10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 22
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another episode of 10 board games ranked so in case you've missed it I am changing the format of the show slightly whereas instead of me kind of recapping on all the games I played during the previous month and ranking them I'm going to be doing it for every 10 new games that I play so that way I'll get more content of this type out there and it'll make it a bit more consistent in terms of the quantity of games on each list because sometimes I have months where I play 20 new games sometimes it'll be 10 and so on so this way it's going to be a bit more consistent and regular now before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order at number 10 I have Echoes the dancer so this is a strange concept so it's a murder mystery game that uses audio as the clue so we're going to be doing is you're going to be scanning these game pieces which will give you a clip of you know of sound which could be voices or sound effects and then you try to piece together this storyline to try and solve what happened basically um I suppose the concept is fresh and different but I think in practice it was quite annoying because you'll sometimes forget what one clip was and then you'd have to scan it again and again and again so it became quite tedious and I also thought that the voice acting was a bit cringy and a bit too try hardish so yeah this was not for me at all and I thought it was quite um yeah quite bad
so that is Echoes the dancer at number nine I have dice Topia so this is a little filler die strapping game as you're taking Dice from this communal board and putting it on your own player board the higher Pips are going to give you more points and however you do have personal objectives that you're trying to aim towards as well um the game was fine and I quite like this idea of when you draft Dice from the board you put down a control marker there which will compete for area majorities from where you took the dice from that was quite cool in some conflicting mechanisms there but the big Death Note for this one was the fact that it was not color colorblind friendly at all myself and my brother are quite severely colorblind and two of the dice colors were completely um you know undecipherable from each other you could not tell them apart so therefore the game was pretty much unplayable for me and for that reason dystopia came in at number nine at number eight I have the king's dilemma so this is a game I've been wanting to play for a long time now because the concept of this game is right up my alley as you are these kind of heads of these noble families trying to advise the king and what to do in certain situations now you've all got your own wants and needs and what you're trying to achieve and that is represented through the use of this kind of tug of war board where you're moving these tokens up and down to try and manipulate the Ball State to your needs now I've always been apprehensive about trying this one because although I love the theme and setting and the concept of it I was kind of concerned how that was going to blend with the mechanical side of the game and
I I think after a couple of plays my concerns are right um because the gameplay is quite weak to be honest despite the storyline being you know relatively interesting and some conundrums coming up I think it would have been better a better game if it were completely through the mechanisms out the window and just said you know what play a role-playing game to try and overcome these scenarios and what would happen so yeah I think sometimes it's trying to be too many different things at times and with tug of war games in general I find them quite annoying because you know there's only a few objectives going around there I want all these tokens to be at the top you want them to be at the bottom so obviously we're going to vote on opposite things and it's going to be back and forth and back and forth all the time so yeah unfortunately um these first few plays have not kind of um reassured me on how the game is going to play out but we are going to play it a few more times to see what happens and uh you know what could potentially um you know be added in terms of mechanisms to hopefully make it a bit more gamified but we shall see but right now I'm not impressed and uh the king's dilemma comes in at number eight at number seven I have Stevenson's rocket now I have to say this was a bit of a disappointment for me because it's quite rare that I don't like a rhino Kenichi design now I'm not saying this is bad but it certainly is not for me so this is kind of an entry level 18xx you know Style game as you are investing it in these different train lines you're getting shares in them um and you're going to be extending their tracks trying to make them Reach new cities scoring it different ways now in theory I should like that style of
gameplay but in practice the game was quite slow plodding and even annoying at times because if you wanted to do a simple action to extend a uh you know a railway line you've had to go through this whole process of allowing the other players the opportunity to veto what you've just done and when you want to do that you know each time you play the game by every single turn you can probably imagine it does start to get quite frustrating so unfortunately I think I'd rather play something a bit more straightforward when it comes to this kind of root building you know just stick to something simple like you know Babylonia or Blue Lagoon or through the desert this one was just I had a bit too much tacked on and try too hard to be like a shared Style game so yeah for me I would rather keep those two aspects of the gameplay separate play those other games I've mentioned and if I want to play a simple Stockton share style game I'll probably lead towards something like a choir so yeah I definitely did not see the need to play this one any further I thought the other players I played it with clearly were not enjoying it either so therefore this one is going to have to go and it was not a hit despite not being a bad game objectively so that is Stevenson's rocket number six I have a splendor Jewel so this is the two player only version of the classic game Splendor um this one has Bruno cathala as a co-designer who obviously had amazing success with putting the two-player version out of Seven Wonders with seven wonders Jewel so for that reason I was quite intrigued to see the changes in this one and to be honest I think the changes were all for the better as the way you drafted the um the tokens were a
lot more interesting as you took them from this grid I had some variable scoring as well rather than Racing for those scoring um you know just overall scoring you could race for these crowns or you could even race to have all scoring in a certain column so I like that you were fighting on multiple fronts rather than just one again we do a little bit more on your toes and be a bit more cautious about what your opponent was doing now despite all the minor changes for the better with this one I do feel like um oh I've personally struggled to why you would pick this one up because the changes weren't that much better than the original one because the original Splendor was actually quite a good game at two players and of course you have that versatility of being able to play it with three or four players and to be honest in general I wasn't a huge fan of Splendor anyway I like the design I think it's very well put together game but it felt a little bit too clinical and a bit too sterile for me I suppose so yeah this was just more of the same certainly an objectively good game I can certainly see why it's so popular but it just needs a little bit more flavor for me personally I needed something else going on rather than feeling so procedural and I feel like it feels like a bit of a grind at times so that is Splendid Jewel at number six a five I have hair and tortoise which is probably the biggest surprise of the month and that is mainly due to the fact that this game came out in the 1970s so naturally I think us as you know modern day Gamers feel a little bit cynical when games like this come out you think you know it's going to be bad but let's get on with it and get it over with and it turns out there's actually some pretty cool things uh going on here now
I believe this game was one of the first games out there that did not use dice as a moving mechanism you were trying to race to the Finish but you do that by managing this hand of carrots which is basically your your currency and the more you have carrots you collect the more you spend the further you can move but if you want to be making sure you're making tactical decisions to kind of keep a smooth flow of carrots in your hand so in certain points in the game you might want to be in certain positions or you might want to fall back to collect more carrots as you go I mean there's also this other cool twist where you needed to have below a certain amount of carrots and had to shed these I think it's lettuce or cabbages at certain points on the map to be able to finish it in the first place so they're more tactical decisions that came into play here now I'm not saying this game is great it's certainly adequate and it holds up quite well considering how old it is you know this is 50 years old now and I think maybe a big part of it finishing relatively respectable you know in terms of being a fifth position uh for the episode um was due to the fact that it was way better than I thought it was going to be and I would play it again so that is hair and tortoise at number five at number four I have a gift of tulips so this is a recently fulfilled Kickstarter card game pretty light in its rule set and it has some commodity speculation going on here as you are playing cards into the center or the the market I suppose to kind of boost the different suits that you want to aim towards so if you keep on playing um cards to the market of a certain type then that's going to be the most popular type and therefore at the end of the game if you have the majority of those cards in front of you they're going to
to be worth more points but of course people are competing for these but I do like this decision of having to draw a card and decide what you want to do with it in terms of playing in front of yourself to try and get towards those majorities you know manipulating the market by playing it face up into the market you can play it face down on the market to try and kind of throw a span of the works and misguide your opponents as to what is going to be more popular or you can even give them to your opponents now if you give them to your opponents and they are one of those most popular suits then you get quite a nice injection of points there so you might think you know what you're no threat to me in this suit so if I'm going to give you a boost there and get a massive bunch of points right now rather than at the end and hopefully I still get those points at the end as well so you actually quite like this one I think the more I play it the more I'm enjoying it and I think maybe the the jury is still out on how this is going to hold up after you know several plays at least you know or as you know time goes by but right now I think it's quite a clean game with some pretty cool decisions going on here especially regarding you know keeping cars or giving them away at number three I have heat pedal to the metal so this is a very popular racing game definitely blew up last year and into 2023 and this is kind of the newer version of flam Rouge which is a racing game I already enjoyed but this one is based on the kind of 1960s era of formula one and it has a lot of shared mechanisms as flower Rouge as you are managing this some hand of cards but instead of getting exhaustion cards in this one you are managing your heat Supply uh by not going too fast around
corners and stuff like that so it really is a game you have to manage these cards quite carefully by kind of flipping up and down gears as you go you know the higher gears you're in you can play more cars go faster on those straights but they're going to be a real nightmare on the corners because you're going to go be over spilling in terms of how fast you go but the lower gears are great because of course they give you more control going around the corners and they'll also let you shed those Heat cards from your hand which are basically just clog up your hand doing no good I thought this game was way better than I thought it was going to be I think the first time I played it I thought I preferred the the cleanness and the Simplicity of lam Rouge but the more I played this one I thought you know what I think these changes are actually for the better and add a bit more meat onto the bones so I can certainly see why this one's doing well I think it's going to hold up for a long time to come I'm going to fit that nice niche of being accessible but certainly not silly and having good or having a good degree of decisions to be made so that is here petal to the metal okay so let's get into the top two games and this is where my accommodations are going to begin and we're going to start with another kanitzi game at number two we have quo vatis so quick baddest is actually pretty unlike any other kanitzi game that I've played because I suppose the main aspect of the game is negotiation now what you're going to do is you're going to have this board which is basically a almost like a ladder to try and get up to this kind of main area and what you're going to do is in order to progress on this board you need to cut deals with the other players so you are lobbying for votes to progress in the Senate you can use your
own boat if you want to but sometimes that's not going to be an option but whenever you give your vote away you get points and whenever you move forward on this kind of track you are collecting these points along the way as well so it's always about trying to broker what's going to benefit you but the twist of the game is that if you do not make it to that final Senate that you are not going to be eligible for scoring uh at all so you're always going to have to be aware about what you're giving and hopefully gaining more than you are giving away some tons of scope for creating deals here I think I barely scratched the surface really I haven't paid it at the higher Play account yet as in being five players and I think it's going to go to shine at that Play account but even at that lower Play account of you know three or four players it still works really well especially if you start adding in these new rules which are going to be used in the kind of new Kickstarter version of this Zoo virus you could easily just use those rules in terms of having neutral player pieces on the board and being able to bribe them so um I think the game is really clever I don't have anything quite like it in my collection and it works at a really Zippy pace and that's actually a little bit chest like in the way you Orient here this board and try to line up not only what you need now but what you need in the future because you can start pushing towards other little holding areas and hopefully you get the majority there it could just help yourself without the need of anybody else so yeah really clever game and I really advise you check it out if you do like this really interactive negotiation style ones so yeah this is Zoo sorry this is quo thatis and finally at number one and hands down my favorite game out of these
10. this is sperium so sperium is quite a fascinating game it's almost worker placement in its mechanisms but not quite as you do not have a communal board you have a bunch of cards out there I think it's a three by three grid of cards and you're not placing your workers on the cards to acquire then you're actually placing them in the gaps between the cars meaning you're eligible eligible to score or to acquire the adjacent cards to your meeples but it has this kind of chicken mechanism where the more popular a card is the more expensive is going to be but instead of buying the card you can remove your worker and gain coins equal to the other people surrounding that cards and because money is so tight in this game that is quite a conundrum and it's all about when to bite the bullet and kind of knowing what you're willing to pay for that card before the other players jump in there and then these cards are going to do a ton of different things that should give you one-off abilities um you know increasing your income each round I'm getting these buildings which will give you these cool conversion ratios in terms of cashing in this resource to get points on money um really interesting has a great progression to it as I think it's only five rounds and you know every couple of rounds the cards get better and better and I was very impressed about how smooth this played that core mechanism of surrounding the cards was fascinating to me and yeah really enjoyed it right up my alley in terms of like a 60 Minute Euro with loads of crunchy decisions to be made yeah this is my kind of game I'm going to show I'm Still Loving uh these Games published by estari at many years ago so yeah hands down my favorite game
that is sperium so there we have it that concludes the video hopefully you've enjoyed this new format and we'll continue to do so as I get more of these videos out there and hopefully it'll give me an opportunity to catch up through my shelf of Shame and really push through them but if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye