Digital Board Gaming - The Mill
Transcript
hello and welcome to the mill I am your host dusty crane in this week I want to talk about something that's kind of a almost a bad word in tabletop gaming and that's digital games first some anyway but before I get to that I want to address the fact that it's been a lot of fun to watch the wingspan Facebook forum and see people getting their games and seeing a ton of people play it and the fact that it has grown to be this giant worldwide phenomenon I mean it's it's amazing right I mean it is so popular now I mean a lot of people are getting into it they haven't been board gamers before so you know they don't know exactly what they're talking about but like you know I keep hearing it called bird box it's everywhere they keep talking about the bird on the box and you know I mean it's so popular even that YouTube has had to tell people stop doing these bird box challenge is because I don't know maybe people are playing the game too long like some of the computer games they do and they they're playing it too long and they get sick and it's and it's awful and people are just dying or something it's it's amazing what you guys are huh a movie no it's not a mood there this is this is the bird box this one right oh I guess you can disregard all that it's a movie
you maybe you guys knew I seem to be the last one to know everything around here anyway yeah so speaking on wing span it has been a very successful endeavor anyway for stone Meyer there are already you know reports of the first run is completely sold out some of the some of the stores are only getting one or two copies the second and third printing is already underway it's been a lot of fun to see how many people are really into this game and hopefully just continues to grow let's talk about the elephant in the room shall we Winx ban is a great game but it's not perfect and by that I mean there's some typos of the game all right the the pink between cards have extra ease and there's a couple of birds that are misspelled and maybe some text that isn't as clear as it could be and some bonus cards that have have a range of cards or eggs or something that doesn't make sense and so when that first came to light people started coming to Jaime and asking how is this being fixed and what are you going to do about this there was the the belief that just because you buy a first print run and you're part of the pre-orders and part of that initial hype that you shouldn't have a lesser game than someone who comes in after the fact
and I understand from a you know from a consumer perspective that you don't like that maybe they're from an early adopter perspective rather that you don't like the fact that maybe you have something that's of perceived lesser quality than someone else and so there was kind of a period of time where Jaime was saying well we'll replace the cards that produce a mechanical problem in the game the gold card you know a bird card when the bird cards has an incorrect victory point value we'll replace those and then there was still a little bit of conversation about is it enough Jaime decided that all these cards that were you know misprinted or would have been fixed in future print runs he's going to go ahead and provide a replacement pack it's it's gonna be still little ways out now because you know it's gonna have to come you know after the the second and third printing here but it is it is being made it's gonna be available through a number of websites I think it's a it's a great compromise I think a lot of people a lot of the people that were originally very vocal about the fact that they weren't happy that their first edition had these errors have come around and finally you know realized that it's a great game and that the errors that person that are there today really don't affect your enjoyment of the game so while you're waiting for that fix pack or whether or not you even
bother to request that fix pack it is a it's something that that is out there and available to you so I think big props to stone Meyer games and to Jamie for deciding that that was the right thing to do by the by the players and the gamers let's talk about scythe or more specifically scythe digital or silence team recently a group of gamers have come together and they started a Facebook page group for a league that's forming they are going to go ahead and start doing tournament play in casual place so if you ever find yourself wanting to play on your computer and you don't have a group of friends that you regularly play with or maybe you're just better than all your friends and you want a a challenge this provides a nice way to you know go ahead and you can enroll in an online tournament at this point its no prizes as far as I know I think it's just you know bragging rights and having fun and some of the conversation I've seen in that group it seems like these are a friendly bunch of gamers to play with and so you should definitely if you have side digital edition or if you have the tabletop simulator instance of scythe it's definitely worth checking out which kind of brings me to the main topic that we're talking about and that is digital editions of tabletop board games now any time you bring up apps and board games you get a clash of the minds you get the
people that say digital has no place in our hobby and then you have the other people that are like no I'm totally in favor of both of those worlds coexisting you really don't have too many people that are like I hate cardboard just give me the board of the digital instance but I'm sure they're there I maybe just don't associate with them no offense I'm sure they're fine but that kind of got me to thinking about you know the different ways we can play digital board games in fact I posted yes on the wingspan Facebook group and I said how is it I think what I actually said was I love you guys so much how is it that no one told me that table topia on the iPad actually has wingspan so yeah if you have an iPad or if you want to play wingspan you don't have it yet or you're on the fence or maybe you just don't want to set it up you can play on your iPad or your PC and that got me to thinking that there are a number of ways to play stone layer games off the table or to to do an on cardboard instance and you know of course that brought up the the the two worlds conflicting that that I mentioned but I just kind of want to talk a little bit about why digital board games exist if there's any value in them if you are interested and didn't even know that this was a thing where you can get
them and what's available where and just kind of like talking about you know the different types so I'm just gonna go ahead and cut to the chase the the three big ones the least that I know of our table topia tabletop simulator and just a full-blown app integration so for example scythe digital edition there's some pretty important differences between all of those different things tabletop simulator in table topia or what you might call like a physics sandbox what that means is that it's not smart enough to know whether you're doing something right or wrong it's basically just here's all the bits play like you would if you had the actual you know version of the game in front of you if you are familiar with how to play the game you play the game how you would normally if you are not familiar with the game you could potentially play entirely wrong you could roll dice inside to decide where you're moving in territories I mean you could just go crazy with some of the the things that it would allow you to do in fact in tabletop simulator there's literally a button to flip the table now you are probably not to be terribly popular if you decide to flip a table but thankfully unlike in real life there is an undo button so you could get frustrated what the table head undo and maybe you got that out of your system maybe that makes for nicer gamers that are nicer competitive gamers I don't know but that is kind of what that physics sandbox is there's no there's nothing in the app or
the game telling you how to play the game it just is the second instance is kind of like a full-blown AI like an actual app where the rules are programmed in so let's say you wanted to move inside for instance and you there's no dice in that but you went to roll a dice that they give the game would actually either not let you roll the dice or it would you know just do nothing because that's not how you how you move so it actually enforces that rule set which is really nice if you're not gonna watch tutorial videos or if you learn kind of hands-on there's a very low barrier to entry in terms of you don't have to set up a game you don't have to risk playing the rules wrong any of those things it just is a nice introduction some of them have tutorials that are really cool I find for me personally that I really really like digital board game apps and I especially for for games that I don't have just yesterday I downloaded Isle of Skye for my iPad and I haven't played it yet but that's one that I've seen that's a game that I've seen recommended several times which kind of make got me to thinking also about a blog post that Jamie wrote I think it was in June last year and it was the truth about digital board games was that a blog entry and it was really fascinating to me because it kind of answered the questions that a lot of people have a lot of people pop into the side Facebook group and they say hey side digital is doing this thing
wrong or you know is it actually doing this thing wrong or my matchmaking is broken like what is going on and they are presenting the the question to stone layer games or to Jamie and it is it's a matter of fact that you know stone way are really just licensed the the size board game out so this isn't a stone layer product itself it is in this case a side digital edition the Knights of unity produced this along with asthma day as MIDI digital so if you had any questions about why side digital is behaving a certain way or misbehaving as the case may be that would actually be the company go to Jamie doesn't actually have any say and how that's done but one of the questions that he you know presented as frequently being asked is why would you do this wouldn't you be worried that if people bought the digital version of the game they're not gonna buy the cardboard version of the game and he mentions that the articles that he's read actually point to the opposite that if you buy the app and you enjoy the app that you're more likely to buy the the cardboard version of the game and from my personal experience that's certainly true I'd heard a lot of great things about Splendor I downloaded the app and have probably played 30 40 50 games of Splendor just in a short period of time and just loved it that made me go out and actually purchase the game I wanted
the cardboard version that I could go ahead and you know much more easily play with with my family verses I think me and my son have actually opened up the app and handed the the phone or the iPad back and forth and played games that way but there's something to be said for that physical the physical texture or the the experience of having actual physical goods in your hand which is you know one of the things that people talk about when they talk about I don't like digital apps because of this is that's one of the things they mentioned it is a tactical experience and I don't or tactile experience and I don't have that when I'm playing a digital board game which is valid what I also find kind of interesting about the whole does this kind of poach sales from you know the the cardboard version is I have access to Jaime and I can bounce questions off of Jaime I also know AJ from Van rider games and I know when he was looking to have an app designed for hostage negotiator this was sort of a grand experiment on whether this was going to help sales or hurt sales hostage negotiator has been in the App Store for a little while now in fact I want to say that it's that it's probably done well enough anyway that they've they've rented continuing to create the abductor packs that you can buy separate since it's been out for a little while I actually send an email to AJ and I asked you know once upon a time you were kind of hesitant or on the on the fence about whether or not this was a good play for the company to produce this digital version of your game how do you feel that it's gone so far and AJ indicated
that you know it is kind of a wash that he doesn't feel that it necessarily drummed up business for the cardboard version of the game but at the same time he doesn't think that it hurt anything so kind of coexists in a nice space where maybe there are you know people that have the game that that love just actually having it in in front of them and then maybe there are the people that just really like having board games just on their their phones and so kind of it was kind of just a wash the next thing I want to talk about is just like what are kind of the pros and cons like the pros and cons of the digital board game that you know one of the things that was that was mentioned in Jamie's blog was that it brings together people that otherwise wouldn't be able to play together these digital instances of the games kind of enable that to whether or not using table topia or a tabletop simulator or an app and so that's that's definitely one of the big things I think it also enables you know people that are more familiar with the game to teach other people that aren't so for example if you have wingspan in your table topia or tabletop simulator and somebody wants to know how to play or they've played once or twice and they are kind of unsure if they played it right and they just want somebody to they wish they had somebody who is more familiar with the game teaching that's something you can easily pop in and do so I think overall for me the pros of digital board games are
greater than the cons but I mean certainly there is I don't think we're ever going to reach a consensus on what is ideally the best way to to or what is the only acceptable way I guess to enjoy our hobby let me go ahead and mention just real shortly there are a few digital titles that are still there in the works that Jamie's mentioned before either in the in the live stream or in that actual blog post they are working on digital copies of viticulture and charter stone and oh I thought there's over between two castles and wingspan so it is nice to see that these games that I enjoy are also gonna be available on in a means by which it's very easily to share now if this is the first time you've heard about tabletop simulator or table topia or side digital let me just kind of run down real quick like what those libraries include table topia pretty much has every I mean I think it actually does have every single stoneware game that's out there that's available to you tabletop simulator has less in terms of official content they have scythe and they have let's see here viticulture and yuphoria they also have something called Steam Workshop this is something that I've been unsure how to feel live in as a consumer I love it that there's a ton of games out there whether or not the developer would actually like them being available I
kind of think of table topia is kind of like apple iOS it's a closed infrastructure you're not making your own stuff but what is put out there you know has a certain amount of polish and it is a you know it's something that a dev team put together it's well assembled whereas I think of tabletop simulator is kind of like the Android of this solution in that anybody can do it it's a wide-open platform if you want to you know put games out there that are you know have never been digital or maybe you know there's some historical instance of a game that people are trying to figure out or if you want a prototype you know any of these things it's very easy to if you're familiar with the toolset to just throw all the bits into this physics workshop and and play a game and so like a lot of times like I mentioned people will just say well I can't find viticulture in this I'll just go ahead and you know download some digital files and put them in there and and play the game and you know that's you know I guess up to you whether or not that's something you want to do or encourage for the stuff that's not available I guess I technically don't see the point the problem but again that's not my IP so Who am I to say yeah I mean I guess it kind of was a more of a rambling topic but it was just kind of something that I that I enjoy talking about in terms of like digital board games and and who's for and who's against if there are any digital copies of games that are
iOS apps in particular that you really like drop it in the comments I would love to know what you're playing what you have got the most I guess play time out of I would also like to know are you one of those people that is like I love digital I hate digital I like you know where the digital is integrated into the into the physical copy of the game I would love to hear your experiences maybe pros and cons for both in the comments if you have any questions or comments for me leave them leave them below if you like what we're doing here hit like and subscribe and if you are still here after all of this thank you so much I'll see you guys next time bye