Top 10 Hidden Gem Board Games - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 hidden gem board games so the criteria i've used to evaluate these games is i've used board game geek as a bit of a template really and looked at how many owners there are of each of these games in these examples all of these have less than or fewer than um you know 1 500 kind of owners so in that ballpark so not many people are owning these games i don't really see them in anyone's collections i never see anybody playing them that kind of thing but they're all really solid games i do enjoy quite a bit and i thought they would have been much more popular than what they are and i think they deserve to be more popular and more spoken about so let's get started at number 10. so at number 10 i have mamat by queen games this one is a very kind of family friendly game about trying to collect these different items to get victory points so pretty standard fare there you know very simple set collection game but the thing i love about this game is the way you actually gather those goods in the first place because it's got this very primitive caveman theme and we have a bunch of these objects in the middle of the table so you've got like your your meat chunks and you've got your kind of bonfires and things like this and the idea is that you can take as many items as you want from the center and put it in front of you and that's going to be your kind of horde for this round scoring but then the next person can either take another big chunk from the center or they can take your bunch of loot that you've just collected off you minus one of those items and then put that one item they've ignored back into the center of the table so there's this constant jockeying for
position as people are just kind of tinkering trying to work out exactly what they're happy with until eventually everybody settles with what they're happy with and then a number of things are assessed such as i said collecting different items trying to collect all these different animals for end game scoring trying not to be they play with the fewest amount of something very standard set collection things but that one twist of how you gather these um resources is really compelling and i'm surprised i've not seen this in anything else so i do really appreciate games that do something a bit different to everything everything else out there and i think mama did a great job of that as i said i think i think a lot of family weight gain usually people who like these kind of gateway level games should really take a look at mama because i think they could get a lot of fun out of this one and um again this has all the kind of tools that these popular games seem to have but for some reason or another mama has gone very much under the radar and um has kind of fallen into that hidden gem category for me so certainly worth taking a look at this one is mammoth and number nine i have pyramids so pyramids is a game by um pretty famous designer matthew dunston uh this one is a a game of i guess some quite interesting mechanisms in there i think this one uh accommodates two to i think maybe even five players um and you are trying to basically choose one of these um these rolls by these different god cards all these tiles and you're going to collect these tiles and these towers are going to have some
quite important information on them because it's going to give you priority at drafting cards uh the lower number you choose but also going to give you the ability to do less with your turn so there are kind of three scoring criteria in the game you've got your pyramid which you're adding to every turn and the idea is you're trying to match up all these different colored stones and trying to get you get points for your biggest kind of collection of those stones that are touching each other you've got the obelisks which you're trying to get the same color in every single layer on those on these obvious and you've also got a crypt as well where you are trying to have the most discarded cards of a certain color to get end game scoring um but the idea is you can either choose to get priority in order to get the um set of cards that you want you know if you want a particular item or you can maybe give yourself um you know a lot less autonomy in the cards that you get to pick but you get to do more with your turn so you know if you go first you only get to add to your pyramid but if you go last you get to add your pyramid your obelisk and your crypt but if you go in the middle you probably only get to do your um your pyramid and your obelisk or your pyramid and your crypt so i love that idea of you know having to go first and getting a lot of say in what you get all having to go last getting loads of actions but not getting a chat not getting much say in what you get in the first place that itself is really cool it has a nice puzzly element to it as you're trying to line up all these bricks trying to get everything linked together really satisfying gameplay and um again not much i can criticize about this game because i think it comes together
really well in a nice simple compact game loads of variability in the cards that you get in this one and some really interesting kind of routes you can go down and getting points as well so a really solid filler game that i'm surprised isn't in more people's collection because it is so pleasant it's so accessible yet still really engaging with that core tile drafting mechanism which i absolutely love so that is pyramids at number nine at number eight i have mask of the red death now mask of the red death is a really unique game that i've not seen anything like so this one matches or merges simultaneous card play with deduction and programming and the idea is that we are trying to collect as much information about where this red death is going to be at certain times throughout the night and we're trying to navigate our kind of particular because everybody's got their own little character with the miniature um and you're trying to work out whether whether death is going to be at each of these times in order to try and avoid them when that clock strikes midnight sounds a bit out there and it is a bit out there but the game mechanisms themselves are pretty clean and simple so i love the fact that once you've once it's time to go when it gets to midnight you are mapping out on your little rondelle where where you're going to go you know i'm going to go clockwise then i'm going to go anti-clockwise then i'm going to stay where i am then i'm going to go clockwise again and then you are basically revealing um revealing cars from this death um from this red death deck and he's going to be going with this
this death figure is going to be going from area to area eliminating players who have not worked out the puzzle properly and again the last man standing with the most popularity is going to be the winner uh really interesting game i'd love to see something like this go out there again that's said great visuals amazing artwork great miniatures really characterful bright vibrant board um i do not understand why this game is not more popular than it is but if you do have a uh a gaming group where you're consist or consistently playing with five or six players and you like your deduction then this one is certainly one check out because it's a lot of fun and um again it got a lot of things that it does differently to almost everything out there on the market so that is mask of the red death at number eight at number seven i have the big score now this one is a pushy luck and drafting game so another mixing of strange mechanisms this one is broken into two very distinct phases and the idea is that we're supposed to be these kind of bank robbers um initially doing these smaller heists and eventually doing the big heists on this um kind of the great big bank and the first part of the game is based on car drafting where you everyone's going to have a hand of cards and those cards are going to show different kind of specialists you've got like your getaway drivers your hired muscles you've got your your hackers and you're going to be secretly drafting these cards and passing them on and eventually once every draft of their cards they're going to be allocating them to these different jobs which have
different kind of requirements to fulfill them and it has this blind bidding mechanism where um you know you're going to secretly allocate them and once everybody's allocated all their cars they're going to be revealed and if they if these kind of objectives have been met by all the players as a as a kind of community then your whoever's contributed is going to get um get the reward from that particular job but there's a cool twist on that part alone is that you can really kind of invest in getting a job done by yourself to ensure that you get the rewards or you can piggyback on other people investing and by just maybe contributing one card and i'm getting a bunch of loot that way so i love that idea in the first place so that's that's cool in itself but the second part of the game is where the real pushy luck gets um gets into motion where you are constantly diving into this um into this vault and pulling towels out a one at a time and you can choose to back out if things are getting a bit too heated because there is this track where the police tokens go up and if it reaches a certain point then everybody still in the vault is going to get caught and have all their loots removed from them so there's that real cool pushy like aspect where you want to keep egging people to go in and get more and more loot and hopefully try and um you know bluff them into staying in while you back out and get them caught by the police so it's got that kind of semi-cooperative feel there and um it works really well and i enjoyed this one quite a bit um got a lot of legs out of it um i think if you want a more pure pushy
luck game you're probably going to want to go something a bit smaller but if you want something that does the card drafting and push your luck then um then the big score does a great job of that you know it takes about 45 minutes to play anyway um but a really solid game that i think a lot of people could enjoy if they only knew about it so that is uh the big score at number seven at number six i have a merchant of missouri's now this is a game uh kind of a trading game as you're kind of buying and selling spices something a bit like jaipur so if you like jaipur i think you're going to like merchants of maziras so this one has an element of work placement as well as you have these bunch of different trader cards out and all your 10 is going to consist of is using one of these traders which are going to let you kind of gather cards they're going to let you sell cards and sets because the idea is you're trying to get as much money as you can by selling you know pairs or triples of cards but the the trick as well to this game is that the cards aren't only based on um worth by selling but they also have their own unique power associated to them as well so you've got this kind of dual used card system where you've got powerful abilities um associated with the cars that are worth more but um you know the cards that are worth less coins are going to have weaker abilities to them as well so you've got that balancing act there um there's it just flows really nicely this one it's got loads of replayability because every game you're going to have a bunch of different work replacement cards out there you've got different kind of end game scoring
criteria different end game triggers so it's very very um modular you can plug things in change things and that does add a lot of legs and mileage into the game and in fact i actually enjoy this game quite a bit more than jaipur which i know is an amazingly popular game um and i'm surprised maziris doesn't quite um you know well hasn't even nearly reached the popularity of jaipur's even though i think the gameplay is quite a bit stronger and um gorgeous production as well you know looks lovely great artwork and um just a solid game that should be looked at more so that is merchants of zerus at number six at number five i have chate now chate is a game by reina kenitzia who is one of the most if not the most prolific board game designer of all time made hundreds of classics of thousands of board games um this one is uh an ultra simple tile placement game for strictly two players and it has a uh a real abstract feel to it and quite a tense feel to it as well as you have these tiles made up of these different terrain types you've got only two terrain types you've got the kind of sea area and you've got the land area and each player is going to be kind of controlling one of those too and the idea is you're going to be placing these tiles out in this nine by nine sorry three by three grid and trying to kind of link up the biggest mass of their depicted area as they can by the time that ninth tile is placed out but not only can you bring it draw out new
tiles and place them onto the board you can actually manipulate the tiles on the board by rotating them 90 degrees which can just completely change the face of the uh or the state of the board this is constant back to back and forth a real brain burnery game because this game is pretty much abstract now all the information is in front of you and just knowing the right move to make can be extremely um you know brain wracking um but i love that it's such a clean crisp and razor sharp design i'm in a tiny little box and i love the way this game does so much for so little so that is uh chat a at number five uh at number four i have break the code a break the code is a a deduction game i do tend to like deduction game this one is probably one of the most mathematical examples of a deduction game that i've ever played if not quite strongly the most mathematical one where you are basically given a series of these numbered tiles and everybody's given these tiles and there's going to be a number in the center of the table which are trying to deduce what they're going to be by um choosing or the gameplay is going to be choosing these cards and you're going to be asking questions based on those cards to the other players so it might say you know what do your three highest numbers um total what are your three lowest numbers total now what's the difference between your lowest number and your highest number and as you're gaining more and more this information you should be able to work out how what the numbers have been taken out of the game and um
yeah if you gravitate towards uh the maths or mathematics then you are probably going to enjoy this quite a lot and you're going to be quite a bit better than someone who isn't so you know mathematical orientated like myself you know i'm terrible at this game but i appreciate how um just how precise this game is and um you can really do a lot with a few flu with a few clues if you could only understand what the information is trying to tell you a wonderful example of of deduction it's really pure um creative i like the way you don't actually have to ask or think of the questions yourself um you know you've always got a bunch of cards in the center of the table you just draft which card you want to ask for the other players which um which keeps things ticking along nicely and keep things um you know keeps things sped up so yeah a really solid game and um i think if you love your deduction games this one is certainly one to pick up that is break the code at number four at number three i have tumble town tumble town uh is a a game actually made by the same designer as calico which was a really popular game in 2020 this one again came out in 2020 but received next uh no buzz hardly anybody backed it on kickstarter but this game is rock solid it's a a card drafting resource management game where your resources are essentially dice and you're using these dyes to build buildings which require certain um certain depictions of dice on
them so it might say in order to build this building you need a a gold dye you need a black dye and a grey dye and they need to total over 14 for example and if you do that you're going to build that building you're going to add it to your little town which can give you more further bonuses um and i'll get you points at the end of the game it's ultra quick ultra simple but i love the dice manipulation that goes into this game because you end up acquiring more and more of these cards and the cards give you powers as well that might say you know re-roll your die or flip the flip the die from one face to the other um you know convert this die into these two other dice so i love the different manipulation and the powers you can use you get a little bit of an engine going it's got a good spatial puzzle um really fast engaging gameplay and with the low rules overhead um almost has a nice table presence as well because you have this blueprint of your city and you're physically building the buildings with the dice so you've got like a you know what might be like a tower of three dice and you stack them on top of each other and things like that really pleasant game another family-oriented game that i i'm a bit like um mama if this game just had the right marketing had the right artwork this would be absolutely huge and i i think my my feelings are that maybe long time you know in three years time or so word will spread about how solid this game is and it might get a new reprinting new artwork and things um particularly as the designer is doing so well this game is great a really good game and i would really endorse this one that
is tumbletown at number three now at number two i have another game from last year this is monasterium now monastery is certainly the uh the heaviest game and most involved game on this list and to be honest um i didn't put this one at number one despite this one being my favorite game on the list because i think there's still time for this one to take off you know only came out last year had a relatively big publisher but by um dlp games i believe um and so i said there is time for this one to take off gained a bit of momentum and it could be a bit of a slow burner and i could end up eating my words and this one being a hidden gem um but i love this game it is a game where you are rolling dice and you are allocating those dice on these different um spots on the board and as as you're allocating these dice everyone's doing the same thing and once they're all allocated you are choosing or drafting these guys from those spots to take certain actions which are kind of traveling along this board and visiting these different um different churches uh you are sending people off to worship in these churches you're trying to collect these different stained glass windows for your board you are investing in your board to get more actions from the different drafting spots lots of euro goodness in this game and the reason why it's on this list is because it has a very few owners didn't come out to any fanfare whatsoever and i'm just surprised about that because it has a lot of things people like you know people love um euro games that have a core mechanism
involving dice um it has a good amount of set collection it's got variable goals that you're trying to go for looks really nice has a classic euro feel to it yeah it takes all the boxes for me personally and um i'm hoping that it will eventually um get out there people will start to appreciate what this game brings to the table because it is fantastic so that is monasterium at number two and finally the game at number one is xi'an uh the terracotta army this one is a game that has very few owners on board gameweek only has 800 which baffles me this game is a uh a really interesting game with some great table presents actually because you have all these different kind of terracotta statues which you can end up painting your own color and transforming into your own player color the idea is you are trying to put as many of these statues out not only to get initial bonuses but then you're painting them your color by collecting these pigments and for area majorities as well and on top of that you've got some set collections you're trying to collect all these different weapons um but the thing i really took away from this game is the card system because you can have a deck of cards and everybody starts with an identical deck and each from for rounds around you're going to be drawing four cards and you're going to be putting them in two pairs of two and the anatomy of those cards is interesting because not only does it have a number on them which kind of dictates your initiative in in other words who's going to go first in the turn by playing the highest
number but it also shows the action you're going to get as well so you're putting these cards together where you know do i want to be the first to do this action or do i want to use the powerful action of that number one um and use the initiative of another card see that idea process is really important because being first player is paramount to get the work to play some spots that you want because there are only four worker placement spots anyway and you can't share the same spot as someone else and um it's a real tight and precise and concise game that has a lot going on in it while still being extremely digestible having interesting decisions um really clean mechanisms you know you've got a track you can go down and get bonuses simple area majorities um managing your resources um trying to get a collect brick to build the statute in the first place trying to collect the pigments to paint them your color trying to um collect the artifacts to um you know to decorate your statues to get end game set collection bonuses ticks all the boxes for a uh an entry-level euro uh euro game and you know games like lords of water team games like stone age um they they just seem to be consistently popular i mean there's work replacement games and for me xi'an is better than both of those games and nobody talks about it it looks good not the not the best of component qualities but it's good enough um get innovative mechanisms that do things unlike anything else but still some familiar mechanisms as well you know you i said the work
replacement is good the hand management is excellent i i love this one it's a real solid game and probably the perfect example of a hidden gem that i've um that i've ever played because okay nobody talks about this i just do not know why because it is just perfectly solid there's nothing wrong with this game whatsoever there's multiple paths to victory um the the decisions are interesting because some of these cars you can play early and end up getting kind of bonuses you go throughout the game unless you've got a bit of an engine there or you can play those cars later and just take them for a bunch of points again i could talk about this game for ages but i would highly recommend checking this one out if um if you do like your lighter end of the scale euro games uh this one is one of the best examples of that so um that concludes my top 10 hidden gems uh if you have enjoyed this video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too also if you are a uh if you are really supportive of the show i really appreciate it if you check out my patreon page where you can support the show for as little as two pound a month for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye