pretty boring but I thought it was there was an interesting takeaway and I'm not going to go in too much longer about it and uh one of my buddies brought up the point of like uh kind of in an unrelated conversation but it it rung true here where the way that we're first exposed to games has really changed over the last 10 years and 20 years with the internet being the first way that people are exposed to games and then you know Kickstarter and game found and all that stuff um being now the way that people are a lot of times first exposed to a game you're not like demoing the game at a convention or a game store or a buddy's house or whatever or reading about it or like even even in the last like 10 years like watching a video about it maybe or reading a review and then checking it out now it's like the way you get at it before it's kind of gone through some of those hoops and stuff it's travel that's been produced it's been vetted it's been all this stuff now your first exposure is this glitzy one page spread on a
crowdfunding uh page and the the interesting thing about it as I went through today and was looking at different Kickstarter projects and game found projects and Backer it uh projects and I'm like these all look the same they have this there's a type you have the sort of the the big old graphics for the uh the bylines that people like reviewers like me and stuff will give you've got the videos and it's always like the same people on there doing the videos in the previous is like these people like aren't every Kickstarter doing every preview and it's like the same like six to eight people doing preview videos and I'm like God this is the same and then the way the stretch goes and the add-ons and all that stuff is displayed like there's different color schemes and there's different like motifs but the layout is the exact freaking same and it's just the same like beat and repetitive uh program and I'm like ah it's like a machine and so I was listening to a I'm going to come back to the point here I was listening to a podcast talking about artificial intelligence and there was two interesting things and these are interesting regardless of what we're talking about so there's two kind of metaphors on there talking about AI and one was this paperclip analogy where you build an AI that is so uh uh proficient and so like elegant and just has so much ability but without any real rules it's just to build the most general of AI what it'll
end up doing this is like a thought experiment is it will take and convert every spare atom in the universe to this elegant form of a paper clip just pick a random object that's kind of like you know swirly elegant thing so this AI gets going kicks on and then the whole universe is one giant cluster of paper clips because the eye doesn't really have any morals right or any bounds or any sort of common sense you know Common Sense in the sense of a collective like hey we expect the world to be this way so that's interesting so okay but that's also very extreme so if you also though if you programmed an AI that was very efficient and you said Okay I want to program some machine or robot to give me coffee every day and that was its only purpose was to go and get you coffee at all costs so what would happen is the robot would go and get you coffee but then on the way back to giving you the coffee maybe it ran over your dog or maybe it took a chunk out of the house because something has happened to kind of throw it off its routine its pattern but it's going to give you the coffee and you can guarantee that but you can't guarantee all these other parameters now obviously you'd want to program the thing smart enough to account for that and or not give it all the capabilities to make it able to do much outside of that and I felt like with the whole Kickstarter thing the ease of it the ease of creating a Kickstarter page the you know relative ease because it's not completely easy because you got to
come up with nice Graphics you got to come up with a good plan a good idea for a game probably a decent design but the ease of putting that kind of page up and then getting interaction getting feedback and you know backers to back it it's just so Dynamic and so easy to do and it kind of feeds itself and there's been enough successful successes and enough really good kickstarters I mean I look over here at dead reckoning I happen to really enjoy that anken blood rage and stuff up here great kickstarters in my opinion um and lots of other things like that so you've got enough good ones rising up there they're kind of pulling the rest of this junk up and that feedback loop I think the data of the last several years proves out that there is somewhat of a problem there because it the number of games that come out every year are just insane they keep going up even like through this pandemic and everything like gaming just keeps growing and growing and growing and the ease of getting it done is both a double-edged sword it's a curse and a blessing because you're able to get it done and get it out there and because of things like Panda game Manufacturing in a lot of places like that that work directly with um Kickstarter producers and stuff and it's it's very easy to get into because a couple of years ago I did like a podcast about when I interviewed uh
Panda game manufacturing and the whole process of that like it's pretty easy to do like the logistical part of it now never mind all the shipping snafus of the last year or two um but the whole process is pretty pretty easy to do so the nice thing about Kickstarter was there was a way to break through the traditional Gatekeepers for certain types of games so for example a game like gloomhaven which is the number one game on boardgamegeek.com let me say it again the number one game of all time you know that's an opinion that's my opinion I hear it's not my favorite game but collectively it's the number one game of all time and just to be clear I think it's a good game because somebody called me on another video said I was bashing glooming I'm like well I'm just not my favorite game um and um I'm kind of I'm kind of short-circuiting in that conversation but it's the number one game of all time on Board Game Geek it would not have existed without Kickstarter it just would not have there's no way the designer publisher Isaac Childress would have taken it to who would he have taken it to say I have this giant game with 90 quests the box is like this big you know it's gonna weigh 25 pounds make this and produce it and people will buy it from you for at the time 120 bucks excuse my phone so coming to my kind of final two points
of this I just wanted to to talk about because I don't want to get the one thing I didn't really want to happen was get into too much of a kick discussion about Kickstarter because I'm not like anti-kickstarter anti-game found anti-any of the stuff um but I think there's a little bit of like a runaway train with some of that stuff that's you know uh it's just kind of out of control in some ways so there's okay let's set that aside though so there's two things I want to bring up one was I did actually email Rick Vineyard or geekmail Rick Vineyard because he stopped doing his list and I was curious why that was I didn't know if it was because of the pandemic because you could really um you know tell when a game is going to come out even more than before because even before pandemic you know it's that game was coming out in 2015 it wouldn't come out until 2017 you know or even later so with the pandemic and the production kind of stopped it's probably very hard to make that list and do it in such a way that was concrete um but I noticed he didn't do 2022 there's no 2023 list which would have started right around now looking forward to next year maybe the shipping stuff there's a reason or maybe he saw what he caught what I kind of see at the last couple where it's like this is a bunch of Kickstarter backers coming to pump their game I don't want to be a part of that I don't know what it was so he doesn't do the lists anymore but he never replied to my geekbound so um but that was the interesting thing I was like oh why isn't he doing the list anymore because they stopped
um so I'm very curious if he ever sees this video if he would answer that or if somebody knows because they couldn't find a post or anything that mentioned anything about why he stopped or anything um so that's the one to leave that there and the second one is I want to kind of turn it back to you folks the viewers and say okay so what exactly gets you hyped to put something on your anticipated list I mean it's got to be kind of this old standby it's the designer if you're a Stefan Feld fan you see a Stefan fell game come out you're like up let me look at that if it's it's an if it's in a theme or a universe if you're like a dune fan and a new Dune game comes out or zombie side fan your zombie side game comes out you know what gets you hyped there or is it like I mean there's nothing wrong with this like do you see something with like a lot of cool Miniatures and you're like okay that looks like a really cool game fair enough I'd really like painting miniatures I'd like to paint those because that's one thing I don't really want to get it bugs the crap out of me when I see some other influencers or content creators whatever like C Miniatures and then just like on the game because of that because you know you don't know what you're talking about because painting is a joy to like tons of people millions of people and that's part of the process now if the game is not your most well-balanced Carnegie brass barrage Talus game doesn't matter it doesn't doesn't matter to those people it doesn't matter to me all the
time um anyway a little tangenty little little little kind of rough Edge there but um it put that certainly back to if you see a game with Miniatures and you're like those look rad I want those miniatures I don't really actually care if the game is that great because I really like painting is that something that that you like because I want that to be an okay thing to say here because it is 100 okay to say that or what is it you know what I mean like is it when you look at a game do you want to see a game play video you're like oh that looks like some cool mechanics on the other side of the coin here that's some new way of doing like supply and demand you know management and this kind of stuff or do you want would you look for something like in terms of Kickstarter do you want some bang for your buck so if you could spend the two to three hundred dollars you want to get this big experience um and I'll just talk real quickly here about um a game oath sworn which you will see on this channel soonish um actually at the time recording this we're going to play it this week again that was one that I actually looked at and I was like oh man this looks pretty cool but it looked like a lot of other kickstarters I was like yeah this looks like a little different but I've been you know foaming once fool me twice and again the kickstarter page of the kickstarter experience looks the same I was like yeah but then okay then it ended it went on and then I saw more stuff about it um I don't know several months ago and I was like Ugh I should have back that this looks actually pretty cool now serendipitously publisher reached out
and said hey do you want to review copy and I never reply to an email so fast in my life I was like oh yeah this looks great and the game just you know spoiler for the review it's it's so far it's panned out really well it looks it's really cool um so um that's the kind of one that I was tempted by and it's one of those words like you get this big experience and it's I think it's reasonably priced for what you get and they have a few different modes I don't want to get too modern and specifics but if that's something you look forward to like I think that's also okay you're like you know what I don't buy that many games a year you know whatever maybe you've got tons of money no big deal but you know I want to when I go in for something I want to go to this big experience like you like a Kingdom Death you know or something or you want a big whole thing so when you get that you're going to play that game for months you know and and is that the kind of thing so I'm just trying to poke at some different things that what gets you like fired up when you see something and you're like you want to go afterwards like mechanics a theme components you know uh whatever anything I I can I can think of a few things for me but it's very hard when I take a look at my collection to kind of put my finger on it and I think maybe maybe that's the case for a lot of you too or it's like there's this this Confluence of components not game components but like all these different parts that go into making a game make me go oh okay that looks cool and you know sometimes you can get
fooled or it's just you know it's just a mistake you don't realize it because it's all First Impressions anyway um I mean even after you've played it once you can still play it again and be like actually I don't like this you know um but it's hard to really quantify all of those little pieces and uh and that's one of the things about games in general is they're very much a sum of their parts right because mechanics is great but if it looks like a prototype yeah some people may not care other people might be like I don't know I like to be kind of entertained visually and tactically tactically not tactically tactically and tactily and all the things that that is part of of life it's part of the gaming experience all of those different senses are kind of in play there so it's hard to kind of stir that pot up and try to come up with a good sort of mixture you know for what makes the game good or makes it exciting to look at and stuff so anyway I just wanted to kind of talk about that um and just kind of realize and try to just try to think about it and maybe there's a vlog in the future or something I'm kind of wearing my kind of writer's block on my sleeve here um and uh because it was just like I hit this point and I was like man this is just this list sucks this 2018 list really sucks the 2019 list was in that it was better
not much better 2020 was good you know but then of course you know everything went away after that um and so yeah I just I wanted to just kind of it's kind of a short circuited end to this series but you know um it's been interesting to kind of see this process and see all of the different ways that gaming can kind of do things you know um the ex the experience of my last like decade or so in the hobby has been very interesting um you know I don't want to bore because the people that watch the channel a lot you're like yeah we know where you've been um but yeah it's just interesting to me just all of these things and it's it really is not suited too much to critique in a way anyway sorry that's it I'll leave that and so I'm gonna stop this series now thank God and then I'll get back to the reviewing some games again I got a little stack uh lined up here so anyway thanks for hanging in there and uh thanks for putting up with it uh it was interesting kind of a little experiment so thanks foreign