5 Games with a PERFECT Mechanics Score
Transcript
I'm going to call this video five board games with a perfect mechanic score and that's probably a really silly thing to do because more so than any other attribute mechanics is subjective to give you an example the other four attributes which are theme components strategy and complexity if I were to take any one of them I could find two board games where generally people will agree take theme for example which game is more thematic splendor or Autobon even without playing those games you can probably think of the answer just by looking at the pictures here's another one which game has better components Tang Garden or food chain magnate regardless of what your precise definition may be if you are English speaker it is easy to distinguish between Extremes in the other four attributes but mechanics is different because if I was to compare any two games I could probably find two people who have a differing opinion on which game has a better mechanic score and that's because there are four factors that weigh into people's evaluation of a game's mechanics so in this video we're going to take an indepth look at board game mechanics and what makes a game truly engaging hi my name is Ben this is board game dad and this is the third video on
a series on what makes great board games in my last video about thematic board games I talked about five different definitions for what people would consider thematic and how that would have an impact on a theme rating so similarly when it comes to mechanics I think there are four factors to consider and depending on how a person weights these four factors they're going to have a different rating on mechanics so those four factors are Innovation Elegance focus and fun and if you're curious to see how I'm going to give you five board games that have a perfect mechanic score my goal is to maximize these four factors so let's describe what each of them means so first let's talk about Innovation we see Innovation whenever we encounter a game that's doing something that no other game has done before the first example I'd like to mention is a game that's appropriately named named Innovation and in Innovation it's a card game where like many other games a person's action can trigger an effect for their opponents but the way that the effect is triggered depends on the level of innovation that their opponents has reached a player performs in action and then they count how many matching icons are on their player board that match the action that they're performing any other player who has equal or more icons as the active player gets to
perform the action as well or if the action is aggressive the aggressive effect is prevented for that player now because a player's player board is constantly changing with icons being added or removed throughout the entire game this means that the triggered effect can always be changing somebody can be doing something that you don't like and you want them to stop it because their engine is just too powerful and in this game there is something you can do you can out innovate your opponent and once you have more icons than they do you either get to perform the action as well or they're being aggressive you can stop them from doing that thing to you it's an excellent Innovation for an Innovative board game called Innovation or another game is Twin Palms Twin Palms is a trick-taking game and I've played so many trick-taking games they are also very Innovative but Twin Palms is the first trick taking game I've ever played where a trick consists of playing two cards so because you're constructing the card you play you can decide whether you want to play a strong card or a weak card just by constructing either a strong or a weak pair of cards it's an entirely different game and certainly very Innovative now sometimes when a game is truly Innovative it gets picked up by other games as well for example Seven Wonders was the first time I played a card drafting game and now there's such an abundance of card
drafting games that I'm not so impressed by that Innovation anymore not only that but sometimes a later game can come out and do what the previous game did only better when it comes to this I call that elegance elegance is what I call it when I see a game that reduces clutter and really improves the flow of a game so one example of a game that I think is truly elegant is King Domino King Domino is a tile placing game where turn order really matters now in a lot of games there's a turn order phase and then there's some sort of action phase in King Domino a player chooses the tile they want to place and in choosing their tile they Place their Pawn in the turn and order for the following round so gaml is really Swift it starts with players placing tiles and then because turn order is already determined for the next round we just just replace the tiles and play the next round take tiles replace the tiles take tiles replace the tiles it's a lovely pattern that makes for Swift gameplay and it just feels so elegant another game that I find remarkably elegant is Paint The Roses paint the Roses is a logical deduction game but whereas a lot of other logical deduction games have an answer which is either hidden somewhere in a table like crypted or supported in an app like the search for Planet X or Alchemists in paint the Roses the answer is held in the hands of the players every player
has a card and on their turn they're placing a tile and using their player markers to indicate where their pattern is satisfied the objective of players is to guess each other's cards based on the hints they give one another paint the Roses doesn't require an app it doesn't require a table and it balances out gameplay because during every single turn one player cannot participate in the discussion among the rest of the players which means that if you've got that Alpha player in the game sometimes that Alpha player will be excluded from the conversation and gives the rest of the players a chance to really work together on their own if this is something you'd like to take a closer look at you can try the game on board game arena as well I'll leave links in the description another factor to consider is focus there are games that have a greater Focus or emphasis on their mechanics than other games you see this best exhibited in games that are inspired by their predecessors take for example Puerto Rico and San Juan both of these games have the same mechanic in common it is an action selection mechanic where the active player chooses an action and then every other player gets to perform a related minor action however Puerto Rico the predecessor has a lot more going on on with player boards and goods to trade and ships that are going out so there's more focus on
additional mechanics whereas San Juan exists to strip out all the extra stuff and hone in on the the most distinct and arguably the best part of uh Puerto Rico that action selection mechanic so a greater Focus May lend itself to a higher mechanic score or another example is the difference between Twilight Struggle and Watergate now both games again have the common mechanic of card play where every card has two effects an effect that helps you an effect that benefits your opponent so the struggle in both of these games is how do I get the most out of my cards while conceding as little as possible to my opponent but the difference here again in Twilight Struggle the predecessor you've got def con status to worry about you've got a space race you've got a map of the entire world there are several more phases to game playay there's a lot more going on to dilute that focus on that card play mechanic whereas in Watergate the entire game is streamlined to be a faster paced game with it almost its entire focus on that card play mechanic the fourth factor is fun and this is the most subjective of all because it really comes down to a person's individual preference When comparing extremes I could make an objective argument for how one game is more elegant than another
game just by pointing to things that kind of clutter the gam playay or increase the amount of upkeep that's required but when it comes to fun I hardly know how I can make an objective argument that one mechanic is more fun than another I personally really enjoy simultaneous action selection and I dis like Press Your Luck but that's just me to give you an example of this I put together a list of my favorite board game mechanics however that is a topic for another video so I'll leave links in the description but for now let's go ahead and move on to the five board games with a perfect mechanics score up until now I've given you examples of games that exemplify one of these four factors so what are the five games with a perfect mechanic score so my first recommendation is San Juan I've already mentioned this game multiple times in the video uh it emulates what Puerto Rico started so long ago this idea of having an action where your opponents have a minor action that was Innovative at the time it's still so much fun and is you see it in in games to this day um but the game play is elegant it has a great focus on that it's just a wonderful game with a perfect mechanic my next recommendation is kuuba I mentioned this game because I personally find the simultaneous gameplay so much fun the Brilliance the Elegance in kruba
is that whereas in every other uh roll and right type game there's a Randomness about what comes out for players to use in kruba you can always see all of your available tiles and so you can figure out what tiles haven't come out yet and what tiles you'll be more likely to get as the game goes on you can use this to plan out how you want your routes to be so you can get your explorers to their treasure the fact that you can get that extra information strikes a perfect balance between luck and strategy that just makes you want to play the game over and over and over again there is no other game that I've played that gives the same amount of satisfaction even given the luck and has so little downtime and lends itself so easily to wanting to be played over and over again I love karuba it will be on our Shelf forever excellent game the next one is an engine building game because engine building is such a popular mechanic and the way this one is done is just so well executed in every attribute the components are wonderful uh the complexity is approachable for anybody and the game is streamlined so that it's quick to te teach and fun to play and you be played over and over again it's the game gizmos so gizmos is an engine building game where you're building machines you're just machines that build
machines uh the fuel for your machines are colored marbles the colored marbles are used to add on to your machine and the actions that you can take are to uh take marbles take machines build machines but the fun thing about the game is that every machine will give you a bonus when you perform an action so you've got one machine that whenever you take a machine you get to draw a marble and you got another machine that lets you take an additional marble whenever you draw a Blue Marble so you can combo these things together it is just so satisfying to have uh moves that stack on top of each other where the game just kind of picks up the pace and becomes more more exciting turn after turn after turn there are a lot of Builders out there I think for the mechanics value for the focus on the engine building mechanic gizmos is my favorite the next game is a game that I'm recommending by virtue of its Innovation because it's doing something so well and I don't think another game can can replicate it as effectively as this game does the mechanic is time and the game is kites in kites you're using sand timers and the objective of the game is to prevent all of the sand timers from running out of time and you're doing this cooperatively by playing cards the cards that you play uh indicate the color of
the sandtimer that you're allowed to flip and so the entire game is just playing cards quickly so that you can keep flipping sand timers over and uh ensure that none of them run out it is wild and fun and fastpaced and people are laughing it's a timed game so you know you're not going to be having a lot of downtime and there's actually a lot of strategy and communication that has to happen between players as they talk about what cards they have and who needs to play which color when brilliant game I'd say the only other game that uses time in such a wildly fun way is escape but last time I checked Escape was still out of print so until that comes back in print kites is my go to for a game that utilizes time in just a amazing way my last recommendation is different from the others because all four of these have a tremendous focus on a single mechanic and I thought well the thing about focus on a single mechanic is it makes the game a lot simpler what about for somebody who wants a game that has a little bit more strategic depth to it something that isn't so simple that can really feels a little bit meteor not not you know not so complex that you lose focus on the mechanic but just a little something extra for people who want that so that game is Crusaders in Crusaders
you are trying to move your Knights across Europe you're conquering different lands you're getting victory points for doing this and the way that you perform actions is through this Malala based Rondell where any action you perform always has a point value on it and after you perform the action you pick up the little markers that indicate the value and you drop them off one by one around the rondelle what this does is it makes every subsequent action a little bit stronger and so what you're doing is you're trying to plan your strategy for how you want to spread out and Conquer over this map but you have to do that Within the the Restraint of this mangala type mechanic and that is why I find the game commendable I think it's a brilliant strategy game with an excellent mechanic the game Crusaders those are my five choices but ultimately it comes down to a subjective rating there are four factors to consider so if you'd like to rate your own game for mechanics what you can do is you can go to the perfect board game and you can log in using Google once you've done that find a game you like and review that game by giving it a number of stars as soon as you've rated even one game you will gain the privilege to be able to uh edit the attributes so you can upvote or downvote
the mechanics rating or any other attribute for any game on that website that concludes my take on mechanics the next video in this series is going to be components so as soon as that's available I will update the cards that are going to appear on the screen or you can check out the links in the description for those and everything else that's going on at the perfboard game.com thank you for watching and I will see you next time bye-bye