How to make a board game FUN with Gabe Barrett
Transcript
what's up my friends Gabe here and I just want to tell you about my new book that recently came out called find the fun this is the culmination of I don't know 15 plus years of game designing experience and Publishing experience now and also just distilling down 300 plus episodes of the board game Design Lab podcast and putting it all into one book the book that I wish I had when I first got started designing games and we dive into obviously fun and talking about how to find the fun and all the things that go along with that lots of different principles and little kind of formulas trying to you know some metaphors trying to help that all make sense also talk a lot about product design and what it look like looks like to create not only a game but a product that people will want to buy that you can pitch to Publishers that you can put on crowdfunding and make money uh talk a lot about play testing talk a lot about prototyping just everything that goes into the game design and creation process from idea all the way to being able to get it published now I don't talk about business or you know LLC or crowdfunding and and that kind of thing but everything else as far as creating the game and bringing it to life putting it on people's tables so that they can enjoy it and so I just want to tell you about it you can find it on Amazon right now I just check out the links down below if you want to learn more I'm also going to put the first few chapters of the book uh at the end of this video I hired a professional voiceover guy to do the audio book version and so I'm going to put the first few chapters here and so you can check those out listen to them and just see if it's something that
you're interested in but yeah find the fun really proud of this one wanted to let you know about it and if think if you think it's something that you would get a lot of value out of please check it out thanks for being part of the board game Design Lab community and have an excellent day find the fun written by Gabe Barrett read by Adam Nano section one getting started I'm so glad you've decided to travel down the game design path it takes a ton of effort but with a little creativity a healthy dose of problem solving and some good oldfashioned hard work I know you can bring your games to life and my goal is to be a helpful guide in your journey now this book isn't meant to be an exhaustive resource it's more of a curation of my best advice taken from designing games for 15 plus years and interviewing more than 300 of the best designers in the world through the board game Design Lab podcast this is the book I wish someone had handed me years ago when I was just getting started and I hope I can help you not waste time on as many dumpster Fire Games as I did you're still going to create some truly awful games that's just part of it but the information in these pages should help you level up your design skills at a much faster rate than I was able to this introduction will lay the foundation for the Core Concepts you need to understand and the rest of the book will reinforce the concepts from various angles so let's get into
it what is a board game really the traditional definition of board game is pretty self-explanatory a game that involves moving pieces on a board in recent years the term has evolved to become a catchall and even games that don't include a board now fall under the board game umbrella however for the purposes of this book that's not really what I'm talking about boards cards dice Etc are just components mere ingredients that can be turned into something much greater than the sum of its parts in the same way you wouldn't say eggs sugar and butter are a cake you wouldn't say cardboard Dice and meeples are a board game what matters is how you put them together to create an experience for the players to put it simply a board game is a fun engine players put time into it and get fun out of it so as a designer your main job is to maximize the time to fund ratio now that's obviously easier said than done but hopefully this book will help you start figuring out what it takes to create a fun engine that players enjoy and that you can turn into a marketable product but anytime you see the word game in this book just know that what I'm really saying is fun engine for years I designed games that worked but weren't particularly fun however once I started to understand games as fun engines my designs got a ton more enjoyable to play so even if
that's the only concept you take away from this book I think it'll level up your design skills by Leaps and Bounds what makes a game fun when you're starting out you should aim to make a game that works the game should have a clear beginning middle and end the player should be able to understand how to win and the player's decisions should move the game forward and ultimately to a defined finish now a lot of new designers do all of that and think they're done however a game that works is not necessarily a proper fun engine to make a game that's fun you need to understand two main factors choices and attension a game can have amazing art unbelievable Miniatures linen finish cards and the most well-written rulebook you've ever laid eyes on but if it doesn't have meaningful choices and the right amount of tension it's not going to be particularly fun in the next chapter I'll dive much deeper into choices and tension I'll unpack Concepts like the choice Trident and the Goldilocks decision space and I'll get into various ways you can find the fun in your game I'm mentioning this stuff briefly in the introduction since fun is probably the most important concept I'll discuss hence the title of the book and I want you to go ahead and put it at the top of your your mind what makes you a game designer I've talked to so many new designers who
don't yet consider themselves to actually be game designers typically they think that to become a legitimate card caring member of the club they need to get a game published but trust me that is definitely not the case a game designer is simply anyone who designs games don't over complicate it and don't feel less than just because you don't have a game on a store shelf I've played prototypes that were amazing but never got picked up by a publisher I've played published games that weren't worth the cardboard they were printed on there are so many factors at play and a lot of them are arbitrary so don't get caught up on having to be published or any other random qualifier the being comes from the doing or put more simply you are what you do a writer is someone who writes a painter is someone who paints a game designer is someone who designs games so the real question isn't are you a game designer that's a given the real question is how good can you be and my goal throughout the rest of this book is to help you become as good as possible it takes a tremendous amount of work to become good at any creative Endeavor but I believe you have it in you to bring some amazing games to life don't prove me wrong what does a win look like before we go any further it's important to take some time to Define what you really want when
it comes to game design what does a win look like do you want to design games as just a hobby but you don't really care if you ever get anything published do you want to design games that eventually show up on store shelves but it's just a side hustle do you want to pursue game design as a profession either part-time or full-time there's no wrong answer but each path has different requirements and calls for a different level of sacrifice I encourage you to be honest with yourself about what you really want and to think through how much you're willing to commit to that path we often wonder why we feel like we're losing when the real problem is that we haven't defined what winning is so what do you want write it down what are you going to have to do to get there what are you going to have to give up write those down too then get to work why designing games is important several years ago one of the most important people in my life found out he had cancer his name was Randy and he was an incredible mentor and an excellent friend and during his battle with cancer he discovered a little game called Ticket to Ride one day I went over to his house and he asked if I had ever heard of the game I laughed and told him once or twice then we sat down and played it Randy played Ticket to Ride hundreds of times over the next couple of years he'd come home from chemo and played friends
and family would come over to visit and he'd introduce them to it he played it literally until he couldn't hold his head up anymore and just before they lowered his casket into the ground his daughter placed a small red plastic train on it Ticket to Ride brought my friend a tremendous amount of Joy during his time toughest times and darkest days and a while back when I met Alan Moon the designer of the game I was able to thank him for creating something that made my friends final days just a bit more bearable I don't know about you but I want to create things that bring people Joy like that and this is a prime example of how much games matter I know it can sometimes feel like game design is a waste of time there are so many problems in the world and we're just cutting out tokens and trying to figure out if a card should do two damage or three I mean really but please understand it's so much deeper than that board games are different from other forms of entertainment because they're about a lot more than just sitting and absorbing content instead games give players an active role in determining how the experience is going to play out they give people the opportunity to not only enjoy a story but also have an impact on how that story gets told that means game designers are storytellers to the highest degree because what we're really creating is opportunities for others to tell great stories we bring people together around
a table to experience something that will hopefully build relationships and create lasting memories so whenever you find yourself asking does this even matter the answer is yes all artistic Expressions come with their fair share of tough days and designing board games is no different but in those moments just remind yourself that games matter and they have the ability to improve people's lives and just remember the impact a game had on my friend Randy how to get ahead of a 99% of other designers most game designers and creative people in general never make it out of the land of mediocrity and never realize their true potential for one simple reason they give up typically this is because they know how their game should play in their head but they can't turn that into reality on a table and that's because people develop taste before skill in other words they know what's good long before they can actually create something good then because of the very large and obvious gap between where they are and where they want to be they quit and move on to the next shiny object without ever realizing how much of an amazing designer they had it in them to be this gets even worse when they start comparing their prototypes to other designers published games but if there's any absolute truth I've ever learned it's this comparison is the thief of Joy the world has no shortage of
opportunities to compare yourself to others and feel like you're less than or behind but for one thing you don't know the whole story you don't have any idea what someone went through or didn't have to go through to bring that game to life and for another thing it doesn't even matter anyway the race is long and in the end it's only against yourself so don't measure yourself against other designers measure against a previous version of yourself are you a better designer than you were a year ago are you learning a new skill today that's going to make you better tomorrow if not why not what can you do to get better if so keep going keep finding ways to improve and push yourself forward but the main thing is to just keep designing those three simple words are the key to you becoming the designer you have the potential to be there's simply no substitute for reps if you want to get better you have to put your reps in to put it in Fitness terms if you want to develop a stronger lower body you should do more squats thinking about squats won't make you stronger reading about squats won't make you stronger posting online about squats won't make you stronger you have to do the actual work and it's the same with game design so many designers never really get out of the planning stage they have ideas but they never create a prototype they
never run a single play test unfortunately it's super easy for planning to become procrastination it seems like you're making progress as you research various topics and scribble down notes about dice driven combat and possible worker placement Loc ations while this feels like movement it's really like being stuck in the mud your tires might be spinning 100 miles an hour but you aren't going anywhere so how do you make sure you don't end up there like so many other designers you make a prototype you play test and you repeat it's just that simple and it's just that hard if you aren't doing those two things you aren't actually going anywhere and your game will never be more than an idea bouncing around in your head in later chapters I'll share my best advice on prototyping and play testing but if you don't turn that information into action this is all a waste of time two of the best things you can learn are to make ugly prototypes and to play test terrible versions of your games the better you get at these two things the better designer you'll become and you'll find yourself much further down the design road than all of the designers who stay stuck in the mud as James Clear says Rome was wasn't built in a day but they were laying bricks every hour you have enough time over the years I've had conversations with thousands of game designers and the number one struggle they bring up over and over again is
never having enough design time and I get it life is busy everyone has more to do than they have time to do it in family friends work sleep traffic cat videos there's no shortage of things to occupy your time however something that radically changed my life was the realization that I always have just enough time for the things I make time for it's not about having time it's about making time so I started putting game design into my weekly schedule and then I protected that time on certain days at certain hours I scheduled specific activities that were going to move my games forward I also took this approach with the board game Design Lab podcast which is how I released an episode 300 plus weeks in a row and after the schedule was made I died on those Hills my friends and family knew not to bother me on those days and times unless someone was bleeding from the head I wasn't going to budge from my workspace another pivotal moment was when I stopped saying I don't have time and started saying it's not a priority it's amazing how much of a difference that small semantic tweak makes instead of saying I need to play test but I don't have time it became I need to play test but it's not a priority that phrase was just an incredible gut P punch and it helped me refocus it also placed the weight squarely on my shoulders which is where it belonged I don't have enough
time put the blame on external factors it was the universe's fault but it's not a priority was on me this also helped me get clear on what my priorities really were there were moments when I would say something wasn't a priority and I would realize that it really wasn't the value of that kind of thing cannot be overstated but my main point is that you have enough time it's just a matter of what you're currently prioritizing the average person spends four to six hours a day consuming online content social media Netflix YouTube Etc so if you happen to be an average person that's about 5 hours per day you could probably repurpose manage your energy more than your time even if you're the best time manager in the world if you show up to your design space physically mentally emotionally or spiritually exhausted you're probably not going to get much done for your creativity to be at its best you have to have energy for it to pull from this means it's better to have a little time and a lot of energy than a lot of time but little energy an energetic 20 minutes is much more productive than a laxidasical 2 hours so managing your energy through getting enough sleep eating healthy foods controlling stress exercising regularly Etc will make the biggest impact in your game design Journey a life in shambles
can be useful if you're writing music but it's not particularly helpful when you're designing a worker placement game and yes this is common sense but unfortunately living it out isn't particularly common on a near-weekly basis game designers tell me they struggle to find or make time for game design however the truth is they're not properly taking care of themselves which leads to low energy levels overall and tends to manifest as lowest common denominator living which usually consists of scrolling their phones for hours on end and if these designers myself included were more intentional with their energy limited time would be much less of a factor the most cre creative and productive days I've ever had as a designer weren't the days that I had the most time they were the days that I felt like I had been shot out of a cannon because I was optimizing my energy it's called Flow State not float State getting into a design flow is active and requires constant adjustments and pivots in what you're doing and thinking which requires energy you're not just floating along randomly bumping into good ideas and when you're tired or hangry or stressed or Worse flow becomes float and you end up more likely to waste a bunch of time scrolling through social media than actually being productive so yes be intentional with your schedule and make time for game design as best you can but be even more intentional with your energy there are
few things that have made a bigger impact on my own ability to bring games to life and to Market and I have a feeling you might experience similar results habits not goals several years ago I spent some time trying to figure out what I wanted to accomplish as a game designer what did I want my life to look like what types of games did I want to make what kind of community did I want to build what skills did I need to learn Etc I figured that if I could get a decent idea of where I wanted to go I would work my way backwards to effectively reverse engineer the path I wanted to take I knew I wanted to go Pro in the gaming industry and I wanted most or all of my income to be generated through things related to designing and Publishing games so I put together a plan that would hopefully make that happen however that plan didn't include any goals now I'm not saying there's anything wrong with setting goals and if that works well for you then please don't let me stop you but one of the main things I learned from playing sports for most of my life is that building habits is far more important than setting and chasing in goals so I didn't set a goal to get a game on a store shelf or run a successful crowdfunding campaign instead I thought through the habits I needed to develop that would make success inevitable designing games and bringing them to Market would just be a side effect generated by the habits I would cultivate daily these habits included
things like working on something design related every day running a weekly play test interviewing at least five people per month to learn more about specific topics Etc and because of the habits I built over the course of several years I eventually made games my full-time job however that actually felt less like an accomplishment and more like a regular Tuesday it was just a natural byproduct of how I was approaching each day week and month of my life and I didn't know exactly when it would happen but I knew I was on a trajectory to get there eventually now your mileage may vary with this type of approach and I know lots of people who prefer the highs and lows of chasing goals but personally I continue to enjoy the steady grind of habit formation and optimization and find it to be far more helpful to get where I want to go so what habits do you need to start or stop what habits would help you get where you want to go in your own design Journey what habits would make success inevitable now what all right I realized this opening chapter is a bit existential and more about setting yourself up for Creative success than about game design specifically however I wanted to start things off with the general Core Concepts I think you need to understand if you really want to design great games people love but now let's start diving a bit deeper into various aspects of bringing a game to life what's your best advice for how a
designer can make a fun game quote game design is not a science there's no fixed to methodology or a tick list that will lead to Great designs game design is an art and each artist has their own style rher Kenia section two designing a game chapter 2 where to start the first stage of game design can be the most exciting but also the most challenging usually something will spark anide idea and make you think that would be a cool game but then what turning an idea into a playable experience can seem like a Monumental task and it's often so overwhelming to think about that many people just leave the idea in their heads so this section aims to guide you through the initial steps of the game design process providing a solid foundation for your creative Journey where to start the best thing thing you can do is simply start getting ideas out of your head write down everything that comes to mind write down the bad ideas that you'll erase later write down placeholder ideas to bridge the gap from one thought to another don't hold anything back and don't worry so much about organization or critiquing your ideas there will be plenty of time for that later just get as many thoughts out
as possible once they're out you can start figuring out everything else and remember that most great writers are actually great rewriters and in the same way most great game designers are actually great redesigners to help get you started here are some things to think about write down Andor do as you flesh out the design number one identify your vision and goals the first step in designing a game is to clarify your vision what kind of experience do you want to create what emotions or themes are you aiming to evoke are you designing the game for fun to share with friends or do you have aspirations for commercial success your goals will influence many decisions down the line establishing your game's purpose helps guide your design choices and keep your project focused also set realistic goals for example if you're just getting into game design it's unlikely you'll be able to create an epic 4-Hour Space Opera type game and taking on more than you can handle might leave you pretty discouraged and frustrated my first design was a zombie game with a massive board and a ton of characters who all had asymmetrical and unique abilities fun fact the game was called fortnite because you had to survive for 2 weeks this was about a decade before a certain video game came out but I don't think I could use that title now I managed to make the first
prototype and run a play test but I quickly realized that my ideas were were much bigger than my current design ability and I had no idea how to fix the 100 issues wrong with the game after that first test I sheld the game and never came back to it instead I started trying to make much smaller shorter games of course those ideas were also way too big and it would be a while before I managed to actually finish a design luckily I'm a very stubborn and sometimes creatively obsessive person so I refuse to let all that early failure and discouragement run me off however a lot of people run into that first brick wall and turn around and walk away I chose to keep slamming my head into it for a while but you can set yourself up for success by having realistic expectations and setting attainable goals that line up with your current aptitude in the wise words of Ira Glass nobody tells this to people who are beginners I wish someone told me all of us who do creative work we get into it because we have good taste but there's this gap for the first couple years you make stuff it's just not that good it's trying to be good it has potential but it's not but your taste the thing that got you into the game is still killer and your taste is why your work disappoints you a lot of people never get past this phase they quit most people I know who do interesting
creative work went through years of this we know our work does have this special thing that we wanted to have we all go through this and if you're just starting out or you're still in this phase you got to know it's normal and the most important thing you can do is do a lot of work put yourself on a deadline so that every week you will finish one story it is only by going through a volume of work that you will close that Gap and your work will be as good as your Ambitions and I took longer to figure out how to do this than anyone I've ever met it's going to take a while it's normal to take a while you've just got to fight your way through taste comes before skill that's why you can play a game and see how good it is long before you can create a game that's good so don't get discouraged just keep going keep designing keep learning and growing and figuring out how to bring your ideas to life number two Define your audience who are you designing the game for understanding your target audience is crucial different players seek different experiences some prefer strategy heavy games While others enjoy casual party games consider age range interest and the complexity level of your audience tailoring your game to its intended players increases the likelihood of creating an engaging and successful game and please don't say everyone a
game for everyone is a game for no one and even if you manage to design and finish such a game it'll likely be pretty forgettable since a game for everyone has to be incredibly generic when I'm first starting a new design I create a game avatar for it I write down all the specifics about the ideal player I'm aiming at and this gives me a great decision filter throughout the design process I would much rather create something that is a small group of people's favorite game and hated by others instead of creating something that people in general think is just okay and forget about it 15 minutes later so in my game Avatar document I put things like enjoys rolling dice only has 30 minutes to play has young kids so can only play one or two player games loves dramatic endings Etc and this helps me guide the design to line up with who the game is for the Avatar is always subject to change but writing down what my ideal player and customer wants provides helpful guard rails as I make changes and slowly bring the game to life number three Inspirations and examples as you immerse yourself in the world of board games and play a wide range of games to understand various mechanisms themes and what makes a game enjoyable you'll find a NeverEnding stream of ideas and inspiration and if you're like me you'll find yourself breaking down games and thinking through
ways to repurpose mechanis and change things according to your own methods and style when I'm writing down my initial vision for a design I'll often see several games that I'm drawing inspiration from and the specific things about those games that get me excited for example I might put pandemic the game's tension increases over time leading players to a dramatic finish or Dominion the card Market is different every game which leads to more replayability the inspiration could be mechanical thematic experiential or a combination of all three but writing down The Inspirations for a game can be super helpful as I work through the design process and it's especially helpful when the game has been on the shelf for a while and I come back to it later after I started designing games I realized that I can no longer simply play games every game night became an opportunity to do research on what works and what doesn't and it helped me to keep up with industry Trends and see where my game ideas might fit in the current market but what made the research extra helpful was writing down my experiences and creating a system that made it easy to reference back to later four the core concept something I learned later in my design journey is to start with a simple core concept or mechanism that will be the centerpiece of the game this could be a unique gameplay mechanism a
compelling story or an Innovative theme but the core concept should be engaging enough to build the rest of the game around it's basically the game's hook it's the first thing you would tell a gamer to make them want to learn more about the game from a marketing standpoint it's the thing you would put in an ad that would get someone to stop scrolling so what is it about your game that's different and interesting you don't have to come up with something hyper Innovative that's never been done before or anything but what makes your game stand out against the rest remember simplicity at this stage is key and complexity can be added later but figuring out the game's core concept and overall hook will make things so much easier as you bring it to life things are always subject to change of course but at least you'll have a direction to move in five theme what's the game about who are the players why are they competing working together or both where are they when are they they if you already have a mechanism for the game what theme would complement it the answers to these kinds of questions will help you bring the world around the game to life some games are full of lore and backstory and a book worth of Flavor text other games have a theme so thinly pasted on that it runs the risk of coming off with the shrink wrap and either way can work it just depends on the game and experience you're going for but theme helps players
understand their place in the game's world and when done well theme can help players understand how the game works some designers prefer to start with theme and then figure out mechanisms that support that theme other designers prefer a mechanism first approach both methods are viable and it can change depending on the game the key word is start please note that the words theme and setting often get interchanged and used to mean the same thing however they Tech technically different things I was recently chatting with Johnny pack about this topic and this is how he put it theme is what players are doing setting is the overall Place time and genre for example Wild West is the setting robbing banks is the theme outer space is the setting fighting aliens and mining for resources is the theme the Caribbean is the setting being a pirate looking for booty is the theme but more generally we can label theme to Encompass all of this and we tend to all the time in the context of this book anytime you see the word theme just know that I'm referring to both what players are doing and the game's overall setting constantly making the distinction gets long-winded and confusing six mechanisms how does the game work What mechanisms can be intertwined with the theme to bring it to life what systems can you combine or present in
interesting ways what actions do players take on a turn how do players interact with the game and each other the answers to these kinds of questions are all subject to change but go ahead and develop a framework for how the game plays if you're unsure about something just use a placeholder for example I've run play tests for games I knew would have combat but that system wasn't ready so I just flipped a coin to determine who won and then moved on to the next phase of the game there are so many options and it can be hard to determine which mechanism to use I mean there are at least 47 ways you could do worker placement so try a bunch of things and see what works best I like to work on one mechanism or system at a time and then put things together after they work individually for example I'll work on a game's movement system and then spend time on the combat system once those systems work well on their own I'll combine them and figure fig out how they can work together I find this approach to be much easier than trying to create everything all at once focusing on one part of the game at a time helps me gain momentum and score little victories which leads to less overwhelm and a greater likelihood that I'll finish the game overall please note that the words mechanism and mechanic often get interchanged and used to mean the same thing a specific process or system that the game has for achieving an outcome for example some people call deck
building a mechanism While others call it a mechanic however for the purpose of this book and based on my own preference mechanism will refer to a specific system or process in a game while mechanics will refer to all the systems or processes working together seven key moments how do you win how does the game end what are the interesting things a player can do on a turn what helps bring the game to a sad satisfying conclusion the answers to these kinds of questions will ultimately determine your game's overall experience and will often alter your choices for the game's theme and mechanisms I like to start here and then figure out the rest for example if I know I want the game to end with a dramatic standup dice roll I design the rest of the game to lead up to that moment or if I want the players to feel a certain emotion as they play I can be more intentional with my theme and mechanism choices if I want players to feel like they're doing taxes I'll design a Euro game with lots of beige I'm just kidding mostly but when you know where you want to go it's much easier to figure out how to get there eight sculptor or painter there are two types of game designers some are sculptors who begin with a massive chunk of ideas and slowly refine cut and chisel away at things until the game becomes what they want and some are painters who begin with a blank canvas and slowly add things to it
until the game becomes what they want neither type is better than the other it just comes down to personal preference and sometimes changes depending on the project however realizing I was a sculptor made me feel a lot better about my personal design process it's kind of like that old quote about a smart fish thinking it's stupid if it's judged based on its ability to climb trees for a while I thought I was a bad designer because all my games started off as a big chaotic mess that had to be cut down by 75% just to be mediocre why couldn't I just start with a simple mechanism and make a game out of it but after I realized I'm a sculptor and this is simply how my design brain works I became a lot more confident in my process so I hope figuring out which type you are will bring you a bit more confidence as well nine document your process keep keep detailed records of your design process document changes made feedback received and your thoughts during development and don't forget to write down why you made a change I can't tell you how many times I've come back to a design after several months and couldn't remember why certain aspects of the game had been altered then inevitably I make the same mistakes and waste time that could have been saved with a simple note to self if you end up working with a developer or publisher the notes can also be super helpful to them and explain why certain decisions have been
made this could save them time Andor money and potentially get your game on the market faster documenting your process can also be useful later if you decide to create a design diary that you share online people love getting a behind the-scenes look at how a game was created and it can be a more compelling way to Market your game than a social media ad but design Diaries are much easier to write when you already have notes instead of trying to remember everything from the last three years 10 stay organized and patient no matter how many years of experience you have game design is a process that often takes longer than anticipated stay organized set deadlines for yourself and be patient good games take time to develop so set realistic expectations and embrace the process whenever I start to get frustrated or annoyed with how long a game is taking I remind myself that designing games is hard and this is what hard feels like that usually helps me refocus and get back to work 11 engage with the community designing games can feel isolating but it works best when you're involved in a community so join online communities find local gaming groups and attend conventions engaging with Gamers and other designers can provide support advice and networking opportunities learning from and contributing to the community is invaluable for a new game designer and helping others is an excellent way to figure out solutions to
your own design challenges the more you help others the more they want to help you and everyone benefits in a lot of Industries the ladder climbers end up at the top however in the board game Space it's the lad Builders who tend to find the most success if you have a Facebook account I welcome you to join the board game Design Lab Community it's the largest group of designers on the internet and it's the most helpful and encouraging place you'll find conclusion starting your game design journey is about laying a solid foundation and building upon it systematically by understanding your game's Vision knowing its audience iterating based on feedback and staying engaged with the community you can transform your game idea into an enjoyable and Polished final product what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game involve other humans all along the way and observe them playing with humility and empathy when designing be playful and experiment Matt leok chapter 3 protecting your creativity why new game designers shouldn't fear idea theft for many aspiring designers the fear of someone stealing their game ideas can be paralyzing it's an understandable concern after all your ideas are a product of your creativity and hard work however this fear while common is often misplaced and can hinder your growth and development in this chapter we'll
explore why new game designers should focus more on development and less on the fear of idea theft one ideas are just the starting point the first thing to recognize is that an idea in isolation is rarely enough to make a successful game the real value of game design relies in the execution of that idea how it's developed the mechanisms involved the story telling how it engages players the overall experience Etc these elements which are unique to each designer's approach and style are much harder to replicate that means sharing your idea for feedback and Improvement is often more beneficial than guarding it also the greatest idea in the world if poorly executed will be a flop the magic is in how the idea gets brought to life on the table two the board game Community Values originality the board game Community including Publishers and fellow designers places a high value on originality and Creator credit the culture within this community often self- polies against plagiarism and respects intellectual property the industry is also rather small and the reputation of a game publisher or designer would be severely damaged if they were caught stealing which acts as an excellent deterrent three collaboration over competition in many cases sharing your ideas with others can lead to collaboration which can enhance your game's development
feedback from other designers play testers and potential players is invaluable for refining and improving your game holding your idea too close could deprive you of these growth opportunities and stifle your creativity plus it's much easier and more beneficial for a publisher to license your game then steal it four the market is massive the industry is fairly small but the board game Market is vast and diverse with room for tons of ideas and genres the likelihood of your exact idea being stolen and turned into a mass-produced game is effectively zero in most cases similar ideas can coexist in the market each finding its unique audience I think I've seen at least 10 games about mushrooms of all things in the last year and many of them have done rather well they all approach the theme from a a different angle and provide a different experience the designers all started with a similar premise but the final products were vastly different five legal protections are limited but you can do some things to help while it's true that protecting a game legally is challenging as copyright law does not cover ideas or mechanisms there are steps you can take to make theft less likely documenting the development process keeping a design diary and sharing your games Journey online with others makes your game less likely to be plagiarized since it'll be easier to prove it was stolen also your written rules do fall
under copyright so if someone copy pastes the rules from your rulebook you can take action however in 15 years of creating games I've only seen this happen twice and it got called out and rectified almost immediately both times I'm not a lawyer but I firmly believe your focus should be on creating a great game instead of wasting time time and money trying to figure out how to safeguard your idea six the value of sharing and openness sharing your game's development process can lead to Community Support networking opportunities and even potential Partnerships the positive effects of being an active and open member of the game design Community far outweigh the risks of idea theft the initial process of creating a game is often very isolating but the quicker you can get it in front of others and the more ideas and information you can solicit from them the better off your game will be could someone steal your idea in theory Sure but designing without the help of others almost guarantees your idea won't be good enough to be worth selling conclusion while the fear of having your game idea stolen is natural it's important to understand that the path to a successful game design is through development collaboration and Community engagement focusing on these aspects rather than the unlikely event of aidea theft will likely lead to a more fruitful and enjoyable game design experience your unique vision and execution are your true assets what's your best advice for how a
designer can make a fun game play test with varied groups always using the same players will develop the game away from the beginners and will threaten to narrow the appeal even at the top Richard Garfield chapter 4 identifying your game's target audience one of the most critical steps in designing a board game is identifying your target audience knowing who your game is for helps you make informed decisions about its design complexity theme and marketing this chapter will guide you through the process of pinpointing your game's intended players an essential factor in creating a successful and engaging game one Define the player experience start by defining the experience you want to offer is your game a fast-paced party game a deep strategy game or a familyfriendly Activity The Experience you aim to create will largely indicate the type of audience you should Target for example a complex strategy game might appeal to experienced Gamers while a light-hearted easy-to-learn game could be more suitable for families or casual players player experience is the best decision filter you can have once that gets determined everything you do just needs to point back to it if it doesn't point back to it effectively it gets removed two consider age range age can be a significant factor in determining your target audience games designed for
children need to be simple with minimal text and engaging visuals on the other hand games for adults can include complex rules and mature themes and games for families need to find a good mix of complexity to keep everyone engaged also always specify age range on your game as this is one of the first things potential Publishers players and buyers will look for three analyze interest and themes what themes or interest does your game cater to if your game is based around a specific theme such as science fiction historical events or fantasy consider the fans of these genres a game with a niche theme might have a smaller but more dedicated audience while a game with a broad appealing theme could attract a wider range of players but as I said before I think it's better to really lean into a certain audience's preferences and create a game that they love and others hate instead of making something that people in general find just okay and forget about in 15 minutes four determine complexity and length the complexity and play Time of Your Game are crucial in defining your audience casual gamers usually prefer games that are easy to learn and can be played in a short period while hardcore gamers are typically more inclined towards games that offer deeper strategic depth and longer play sessions assess your game's complexity and length honestly to Target the Right
audience if your games play time doesn't line up with your target audience you have to make changes a good game that drags on for too long is no longer a good game but too long is completely up to the people playing it so make sure the game's complexity and length line up with your target audience's expectations five assess learning curve and accessibility consider how easy it is to learn your game a steep learning curve might deter casual players but can be appealing to Gamers who enjoy a challenge learning the rules is the number one barrier to playing a game so make sure the rule book is as clear and easy to absorb as possible a hard- tolearn rule book leads to Gamers playing something else or just watching Netflix also think about the accessibility of your game does it accommodate players with different abilities eyesight limitations Etc this can broaden or specify your audience six look at similar games research games that are similar to yours in theme mechanism or style who are their fans understanding the audience of comparable games can give you insights into who might enjoy your game and how to cater to them however be cautious not to assume assum that your game will attract the exact same audience or sales numbers and from a more philosophical standpoint never forget that comparison is the thief of Joy seven use play testing feedback play testing provides valuable
insights into your target audience notice who enjoys your game the most and ask for feedback directly about who the testers think would like it this real world testing can often reveal audience segments you hadn't initially considered nothing be it's the type of market research you get from people actually playing the game so the sooner you can start getting things in front of people the better eight Define your audience but remain flexible while it's important to Define your target audience stay flexible be open to the idea that your game might resonate with a different group than you initially anticipated sometimes games find Their audience organically and part of the design process is adapting to this discovery I've designed several games that were were targeted at a certain audience but play testing revealed they were much better fits for a totally different group of people when this happens sometimes it means changing the game to be a better fit for the originally intended audience other times it means leaning into the unexpected audien's preferences either path can be successful but the key point is to be intentional with who your game is for conclusion identifying your target audience is a critical part of the game design process it influences many aspects of your game from mechanisms to marketing to everything in between by understanding who your game is for you can tailor Your Design to meet their preferences increasing the chances of your game resonating with its intended players but keep in mind that the
audience might evolve over time and be prepared to adapt your game to meet the needs and expectations of its players what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game know your audence a different games are fun for different types of players knowing the level of mechanics rules and interactions that your target audience wants and can handle will help craft a game that they find fun to play Erica bueras chapter five game design is product design if you want to see your game on store shelves it's essential to recognize that game design is not just a creative Endeavor but also a form of produ product design understanding this and what it means for your game's overall design gives you a much better chance of bringing a game to Market and ensuring its success in this chapter we'll dive into why viewing game design through the lens of product design is beneficial and how it can shape your approach to creating games one understanding the market and audience like any product a board game must meet the needs and preferences of its target market this requires understanding who the game is for what they enjoy and what gaps exist in the current market by researching Trends player preferences and successful games you can design a game that appeals to a specific audience much like a product designed to satisfy a particular
consumer need many designers including myself often start with what game would I like to play and then try to bring it to life being the target audience makes things a bit easier and the design process feels less like a grind not a whole lot less especially by the end but every little bit helps however many starting points are viable and it can even be helpful to begin by thinking about the audience you have in mind even before thinking about the theme mechanism Etc this is where having a specific gamer Avatar as mentioned in chapter one of this section can be a Guiding Light to creating a game that is viable in the marketplace two balancing Crea creativity and functionality in product design functionality and usability are as important as aesthetic appeal similarly a well-designed game balances creative elements like theme story and art with functional aspects such as rules Clarity mechanisms and playability a game that's visually stunning but difficult to play or vice versa may not resonate with players there are outliers of course sometimes A Game's rulebook is a mess or it looks a bit ugly set up on a table but it still sells a lot of copies and finds a fan base however I've learned to never think or assume my game will be an outlier instead I assume that I'm not going to get lucky at all so I need to make sure my game is set up for success in every possible way then lucky breaks
feel like a nice bonus instead of being something I need to succeed people buy games based on how they look but they play games over and over again and recommend them to others based on how they play and with thousands of games coming out every year you'll need to create a game that appeals to Consumers on all levels if you want to sell more than a handful of copies I realize it can be overwhelming to think about theme gameplay Aesthetics Etc all at once so it can be helpful to focus on just one aspect at a time this is also why partnering with a good publisher can be invaluable and I'll go into more detail about that in Section 8 three product considerations product designers must consider manufacturing process materials and costs and these factors are equally vital in game design the quality of components packaging and the overall product value can significantly impact the game's marketability and appeal decisions about the game's components also affect its retail price a crucial factor in the minds of potential Publishers and ultimately the consumers who would be buying the game whether you plan to pitch to Publishers or publish the game yourself having at least a general idea about how much each component in your game costs and designing with those costs in mind is extremely important when it comes to meeting the expectations of your target market a casual game with a $100 price tag probably isn't going to do very well
something I find helpful is to have a specific box size in mind from the very beginning of a design it doesn't have to be down to millimeter or anything but just having an idea of how much physical space I have to work with is super helpful in determining things like card count board size etc for example if I'm designing a $20 solo game that comes in a small box I know my card count maxes out around 100 and I have enough room for a small number of other components like cubes and dice to get a sense of Industry Norms take a look at the box sizes of games on your shelf and in stores and then take note note of how many components fit in there and what the game's cost is in the past most games were sold in physical stores so a lot of Publishers made their game boxes way bigger than they needed to be in an attempt to stand out better on the Shelf however since most games are now sold online most Publishers are choosing smaller boxes to cut down on manufacturing and shipping costs speaking of shipping costs that's another thing to have in mind when creating a game for the marketplace send it's definitely going to be important to potential customers a $20 game that cost $15 to ship is going to be a hard sell so be aware of not only component count but also component weight a question I often ask is does this component justify its cost if adding a certain piece or deck of cards is going to increase the cost to manufacture Andor ship the game it has
to increase the game's perceived value in how it's either played viewed or marketed and perceived is the key word here it's more about the customers perceived value than what an extra component actually means to a game for example the game everdell has a massive cardboard tree that doesn't really do anything other than hold cards but the tree makes the game look incredible and draws players into the game's theme much better than just having the cards spread out on the table four production consideration just as product designers prototype test and refine their products board game designers must do the same through play testing and product testing the play testing process is about identifying and fixing issues in gameplay however it's equally important to test the game as an overall product to ensure it's enjoyable engaging and accessible from the time the player picks up the box to the time they put it away it's about refining the product the game to create the best experience possible I'll go into much greater detail on gameplay play testing in section 4 and it's probably the most important part of the game design process but for now just be aware that testing is about a lot more than balancing mechanisms and tweaking numbers how does the game look on a table how does it look in social media posts how does it fit in the box is it easy and intuitive to set up and put away do the colors cardboard layouts
fonts and components create an accessible experience is the the rule book clear with plenty of examples and Graphics how hard are the rules to learn and teach does the Box open easily but stay closed when you hand it to someone are the components easy to organize Inside the Box are the tokens easy to pick up Etc these are the kinds of questions to be asking as players engage with your game's overall and entire experience a great game that fails as a product is doomed from the start so make sure you're testing every aspect of your game to make it as good as it can be and once you have good data about the overall product make changes don't let Pride or ego get in the way and hamper your game in the process if players are having a hard time setting the game up learning the rules understanding the iconography Etc don't blame them fix the Hang-Ups to make things as smooth as possible if someone chooses to play your game over the near infinite number of other things they could have chosen don't disappoint them especially with something that could have been fixed with a little more work in the testing stage five marketing and branding in product design how a product is marketed and branded plays a critical role in its success and board games are no different effective branding from The Game's name to its visual identity and how its positioned in the market can attract attention and differentiate it
from competitors understanding marketing strategies and channels is crucial for a game's viability and success and this applies to both Publishers and designers I will go into more detail about naming a game later in this section so for now I just want to focus on setting your game up for General marketing success even if you plan to pitch your game to a publisher there are still certain things you can do to help your game have a better chance in the marketplace which will also make it more likely that your game gets signed by a publisher the best thing you can have is a captivating hook that intrigues people and makes them eager to learn more whether it's text based or visual it should compel a person to stop and explore further for example the hook for Scythe from stonem Meer games is Scythe is an engine building asymmetric competitive board game set in an alternate history 1920s period it is a time of farming and War broken hearts and rusted gears Innovation and Valor then combine that with beautiful classic artwork that mixes giant mechs with farmers and it's no wonder the game has sold over a million copies ston Meer takes a similar approach with best-selling game viticulture oldw World Tuscany awaits your wine makinging skill and strategic cunning you'll plant vines Harvest grapes age wines and fill Merchant orders to create the greatest wiery in Italy and then the artwork on the box cover and product shots reinforces this
hook ston Meer games is a great example of how to build a brand with provocative Hooks and attractive artwork combine that with the games being genuinely fun to play and it's no wonder why the company has become such a force in the hobby gaming industry so what's your game's hook does it describe your game's experience and get someone to stop scrolling and want to learn more a good hook opens up a loop in a potential customer's mind that they have to learn more about your game in order to close our brains hate open Loops so what Loops are being opened by your games tagline box art component images mechanisms Etc the better you open the loop the more attention you'll get the better you close the loop the more sales you'll get six Regulatory Compliance and safety all products sold on the open market must adhere to safety standards and regulations and this is true for board games as well ensuring that your game complies with safety standards especially if it's intended for children is an important aspect of the design process this includes using non-toxic materials and ensuring that small parts are not a choking hazard this is something a publisher takes care of at the factory level by paying for product safety testing and the paperwork is required to accompany large shipments when games are clearing customs if you're licensing your game to a publisher this isn't something you need to worry about but if you're in a
game talk to your manufacturer about their process and costs not having the proper paperwork can cause long and costly delays when importing games however at the designer level if you want to create anything that uses non-standard components make sure to do some research on the feasibility from a production level before you travel too far down that design path for example a game that utilizes smell or taste could have some Regulatory and safety issues depending on the country also a game with custom plastic components might also have issues depending on how breakable it is the target audience the materials used to create it Etc the main thing is to understand the possible issues you could run into and to make sure you're checking all the necessary boxes conclusion approaching game design as product design offers a helpful framework for creating games that are not only creatively fulfilling but also Market ready and appealing to your target audience it involves a balance of artistic Vision with practical considerations for functionality production marketing and user experience by understanding and embracing these aspects you can increase your chances of creating a successful game that resonates with players and thrives in a competitive market realizing I was just as much a product designer as I am a game designer was a huge shift in my thinking several years ago and it was one of the main ways I leveled up my ability not only to find the fun but also to be able to effectively share it
with others I hope a similar realization will help you just as much what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game be very clear about the story you wish to tell and try to ensure that the mechanisms you apply serve that story Martin Wallace chapter 6 embracing Simplicity when first getting started started it's natural for designers to be filled with ambitious ideas however one of the key principles in game design is to start simple creating the simplest version of your game before adding complexity can lead to a more refined engaging and ultimately successful game this chapter explores why beginning with Simplicity is a winning strategy in game Design One clarifying core mechanisms starting simple allows you to focus on and refine your game's core mechanism M and it's essential to establish what makes your game unique and enjoyable before adding additional layers this approach ensures that the foundation of your game is solid and that every added element has a purpose and enhances the core experience two identifying and solving problems a simpler version of your game makes it easier to identify and address issues complexity can mask underlying problems making them harder to spot and fix by starting with a basic prototype you can quickly see what works and what
doesn't allowing for more efficient troubleshooting and refinement three streamlining the learning curve board games need to be accessible and easy to learn especially for newer players a game that is too complex from the outset can be daunting and offputting by starting simply you can create a more approachable learning curve gradually introducing players to the game's mechanisms and strategic depth four facilitating more productive play testing simpler games are easier for play testers to understand and provide feedback on this leads to more effective play testing sessions as testers can focus on the core gameplay rather than getting lost in complicated rules or mechanisms early play test should be about gauging the game's fundamental appeal not managing its intricacies five reducing development time and costs developing the simplest version of your game first can significantly reduce both time and cost complexity adds layers of development testing and production cost by building a simple prototype you can iterate faster and more economically allowing for a more agile and flexible design process six creating space for organic growth often the best features of a game arise organically during the development process starting with a simple Foundation provides the space for such organic growth and as you play test and
iterate you'll naturally find Opportunities to add complexity and depth where it feels necessary and beneficial seven ensuring coherence and balance a simpler game is easier to balance and keep coherent as you add complexity it's vital to maintain the game's balance and ensure that all elements work harmoniously together starting simple gives you a clear overview making making it easier to maintain this balance as you gradually add new components or rules eight appreciating the power of Elegance there's a beauty in Simplicity and elegance in design some of the most beloved and enduring games are those with straightforward elegant mechanisms that provide depth and replayability by aiming for Simplicity you're striving for an Elegance that can make your game both accessible and captivating conclusion starting with the simplest version of your game is not about limiting creativity it's about building a strong Foundation upon which complexity can be meaningfully added it allows for a focused efficient and player-friendly development process as a new designer embracing Simplicity can be your greatest Ally in creating a game that is enjoyable engaging and ready for Success most designers start out trying to create their magnum opus and then get frustrated when they can't make it work for some this frustration leads to walking away from game design forever However if those designers had started
small and tried to create a simple game with fewer Concepts they would have had a much easier time bringing a game to life also a few early wins do a great job of building confidence and momentum which can Propel you even further down the design path what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game design with the player in mind watch People's First First Reactions to the game and be honest about what you see if someone has a hard time getting it or expects things that aren't there that's not a problem with them it's a problem with the game James erest chapter 7 creating a minimum viable product for aspiring Gamers starting a new project can be an exhilarating yet daunting experience one of the biggest challenges is avoiding the Trap of over complicating things this chapter dives into the concept of a minimum viable product or MVP and explains how it can be a GameChanger in transforming your grand ideas into playable prototypes one understanding minimum viable product an MVP is essentially the most basic version of your game idea it strips your Grand Vision down to its core focusing on a single fundamental aspect for instance if you dream of designing an expansive space themed Game featuring intricate ship-to ship combat your MVP might just be the core dice rolling combat mechanism similarly for a
Euro style farming game it could be the basic resource collection system basically break the game down into smaller parts and systems and then focus on those one at a time as you slowly bring the whole thing together it can sometimes feel a bit tedious but it makes the design process much more manageable two The Power of starting small starting with an MVP approach has several advantages Simplicity of focus concentrating on a single aspect of your game reduces complexity and helps maintain your focus early fund testing it enables you to assess the fund factor of your concept early in the development process saving you time and effort in the long run building momentum completing a small manageable part of your game can give you a sense of achievement and the motivation to tackle the next component easy to Pivot it makes it easier to try different mechanisms to see which ones fit best and to find out if this is actually a game you want to pursue to completion three designing in modules I use and recommend a modular approach to game design that breaks the game down into distinct systems or modules start perhaps with the movement system followed by the combat mechanics and then the resource management mechanism this method allows you to play test and refine each element individually before integrating them into a cohesive hole each one has to stand on its own
and be fun before it gets combined with the other systems and each one gets the focus it deserves it also frees me up to experiment and try out different mechanisms to see which ones fit the theme and overall experience best should the game have a rondle for its action selection let's try it real quick maybe an element of area control needs to be involved with how workers are placed draw it on some note cards and see what happens it's like building with Lego you can switch out any blocks you want and piece things together as you see fit and if you build something that later doesn't quite work just leave it put together to possibly use in a future game after years of doing this I have a ton of systems that I really like that ended up being cut out of a game for various reasons however this means I also have a library of systems that can be integrated into future games and that's been one of the main reasons my design process has sped up over the years nothing is ever wasted four iterative process and small victories designing a game is an iterative process and your primary goal in the early stages should be creation rather than Perfection small victories in developing individual modules can provide a significant boost telling you forward in your design journey I find that designing this way is a lot easier to manage as I don't feel overwhelmed by the work involved I'm not trying to design a game I'm simply figuring out
how one small aspect of the game needs to work and that's a lot easier to wrap my mind around prototype and play test then each completed module gets me one step closer to realizing My overall Vision but never underestimate the power of a little momentum one small victory can be the Tipping Point you need to ultimately bring a game to life Perfection is procrastination masquerading as quality control Chris Williamson five transitioning to play testing one of the fundamental truths in board game design is that you cannot play test an idea you need a tangible playable version of your game however rudimentary this is where your MVP comes into play it allows you to get something physical on the table something you can actually interact with and test this step is crucial in determining whether your game concept has the potential to Captivate and engage players a lot of my games start off as a few dice some bits of paper and a note card just anything that I can move around on a table to get a sense of how the game could work and if I can make something fun and interesting out of those simple components I know I can scale it up conclusion adopting the MVP philosophy in your design process is about embracing Simplicity and taking pragmatic steps it's about breaking down your Grand Vision into manageable
testable pieces that gradually come together to form a more complex ho whether you're a seasoned designer or just starting out the MPP approach can streamline your design process keep you focused and provide much needed Clarity and Direction remember the goal is not to create the perfect game right out of the gate but to develop a functional prototype that you can refine and improve upon so take that big idea distill it down to its Essence and start the exciting journey of bringing your game to life one piece at a time chapter eight overcoming designers block strategies to get unstuck every game designer at some point encounters the dreaded designers Block it's an all too common part of the creative process often striking when you least expect it you might be progressing well with your design when suddenly you hit a wall an obstacle appears that seems insurmountable but fear not there are several strategies to help you navigate through these challenging Moments One accepting the inevitable firstly it's important to recognize that designer's block is normal many of the best games we know today faced similar roadblocks during their development and understanding that this is a typical part of the process can alleviate some of the frustration designing games is hard and when you run into problems you don't know how to solve that's just what hard feels like unfortunately a lot of people hit low points in their design journey
and assume creating games isn't for them however it's really just part of the price of admission that everyone has to pay no matter who they are accepting this and knowing deep down that every problem is figureoutable with enough time effort and question asking helped me to stick with game design in spite of the roadblocks I ran into some games took years to bring to life some games require me to find a co-designer or developer and some games are still on the Shelf of not quite sure what to do next but after doing this for over 15 years I know beyond all doubt that every hole can be climbed out of and I firmly believe the same is true for you two taking a break when you find yourself stuck one of the most effective strategies is to take a step back allowing your brain some time to rest and recharge during this period do the following a play other games engaging with other games can be incredibly insightful observing how different designers tackle similar problems can often spark the solution you need or give you an idea on a totally different approach alternatively if you're not able to play as many other games as you like you can also absorb game related media read design Diaries watch review videos and playthroughs listen to podcasts anything that might offer insight into how other designers think and overcome their own challenges B shift your focus Sometimes
the best way to solve a problem in one project is to divert your attention to another working on a different game can provide a fresh perspective and inadvertently lead to a breakthrough in your original design I typically have three main designs going at one time and then a few more secondary ideas that I'm just playing around with being able to jump back and forth between projects keeps my mind fresh and my creative juices flowing this doesn't work for everyone and some people really need to focus on only one game at a time but it's definitely a strategy worth trying three embrace the learning curve recognize that sometimes the issue might stem from a gap in your current design Skills game design like any art form requires time practice and patience to master it's common to be able to identify what makes a great game long before you have the skills to create one yourself this is especially true when you're just starting out you simply don't have the experience tool set or frame of reference necessary to overcome a lot of design problems you run into but why would you when someone starts to learn a sport you don't throw them into a game situation and expect success instead you start with the basics the general rules and basic skills and then slowly move toward playing at full speed in an actual game when you're getting started in game design expecting to be able to create a fully complete and fun experience is
like putting a child in an adult league basketball game and expecting things to go well so cut yourself some slack anything worth doing takes time to learn how to do well and creative Fields like game design take a lifetime to to master but if you commit to the process of learning and growing over time you'll surprise yourself in how much you start to understand the nuances of theme mechanisms player experience and everything else involved in the craft conclusion designer's block is an inevitable part of the game design Journey but with the right approach it can be overcome whether it's taking a break to play other games shifting Focus to a different project or simply acknowledging your current skill level and persisting despite the challenges there are ways to move forward Embrace each block as an opportunity to grow and remember that persistence is a key ingredient in the recipe for success in game design the journey to becoming a great designer is paved with projects that never see the light of day but remember most people don't achieve greatness in their field overnight it's the result of Relentless perseverance numerous failed attempts and the courage to continue despite setbacks so when faced with designers block keep pushing forward the greatest writers artists designers Etc only got to that point because they created a bunch of art that ended up in the trash and they kept going so I encourage you to do the same
keep designing keep learning and above all keep playing chapter n crafting the perfect name a guide to naming your game the name of your game is more than just a label it's the first impression and a vital marketing tool a well-chosen name can Intrigue entice and inform potential players for both new designers and seasoned vets naming a game can be a daunting task but it's an important part of the design process so this chapter provides some ideas on how to name your game effectively one reflect the theme one option is for the title to reflect the game's theme it should give players a hint of what to expect when they open the box if your game is about building empires in ancient times the name should evoke that era and activity a name that aligns well with the game's content can create Intrigue and set the right expectations games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective pandemic terraforming Mars and Great Western Trail tell you exactly what the theme is in the title and when that gets coupled with the Thematic artwork players know exactly what they're getting into before they even open the box two reflect the core mechanism a similar option is to put a nod to the game's core mechanism in either the main title or subtitle this could be a great way to clarify what type of game it is
and make sure you're appealing to the intended audience many games also include stylized components in the box art to reinforce this for example rooll for the Galaxy has roll in the title and several sci-fi themed dice on the cover to suggest you're going to be rolling lots of dice Arkham Horror the card game and Star Wars X-Wing miniatures game use their subtitles to clarify what kinds of games they are and flick them Up's title lets you know it's a dexterity game based on flicking three keep it short and memorable a good game name is usually short and memorable long or complex names can be difficult to remember or pronounce which might put potential players off aim for brevity and impact a concise name is also easier to brand and promote even a short madeup word can work really well take Katan for example other examples include Ark Nova Azul Seven Wonders Nemesis and Scythe four consider uniqueness and originality check that your Game's name isn't already in use a unique name helps your game stand out in a crowded market and avoids confusion additionally avoid names that are too generic as they can get lost among similar titles originality can also make your game more searchable online on retail sites and Board Game Geek for example wingspan is a game about birds but the Creator chose to use a rarely used term related to
birds instead of calling it something more obvious like bird watching five test for clarity and pronunciation your Game's name should be easy to pronounce and understand avoid words that might be confusing or hard to spell test the name with friends family or gaming groups to ensure it's clear and easy to communicate this also applies to terms inside the game when people can't pronounce an alien faction in a Sci-Fi game they just call it the purple one which doesn't help with immersion six think about cultural sensitivity be mindful of cultural Sensi activities when naming your game avoid names that could be offensive or inappropriate in different cultures a name that is respectful and inclusive can broaden your game's appeal to a global audience also be aware that words can mean completely different things in other countries or regions I once suggested a town in a game should be called slago the game had a robot and metal theme the artist I was talking to burst out laughing and let me know that in the United Kingdom where he was from slag had a bit different definition than the one I was used to in Alabama seven check for trademarks and domain availability before finalizing your Game's name check for existing trademarks to avoid legal issues also consider the availability of relevant domain names for your game's website a matching domain name can be an asset for
online marketing and branding the easiest thing to do is search for the title in board game Geeks database and and see if anything pops up eight evoke emotions or curiosity a great game name can evoke emotions or spark curiosity and names that create Intrigue or an emotional response can really draw players in think about the feelings you want to evoke excitement mystery Adventure joy and see how your name can reflect these a few examples are so you've been eaten final girl Mansions of Madness and flasho fire rescue nine play with words don't be afraid to get creative by playing with words using puns or creating new words a clever play on words can make your Game's name stand out and be memorable however ensure the word play aligns with your game's theme and is easy to understand some good examples are dead of winter this town ain't big enough for the two to four of us role player and broom service 10 flexibility for future expansion if you plan to create expansions for your game consider a name that allows for flexibility a name that lends itself to thematic variations can be beneficial for Branding future expansions the game Russian railroads is about constructing railroads in Russia that worked pretty well until they
decided to create an expansion set in Germany it's called Russian railroads German railroads which sounds kind of silly 11 when in doubt just name it a location one of the most popular game name conventions is to Simply use the main location as the title this applies to both real life places and ones that are completely made up this method isn't quite as creative as others but it definitely works Carone on Mars Puerto Rico everdell Gloom Haven and Earth are good examples conclusion naming your game is a creative and strategic process the right name can capture the essence of your game attract players and help with marketing so take your time to brainstorm test and refine your game's title remember a well-chosen name not only labels your game but also becomes a key part of its identity and success what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game in game design there's way too much talk about iteration and test groups and metrics and objectivity and not nearly enough about love if you truly love a game and you share it with others and they love it too there's a decent chance a wider audience will also Alf seagert chapter 10 designing games for everyone the importance of
accessibility board games are more than just entertainment they're a way for people to to connect learn and engage with each other in a shared space of fun and challenge however not all games are accessible to everyone which can exclude potential players due to physical sensory or cognitive barriers designing with accessibility in mind is not just an act of inclusivity it's an essential approach to embracing the diverse community of players around the world and getting the game on as many tables as possible one the need for accessibility in board games in this context accessibility refers to the ability of the game to be played by people with various disabilities including visual impairments color blindness hearing impairments physical disabilities and cognitive impairments many board games feature small text color-coded pieces that are indistinguishable for colorblind players or complex rules that can be daunting for players with cognitive challenges by addressing these issues you can create games that are more inclusive and more marketable two benefits of accessible design broader audience reach accessible games can reach a larger audience this inclusivity can lead to higher sales and a more robust Gaming Community enhanced gameplay experience games designed with accessibility in mind often result in a better experience for all players simplified and clear rules high contrast
game pieces and versatile gameplay options can improve the game for everyone not just those with specific needs social inclusion board games are a social activity and making them accessible means more people can participate in the fun this inclusion Fosters community and brings diverse groups of people together three creating accessible game experiences some key areas of accessibility include visual accessibility Implement High contract colors legible fonts and avoid Reliance on color as the sole game element good examples are games like quirl and fantastic factories that are double-coded to provide extra levels of information Beyond color to differentiate game components games that provide dual layered boards can also be helpful to know exactly where to place game pieces auditory accessibility for Audi dependent games provide Alternatives like visual or tactile options visually focused games such as the Mind enhance accessibility as they don't rely on sound physical accessibility design components that are easy to manipulate like larger cards or titles to accommodate those with motor skill challenges Cooperative games like pandemic that encourage group participation can be more inclusive for players with physical disabilities cognitive
accessibility simplify rules or offer rule variations for different cognitive abilities games with straightforward objectives like Ticket to Ride can be more inclusive four practical steps for Designing accessible board games consult accessibility guidelines utilize resources like the colorblind awareness organization and me like us to understand common issues and solutions you can also upload images to online simulators like cblas to test your cards boards etc for color blindness accessibility involve testers with disabilities during the development process include testers who have disabilities to provide feedback on the game's accessibility their firsthand experience is inevitable in identifying obstacles that might not be evident to someone without those disabilities use symbols and textures incorporate symbols or patterns along with colors and if possible use different textures shapes or sizes game pieces to help players distinguish them by touch consider font size and contrast ensure that all text is legible with a suitable font size and high contrast against the background to help both the visually impaired and those playing in low light situations simplify and clarify rules write rules that are easy to understand and remember include player AIDS or quick reference cards for core rules and
make sure to have enough for each person at the table also in your rule book include lots of examples and possibly a glossery of terms conclusion designing with accessibility in mind allows you to not only Foster inclusivity but also innovate in game design ultimately the goal is to ensure that everyone can participate in the joy of gaming making each game a richer more inclusive experience it's obviously not possible to make every game accessible to everyone however identifying often easy to fix accessibility issues and designing with intentionality can help you get your games on more tables what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game play test listen adjust and repeat do this until the majority of play testers who enjoy the particular emotions your game evokes confirm feeling the emotions you're seeking to create Rachel Bruner chapter 10 so solo designing versus co-designing for new game designers one of the earliest decisions to make is whether to embark on the design Journey alone or with a co-designer and both approaches have unique advantages and challenges understanding the Dynamics of solo and co-designing can help you choose the path that best aligns with your personal preferences working style and overall goals solo designing designing a game on your own allows for complete creative
control control you make all decisions regarding the game's theme mechanisms rules and experience however working alone also means all the weight of a project falls on you which can lead to overwhelm procrastination and missed opportunities pros of solo designing complete creative control you have the freedom to realize your vision without compromises or needing consensus simpler Logistics coordinating schedules and meetings is not a concern you can work at your own pace and on your own schedule direct communication when presenting your game to Publishers or play testers the communication is straightforward as you are the sole representative of your game more royalties if you're the only designer signing a licensing contract you obviously make more money than if you have to split the royalties with a co-designer cons of solo designing limited perspective working alone means you rely solely on your own ideas and insights which can sometimes limit the game's creative scope also without external input there's a risk of not noticing flaws or areas of improvement in your game greater responsibility all tasks from initial concept to play testing iterating and pitching to Publishers fall on you which can be overwhelming less accountability when working alone there's less pressure to get things done which can lead to
procrastination and lack of focus working with someone else can be a great motivator to hit deadlines and make steady progress so you don't let the other person down code designing collaborating with a co-designer brings together diverse skills and perspectives and allows for shared responsibilities more creative ideas and a team that can be much greater than the sum of its parts however anytime more people are added to a project the potential for conflict increases substantially and you'll have to balance your working relationship with your personal vision for the game pros of co-designing diverse skills and perspectives different viewpoints can enhance the game's creativity and possibilities as each designer brings unique strengths to the table shared workload responsibilities such as play testing rulebook writing and pitching to Publishers can be divided reducing the burden on a single individual support and motivation working with someone else provides moral support and motivation especially during challenging phases of the design process cons of co-designing Need for compromise differences in vision and ideas will require compromises which might not always align with your original Vision logistical challenges coordinating schedules and managing consistent communication can be challenging especially if you don't live
close to each other potential for conflicts differences in opinion and working Styles can lead to conflicts which may affect the game development process and the quality of the final product less royalties sharing the workload also means splitting the royalties from licensing deals start with a contract designing games with a close friend might be a ton of fun but it's also a business relationship so if you're going to work with a co- designer make sure you have a contract in place that clarifies and specifies what each person's responsibilities will be and what happens in the wake of certain Unfortunate Events here are some specific things to work out and put in the contract what is each person's role in the project for example who is in charge of play testing prototype creation reaching out to Publishers Etc even if everyone takes part in a task it's good to have one specific specific person in charge of it to make sure it gets done what's the process for leaving the project if someone wants to abandon the project or if something tragic happens you need a process that outlines how a designer can be removed from the partnership who gets final say sometimes a disagreement doesn't have a viable compromise when that's the case who gets to make the final decision a different person could be the decision maker for different aspects of the game who pays for what are all cost split 50/50
prototyping materials are usually fairly cheap but what about airfare hotel rooms and Convention badges what if one designer really wants to buy a laser cutter or 3D printer some simple language in the contract can make it clear and leaves less room for disagreement and frustration how will workload and royalties be split 50/50 seems like an obvious choice but is that really the case make make sure to have a conversation about all the work involved and make sure you're on the same page about who does what if you started the project alone but are now bringing on a co-designer it might make more sense to do 6040 or a split that better reflects each designer's contributions to the game working with a code designer can be incredibly rewarding and help you get more done in less time however disagreements can quickly send a project off the rails so it's best to have a simple contract and a list of agreed upon expect ations to prevent conflicts and keep everyone focused on the main goal creating a fun game conclusion deciding between solo and co-designing Depends largely on your personal working style the complexity of your game and your ability to either work independently or collaborate effectively solo designing offers full creative control but can be isolating whereas co-designing brings diverse insights and shared responsibilities but requires compromise and coordin ation whichever path you choose being aware of the pros
and cons will help you navigate the process more effectively and make inform decisions that best suit your game design Journey what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game it's easy to get lost in your own design and love it but when I start to compare my own design to the games in my collection particularly the fun ones that I play all the time I'll see that I'm just designing in a vacuum Jason tag me section three find the fun chapter 1 understanding fun the heart of game design when play testing my own games and others I often find myself saying there's a fun game in here somewhere usually that means certain parts of the experience are interesting and that I see the fun that the game is trying to create however that fun is still buried beneath things that need to be removed replaced or refined game design is often a long drawn out sifting process as you try to get rid of all the unnecessary parts and leave the bits that create the true experience you're going for and unfortunately fun is very good at hiding sometimes it's underneath an idea that worked perfectly in your head but bombed spectacularly in real life other times it's behind a mechanism you love that just isn't working with the theme you've chosen and sometimes it's right there in front of you hiding in plain sight and
right next to a shiny new bad idea you can't take your eyes off fun is Elusive and even the best game designers in the world have a hard time finding it but it must be found if you want people to enjoy your game and play it more than once so this section will explore what fun is how to find and created and various ways it can be implemented in your games understanding fun the heart of game design at the core of every game is a simple yet profound objective to be fun but what exactly makes a game fun this elusive quality is obviously subjective and varies from player to player and even day-to-day yet there are common elements that consistently contribute to A Game's enjoyment this chapter explores these elements to help you create games that Captivate and engage players and General I think of games as fun engines players put time in and get fun out and as designers it's our job to maximize the ratio of time to fun now there are lots of ways to approach this but there are several overarching Core Concepts that you should be thinking about in order to find the fun throughout the rest of this section we'll explore these Concepts in Greater detail one engaging mechanics the mechanics of a game are are how its individual mechanisms rules systems and procedures all work together
fun arises when these mechanics are engaging and provide a satisfying gameplay experience this could mean creating an Innovative mechanism that offers new challenges or using a tried and tested system that's refined for maximum enjoyment the key is that players should feel actively involved in the game with every action and decision feeling meaningful two meaningful choices speaking of which the presence of meaningful choices in a game significantly contributes to its fun Factor these are decisions that have real consequences in the game influencing the outcome in significant ways when players feel that their choices matter they become more invested in the game leading to a more engaging experience people want to feel like they're playing the game not like the game is playing them three balanced challenge a game should present a Balan Ed level of challenge too easy and it becomes boring too hard and it becomes frustrating The Sweet Spot lies in presenting players with challenges that are surmountable yet requires strategic thinking skill or sometimes a bit of luck games that manage to hit this balance often keep players coming back for more four social interaction many games are fun because they facilitate social interaction whether it's through teamwork comp competition negotiation or just shared storytelling games can create memorable social
experiences designing mechanics that encourage interaction can make games more enjoyable and unique Five theme and narrative a compelling theme or narrative can immensely enhance a game's fun when players feel immersed in a game's World they connect more deeply with the game playay and a well-crafted theme or story can transform abstract mechanics into a compelling experience six surprise and variability elements of surprise and variability can keep a game fresh and exciting this could be in the form of random events a variety of game scenarios or unpredictable actions of other players games that offer a different experience each time they are played often have high replay value seven aesthetic appeal never underestimate the power of a game's aesthetic appeal beautiful artwork highquality components and a visually appealing setup can greatly enhance the fun of a game these elements can draw players into the game's world and enhance the overall experience eight achievable goals and rewards Games should have clear achievable goals and a system of rewards that motivate players the satisfaction of achieving a goal or earning a reward is a significant part of what makes a game enjoyable in general players want to feel powerful wealthy Andor clever and the more your game can create those feelings the more fun it will be
conclusion creating fun is a multifaceted challenge that involves balancing mechanics themes choices and Aesthetics as a designer your task is to weave these elements together into a cohesive and enjoyable experience at the heart of every great game is a simple promise the promise of fun and by focusing on what makes games enjoyable you can create fun engines that players will love to put time into what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game understanding what you might find fun could be different than what other people find fun if you can see if your game can have multiple types of fun J Cormier chapter 13 finding the fun how to identify and enhance the enjoyment in your game creating a board game is a journey filled with creativity iteration and Discovery at the heart of this process lies a fundamental question is the game fun and finding the fun in your game is vital for its success and player enjoyment but how do you identify what makes your game enjoyable this chapter will explore specific ways to uncover and enhance the fun elements in your game The designer's Dilemma it's extremely difficult to know if your own game is actually fun to play it's hard to read the label from inside the bottle and fun is so subjective and varied encompassing everything from
strategic thinking and social interaction to storytelling and exploration that you're never going to find it while your game is still in your head or on a notebook you have to get it on a table in front of other people and start moving things around many times the aspects you thought would be the most fun are actually the parts you need to get rid of first and a random mechanism you threw in as a placeholder turns out to be the real juice that makes the game fun but once your game hits the table the key is to identify what kind of fun your game aims to deliver and focus on amplifying the elements that bring that fun to life ways to identify fun in your game one play test by yourself why it's important while external feedback is invaluable solo play test in allows you to gain a deeper understanding of your game's overall mechanics and identify potential issues before involving others how to do it simulate different player perspectives and strategies by playing multiple roles take detailed notes on which aspects feel engaging and which feel lacking this approach helps you refine the game's flow and create fun moments before introducing it to innocent victims I mean play testers two play test with different groups why it's important different players find different aspects of a game fun play testing with a variety of groups helps you understand what works
for a broader audience how to do it organize play test sessions with players of different ages skill levels and gaming preferences observe their reactions and gather feedback on what they enjoyed the most three identify moments of Engagement why it's important moments when players are most engaged are often when they're having the most fun how to do it during play testing watch for moments when players are fully absorbed in the game note the actions strategies or scenarios that lead to heightened engagement four analyze player feedback why it's important direct feedback from players can provide insights into which aspects of the game they found most enjoyable how to do it use open discussions and structured feedback forms to ask specific questions about what players liked what they found challenging and what they found dull look for common themes in their responses five focus on player emotions why it's important fun is often tied to emotional responses like excitement tension surprise and satisfaction how to do it pay attention to players emotional reactions during during the game are they laughing celebrating victories or intensely focused these emotional highs can highlight the most fun parts of your
game ways to enhance fun in your game one refine and highlight key mechanisms why it's important the core mechanisms should be the most fun parts of the game and therefore should be emphasized and refined to ensure they stand out and are supported by every other aspect of the game how to do it once you've identified the parts of the game that players enjoy the most look for ways to simplify streamline and enhance them ensure these aspects are Central to the gameplay experience and consider removing anything that doesn't point back to them two create meaningful choices why it's important players enjoy games where their decisions have significant and clear impacts how to do it design your game to offer a variety of strategic options that lead to different outcomes ensure that each choice feels consequential and rewarding three encourage social interaction why it's important many players find social interaction to be one of the most enjoyable aspects of board games how to do it incorporate elements that encourage player interactions such as trading negotiating and Cooperative tasks ensure that these interactions are intrical to players success four balance Challenge and reward why it's important a game that is too easy or too hard can quickly become
boring or frustrating how to do it strive for a balance where players feel challenged but also have a fair chance of success provide clear and achievable goals with rewards that feel satisfying and motivating conclusion find finding the fun in your design is the most important step towards creating a game that players will love and return to by play testing with different groups focusing on moments of Engagement analyzing player feedback and enhancing core mechanisms you can identify and amplify the elements that make your game enjoyable remember the goal is to create an experience that not only challenges players but also brings them joy and satisfaction embrace the iterative process of testing and refining and you be well on your way to designing a game that captures the hearts and minds of players note that I'll go deeper into the topic of play testing in section five what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game for most hobby game designs you as the game designer should set a goal for yourself to ensure that your design acts as a catalyst for your players to feel clever about their play and their choices do that and the fun will follow JB Howell chapter 14 designing a series of interesting choices Sid Meer once said a game is a series of interesting choices basically a player having
options is what makes an experience a game and not just an activity and the more interesting these choices are the more fun the game will be so when you're designing a game understanding The Power of Choice is Paramount A Game's ability to engage players often hinges on how meaningful each decision feels during play but what makes a choice meaningful it's not just about the mechanics or the complexity it's about impact when players see that their actions have significant consequences leading them closer to Victory or defeat the game transforms from a simple Pastime to a compelling journey of strategy and Consequence the importance of meaningful choices in game design meaningful choices are the Cornerstone of engaging games they provide players with a sense of agency the feeling that the game's outcome is directly influenced by their decision this sense of agency is crucial because it makes the experience personal and immersive players aren't merely going through the motions they're actively shaping their Destiny within the game's World characteristics of meaningful choices to identify meaningful choices in a game look for these aspects impact a meaningful Choice must have a clear and perceivable impact on the game's outcome this impact doesn't need to be immediate but it should be present and recognizable visibility player should be able to understand how a choice affects
the game this requires clear communication of the game's rules and mechanics relevance choices should feel relevant to the game's objectives irrelevant decisions diminish the player's sense of influence over the game balance effective choices are those that provide a balanced set of options each with its own set of risks and rewards however as I mentioned in the previous section balance is more about feel than a specific algorithm so pay more attention to player perception than a spreadsheet designing for Meaningful choices to design a game that is full of meaningful choices follow these guidelines one clear objectives ensure that players understand what they're trying to achieve clear objectives set the stage for decisions that feel like they matter two interconnected decisions design choices that build upon one another creating a layered experience where early decisions impact later opportunities three margin for error if you hear play testers say something to the effect of the game feels too tight it means that they feel like the game is too punishing for missteps if a poor choice in the first round plays a large role in losing the game an hour later it will leave players feeling frustrated choices should matter but make sure individual choices don't matter too
much four diverse strategies offer multiple paths to Victory to accommodate different play Styles and strategic approaches this diversity encourages players to think critically and make choices that align with their preferred tactics five feedback loops provide feedback that helps players understand the consequences of their decisions whether through the game's narrative scoring system or visual cue immediate feedback helps clarify the impact of a player's actions simple versus complex D Jenga is one of the simplest games ever made however each Block's removal is a meaningful Choice fundamentally altering the structure's stability the consequences of each decision are immediate and visible making even the simple game engaging and fun contrast that with a complex strategy game like Tera mystica here players must manage multiple variables and long-term strategies the choices involve selecting actions that will develop resources expand territory and Achieve strategic goals over time each decision made in early rounds sets the stage for future opportunities creating a deep ly interconnected and impactful gameplay experience both paths work it just depends on the experience you're trying to create however the best complex games are also the ones that keep things simple winning might consist of 50 turns
of interconnected actions but each turn typically only has a few choices to pick from in the same way a turn of D Jenga only has a few blocks that a player can remove as your game becomes more complicated overall you you need to find ways to simplify its individual parts for example Twilight Imperium is a massive game that can take 8 hours to finish but the game is broken down into several phases where the players make simple choices to move their overarching strategies forward this works because complexity is diffused by Clarity clear rules and objectives can make even the most complicated games easy for players to understand and placing various aspects of the game in their own fa phes means players only have to think about a few things at one time a game can be an absolute brain burner but if it also limits the number of choices present to a player at once it can prevent players from feeling overwhelmed or locked in analysis paralysis learning from loss as people play your game they should be able to Think Through various options and paths to take that they think will lead to winning the game if they can't see clear options and just take their turns randomly there's a disconnect between them and the game which you'll need to find a way to fix sometimes it's because they don't understand the rules other times it's because they haven't fully grasped how the game's core mechanism works but whatever the case may be it's your job
to make their choices and potential outcomes clear when players lose they should be able to look back over the choices they made throughout the game and realize what they could have done differently to have a better chance to win when they think through how the game played out and can't understand why they lost and what could have been done differently they assume the game's choices were arbitrary which doesn't exactly get them excited to play again conclusion meaningful choices are at the heart of fun games they transform routine play into an engaging Narrative of cause and effect where every decision counts as a game designer understanding how to craft such choices means striking a balance between complexity and Clarity ensuring that each player's decision-making process is both challenging and easy to understand by focusing on the impact visibility relevance and balance of choices you can create games that players will return to eager to explore new strategies and outcomes what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game remove as many obstacles from playing as possible every time there's a rule or implied rule that says you can't do that it saps a little bit of fun away Ted albach chapter 15 The Choice Trident power wealth and cleverness when designing a game understanding what drives player
enjoyment is crucial the choice Trident is a concept that encapsulates Three core feelings that according to human psychology significantly contribute to player experience and fun this chapter dives into how incorporating these elements can enhance the gaming experience making your game more engaging and satisfying for players one the Allure of power control and influence the first prong of the choice Trident is Power Players often seek a sense of control and influence over the game's environment this doesn't necessarily mean overpowering others it can also manifest as control over one's own fate within the game designing game mechanics that allow players to feel they have a direct impact on the game's outcome whether through strategic decision making resource control or character development Taps into this desire for power it's about giving players meaningful choices that have visible consequences in The Game World you can also help players feel powerful by offering ways to level up or improve over the course of the game this could be through gaining access to better cards unlocking abilities opening up new areas to explore or control Etc any choice that gives the player a sense of progression as their character or faction or Empire becomes more of a force to be reckoned with will go a long way in harnessing this part of the choice Trident in regular life many
people feel powerless in their situations and unable to control a lot of what happens but in a game those same people can be bulletproof superheroes level 99 Warriors and world conquering Emperors and for just a few minutes they can feel like they have much more power to affect how their story plays out two the gratification of wealth accumulation and utilization the second prong of the Trident Is wealth this doesn't solely refer to monetary riches it encompasses any form of resource accumulation and utilization players enjoy collecting whether it's points resources cards or any other in-game asset the key is to make the accumulation of these resources feel rewarding and provide opportunities for their strategic use the sense of building growing and efficiently managing resources can be deeply satisfying and it offers players a tangible measure of their progress and success in the game even little things like making money $1 million instead of $1 can help players feel like they're up next on MTV Cribs one of my favorite examples is the money in Millennium blades in this game players buy cards for a fictional collectible card game but instead of having individual tokens or using single paper bills like Monopoly for currency the game has stacks of paper money that are wrapped together to present different values for example a stack of 10 green bills is used for $1 So when you buy a card for
$1 you toss a stack of cash instead of one cardboard chit and it's amazing how something so simple can make a player feel so rich games with auctions negotiations open markets or any other mechanism that allows players to accumulate resources and spin them can utilize this part of the choice Trident and have players excited to play again three the satisfaction of cleverness strategy and problem solving the third prong is intelligence players love to feel smart they enjoy puzzles strategic planning and the challenge of outthinking the game or other players and games that challenge players to think strategize and solve problems can be incredibly engaging this involves creating scenarios where players must make decisions with meaningful impact where foresight and planning are rewarded it's not about the complexity of the rules but the depth of the choices players face giving players multiple paths to score points defeat other players create combos Etc goes a long way in helping them feel clever as they try to outwit the other people at the table few things are more satisfying than a long-term plan coming together over the course of multiple turns and the slow realization of everyone else at the table as they figure out what's happening it's a rush and any choices you can add to your game that highlight this feeling will help you apply this part of the choice Trident and make your game much more fun
to play incorporating the Trident into game design to effectively incorporate the choice Trident into your game design consider the following incentivized Behavior whatever experience you're going for people will almost always do what Their incentivized to do so if you want players to level up to feel powerful buy and sell Goods to feel wealthy or piece together combos to feel clever make sure those are the main things that help players win player agency regardless of the game's theme or mechanics players should always feel that their actions matter ensure that the choices they make in pursuit of power wealth or cleverness significantly impact their experience and potential for success in the game feedback mechanisms provide clear feedback for players actions related to these three aspects whether it's a visual cue for gaining resources wealth a strategic Advantage gained cleverness or a significant alteration of the game State Power Players should be able to see the results of their choices except accessibility and depth while catering to these three aspects keep the game accessible to new players while providing enough depth for seasoned Gamers the game should be easy to learn but offer a rich array of strategic possibilities multiple paths different players have different tastes and will be drawn towards different choices some
players will choose the Barbarian who does a lot of damage some would rather have the Rogue who can steal money from enemies and some want the wizard who has different spells for different situations so having multiple options and potentially multiple paths to Victory can make your game more appealing to a wider audience as you tap into the preferences of different player types conclusion by understanding and integrating the choice Trident power wealth and cleverness into your game design you can create a more engaging and satisfying experience for players these elements tap into fundamental aspects of human psychology and when balanced and well implemented can significantly enhance the enjoyment and replayability of your game what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game if you find yourself designing a game what is your goal is it that you want to have fun designing it is it that you want to make a game that is closer to your idea of fun than other games out there do you have a particular audience in mind and want to make a game that they find fun do you want to express yourself do you want people to say nice things about something you've created and get that sweet sweet Rush of endorphins do you want to make money it's likely that you want a number of things kobby Dow chapter 16 the role of tension in game design enhancing fun and
engagement tension in games refers to a sense of uncertainty challenge or anticipation that players experience during gamepl and significantly influences how enjoyable a game is it's a driving force that keeps players engaged invested and emotionally involved in the game this chapter explores why tension is essential in gameplay design and how it directly correlates to the fun and excitement players's experience types of tension in games competitive tension arises from player interactions such as racing to achieve a goal battling for resources or out smarting opponent narrative tension created through storytelling elements where players are eager to see how the story unfolds mechanical tension stems from The Game's mechanics such as time limits Resource Management challenges or risk reward decisions tension as a source of Engagement tension captivates players attention and keeps them engaged throughout the game it arises from situations where players are invested in the outcome but uncertain about what will happen next this uncertainty can stem from various sources competition with other players challenges posed by The Game's core mechanism or the unpredictability of game events limiting player actions or allowing players to actively affect each other can greatly enhance your game's tension for example in the worker
placement phase of Dune Imperium you typically only have two agents or workers which limits your actions however most of the action spaces can only have one worker which creates a ton of tension as you wait for your turn and hope other players don't take the spot you need lost cities is another great example in this two-player game you're constantly discarding cards that your opponent can pick up and every card you lay down comes with a small amount of anxiety as you hope it's not the exact card your opponent has been waiting for balancing challenge and ability a key aspect of creating tension is finding the right balance between the challenge a game presents and the player's ability to meet that challenge if a game is too easy it lacks tension and becomes boring if it's too hard it can become frustrating The Sweet Spot is where the game's challenges are aligned with the player's abilities creating a satisfying level of tension that is exciting but not overwhelming when players don't understand how the game works they won't experience its tension ention because they won't be able to see the possible cause and effect possibilities they still might feel tension but it'll be the tension that comes from trying not to look stupid in front of other people to help players a clear rulebook is vital but you can also adjust the learning curve so that the game gradually increases in difficulty and complexity over time so players can understand key Concepts before giving them more options you can also limit the
number of choices or options available to the players at one time to manage the game's cognitive load the brain power it takes to play the game tension comes from being unsure about what's going to happen next but if a player has to think through 20 different possibilities they're more likely to feel burnout than tension tension through uncertainty and risk incorporating elements of uncertainty and risk can significantly enhance a game's tension this could be through mechanisms like dice rolling drawing cards from a shuffled deck or making decisions with predictable outcomes the key is to ensure that these elements are not purely based on luck but allow for at least some strategic decision making as mentioned in the first chapter of this section surprise is a powerful tool in a game designer's toolbox when used effectively tension and surprise work together to create memorable moments where a player takes a chance and either comes up big or fails miserably the fun comes from the buildup of not knowing and then the quick release of of finding out for example in Kingdom Death monster combat often comes down to a final die roll and players will either succeed and Vanquish a monster or they fail and the monster will eat their faces off next turn combine that with the game's hit location deck the possibility for critical wounds and the potential for One-Shot kills and you get very tense and often surprising combat every single
round managing tension and player emotion throughout the game tension should EB and flow throughout the game with moments of high tension followed by periods of relative calm this pacing keeps players engaged and prevents the game from becoming too stressful or too dull tension directly impacts players emotions creating a sense of excitement suspense and thrill and when players are emotionally invested in the outcome of the game they're more engaged and typically find the game more enjoyable the resolution of tension such as achieving a goal or surviving a challenge provides a sense of accomplishment and satisfaction and most people find that fun which is why it's usually best to end the game on one of those highs for example in pandemic the game immediately ends when players find the fourth and final cure this is a tense exciting moment that took planning and teamwork to accomplish and the players get to sit back and bask in Victory however if the game didn't end when you got the fourth cure but instead forced players to methodically move around the board removing the rest of the disease cubes one by one it would end on a rather dull moment of picking up a cube you had the cure for five turns ago when telling a story you want to start as close to the end as possible and once the story hits its climax you want to get to the end as quickly as you can game design works the same way and ending right after a big tense moment will leave players with that as their
main memory play testing and adjusting tension play testing is crucial in assessing and adjusting the level of tension in your game observing players reaction and Gathering feedback can help you fine-tune elements that contribute to tension ensuring that it enhances the game's fun and excitement however don't wait until the game is over to gather feedback about tension pausing at certain points throughout the game and asking how players are feeling and why can give you excellent insight into if the experience is achieving the buildup and release type of moments you're hoping for players tend to only remember the most recent swing of emotions so if you wait until the end of the game to get feedback you're going to miss out on key data conclusion tension is a powerful tool in game design directly contributing to a game's fun and engagement by carefully crafting and balancing sources of tension you can create compelling Gam gam play experiences that Captivate and thrill players just keep in mind that the goal is to strike the right balance creating a game that is challenging engaging and most importantly fun to play what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game create something that you enjoy playing over and over again play a lot of games and find out what fun means for you then try to add that into your own designs Shem
Phillips chapter 17 the Goldilocks rule fun that is just right every game you design is going to have a different approach to fun depending on the overall experience you're going for however game design in general is a consistent complex Balancing Act where you're always trying to find the perfect harmony between too much and too little of each game element whether you're working on a 10-minute part party game or a 3-hour Euro you'll be seeking out the ideal sweet spot where every aspect of your game feels just right to players I call this concept the Goldilocks Rule and my game design process got much faster easier and better when I started applying the rule to my games and how I gather feedback and in this chapter we'll explore how to apply the Goldilocks rule to your games understanding the Goldilocks rule the Goldilocks rule emphasizes just right for every aspect of the game ensuring that each part contributes positively to the overall experience whether it's the complexity of rules game length player interaction or the balance between luck and skill every element should feel optimal and enhance player engagement key elements to get just right one game length a game that ends too quickly can leave players unsatisfied prolonged game playay can lead to Bor and disengagement find a duration that keeps
players engaged from start to finish here's a tip time your play test and gather feedback on game length to adjust pacing and ensure a satisfying experience two downtime if players don't have enough time to think the game can feel rushed excessive downtime can make the game feel boring and sluggish maintain a balance where players are engaged but have enough time to make thought thought ful decisions here's a tip monitor player engagement during turns and streamline gameplay to reduce unnecessary waiting times three interaction isolated gameplay can make players feel disconnected from each other overbearing interactions can lead to chaos and frustration ensure meaningful interactions that enhances the social aspect of the game without causing chaos unless chaos is the experience you're hoping for here's a tip incorporate mechanics that encourage strategic interaction and collaboration without overwhelming players with too many choices four theme a weak theme can make the game feel abstract and uninspiring an overly dominant theme can overshadow gameplay mechanics and become more of a simulation than a game the theme should immerse players in the game without detracting from the gameplay here's a tip integrate thematic elements with mechanics to make the game more
intuitive and to create an immersive yet clear and enjoyable experience five choices limited choices can make the game feel monotonous and unchallenging or like the game is playing itself an overabundance of choices can be overwhelming and confusing the correct range of meaningful choices allows players to feel in control and like their decisions matter with without leading to analysis paralysis here's a tip offer choices that impact the game's outcome encouraging strategic thinking and planning but limit the number of choices available on a single turn often two to three options is plenty six Luck versus skill games driven by too much luck can feel unpredictable and unfair games that rely solely on skill can be intimidating for casual players and feel solved for experience experienced players balance elements of luck and skill to cater to both strategic and Casual players enough luck so that the game has surprises but enough skill so that players feel like they're playing the game more than the game is playing them here's a tip use a mix of random elements and strategic decisions to make the game more Dynamic and to appeal to a broad audience seven rules missing Andor unclear information can lead to confusion and frustration overwhelming players with overly detailed or complex rules can
detract from the enjoyment and make the game appear more complicated than it really is aim for clarity and brevity rules should be easy to learn and clearly explained here's a tip simplify your rulebook and use visual aids like diagrams or quick reference guides to enhance understanding Gathering and implementing feedback during play testing you can use the Goldilocks rule as a guide as you watch players engage with your game and gather feedback from them throughout the experience and after the game is over if you'd like to use the feedback form I use which utilizes the Goldilocks rule you can download it at www.boardgamegeek.com
your game to better align with the Goldilocks Rule and continue testing until you achieve the desired balance this iterative process is essential for refining your game and ensuring it provides an enjoyable experience for all players conclusion every game is going to have a different just right and it really comes down to the experience you're trying to create some games last 2 hours and it feels too short other games last 10 minutes and it feels too long some games rely mostly un luck by Design other games take years to master but ultimately it's all about the player experience and what's going to create the most fun at the table applying the Goldilocks rule in your design and play testing process will help you find the right balance in every aspect of your game and by focusing on finding the sweet spot for each of your game's key elements you can create a game that is both enjoyable and replayable and ensure players think it was just right chapter 8 the power of incentives motivating players to engage and enjoy in the 1700s 33% of British criminals being transported to Australia died and Route initially sea captains were paid for every passenger who boarded the ship however when Britain switched to paying captains for every passenger who walked off the ship in Australia the survival rate skyrocketed to 99% it's amazing how shift incentives
can lead to significantly different outcomes and just as incentives influence behavior in real life they guide players actions decisions and engagement in board games and by understanding and implementing effective incentives you can create more engaging enjoyable and fun experiences so this chapter will explore the importance of incentives in game design and provide practical ways to incentivize players the importance of incentives in incentives in board games serve as the psychological backbone that guides players behavior and decisionmaking they are the reasons players chose one strategy over another and feel invested in the game play extrinsic such as victory points Rewards or game assets which players earn through specific actions or intrinsic where the motivation comes from the joy of playing strategizing or the social interaction within the game itself incentives are essentially Rewards or motivators that encourage players to take specific actions when used effectively they can do the following Drive player engagement effective incentives keep players interested and engaged throughout the game they provide goals and challenges that players strive to achieve or overcome encourage strategic depth by offering multiple Pathways to win and different strategies to explore incentives encourage deeper thinking and planning enhancing the game's strategic nature nature enhance reliability well-designed
and varied incentives ensure that each game session feels different encouraging players to explore new strategies and increasing the game's replay value applying incentives and game design here are several ways to incorporate effective incentives into your games one victory points concept award points for achieving specific objectives or milestones implementation in games like Katan players earn points for building settlements cities and achieving certain goals this incentivizes players to pursue these objectives throughout the game two Resource Management concept provide rewards for efficient Resource Management implementation in terraforming Mars players gain resources that can be used to build projects incentivizing careful planning and management of their assets three achievements and Milestones concept offer rewards for reaching certain Milestones or achievements implementation in Gloom Haven players receive new abilities by leveling up and new characters by completing quests motivating them to work towards these goals four risk versus reward concept design choices that involve weighing potential risks against rewards
implementation in debt of winter when players are searching for items they must decide whether to keep searching for higher rewards at the risk of attracting zombies or be satisfied with what they already found five variable player Powers concept give players unique abilities or advantages implementation in root each faction has distinct abilities and goals incentivizing players to leverage their unique strengths to win six iname currency concept use endgame currency as an incentive for various actions implementation in Monopoly players earn money by acquiring properties and charging rent driving the core gameplay Loop seven hidden goals concept provide secret objectives that players work towards implementation in Scythe players have personal objectives that offer additional points if completed adding a layer of strategy and surprise eight feedback loops concept create systems where actions lead to immediate and noticeable feedback implementation in Ticket to Ride players immediately see the impact of completing a route on their score and board position reinforcing ing their actions nine narrative progression concept give players a story
to progress through to see how it ends implementation in time stories players become protagonists in the story making choices that reveal new plot elements and outcomes more things to think about balance is key a fun game must balance its incentives to avoid dominant strategies that make the game predict balancing incentives involves ensuring that no single strategy is overwhelmingly better than others providing players with a variety of viable options to explore align incentives with the theme incentives should feel organic and ingal to the game's theme for example in a game set in medieval times incentives might include gaining land Building castles or accumulating wealth which all align with the historical context gradual complexity introduce simple incentives early in the game and more complex ones as the game progresses this approach helps a new players learn the game without feeling overwhelmed while providing depth for experienced players diversify incentives for different player types recognize that different players enjoy different types of incentives some may prefer competitive challenges While others might enjoy Cooperative elements or simply want to explore the game's narrative and most importantly fun equals winning the things that make your game fun to play should also be the
things that help players win if a boring strategy gets the most victory points players will be incentivized to do it but they won't have much fun along the way for example in ghost stories you win when the final boss is defeated which takes careful planning collaboration and mitigating bad die rolles as much as possible those are also the things that make the game fun and when having fun leads to winning people have a tendency to want to play again it also means that even when players lose they had fun along the way and want to play again conclusion incentives are not just rewards they are the guiding forces that make a board game intriguing challenging and fun they are crucial for directing gameplay enhancing player interaction and ensuring that every game session provides a unique and memorable experience as a game designer understanding and skillfully implementing incentives is essential to creating games that Captivate and engage a diverse audience of players through thoughtful design and careful balancing incentives can transform a simple concept into a beloved game on any shelf what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game I've had great ideas while working on a game but scrapped them or written them down for future your use because they didn't fit what my target audience would enjoy are you designing for gamers is this a family game are you aiming for Mass Market those are potentially very
different types of games with audiences that find different things fun know what your end goal is research that market and design with that in mind Kane Kinko chapter 19 unlocking engagement applying Nicole's borrows four keys to fun and board game design creating a game that captivates players keeping them engaged from start to finish is a challenging yet rewarding Endeavor and Nicole Lazaro's framework the Four Keys to fun provides invaluable insights that can be directly applied to board game design these Keys hard fun easy fun serious fun and people fun offer a holistic approach to crafting experiences that resonate with different players preferences I encourage you to dive into Nicole's entire framework when you have a chance but here's a summary of how it can be applied to the game design process one hard fun challenging yet satisfying hard fun is at the heart of many classic and strategy heavy board games this type of fun stems from The Challenge strategy and problem solving aspects that demand player involvement to implement hard fun in games incorporate strategic depth design mechanics that allow players to make meaningful choices for instance in games like chess or terraforming Mars each decision impacts the game's outcome rewarding strategic planning and
tactical adjustments offer graduated challenges to keep the game accessible yet challenging structure gameplay to increase its complexity this can be achieved through Progressive leveling or scenarios that introduce new challenges as the game advances give feedback and rewards provide clear feedback for player actions particularly when overcoming challenges or achieving significant Milestones within the game rewards can be intrinsic like gaining personal satisfaction for pulling off a ridiculous combo or extrinsic such as earning victory points or piles of money two easy fun curiosity and exploration easy fun is about immersing players an experience that arouses curiosity through exploration role playing or narrative this key focuses on the sensory and imaginative aspects of fun and can be implemented in these ways Rich storytelling create a compelling narrative that pulls players into the game's world games like tales of the Arabian Knights Excel by allowing players to explore stories and make choices that influence the narrative's direction aesthetic appeal in invest in highquality thematic Art and Design Elements that enhance the visual and tactical experience of the game the artwork in games like tokaido not only serves a functional purpose but also helps to create a vivid immersive World
open-ended exploration design elements of the game that encourage players to explore different strategies or outcomes without punishing them for experimentation this could be through modular boards random event cards or multiple paths to Victory for example in everdell players can choose from various strategies to build their Woodland City focusing on constructing buildings recruiting Critters or gathering resources the game's open-ended nature and numerous paths to Victory encourage players to experiment with different approaches fostering a sense of Discovery and creativity three serious fun real world benefits series fun ties the enjoyment of gameplay to real world outcomes values or learning this key is particularly powerful in educational or lifestyle games but can be subtly integrated into any board game in the following ways educational value design games that teach or inform for instance Ticket to Ride subtly educates players about geography and strategic route planning while engaging them in competitive gameplay players learn about various cities and countries as they build train routes across a map enhancing ing their geographical knowledge and planning skills through a fun and Casual experience themes with real world connections utilize themes that reflect real world activities conflicts or scenarios which can lead to Greater player empathy and understanding as seen
in games like this war of mine reward cooperation and reflection encourage players to reflect on their actions and their consequences potentially rewarding cooperation or decisions that line with real world values or ethical considerations for instance in Hanabi players must work together to create the best possible fireworks display by playing cards in the correct sequence however players cannot see their own cards so they must rely on cooperation and communication this Cooperative gameplay not only Fosters teamwork and strategic thinking but also encourages players to consider the impact of their actions on the group's success four people fun social interaction people fun focuses on the social interactions that games facilitate this is where multiplayer games Shine by creating a framework for players to interact compete and cooperate and you can create this type of fun in the following ways Foster interaction design mechanics that require player interaction such as trading negotiating or teamwork games like Katan and Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective thrive on player interactions that lead to interesting and fun social engagements include roles and characters allow players to assume roles or characters with unique abilities and perspectives enhancing the social and role playing elements of the game Sheriff of Nottingham does this well
with players bluffing and negotiating their way to Victory add social deduction elements incorporate elements of social deduction to encourage discussion deceit and detection which can lead to Lively group dynamics and memorable gameplay experiences as seen in games like werewolf and murder in Hong Kong conclusion by understanding and applying these four keys to fun you can create more engaging and enjoyable games and appeal to a variety of players each key opens different doors for creativity and player engagement making your game not just a product but an experience that stands out in the crowded board game Market what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game a key thing is just to Value fun over things you can only maximize one variable which game is more fun the most fun game or the best balanced game it could be a tie otherwise the more fun game is more fun Donald X Vino chapter 20 harnessing the eight kinds of fun in board game design understanding the various ways people find enjoyment in games can dramatically enhance how you approach game creation I recently found a framework called the eight kinds of Fun by video game designer Mark LeBlanc and even though it was created based on digital games it
still provides a comprehensive lens through which to view and design board games so this chapter explores how each type of fun can be effectively integrated into board game design to create engaging and memorable experiences one sensation creating a rich sensory experience board games that excel in providing sensation affect players senses in various ways to deliver a compelling aesthetic and tactile experience highquality components beautifully Illustrated cards and detailed Miniatures contribute significantly to this kind of fun games like aul with its pleasingly bright and chunky tiles everdell with its Charming 3D tree and intricate artwork and too many bones with its weighted poker chips demonstrates how sensory Pleasures can enhance the enjoyment of the gameplay two fantasy building immersive World fantasy in board games allows players to step into another role or World escaping reality for the duration of the game and designing games with a strong thematic narrative where players feel immersed in a role or setting caters to this type of fun oath sworn for example plunges players into a dark evolving fantasy world where their decisions have lasting consequences allowing them to live out Heroic Adventures three narrative crafting engaging stories narrative fun comes from a
game's ability to tell a story in which players feel actively involved integrating narratives that unfold as the game progresses can turn an ordinary game night into a memorable adventure games like Destinies stuffed fables and pandemic Legacy allow players to impact and be part of an unfolding narrative over the course of one game or multiple sessions Four challenge engaging players intellectually challenge is a fundamental aspect of many board games and involves providing players with obstacles that are satisfying to overcome this can be achieved through strategic decision making puzzle solving or competition games like last Bastion and the captain is dead require strategic planning and adaption while games in the unlock series offer players a rigorous mental workout as they figure out various puzzles all of which is intellectually rewarding and fun to a large segment of the gaming Market five Fellowship fostering social interaction many players are drawn to board games primarily for social interaction games that promote Fellowship allow players to engage in cooperation Andor competition or simply socialize in a structured way eldrich exemplifies this with its Cooperative gameplay requiring players to work together to save the world enhancing both social interaction and teamwork code names is another great example as players try to help each
other make correct guesses using simply a word and a number with often comical results six discovery exploring New Frontiers games that encourage exploration and Discovery tap into the joy of uncovering new strategies Secrets or narrative elements designing games with Dynamic environments or varied strategic possibilities can give players a sense of Discovery in every game seventh continent with its a massive number of map tiles to discover takes players on an exploration driven Adventure where each new tile provides something new to uncover however it can be just as fun to explore A Game's core mechanism for example Dominion allows players to dive into the many nuances of deck building and its enormous number of cards ensures that no two games are the same continually offering new strategies to discover seven expression allowing personalization and self-discovery expression deals with the player's desire to project their identity in into the game through customization or strategic choices that reflect their personal style or values games like Dungeons and Dragons and other RPGs role playing games allow users to create characters down to the finest detail and then occupy that character throughout a campaign with near infinite possibilities eight submission enjoying
the act of play some games are enjoyed simply for the experience of playing not necessarily for competition or achievement these games are often relaxing and can be seen as a way to unwind myth wind is a great example offering simple cozy gameplay that doesn't demand too much mental strain allowing players to relax and engage casually with the game and each other conclusion integrating these eight types of fun into board game design isn't about packing all eight into every game but understanding your target audience and what kinds of fun will most appeal to them by focusing on delivering specific types of fun effectively you can create games that resonate more deeply with players leading to experiences that are returned to and cherished for many years and whether you're enhancing the sensory aspects of a game to heighten its physical appeal or weaving intricate narratives that Captivate and tell memorable stories each type of fun offers unique Pathways to enchanting the players and creating successful games what's your best advice for how a designer can make a fun game no game is for everyone so don't bother trying to make a game for everyone make a game for your audience no matter how small that audience is make a game that some people love and some people hate Nikki valin