Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 16

Transcript 11:55

hey everybody and welcome to another installment of board games i got rid of and why so this is a series where i talk about board games that have previously been in my collection but for one reason or another are no longer in my collection and i'll try to give some rationale as to why i made that decision so let's get started with the first game which is ispahan and isbahan is an older euro strategy game and to my knowledge this was actually one of the first dice drafting games out there as you're rolling a big cluster of dice and you're advocating them on these different action spots depending on how common those particular values were rolled so you know say you've three ones for role that might be the most common value so therefore that would associate to the weakest action and so on and then what you're trying to do is you're trying to control these different buildings by putting your influence cubes on them with the aim of scoring victory points and also controlling these caravans of camels um and there's some cool different things as well you could do such as moving this meeple up and down this row or column to knock people off their particular buildings or even to upgrade your player board to make you more efficient and build a bit of an engine as the game went on now i did like the way this game worked it functioned very smoothly it was a lot of fun but the problem with it was there's next to no replayability of the game there's no modularity there's nothing you can switch in or out no additional rules you can add and so every game you type every time you played this one it felt very samey and that incentive just became next uh you know next to none i have to play this one again so unfortunately i couldn't really walk keeping it around because again i didn't have that room to explore anything further so

despite liking it and i do think it's worth at least taking a look at and it just didn't have the hook to keep me coming back now i know there has been a role in right version this game brought out called corinth which might be worth checking out because i'm not sure if it would lend itself to the mechanisms in a better way but they go nice game but ultimately just didn't have the legs to keep going that is ispahan the next game is one that i was massively looking forward to last year this is a game called dark ages by board and dice this one on paper was everything i wanted in a board game i know i love medieval battles i love kind of engine building style things or resource management this one you're doing all of that so it's kind of like a euro 4x style game as you're building up your little civilization from scratch really venturing into new lands fighting off barbarians i mean managing resources accordingly um the thing that was wrong with this game was that it was too slow to get going you know it was such a churn and a slog to start gathering resources and to get this kind of uh you know like a flow of resources going so you can keep doing new things so it felt like a lot of work for a little payoff and it just made the game feel long it made it feel drawn out and it was a shame because again on paper this one looked great now i will say that there were some additional things such as dice combat you know i don't like dice combat and that should have been a red flag for me but i was willing to overlook that because of the other stuff in the game but unfortunately it did drop the ball on some of those things and it just was too slow to get going it really could have done with a kind of a kick start mode you know so you start with a certain infrastructure to get going but

unfortunately there wasn't that so i had to um part with dark ages because because there was no chance it was ever going to get back out onto the table again that is dark ages the next game is called great planes and this was actually another quite anticipated game for me because i was such a big fan of the designer's previous game called mandala this one though is a kind of a rhinoceros style game as you're trying to control these different regions by placing your play pieces out connecting from the last one so you're kind of you know just a point to point movement style game um or a root building style game i suppose you're trying to control these different planes basically um by having the most people on them and then get points accordingly at the end of the game but as you went throughout the game you'd cut these tokens which would let you do things you wouldn't normally be able to such as jumping over mountains or pushing people off spots you want to get onto so it was quite head-to-head it was quite um abstract in its approach and i did like it i thought it was a nice again another smooth design very clean in its approach um but ultimately i always just couldn't help but thinking you know i'd rather play one of those canucky classics rather than this one yeah games like babylonia kingslike and blue lagoon i think just do this style of game better than great planes did it so for that reason i couldn't warrant keeping it and it had to go so that is great planes the next game is called fairy tail in now this is a kind of a modern take on the connect four mechanism as you are building uh or placing tiles in this vertical kind of sandwich board really trying to line them up to get different points in different ways you know majorities or connecting certain symbols

with different symbols and this is by quite a reputable design as well called palo mori who's not done loads of great games this one for me i wanted to like more than i did because it was nice to see you know bringing that older game into into the modern age but for me it was just a bit too simplistic all the scoring wasn't interesting enough it just felt a bit too bog standard and just no real kind of nothing innovative or anything like that which was a shame because again i would like to see that system used in a modern game but this one wasn't the one to achieve that um and i think you know to be honest it was probably more tailored towards a younger audience children etc and not for you know more experienced gamers and for that reason i wasn't going to keep it so that is fairy tale in the next game is tiny epic pirates which of course is part of the tiny epic series and this one um is a bit of a mishmash of mechanisms to be honest it had a kind of a mancala rondelle it had pick up and deliver it had lots of different things going on and for me i don't really think it pulled off the kind of meshing of those mechanisms to a high standard it felt like boring a bit from lots of different games with nothing again nothing new nothing innovative nothing exciting and it just felt like a bunch of different games mashed together in a pirate themed game and while that's fine for a lot of people i think you know people probably could enjoy this one um once once you play so many games it just feels like a copy and paste style game nothing new nothing fresh and those kind of games are just a bit of a gray area for me i'm not really interested in them and you know had some nice

production maybe a little bit too fiddly and a bit too small which i suppose was part of the gimmick but it was okay at best just nothing exciting as i said so that was tiny epic pirates the next game is odin's ravens which is a a pretty light game where you're trying to race these two ravens um well one one person's it's a two player game one person's the black raven wants the white raven and you're trying to get them back to the starting point by traveling up and down these cards by matching these terrain types of cards you have in your hand but it has some cool manipulation of the board as you can play these low key cards which will kind of flip cards around or slide them to make your pathway more efficient and even make obstacles for your opponent so it did have this really cool tense racing system and i would happily play this one again um and this was really used as a kind of a a gateway to introduce my girlfriend into games she really did like this one and we used to play some quite a lot on holiday um and this was actually she picked up herself she does have a copy so i do have the option to play some with her and i didn't really see the opportunity or the the need to keep this in my collection when she has it herself and additionally if i've got to play a two-player game i'm probably gonna play something a bit more advanced and a bit more complex but a nice game one that i'd still recommend for people just getting into the hobby um that is odin's ravens the next game is okay by bruno cathala now this is another two player abstract star game that almost uses the connect four system as well as you're trying to build these rows or columns or of four geisha girls or even create a square of them by claiming these tiles with these

different symbols on them and the idea is you're going to claim one of these tiles put it in front of you and replace it with one of your geishas but that means that your opponent can only place their geisha on one of the matching symbols you've just taken so you're trying to kind of lead your opponent astray to keep them out of your way but not give them the opportunity to create a line of for themselves so it had a good degree of strategy here because you could plan several turns ahead and all the information was available to you and i did appreciate the design that was very very clean very easy to understand but for me personally these kind of abstract style games i don't tend to take a lot of enjoyment from them so despite appreciating them i don't tend to find them fun and i think this is probably the perfect example of that just felt a bit too just yeah just a bit too dry and that's coming from me just not going on it just a bit too a bit too head-to-head-ish so yeah for that reason i didn't really see keeping it around despite enjoying the game i would say you know if you like abstracts this is one to definitely take a look at because um it's very cheap nice production looks good um and the gameplay is solid but just one that wasn't for my personal tastes and you know i'm i can quite comfortably differentiate my taste from a good game and i think this is a good game but just one that's not for me that is okiya the next game is a game called blueprints which is a kind of a dice manipulation style games you're trying to make these formations of dice and pips and shapes um this one for me was just dead in the water once sagrada came out it was not a good a sagrada in any degree shape or form everything cigar did it did better than blue prince did therefore it was

just completely hamstrung and had no need to be played again so um that's simple as that really um if you want a dice manipulation game then that was the one to go for and not blueprints so there you go uh the next game is a kinicia game called kariba another very small box ultra light card game but one that works really well at two players actually so um this is a game where you're trying to play these animal cards around this watering hole and the higher cards you play if you play three of the same kind or whatever is three the same kind down you end up kind of gobbling up the next animal below in the animal chain so like the eights will eat the seven sevens with the sixes and so on and you're basically just trying to collect these cards for points at the end of the game um and i did like the game it had a very fast flow to it it was quite chaotic especially when you did have the three or four players but it worked well and ultimately because i did prefer this game at two players and it was a lot more had a lot more depth to it than you might first meet the eye of two players but still not enough to the point where i would pick this one above a lot of the other two player games i have so for that reason it i didn't know despite appreciating the design and liking it it was just sat on my shelf for such a long time with no almost no sign of it coming back off the shelf so i think when it gets to that stage i have to make that decision and be a bit um a bit aggressive and say you know what you have to go and create some space for something else so that was the case for kariba what i'd like to have kept hold of because i do like the game but um you know space is a premium in my collection so it had to go and the final game i'm going to talk

about is one called island siege uh this one i only played this game once so you know forgive me if my memory is a bit foggy on this one this was a game about trying to build up these fortifications and then put your basically basically get your meeples onto the board basically that's one of the winning conditions but you'd build up these fortifications by placing these cubes on them and then your opponent would come and attack those by rolling dice so it was quite lucky you know very dice-driven combat um and you're basically trying to build these buildings as well behind these fortifications and get different abilities and stuff it was it was fine at best i didn't really enjoy it and i just found that dice combat a bit too you know far too lucky really if someone kept rolling well then you've pretty much got no chance at all to win um so that was it really just not a game for me and um that's pretty much my extent of my memory on ireland siege so there we go that's another 10 games that left my collection you know hopefully these videos are useful to you and i've got a big library of these now so if you want to check out all the previous videos then please do so because they are timeless and they're not going to date at all and if you want to know more about games that left my collection then um you know check these videos out but for everyone else um you know please be sure to subscribe to the channel hit like um leave a comment if you have anything or anything to say about these games and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now

Progress saved