Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Game Campaigns w/ Sidegame LLC

Transcript 2:29:50

oh everyone hopefully this is all working please let me have no issues this time around it would make a change certainly compared to others i even got my guest here to put on some earphones because i thought i'm not having the echo problem again but bow means let us know in the chat if you do get any audio issues because then at least sort them out so yes thanks for tuning in today i think it's it's late afternoon for me it's what like first thing in the morning for you a lot over there absolutely about 10 a.m listen say i do you know i've got to come to britain or i've got to move to america or one way or the other because this would make it a lot easier to deal with time zones but but then all the europeans would have a problem so there's all problems there but that this one is a bit of a unique list actually and half suggested by me but half suggested by uh well actually let me get on to that in a minute because i've got mackenzie franklin with me then some people are probably like okay you know who have you got on this week and it's from side game llc llc is was it your your effect your equivalent of a limited company or something because absolutely so that's fine there but um like share my screen that might help get that done in there application stream yard it's always a problem when you try to get these done that's a i don't have any problems with that but uh hope everybody's good how's that how have you been today okay i know you've only just got

you've only just turned um got up in the morning i suspect today's been pretty great so right now we're watching little french bulldog puppies so that's been wonderful and also been coming down we got our i got my last vaccine shot on friday so been a little sick with those side effects but doing okay now things are great so oh yeah it's gonna be a while before i get mine i must admit because that's the because that's the thing i need to well i want to get my vaccine so it will make things a lot easier but i'm only i'm in the pin well despite getting older the pinnacle of health but i'm still only 36 which does mean that i'm kind of last in the running before getting stuff done so i'm kind of like oh you know maybe maybe it will be a while before i i'm at a position where i can go oh okay you know what this will work but my wife and i are both educators so we were pretty early on the list here so we were very lucky to both get our shots pretty soon ah that makes sense actually yeah because if you are on the in when you're on the front line absolutely yeah yeah we had that right there we go at the site probably it's because i had everything in one chrome tab which means that i can't share one chrome tab on its own but uh yes side game llc as you can see has their own youtube channel criminally less than 100 subscribers say that only been operating for what like two three months now about three months yeah we started in very early december so we're coming on our we're starting our fourth month here yep and one thing one thing i can certainly

say is that if you want to check out a lot of top 10 lists i know i say like check out my channel because i love doing top tens but blimey you've got a lot in three months so right now i've really been focusing on the channel in particular top 10 lists because it's just something fun to talk about and these organizing videos so i feel like it's not something that's really shown on channels is a lot of people show unboxings but in this case we're looking at how to organize things so um how to pack things appropriately what organizers to use and how to get games started quick because i think that's pretty dang important when it comes to gaming that would be good and for some of these like kingdom death monster maracaibo akamara living card game and there's quite a few that could use those sort of videos uh so that's pretty good i'm quite impressed you've got enough games in your collection to have a top 100 so at least i'm not the only one who's doing that various color games but the other reason that i brought you on is because of this do you want to just explain what this personal game night host is absolutely so cygame llc is a personal game night host company first and foremost we've got a giant library of games that we will cater to your event so you basically drop us a line and say hey we have this many people we're hosting we want a game like this and we come and we cover everything we cover the music we cover the setup we cover the rules we will make sure to not only teach but also facilitate the games to make sure it's a perfect experience that you really don't have to put any effort into so you're like man i want to do this we'll make sure it happens as smooth as possible so you there's a lot of different options you can just have that kind of basic package or

you can even keep the games if you want them we can provide all sorts of different services on top of it so it's really up to whatever the people that are hosting the game nights what so so what's up the audience for this are we talking like mostly families or people new to gamers because i can't imagine someone like me for example unless maybe you've got some heavy euros in the library that i've always wanted to try maybe that's an option but so we have a huge range things from basic family games to heavier euros like some loserta games some of the newer hits from last year so we have like maracaibo and things like that we have a huge range of games to really hit everybody so our business started at the end of 2019 so we were starting to volunteer at conventions and really trying to get our name out that way and a lot of people had a lot of hits with a mix of small and large games gave out a lot of cards but once 2020 came around we got hit really hard by the coronavirus not able to go to these large conventions anymore or advertise had to restrict the amount of people that were able to gather so right now our main target is families yes yeah oh i mean your your thing would have crashed and burned in the uk if it happened but you're like we're allowed to go indoors if you were lucky let alone have multiple people around your game night host so i tried it as much as i could when lockdowns weren't on but yeah i mean you're you would have struggled to get anything past regulations down here but no i like this idea i don't know anyone in the uk who has done this and this is the first i've heard of such a thing but yeah i can see this working if you're a heavy gamer i want to try this euro game out bring you guys round you're teaching it you've got the game perfect you don't

have to rely on someone else to get the game for you families is obvious why this would work you know if you're new to games you just want to try them out well great it's a bit like wine tasting i've done stuff like that where i've had a guy come over and show us a bunch of wine that's in my lounge i provide the food and they provide the drinks or something they've been pretty good so i don't see stuff like that as was fun for tastings i can't see why it wouldn't work for board games but nah cool so sorry and where are you based at colorado is it so we're in colorado springs colorado but as part of our package you can go to different parts of colorado if that works um there's a i don't know a big color rather i know it's cold that's about it it's cold in the south park that's about it that's about my knowledge but now it seems like a pretty cool idea all right well but say hope that goes well but bowel means everybody hashtag support some more creators get on these youtube channels subscribe and check out some of those lists because there's a lot of them i might even have to do a reaction video to one maybe at some point that'd be quite cool because that took off quite nicely the one i did for board gaming ramblings and reacting to people's top 10 list is always quite something i sort of find quite interesting as i said i can just go right i've not seen these top 10 before i want to see what they go and then i you know agree or disagree as i go on it's something new that i'm trying to do at the moment it's worked for one video i need to do a few more but cool anyway what on earth are we doing this this for so top 10 campaigns now originally uh you suggested it was going to be like top 10 scenarios in games i thought that might get a little bit too detailed down like especially with some of the games i know are going to be on

our lists where we're talking about a very specific scenario we can mention them if we want but it just seemed like like maybe for people who aren't familiar with the game it just might be a little bit too niche um even that makes sense some of that so i tweaked it slightly so that we were doing top 10 campaigns specifically and we're not just talking about the gaming question yes we will mention what game it is and some games only have one campaign in it but there are some games that have multiple campaigns but by expansion or just best in the box and so we're saying right okay yes we putting this game on but we are specifically putting this game on because of x campaign so you won't see the game repeated on the list like i'm not going to have my my one through six is not the same game but six different cycles you know i've had to actually go right i'm putting this game on this number but saying it's this one that's making the reason now in terms of my reasoning it's kind of a mixture really i mean mostly it's theme and story but it's also mechanical changes as well if any like maybe it brought in some new mechanics that were quite fun if it's just one campaign and the whole game is that campaign and maybe the game itself like in general it's just good enough like it was a good experience it could be legacy based as well that's you know that's on the cards uh but a lot of it would probably be more weighted towards fema's story what about you my biggest thing was the evolution of mechanics so how you start the game versus how you finished in addition to the uniqueness and the carryover from piece to peace so i thought those are huge things to look at and to see

basically what's going to get you to come back really hmm that fair enough right well let's get on with it then trying to keep well i ain't promising anything about this being less than two hours guys i've kind of given up on that front i talk too much and i i don't i don't tell my guests to like be quiet or anything i just let the stream go on as long as it's going to so all right let's start with tens

all right guests go first while i type in your details and bits sounds good so the first game that i have is probably the smallest game on this list i want to say and it's one i don't think a lot of people have played this is going to be the grizzled armistice editions campaign so in the campaign version of the grizzle have you played the grizzle i have put the grizzled i forgot it had a campaign i haven't played it with the expansion which is probably why a lot of people do a lot of people don't know this actually exists but in the armistice edition it introduces a campaign where you're actually going to be going through different battles of world war one and the grizzled is all about dealing with the issues that the individual soldiers will face during the war and the trauma and the struggle that they face as a whole so an armistice edition you have a the normal deck of cards that you're going to be drawing but as you play you're going to be adding more hard knocks and more of these cards with different symbols as you play so it's got a nice evolution of mechanics in addition to the cards that you'll be adding to the deck you also have these good luck cards i think they're called something like that but you'll add them to the side and they're like one time bonuses that you can use if you're in a pinch and does it come with these miniatures it does come with the miniatures they're really nice actually that's really cool looks great and it comes in a great little package you can fit everything in the box and it's wonderful i was quite surprised and it does my favorite thing that really gets you coming back to legacy games is easy to set up and it's short it's surprisingly short i played this with a group that i had

played other legacy games with we played um rise of queensdale and we just gave up on that one because it took forever like over 20 games something like that i've not actually played that yet no i wouldn't recommend it but this one you can get into so quickly it's wonderful so all these different chapters ago i mean yeah i mean i enjoyed the grizzle fine and not enough to keep it but i thought this is a neat little game and i thought this was the expansion actual orders which i have not played so i had no idea this even existed this looks more like it's a special edition although does it actually have the base game in it or is it just as a campaign it will it comes with everything you need for the base game and essentially it includes the at your orders expansion in it it takes a lot of the ideas from that expansion with the kind of like you're going on missions every day but it ties them into a campaign experience it really takes the whole grizzled package and weaves it into a complete game in my opinion i'd be tempted to grab this actually because i i heard the olders fixed a few bits in the base game and certainly made it more enjoyable so i was already tempted by that but knowing that this armistice edition excess i'd be tempted to grab that for a short quick legacy campaign although i'll bet it's nigh on impossible to get hold of because i mean i didn't even know its existence let alone whether it's in stock anywhere if you've got a group of three or four i strongly recommend this one wonderful i have to look this one up okay fair play that's a good start all right i was wondering if you'd heard about this one so that's cool it's cool it's not something even new only the game but that seems pretty cool all right fair enough so with that so my 10

is mostly a mechanical side of things because in terms of its story i wouldn't say that this one was like the best story in the world it kind of like okay this story is there not too fast even though it does throw in a few callers like wow you know but this one was one of those campaigns where it br it was a mod you could you could cannibalize the game and just get use the modules in your main game it was an expansion but rather than simply play the whole campaign if you wanted you could just kind of say right i'm just going to use these modules but the campaign teaches you these modules as you go through by throwing in a half decent backstory but mostly just throwing in surprises like okay right get this module out and it turns out to be oh this is one's really good and that's the rise of fenris forsyth so as i say this one is definitely more of a mechanical reasoning for it but i mean the story's not bad it's just like okay cool there's a fair bit of backstory and i do like this world setting the kind of alternate history mex some people like compared it too but i loved how it taught you all these extra bits as it went on and i would like more campaign games to do this particularly if they are expansions to games don't just give us a campaign with all this new stuff all at once and say right only the campaign uses the stuff i like the idea of like no no i can use this in a normal game of siphon occasionally i do but it's recommended not for new players but i don't want to spoil too much because it is kind of

one of those deals so i might just like hover on that one picture and leave it there actually but as i say it the new modules that you get in this really cool they change up the game for the better and some they kind of add a bit more variety in various types of aspects again not trying to spoil at all and i say this whole top ten i'll try not to spoil but i was i was keen with this one i say it's my number 10 mainly just because this is more mechanical and format rather than i'm gonna read this story and come back to it like i mean i i could be convinced to play through this campaign again if someone asked even though i know what's happening and i know there is the potential that that will happen in the future but you know otherwise i might just say look oh you got it you fussed about the campaign no right well let's get all the pieces because the pieces that made up the campaign were still good so i really like the way this introduces those aspects it reminds me a lot of space bases expansion where the shy pluto it introduces those little bits and pieces but i left this one off my list because i think the campaign's just pretty bad in general i love the expansions and the modules but god man this campaign has some huge runaway leader problems that's well that's what i experienced at least played this with a group of four and as soon as you started winning you started unlocking these things that clearly give you extra bonuses and that's just going to carry you the whole way there was a point where you think it was maybe our sixth or seventh game you unlock something major and everyone at the table was silent because they just watched as their their people were getting decimated over and over again

and it was go ahead and notice as much the the whole runaway leader thing i mean i certainly won the campaign and i won the majority of the games but then i could i mean not getting too big-headed i classified myself as better than the other players at scythe just from experience so i figured well i'm winning a lot that's probably because i know how to play scythe more than these do so it's like fair enough so i couldn't really tell if it was a runaway thing it'd be interesting to sort of play this again with people who are like scythe veterans um but yeah i didn't mind that too much the story bit so as i say this is why it's kind of squeaked in on the 10. you know there was an honorable mention for the well i'll get on to that at the end of the list but okay it was kind of like i was tossing between this and another one that i played recently and i'm kind of like hmm and i could switch either way but they would be on there for totally different reasons okay but i'm curious to hear what you have to say we'll get on to that later all right let's move on to nines all right we'll start again oh yeah always guess first all right sounds good so this one is a new one that i've started recently and i finished the first campaign and i was okay on it but this second campaign is incredible oh my gosh it like fixed a lot of the problems i had with the original campaign and made it so that it's more focused on the exploration as a whole rather than this artificial timer and that is gonna be the last

night for tainted grail so the last night is the second campaign for tekken for tainted grail it's set hundreds of years in the future of the original campaign but it's you wake up in this snowy landscape now very similar to scythe i'm not going to get into the spoilers at all but wow it the biggest thing that it does to make it an incredible experience is it actually takes out the menus so the men here is in the original game are timers you have this little coin that will track how many turns you've been using but for the last night you actually don't have them on the board you have to kind of just deal with this wilderness and all of the issues that are surrounding you and tainted grail does it really well it has you focusing on surviving there's this aspect of surviving the cold because you're covered in snow as well as just you know pushing on from area to area so i think they did a great job with this the new characters they introduced are great and i love all of the new backstories and the more thematic um use of the characters is they added this new expansion with the second wave of stuff that gives backstories all the characters and like tiny micro missions you can complete that give you snippets of your personal history and i think it just does wonders to the game so right now go ahead i was kind of guessing naturally the way you were describing it because i do have to agree that it certainly did when you were saying it fixed problems with the base one i'm kind of like hard-pressed as to which one i prefer story-wise this one or the best one but yeah mechanically this one did fix some issues of the base i have not yet tried

the age of legends one or whatever it is the second one yet um but i have died the last night you say it gets rid of the men hears it does sort of yeah i mean it doesn't fully get rid of them but it does mitigate it a lot more than the first one did i mean the first one you have to house rule how those men here's work in order to enjoy the game because otherwise it's just a pain but the second one does a better job at mitigating it for a bit but you still have to house rule a few things in it like the frostbite did you keep that rule as it was so i haven't had a big issue with the frostbite that might be because of the character i'm playing i'm playing the butcher so he can pretty easily get rid of it uh his abilities you can eat a food and heal two frostbite something like that did you have that i don't remember the butcher was that one of the was that one of the characters or one of the abilities that's one of the characters abilities i think his name is dagon or dragon something like that really close to dagon so i forgot yeah the frostbite you know it was like playing i was playing uh i almost put the wolf girl but now i played the bard the storyteller yeah and she actually came in andy because that movement ability of hers was just god like is i mean all you've got to do is basically not stay in the same place for too long okay that's for the most part of the game pretty easy to achieve but otherwise she just came in handy but now that was a good one and tay tated grill's a

sweet little game as well okay ah that's cool and interesting i'll be interested to hear what you think of this next campaign depending which one of us actually gets around to playing it first absolutely i'm kind of terrified about starting the red death that one just seems like a nightmare mode holy cow yeah although i got a bit i have you know um that red death one yeah the idea that is like this is for the veteran players it's like excuse me it's not that the game was a cake walk beforehand and you know we're playing an age of legends has what i can tell is like controlling troops in a sense it sounds like you're going to be like having armies under your control i don't know the full rules of it but that's what it seems to be hinting at because bear my age of legends is set in the prequel stage i'm hoping that's not going to be too ridiculously complicated not to mention like a nightmare to like like do well in oh man if you have to feed all those troops every round or something like that no i'm pretty sure rosenberg hasn't gone anywhere near it so it should be fine but all right my next one is the game is the whole campaign you know there is no other like special campaign the whole game is just one big legacy campaign once you've played it there's no physical way i think that you can reset it maybe you can but i'm not sure i would want to because i wouldn't want to spend all the time getting the cards in the right place and that but took me ages to get this one to the table i had to wait for a group to be available and even then i could only see them so often then covid happened and then

got delayed so we were almost kind of cheering that we actually finished it purely because it was dragging on a bit but that's not a fault of the game that was just covet getting been a problem but i had a good time with the king's dilemma this this really sort of interesting unique card game where the i mean the setting is dollar's ditch water game of thrones type thing but calling this game of thrones the negotiation game is actually not too far off what it is each of you takes control of a rival house and the idea is is that the king you play over multiple years of like well is it king ships i'm not sure but like multiple reigns so one game is a particular king's reign and then that that game is done you go through the motions and then the next game is kind of like your descendants and the next king on so it's going through like like the whole history basically but it's a negotiation game where every round trying to find like decent pictures of it which is proving somewhat difficult but these story events come up and like you can see like these branching path things so you you open one particular card and it says your you've heard about some rustlings over in the next village they want armies to defend them do you go send armies or do you say sort your own problems out it basically gives you all these yes or no dilemmas but then each of you as a group has to vote on whether you are going to say yay or nay to a particular scenario and each one of these scenarios that you vote on has ramifications for the overall story

as well as your ability to score points on each game depending on what your secret sort of faction uh like objective is because everybody's got their own kind of short game and long game plans but yeah you might decide right we're not we're not going to go help that village screw them and then later on in the campaign they rise up as rebels and militia and start like giving you hassle there might be another one where you this person is accused of being a witch and so it's like well do we put her to death or do we let her live and it's like well if you put her to death morale goes down and that but then if you keep her on and she turns out to be a bit of a witch then it's like oh you know that causes problems later on there's like there's all these different story like branching stories that can develop from it which was the one of the main reasons i loved it the other bit was just the fact that negotiation games are a good laugh for me and like the pictures don't really do it justice because it's not showing a lot but you effectively have the cards and once you're done with them you can stick them in like the bin pile once they're done with but otherwise they stay on the board and act as that's a little bit better um they stay on the board and act as story plot arcs down the side here and this chart in the middle is telling you is like morale and economy and welfare and knowledge going up and down depending on whether you vote yay or nay on stuff interesting so it looks like they're communal resources so how does that work does each player kind of work on different resources or no it's it's basically this is like that grid is like the city in general like the city's okay welfare in a sense and you're you might like one of your long game ways of scoring some points might be that you don't want

knowledge to get too high so when the dilemma comes up so when so when a dilemma comes up that says we found some inscriptions in this cave here which kind of disproves the whole mother religion thing or at least throws some doubt on it and it's like well do we publish these or do we commit them as heresy oh you burn them absolutely i was playing a faction that because there's lots of different ones you can pick i picked one that was more kind of like the zen lot uh like fanaticism thing for the most part so i rope and you role play this your hearts get dead but i was role playing the idea that we were just like religious nut cases so any time somebody tried to dispute the mother or something like that i was constantly like nope all my power on this vote not having it burned heretics it just went completely bad with it like to the frustration of the other players but you know it doesn't always go your way and i just like the way that the story shaped itself but i can't see myself wanting to play it through a second time because i'd recognize too many of it but then to be honest even if you did you wouldn't see the same progression twice because yay on a for a lot of dilemmas and there's a lot of them you know drastically changes things wow and does that like start from the original i saw that they had that branching path so if i say yes to the first thing does that completely change my game if i said no to the first thing well one dilemma on its own wouldn't necessarily dramatically change it's more like the combination because there's you'd imagine that there's maybe like about 10 major storylines that are going on but depending on whether you vote yay on there and certain dilemmas that story arc progresses and eventually completes you

know it will have some cool odd effects but yeah you role play this if you like a negotiation game this one's a good fun like kind of legacy style game i'll be honest this sounds amazing but i don't think it's something that i'll ever get to play because it's that legacy and you have to have a competitive group that's you know going to be that many at least three or four there's got to be four right four or five or how many people i think you can play this with a three i mean you can't play it too and i certainly you certainly can't play it solo as some people in the chat are like wondering no i'm a solo player so this won't work it's like well of course it won't you know of course but you need a group that's going to role play you need a group that's going to get into negotiations i want to bribe people like you know i was like look i'll give you five bucks here vote yes all right vote yes why do you want me to vote yes i don't care here's some money votes yeah it's that kind of thing but that is it's a good laugh but not for everybody all right that's nines

all right number eight is one that came out this past year and it's an expansion that is the culmination of everything that this game has released so far and that is going to be hostage negotiator and this is specifically the career expansion so hostage negotiator has you playing as go figure a hostage negotiator and you're going to be trying to rescue as many people as you can so with these people they're going to be held by some some bad guy basically and this can be as realistic as possible it could be just a person that is burnt out of student loans it could be a person that has is needing to pay for their health care on their children or it could be a person that's just working for some militia for another country and you need to go in and you need to do what you do best rescue these people and hopefully capture these the people that are trying to capture i guess trying to kill everybody else the uh what's what's a good name for this the bad guy i mean the yeah what do you what do you call a bad guy that's kidnapping somebody the kidnapper yeah there you go the terrorist terrorist yeah there we go so the kidnapper but career does this so well where it puts you through this large campaign where you're going to be going from case to case to case to case but before every case you're gonna have some card that will affect you some way and generally it's going to be something that happens at your office so this might be something that deals with your promotion status you distress at work the interactions with your co-workers things like this and

every game you play will be drastically different you're going to construct the stack of event cards there's one for each year as well as personal events that will happen after work every day and based on how well you do with the negotiations good or bad things may happen and these personal things may affect your stress levels they may affect the way you perform the next day and you can do crazy things there's a bunch of these stressor cards that you may accrue and these could include things like debt it could be it could include your spouse maybe you're having a spat with them it could include your car or something something small like that but these really add up i would love to have that where it's like i lost this campaign because my wife was giving me this morning it was like how's that gonna work you can get divorced it's pretty like pretty serious like it's it's pretty bad and this yeah go ahead the sounds i mean is the story interesting more than like just the fact that it's like got brand new bats i mean did you find the story good fun or so the way the story works is it doesn't it's not on rails so it's very much like your stories made up of these event cards there is one event that always happens in the middle of the campaign and then the end of the campaign has a big secret envelope that's going to be the end of your campaign and i think that's the coolest part because the giant envelope at the end has one really cool mission that kind of takes everything you've worked for and puts it into this one thing and they're completely different you might think that it just might be another hostage case but it's not it's it could be something i don't want to spoil anything because they're so cool when you open

them up it'll be it'll be completely different than anything you'll experience and you really want to just keep going back in until you've seen them all because they're all so good they're all different levels different experiences i can't recommend this one if you enjoy solo games this is a solo only game so it's gotta be something you're willing to sit down and play but the best part of this is it's quick very similar to the grizzled armistice edition these games take 20 minutes tops and you could play three of them in a row really quickly and the game actually recommends that you sit down and play multiple in a row because it is fun it's easy to jump into and it's a blast honestly this one makes me sad though because i i have hostage negotiator in the other room and i do have career because i did kickstart it i just haven't had time to play the thing so i didn't have time to play it before this list so that one is like you know you want to call that my 11 maybe but i'm looking forward to tried it but i just did not get time to sit down and give it the beans and now you've had it on your list and now it makes me more like excited to like get it get it out to the table so it's it's definitely going to happen but at least you've mentioned it so it hasn't been forgotten and i think there won't be like comments later um i mean this should please a lot of people because we've got about we've got basically a bit of a bromance of solo players going on in the chat at the moment where we seem to have got not only we got my buddy the hexy beast we've got on next week but also several other solo players so which to be fair for a campaign top 10 list actually i think solo player oh yeah probably going to be more uh more there but apparently

xc base has not actually tried hostage negotia which is actually quite shocking because you live in brief solo games i cannot believe you have not tried it yet you gotta try this one it is wonderful it benefits if you have all the expansions because each expansion that you have will put an investigator in your potential pool of hostage negotiator cases and so the more you have the more variety you're going to have but you don't need it all so i would recommend some of the newer scenarios because they are that cool there's one recently that i did some uh covered it's the there's a social media influencer that's holding hostages and i think that's a super fascinating super fascinating scenario yeah i mean the later ones do throw in some weird rules that make life a little bit more fiddly like complicated wise but not too bad but i say you can make do with the base game for a while because there's plenty enough content in there crime rate just basically doubles it yeah and i do have a bunch of those packs so there are some cool ones in there i mean i like some of the simple ones on the old block which is like the guy trying to get hospital bills paid for his daughter that's dying or sorry this is definitely a game that will trigger people it is very serious yeah but i like that and at the end of the day it's a dice game in the luck can hosho but it's still pretty solid alrighty number eight so there's two campaigns in this one and i there's a legacy one and a normal one i'm picking the normal one mainly because you know uh the legacy one's decent as well but i thought like just the for simplicity's sake the main one was still pretty good this game from portal has not had the

best of start so must have it had a bit of a shaky upbringing and i can see why it's rule book was somewhat diabolical and the app integration was not uh perfect but i got into it late when i found a better rule book on bgg not to mention the app stuff had been fixed and so i still give first martians credit and i think the main campaign in first martians was pretty decent actually you got you you've already got these standalone scenarios in the box but then you had a separate campaign with totally different missions so it wasn't anything from the standalone stars it's not like you just played five of them in the row which i was afraid it was going to be no it has its own book with its own storyline from start to finish we've you've landed on this planet you're trying to set up you start getting weird signals coming through that's messing all over your systems and the app is taking you through this like you know you'll be just setting up oxygen tanks and you know doing stuff with the rover and then all of a sudden you're like radio signs like huh well just just cause this and the plot is kind of you trying to obviously contact home and survive because things are going to pot and if you can't contact home you'll never get home but as you're finding out what's causing it you know it's just it very much is like a realistic film about being on mars because this is not uh shall we say what's the word uh fat like blockbuster movie type thing this is more like the martian the movie so matt dave you know matt damon surviving potatoes and that so this is like semi-realistic what's going on and i liked

i mean i love the app integration in this where it's got the ambient music and it's got different story elements that it gives you like all the different like written as if it was nasa talking to you with codes and that but my thought this was a pretty decent storyline throughout it it kind of ends on a bit of a a somber note in the sense but i was entertained playing through this one and it gave me a chance as a solo player to enjoy a bit of first martians again excellent so i really steered away from this because i'm not the biggest fan of robinson crusoe i think that the system is a little kind of wonky with the luck being such a heavy factor in like really critical like results which is hilarious think it's because maybe hostages are so short because i think maybe like my my luck to uh strategy ratio you know leads to shorter games but i'm so happy that they were able to take the criticism and implement it they use the app i assume to fix some of the problems or how did they fix it what do you think well i mean i've got robinson cruiser on my shelf i mean i don't have a problem with that one like lux sorry because i mean there's luck in a lot of these games for car draw or dice and that so that never flummoxed me with robinson crusoe it was just a fact of wow i gotta learn all these rules again cause there was quite a few of them this one yeah you need to do a bit of research in terms of the rule book and that because you know certainly the the initial rule book for this was not great and with robinson crusoe it's more kind of semi-fantastical in the sense that you

know you're doing exploring and things like that whereas this one is more somebody says like work uh in a sense but don't bring work as in boring this is like i say it's meant to be the martian this is to be taken more seriously compared to robinson crusoe which has you like eating berries and then off like a few days later or something you've got stubborn aches and comedic stuff like that and this one's a bit more serious like you know you notice something's going wrong with the the electrical plan do you fix it in advance it's like now skip it for now it's fine then later on it blows up you know it you get those semi ramifications but yeah this one is definitely more on a serious level but i mean i love the app integration in it it tells us i was about to ask the bookkeeping and i i want more games to have into you know app integration interesting would you prefer this over robinson crusoe uh it's been very cl it's been very close in the past as to whether i prefer this to robinson crusoe but i think i think overall i still prefer robinson crusoe okay because i think that slightly more comedic element is more to my liking that there are more scenarios in it now and with the new game found campaign that's coming out soon with that book of adventures it's just going to get ridiculous the amount of variety in that game uh so yeah roberson cruzo is still my preferred one but i mean if robinson crusoe when he said that oh we're doing a new edition of it if he'd said oh we've got app integration for this now i've jumped on board in seconds i mean i think that's the one thing robinson crusoe could do with an app but you know if it can't do that then

i'll just take more cards and stuff so uh yeah like i say i'm one of the few people that goes mad for third martians in the center or like gives a lot of buzz because i know it had the shaky stuff even ignasti's like yeah okay we made a mistake with first martians you know so it's not going to be for everyone but for how cheap it is you know you can get it on sale pretty much everywhere i gave it a chance you know i i came into it late which i think helped but i get a chance of that i think for us i think maybe my collection just needed a semi-serious campaign and first martians kind of did that because i'm not mad on the whole martian thing because we've done it to death so everything is now about mars but this one i think was just that one where i thought yeah you know what as a co-op rather than competitive thing and taking it more seriously because a lot of the other well i mean terra for me mars it could be any planet it could be anything it doesn't really need to be mars it's just drafting cards at the end of the day this one actually felt more like no no i'm actually on mars i've got to deal with oxygen and you know growing plants and staying alive you know that that just felt a bit more realistic it sounds really thematic and i think that's probably the strength of the game in my opinion robinson crusoe was one that i bought twice and i've sold twice but this one seems really interesting i like the idea of hey this is a space simulation this is you are on the red planet i think this could be a cool one and the app integration like you were saying that sounds like a great step in the right direction for a game like this yeah wow i mean okay i mean another comment that kind of goes well with it is that yeah this has you working to prevent things from

failing that's kind of more itch stick whereas robinson crusoe's more you do this particular event and then it comes back to bite you but yeah i mean if robinson had an app fantastic this one has the app and as i say it's still one that i'm pretty fond of for now but i pretty much reserve it solely for solo on the basis that i'm one of the fewer people that sort of jumps on board with it that oh well different strokes onto sevens

all right my number seven is the only game i don't have with me and that's because it's a one and done game so you open this one up you throw it away but i don't have king's dilemma anymore for that same reason that's all there is perfect so in this one it is a game we're gonna be taking out a pandemic it's very straightforward you're gonna be fighting viruses this is pandemic legacy now all three of these are great but the one that i've had the most fun with is actually the newest one pandemic legacy season zero where you actually are not going to be fighting a pandemic right off the bat you're fighting against soviet agents so it's really fascinating that you are able to take this core pandemic system and apply it to so many new different scenarios and i guess this is proven with things like defenders of the realm and the new one from uh arcane wonders i forget what's called the superhero one freedom five fantastic five something like that but you can take this cool pandemic system and apply it to new situations and make a wonderful tight cooperative experience and i love that about this the randomness for the cards coming out but it's kind of a controlled randomness when you know what the order is i think it's wonderful and season zero does some great things as you can see here you've got a passport on the board and that whole passport system is wonderful it really allows you to customize your character and the way that the crisis the outbreaks are done in this game is wonderful so normally in a game of pandemic you're going to when there's a cluster of three disease cubes and a new one comes out you'll reveal another card and some disease more disease cubes will come out

so it's oh geez things are really getting out of hand but in this case when you reveal a card the bottom of the card will say something and something terrible will happen for that specific region but it could be anything it could be something you don't see coming it really could blindside you or it could do nothing and that's also great so there's a lot of yeah go ahead i mean without spoiling is it like other people out there because i mean i get asked this question as well the yeah it's called pandemic and yes we're used to pandemic stopping a virus so without spoiling too much is this like does this actually care about a pandemic at any point or is it a bit like the fall of rome ones where it's like oh no it's not a virus anymore it's just using pandemic rules except now it's the cold war i can't answer this question yes i'm struggling to figure out how to answer it as well it's like i can't and you if you like pandemic and you like the theme of pandemic you should pay pandemic legacy season zero that's my suggestion to you yeah you like the idea of fighting against a pandemic it's a great game as to say we can't really say much more on it it's just it's impossible without spoiling it so we'll just have to let everybody else but let's get on there alrighty so my seven ah yes now we're actually staying with uh portal games actually funny enough i didn't realize that they were gonna be uh on the same list shall we say but there there's a lot of games that are following this theme um this is

i do own both the actually i think i own about three different ones in this kind of uh you know detective style like deduction game and well funny enough well i kind of gave it away it's detective so yeah the modern crime board game but i'm not specifically thinking of the main campaign because if anything i like the main campaign and detective a log because obviously i love the game but it was a bit long five was too long i however got a rat blast out of la crimes the expansion one they did for a few reasons one three stories not five so you've only got to commit for three like stories not five it's just you can wrap it up a bit quicker you don't have to get the same group together for multiple sessions too much but the story in it i thought was pretty good all three scenarios felt very different even though the plot was still overarching you know there was a different feel to certainly for the last act compared to the first act but one thing that just like sold me on this was just the immersion factor is turned up to 12.

you know particularly if you have any nostalgia for those 80s style cop movies the buddy cop movies because this is just dripping with theme from those ones i mean you can just look at the cover and you know this is like the miami vice beverly hills cop lethal weapon style thing even the mug shots you get and the pictures like they all look like photographs taken from that time period everything is authentic as as can be in this and i love that the police reports are even printed on like this like fax paper yeah it's so cool yeah because normally you've you've still got that uh typing in where'd you go the the database but yeah the peace report you get is on those old facts papers with the ripoff um whole bits on the side that's stupid and annoying you could like it it's come off with one of those bridges which i got a admit i do love that even though the database is like a big blue screen and nothing else so imagine it's like your first atari database but if you play this play it with a soundtrack and do what i did go onto your spotify youtube music whatever you've got and simply put on the soundtrack to your favorite 80s movie i played this listening to nothing but beverly hills cop lethal weapon die hard all those soundtracks and believe me trying to solve a particular case or decide what you're doing or like like when you get into a story bit of like all right i'm going to tail someone or was it scope yeah scope out their place

and then axle f comes on on your spotify i'll say oh it's like perfect absolutely perfect is that so you know we've there's been single cases for this which i've enjoyed and i still like the more what you call it like the five yeah the five one i mean that is a very complex story and there's definitely a lot to learn in that this one i think just like condensed it a bit more like it three axes easier to manage than five and it didn't go ridiculously outside the box as the first one did because the first one you had to learn some pretty out there stuff you know on wikipedia and that to kind of get some of the historical bits that go on it this one felt more condensed like this is your mini series of miami vice in a box you know you still got it's still not easy it's not like this is a pushover you can still fail this one hard if you're not careful but it just felt like you were in this world in this city and it kept you there i absolutely agree with you so this is actually on my honorable mentions i just think that this one has a little bit too much reading for my opinion and a lot of people think of this more as work than they think of as play but i love this i love this game i love this system i think i totally agree with you with this as well i think that the la crimes is the best version of this it's short as you were saying and i think that really helps with remembering things from campaign to campaign because in the first one my goodness if you forgot like a little detail in the first story it could really come back to haunt you and this one is you're able to keep up with it some more and i think that's huge but i wish i could argue with you on this one but man it's good

ah this is i love this i love this i mean i don't have a problem with the too much reading i've still got sherlock holmes consulting detective on whether you want too much reading you play that game that is reading but this one i thought it's a bunch of cards yeah but you've still got to read a fair bit in chronicles of crime you've still got to read text on the app as it comes through so it's i didn't feel like this was like overly a ton of reading or at least no more than i could do but playing it solo because i don't tend to play this one in the group you know perhaps it's something i don't notice as much but nah you know they're kind of steering away from the whole campaign set up and just going for single cases now which i gotta admit i do prefer i do prefer just having a nice one case make it as complex as you like but make it one case so that once i'm done with it the fact that i haven't picked up the game for another like month or two is not gonna suddenly like screw me over so what do you think about the new um detective season one versus the standalone adventures for just detective as a whole they did one that was by matt leock recently and then they also did the season one what do you think about those two i haven't played the most recent like uh spin-off one that they're getting designers to do i need to do that at some point that one is great i have played i've got it it's just it's in the box i just have time to play it but i think i've got it anyway it's i i did a review of season zero or season one whatever it was called ten out of ten still love it i actually recommend people buy that before the main campaign box because well it's three good cases but they're standalone so if i want to teach this game to people i can just do

a single case from there whereas if you do the base box you've got to do the five act campaign and that's where you get problems so you know i'd say pick up season one first and then if you like the system and you want something a bit more in-depth and you're going to play with the same group then yeah go get the other like multi-act campaigns but i don't think you should start with it and i think even ignasti admits that so although i don't wanna i don't wanna put words in his mouth but why release season one if you know as a standalone box you know and not make it oh i must have original components so i mean i guess just pick your poison really are you excited for the dune version of this game no well i like the system so part of me is like okay this will be cool but i know nothing about dune i have dune imperium on my shelf and i did a review of that game but i went into it as a complete noob i've not read the books i don't read i've not watched the old movie people tell me not to i've not watched the old mini series people tell me it's still got flaws so it's like well what am i supposed to do then and it's like i'm going to watch the new movie when it comes out and hope that fills me in because frankly all i see is a barren bland looking desert planet with some worms in it it's like okay great and spice is important for reasons you know this is my knowledge of dune is non-existent i feel like it should be fine like i know a lot about doom through osmosis just by playing games with people that know dune and just you know i feel like i've got a pretty good hold on the way the world works so i'm excited it looks cool political

intriguing in space let's do it but i will definitely try it just because i like the system oh yeah when they announced it some people were going oh my god dude yes because everything's now doom it's like oh great we're going to milk this one until it's dry now but it's like i saw and i thought okay might be cool but my lack of knowledge for dude has kind of made me go yeah whatever i'll play it and hopefully i'll enjoy it but yeah go say i'm a complete dune noob all right let's get down to sixes

all right my number six came out in the last quarter uh last year and this is going to be etherfields so etherfields comes with two campaigns in its base box it comes with the harpy campaign as well as i don't know the first one's called it might be the sphinx campaign something like that anyways go ahead well they had like a bunch of stretch goals but i mean the main one is just the campaign okay so it does have a two campaigns in the main box though so once you finish the first one it introduces you a second campaign so you get to jump right in yeah so so the second campaign though is the one i want to talk about because my goodness it is so good and the first came what's up what was it harpy campaign harpy i think h-a-r-p-y so for a harpy campaign you are going to take this foundation of the dreamwalking you've been doing in the first part of the anther fields and you are going to take your deck and during the first part your deck is going to get customized and modified and you're just going to continue that through this new space this this new campaign so i really like the second part of the campaign the second campaign because it introduces new and unique dreams that kind of really push the boundaries of the etherfield system it adds a lot of innovation and uniqueness to the scenarios and it tells some great stories with what you're doing in addition i'd already did a pretty good job on the dreams being unique i'm curious i absolutely agree it can be but that's what i'm saying go figure this second portion really takes the ideas of the card based

lane system and really twists it and i think it does a wonderful job with it now the biggest part of this second campaign is the fact that you're going to be knowing you're going to know more about the story as a whole and i think that's huge because you have a better idea of what's actually going on in the dream world and it adds in the first part i felt more that i was just kind of wandering and doing things to do things and this one i feel like i have more of an idea of what actually is happening and what i'm doing as a as a dreamer so i really like the the individual cards that you're going to get from playing this campaign as you play you'll interact with experiences they're going to add cards to your deck and the cards in these dreams are super thematic i there's i don't want to spoil anything because they are so good um but you can find some really unique things during this second half that really will make you feel like a different player and i think that is amazing one thing i'm going to ask though um so formatically that sounds amazing yes another campaign that explains a bit more about the world etc now does it fix the mechanics though so which mechanics do you have issues with so i know a lot of people don't like yeah they effortfields was one like backed it is currently on the floor over there and the only reason it is still in my house is because i am waiting for this new rule set to come in to probably fix the game because oh yeah yeah yeah yeah so this this frustrated the hell at me i had to give this one a 5 out of 10 when i reviewed it because i was so much i loved the world i loved

the art and i loved the whole dream stuff like the main dreams were cool i could not stand though those slumbers and the grindiness of this game it was beyond i mean tated grail has problems in that fact this one took those problems and just like like emphasized them like crazy because you're doing that stupid ringer in a roses thing on the mini maps to get keys i house rule that you don't need keys anymore because frankly they serve no purpose other than unlocking dreams they're just there to pad the game out yeah you can use them to discard morphines that's a thing you can use keys for then maybe i'll leave that or something i mean i didn't do that very often i let the bad guy get morphines and just dealt with him but the i just that whole grind like killed the game because of having to constantly go around and get those keys meant that you did those mini slumbers ad nazium you know i'm cool with going into a thing and going right the puppet master is now a slumber that you have to fight every now again like you found him in a dream and now he's going to come back and screw you over i would have been fine with that had you faced him once i've lost track of how many times i had to face that stupid dream shadow behind your shoulder or whatever the first one is that you come across or something and that just got really annoying the grind in this game and i knew this was going to be grinded as soon as i saw them say we've got hundreds of hours like over 100 hours of content in this box yes that's because you pad the game out like crazy world of warcraft probably would only take you about 12 hours to complete the game if it didn't require you to grind

100 pigs for leather on a regular basis you know i used to play world of warcraft like crazy but you know that's the problem with this game is like it probably only takes you about 20 hours to play the game if it didn't pad out like crazy and so they do have that fix that you're looking for they've introduced it it's very similar to the story mode version of tainted grail they have a fix now it's out i believe it's on the emails to the backers or maybe it's on their updates but they do have it and it's pretty straightforward basically they do exactly what you said they say hey you're just gonna skip and go to the next thing but you're gonna start with like two wounds and five card sealed so it simulates the idea that you've fought a couple of things so it's something like that it's very straightforward so if you don't like it it's it's very easy to skip and like i said you can go ahead i knew i knew they were doing it i didn't realize they'd finished it or i needed to look because at some point i do want to get this back to the table because i do love the setting and i paid enough for it but i didn't buy the sphinx campaign i literally just bought the main box with the harpie harpionix i thought okay let's not go mad here because this could be a problem here um and thankfully i'm glad i didn't spend ton tons on it but i i want to try it with that new rule set and do a video on whether it fixes it for me or not because i want to give this game a second chance but i don't have like the official printed version of it they said that they're going to include that with the next wave of expansion stuff like like a car that you'll slide into your little divider thing but uh they do have the actual like thing the like i say you just print and play it i just didn't know that they actually

sorted out but i mean yeah i hope it works after that point because that grind just drove me nuts and i said give it a try i don't like the idea though that it's saying oh you take a couple of wounds on a five-card seal and it's like yeah but you're still punishing me i mean the game's not easy this anybody who plays this on like hardest difficulty i swear is a masochist because you know some of these games are just like oh we're gonna punish you for every little thing you do and the game's already got quite a bit of luck in some of those scenarios i mean some of the times you're all right all right pick a b or c well how do i know which is which you don't just pick one see what happens it's like well you know don't punish me for picking a random choice and then you know screwing me over for it these boxes i am curious what uh what dreamer are you using if you're if you're playing this game um i play solo and i use the green dude is either okay i would recommend use the blue one blue or the yellow they are they are the best for if you're on your own just in general they're the best the blue one can get extra actions and the yellow one gets lets you re-roll stuff and that's huge um because you're going to want to be rolling yeah reactions every turn so i would recommend those two green one kind of sucks i would not hate these gaudy sucked yes i don't get a bunch of progress cards yeah what's that i'm gonna have a look for that rule set and i'll try and get this one out to the table again soon but moving on like i say not on my list until i try this new rule set out so maybe it will fix everything for me but part of me is like but then i'm going to miss out on those little slumbers but then you should have corrected the rule in

the first place it's it's a tough one but hopefully it'll do the job so with my one oh we'll see my number six right this is a crossover in terms of game but not campaign so yeah i i do agree that uh one of the campaigns that this game did was great fun in fact i would say two of them are good although the main reason is is that i have not actually played the third one and i will get on to my reason well there's several reasons why but legacy yep it's a southern legacy game but i'm not gonna go for season zero i go for season one of pandemic legacy now i like both season one and two season two's certainly a very different game but i enjoyed that one fine it's just i don't know it was it was very different but i mean that was one of the appeals season one was just like a nice like right i'm familiar with pandemic i can jump straight into this and go straight into what i'm familiar with but then it throws a pretty decent story overall you know not not one that i'm gonna like watch a movie of shall we say but it still does a pretty good one but it threw in a lot of good surprises again i'm not gonna spoil but yeah it threw you for a loop on certain occasions in a good way like i got a suspicion this might happen but oh okay i didn't realize to that extent or uh something happens it's like okay did not see that coming that just screwed some of us over curses so and it made me look forward to the next game like all right we've played seven

games right i really want to get can we meet up soon so i can do game eight because i want to see how this like new development progresses so yeah that one came kept me going and i think from a to follow what's going on and just familiarity i put this one over the second one i've still got the uh boards on my wall actually over there the finished the finished boards are well i needed something from a wall so i thought i'd put those on although they don't stay flat so they're a problem to keep on the wall so eventually i'm going to get sick and tired of them and bin them but i'd look at the season one one over there and it's like yeah i remember when that happened i remember that happening i remember why we in this in season two we made sao paulo the biggest defensible like haven possible because in season one i'm not saying sao paulo goes to pot in every game i say no it says i but in our particular game let's just say that south america didn't do well okay um but i have not played pandemic season zero i also maybe i'll play it but i am not keen on trying it interesting i've done two games of it i feel like i'm done with pandemic legacy i don't feel like i need this to be milked for all it's worth um it also requires me getting the same group of people that i was talking about a minute ago with um king's dilemma which is like we can't meet up very often and we're only getting so many games done at the time and it's like i don't want this game to drag on for this long because it's still like 15 odd games you gotta play of this it's not

like it's going to be over and done with and so with that particular group i'm less inclined to take campaign games to them now i just want to take one-shot games um we make an exception for things like near and far in that because we all like those brian locket games but i also could not maybe there's something in season zero that would throw me for a loop but i could not give her monkeys about the cold war theme uh yeah i like james bond movies okay that's my limit of what i care about the cold war james bond movies that says it all really you know when i saw season zero i just looked at that box and thought and the boards and i thought you had you know standard blue but at least you had a fairly you know nicest looking production nicest looking board i'm sorry but pandemic season zero is ugly don't you not agree that that season zero looks ugly i love the aesthetic i'll be honest i love the way that it kind of looks like you're looking at this like real world map at the time i think it's really cool but it gray do you think twilight struggle looks horrible this one is basically twilight struggle all right and with like little red bits there but i thought like they'd cut corners on the production or something when i was looking i mean i have not tried it so i could be completely wrong about this but yeah like i said that whole theme when i heard it was just cold war themed i thought okay it's just like pandemic fall of rome and all the rest where it's like it's not technically a pandemic baby it is i don't know i don't know the plot but it because i've got to play it with that groove and it's going to drag on and it's called where i just thought

i'm not that caring about trying out season zero i'm lucky enough to where my wife is my primary cooperative partner so i'm able to get a lot of these games played but if you have to get a group of four like that i can understand like do i play this or do i play something like sleeping gods i mean like what do you pick right yeah and i do not want to play the solo that's the same if i play the solo and my friends find out also they'd kill me because they're because they're bigger pandemic fans than i am that's the thing i like pandemic but i don't love it to bits but they latched on the pandemic like crazy so yeah that's the other thing it's kind of like i've played two legacy games of pandemic i'm kind of done you know iberia is on my shelf as a gateway game but i don't bring it out all the time so it's like maybe i'm just sort of kind of like all right i'm sick and tired of the word pandemic being stapled onto everything these days because that's what it does feel like but i say i could be missing out but you know just at first glance it's not reeled me in you know maybe there's stuff in it that i would love but uh as i say first bite is with the eye and i'm sorry but it's ugly i'm i'm calling it ugly i'm sticking with that each of them

yeah so this is number five yes naba five yep all right so my number five is the it's not the biggest game but it is the most popular game i know that one's pretty big right so this one we're going to talk about is a huge campaign based game it's only got i guess it has three campaigns technically but it's got one major campaign and it also has a smaller version of it but this campaign has you playing as a group of mercenaries trying to make your way in this world and while you do this you're going to be encountering the same evil force that eventually you're going to have to stop yourself and that's going to be gloomhaven so gloomhaven has you i was i was thinking like i don't recognize this game at all and then as soon as i saw the boxes i oh that one now like luke just mentioned you probably don't know the story of this game a lot of people will complain about the writing in this because let's be real it's not the greatest now my recommendation is if you play this game use the foreteller app so foreteller has narration for the game and they'll read everything for you it includes sound effects and background noises and it's it's wonderful it really like i played this one two times through and the second time i played with the narration and my goodness i really enjoyed it so if you're gonna play this use that oh my gosh i use the four teller app so gloomhaven does some great things in the world of campaign games it sets you in this unique setting with multiple missions multiple paths and really kind of a never-ending story that you get to go on but it keeps

you engaged by offering rewards as you play so it does this with level ups so every time you play you'll get experience that will lead to level ups which gives you card unlocks and it'll also give you your own private missions that you have to complete in order to retire and when you retire you unlock a brand new character and that's huge they're in these little boxes you pick the one you want to go after based on its symbology and then you go for it and then the same thing happens again you get this new character you get to learn their abilities and then you get to go for your new um your new goal all the while playing in this game that is based on this wonderful tactical combat where you have these two cards and you get to really know your hand of cards really well as you play campaign game after campaign game i really love the whole system in this game i like the way the ai works with the monsters and their own initiative decks i like the mana system and i love the card system where you'll be playing them at the same time and figuring out what the best combination is based on what happens so really enjoy gloomhaven and i specifically like the original versus jaws of the line jaws of the lion introduces the book which is amazing oh my gosh if they make up the scenario book jaws of the lion is just gloomhaven but easier i mean it's the same game i wouldn't say easier there's some scenarios in java lion that are super ambitious less complex i would say yes to that it leaves out a lot of keywords but the fact that gloomhaven has the unlocks it has new classes that you're getting is huge it's going to keep you coming back once you play jaws of lion for like 12

or 13 scenarios you're gonna get to a point where like okay i'm just doing the same thing every time and there's nothing i'm really working towards and that's to be fair 12 13 times if you've played a game that long then you can't say it's all samey if you stuck with it for 12 games when you're comparing it to like the 100 scenarios in the base game though i mean i don't know i mean i can play i mean i couldn't get past sir i couldn't get past scenario six so yeah i mean i mean certainly i was going to be surprised if it wasn't on this list for somebody i mean you were the only person who was going to put it on put it that way because yeah i don't know before i don't know anybody who likes the story of this game that was the one thing that made me think maybe it won't be put on the list because as much as people love the game nobody's coming out there saying this is the best writing for story because it really isn't i mean generic is the poster child word for that but uh ah now i i gave it a chance i went through six scenarios of this game trying to think come on this is like everybody is raving about this this is gonna be like potentially the number one on board game geek and lo and behold it was and and i just thought like okay what am i missing here but i couldn't get on with it i mean the comments on there are actually kind of mirroring what i kind of feel like it i mean for starters the difficulty spike in the first few missions was ridiculous like would you like to get into this game would you like to be taught how to play goon haven right punch you know it punches you in the face repeatedly but it also just felt very slow in the progression like you say it's 100

scenarios give me 25 scenarios but then let me build up quick enough so that in 25 scenarios i feel like a god don't give me a hundred scenarios but mean that by the time we get to like like 25 scenarios through i might have just like upgraded from a toothpick to an actual spear yeah i kind of wanted like a little bit quicker it does get to a point though in this game where if you are leveling up to be a god the game stops being fun like once you get too high my goodness it's gonna be it's gonna be a breeze and i think that the challenge that this game presents is one of its charms you get to decide you have to really plan on what you're going to be doing because ultimately it's a big puzzle and i really enjoyed that about this but then that's just i just put that down to bad design then i mean if you're if your game is not scaled difficulty wise to the point that it's too hard to begin with then eventually gets to normal but then eventually gets so easy that the end game which is supposed to be the climax here is boring that's bad design that's not a good design that's the way i sort of see it but i also i mean with this one it's kind of a similar problem i had with mage knight i know they've been talking about that in the chat laws i don't like magento either but you were talking about the euro mechanisms of this um i like i mean it's generic fantasy whatever i'm kind of done with generic fantasy i like the idea of leveling up and getting all cool stuff it's too slow in this game but i did like the variation of characters and i thought they were all really distinct so it's not like i hate they like hate everything about it it definitely did have some stuff i liked

but i didn't get on with the euro side of it this one like mage knight felt more like a euro game with a dressed up dungeon theme shoved on top of it as opposed to the type of dungeon crawl i like which is a dungeon crawl with euro mechanics maybe drizzled over it like i'm more than i'm more the descent type crowd i want i want simplicity streamline kick the door down kill the big dragon get some cool loot from a chest like the worst this one the card system was okay although i don't get why loot is an action it's like okay there's some coins on the floor i can pick them up i don't need to spend actions to pick up coins on the floor it seems a little bit insane and why when the mission finishes can i not loot the whole area is like i had that in the first campaign which drove me nuts it's like oh well we just killed the skeletal boss or whatever and it's like right what was in that chest then oh you don't find out what do you mean oh you finished the scenario you now have to move on to the second one so excuse me the chest is right there is that i can literally i can literally go and open it right now it's like nope you gotta get going just like come on fema luke did you play this solo with other people other people okay group of four group of four and so i would say play this game at two or three but with other people i think having the opportunity for someone to be like i'm not gonna help i'm gonna go get the chest is great fun i think it has a go ahead that's well that's why i wanted it no i mean i get what you're saying yeah i wanted that

as well but i mean just the idea that it takes an action to do it and you have to do it before the scenario finishes and that i mean the items are fine everyone goes on about the modifier deck and it's like this thing and it's like it's just a custom die get over it it's not innovative it's just you just couldn't be bothered to make a dice and just made you cards you know fair enough um you're not gonna notice too much with it but it's complicated as well i mean look at this look at this one here a cup ah get back yeah this one here i mean i'm looking at these abilities and it's just like seriously just can i just say whether i want to attack or defend or charge or something i don't need this great big flow chart here to explain one particular action that i'll get to do once per three hour scenario because they take too long to do now i would completely agree with you on this however i think the fact that you start with all of your cards and you are going to be familiar with those cards really helps with that because you're going to know what that card does because you decided on it you picked this card and the fact you can decide when you want to play it i think it's i think it's huge if you have like a giant deck of cards and you were shuffling it and you just drew them and you weren't sure what you're going to get i think it'd be a huge issue having cards that much text i mean we're not playing yu-gi-oh man i mean so well yeah i mean granted well i mean it's got too much text on it i mean if they just streamlined that a bit but then gave me the tactical thing of right draw five cards this is what you got to work with i'm fine with that i like that sort of thing you've got a lot of things to look at in your starting hand which is why people freeze up with analysis paralysis going into it but also the fact that you

know you get rid of the card so it's gone for good it's like well i do this by i've done pick up coins and apparently i can no longer pick up coins for the rest of this map because the card's gone it's like it's not like i forgot how to pick up coins and they say all right it's your stamina it doesn't take much to bend over and pick up some cash you can always pick up coins just by ending your turn on them you don't have to spend an action well even with the other stuff like moving because i mean i mean the first scenario is just free rooms yeah i mean yeah i mean come on granted lock down i'm not as fit as i used to be a few months ago but i'm pretty positive even now i could survive a couple of sword fights in three rooms before i was knackered you know to the point where i was like seriously these adventurous suck the fact that you could barely do three rooms like two rooms in a corridor before you top all over and exhaustion it's like seriously it's like i've never gone to the gym with skeletons so i can't comment on that so either anyway i say i've given you enough garbage on this i say if you're more people and four out of ten i gave her the chance but no i i mean this is one of the most overrated titles i've seen on bgg but let's say there's there is there is more gloomhaven fans than there are people like me who don't like it so believe me people who watch this later who are massive glue moving fans are going to give me such garbage and they're going to be totally on your side i guarantee it but you feel free to give me garbage over some of my picks like i said oh absolutely i'm waiting for it you've picked good ones so far so i'm waiting for it you won't get i don't

have garbage picks this is whatever just to sort of like so i don't get screwed in the comments right people i did actually say before this went live you are free to grill me like crazy or sorry so if i put on the choice you don't agree with he could grill me to next week and i'm totally fine with it because that's what's good about this it's just happened oh yeah you got a lot more music right yeah i know but it's just that i've had more reason to grill you the other way around so it does seem a little bit one-sided but anyway right let's move on uh number four we're only on five so well this will be a long stream deal with it guys number five right we're going on to an lcg now i love the co-op lcgs i've got three of them in my collection and it took me a while to decide which cycle i liked the most out of this one but it it was kind of a toss-up between two and at the end of the day it came down to right okay i like both of them for story but mechanically which ones were better and for me lord of the rings lcg wins over with the grey havens i was tempted between this and the red uh mifrin one or whatever it is or the one that wilds of revelation it had you fighting dragons and drakes yeah it was pretty cool and spiders why does that always have to be spiders i've had enough dealings with them recently uh like fighting them off into all the journeys of the earth yeah yeah but grey havens i thought was a really good cycle i mean mechanically it froze in some really good scenarios you've got sailing so you you take your ships you can pick what ship you want and you know you're chasing other ships

you've got the sailing test to make you've got ship battles which is really cool the player cards that they threw into it both like the heroes and the vents they really opened up some really good archetypes in there artwork was stellar because i'm like i'm a fan of sea based artwork in the sense like water-based arrows so ocean landscapes islands that kind of thing archipelagos is something i like the look of but the plot for it was generally pretty cool you know you were fighting off corsair pirates and you had to go explore islands and this was i think the first there's not many pictures unfortunately but uh it was one of those ones where it went it put you on an island and it made you actually explore the islands like it wasn't just a linear path you had all the different bits and you was like right let me just move to that spot flip it over oh it's that location okay that's a cliff i can't go any further in that direction so i'm gonna need to go back round so it it made it more immersive and the fact that i'm actually exploring as opposed to just going through the scenario act one act two act three so that was always a really good one as i already mentioned player cards were great but some scenarios from this i just have such good memories i mean here's like some of the lost island cards so this is what i'm on about you know you explored the island itself but i remember having to go like in an underwater tomb i remember having to invade a corsair city defender harbour but the favorite scenario out of this box was i think it was called the thing in the depths or something like that and it's two acts you start off fighting a corsair guy that you've been chasing so it's like okay battle there's your boss take him out survive for a bit

deal with other corsair enemies now and then halfway through the scenario when you get through the first act suddenly kraken appears like tentacles start like swarming the ship and that and you basically just sort of take a look it's the classic cliche from movies where you take a look at your like enemy there and you're just like yeah that you know like go for it and suddenly he's your ally and you're fighting the kraken and it's like that's just such a great scenario like that's two hearts that's completely different and he's like now you've got to take out this giant monster and you're kind of in a temporary truce you know what with your enemy it's kind of like yeah we could kill each other but that thing's gonna kill our ship you know get going and out of all of them i just thought yeah for story and memorable scenarios grey havens had to win through so i can't give you any grief on choosing lord of the rings lcg i'm actually playing through the gray havens right now which is kind of crazy that you put it as your number one but i do disagree with you i don't think this one is the strongest scenario um i don't think that this is the best campaign i think the best campaigns are actually the saga campaigns i really like the hobbit saga campaign i think it's incredible you go through a story you're familiar with but you get to live it and i think that is amazing i think they did a great job taking it from page to adventure and i think that this scenario in particular that grey havens introduces a lot of concepts that a lot of the lcgs that fantasy flight has made in the future they use them a little bit better in their scenarios um so i know you were saying that you have other lcds by them like marvel champions

and i assume arkham um i think they take the exploration mechanic and use it well there and i feel like they are introducing new vehicle scenarios in these games and i feel like there'll be some more additional add-ons that you know as well this one came out first and then basically i did contemplate i mean i think the runner-ups were that it would admit from one and i did consider the lord of the rings main whatever they call the black riders and so forth yeah i did think that was good i wasn't a huge fan of the hobbit one i thought the scenarios were a little bit well it was fine but the the one scenario was like kind of hit and miss as to whether it worked like based on luck of the draw and i thought the battle of five armies once you got to that stage was like jesus how impossible do you want the scenario to be and it was also a similar problem i had with the black rider ones because one that one goes on forever this one at least it's one cycle when you're done whereas that one you haven't you've got like four or five deluxe boxes it's like okay that's true you have four deluxe it might be six actually six lots of boxes takes a long time to get through that campaign and bear in mind you're trying to succeed scenarios i can't even get past shelob yet you know i haven't played the full campaign of it i've got to shelob got stuck because i thought this boss character is just way too hard for my hobbit deck and you know and and then i sort of quit and now i need to go back and revisit it at some point but i mean i've seen like i've done like standalone plays for like the last deluxe set and it's just like ah the difficulty spike just goes through the roof and that kind of kills my enjoyment up to a point this one the grey havens i will say one of the

scenarios particularly i think the last couple or certainly the last one is quite a difficult one and that is the floor of the lord of the rings lcg but as i mean i'm not gonna fault if that one's your favorite they're great because it was a runner-up so oh yeah absolutely and this uh the grey havens it takes your card pool in mind which i think is great i mean they say okay these cards have come out your difficulty is probably going to be about this and they introduce some great cards here like sir don the shipwright i love decks with him just any kind of like i forget the name the decks where you're drawing and discarding a bunch of cards and manipulating that i think it's super fun so yeah i really like this set though so i can't complain i think that was another thing the player cards i think also sort of picked up i mean there were some great hobbit cards in that black rider said but i can't remember like some of the other ones that they had so yeah that's good very quick question that i will just have so that fatal people goes like did you see the siege expansion for war chest it has come out i've not bought it because to be honest i don't know how much longer war chest is going to be in the collection on the bases it's not getting played i do love the game but it's uh not one there so yep number five yeah that was number five sir we've done your number five aren't we yeah we did gloom oh yeah we did gloomy maybe in your favorite game right yeah totally my favorite characters all right number four is my newest game to the list and this is probably the best game i played in 2021 and i was super impressed with it this is one that i thought

oh wow you've played i was going to say not a lot has been released yet correct so uh this game is one that i've played on my own and i've also played cooperative fantastic one of the best adventure games i've ever played you might be looking at it this is going to be sleeping gods yes there's only one that fits the description yes so sleeping gods the new game by ryan rocket this is gonna have you exploring this huge map and that's the core of the game you go explore you go do stuff you're you take place as the crew of the manticore and you need to find totems to get back home and that's the entire spiel honestly when you start the game you might feel like you really don't know what to do but if you keep that idea in mind that you're looking for totems that's really what it what matters and the way that your the best part about this campaign game is the way that your entire board will grow and what i mean by this is you start the game with four cards and these four cards will give you some type of ability you can cook something you can manipulate something and you can draw something that's it you're really familiar with those four cards you start with them every game awesome you got this cool stuff but as you play you're going to get more things added to your repertoire of skills you're going to get more crew members you're going to get more weapons more abilities and you're going to be adding these this giant tableau in front of you of abilities and by the end of the game you can have like 50 of these cards in front of you but you're going to know what all of them do and it's kind of crazy because you started with four and you're adding one and people might come and look at your board and be like what the heck is this but you know all of these cars because you earned them and you use them it's it's kind of wild what

were you gonna say luke that was uh i was gonna let you finish that but yeah i agree by the time i finished because i have finished the campaign of this one and it like i had so many cards in front of me i thought seriously and i was scared going into the solo because i thought i've gotta look at nine characters this is gonna be too much it's like the nine characters from a solo perspective are not difficult you literally literally these characters are basically just i have two little abilities that you won't even use on a lot of them you know it varies but and you can have two cards on each they've got their own like three or four level up cards like experience wise and they've got the skill icons which kind of power you through challenges that's pretty much all you need to know they're essentially resources which i think is a great way to take them they are characters so they do have a part in the story when you're reading you might see one character says something you grow a relationship those characters we had one character in our game i don't even remember her name but we called her becky because she just didn't do anything and complained all the time she took like all her damage it's poor girl but um is there something i should be like apologizing to with this one i don't remember her name but oh man it was really funny because we like never used her abilities so we'd always make sure to level up but later in the game she got better we made sure to level her up some to be fair i did the similar feed actually because i think when you've got nine characters you do have you have like four or five that you focus on and they're like your bread and butter but then there's a dump character who gets all the stick gregory was mine yeah great great gregory he's the best character the doctor

he's so good i didn't gregory is our man i didn't get poisoned enough to care and uh i was more dealing with low morale for a few things so the captain sorted that out and i didn't get too many of the status effects and a lot of the other things i was just eating lots of recipes like the cook was like more used to a dab but something can and that became like really good in fact why am i talking about this so much well because for the first time ever on any of these collabs yeah on the same number exactly yeah great as a open-ended campaign and absolutely i mean i thought can i put this higher but the one thing that stops it going a little bit higher is because in terms of the main plot it literally is you're in this world you're on a ship get totems wake the gods the end that that's literally what the main plot is correct but it's open-ended so the story you tell in between you kind of make up as you go along and that's like the one thing that sort of stops it going a bit higher because it's kind of like right there's not really much of a structure here it's more just you come across random you come well you come across stuff at random they are plot arcs in themselves but it's not like like i say the main story arc is pretty basic it's what you tell in between that's really really good and as i know it sounds negative but you know that's a it's still something that's really cool with the game um you know like i don't know wonderfully absolutely like this is the best version of this game in my opinion of that open world idea i think it takes that concept and runs with it super well not to mention as

beautiful as i'll get out of it i love ryan lockett's artwork on everything he touches and this is no exception with the atlas book and that but now i mean i had to burn through this campaign like crazy earlier this month to get it played in time for this and it's like right great i'm glad i did although i did i do have to make a slight correction to the podcast episode i did the other week where i did my first impressions um this was like first impressions after a few hours of play i ragged on it a bit for its difficulty and i still think that it could be a little bit easier in certain places with the challenges because you quickly get to those challenges or high levels quite fast but i was really ragging on it for its combat being too hard i got a rule wrong um it was quite a quintessential rule um i was basically i was playing on normal difficulty but for the combat i might as well have been playing it on super hard hell on toast mode because it literally was making my game experience bad and it was because the combat that you have you put like heart tokens on the enemy as like body limbs like hacking off the arm the head or whatever and you take off this some of them have got two and three written on them now the correct rule is that you need to do at least that much damage to that part to put the token on it it's one token per square that's fine when you play it that way the combats are actually relatively balanced i actually played it though where i interpreted the rules somehow where it wasn't one token per space it was the fact that i had to put three tokens on that one square in order to kill off that part

i thought that what's the rule no oh that's what we're playing oh man really and you've not been like ragging on the game for difficulties how on earth are you surviving is it possible with that difficulty i'm not gonna say we're good at the game but we may be good at the game not cause just let people take hits i guess because i thought you could only put one token at a time on the square but it's not it's that you can only have one token on the square period so i thought when a heart free symbol came up it meant i had to attack the creature three times at least to get that one covered on top of all the other bits but all the while every time you're attacking it it's counter-attacking you back so i thought this is way too much damage i've got to heal up every time these higher difficulties are ridiculous and i thought this game is broken but and yeah somebody is like vince has just said yeah this is why you're like the doctor character because you're having to heal up so much but yeah but no the correct rules maybe i'm seeing this incorrectly it's like so you if it says three hearts right three of your damage that you just dealt goes on that and that's for the token right and that's it okay yeah that's okay that's how we've been playing okay the way you described it sounded like it was some nightmare scenario okay yeah i mean i always played it because i had to attack the creature three times at least to cover that squares yeah how did i survive well the rule book's not great you got to a bit the rulebook yeah you're right there yeah and i just read it fast i misinterpreted it you know and like once i think i know the rule correctly i'll stick with it because i'm playing it by myself it's not like anyone can correct me it wasn't until someone pointed out in a

comment it's kind of like you've changed the world well i played the rest of the game i i've switched to easy mode when i thought okay this is too hard but i also put that rule correction in and when i put that real correction in it's like ah yeah actually you know what i could play this on normal mode i think this is relatively bad style so it's like that's to say that's the whole point of it being initial impressions people as i get over it but yeah once i got that correct it's like okay cool we're on to a good thing here and so i got to enjoy the rest of the campaign for what it was and i think i'm and then i'm not spoiling there's like 13 different endings you can go and i got the good ending and i think that's really cool about the endings is that if you do do certain things during your quest your ending could actually make itself very unique um once you get through at one time you'll kind of get hints as to what that could be i haven't seen any of those super secret endings i've actually got the same ending both times we played but i am excited to kind of go and see what these additional endings could be and how to achieve those did you get the ending that was in my terms good like you also yes yes yes you must have had to go to a specific place then and do that quest line or maybe there's another way to get it i don't know or maybe there's two or three endings that are technically good i don't know like i say the ending i got i thought you had to go to a very specific place and do a very specific questline to get that ending i think my needs were very generic but still good if that makes sense not to say but i have to say i mean i want to get to the table again and play absolutely for the open-ended thing on

top of that but then the same group who loves my near and far and that wants to play this with me and it's kind of like this is like the one exception to that rule where okay we'll play this campaign because i know they want to play it but at least i'll know the rules in advance so all right that's that's say we crashed over on this one so we can move on to yeah i'd say first time i've had a crossover on the same number that's definitely going to be one for the history books i think all right moving on freeze but right my number three is one of my favorite games ever it's an incredible euro game and it is so i don't know your opinions on maracaibo as a whole i know you're not a big fan of great western trail but god no but i'd well before you start i mean barracad was on the shelf i do like it i don't know how much longer for but it is on the shelf and i do like the game good but i am definitely going to disagree with you about putting it on this list for all right but first give it praise you give it away i'm gonna praise it first and you can try and tear it down so maracaibo is a euro game where you play as a group of mercenaries in the caribbean you're gonna be sailing around doing whatever you want it's pretty cool it's pretty open-ended but ultimately you're trying to get points points are made from hiring crew completing quests and exploring and fighting so you're going to be doing all this stuff in the best way you can throughout as you kind of sail through these different islands now the best part about this campaign system is it is tiny all you're going to be doing is adding a card and this card comes from this deck of

cards and it's called the story deck you place the card in front of you and it will have some sort of additional quest that any player may complete now it'll score your points just like normal and generally the reward is pretty great it's something that you do want to go out of your way to finish and that's where this game shines it seamlessly adds a little expansion to the game and every time you complete this little expansion a new thing will get added it might add a new territory to the port it might add new cards to the deck it might add even more quests to the board it might add new ways to interact with the caribbean it evolves the game as you play now we've gone through this whole thing and it's great because you don't have to play it with the same people it's something you can just simply add that makes the game a living breathing world your game is going to be different than everybody else's game and i think it's wonderful i think that this has one of the most simple straightforward campaign games and i like that it's really fresh and different from these giant story campaigns you can play this once throw in the campaign come back to it in two months and go play it again and continue in where you were there's a little blurb that tells you what's happening in the world and it's super easy to play with anybody it reminds me of games like oath from letter games where you can simply bring this with anybody and the game itself is a thing that's evolving and i think that's such a wonderful addition now this is the pinnacle of the campaigns that alexander fister has done he's done this before in games like oh my goods which i think does it well but i don't think it's as strong here the components it's adding are simply cards it also has done it in more recent games like cloud h and cloudh

actually is does a job pretty well it's going to add new actions that you can take but i think maracaibo's ability to add cards add new pieces to the board and add new quests and storylines is wonderful all right luke let me have it go for it well it's not although i feel that this person is a little biased i can't put my finger on why this is a biased opinion yeah although i'm glad my mom doesn't watch my content yeah oh yeah right i do like the game but i much prefer this as a multiplayer game like while playing it normal thing i like the idea that it adds new stuff to the board when you say expansions it's basically a few extra cards and that one space on the board changes i mean it's not the most dramatic changes in the world but it's nice that it fairies things up a bit but i could not give a monkeys about any story in this game i mean this is a solo campaign for mechanics purely there is no care about the story in this game of what's going on and it doesn't even make sense when you think about it because the rule book stipulates that one cycle of the board like sending the ship around is a year or ten years i can't remember something like that i don't know yeah yeah a year right i first scenario you come across a lady that you save from whatever and she says oh yeah we do this my father is rich you should go visit him sometime you don't visit him until you go around the board again well it took me a year to go visit this guy what happened it's like the worst invite ever you all just start the

game as children and by the end you're like that's really really what it's all about it's like when you think about how much time is meant to be passing none of the story elements make any framatic sense whatsoever and i know that's just like all right fine it's a euro who cares but i just found that funny when i played it because i just like okay i need to turn my brain off on that because that was a thing but as i say with this one i mean i wouldn't also say you said it was like one of the easiest ones to play it's not the easiest uh solo game in the world i mean this game in particular you don't have to play it solo this game the campaign expansion is good for any player count if you're playing with a lot of people you simply throw it in and boom it's ready to go the the hardest thing it does is it adds a tile that's all you're going to really have to put on and then it might have one or two small things that you have to explain and i think that's great it reminds me of like a goody box expansion where it's a really tiny tile that you add or a card that you shuffle in or something like that super low overhead if you know the game or you're familiar with mechanics if you like fisters games in general this one's a pretty easy one to get into the hardest thing to understand is the cards and once you know that you can pretty much play the whole game so the overheads were a little bit on the fiddly's eye because i mean like when you have the multiplayer game you use a set set of cards and it's like tailored this way but then when you set up the solo mode you then go hang on a minute let me find the cards that specifically are for solo and i think it's more that story card deck is a fiddly thing to set up i like the idea that players can come in and go but then that kind of destroys the story because it's like i'm saying like oh yeah don't care about the story that's going on or whatever because frankly you're only in it for part

four of whatever we're playing and therefore you don't need to worry or so much so it kind of as as i say i didn't mind this one too much from a mechanical sense but it's just the story was just completely destroyed for me from like the get-go and that kind of put me off wanting to go through a lot more of the campaign i just play the basic setup multiplayer i mean with though with some of the cards like thrown in i'm i'm happy you know i mean this is the only fist to get oh no actually i do have all the sky and technically broome service although that was co-designed as i count but they're the fister games i've got because they're the ones i like but the if you're interested in trying any of the content without playing the story you can play the very difficult mode of the game and it just includes basically all the islands and all the expansion stuff so i'd recommend that if you're at least interested in what the content it provides is and you don't like the story so maybe try that your next time as for that i mean like i say i mean i don't mind what the baseboard has it's nice at the edge and maybe i'll revisit this one at some point maybe just give it another go just turning my brain off in the story and just accepting all right cool let's just play the mechanics of this game but i mean you because you mentioned like this is the pinnacle of the campaigns he's done i don't remember alexander fister being on a particularly high note when it comes to campaigns in general so it's mainly with like this weird incorporation of a campaign in a straight up euro game and the campaign as a card so i think this is his best version of this here's a card you're in a campaign now erica i suppose like when i do a campaign this is at the time when campaigns are just getting rolled into

everything like every game's got to have a campaign now and it doesn't count like the crew has a campaign mode today yeah it's not a campaign it's it's it's not going to show up yeah love the game but it's not a campaign stop calling it that just to sell more copies and and like fister i feel like like keeps doing this a little bit too much as well like i mean i don't know about oh my goods but remember expedition to new dale i didn't play that one because i heard it was basically all my goods it's basically oh my goodness if you wanted to make it more lucky take twice as long take four times longer to play and put in the most pointless story progression ever like you can play like different board like and it's technically a story as you go through but for cried out loud i mean i can't imagine falling asleep do anything like more bland it's like there is no point for that game to even exist oh my goodness was perfectly fine as a small card game it did not need to be a two-hour board game with luck it just didn't seem to work with that so i may i need to revisit this one so this isn't really a garbage day but i think that's just my reason why it wouldn't make my list the story just was nonsensical this is purely cool from a mechanical perspective the mechanical implementation is the best part in my opinion story not as much but i still think it's great flavor for the theme with the plague and whatnot going on well well the theme i mean i said i'm not a big historical theme fad so i mean i didn't even buy this game because i like cared about the caribbean 17th century

fever so when you've seen one of those themes you've seen them all this was the reason i got the game in the first place and this is the reason well no the cards in general that's the thing but the yeah because i mean the whole going round on the rondelle whatever the whole 17th century i think could not care leveling up on tracks again euro could not care it's i'm a sucker for multi-use cards so the fact that these cards have all got free uses and there's lots of different abilities and you cycle through the deck like hyper speed seeing all these different cards and ways to play that's what hooked me onto the game so it's like i say i still enjoy it it's just that's the main reason why even though i do think that questing is pointless and you should never do it in any game from a balance perspective i much prefer the other ways of winning focusing entirely on quests will not win you the game period you don't disagree with me on this one i will say that if you are taking your action to quest there's probably better uses of your time based on what the crust reward is but if you're able to get a quest through exploring or if you're able to get a quest through whatever the story's quest is or if you're getting a quest to complete one of your own mini objectives or if you're getting a quest through the there's a city that gives you quests those i would recommend but you're probably right if you're just getting a quest to score like a couple points oh like that's my strategy for the game is that new yeah as well well we spent a while on that one that's because we don't need to spend very long on my free because it is another crossover

oh excellent but but not maracaibo and i got to admit i only changed my mind about this one this morning in terms of which campaign i preferred and i almost sort of thought like as soon as you were talking about it earlier it's like yeah probably this one is better if i think from a mechanical perspective more than a uh formatic perspective certainly saying with that but yeah i agree i love the story in tainted grail and i almost did this morning have it as full of avalon rather than last night so it almost was like oh i just not that i don't like the last well like i say it's my vote so i do prefer the last night just i i think story-wise i kind of prefer fall of avalon like the with the same you meet more of the iconic characters everything's kind of going to pot as opposed to this one where it has already gone to pot but you know it's still a really good story in this one this one kind of like it's not like the story is so much better than avalon compared to this one both of them are fantastic stories i mean as much as i have to house rules some of the mechanics in this game you know this is the theme with awakened realms they make some of the best storytelling narrative adventures that i can think of but they do need to think a little bit harder about their game design when they're doing these kickstart stretch goals you know so um but the last night i say yes does fix more of those problems you know the men here grind is not as bad as this one it for the most part it's not even there but you know occasionally you have to grind for a couple of things but there's nowhere near as bad the only thing i will say about the last

night that you must house rule is frostbite if you don't houseware for a spike this game will tick you off quickly because what do you do for your house well with the fall of avalor i house rule them in here and there's loads of different variations of that i personally say that they've either got plus one range or you remove the dials so that there's no timer on them you know your maximum limit is free but remove the dials i think that's the best variant i've seen sometimes i do just plus one range so that you don't have to activate six or seven of them just to get from one side of the map to the other but the last knight frostbite rule in its normal form is that if you get given frostbite lowers your maximum health but the only way you can get rid of it is if something tells you remove frostbite so you can't just simply rest and get rid of it but the problem is every time you move to a different place not do any like action or anything just move the frostbite gets worse and the only way to get rid of it is to go to a settlement pay somebody or do something specific and get it so it removes your frostbite there's not that many settlements in the game you could literally get frostbite at the worst possible time and then have to go at least five or six cards to the nearest settlement that's assuming you even know where it is and at that point you are crippled beyond relief you get rid of the frostbite but then you've still got to then heal yourself up the frostbite adds a difficulty spike grind that i just thought as soon as i saw how the mechanic worked i felt

unacceptable like this is way too punishing you know it was killing my experience and i thought oh this is actually worse than the men here grind i have house ruled though that you can get rid of frostbite by normal rest if you're at max health so as long as you have because it lowers your maximum health but as long as you have got to that maximum bit and then you rest you can get rid of frostbite but i hate i think whatever you need to do to make the game more like enjoyable especially if it's a story based game like this that's more about the cooperation and the adventure i think that's fine i don't think it's a big deal but that's a thing yeah it's like it's one change that just made it it's not like the game was a pushover at that point but i just thought that yeah the second it says because sometimes you can't avoid the frostbite you know it's not like oh i did a bad choice therefore i got it sometimes the story just gives you it or a location just gives you and it's like oh great so now walking to the settlement i'm gonna be on like two health again it's like you go into a combat with low health and frostbite you might as well just like cool game right there because you're gonna die it's just like you're not gonna survive long enough so that one i just thought seriously in play testing they could have come up with a less punishing way of that so i just put that house rule in so that when i get frostbite it sucks but i know that if i just you know eat a bit of food just hang tight for a turn get to max health and then rest i'm good you know because you know you should be able to rest and get rid of frostbite you know i actually know that's a bad analogy but it's i don't know i just felt like it needed to be a little less pudgy but other than that once i put that house rule then yeah

this was a great campaign to play through excellent yeah no two more left although if we're going to cross over on anymore it has to i think we're going to cross over on one and i think it's going to be number one that's my guess but i think that our choice on the actual campaign will be different so i think the game for number one is going to be the same but i think it's going to be different campaigns that's my guess what about you well well let's see if your prediction's true

all right so this one is the biggest game and this is kingdom death monster so in kingdom death monster you play as a settlement of survivors and these survivors are forced to survive go figure in a nightmare world the entire place is dark except for the light of your personal lanterns and these lanterns are going to guide you through the darkness to go hunting gigantic beasts and these beasts you have to take them down hunt them kill them skin them and then use their body parts as resources to make new equipment for yourself innovate new things back at your home and you know make a nice lovely bed for yourself nothing like a sofa made out of lion fur i'm telling you it feels great so in kingdom death monster the campaign itself you have three different i guess six different campaigns right now there are three major campaigns people of the stars people of the sun the people of the lantern but there are also some mini campaigns known as people of the bone people of the flower each of them introduces new rules but the three big ones introduce timelines and these timelines are going to give you specific events that you'll go through as you play every lantern year each game is mainly comprised of about 25 lantern years which means 25 of these cycles where you're gonna hunt kill and then come back to the settlement in order to kind of fix everybody up so the campaign that i choose in particular is people of the lantern it's just the basic one so this is the one that you get out of the core box it has the most ability to customize though with people of the lantern you can include any of the expansions that you

wish and that can really increase or decrease the difficulty as you see fit i've never won this campaign i've played this game for about three years and i've never won i've gotten to the final boss once and i got destroyed it was terrible but my gosh do i keep on coming back to this game i am playing a game right now that i've been playing for about a year with my friend robert and my goodness we are this is this is the one i'm feeling it this is the one we're gonna win finally we're min maxing everything and it's gonna be great but my goodness the campaign structure in this is wonderful everything you do compiles if you have a rough first couple of years that's gonna matter in a couple years from now your innovations that you make early will allow you to unlock different innovations in the future your results from one thing really will impact those futures and i think that's huge in a campaign game especially one that's 25 missions and when you play this game you're gonna play probably two missions in a row so it's gonna be like 12 weeks most likely to play can be longer can be shorter especially if you die it could be much shorter but um the game itself really rewards planning and executing those plants and i think that's huge in a campaign game of this scale have you do you have any familiarity with kingdom death monster or this nightmare world i think all i can say about it is dot dot dot because i have not even seen this on the table let alone played it or no much i mean the fade is as i try to go through these pictures the one thing that stuck out with me with kingdom death monster is like oh god it's a kickstarter with too many miniatures because every picture is miniatures

it's like talk about like somebody showed me a picture of the game play it's like you know because everything is good go back one space so the that one right there so that is the main gameplay it's a boss battler at its heart have you played the game uh monster hunter by chance um i actually played monster hunter world every friday with some friends but yeah i mean that dark souls just kind of feels like but yeah so yes it's kind of monster hunter in the dark souls universe so you have this showdown board which is what you're seeing in front of you here and your monster your boss is going to be the middle and you control four survivors it's a very straightforward tactical game where you are going to be taking your survivor and you get a movement and an act you'll be moving up to it generally you're going to be attacking it and based on how you hit you'll hit different hit locations and i love that part about this game you go ahead this sounds good from a gameplay perspective i mean one thing that put me up one it was kickstarter only so i was like all right well if i can't get it by normal means i'm not gonna bother secondly everybody just kept talking about the minis not the actual gameplay and it's like oh it must be a great game then but you know could not tell so as you said for its miniatures um so that's what they started off with yeah free as you said stupidly punishing or stupidly hard and i thought if you're gonna tie me to a 12 week like 25 mission i mean i think 25 missions is a bit much you know because this is one thing i find with campaigns in general like everyone goes on about gloomhaven sort of saying oh yeah it's got all these like all these scenarios it's like how many people realistically unless this is the only game you play ever are gonna see all that content it's

just too much you can have too much of a good thing and so i'm glad i like to see an end eventually to a campaign and with that i just wouldn't this one like 25 missions i think would get insane the theme's gritty and dark i like that i would not have a problem with that um i was quite abused that somebody said like yeah kingdom development has a story i didn't realize it had a campaign i thought um the first one has you kind of just exploring your existence and what you are some of the other campaigns though are really fascinating they do this one it's called people of the stars this is one where you play with the dragon king expansion and instead of waking up and just kind of surviving your own the dragon king finds you and he says hey you're going to come live with me and he watches over you and he trains you to become like him and it's really fascinating so just things like that this weird ideas and these weird stories that can take you on super fascinating this is one i'd play if someone like said look like someone lives local to me and says we're gonna play a campaign a kingdom death monster i have everything it's already made do you want to play it then i'll play it but this is not one that i'm going to seek out build it and like try and get a group together because is it is i don't know where was it there was it yeah is the hexapiece great do you have to build the minis so that is the one reason i didn't want to play this game now in order in answer to your question really luke this is not kickstarter exclusive you can buy this at their shop they have it available it's about like 350 dollars for the entire thing it's really expensive but it does come with like a thousand miniatures something like that but yes

i hate building miniatures but i built them for this game because i like the gameplay so much but yes you got to build them no i'm not building managers i'm sorry i've done games workshop already in my life you know fair enough that's a hobby you know in itself like i'm gonna build these miniatures and that i want a board game i want the miniatures built the new one the aliens one that gale force nine did when i found out you had to put those minis together end of i i don't care i'm sorry i ain't got time to assemble your minis because you couldn't be bothered to pay for them to be assembled in the first place you know you're going to cut those sort of callers especially with this like i'm paying 350 dollars and bear in mind this is what probably american isn't it this is american dollars yeah yes that's 350 plus with another thousand dollars to ship it to the uk there's no way i'm paying that kind of money eu warehouse but you're in uk so yeah we're in uk with brexit yeah it's bad enough um but i'm not paying that kind of money and then having to assemble the stuff it's like no sorry i gave you triple digit money for this game you make the middies you know but the minis are awesome yes i know they're awesome i'm not denying that front but we have to tell coolmini or not on a regular basis that good minis don't make the game great you know you will learn this as well so it's it's like i said i want to play the game but i do not want the chore as the kaguy kid says yeah i don't want the chore of assembling the theme yes as a board i absolutely agree i find it as a chore i hate it it's my least favorite part about this game but i've got this gigantic cabinet full of these minis and i've had to build every

single one of them and i hated every moment of it but my goodness the gameplay is worth it um yeah the gameplay is absolutely worth it big fan fair enough okay well look at this this is going to be a long stream deal with it guys but uh yeah so this is the one yeah like i said we were talking about that there's going to be one more crossover yeah it's gotta happen we gotta have this crossover although it's not gonna be our ones because it's actually my number two and this one has to be a crossover with you in terms of the game although i'm curious as to whether this one is your crossover in terms of cycling rlcg oh man you love that game so much though oh i know you're number one now i do love i do love the game although it is dropping a bit because the chaos well well only because like when it's been going on for so long it's going to lose a little bit of appeal and plus the chaos bag is a little bit of an annoyance it's kind of like you know because i i play this on normal at the moment i think after i'm done with this insmuth campaign i'm gonna play it on easy and never not play on easy because because all the difficulty does is makes the chaos bag worse the chaos bag is a luck fest you know like you could pull out the auto fail token three times in a row if you're really unlucky but all you're doing when you up the difficulty is making the odds stupidly punishing it's just like no if you don't want to up the difficulty in something it's like a video game if i play it on normal mode i want the boss i want the adversaries to be normal damage normal health whatever i've got to kill

them off and then when i go on to hard difficulty they damage you more or they're harder to do or their ai is better in arkham horror when you up the difficulty all you're doing is saying did you have bad luck before when now it's worse and it's like no because the fights no the bosses aren't any easier to kill you know nor's the actual scenarios and that so it's like why play on hard difficulty if you're just going to frustrate yourself but back to the tell me why you love the game though why is it number two well now but i i do let's say the chaos bag's the one nickel i have and like i say if i play it on easy i don't have that problem but yeah love the stories that it generates love the mechanics still the sense of exploration the theme is top notch like i say it's that one niggle is the chaos bag otherwise love it but pastor karkoza was hands down the cycle i chose i mean it wasn't even a close second for the ones i liked and like i said the game campaigns are all pretty good but this one not only did it have like some excellent player cards throughout it and some cool characters it takes one of my favorite stories from the arkham horror lore even though i'm not exactly a big aficionado with it which is the king in yellow and rolls with it that's the main plot line but whereas the rest of the cycles kind of look like they they sometimes get a little bit weird towards the end like you you enjoyed the story for the first half and then by the end of it it's like okay this is getting a bit weird where's the big boss battle you know this one has a boss battle yes but it's not quite the same way but whereas the others also have like oh here's the big gribbly monster

here's the gore fest i'll say i mean i i used to like horror films a bit more than i do now but now i'm kind of not screamish but i just can't stand gorfest anymore it's like i'm done with it because it's not scary to have blood and guts everywhere it's just sick and lately we've had some sickness on horror films as they try to up the ante but one of my favorite horror films of all time is adian the first adian there's barely any gore in that there's a couple of gory moments i mean that's about it the rest of it is just atmosphere and suspense and i like psychological horrors as well and that's what this cycle does the kenyan yellow as far as i can tell from like obviously i'm not the expert of the law is essentially a play that when you watch it everybody goes insane but there's nothing about like weird about the play it's like okay this is an unusual story but why do i go insane but you basically sort of see the aftermath as opposed to why people go insane so it's like you don't understand it fully it just happens but i love the insanity part with the arkham horror law because when you play through this cycle weird stuff is happening and it's like what on earth is going on here this is very much a psychological horror story and you've got a character who keeps appearing like this man in the hooded mask or something that's just like the ominous character it's like who are you you're trying to chase after them you've got a scenario where you've got like this ghost musician dude like stalking you from paris which i thought was a really cool scenario there's a going through like arkham asylum is one of the scenarios i thought uh the second scenario is like going to a party with get the actors of the play and this one has some of the

best areas in it for sure like the play one the catacombs there's just so many cool places you visit i love that you travel from place to place and there's a big breath of exploration in some of the scenarios which is super like one of the best things about arkham in my opinion yeah and like i said i know i bragged on the chaos bag of that but like i said i play it on easy mode now and now yeah that's mitigated or sorry so i know i said that i went on too much there i still love this game a bit but pastor i didn't even have to think i thought all the campaigns i thought i like this don't like that like this don't like that here i don't have anything i don't like every scenario in this i love maybe the lesser one being the final boss battle because those ones you can only do so much apart from fight a big boss battle but even that has some cool variety in it but all the scenarios leading up to it i just thought were great and they say the kenyan yellow is one of my favorite aspects of the law because it's not all about gorfests or gribbly monsters it's mind scrooge and it's like what is going on it's like it's this one has you asking questions and doesn't resolve them and going through the story itself you've got the conviction and doubt uh aspects so depending on what choices you make you either you're convicted to stopping what's going on but then if you go the other way you're kind of doubting this is all real and this is all made up it's like it was such a i mean it's like most tv series you start off good you peak at season two and then it kind of dwindles after that this is this is your season two of a good tv series that's funny well i watch a lot of arrowverse cw

shows and that and it's like like arrow for example started off great season two was amazing and all the other seasons as much as i enjoyed them never quite measure up to season two and it's just it's the same with this but this is obviously your number one so we'll get on to what your favorite cycle is at that point you got it yep of course it's gonna be a number one so of course so why don't we just get on that although i wonder if you're correct as to what you think my number one's gonna be and i'll be interested i think i do i think it's a new addition to this list we'll see all right my number one as luke predicted absolutely it's arkham horror the card game so in which psycho my cycle is actually going to be one of the newer ones it is the dream years so the dream eaters cycle has you participating in a standard eight campaign if you want it has many different ways to play its campaign it has you separated into two groups so you can either do the dream world or you can do the real world so in each campaign you're interacting with the game differently but it also can be a long campaign or a short campaign and i think that really plays to its strengths in this campaign instead of the normal eight you can play a four scenario campaign which is actually a lot of fun because you're getting almost double the experience points that you normally would which means you're able to level up your deck faster you're able to just really build really cool decks really fast and get those powerful guards played as soon as possible and i think that is awesome for a game like

arkham horror where sometimes it'll take a while before you get that really cool shotgun or some really cool abilities or maybe you need a specific card to get a deck working so i think that adds to a lot in this scenario and the world itself is wonderful the first half you have is the dream itself you can enter the dream world and you're interacting with these cool creatures and it has my favorite scenario of all time from arkham horror and from anything really the search for cadaph search for cadav has you basically going on a ship and exploring the dream world and i think that is just so fun you get to go from place to place seeing all these fantastic creatures and really strange landscapes and the story's really yours to go through it honestly gives me that sleeping god's vibe where you're you're on a ship and you're sailing around but it's got the art you gotta fight about that yeah because i think i do maracaibo you're on a ship a sleeping guard you're on a ship something about ships i mean i know i don't know enough about the arkham law but i mean this was the first time i heard of kadaf so i'm quite surprised that that that's not your favorite of the law so cool i i honestly have only read the insmith the insmith story from uh from the whole hp lovecraft thing i haven't read anything else the only once again i've learned through osmosis just by being around this arkham stuff but um oh man i i love this i think it's i think it's so well done and then on the flip side of this that fantastical dream world you have the real world where you're trying to break into the dream world from our reality and it has you going

through these like super terrifying experiences where little pieces of the dreams the nightmares are coming in and you're having to deal with that i think that's just such a cool way to deal with things they hit it out of the park with the first scenario of each leading you into the story and each of them have their own final bosses which is super cool small campaign but you still have a great final boss i think they knocked it out of the park with them as well you have one that is all about positioning and the other one kind of messes with your hand and i think that's super wonderful they did a great job with the theme they did a great job with the new mechanics the new player cards are really interesting with the new bonded cards they included and the locations and the art is stunning so wonderful what do you have to say about dream eaters i know you like the game but did you play through this one yet i have i'm up to date with the exception of the newest cycle pack from in smith whatever it is light in the fall oh nice i think yeah yeah i haven't played that yet but i'm up to date so i this was definitely a runner-up i can't remember if it was like my number two or number three when i was thinking like ranking the cycles um because i do like i would like to see this eight-part campaign thing done more because i like the idea that if i want a shorter campaign i can just play one of these in a four-parter or something and i would like and they haven't done it with the insmut which is a bit of a shame so you know there's a bit annoying that it's tied to this particular one the dreamlands is a part of the law i do like or i'm kind of interested in and but like i didn't i really care about the whole cadaph thing the pooks or whatever they're called the

the creatures that you find the zombies what's that yeah zeus they are creepy in this game they're like creepy like drug-infused gremlins is what i think of them yeah i i mean there's there's not going to be a picture of them but yeah they are creepy oh there's one oh there's one yeah this thing down the right ear it basically looks like a gremlin if you gave it like a spider mouth thing or something they are very creepy i wouldn't want to see them normally but the thing is when i play for this campaign the dreamland stuff i was kind of like okay with like i liked it but i wasn't like as invested in the story um and the final boss i'm like okay to me you're just generic elder god or something it's like i don't know a lot about him whoever he is a la la la tip or whatever i don't know is i can't pronounce his name but as i said it's just because of the law the dreamlands is not my firm favorite i did however really like the other half of the campaign with the real world stuff i thought that was really good because you were because you deal with the old fire and the cats which i thought was great but one thing that does stop me wanting to play this too often though arkham horror is already a scary setting right it already does a very good job at like atmosphere and fear i was dreading playing this expansion though the cover kind of says it all really it's like no not the dream eater part no the bit in the middle the giant spider in the middle exactly spiders and the ah the oh my god i mean i hate spiders in all

games i have to have to thought them in journeys in middle earth like oh like for ages i was like hate these spiders but in this and in the arkham or second edition i used to have the i hated playing against the elder god and attack lacquer or whatever it is or something because it's got one of the most creepiest pictures i've ever seen it's like a spider with like a human face on it or something it's just like that is scary that's gonna haunt my nightmares so i thought i'm gonna have nightmares playing this like campaign with spiders and i thought okay just deal with it all right hopefully good the problem is fantasy flight does good artwork and a lot of the spiders i mean some of them i can get over like that one on the cover it's like it's nasty it's creepy but it's like it's fantastical it's not it doesn't look realistic because you know it's a alien concept the problem is spider swarms and normal spiders aren't fantastical it's why arachnophobia is still probably a film that i will refuse to watch ever again because everything looks realistic in that film i can see why you don't go back to the lord of the rings campaign anymore because you're on that shelb scenario it all makes sense now it's all coming together oh god the spider artwork in lord of the rings bad i have had times where i've just been flipping over and i turn over a card and i have a heart attack like i see the picture as i chuck it away i can't the artwork's too good in that game but here it's worse because the artwork in this is really good there's like a card called spider swab it's just basically a swarm of spiders and it's like if i saw that i would brick it and run out of the scenario immediately

like i'm sorry and the first scenario in this one has like you've got like a lot of the cards have got spider artwork on them and they're close-ups and stuff and it's like i can't even look at this artwork it's too scary but the first scenario in this is nightmare fuel like this is the sort of thing that i would literally have a nightmares about it's like okay it's like we're in a hospital okay not the nicest place to be and it's like they're on the bed you're looking at your friends they're dreaming it's all like that why is everything getting cobwebs everywhere it's like oh christ and then it's like you go around like the orderlies come by and they look normal but something's not quite right but then you start seeing spiders appear in all sorts of places it's like okay this is nightmare fuel i don't want to be in this scenario and then you get the pictures whereas like the orderly suddenly have like the spiders coming out of their goblin i was like i'm done i'm out i'm done sorry if i'm triggering any ptsd here we don't have to keep talking about this we can move on i was just like i'm i'm checking out as i i wanted to get that scenario over here but i've never been more scared playing the star which is my quality to the game it really did not put me in a test mode it does its job but this is why i do not like i mean oh koi it's like yeah the artwork's too good it's like other spiders but it made me want to succeed and when you get to the final boss in the actual cycle go admit mechanically that was fantastic i thought the mechanics of that final boss were brilliant but it's like oh god i gotta fight this thing can you guys touch it oh man yeah honestly

these investigators have to put up with all this stuff i feel like if i went up against jig and saw the snakes i'd be fine i'm cool with snakes i'll have a python around my neck or something about whatever ramen neck i wouldn't care too much until it kills you but you know like i wouldn't be scared of it it's a snake i'm fine with them so it's like if i see jig i'd be like oh my god it's a monster but die you know deal with it and die if i saw any of these spider things turn up i'm like yep check out you're on your own guys i'm sorry the world can go to pot i don't care i'm not dealing with this right it is so scary but that i mean i like the scenario if i'm i thought the difficulty spikes got a little bit ridiculous in the later parts that's kind of what stopped it being my favorite but like i said this this is easily like my second or third favorite cycle um we haven't played enough of innsmouth to know if that's going to overtake it because i do think the intimate one's pretty good so far that's pretty great it is pretty but yeah this is better than dumb witch this is better than forgotten age and probably better than the circle undone as well so yeah probably is probably a second favorite so obviously but it's like this one just like like yeah i can deal with it but it's like this one would trigger me a lot more than i wanted oh there's like as soon as i knew this was the expansion i thought oh no i can't deal with this one all right well let's see under something up actually i was about to say something a bit more cheerful that is entirely the wrong phrase to illustrate this particular one you've probably figured out and i'm sure yeah i know this one for sure yeah this

one i didn't think like when i even got this that this was going to be number one for this list i thought how did this get to the volume but when i thought about it and after i played it it's like no this is easily the my favorite campaign i've ever played in any game not just from a mechanical perspective but primarily just because the story is that good it is easily this war of mine days of the siege this one people in comments have actually mentioned like oh you know i you know is this one on your list or something like that it's like we'll get to it we'll get to it this one is hands down the best story i've come across in any they know that i mean i already love this war of mine you know gritty dark i really want to get back on the pc game again i just haven't had time but you know i still play the board game each scenario was great fun but i thought i held off this one for a bit i thought do i really need to play this as a big campaign is this like too much it wasn't a cheap expansion but i thought oh i'll go with it bought it and then i thought we're gonna do this this soon i need to do a video on this i put one out recently that's probably why you knew it was gonna be my number one um yeah from that review absolutely and exactly and i thought let's play it free acts okay cool this won't take too long yes each scenario is a good three hours also to get through it like when you're playing it's a long game but i thought i can deal with three acts of this long didn't take much to get into the rules it tweaks some of the rules but i think what it does to exploration links and improvement in the sense having a map

board and then going to the various locations to like find the apartment building not necessarily i mean there's not many pictures of this i've already scouted ahead on this front but i mean i just love this artwork this artwork is so good um you know the video game is just so immersive in fact when i play this game board game wise i put the soundtrack to the video game on all the time yeah it's really good like atmospheric music but i don't think you'll find much in the way of photos of the games obviously it doesn't want to spoil too much but you i suppose it's as good as you're going to get but yeah you've got a sideboard here of the area and it's it's kind of like the same setting you're in this city and it's all going to pop but this is sort of like the culmination of the battle the war that's going on okay and again you've got to survive but in terms of the paragraph stories that you come across and the plot arcs that you find i've never seen a game do a theme so rich and well as this i mean if you if the original game is going to trigger you this will trigger you worse um in terms of like the stuff that you have to do because you've really got to do some morally bankrupt stuff on occasion or you can be the nice guy but then that's going to hurt you as well but i love how much branching storyline this is i've played it and i feel like i could play this another five six seven times before i find everything because put it this way you get to a point where you it says put all the story tokens you found on this slot and then you might use them later there were seven slots i found one it's like wow okay i still did i still

succeeded in the campaign and it's not like you need them all to succeed but that's a lot of plot arcs that i didn't find and that was like halfway through the campaign but the main three acts i've got branching paths as well so you've got at one but then depending on how you end that one you've got act two a act two b and then a for act three a and a fact three b depending on how that one ends you've already got branching paths with the main things that are very different but even just the events that come up the event deck that you normally have in the base game that just gives you an event and that's it yeah this one they're like mini stories so if you ignore them they tick down on the timer track and if you leave them be then something resolves like i mean i'll an example not from not taking straight from the game here but like say the bridge is out you could fix it you might get some food it's going to take time and resources though all right i'll leave it but then the bridge is broken now you can't get across it for the rest of the campaign you know it's stuff like that so everything has consequences nothing feels like it was just there as a card done and dusted but the events there's multiple events for each act you only use i think six of them or something there's probably a good nine ten of them you know so you're gonna get different events turn up every time you play through the whole campaign and you might ignore one in which case it goes away or you might follow one and it could be like another six seven different story missions that you go through it could be like its own story in itself and like i said i'm not spoiling very much here because it's like 0.5

of the game or something but i came across an event that said go check out an orphanage okay fine orphanage is somewhere at the other end i'll go check it out and see what happens kids need feeding and assuming you're not crying by the time you get through just the initial paragraph of kids starving to death it's like okay fine um the idea of like the kids find you and they're all happy until they realize you have no food in your hand and then they go away depressed it's like dang you know but i thought right i'm going to save these kids and i don't want kids in real life so me deciding i want to save the orphanage is a stretch very noble exactly and i thought right i'm going to make it this game i'm going to save all these kids this is going to be my plot for the game did several missions i won't go into details but like i say did several things get them stuff go help this go find this and then eventually after going through it because you might not do all their plot arcs but i thought i'm gonna see this one through to the end the last thing you have to do is find them a new place to be because the army has just got too held up where they are and so you have multiple choices of places you can go i was struggling to get through my job of survival so i thought i've only got time to visit one place so i'll go to this one place read the description it said it was pretty good but there may be some issues and i thought this seems fine it could be worse you can stay here i found you a new place it gives you an epilogue to read at the end right so i got through the scenario and bear in mind you can actually succeed this campaign on act two you can actually you can actually follow a path so well that you get out on there and i did i had to actually

rewind the game to go through and play through act 3 because i didn't want to finish too early although wasn't exactly a great ending it basically meant that your character survived i hope the rest of the people in the shelter did also and it's like what so one person's out that's it no that's it that's horrible ending no rewind you know but i got got to yeah just like right we've all survived great fantastic oh epilogue yeah let's read that orphanage how did they do you go back there and what's left of it is you think there may be some kids under the rubble but you don't want it wow is that the orphanage got shelled like as the epilogue the place that i found them was not defensible enough so it got hit by rockets uh wha i mean it doesn't trigger me it's on you right that was your decision yeah man but but that's the consequences it doesn't faze me too much because i detach myself with this sort of thing but it's like yeah dark and gritty and because i like things like black mirror and stuff i love it because it made me feel like i chose i went through this whole arc of trying to save this orphanage and because of one decision i made they all died and that's very much in the this war of mine theme and in general like that's that's the game in a nutshell if you if you like stuff like that you're going to like this game yeah i do love it i just say i played for this guy but i thought if i had more time on my hands i would have played this straight away i haven't even done that with sleeping gods you know you know it's not a massive rules change if you know how to play this war of mine the map board the rule books actually

pretty straightforward in terms of the new stuff some stuff you don't use from the old set that you don't have to bother with uh like finding piles and a couple of other decks of cards you can actually not use them it's like that's simplify things even the building up your house is simpler because you no longer have to dig all the bits out of your house anymore apart from i think the basement briefly all the rooms are there you don't have to like generate ideas for the better inventions you have them all available so you can do whatever you like so it simplifies that prospect and focuses more on the story and i'll say the story is top-notch it's not just a bunch of little mini scenarios there is one overarching plot some major characters that can get killed off if you do things wrong and stuff you know it and no it never feels like oh you never feel like i'm in a happy place it's like even there's like oh we've got a potential ally yeah but he's still dick you know it's like it this one just like balled me over so much like if i played this war of mine if i need to get a quick scenario done i'll do one of the ones on the first expansion but if i've got the time to devote and leave it on the table so i'm pulling out days of the siege it just really worked for me so i can't argue with you on this pic it's it's wonderful it does exactly what it does super well i don't know if you know this but they actually use this game as a teaching device in europe so it's it's a it's a huge part of the history curriculum in polish schools so they'll use this as a teaching tool to talk about civil wars and the the idea of living during one of these

so i think that's super fascinating that it does its job so well now whenever i bring out this game i generally try to play just one offs but i do have the last days of the siege but you're saying that it's short it's not like a super super long campaign so this sounds like something that i would really enjoy free acts free acts if you do well enough you can finish on the second act and because i say i say wet enough it's if he follows pass to certain fruition you know there may be more than one way to do it in act 2 i don't know but there was certainly this one way i did it but it wasn't like oh everybody survives there may be a way for everyone to survive but i don't know but this particular one it was like one of your because it depended on i only sent one character to this particular thing had i sent everybody there they would have all survived but because it was just the one person it technically said they survive i hope the rest of the people in the shelter are fine oh my god you basically abandoned your friends jesus and it it just froze in i mean there's a couple of little modules like kids in that that you can throw into stand-alone games but frankly i just put them in this campaign one like you can find an orphan child and bring them up as well which is quite i mean certainly interesting to do i mean i had a fully kitted out house by the end of this i had three characters i got a kid i then also found a fourth character who turned up i think from the plot but then i also ended up with a fifth character because i went outside to try and see if i could find a trader somebody came to the door it's like do you want this person in your party and

it's like but they do have some interesting stuff i need i mean he has a hatchet i could do with that right now and it's like so i invited this i had a five-person uh team that i was looking after it was cool and you left them all right naturally no no we all survived oh you all survived excellent okay well one guy survived oh man originally it was when i finished in act two but as i say what i did was i basically said right hang on let me do the other choice in that paragraph and then see what happens and yeah it fundamentally changed things by doing the other choice but yeah by doing that it meant i could get to act three that's the only time i would rewind it it's just because i wanted to obviously do all three acts and it's like okay fine and as i say even just the the free acts themselves are good i mean i but like i say they are very different outcomes so i know in your review for this game you said that you were much more a fan of this than the one-off scenarios so i do like a lot of the scenarios but you would recommend this larger campaign instead of those one-off scenarios i would recommend this expansion over the ruined city one but the thing is the only thing i like from ruins city expansion is those scenarios and i think they are really good unique one-off scenarios i mean there was one in particular i really loved which was like uh i think it was like a boyfriend and girlfriend or two christians invited two of them yeah i was like that was such a good story one like trying to have the both of them survivors too so i thought that was brilliant but the problem is i don't like the sewers module it's weird and it's like

complicated as all get out and i didn't really like the farmer's thing either and i thought i thought the extra modules that expansion added were just too fiddly and too complex and i just didn't want to use them but i love the one-off scenarios but that's the only reason i would get that expansion now this one though is all about the campaign i mean yes you can throw the kids into any game but that's such a small addition and i think there's a dog i don't even use the cat from the other one it's like so i'm not going to use the dog either you know it's a it doesn't really do much for you but it eats your food well why on earth would i want it then it just makes the game harder yeah but predominantly you get this for the campaign which is why i didn't buy it originally because i wanted to play the game more first and i thought oh great another campaign i skipped essen when i saw it and i thought but then i think in the last couple of months i thought at some point i'm going to talk about this kind of thing it's like you know what i've got a gift voucher for this i need to check this campaign out and boy i'm glad i did but yeah all right whoo two and a half hour stream yeah like definitely a long one because we certainly went on there but uh i think most people i think a lot of the people in the chat have kind of like they agree that they like this war of mine and and in some cases actually prefer it than the video game which to be honest well the thing is i i do find myself playing the board game probably from a tactile perspective more than the video game but the video game is still really good i mean it's kind of pick your poison because i like the board game for like the events and the cards and stuff like that come up and the fact that it is just a really cool board game in a sense and i

love the paragraph books but i do miss from the video game that when you go exploring you physically go and explore like i am actually trying to hide like yeah because when you have you not played the video game i have not played the video game but i really like the exploration mechanic in this war of mine board game so the idea that you are actually doing these actions though seems insane yeah because in the video game you phys you actually move the people around in your house and you do cuts and you've got a certain amount of time before day ends so you're kind of on a slow timer but when you do the actual exploration the scavenging you physically choose the location you you end up there with your character you interact with people who are already there like you might go to the hospital and actually talk to the doctors and that they'll be locked doors there'll be cabinets that you can get stuff out of but then if you obviously raid a cabinet while someone's watching you then they try and chase you out and stuff and it's just like you actually have a little third person it's a bit like the old platforming games where yeah like the 2d scroller was you basically have that kind of mini game every time you go and explore and they'll you'll come back to the same location multiple times because you've got like a hacksaw and you find a new area with more stuff to do but i just love the fact that you interact with the characters there and you can't just merely like in other games just go no i'm just stealing all your stuff like in skyrim or like some of those i'm just nicking all your stuff don't mind me yeah you don't care i'm out of it no this is like there's a priest there he's looking after some people and i decide next door to him to go

that's a nice tin of can spam like like run or like do it anywhere near army people who try to shoot you on site it's it's a really cool game i love it i say the soundtrack's wonderful another one to check out all right but yeah top 10 cam pains oh there's quite a few i mean you know i did consider journeys in middle earth but i like journeys of middle earth campaigns more from the mechanic side of it because i love how the mechanics work in that game the stories are kind of basic yeah there's not much to the stories and as i found out with the campaign i finished today they tend to be very very good up until you get to the finale when the difficulty spike goes to subscene levels that it really tarnishes what you've just been going through so that's my sort of with journeys in the middle low so i thought that was kind of like 11 or 12 but i didn't want to put it on the list and career i just haven't played it yet i'll get you get round to this war of my days of the siege i'll get round to career how about that deal deal so for me my like 11 12 one of them was out of luxem it is a campaign expansion for alterquest so have you played altar quest at all never played it so it takes the idea of the modular deck system you take a dungeon you take a boss and then you take those cards and those kind of populate what you're going through and then you take your own character as his own personal deck out of luxon gives a campaign to this game where every time you win you'll get equipment that you can carry from scenario scenario and when you lose you'll get some negatives that will basically strengthen the bad guys from

scenario to scenario so it's a really cool combination of the story but the campaign itself is a little bit too easy in my opinion and four games like this where you have that kind of like mix up two things and smash them together i like the one-off scenarios more than i like the campaigns themselves so that's why i didn't make this list i think though it's its strength is its one-off scenario so that and street masters have a similar thing so i would recommend the offs more than the campaigns in that case fair enough right right i need to shut this down because i've only just noticed the time getting on the two and a half hours because sunday evening is when i play games with friends online in a few minutes i need to actually go meet them so i was like yeah but finish the stream so cheers everybody for turning up you know thanks for once again luke for having me yeah i appreciated fun actually this is the most back and forth banter i've had like in terms of grilling each other's choices and stuff like that so it's like we have to repeat this at some point with a much more touchy subject i think maybe absolutely down for that let's do it this this was a good lap but as i say hashtag supports all creators there's a link to his youtube channel side game mail they'll see in the description but by all means also have if you're well if you're in a colorado area that's going to be a niche audience who's watching this channel but like i say check out the whole uh board game host party night thing because this is a cool idea it'd be nice to see that do well once lockdowns and that start easing up and we can actually do that more but now this is this has been good fun so thanks for coming on and thanks for watching everybody we'll see you guys soon all right bye

Progress saved