Skip to main content
Loading video...

Replacing Catan with Science!

Transcript 14:22

sometimes there's just something about a game that you just can't explain something special maybe it's the art maybe it's the mechanics maybe it's just the way the game makes you feel we've decided to take the most popular board game of all time Monopoly no Katan and break it down into its mechanics and suggest you a game that we think does those mechanics better we're essentially replacing Katon using science science do you know that reference No She Blinded Me With Science oh I know what you'll

get i e wood for sheep now I have along this road theame doll doll doll doll doll dollar doll doll doll the bo bill bill bill B Bill take this whole exercise as being a little tongue and cheek you know it's not one of those videos where we just sort of hate on Katan because it's old and it's like nickel back now so it's cool to hate on it atph I obviously would like Katan it's a thing that brought me into the hobby at least my copy is like look at it this is what it used to be called the settlers of Katan in my day we just wanted a way to suggest new games that we think do certain mechanics makes just a little bit better and to spice things up we decided to select games that the other person doesn't know about just make things a bit more interesting but we have some general rules that have to be followed first and foremost it has to be the same play time as sellers of Katon you can't go suggesting Twilight Imperium an 8 Hour game because Twilight Imperium has trading and it has to be the same level of complexity you can't pick a really complex game for a replacement for Katon that's absurd and it has to have the same player count so two to four players those the rules we begin with with random resource production and Resource Management what that means is that the resources you gain in the game are randomly distributed to qualifying players so think rolling a six in Katon and if you have a settlement on ore you get ore there's just something really fun about

chucking these two dice and then just seeing what you get there's an element of chance it's that sort of calculated gambling it's it's what makes Katon so fun I think I think it's ironic coming from you since you're that person that whenever you're unlucky game or you don't get the numbers you want you are such a potty mouth a RNG man sometimes you got to blame the gods bad luck if I lose a game it's because of bad luck never a bad planning no just bad luck but it is a big part of Katan you know it's not fun when everybody gets the exact same amount of resources all the time and the game that we ended up picking for this and yeah we ended up picking the exact same game and we share a collection after all was bad company we think bad company does that component much better than sers on it it just feels much more fun so bad company players take on the role of rival gangs trying to earn as much Heist money as possible by recruiting new members outrunning the police completing jobs and just chucking tons and tons of dice when we play Katon and the different numbers come up I always feel like it's very unfair with Bad Company we all have our own board but Al you have all the numbers so if there's a two or five gets rolled you don't you don't get nothing from it you get something but the fun part of the game is that you can really stack up on a certain number and so get that thrill of like am I going to roll a six and you roll a six and then you just get this heap of just various resources where with Katan I feel like a lot of times if a number that like it's not you don't have anything on that number and say rolled it just feels like it can be a little disheartening yeah especially

when it happens over and over and over again but like we said you're always at least getting like you're getting a consolation prize I guess but also in Bad Company you you still have that agency you still have that sense of control because it's up to you what numbers you want to double down on because you can spread thin and just put more guys on every single number or you can double down on the you know eights and sixes are the numbers that appear a lot it's kind of the same thing in Katana you know you make sure you build your settlements on numbers that appear more regularly so you have and I think that's important I think that's important whenever you're dealing with some element of Randomness that you want to feel like you have some some some possibility of control a bad company for example does a much better job at making you feel that you've control over it than Katan does next is trading in negotiation which sees players trading in-game resources and sometimes out of game favors in order to gain benefits for themselves yes that's my favorite part about the G yeah it's it's there it's just a lot of fun and for whatever reason I don't know why it just doesn't seem to be very popular at contemporary board games and I kind of get it cuz I guess like it can add a lot of playtime right because players can kind of bog a game down with trading like I know when you're trading at settlers and you're just like uh do you have brick no oh oh you have brick okay I'll give you this I no okay how about this and it just goes on and on and on so my pick for trading and negoti it has to be Lords of Vegas Lords of Vegas just does trading so so amazingly well I don't know why but like it really does when you're playing it it makes you feel like you're this like Crime Boss even though there's no crime in the game where you're just sort of like controlling maybe where you're just kind

of controlling these casinos and you're like wheeling and dealing with other players and I think it's because you can trade with a lot more in in in in in Lords of Vegas and you can in Kon because you can give out your casinos you can give out money future favors I am I I love that's I I like Lord I love that game it's in my top 100 it's it was one of the first games where I I played against you and I won so drastically against you and it really gave me that like that love you know you know you know we you do something really well and it inflates your Eagle like crazy that was the first board game that gave me that feeling was it because of the trading and it was because of the trading and because people stop trading with me after a while like what are you supposed to do but I still love the game so so like a lot of our viewers I know I've mentioned this before but like miking become a sore loser I'm not a Sol loser he's very Petty I'm vindictive yes and he is one of those people that like likes to be a mean player for the fun of being mean he fun to be mean and so when it comes to there not not full games that focus on trading but when the very few games that do like Katan like lot of Vegas which I absolutely love people can start getting their Revenge to him in a certain way CU it's like oh you're so mean to us ha I wanton trade with you then then you can suffer and so I remember becom like a like insane millionaire the first game we played and Mike was just poor and I was like this is hilarious this is great all our friends sign it with me it was fantastic but there's a lot of cool like mean ways to trade in in Lords of Vegas that you're not going to get with Katan because you can sort of trade a person's casino right you don't have to you don't

have to be mean but you can trade for a person casino without them actually knowing that you're going to use their casino to creep over to to the other Casino they own and then take it over that's the way I like to play and that's what makes it fun that's why I feel like a Crime Boss every time I'm playing that's why people don't trade with me lot of Vegas would have been my like ordinary mention cuz I really really love what you heck down it's off yes it's not a trading Focus game but it's an element to the game and I think it's an element that makes that type of game so unique and we have many deduction based games that we play and I think the training element in that one kind of like tips it over the edge of like the top type of deduction type game for me just because a lot of deduction games like I love like Planet X but it's so Sol right you're playing in a group but you're really focus on just what you're doing and very often in these games you get a clue and then you're just adding it to your game and as much as I love solo Focus type games in a group setting it's something about being able to share and kind of create like you kind of pick the people that you're supporting and helping kind of cuz you can choose the type of Clues you give them and whether or not you want to give them like a lot or very little and then give them back the same stuff they've given you I think it adds a whole different layer of complexity and fun to the game absolutely and it just it it offers a way for the game to have some element of interaction where otherwise there would just be none and so that it's that for that it's pretty cool next we have networking in roof building which sees players trying to connect various destinations for in-game benefits Network in roof building Caton is is really important you know there might be

that you've been Gathering a ton of ore and so you're trying to build your network and your route towards the the two for one or trading spot there's just something about building those roots that's just like really satisfying and so the game I picked would have to be equally satisfying and I think that's witchstone witchstone is a game that I don't think anybody talks about at all have I believe you didn't you have yeah we played it it we played Andrews like a few weeks ago it's one of those games where like yeah the the main component is sort of placing down those action tiles that trigger off other action tiles and and that is really rewarding and I think that overshadows the network in root building which occurs in the game which I equally love where you're sort of like guiding your I don't know how to call them like hen witches I don't know you build a route for for essentially them to travel and gather resources and and try to take over other little cities for victory points and I think it really captures that same element of chasing a distant resource that that Katan does literally in my mind a root building game is CH Cho very that's what I figured I was like I don't want to make something it's just like train game you think you know what I pick yeah you picked Ticket to Ride I thought strongly very strongly right but that is not my pick actually my personal pick would have to be Carnegie Carnegie you're building the route to connect different locations you don't have to build a really long route like it's just it gives you what 20ish points 18 points at the end of the game so it's not a Make It or Break It plus it gives you that opportunity to screw other players because essentially if you can tell that

they're trying to connect I don't know some place in the South to some place in the west you can go like oh I'm going to put my thing here and then you blocked them just like in Katon that's the best part of Katon you can tell a person's like he kind of trying to get to that spot on the board to build their settlement and he was like I'm put a road there and he just blocked them off if you can't sense the pain I feel if I'm playing games with him sometimes I really do feel like there's sense of satisfaction in connecting that route and I think I get it with katal I really feel that with Carnegie with a game like Carnegie the map is kind of pre-decided with Carnegie you have to pre-plan where you want to go and then make that rout and so for me like it's it's the most strategic game of play and makes the root building more intent like um like there more intent going into it next we have endgame racing and negative player interaction which sees players attempting to achieve a particular objective as quickly as possible and end the game all all trying to negatively impact the performance of other players using in-game actions negative to interaction actually I would say for mic specifically applies to every game he likes any game he loves is like oh I have to find a way to destroy everyone else to make them all the if you see me in a convention be sure to play with me you'll hate me when you see a person sort of getting out in ahead you want a way to sort of mitigate that just bash them down essentially and that's you can do in Katan when somebody gets to like those seven or eight victory points nobody trades with them anymore and of course everyone starts targeting them with the robber once they roll that seven and start stealing all the

freaking resources which we always love in Katan and the game I pick is actually I don't know you haven't played it you haven't played it it's wizar wizar sees you as one mage battling other Mages all in an effort to get victory points so you can get victory points either by capturing the other Wizard's chests or you get victory points by defeating them and killing them it's like a death battle and like Katan you are racing and the game is entirely under the player's control whoever gets to those two victory points first will end the game and all of the game is negative player interaction you're not helping anybody you're out to help yourself and that's it it is incredibly I as I said in my top 100 video If you haven't seen that check it out it is just dumb in the best possible way it is silly it is filled with like Stacks and stacks of cards that all seem to combo off each other in like random weird ways but it's just it's a it's a blast to play and it's fun to be mean to people and turn into giant monsters and punch holes through their heart you know and you can't do that in Katon yeah you can only Rob people in Katon I want to punch people with my werewolf fists and cast Fireball lightning bowlt lightning bowt did you get that reference lightning I forget it my watch just to uh gave me a remind that I'm stressed are you stressed why oh nothing not no my VI stress inducing or living somebody wants to turn into a monster and punch people through the heart why' you pick what' you pick K Tokyo has the best negative player I hate negative player interaction games I hate when someone's getting in my way of my goals whatever

I'm trying to achieve and focusing on that's why you beat them down no it's like I'm a very stain your only Lan kind of person but then King of Tokyo like it's the one that games where I'm like I enjoy it I enjoy forcing someone else into CH you or for someone else is seeing them like lose Health points I really enjoy that it says a lot for someone like me that hates negative interaction games to love negative interaction in a game that focuses strongly on it but I think it's also more of a to me a party type game different long shot is too it's more of a party type game but it's okay don't mind those you still they still really capture that it's the same thing with like placing the robber down in Katana you know you want to beat up on the leader and that what wraps it up hopefully you enjoy to this list of games obviously there's no replacement for a Katan yeah Katan will always hold a special place both our hearts before we met like when we first met and he asked me like oh do you play a board games I'm like like Katon yeah I like that katan's become this new thing that you can sort of test out as to whether or not a person you don't know is familiar with games that you enjoy you know what I mean cuz like even if you don't play Katana anymore you can be like no not like Monopoly when they say like oh Bor game is like Monopoly like no more like Katan and then it makes it makes it less you're either a monopoly player or a Katon player yeah so let us know whose list was better cuz it was mine the end bye but this game she blind She Blinded Me With Science bye everybody she blooded Me With Science

Progress saved